4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Make a guess: If nothing could ever change your mind, are you really claiming anything?
Flew, adapting a parable by John Wisdom ("Gods", 1944) (paraphrase):
Q1 What does each new "invisible, intangible" step do to the believer's claim?
It removes another way the claim could be tested, until nothing could count against it.
Q2 What is the gardener a picture of?
God, believed to care for the world, though no test detects God.
Task: explain how Mitchell responds to Flew.
Flew asked what belief rules out; Hare said belief is a way of seeing; Mitchell said belief is trust that feels the strain. Next: what if religious language is a different game altogether?
Make a guess: Does "God" mean the same in a prayer as it would in a science report?
From Wittgenstein's 1938 lectures on religious belief, published from students' notes as Lectures and Conversations (1966) (paraphrase):
Q1 Why does Wittgenstein say he is not contradicting the believer?
They are not making rival claims in one game; the believer's words play a different role in his life.
Q2 How does this differ from Hick's view of belief in life after death?
Hick treats it as a factual claim verifiable in future; Wittgenstein treats it as a picture that regulates life.
Task: evaluate whether language games show that religious language is meaningful.
Words take their meaning from the life they are part of; the question is whether that is all religious words mean. Across: negation, analogy, symbol, verification, falsification and language games each answer the same problem differently.
Make a guess: Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?
Richard Dawkins (b. 1941), The God Delusion (2006), paraphrased:
Q1 Does Dawkins claim to know that there is no God?
No: he thinks God very improbable and lives on that assumption, but claims no certainty: a 6, not a 7.
Q2 Why does he think "God designed it" is not a good explanation?
The designer would need explaining even more than the design.
"I don't believe in God" and "there is no God" are different claims: the first reports a lack of belief; the second denies that God exists. Whether either speaker claims to know is a further question. Next: what existentialists and humanists make of a world without God.
Make a guess: Does the universe need an explanation, or is it simply there?
Task: explain how Copleston uses the argument from contingency in the extract.
Copleston asks why the whole exists; Russell replies that the question may not apply to the whole. The debate ends in an impasse about what philosophy can ask.
Mission 1
Mission 2
Mission 3
Mission 4
You've worked through Religious language; Works of scholars (part 2) for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Your stars: 0 / 0