← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4D Islam – 2 Sources of wisdom and authority (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Islam: Sources of wisdom and authority (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If the Qur'an came in pieces over 23 years, how did it become one book?
  2. Mission 2Why do Muslims who don't speak Arabic still learn to recite the Qur'an in Arabic?
  3. Mission 3The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  4. Mission 4Islam has five verdicts for any action, not two. Why would a religion need a "disliked" category?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If the Qur'an came in pieces over 23 years, how did it become one book?

Make a guess: If the Qur'an came in pieces over 23 years, how did it become one book?

Mission 1

What Muslims believe the Qur'an is

Chain of revelationGod (Allah)the source: His speech, kalam AllahJibrilthe angel: the medium of revelationMuhammad's heartthe recipient, not the authorRecitationthe Qur'an: "recitation", in ArabicCompanionsheard, memorised and wrote it downMuslim belief: symbols only, no figures
  • Qur'an means "recitation": a text meant to be heard and recited.
  • Muslims believe it is kalam Allah, the speech of God, not the words of Muhammad.
  • Revealed in Arabic, through the angel Jibril, to Muhammad, over about 23 years (610–632 CE).
  • Muhammad is the recipient and messenger, not the author.
  • It is the final revelation, confirming and completing earlier scriptures.
Mission 1

Wahy: revelation through Jibril

Revelation over 23 yearsRevealed in stages (Qur'an 17:106)Hira 610Hijrah 622632MakkanMadinanabout 23 years
  • Wahy is the revelation God gives to a prophet.
  • Jibril is the medium: "for he brings down the (revelation) to thy heart by Allah's will" (Qur'an 2:97, Yusuf Ali).
  • "With it came down the spirit of Faith and Truth- To thy heart and mind, that thou mayest admonish. In the perspicuous Arabic tongue." (Qur'an 26:193–195, Yusuf Ali)
  • How it came (Bukhari, paraphrase of Aisha's report): sometimes like the ringing of a bell, the hardest form for him; sometimes the angel came as a man and spoke.
  • Companions saw him sweat on a cold day as revelation came.
Mission 1

Revealed in stages

Revelation over 23 yearsRevealed in stages (Qur'an 17:106)Hira 610Hijrah 622632MakkanMadinanabout 23 years
  • "(It is) a Qur'an which We have divided (into parts from time to time), in order that thou mightest recite it to men at intervals: We have revealed it by stages." (Qur'an 17:106, Yusuf Ali)
  • Makkans asked why it did not come "all at once"; the reply: "that We may strengthen thy heart thereby" (Qur'an 25:32, Yusuf Ali).
  • Reasons Muslims give: to strengthen the Prophet; to answer events as they happened (asbab al-nuzul, occasions of revelation); to make memorising easy; to bring in laws step by step.
  • And the Night of Power? Many scholars, following Ibn Abbas, say the whole Qur'an came down to the lowest heaven that night, then to Muhammad in stages.
Quick check
?Which statement describes mainstream Muslim belief about how the Qur'an was revealed?
Mission 1

Makkan and Madinan surahs

Two kinds of surahMakkan610–622Madinan622–632Numbermost surahs(traditionally 86)fewer(traditionally28), but longerStyleshort verses,rhythmic, vividoaths andimageslong verses,more detailedproseThemestawhid, Day ofJudgement,earlier prophets,signs in nature,answeringidolaterslaw, worship,family, war andpeace, theummah, Jewsand ChristiansExampleSurah 96, Surah112Surah 2(al-Baqarah),Surah 4Counts are the traditional ones; lists differ slightlyOrder in the book: 114 surahs…al-Fatiha firstSurah 96then roughly longest to shortest; not in order ofrevelation
Makkan (610–622)Madinan (622–632)
Numbermost surahs (traditionally 86)fewer (traditionally 28), but longer
Styleshort verses, rhythmic, vivid oaths and imageslong verses, more detailed prose
Themestawhid, Day of Judgement, earlier prophets, signs in nature, answering idolaterslaw, worship, family, war and peace, the ummah, Jews and Christians
ExampleSurah 96, Surah 112Surah 2 (al-Baqarah), Surah 4
  • Each surah is labelled by where most of it was revealed; some contain verses from both periods.
Mission 1

The structure of the Qur'an

Two kinds of surahMakkan610–622Madinan622–632Numbermost surahs(traditionally 86)fewer(traditionally28), but longerStyleshort verses,rhythmic, vividoaths andimageslong verses,more detailedproseThemestawhid, Day ofJudgement,earlier prophets,signs in nature,answeringidolaterslaw, worship,family, war andpeace, theummah, Jewsand ChristiansExampleSurah 96, Surah112Surah 2(al-Baqarah),Surah 4Counts are the traditional ones; lists differ slightlyOrder in the book: 114 surahs…al-Fatiha firstSurah 96then roughly longest to shortest; not in order ofrevelation
  • 114 surahs (chapters), each made of ayat (verses; ayah also means "sign").
  • Order: al-Fatiha first, then roughly longest to shortest. Not chronological: the first revealed (96) comes near the end.
  • Every surah but Surah 9 opens with the basmala: "In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful" (Qur'an 1:1, Yusuf Ali).
  • Divided into 30 juz' (parts) for reading across a month.
  • Muslims believe the order of verses was set by the Prophet as Jibril directed; each Ramadan Jibril reviewed the revealed Qur'an with him.
  • Scholars differ on whether the order of surahs came from the Prophet or from the companions.
Quick check
?A surah has long verses, gives detailed laws on inheritance and marriage, and addresses "O ye who believe!" How would it usually be classified?
Mission 1

Memorised and written in the Prophet's lifetime

How the Qur'an was gatheredIn the Prophet's lifetimememorised:huffazpalm stalkstoneboneleatherwritten down: no single bound copy in 632Abu Bakr, 632–634Zayd ibn Thabit gathersthe written pieces, checkedagainst memorysuhufsuhufUmarHafsahHafsah: Umar's daughter, a widow of the ProphetUthman, c. 650committee led byZayd copies thesheetsstandard mushafcopies to the maincitiesmain cities(reports differ)
  • Revelation was first memorised: companions who learned it all were called huffaz (singular hafiz).
  • Scribes, such as Zayd ibn Thabit, wrote verses down as they came: on palm stalks, flat stones, shoulder bones, leather and parchment.
  • Muslims believe the Prophet checked the recitation, and Jibril reviewed it with him each Ramadan.
  • At his death (632) there was no single bound copy: revelation had continued almost to the end.
Mission 1

Abu Bakr and Uthman

How the Qur'an was gatheredIn the Prophet's lifetimememorised:huffazpalm stalkstoneboneleatherwritten down: no single bound copy in 632Abu Bakr, 632–634Zayd ibn Thabit gathersthe written pieces, checkedagainst memorysuhufsuhufUmarHafsahHafsah: Umar's daughter, a widow of the ProphetUthman, c. 650committee led byZayd copies thesheetsstandard mushafcopies to the maincitiesmain cities(reports differ)
  • Abu Bakr (caliph 632–634): many huffaz were killed at the battle of Yamamah. Urged by Umar, he asked Zayd ibn Thabit to gather the written pieces, checked against memory and witnesses.
  • The result, suhuf (sheets), passed to Umar, then to his daughter Hafsah, a widow of the Prophet.
  • Uthman (caliph 644–656), c. 650: Muslims in distant provinces recited differently. A committee led by Zayd copied Hafsah's sheets into a standard mushaf (written copy) in the Quraysh dialect.
  • Copies went to the main cities; other copies were destroyed. Today's Qur'an follows this Uthmanic text.
  • Later, dots and vowel signs were added to make the script easier to read. Recognised readings (qira'at) remain, e.g. Hafs (most widespread) and Warsh (North and West Africa).
Mission 1Diversity

Sunni, Shi'a and academic views

Sunni, Shi'a and academic views of compilationSunniThe account of Abu Bakr and Uthman: theUthmanic text is complete and exact.Shi'aAccounts add that Ali compiled his own copyafter the Prophet's death, in order ofrevelation with explanations. MainstreamTwelver scholars, e.g. al-Khoei (1899–1992),hold today's text is complete.AcademicMost historians: a fixed text by the mid-7thcentury. Wansbrough, Quranic Studies(1977): a later formation. Birmingham (2015):two leaves radiocarbon-dated to 568–645 CE.
  • Sunni account: as on the earlier screen; the Uthmanic text is complete and exact.
  • Shi'a accounts add that Ali compiled his own copy after the Prophet's death, in order of revelation with explanations.
  • Mainstream Twelver Shi'a scholars, e.g. Abu al-Qasim al-Khoei (1899–1992), al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur'an, hold today's text is complete; some argue it was already gathered in the Prophet's lifetime. Early reports alleging missing verses are rejected by most.
  • Academic views: most historians accept a fixed text by the mid-7th century. John Wansbrough (1928–2002), Quranic Studies (1977), argued for a later formation; early manuscripts have since weakened that view.
  • In 2015 the University of Birmingham reported two Qur'an leaves radiocarbon-dated to 568–645 CE.
Mission 1Read the source

"We will assuredly guard it"

> "We have, without doubt, sent down the Message; and We will assuredly guard it (from corruption)." (Qur'an 15:9, Yusuf Ali)

  • Muslims read this as God's promise to preserve the Qur'an, unlike earlier scriptures they believe were altered by human hands.

Q1 According to 15:9, who preserves the Qur'an?

Show answer

God: "We will assuredly guard it".

Q2 How might a Muslim link 15:9 to the work of the huffaz and of Uthman?

Show answer

God's preserving is believed to work through people: memorisers and a standard text.

Quick check
?Why did Uthman have a standard written copy (mushaf) of the Qur'an made, c. 650?
Mission 1Evaluate

How far is the Qur'an's compilation a human work?

Argument map: how far is the compilation a human work?The Qur'an as Muslims have it today is theproduct of human compilation.ForPeople chose scribes, gathered sheets,standardised dialect, burned other copies,added dots and vowels.Different readings (qira'at) and earlyvariant manuscripts (e.g. the Sana'apalimpsest) show a history.AgainstThe words are believed revealed by God;humans gathered, they did not compose.Memorisation by huffaz checked everycopy.The process was early and public, underthe Prophet's own scribes, within about 20years of his death.Judge it byIs gathering the same as authoring? · Whatdoes 15:9 promise: the words or everymanuscript? · What can historical evidenceshow about divine origin?
  • Claim: The Qur'an as Muslims have it today is the product of human compilation.
  • For: People chose scribes, gathered sheets, standardised dialect, burned other copies, added dots and vowels.
  • For: Different readings (qira'at) and early variant manuscripts (e.g. the Sana'a palimpsest) show a history.
  • Against: The words are believed revealed by God; humans gathered, they did not compose. Memorisation by huffaz checked every copy.
  • Against: The process was early and public, under the Prophet's own scribes, within about 20 years of his death.
  • Judgement criteria: Is gathering the same as authoring? What does 15:9 promise: the words or every manuscript? What can historical evidence show about divine origin?
Mission check

?A museum displays a Qur'an leaf from about 650 CE, written without vowel signs. A visitor says: "This proves the Qur'an was made up long after Muhammad." Which reply best fits mainstream Muslim belief and the evidence in this mission?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do Muslims who don't speak Arabic still learn to recite the Qur'an in Arabic?

Make a guess: Why do Muslims who don't speak Arabic still learn to recite the Qur'an in Arabic?

Mission 2

An Arabic Qur'an

Arabic and translationthe Qur'anArabic words and sounds: believed revealedsalah is always in Arabictranslations of the meaningkhalifah (2:30)vicegerentsuccessorstewardeach suggests a different role for humansEvery translation is an interpretation; it is notused in salah.
  • "We have sent it down as an Arabic Qur'an, in order that ye may learn wisdom." (Qur'an 12:2, Yusuf Ali)
  • Muslims believe the Arabic words and sounds themselves are revealed, not only the ideas.
  • I'jaz (inimitability): Muslims hold no human could produce its like: "they could not produce the like thereof" (Qur'an 17:88, Yusuf Ali).
  • So Muslims everywhere learn to recite in Arabic, even without understanding every word. Salah is always in Arabic.
  • Arabic unites a worldwide ummah: the same words in Jakarta, Lagos and Leeds.
Mission 2

Translation as interpretation

Arabic and translationthe Qur'anArabic words and sounds: believed revealedsalah is always in Arabictranslations of the meaningkhalifah (2:30)vicegerentsuccessorstewardeach suggests a different role for humansEvery translation is an interpretation; it is notused in salah.
  • Every translation must choose between meanings, so every translation is an interpretation.
  • Example: khalifah (2:30) can be rendered "vicegerent", "successor" or "steward": each suggests a different role for humans.
  • So many Muslims call an English version a translation of the meaning. Pickthall titled his The Meaning of the Glorious Koran (1930).
  • Translations are valued for understanding and for sharing the message, but they are not used in salah and are not "the Qur'an" itself.
  • Trustworthy interpretation: tafsir (commentary) by qualified scholars, using the Arabic, the hadith and the context of each revelation.
Quick check
?Why do many Muslims describe an English Qur'an as a translation of its "meaning"?
Mission 2

Treating the mushaf with respect

Treating and using the mushafkept high,wrappednothing on toprehal(folding stand)wuduwashing beforetouching theArabictarawihnight prayers,Qur'an recitedin fullRamadanmonth theQur'an wassent down
  • "Which none shall touch but those who are clean" (Qur'an 56:79, Yusuf Ali). Most scholars take this to mean wudu (ritual washing) before touching an Arabic copy.
  • Some read 56:79 as describing angels and the heavenly book; they still urge respect.
  • A copy is kept high, often wrapped, nothing placed on top; read on a stand (rehal); never put on the floor or taken into a toilet.
  • Worn-out copies are buried or burned respectfully, never thrown away.
  • Many treat translations with respect but with fewer rules, as they are not the Arabic text.
Mission 2

Recited, memorised, remembered

Treating and using the mushafkept high,wrappednothing on toprehal(folding stand)wuduwashing beforetouching theArabictarawihnight prayers,Qur'an recitedin fullRamadanmonth theQur'an wassent down
  • Tilawah (recitation) with tajwid: precise rules of pronunciation and rhythm. A skilled reciter is a qari.
  • Hifz: memorising the whole Qur'an; a hafiz is honoured in family and mosque.
  • Al-Fatiha is recited in every rak'ah (unit) of salah.
  • Ramadan: "the (month) in which was sent down the Qur'an" (Qur'an 2:185, Yusuf Ali). Many read the whole Qur'an across the month; in many mosques it is recited in full in the night prayers (tarawih).
  • Laylat al-Qadr: in the last ten nights, Muslims pray through the night; some stay in the mosque (i'tikaf).
  • Recited at births, weddings, sickness and funerals; written as calligraphy in mosques and homes.
Mission 2Read the source

Surah al-Fatiha

Surahs 1 and 2Surah 1, al-Fatiha: seven versesRequest (verses 6–7)show us the straight wayPromise (verse 5)worship and help-seeking from GodalonePraise (verses 1–4)Most Gracious, Most Merciful; Lord of theworlds; Master of the Day of JudgmentSurah 2, al-Baqarah: 286 verses, MadinanPeople2:1–20: believers, those who reject faith,hypocritesProphetsAdam as khalifah (2:30); Musa; Ibrahim andIsma'il (2:127)Practiceqiblah (2:144), fasting (2:183), Hajj, charity,family law, debtsBeliefthe Throne Verse (2:255); "no compulsion inreligion" (2:256)Submission"We hear, and we obey" (2:285)

> "In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful. Praise be to Allah, the Cherisher and Sustainer of the worlds; Most Gracious, Most Merciful; Master of the Day of Judgment. Thee do we worship, and Thine aid we seek. Show us the straight way," (Qur'an 1:1–6, Yusuf Ali)

  • Verse 7 asks for the way of those whom God has blessed, not of those who earn wrath or go astray.
  • Called Umm al-Kitab ("mother of the Book"): the whole Qur'an in miniature.
  • Declaration of Allah: merciful, Lord of all worlds, Judge.
  • Submission: the believer worships God alone and depends on Him alone.

Q1 Which words declare God's mercy?

Show answer

Most Gracious, Most Merciful: twice.

Q2 How does verse 5 express submission?

Show answer

The believer promises worship and help-seeking to God alone.

Mission 2

Al-Baqarah: the Qur'an in summary

Surahs 1 and 2Surah 1, al-Fatiha: seven versesRequest (verses 6–7)show us the straight wayPromise (verse 5)worship and help-seeking from GodalonePraise (verses 1–4)Most Gracious, Most Merciful; Lord of theworlds; Master of the Day of JudgmentSurah 2, al-Baqarah: 286 verses, MadinanPeople2:1–20: believers, those who reject faith,hypocritesProphetsAdam as khalifah (2:30); Musa; Ibrahim andIsma'il (2:127)Practiceqiblah (2:144), fasting (2:183), Hajj, charity,family law, debtsBeliefthe Throne Verse (2:255); "no compulsion inreligion" (2:256)Submission"We hear, and we obey" (2:285)
  • Surah 2, al-Baqarah ("the Cow"): the longest surah (286 verses), Madinan.
  • Opens: "This is the Book; in it is guidance sure, without doubt, to those who fear Allah;" (Qur'an 2:2, Yusuf Ali)
  • Three kinds of people: believers, those who reject faith, hypocrites (2:1–20).
  • Prophets: Adam as khalifah (2:30); Musa and the Children of Israel; Ibrahim and Isma'il building the Ka'bah (2:127).
  • Practice: qiblah (2:144), fasting (2:183), Hajj, charity, family law, debts.
  • Belief: the Throne Verse (2:255); "no compulsion in religion" (2:256).
  • Submission: it ends with believers saying: "We hear, and we obey" (Qur'an 2:285, Yusuf Ali).
  • Anthology extract 1 is Yusuf Ali's translation of Surah 1 and the opening of Surah 2.
Quick check
?Which line of al-Fatiha is the believer's own commitment to worship God alone and rely on Him?
Mission 2

The first source of authority

Sources of authorityQur'anfirstSunnahthe Prophet's way,known through hadith;explains the Qur'anScholarshiplater reasoning, tested against theQur'anGod's speechhighestauthority"Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger" (Qur'an4:59)Shi'a Muslims also receive the teachings ofthe Imams through their hadith.
  • Muslims hold the Qur'an is the first and highest authority for belief, worship, law and morals.
  • It is the first source of shari'a; everything else is tested against it (see Mission 3).
  • Its words are God's own speech; to obey it is to submit to God.
  • Created or uncreated? Sunni theology (Ash'ari, Hanbali) holds the Qur'an is God's uncreated speech; the Mu'tazila, and most Twelver Shi'a theologians, hold it was created. (The caliph al-Ma'mun tried to impose the "created" view in the mihna, 833.)
  • Both sides agree it is fully God's word and fully authoritative.
Mission 2Diversity

Nasr and Malik on the Qur'an's authority

Nasr and Rahman on the Qur'an's authoritySeyyed Hossein Nasrb. 1933Fazlur Rahman Malik1919–1988Ideals and Realities ofIslam (1966)Islam (1966); MajorThemes of the Qur'an(1980); Islam andModernity (1982)Sacred text as givenMoral principlesapplied todayArabic sounds andrecitation carry baraka(divine presence)Double movement:ruling → purpose incontext → todayAuthority completeand timeless; traditionguards itWholly God's word; ina sense also theProphet'sBoth accept full authority
  • Seyyed Hossein Nasr (b. 1933), Ideals and Realities of Islam (1966).
  • Nasr (paraphrase): the Qur'an is the central sacred reality of Islam; its Arabic sounds, letters and recitation carry divine presence (baraka). Its role is closer to Christ's in Christianity than to the Bible's. Its authority is complete and timeless; traditional interpretation guards it.
  • Fazlur Rahman Malik (1919–1988), Islam (1966), Major Themes of the Qur'an (1980), Islam and Modernity (1982).
  • Rahman (paraphrase): the Qur'an is wholly God's word and, as it came through the Prophet's heart, also his word in a sense. Its authority lies above all in its moral principles: a "double movement" from specific rulings back to their purpose in context, then forward to the present.
  • Contrast: Nasr stresses the sacred text as given; Rahman stresses principles applied today. Both accept full authority.
Mission 2

Qur'an, Sunnah and Hadith

Sources of authorityQur'anfirstSunnahthe Prophet's way,known through hadith;explains the Qur'anScholarshiplater reasoning, tested against theQur'anGod's speechhighestauthority"Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger" (Qur'an4:59)Shi'a Muslims also receive the teachings ofthe Imams through their hadith.
  • "Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger" (Qur'an 4:59, Yusuf Ali).
  • Sunnah: the Prophet's way: what he said, did and approved. It explains the Qur'an.
  • Example: "be steadfast in prayer" (Qur'an 2:43, Yusuf Ali) does not say how; the times, movements and number of rak'ahs come from the Sunnah.
  • Hadith: the reports through which the Sunnah is known.
  • Order: Qur'an first; mainstream scholars hold that sound hadith explain the Qur'an and do not contradict it.
  • Diversity: Shi'a Muslims also receive the teachings of the Imams through their hadith; a small minority ("Qur'anists") reject hadith as a source of law.
Quick check
?The Qur'an commands Muslims to pray but does not give the number of rak'ahs in each prayer. Where do Muslims find it?
Mission 2Evaluate

Can the Qur'an ever be translated accurately?

Argument map: can the Qur'an be translated accurately?The message of the Qur'an can betranslated accurately.ForMeanings can be carried across: millions ofMuslims understand their faith throughtranslations.Careful translations with notes (e.g. YusufAli) give context and alternatives.AgainstArabic words carry many meanings atonce (e.g. khalifah); translators mustchoose.Sound, rhythm and rhyme are part of therevelation (i'jaz); they are lost in any otherlanguage.Judge it byIs "the message" the meaning or the words? ·Accurate enough for what: understanding,law, or worship?
  • Claim: The message of the Qur'an can be translated accurately.
  • For: Meanings can be carried across: millions of Muslims understand their faith through translations.
  • For: Careful translations with notes (e.g. Yusuf Ali) give context and alternatives.
  • Against: Arabic words carry many meanings at once (e.g. khalifah); translators must choose.
  • Against: Sound, rhythm and rhyme are part of the revelation (i'jaz); they are lost in any other language.
  • Judgement criteria: Is "the message" the meaning or the words? Accurate enough for what: understanding, law, or worship?
  • For relevance today, compare Nasr (timeless text) and Rahman (principles applied anew).
Mission check

?At home, Amina keeps her Arabic Qur'an wrapped on the highest shelf and performs wudu before opening it. Her English translation sits on her desk with her schoolbooks. Which belief best explains the difference?
Mission 3

Mission 3: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Make a guess: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Mission 3

Shari'a and fiqh

Shari'ah and fiqhshari'ahGod's way (ideal)fiqhhumanunderstanding
  • Shari'a: literally "the path to the water": God's way for human life.
  • "Then We put thee on the (right) Way of Religion: so follow thou that (Way), and follow not the desires of those who know not." (Qur'an 45:18, Yusuf Ali) The Arabic word is shari'ah.
  • It covers worship (prayer, fasting) and dealings (family, trade, food, crime): much more than criminal law.
  • Fiqh ("deep understanding"): the human effort to understand and apply the shari'a. Scholars can err; the shari'a, as God's will, cannot.
  • So Muslims distinguish the ideal (God's shari'a) from law in practice (the jurists' fiqh).
  • Edexcel spelling: Shari'ah.
Mission 3

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and Sunnah

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and Sunnah1 Qur'anthe first source: God's worde.g. commands prayer2 Sunnahthe Prophet's example, known throughhadith: explains and adds detail (shows howto pray)Shi'a: includes the Imams' teachingsHadith graded by chain and textsahihsoundhasangoodda'ifweak
  • Qur'an: the first source, God's word. Some rulings are clear (no pork, 5:3; fasting in Ramadan, 2:185); many verses give principles (justice, 4:58; consultation, 42:38).
  • Sunnah: the Prophet's example, known through hadith. It explains and adds detail: the Qur'an commands prayer; the Sunnah shows how to pray.
  • "So take what the Messenger assigns to you, and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you." (Qur'an 59:7, Yusuf Ali)
  • Hadith are graded by chain and text: sahih (sound), hasan (good), da'if (weak).
  • Shi'a Muslims include the teachings of the Imams within the Sunnah.
Mission 3

Non-scriptural sources

The sources of lawSunni1 Qur'anGod's word2 SunnahProphet's example3 ijmaconsensus4 qiyasanalogyTwelver Shi'aQur'anSunnah, withthe Imamsijma, if itreflects theImam's view'aql (reason)no qiyasAlso used: 'urf (custom), istihsan (Hanafi),maslahah (Maliki)
  • Ijma (consensus): agreement of the qualified scholars of an age on a ruling. Once reached, Sunnis treat it as binding ("my community will not agree on error", Ibn Majah; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas (analogy): extending a ruling from a case in the texts to a new case that shares its cause ('illah).
  • 'Urf (custom): local practice accepted where it does not contradict the texts (e.g. customary amounts of dowry). Malik also gave weight to the practice ('amal) of Madinah.
  • Other tools: istihsan (juristic preference, Hanafi), maslahah (public interest, Maliki).
  • Twelver Shi'a jurists: Qur'an, Sunnah (with the Imams), ijma (valid if it reflects the Imam's view) and 'aql (reason); they reject qiyas.
Mission 3Read the source

From wine to every intoxicant

Qiyas: from wine to every intoxicant2:219more harmthan benefit4:43don't prayintoxicated5:90avoidcompletelystages many scholars seeoriginal casewine (forbidden in the texts)cause ('illah)intoxication: it clouds the mindnew casecannabis, cocaine, other drugsrulingharam

> "They ask thee concerning wine and gambling. Say: 'In them is great sin, and some profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit.'" (Qur'an 2:219, Yusuf Ali)

> "O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper." (Qur'an 5:90, Yusuf Ali)

  • Many scholars see stages: 2:219 (more harm than benefit), 4:43 (do not pray intoxicated), 5:90 (avoid completely).
  • A hadith: "Every intoxicant is khamr, and every khamr is forbidden" (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas: original case: wine · cause ('illah): intoxication · new case: cannabis, cocaine, other drugs · ruling: haram.

Q1 Which verse gives the final ruling to avoid intoxicants completely?

Show answer

5:90.

Q2 What shared cause allows the ruling on wine to cover drugs?

Show answer

They intoxicate: they cloud the mind.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes how qiyas works?
Mission 3

Al-Shafi'i: a method for law

Al-Shafi'i and the founders of the Sunni schoolsAbu Hanifa699–767Malik ibn Anasc. 711–795al-Shafi'i767–820Ahmad ibn Hanbal780–855700750800850Al-Shafi'i, al-Risala: set out an order ofsources; called the founder of usul al-fiqh.
  • Muhammad ibn Idris al-Shafi'i (767–820), al-Risala ("The Epistle").
  • Before him, regional scholars (Kufa, Madinah) mixed hadith, local practice and personal opinion (ra'y) in different ways.
  • He set out an order of sources: Qur'an → Sunnah → ijma → qiyas.
  • A sound hadith binds, even if reported by a single chain, because the Sunnah explains the Qur'an (2:151: "Scripture and Wisdom", Yusuf Ali).
  • He limited free opinion and istihsan: reasoning must be tied to a text through qiyas.
  • So he is called the founder of usul al-fiqh (the roots, or method, of jurisprudence).
Mission 3

The law schools (madhhabs)

The law schools: where each predominatesHanafiTurkey, Central and South AsiaMalikiNorth and West AfricaShafi'iEgypt, East Africa, South-East AsiaHanbaliSaudi Arabia, QatarJa'fariIran, Iraqshading: named countries · dots: named regionsPredominant school only: most areas aremixed, and many Muslims live elsewhere.
  • Hanafi: Abu Hanifa (699–767), Kufa; wide use of reasoning and istihsan; Turkey, Central and South Asia (most British Muslims of South Asian heritage).
  • Maliki: Malik ibn Anas (c. 711–795), Madinah; al-Muwatta; the practice of Madinah; North and West Africa.
  • Shafi'i: al-Shafi'i; Egypt, East Africa, South-East Asia.
  • Hanbali: Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780–855), Baghdad; text first, cautious about reasoning; Saudi Arabia, Qatar.
  • Ja'fari: Ja'far al-Sadiq (d. 765), the sixth Imam; Twelver Shi'a; Iran, Iraq.
  • They agree on essentials; they differ in detail (e.g. hand position in prayer). Each recognises the others as legitimate.
  • Taqlid: ordinary Muslims follow a school or scholar; ijtihad: qualified jurists derive rulings within its framework.
Mission 3

The five rulings (ahkam)

The five rulings (ahkam)fard / wajibobligatorysalah; fasting in Ramadanmustahabb / mandubrecommendedextra prayers; sadaqahmubahpermittedmost foods; ordinary workmakruhdislikedwasting water in wuduharamforbiddenalcohol, gambling (5:90); pork (5:3)halal (lawful)
  • Fard / wajib (obligatory): rewarded if done, sin if left: salah, fasting in Ramadan.
  • Mustahabb / mandub (recommended): rewarded if done, no sin if left: extra prayers, sadaqah.
  • Mubah (permitted): neutral: most foods, ordinary work.
  • Makruh (disliked): better avoided, no sin if done: e.g. wasting water in wudu; coming to the mosque after eating raw garlic.
  • Haram (forbidden): sin if done: alcohol and gambling (5:90), pork (5:3).
  • Halal: lawful, everything not haram. Modesty: lower the gaze and guard modesty (24:30–31); dress rules derive from these verses and the Sunnah.
  • Killing and eating animals: halal meat is slaughtered with God's name (6:121), a swift cut and draining of blood; scholars differ on pre-stunning.
  • Makruh applied: smoking was long called makruh; as its harm became known, many scholars ruled it haram (harm to self is forbidden).
  • Edexcel: the "Akham (ahkam) pentad".
Quick check
?A Muslim decides not to smoke even though his local imam calls it makruh. Which statement about makruh is accurate?
Mission 3

Interpretation and authority beyond the texts

Authority beyond the textsulamascholarsmuftisissue fatwas(non-binding)madhhabslaw schoolsijtihadqualified juristsderive rulingstaqlidordinary Muslimsfollow a school orscholarThe "gate of ijtihad"Closed after about the 10th century? Acommon Sunni view: yes. Wael Hallaq: juristsnever stopped. Twelver Shi'a: always open.
  • Ulama (scholars), muftis issuing fatwas (non-binding legal opinions), and the schools carry authority beyond the texts.
  • Was the "gate of ijtihad" closed after about the 10th century? A common Sunni view said yes; Wael Hallaq (b. 1955) argues jurists never stopped independent reasoning. Twelver Shi'a always kept ijtihad open.
  • S. H. Nasr (b. 1933), Ideals and Realities of Islam (1966): the shari'ah is divine, the ideal pattern for every human act; its principles do not change, though applications do (paraphrase).
  • Fazlur Rahman Malik (1919–1988), Islam and Modernity (1982): a "double movement": from the Qur'an's specific rulings back to their moral aims, then forward to apply those aims today (paraphrase).
Mission 3Evaluate

Divine law or human interpretation?

Divine law or human interpretation?Shari'ah as Muslims practise it is morehuman interpretation than divine law.ForFiqh is human; the schools disagree;rulings change (smoking); applying oldrulings to new cases needs interpretation.Ijma and qiyas are human methods; stateshave codified and reshaped the law.Rahman's double movement supports thisside.AgainstThe sources and principles are divine;scholars discover rulings, they do notinvent them.The core (prayer, fasting, the mainprohibitions) is agreed across all schools.Nasr's view supports this side.A further viewThe limits of human understanding canlead to tolerance of diversity withinMuslim practice.Judge it byWhere is the line between Shari'ah and fiqh? ·Does diversity weaken authority or show itsdepth?
  • Claim: Shari'a as Muslims practise it is more human interpretation than divine law.
  • For: fiqh is human; the schools disagree; rulings change (smoking); applying old rulings to new cases needs interpretation.
  • For: ijma and qiyas are human methods; states have codified and reshaped the law.
  • Against: the sources and principles are divine; scholars discover rulings, they do not invent them.
  • Rahman's double movement supports "for"; Nasr's view supports "against".
  • Against: the core (prayer, fasting, the main prohibitions) is agreed across all schools.
  • A further view: the limits of human understanding can lead to tolerance of diversity within Muslim practice.
  • Criteria: Where is the line between shari'a and fiqh? Does diversity weaken authority or show its depth?
Mission check

?A new synthetic drug is sold as "not mentioned in any holy book, so permitted". A Sunni mufti rules it haram. Which reasoning is he most likely to use?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Islam has five verdicts for any action, not two. Why would a religion need a "disliked" category?

Make a guess: Islam has five verdicts for any action, not two. Why would a religion need a "disliked" category?

Mission 4

Why five categories?

Shari'ah covers all of lifeShari'ah: all of lifeworshipfamilytradefoodmanners
  • Muslims believe the shari'a covers all of life: worship, family, trade, food, manners.
  • As fiqh developed, jurists needed a clear way to say how strongly God wants or forbids an act.
  • The answer: al-ahkam al-khamsa, the five rulings, a scale from "must" to "must not".
  • The scale guides intention and reward, not only law courts.
  • Edexcel calls this the ahkam pentad; spelling Shari'ah.
  • S. H. Nasr stresses the Shari'ah as the divine pattern for every act of life; Fazlur Rahman (F. R. Malik) urged reading rulings in the light of the Qur'an's moral purposes (both paraphrased).
Mission 4

The scale of five

The five rulings: a scaleDo itLeave itfard / wajibobligatoryrewardsinmustahabrecommendedrewardno sinmubahneutralnothingnothingmakruhdislikedno sinrewardharamforbiddensinrewardrewardsinnothing / no sin
  • Fard (also wajib): obligatory. Doing it is rewarded; leaving it is a sin.
  • Mustahab (also mandub, sunna): recommended. Doing it is rewarded; leaving it is no sin.
  • Mubah: permitted and neutral. No reward, no sin.
  • Makruh: disliked. Avoiding it is rewarded; doing it is no sin, but it is discouraged.
  • Haram: forbidden. Doing it is a sin; avoiding it for God's sake is rewarded.
  • Halal means "permitted": in a broad sense everything not haram; Eduqas uses halal for the middle category.
Mission 4Read the source

Do not invent the haram

> "O ye who believe! make not unlawful the good things which Allah hath made lawful for you, but commit no excess" (Qur'an 5:87, Yusuf Ali)

> "But say not - for any false thing that your tongues may put forth,- 'This is lawful, and this is forbidden,' so as to ascribe false things to Allah." (Qur'an 16:116, Yusuf Ali)

  • Jurists drew a principle: in everyday matters, the default is permission; a ban needs evidence.

Q1 What two errors does 5:87 warn against?

Show answer

Forbidding what God allowed; and excess.

Q2 Why might 16:116 make jurists slow to call something haram?

Show answer

Declaring a ban without proof is attributing a lie to God.

Quick check
?In the five categories, what is the difference between a mustahab act and a mubah act?
Mission 4

Fard and mustahab: examples

  • Fard: the five daily salah; fasting in Ramadan; zakah; Hajj if able; honesty; caring for parents.
  • Fard 'ayn: on each person (salah). Fard kifaya: on the community; if some do it, the rest are free (funeral prayer, training doctors).
  • Mustahab: extra (sunna) prayers; fasting on Mondays and Thursdays; sadaqah; saying bismillah before eating; using the miswak (tooth-stick).
  • Greeting with salam is mustahab; replying to it is obligatory.
  • These categories show a Muslim where the floor is and how to go above it.
Mission 4

Mubah, makruh, haram: examples

  • Mubah: most daily choices: which halal food, which job, what colour to wear.
  • Makruh: wasting water in wudu; eating raw garlic or onion before going to the mosque (Bukhari; paraphrase); many classical jurists put smoking here.
  • Divorce is lawful but discouraged: reported as the most hated of permitted things to God (Abu Dawud; paraphrase; chain debated).
  • Haram: alcohol and gambling (5:90); pork, blood and carrion (2:173); theft; riba; lying; murder.
  • Killing animals for food: halal if slaughtered in God's name with a swift cut to the throat and the blood drained; whether pre-stunning is acceptable is debated.
  • Modesty: covering the body as required is fard; immodest display is haram; how much must be covered, and whether a face veil is required, varies among schools and scholars.
Mission 4Diversity

Same scale, different placements

Same scale, different placementsSchoolwitr prayerprawnsHanafiwajibmakruh orforbidden (manyHanafis; viewsdiffer)otherschoolsstronglyrecommendedhalal for mostschoolssmokingmany classical jurists: makruh; schools andscholars place it differently
  • Hanafi jurists split the top: fard (proved by certain evidence) and wajib (by less certain evidence), e.g. the witr prayer is wajib for Hanafis, strongly recommended for other schools.
  • Hanafis also split makruh tahrimi (close to haram) and makruh tanzihi (mildly disliked).
  • Twelver Shi'a jurists use the same five: wajib, mustahabb, mubah, makruh, haram.
  • The same act may sit in different places: e.g. prawns are halal for most schools, makruh or forbidden for many Hanafis.
  • Each believer follows their school or, for Twelver Shi'a, a senior scholar (marja') (taqlid: following a qualified scholar or school).
Quick check
?Which pairing of an action with its category do most Sunni jurists accept?
Mission check

?Yusuf oversleeps and has time only for the two fard rak'ahs of Fajr, so he misses the sunna prayer before them. How do most jurists judge this?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • The Qur'an: God's speech (kalam Allah), revealed through Jibril (wahy) to Muhammad in Arabic, in stages, 610–632 (2:97, 17:106).
  • Makkan surahs: short, tawhid and judgement; Madinan: longer, law and community. 114 surahs, al-Fatiha first, then roughly by length.
  • Memorised and written in the Prophet's life; gathered under Abu Bakr (Zayd); standardised under Uthman (c. 650); "We will assuredly guard it" (15:9).

Mission 2

  • Muslims believe the Arabic words are revealed (12:2) and inimitable (17:88); translation is interpretation, so salah stays in Arabic.
  • Treated with respect (56:79: wudu, kept high, never on the floor); recited with tajwid, memorised by huffaz, read through in Ramadan.
  • Al-Fatiha declares God and submission; al-Baqarah summarises guidance, belief and practice. Nasr: sacred text; Rahman (Malik): moral principles.

Mission 3

  • Shari'a is God's way; fiqh is the human understanding of it. Sources: Qur'an and Sunnah, then ijma, qiyas and custom (Twelvers: reason instead of qiyas).
  • Al-Shafi'i (767–820) set the order of sources; five schools (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali, Ja'fari) apply them.
  • Every act falls under five rulings: obligatory, recommended, permitted, disliked (makruh), forbidden (haram).

Mission 4

  • Fard, mustahab, mubah (halal), makruh, haram: a scale of how strongly God wills an act, linked to reward and sin.
  • Most of life is permitted; bans need evidence (5:87, 16:116); necessity and intention matter.
  • Schools differ at the edges (Hanafi fard/wajib; prawns; smoking); Shi'a fiqh uses the same five.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islam: Sources of wisdom and authority (part 2) for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If the Qur'an came in pieces over 23 years, how did it become one book?
  2. Mission 2Why do Muslims who don't speak Arabic still learn to recite the Qur'an in Arabic?
  3. Mission 3The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  4. Mission 4Islam has five verdicts for any action, not two. Why would a religion need a "disliked" category?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel