← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4F Sikhism – 5 Works of scholars; Paper 4F Sikhism – 6 Religion and society (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Sikhism: Works of scholars; religion and society (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1The Gurus called women equal five centuries ago. Why are Sikhs still arguing about it?
  2. Mission 2Is the Sikh scripture a feminist text, or has Sikh history been retold to make it look like one?
  3. Mission 3Guru Nanak met Hindu priests, Muslim judges and yogis. Did he come to argue or to listen?
  4. Mission 4Sikhs say God can be found in every faith. So why do some Sikhs insist they are not Hindus?
Mission 1

Mission 1: The Gurus called women equal five centuries ago. Why are Sikhs still arguing about it?

Make a guess: The Gurus called women equal five centuries ago. Why are Sikhs still arguing about it?

Mission 1

Guru Nanak: why call her inferior?

Guru Nanak: why call her inferior?Guru Nanak's Punjabwomen often seen asritually impurewomen seen asspiritually lessersati: widows burnedon a husband's pyrepurdah (veiling)among elitesGuru Nanak taught“Why call herinferior, when fromher even kings areborn?” (GGS 473,paraphrase)the same divine jot(light) is in everyperson
  • In Guru Nanak's Punjab, women were often seen as ritually impure and spiritually lesser; widows could face sati (burning on a husband's pyre); purdah (veiling) was common among elites.
  • Guru Nanak, Asa di Var, Guru Granth Sahib 473 (paraphrase): from woman we are born and conceived; to woman we are engaged and married; woman is our friend and the source of future generations. Why call her inferior, when from her even kings are born?
  • He adds that without woman there would be no one at all; only the One True Lord is beyond needing a mother.
  • Spiritual basis: the same divine jot (light) is in every person.
Mission 1

Guru Amar Das: reform in practice

Women and the Gurus' reformsGuru NanakGGS 473: why call her inferior?Guru Amar Daswomen among the leaders ofpreaching districts; against sati andpurdah; widows could remarryGuru Gobind Singhwomen take amrit and join theKhalsa; the name Kaur1705Mai Bhago led forty Sikhs back intobattle at Khidrana (Muktsar)after 1708Mata Sundari guided the Panth,issuing letters (hukamnamas) to thesangats
  • Women teachers: Sikh tradition says he set up preaching districts (manjis and piris) and appointed women as well as men to lead them.
  • Against sati (Guru Granth Sahib 787, paraphrase): true satis are not those who burn on the pyre, but those who live with virtue and contentment, and those who die of the pain of separation.
  • Against purdah: women came into the sangat unveiled; the Rahit Maryada later forbade Sikh women to veil their faces.
  • Widows could remarry.
  • Langar: women and men cooked, served and ate together (Mata Khivi before him).
Mission 1

Guru Gobind Singh and the Khalsa

Women and the Gurus' reformsGuru NanakGGS 473: why call her inferior?Guru Amar Daswomen among the leaders ofpreaching districts; against sati andpurdah; widows could remarryGuru Gobind Singhwomen take amrit and join theKhalsa; the name Kaur1705Mai Bhago led forty Sikhs back intobattle at Khidrana (Muktsar)after 1708Mata Sundari guided the Panth,issuing letters (hukamnamas) to thesangats
  • Women as well as men take amrit and join the Khalsa; women take the name Kaur ("princess"), men Singh: a name that removes caste surnames for both.
  • Tradition says the Guru's wife (Mata Jito in most accounts, Mata Sahib Kaur in others) added sugar to the first amrit; Mata Sahib Kaur is honoured as "mother of the Khalsa".
  • Mai Bhago led forty Sikhs back into battle at Khidrana (Muktsar), 1705.
  • Mata Sundari guided the Panth for decades after Guru Gobind Singh's death (1708), issuing letters (hukamnamas) to the sangats.
Quick check
?Which reform did Guru Amar Das make that directly gave women religious authority?
Mission 1

Teaching and practice

Sikh teaching and practiceSikh teachingPractice debatedwomen and men takeamrit and join theKhalsavery few women inthe Panj Piare orleading major Sikhbodiesthe same divine jot inallwomen do notperform kirtan in thesanctum ofHarmandir Sahib(2005 SGPC decisionnot put into practice)the Gurus' teaching:equal dignity (GGS473)dowry and preferencefor sons persist inparts of PunjabicultureCounter-exampleBibi Jagir Kaur: first woman president of theSGPC (1999)Debatedmany Sikhs: the gaps are Punjabi culture, notteaching · others: institutions need reform
  • Gaps many Sikhs themselves point out:
  • Very few women in the Panj Piare or as leaders of major Sikh bodies (though Bibi Jagir Kaur became the first woman president of the SGPC in 1999).
  • Women do not perform kirtan inside the sanctum of Harmandir Sahib: an SGPC decision in 2005 to allow it has not been put into practice.
  • Dowry and preference for sons persist in parts of Punjabi culture, against the Gurus' teaching.
  • Many Sikhs explain the gaps as Punjabi culture, not Sikh teaching; others say institutions themselves need reform.
Mission 1Diversity

Equal, but with different roles?

Equal, but with different roles?Complementary viewspiritually equal, equally able to reach mukti;often different roles (family, household)Egalitarian viewequal souls, equal roles everywhere,including leadership and the Panj PiareConservative practicesome gurdwaras and families keep traditionalroles; some groups expect women to wearthe keskiviews held by Sikhs; none marked correct
  • Complementary view: men and women are spiritually equal and equally able to reach mukti, but often have different roles (e.g. in family and household).
  • Egalitarian view: equal souls should mean equal roles everywhere, including leadership and the Panj Piare.
  • Conservative practice: some gurdwaras and families keep traditional roles; some Sikh groups (e.g. the Akhand Kirtani Jatha) expect women to wear the keski, to which others object as unnecessary.
  • Your spec: "different attitudes to social and political issues, including gender".
Mission 1

Under-reported women

  • Mainstream histories of Sikhism (often written by men, colonial officers and later reformers) focus on the ten Gurus and male warriors.
  • Under-reported: Bebe Nanaki (Guru Nanak's sister, often called his first follower); Mata Khivi; Bibi Bhani (daughter of Guru Amar Das, mother of Guru Arjan); Mata Gujri; Mata Sundari; Mai Bhago.
  • Changing roles over time: Gurus' era reforms → 18th-century leaders (Mata Sundari, Mai Bhago) → Singh Sabha schools for girls (late 19th century) → women vote in SGPC elections (from 1920s) → Bibi Jagir Kaur, SGPC president (1999) → diaspora women's groups.
  • How to read this history (feminist vs historical-critical).
Mission 1Evaluate

"Feminism has always been part of Sikhism."

Has feminism always been part of Sikhism?“Feminism has always been part ofSikhism.”ForGGS 473: why call her inferior?Guru Amar Das: women teachers; againstsati and purdahWomen in the Khalsa (Kaur)Mai Bhago and Mata SundariThe same divine light in allAgainst“Feminism” is a modern movement andconceptNo women Gurus; no hymns by women inthe Guru Granth SahibMuch imagery is of a male LordPractice has often laggedMiddle viewThe Gurus taught spiritual equality andattacked specific injustices; whether that is“feminism” depends on definitionJudge it byWhat counts as feminism: equal dignity, equalroles, challenging patriarchy? · Teaching orpractice? · Which period?
  • For: GGS 473; Guru Amar Das's women teachers and his stand against sati and purdah; women in the Khalsa (Kaur); Mai Bhago and Mata Sundari; the same divine light in all.
  • Against: "feminism" is a modern movement and concept; no women Gurus and no hymns by women in the Guru Granth Sahib; much imagery is of a male Lord; practice has often lagged.
  • Middle view: the Gurus taught spiritual equality and attacked specific injustices; whether that is "feminism" depends on definition.
  • Judge it by: what counts as feminism (equal dignity, equal roles, challenging patriarchy)? Teaching or practice? Which period?
Mission check

?A gurdwara committee in Birmingham has only men. A young Sikh woman stands for election, quoting Guru Nanak. An older member says women serve best in the langar. Which statement best describes this debate in Sikh terms?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Is the Sikh scripture a feminist text, or has Sikh history been retold to make it look like one?

Make a guess: Is the Sikh scripture a feminist text, or has Sikh history been retold to make it look like one?

Mission 2

Two scholars, one question

Two scholars, one questiongender equality:original or constructed?N K Singh(2011, extract 3)Jakobsh(2006, extract 4)
  • Nikky-Guninder Kaur Singh (N K Singh): Sikh scholar of religion (Colby College, USA). The Feminine Principle in the Sikh Vision of the Transcendent (1993); Sikhism: An Introduction (2011), chapter 6, "Feminist Text in a Patriarchal Context" (anthology extract 3).
  • Doris R. Jakobsh: historian of religion (University of Waterloo, Canada). Relocating Gender in Sikh History (2003); "Sikhism, Interfaith Dialogue, and Women: Transformation and Identity" (Journal of Contemporary Religion, 2006) (anthology extract 4).
  • The question: is gender equality in the Sikh tradition from the start, or has it been constructed over time?
  • Anthology extracts are in copyright: below is paraphrase only.
Mission 2

Singh: a feminist text

N K Singh: a feminist text in a patriarchal contextthe textIk Oankar: the One, beyond form, sobeyond genderthe divine as mother; creation asbirth…the Gurus' voice as the soul-brideHeLordMasterHeLordthe context: patriarchal readingmale interpreters and translators
  • Singh reads the Guru Granth Sahib itself as a feminist text (extract 3, paraphrase).
  • Ik Oankar: the One is beyond all form, so beyond gender; the numeral "1" breaks any picture of God as male.
  • Feminine imagery: the divine as mother; creation pictured as birth; the Gurus speak in a woman's voice as the soul-bride longing for the Beloved.
  • The female is not "other" or impure: Guru Nanak asks why woman should be called inferior (GGS 473).
  • So feminist values are in the text; the task is to read it again, freed from patriarchal assumptions.
Mission 2

Singh: the patriarchal context

N K Singh: a feminist text in a patriarchal contextthe textIk Oankar: the One, beyond form, sobeyond genderthe divine as mother; creation asbirth…the Gurus' voice as the soul-brideHeLordMasterHeLordthe context: patriarchal readingmale interpreters and translators
  • The text came into, and was read in, a patriarchal context (extract 3, paraphrase).
  • Later authorities narrowed women's place: she points to restrictive rahit-namas (e.g. Chaupa Singh's), the Sikh royal court, British rule and modern son preference.
  • Interpreters and translators, mostly men, render the One as "He", "Lord", "Master"; feminine words and images are passed over.
  • Singh's response: recover the feminine principle; uphold the Rahit Maryada's rules against dowry, veiling and female infanticide; give women public roles such as granthi.
  • Her method: feminist hermeneutics (re-reading scripture from women's experience), as an insider who loves the text.
Quick check
?According to N K Singh, why has the feminist vision of the Guru Granth Sahib often been missed?
Mission 2

Jakobsh: gender as a lens on history

Jakobsh: gender as a lens on historygender lens on historyGurus'periodchallenged sati, purdah,impurity; praised womenmainly within the householdsilencesthe sources say little aboutreal womenfrom 1873Singh Sabha movementreshapes Sikh identitytodaydiaspora and interfaithdialogue (2006 article)
  • Jakobsh uses gender as a category of historical analysis: asking how ideas of men and women were made and changed over time (Relocating Gender, 2003, paraphrase).
  • Gurus' period: the Gurus did challenge some practices (sati, purdah, impurity), but largely praised women within the household, as wives and mothers; they did not overturn patriarchy.
  • Imagery is mixed: alongside positive images, some hymns use female figures for maya (worldly attachment) or temptation.
  • Silences: the sources say little about real women; history has been written mainly by and about men.
Mission 2

Jakobsh: the Singh Sabha and the "ideal Sikh woman"

The "ideal Sikh woman"the “ideal Sikh woman” (Singh Sabha)educatedpioushome andfamilySide notethe reformers promoted women's educationJakobsh (paraphrase)
  • The Singh Sabha movement (from 1873), under British colonial rule, reshaped Sikh identity.
  • Reformers promoted women's education and Anand Karaj, and condemned practices they called "Hindu" (e.g. some customs of widowhood and dowry).
  • They presented Sikh women as freer than Hindu and Muslim women: part of building a distinct, protected minority identity (extract 4, paraphrase).
  • Jakobsh argues they also created an ideal Sikh woman: educated, pious and devoted to home and family, matching Victorian ideals (paraphrase).
  • The claim that Sikhism was always gender-egalitarian became part of this new, distinct Sikh identity.
  • So equality is partly a construction of modern Sikh history, not simply a timeless fact.
Mission 2Read the source

Extract 4: dialogue and identity

Jakobsh, "Sikhism, Interfaith Dialogue, and Women" (2006), extract 4 (paraphrase):

  • Much modern Sikh writing, especially online, presents Sikhism as uniquely liberating for women and blames Hindu and Islamic influence for patriarchy among Sikhs.
  • This "blaming the other" harms interfaith dialogue; dialogue should instead join other traditions in shared action against practices that oppress women.
  • There is a gap between the rhetoric of equality and practice: e.g. women's exclusion from the Panj Piare and from some sewa and kirtan at Harmandir Sahib.
  • Women, many in the diaspora, are challenging that gap; this raises the question of who speaks for women in Punjab.

Q1 Why does Jakobsh criticise "blaming the other"?

Show answer

It turns equality into a claim of superiority and blocks shared action with other faiths.

Q2 What gap does she identify?

Show answer

Between claims of equality and women's actual exclusion from some roles.

Quick check
?Which statement best summarises Jakobsh's argument about the Singh Sabha?
Mission 2

Comparing the two

Singh and Jakobsh comparedN K SinghJakobshStartingpointthe text and itstheologyhistory andsocial contextMethodfeministhermeneutics,as an insiderhistorical-critical,gender analysis,as an academichistorianEqualityoriginal to theGurus' vision,then obscuredpartlyconstructed,especially bymodernreformersCriticismsreads modernfeminism intomedieval poetrysome Sikhscholars:imposesWestern framesAgreementboth: women under-represented in mainstreamaccounts and leadership; women today useSikh ideals to claim change
  • Starting point: Singh: the text and its theology. Jakobsh: history and social context.
  • Method: Singh: feminist hermeneutics, literary and theological, as an insider. Jakobsh: historical-critical, gender analysis, as an academic historian.
  • Equality: Singh: original to the Gurus' vision, then obscured. Jakobsh: partly constructed, especially by modern reformers.
  • Agreement: both say women are under-represented in mainstream accounts and in Sikh leadership; both see women today using Sikh ideals to claim change.
  • Critics: some Sikh scholars reject historical-critical approaches (as with McLeod and Oberoi) as imposing Western frames; others say Singh reads modern feminism into medieval poetry.
Mission 2

Under-reporting and changing roles

Changing roles over timeGurusthe Gurus' reforms18thcenturywomen leaders: MataSundari, Mai Bhagofrom 1873Singh Sabha: girls' schoolsand the “ideal Sikh woman”1920swomen voting in SGPCelections1999Bibi Jagir Kaur, first womanSGPC presidenttodaycampaigns: women ragis atHarmandir Sahib, women inthe Panj Piare; womenwearing the dastaar
  • Under-reported in mainstream accounts: Bebe Nanaki, Mata Khivi, Bibi Bhani, Mata Gujri, Mata Sundari, Mai Bhago (see Mission 1).
  • Over time: Gurus' reforms → 18th-century women leaders → Singh Sabha girls' schools and the "ideal Sikh woman" → women voting in SGPC elections (1920s) → Bibi Jagir Kaur, first woman SGPC president (1999).
  • Movements today: campaigns for women ragis at Harmandir Sahib (an SGPC decision in 2005 to allow it has not been put into practice) and women in the Panj Piare (the Rahit Maryada allows Sikh women among the five who give amrit); diaspora women's organisations; women wearing the dastaar as a statement of equality.
  • Men's roles are changing too: shared sewa in the langar, shared care in families.
Quick check
?A student writes: "Singh and Jakobsh disagree about everything." Which point shows this is wrong?
Mission 2Evaluate

"N K Singh gives a more convincing account than Jakobsh."

Singh or Jakobsh?“N K Singh gives a more convincing accountthan Jakobsh.”For SinghGrounded in the primary text, which allSikhs accept as GuruExplains Sikh women's own sense thatequality is theirsOffers a constructive way forwardFor JakobshAttends to evidence of actual practiceExplains why rhetoric and reality differShows how history and colonial contextshaped identitiesCombined viewText and history answer differentquestions: Singh asks what the scripturemakes possible; Jakobsh asks what Sikhsmade of itJudge it byWhich question matters most: scripture orpractice? · Insider vs outsider strengths? ·Evidence offered? · Fit with women'smovements today?
  • For Singh: grounded in the primary text, which all Sikhs accept as Guru; explains Sikh women's own sense that equality is theirs; offers a constructive way forward.
  • For Jakobsh: attends to evidence of actual practice; explains why rhetoric and reality differ; shows how identities are shaped by history and colonial context.
  • Combined view: text and history answer different questions: Singh asks what the scripture makes possible; Jakobsh asks what Sikhs actually made of it.
  • Judge it by: which question matters most (scripture or practice)? Insider vs outsider strengths? Evidence offered? Fit with women's movements today?
  • Extract tip: state each scholar's argument accurately in your own words, then evaluate it against the other and against evidence.
Mission check

?A Sikh women's group in Toronto campaigns for women to serve in the Panj Piare at their gurdwara's Vaisakhi amrit sanchar. They cite Guru Nanak and the Rahit Maryada, which allows women among the five who give amrit. How might Singh and Jakobsh each interpret this campaign?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Guru Nanak met Hindu priests, Muslim judges and yogis. Did he come to argue or to listen?

Make a guess: Guru Nanak met Hindu priests, Muslim judges and yogis. Did he come to argue or to listen?

Mission 3

Diversity is a fact; pluralism is a response

Diversity is a fact; pluralism is a responseFACTReligious diversityMany religions (and many groups within each)exist side by sideRESPONSEPluralisma response to that fact, used in two waysSocialwelcoming andprotecting manyfaiths in one societyPhilosophicalequally valid routesto the same ultimatetruth
  • Religious diversity: the plain fact that many religions (and many groups within each) exist side by side.
  • Pluralism is a response to that fact. The word is used in two ways:
  • Social pluralism: welcoming and protecting many faiths in one society.
  • Philosophical (religious) pluralism: the view that different religions are equally valid routes to the same ultimate truth.
  • A person can welcome diversity in society without holding that all religions are equally true.
  • Sikhism was born in Punjab between Hindu and Muslim communities, so these questions were there from the start.
Mission 3

Testimony from many traditions: the bhagat bani

Voices in the Guru Granth Sahibsix Gurussix GurusGuruGranthSahibKabirHindu bhakti / santRavidasHindu bhakti / santNamdevHindu bhakti/ santRamanandHindu bhakti/ santSheikh FaridMuslim Sufibhagat bani: hymns of bhagatsincluded by Guru Arjan, 1604
  • The Guru Granth Sahib (GGS) contains the hymns of six Gurus and of bhagats (saints) from other traditions: the bhagat bani.
  • Bhagats from the Hindu bhakti and sant traditions (e.g. Kabir, Ravidas, Namdev, Ramanand) and a Muslim Sufi, Sheikh Farid; several were of low caste.
  • Guru Arjan included them in 1604 because they agreed with the Gurus: one formless God, the Name, against caste and empty ritual.
  • Their hymns are sung with the same reverence as the Gurus'.
  • So the Sikh scripture itself is a meeting place: Sikhs bow daily before words written by people who were not Sikhs.
  • Your spec calls this "the collection of testimony from diverse traditions".
Mission 3Read the source

What the Guru Granth Sahib says about other faiths

  • Kabir (Prabhati, GGS 1349, paraphrase): first God created light; from that one light the whole creation came. So who is good and who is bad?
  • Kabir (Prabhati, GGS 1350, paraphrase): do not say that the Vedas and the books of the Semitic faiths are false. False is the one who does not reflect on them.
  • Guru Arjan (Ramkali, GGS 885, paraphrase): some call on Ram, some on Khuda; some serve Gosain, some Allah. The one who understands the Lord's will knows the Lord's secret.
  • Guru Arjan (Bhairo, GGS 1136, paraphrase): I keep neither the Hindu fast nor the Muslim Ramadan; I am neither Hindu nor Muslim. Body and breath belong to the One, called both Allah and Ram.

Q1 What do these passages agree on about God?

Show answer

There is one God of all people, called by many names.

Q2 Does GGS 1136 say that the other religions are worthless?

Show answer

No: it rejects their outward rituals as necessary for the speaker, while naming God with their names. It marks a distinct path, not contempt.

Quick check
?A student says: "Because Kabir's hymns are in the Guru Granth Sahib, Sikhs believe Hinduism and Sikhism are the same religion." What is the best reply?
Mission 3

Guru Nanak with Hindus

  • Nanak was born into a Hindu (Khatri) family; he knew Hindu practice from the inside.
  • The sacred thread (janeu): as a boy he refused it (janamsakhi tradition). His verse asks instead for a thread of the soul: compassion the cotton, contentment the thread, self-control the knot, truth the twist (Asa di Var, GGS 471, paraphrase).
  • Haridwar (janamsakhi tradition): pilgrims threw water east towards the sun for their ancestors. Nanak threw water west, "to water my fields in Punjab". If water cannot reach Punjab, how can it reach the dead?
  • His method: question the ritual, keep the inner meaning, and invite people to the Name of God.
  • His target was empty ritual and caste pride, not Hindus as people.
Mission 3

Guru Nanak with Muslims

  • His lifelong companion, the musician Mardana, was born a Muslim.
  • Sultanpur (janamsakhi tradition): Nanak joined the Nawab and the qazi at prayer but did not bow. He said their minds were elsewhere (the qazi on his newborn foal), so their prayer was empty.
  • Mecca (janamsakhi tradition): told not to point his feet towards the Kaaba, he asked to be shown where God is not.
  • His verse (Majh ki Var, GGS 140–141, paraphrase): make mercy your mosque, faith your prayer mat, honest living your Qur'an. It is hard to be called a true Muslim: first love the way of the saints.
  • He criticised injustice by rulers of any faith: in the Babarvani hymns he laments Babur's invasion (GGS 360, 417–418, 722).
Mission 3

Guru Nanak with the yogis

Three dialoguesWith Hindus: Haridwar (tradition)Hindus: inner meaning of ritualNanak: westto fields in Punjabpilgrims: eastto the sun, forancestorsWith MuslimsMuslims: make mercy your mosquefaith your prayer mat (GGS 140–141)With the yogisyogis: pure in the world(Siddh Gosht, GGS 938)
  • The Nath yogis (Siddhs) sought liberation by leaving family life, through body discipline and supernatural powers.
  • Their debate with Nanak is preserved as the Siddh Gosht ("discussion with the Siddhs", GGS 938–946).
  • The yogis asked why he stayed in the world. Nanak's answer (paraphrase): live like the lotus in water or the duck on the stream, untouched by the water around it (GGS 938).
  • Yoga is not the patched coat, the staff or ashes; it is staying pure in the midst of the world (Suhi, GGS 730, paraphrase).
  • So Nanak offered a householder path: work, family, service and remembering the Name, rather than renunciation.
  • Many Sikhs see this as the birth of the Sikh ideal of grihasth (family life).
Mission 3

The pattern of the dialogues

  • Respect for persons: Nanak ate, travelled and debated with Hindus, Muslims and yogis as equals.
  • Criticism of hypocrisy in every tradition, including his own birth tradition.
  • Reinterpretation: he took each group's own symbols (thread, mosque, yogi's coat) and gave them an inner, ethical meaning.
  • One God, one message: the call to the Name was addressed to all.
  • N K Singh (Nikky-Guninder Kaur Singh, Sikhism: An Introduction, 2011, ch. 1, extract 2; paraphrase only): reads Nanak's message as open and poetic, an experience of the One that crosses the boundaries of Hindu and Muslim.
  • Your spec also names S B Singh Dalawari for this topic.
Mission 3

History: conflict as well as friendship

Conflict as well as friendship: timeline1604Adi Granth compiled, with thebhagat bani1606Guru Arjan executed (Lahore)1675Guru Tegh Bahadur executed(Delhi); Sikh tradition: for theKashmiri Pandits' freedom
  • Sikh attitudes to other faiths were also shaped by persecution under Mughal rule:
  • 1606: Guru Arjan executed in Lahore under the emperor Jahangir.
  • 1675: Guru Tegh Bahadur executed in Delhi under Aurangzeb. Sikh tradition: he died defending the Kashmiri Pandits' (Hindu priests') freedom to practise their own faith.
  • Guru Gobind Singh fought both Mughal forces and Hindu hill rajas.
  • Yet friendships ran across these lines: the Muslim Sufi Pir Buddhu Shah fought for Guru Gobind Singh (tradition); Sikh tradition says the Sufi Mian Mir laid the foundation stone of the Harmandir in Amritsar.
  • So the history gives Sikhs both a memory of conflict and a model of defending other people's religious freedom.
Quick check
?Which event do Sikhs most often cite as showing that a Guru defended the religious freedom of people of another faith?
Mission 3Evaluate

Do Guru Nanak's dialogues show that all religions are equally valid?

Do the dialogues show all religions are equally valid?Nanak's dialogues show that, for Sikhs, allreligions are equally valid paths to GodForOne God of all, called by many names(GGS 885); "no Hindu, no Muslim"(janamsakhi tradition)Hindu and Muslim saints in the scripture,revered as Gurbani alongside the Gurus'AgainstHe criticised core practices of each group(thread, ritual prayer, renunciation) andoffered the Name as the true wayGGS 1136: neither Hindu nor Muslim, adistinct path: more inclusivism thanpluralismJudge it byValid: God found there, or every practiceequally good? · Criticising people, or onlyhypocrisy? · Which reading fits the wholescripture?
  • Claim: Nanak's dialogues show that, for Sikhs, all religions are equally valid paths to God.
  • For: He taught one God of all, called by many names (GGS 885); "there is no Hindu, there is no Muslim" (janamsakhi tradition).
  • For: The scripture includes Hindu and Muslim saints, whose words Sikhs revere as Gurbani alongside the Gurus'.
  • Against: He criticised core practices of each group (the thread, ritual prayer, renunciation) and offered the Name as the true way.
  • Against: GGS 1136 (paraphrase) declares the speaker neither Hindu nor Muslim: a distinct path, which suggests inclusivism (truth found elsewhere, fulfilled in the Guru's way) more than pluralism.
  • Judgement criteria: Does "valid" mean God can be found there, or that every practice is equally good? Do the dialogues criticise people or only hypocrisy? Which reading fits the whole scripture?
Mission check

?At a school interfaith day, a Sikh speaker says: "My Guru would sit with your imam and your priest. He would also tell all of us that our rituals are worthless without a pure heart." Which statement best explains this?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Sikhs say God can be found in every faith. So why do some Sikhs insist they are not Hindus?

Make a guess: Sikhs say God can be found in every faith. So why do some Sikhs insist they are not Hindus?

Mission 4

Three answers to "Is my religion the only true one?"

Exclusivism, inclusivism, pluralismExclusivismOnly one religion is true; salvation or liberationonly through itInclusivismOne religion has the fullest truth; otherscontain real truthPluralismMany religions are equally valid routes to thesame ultimate realityultimatereality
  • Exclusivism: only one religion is true; salvation or liberation comes only through it.
  • Inclusivism: one religion has the fullest truth, but others contain real truth, and their followers can be saved or liberated through it, often without knowing.
  • Pluralism: many religions are equally valid routes to the same ultimate reality.
  • Recap: diversity is the fact of many religions; pluralism is one response to it (see Mission 3).
Mission 4

Where Sikh teaching sits

  • The Mool Mantar begins Ik Onkar: there is one Creator of all, not a Sikh God.
  • God is beyond any one name; people call God Ram, Allah, Khuda (GGS 885).
  • Liberation comes by God's grace (nadar) to those who remember the Name and live truthfully. No birth, caste or label earns it.
  • So many Sikhs hold that enlightenment can be reached through any theistic tradition lived with true devotion.
  • But the Guru's word is the clearest guide; Sikhs follow it, and the Rahit Maryada says a Sikh owes allegiance to no other religion.
  • Many scholars therefore call the Sikh view inclusivist; some Sikhs describe it as pluralist.
  • Every Ardas ends by asking for sarbat da bhala: the welfare of all.
Mission 4Diversity

Different Sikh responses to religious freedom and pluralism

Sikh responses to religious freedom and pluralismOpen engagementGurdwaras and langar open to all · interfaithcouncils · 1675: Guru Tegh Bahadur'smartyrdom, a duty to defend everyone'sfreedom of religionDistinct identitySingh Sabha (from 1873) · Ham Hindu Nahin,"We are not Hindus" (1898) · objections toArticle 25 of the Indian ConstitutionDefending visible faith in secular statesMandla v Dowell Lee (House of Lords, 1983):Sikhs are an ethnic group protected fromdiscriminationNot opposites: many Sikhs are both open toothers and firm about their own identity
  • Open engagement: gurdwaras and langar are open to all; Sikhs serve in interfaith councils; Guru Tegh Bahadur's martyrdom (1675) is cited as a duty to defend everyone's freedom of religion.
  • Distinct identity: the Singh Sabha movement (from 1873) worked to separate Sikh practice from Hindu custom. Kahn Singh Nabha's book Ham Hindu Nahin ("We are not Hindus", 1898) argued that Sikhs are a separate faith.
  • Many Sikhs still object that the Indian Constitution (Article 25) groups Sikhs with Hindus for some legal purposes.
  • Defending visible faith in secular states: in the UK, Mandla v Dowell Lee (House of Lords, 1983) held that Sikhs are an ethnic group protected from discrimination (a school had refused a boy in a turban).
  • These responses are not opposites: many Sikhs are both open to others and firm about their own identity.
Mission 4

No longer a missionary religion?

  • Guru Nanak travelled widely and taught all who would listen; the early Panth grew fast.
  • Today Sikhs welcome converts but do not, on the whole, run organised campaigns to convert others.
  • Reasons Sikhs give: God's grace, not a label, liberates; other faiths can lead to God; the Gurus forbade forced conversion.
  • But Sikhs do teach their faith (parchar): e.g. the Sikh Missionary Society UK publishes free literature, mainly for Sikhs and enquirers.
Quick check
?A Sikh says: "A sincere Muslim who loves God and lives truthfully can be liberated, but the Guru's path shows the way most clearly." Which view is this?
Mission 4

Interfaith relations today

The Kartarpur CorridorPAKISTANINDIAKartarpurKartarpur Corridoropened Nov 2019approximate scale
  • Langar: the free kitchen serves anyone; many interfaith events in the UK and beyond are hosted in gurdwaras.
  • Shared service: Sikh relief groups help people of every faith in disasters.
  • The Kartarpur Corridor (opened November 2019, for Guru Nanak's 550th birth anniversary) lets Indian pilgrims visit Kartarpur in Pakistan, where Nanak spent his last years.
  • Barriers: memories of persecution; disputes over identity; hate attacks on Sikhs mistaken for other groups (e.g. after 11 September 2001).
Mission 4

Knowing God: experience, not speculation

  • For the Gurus, knowledge of God is "experience of" the One, not a theory about God.
  • It comes through Naam simran (remembering the Name), the Guru's word and God's grace.
  • Japji, pauri 1 (GGS 1, paraphrase): God cannot be reached by thinking, even if one thinks a hundred thousand times.
  • Asa di Var (GGS 467, paraphrase): one may read cartloads of books; only one thing is of account (usually read as the Name); all else is the idle chatter of ego.
  • So the Gurus rejected the philosophy and speculation associated with priests (Brahmin pandits, Muslim qazis) as the way to know God.
  • W O Cole (with P S Sambhi, The Sikhs, ch. 5 "Sikh religious thought", extract 1; paraphrase only): Sikh thought rests on revelation through the Guru and on lived devotion, not on speculative argument.
Mission 4Read the source

Japji, pauri 21

  • Guru Nanak asks (GGS 4, paraphrase): what was the time, the moment, the season when the world was made?
  • The pandits did not know, or it would be written in the Puranas.
  • The qazis did not know, or they would have written it in the Qur'an.
  • The yogis do not know the day or the season. Only the Creator who made the world knows.

Q1 Which three groups does Nanak name, and what do they share?

Show answer

Hindu scholars, Muslim judges, yogis: each claims special knowledge through text or discipline.

Q2 Is Nanak attacking their faiths or their speculation?

Show answer

Their claims to know what only God knows: speculation, not the search for God.

Mission 4

Reason, evidence and authority

Reason in Sikh teachingFor Sikhs:reason(manmukh)ego(gurmukh)Guru's wordgoes astrayleads to truthShared ground with humanismagainst superstition, caste, priestly privilegeand inherited custom
  • Some worldviews (e.g. humanism) build a rational and virtuous life on reason and evidence, and reject religious and inherited non-religious authority as its foundation.
  • Shared ground with Sikh teaching: the Gurus used reason against superstition (Haridwar), rejected caste, priestly privilege and inherited custom, and prized bibek budh (discerning intellect).
  • Difference: Sikhs hold that reason guided by ego (manmukh, self-willed) goes astray; reason guided by the Guru (gurmukh) leads to truth. The foundation of life is the Guru's word and God's will (hukam), not reason alone.
  • Respect: Sikhs recognise honest, compassionate living wherever it is found; many work with humanists on shared causes.
  • N K Singh (paraphrase only): stresses that the Gurus' poetry aims at an experience of the One that no single doctrine or authority can contain.
Quick check
?How would most Sikhs respond to the claim that reason and evidence alone are the right foundation for a good life?
Mission 4

Khalsa and non-Khalsa Sikhs

Khalsa and non-Khalsa Sikhsamritdhari(Khalsa)keshdharisahajdhariOuter dotted ring: some Hindu Punjabi andSindhi families who revere Guru NanakSpelling on Edexcel papers: sehajdhariAmritdhari keep the 5KsSikhs differ over how sharp the line betweenSikh and non-Sikh should be
  • Amritdhari: initiated into the Khalsa; keeps the 5Ks and the Rahit.
  • Keshdhari: keeps uncut hair but has not taken amrit.
  • Sahajdhari: follows the Gurus but cuts hair and has not taken amrit.
  • Spellings on your papers: sehajdhari, Rehat Maryada.
  • The Rahit Maryada defines a Sikh as one who believes in one God, the ten Gurus, the Guru Granth Sahib and the Gurus' teaching, believes in the necessity of amrit, and owes allegiance to no other religion (paraphrase).
  • Khalsa identity marks clear boundaries: a visible, distinct faith.
  • Many non-Khalsa Sikhs, and some Hindu Punjabi and Sindhi families who revere Guru Nanak, live with looser boundaries: attending both gurdwara and mandir.
  • So Sikhs differ over how sharp the line between Sikh and non-Sikh should be.
Mission 4Evaluate

Is Sikhism an exclusivist or an inclusivist tradition?

Is Sikhism exclusivist or inclusivist?Sikhism is an exclusivist traditionForRahit Maryada: allegiance to no otherreligion; the Khalsa's distinct, visibleidentity; Singh Sabha: "we are not Hindus"The Gurus rejected many practices ofother faithsAgainstLiberation by grace is open to all; God isnamed Ram and Allah; Hindu and Muslimsaints are in the scriptureSikhs do not seek converts and defendothers' religious freedomJudge it byExclusivism: a distinct identity, or only Sikhsliberated? · The Rahit's boundaries or thescripture's openness? · Do Khalsa andnon-Khalsa Sikhs answer differently?
  • Claim: Sikhism is an exclusivist tradition.
  • For: the Rahit Maryada requires allegiance to no other religion; the Khalsa marks a distinct, visible identity; the Singh Sabha insisted "we are not Hindus".
  • For: the Gurus rejected many practices of other faiths (see Mission 3).
  • Against: liberation by grace is open to all; God is named Ram and Allah; Hindu and Muslim saints are in the scripture.
  • Against: Sikhs do not seek converts and defend others' religious freedom.
  • Judgement criteria: Does exclusivism mean a distinct identity or a claim that only Sikhs are liberated? Which counts more: the Rahit's boundaries or the scripture's openness? Do Khalsa and non-Khalsa Sikhs answer differently?
Mission check

?A Sikh family welcomes a Christian neighbour to langar every week, but the father tells his son he may not also be initiated into another faith. Which statement best explains the family's position?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Guru Nanak (GGS 473), Guru Amar Das (women teachers; against sati and purdah) and Guru Gobind Singh (Kaur, women in the Khalsa) taught women's equal dignity.
  • Sikhs differ: equal with different roles, or equal roles everywhere; practice often lags.

Mission 2

  • N K Singh: the Guru Granth Sahib is a feminist text (Ik Oankar beyond gender, feminine imagery) read in a patriarchal context (extract 3).
  • Jakobsh: gender as a lens on history; the Singh Sabha's ideal Sikh woman; "blaming the other" and the gap between rhetoric and practice (extract 4).
  • Both note under-reporting of women and changing roles; they differ on whether equality is original or constructed.

Mission 3

  • Diversity is the fact of many religions; pluralism is a response to it, either social (welcome) or philosophical (equally valid routes).
  • The bhagat bani puts Hindu and Muslim saints' testimony at the heart of Sikh worship; Nanak met Hindus, Muslims and yogis as equals but challenged empty ritual in each.
  • Persecution (1606, 1675) and friendship (Mardana, Mian Mir, Pir Buddhu Shah) both shaped Sikh attitudes to other faiths.

Mission 4

  • Exclusivism, inclusivism and pluralism are three answers to other religions' truth claims; many scholars call mainstream Sikh teaching inclusivist.
  • Sikhs respond to pluralism in different ways: open engagement, a firm distinct identity (Singh Sabha), and defence of religious freedom; Sikhism welcomes but does not actively seek converts.
  • For the Gurus, God is known by experience through the Name, not by priestly speculation; reason matters, but guided by the Guru.
  • Khalsa and non-Khalsa Sikhs differ over how sharp the boundary with other faiths should be.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Sikhism: Works of scholars; religion and society (part 2) for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1The Gurus called women equal five centuries ago. Why are Sikhs still arguing about it?
  2. Mission 2Is the Sikh scripture a feminist text, or has Sikh history been retold to make it look like one?
  3. Mission 3Guru Nanak met Hindu priests, Muslim judges and yogis. Did he come to argue or to listen?
  4. Mission 4Sikhs say God can be found in every faith. So why do some Sikhs insist they are not Hindus?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel