← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4C Hinduism – 6 Religion and society
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: Religion and society

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If all paths lead to God, can a Hindu still think one path is best?
  2. Mission 2Can you keep a 3,000-year-old tradition alive in a Leicester terrace or a London suburb?
  3. Mission 3Yoga, karma, Diwali lights: does the West understand Hinduism, and what makes someone a British Hindu?
  4. Mission 4One law book says women must be honoured and also never independent. What do Hindus make of that?
  5. Mission 5Sati was banned in 1829. Did change for Hindu women come from inside the tradition or outside?
  6. Mission 6Is wanting money a spiritual failure, or can wealth serve God and the poor in Hindu teaching?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Hinduism: Practices and identity.

Mission 1

Mission 1: If all paths lead to God, can a Hindu still think one path is best?

Make a guess: If all paths lead to God, can a Hindu still think one path is best?

Mission 1

Diversity is not pluralism

Four positionsExclusivismonly one religionleads to the truthInclusivismone (the main road)holds the fullesttruth; others containpartPluralismmany religions arevalid paths to thetruthDiversitythe fact: manyreligions exist side byside
  • Diversity: the fact that many religions (or many traditions) exist side by side.
  • Pluralism: a view about that fact: many religions are valid paths to the truth.
  • Exclusivism: only one religion leads to the truth or to liberation.
  • Inclusivism: one religion holds the fullest truth; others contain part of it.
  • Inside Hinduism itself: Vaishnavas, Shaivas, Shaktas, Smartas and many local traditions live together without one creed or authority.
  • Gavin Flood (An Introduction to Hinduism, 1996): "Hinduism" has fuzzy edges; some forms are central, others less typical, so it may be seen as a family of traditions (paraphrase).
Mission 1

Ishtadeva: your chosen form of God

IshtadevaVishnuKrishnaRamaShivaDurgaGaneshaBrahmanone Brahman, many names and forms:choosing one does not deny the others
  • Ishtadeva (or ishta-devata): "chosen" or "cherished" deity, the form of God a person or family is drawn to.
  • One Brahman, many names and forms: Vishnu, Krishna, Rama, Shiva, Durga, Ganesha.
  • Choosing one focus does not deny the others: a Krishna devotee may also honour Ganesha and visit a Shiva temple.
  • Many Hindus apply the same logic to other religions: Jesus or Allah as further names of the one God.
Mission 1Read the source

One truth, many names

  • "Truth is one; the wise call it by many names." (Rig Veda 1.164.46, paraphrase)

> "Whoso worship me, / Them I exalt; but all men everywhere / Shall fall into my path" (Bhagavad Gita 4:11, Arnold 1885)

> "Nay, and of hearts which follow other gods / In simple faith, their prayers arise to me, / O Kunti's Son! though they pray wrongfully" (Bhagavad Gita 9:23, Arnold 1885)

Q1 What does 4:11 suggest about people on other paths?

Show answer

All paths come to Krishna in the end.

Q2 What qualification does 9:23 add?

Show answer

Worship of other gods reaches Krishna, but is "wrongful", not the proper way: a ranking.

Quick check
?Which view of other religions best fits Bhagavad Gita 9:23 ("their prayers arise to me … though they pray wrongfully")?
Mission 1

Vedanta as religion

Vedanta as religionVivekananda's viewVEDANTAVaishnavaShaivaShaktaChristianityIslamother faithsHindu sectsother religionsOne view: every faith, and every Hindu sect, isa partial expression of Vedanta (Chicago,1893)
  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902), Chicago, 11 September 1893, quoting a Hindu hymn: "As the different streams having their sources in different places all mingle their water in the sea, so, O Lord, the different paths which men take … all lead to Thee." (Vivekananda, Chicago address, 1893)
  • His claim: Vedanta (above all Advaita) is not one religion among many but the universal religion: every faith, and every Hindu sect, is a partial expression of it.
  • Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan (1888–1975), The Hindu View of Life (1927), paraphrase: Hinduism welcomes all forms of worship as approaches to the one reality, but ranks them, with worship of the formless Absolute highest.
Mission 1Diversity

Hindu responses to "Vedanta as religion"

ResponsesGroupView ofother faithsTends toNeo-Vedantins(RamakrishnaMission)welcome it:"as manyfaiths, somany paths"pluralist intheir ownwords;Hacker:inclusivistDvaita(Madhva)reject it: Godis a person;some soulsneverliberatedtends toexclusivismISKCON(theisticVaishnavas)reject it: Godis a person,notimpersonalBrahmansome: onlydevotion toKrishna bringsfull liberationArya Samajthe Vedasalone are truetends toexclusivismHindutvatolerance as amark of Hindusuperiorityexclusiveaboutbelonging, notsalvationOther faithsmanyChristiansand Muslimsobjectnot a "partial"Vedanta
  • Neo-Vedantins (Ramakrishna Mission): welcome it; Ramakrishna practised Christian and Muslim devotions and taught "as many faiths, so many paths".
  • Theistic Vaishnavas (e.g. Madhva's Dvaita tradition; ISKCON): reject it; God is a person, not impersonal Brahman, and Advaita is not the Hindu norm.
  • Arya Samaj: the Vedas alone are true; Dayananda's Satyarth Prakash (1875) criticised other religions.
  • Hindutva: uses tolerance as a mark of Hindu superiority but draws national boundaries.
  • Scholars: Paul Hacker (1913–1979) called this pattern inclusivism: other views are absorbed and placed lower. Many Christians and Muslims object that their faith is not a "partial" Vedanta.
Quick check
?Which group is most likely to reject the claim that all religions are partial expressions of Vedanta?
Mission 1

Exclusivism in Hindu settings

ResponsesGroupView ofother faithsTends toNeo-Vedantins(RamakrishnaMission)welcome it:"as manyfaiths, somany paths"pluralist intheir ownwords;Hacker:inclusivistDvaita(Madhva)reject it: Godis a person;some soulsneverliberatedtends toexclusivismISKCON(theisticVaishnavas)reject it: Godis a person,notimpersonalBrahmansome: onlydevotion toKrishna bringsfull liberationArya Samajthe Vedasalone are truetends toexclusivismHindutvatolerance as amark of Hindusuperiorityexclusiveaboutbelonging, notsalvationOther faithsmanyChristiansand Muslimsobjectnot a "partial"Vedanta
  • Hindutva: not exclusive about salvation, but about belonging: full membership of the nation tied to holy land in India.
  • Your spec: "exclusivism with reference to Hindutva".
  • Sectarian: some Vaishnavas say only devotion to Krishna/Vishnu brings full liberation; Madhva even taught that some souls are never liberated.
  • Conversion: most Hindu traditions do not seek converts; many Hindus see missionary conversion as disrespect for other paths.
Mission 1Diversity

Living it: from India to Britain

An interfaith walkHigh St1234mandirgurdwarachurchmosque1mandir:school visits and interfaith events2gurdwara:Hindu–Sikh–Jain ties: sharedfestivals (Diwali)3church:shared spaces: Hindus visit churchestoo4mosque:one more stop on the interfaith walk
  • Shared spaces: Hindus visit Sufi shrines and churches; in Britain many mandirs host school visits and interfaith events.
  • Hindu–Sikh–Jain ties: shared festivals (Diwali), sometimes shared buildings in the UK.
  • Organisations: Hindu Council UK and the Hindu Forum of Britain take part in national interfaith work.
  • Tensions: debates about conversion, about caste, and about events in India can strain relations abroad.
  • Friedhelm Hardy (1943–2004), The Religious Culture of India (1994), paraphrase: India's religious life is a web of many regional traditions; "Hinduism" is one way of grouping them.
Quick check
?A Hindu says: "I worship Shiva, but I am glad my neighbour worships Krishna and my colleague prays in a mosque. God is honoured in all of them." Which idea does the first half of this most clearly show?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Hinduism is inclusivist rather than pluralist."

Inclusivist or pluralist?"Hinduism is inclusivist rather thanpluralist."For inclusivismThe Gita includes other worship but callsit "wrongful" (9:23).Radhakrishnan ranks forms of religion.Vedanta-as-religion places Advaita at thetop.Hindutva and some sects drawboundaries.For pluralismIshtadeva: a chosen form does not excludeothers."Truth is one, the wise call it by manynames."Ramakrishna practised several faiths.Gandhi's equal respect for religions.No Hindu creed to exclude anyone.ComplicationThere is no single Hinduism (Flood):Advaitins, Dvaitins and Neo-Vedantinsanswer differently.Judge it byDo Hindus rank paths, or only describe them?· Is "all paths are Vedanta" generous orabsorbing?
  • For inclusivism: the Gita includes other worship but calls it "wrongful" (9:23); Radhakrishnan ranks forms of religion; Vedanta-as-religion places Advaita at the top; Hindutva and some sects draw boundaries.
  • For pluralism: ishtadeva; "Truth is one, the wise call it by many names"; Ramakrishna practised several faiths; Gandhi's equal respect for religions; no Hindu creed to exclude anyone.
  • Complication: there is no single Hinduism (Flood): Advaitins, Dvaitins and Neo-Vedantins answer differently.
  • Judge it by: do Hindus rank paths, or only describe them? Is "all paths are Vedanta" generous or absorbing?
Mission check

?A Hindu student tells a Christian friend: "Jesus is a real path to God. In the end, though, your path and mine are both part of the one truth that Vedanta teaches." Which description fits this view best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can you keep a 3,000-year-old tradition alive in a Leicester terrace or a London suburb?

Make a guess: Can you keep a 3,000-year-old tradition alive in a Leicester terrace or a London suburb?

Mission 2

Arriving in Britain

Arriving in BritainUKGujaratPunjabKenya, UgandaSri Lanka11950s–60sfrom Gujarat and Punjab, to work in mills,factories, transport21967–72Gujarati Hindus from Kenya and Uganda(expulsion from Uganda, 1972)31980s–90sTamil Hindus from Sri Lanka (civil war)2021 CensusEngland and Wales: just over 1 million Hindus,1.7% of the population. Source: ONS Census2021
  • 1950s–60s: men from Gujarat and Punjab come to work in mills, factories and transport; families follow.
  • 1967–72: East African Asians, mostly Gujarati Hindus, leave Kenya and Uganda (Idi Amin's expulsion, 1972); many arrive with business and professional skills.
  • 1980s–90s: Tamil Hindus from Sri Lanka (civil war); later skilled migrants from across India, and Nepalis.
  • Main centres: London (Brent, Harrow), Leicester, Birmingham, Bradford, Coventry.
  • 2021 Census (England and Wales): just over 1 million Hindus, 1.7% of the population.
  • Your spec: "Hindu migration, including Hinduism in the UK".
Quick check
?Which statement about Hindu migration to Britain is accurate?
Mission 2

From front rooms to mandirs

From front rooms to mandirs1Homea shrine in the frontroom or on a kitchenshelf2Hired hallrented halls forfestivals3Convertedbuildingformer churches,chapels, schoolsbecome mandirs4Purpose-builtmandirstone mandirs, e.g.the BAPS mandir,Neasden (1995)
  • Worship began at home: a shrine in the front room or a kitchen shelf.
  • Then rented halls for festivals, then converted buildings (churches, chapels, schools) as mandirs.
  • Then purpose-built stone mandirs, e.g. the BAPS Shri Swaminarayan Mandir, Neasden (1995).
  • Diversity: regional (Gujarati, Punjabi, Tamil, Bengali); sampradayas (Swaminarayan, Pushtimarg, ISKCON, Sathya Sai, Shaiva temples); caste associations.
  • Many mandirs serve everyone: several deities under one roof, English used for children.
Mission 2

Daily practice in a non-Hindu society

A UK weekMonTueWedThuFriSatSun6 am9 am5 pm9 pmfestivalwork and schoolpuja: squeezed into a short early slotwork and schoolfestival moved to the nearest weekend
  • Time: work and school timetables leave less time for daily puja; festivals move to the nearest weekend.
  • Priests: often trained in India; fewer can explain rituals in English.
  • Food: vegetarianism and fasting are harder at school, work and university.
  • Language: children may not speak Gujarati, Tamil or Hindi; mandirs run classes and use English.
  • Public festivals: Leicester's Diwali lights are often described as among the largest outside India; Navaratri dances (garba) fill halls.
Mission 2

Freedom of religion as a human right

Law and practicePracticeLawOutcomeOpen-air pyreCremationAct 1902:cremation inacrematoriumno openriverside pyreon public land;a son may stillstart thecremationAshes in ariverUK lawashes may beplaced in a riverTemple bull(Skanda Vale)Article 9may belimited forpublic healthShambo, withbovine TB,slaughtered(2007)Public worship(BhaktivedantaManor)planning lawlong disputeended with anew accessroad (1996)
  • European Convention on Human Rights, Article 9 (1950): freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including worship and practice; in UK law through the Human Rights Act 1998.
  • It may be limited by law where necessary for public safety, order, health or others' rights.
  • Skanda Vale (2007): the temple bull Shambo tested positive for bovine TB; the courts allowed the Welsh government to slaughter him despite Article 9.
  • Bhaktivedanta Manor: a long planning dispute over public worship ended when a new access road was approved (1996).
  • Effect on Hindu thought: Hindus present themselves as one faith community among others, alongside churches, mosques and gurdwaras.
  • Example, funerals: UK law requires cremation in a crematorium (Cremation Act 1902), so an open riverside pyre on public land is not allowed; a son may still start the cremation, and ashes may be placed in a river.
Quick check
?Why did the courts allow the slaughter of Shambo, the Skanda Vale temple bull, in 2007?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Traditional Hinduism cannot be fully practised in a non-Hindu society."

Fully practised?"Traditional Hinduism cannot be fullypractised in a non-Hindu society."ForNo sacred rivers or tirthas; funeral ritesmust change.Varnashrama barely fits.Priests and languages come from India;time pressures.AgainstHome puja, festivals and mandir life thrive.The law protects religious freedom.Sacred sites can be created.India itself has adapted constantly.Another view"Traditional" was never one thing;adaptation (e.g. weekend festivals) is itselftraditional, since dharma depends on timeand place.Judge it byWhich practices are essential? · Whosetradition (Gujarati, Tamil, Punjabi)? · Whichgeneration?
  • For: no sacred rivers or tirthas; funeral rites must change; varnashrama barely fits; priests and languages from India; time pressures.
  • Against: home puja, festivals and mandir life thrive; the law protects religious freedom; sacred sites can be created; India itself has adapted constantly.
  • Another view: "traditional" was never one thing; adaptation (e.g. weekend festivals) is itself traditional, since dharma depends on time and place.
  • Judge it by: which practices are essential? Whose tradition (Gujarati, Tamil, Punjabi)? Which generation?
Mission check

?A Tamil Hindu family in Birmingham wants their grandmother's funeral to follow tradition as closely as English law allows. Which plan fits best?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Yoga, karma, Diwali lights: does the West understand Hinduism, and what makes someone a British Hindu?

Make a guess: Yoga, karma, Diwali lights: does the West understand Hinduism, and what makes someone a British Hindu?

Mission 3

What makes a Hindu identity?

Identity braidbeliefpracticelifestyleworshipbelongingPractisingall strands strongCulturalfestivals and family; little belief or practiceSpiritual,not religiousbelief and lifestyle; little worship or belonging
  • No creed, founder or single scripture to sign up to. So identity is built from several strands.
  • Belief: Brahman, deities, karma, rebirth, dharma.
  • Practice and worship: home puja, mandir, festivals, samskaras (life rites).
  • Lifestyle and conduct: vegetarianism, ahimsa, family duty, respect for elders.
  • Belonging: family, region (Gujarati, Punjabi, Tamil), caste, language, sampradaya.
  • A person may be strong in some strands and weak in others: "practising", "cultural" and "spiritual but not religious" Hindus.
Mission 3

Popular culture

Popular cultureYogaglobal fitness, oftencut off from its rootsand goal (moksha)"Karma""karma"used for instantpayback or luck, notthe law of action andrebirthProductsdeity images onshoes, swimwear anddrinks have drawnHindu protestsFilm and TVTemple of Doom(1984) criticised forits picture of Kaliworship; Apu forstereotypingPositive visibilityDiwali in Trafalgar Square;Bollywood; Holi-style colourruns
  • Yoga: a global fitness practice, often cut off from its Hindu roots and goal (moksha).
  • "Karma": used to mean instant payback or luck, not the law of action and rebirth.
  • Images: deities printed on shoes, swimwear and drinks have drawn Hindu protests.
  • Film and TV: Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom (1984) was criticised for its picture of Kali worship; the Simpsons character Apu for stereotyping South Asians.
  • Positive visibility: Diwali in Trafalgar Square; Bollywood; Holi-style colour runs (sometimes criticised as stripped of meaning).
Mission 3

Secularisation in Britain

SecularisationSource of truthscience and reason,not scriptureMoral valueslaw, human rightsand personal choicePublic lifeschools and publiclife largely secularPrivate faithreligion becomes aprivate choice37.2%said "no religion"2021 Census, England and WalesSource: ONS 2021
  • Secularisation: religion loses social influence. In the 2021 Census, 37.2% of people in England and Wales said they had no religion.
  • Source of truth: science and reason, not scripture, become the public authority.
  • Moral values: law, human rights and personal choice, not religious teaching.
  • Personal sphere: religion becomes a private choice; schools and public life are largely secular.
  • For Hindus: pressure to treat Hinduism as private "culture"; children educated in secular values; less time for ritual.
Mission 3

Generations and identity

GenerationsFirst generationidentity through region, caste,language and village links;religion taken for grantedSecond and third generations"British Hindu"; more choice;less ritual knowledge, morequestions ("why do we dothis?")Their responsesuniversity Hindu societies builda shared identity; some stressdharma as lifestyle, othersbecome cultural Hindus
  • First generation: identity through region, caste, language and village links; religion taken for granted.
  • Second and third generations: "British Hindu"; more choice; less ritual knowledge, more questions ("why do we do this?").
  • University Hindu societies (e.g. the National Hindu Students' Forum) and youth wings build a shared Hindu identity across regions and castes.
  • Some young people stress dharma as lifestyle: vegetarianism, ethics, yoga, service.
  • Others become cultural Hindus: festivals and family, little belief or practice.
  • Your spec: "religious practice in a multi-cultural society".
Mission 3Evaluate

"There is one clear Hindu identity in Britain."

One identity?"There is one clear Hindu identity inBritain."ForCommon festivals and values.National bodies speak for "British Hindus".The Census groups 1 million people asHindu.Young people build a shared identity.AgainstDeep regional, linguistic, caste andsampradaya differences.ISKCON converts and Gujarati elders mayshare little.Many are "cultural" Hindus.Judge it byWhich strands of identity (belief, practice,belonging) count most? · Is "Hindu" a religion,a culture, or both?
  • For: common festivals and values; national bodies speak for "British Hindus"; the Census groups 1 million people as Hindu; young people build a shared identity.
  • Against: deep regional, linguistic, caste and sampradaya differences; ISKCON converts and Gujarati elders may share little; many are "cultural" Hindus.
  • Judge it by: which strands of identity (belief, practice, belonging) count most? Is "Hindu" a religion, a culture, or both?
Mission check

?Priya, 19, born in Leicester, is vegetarian, does yoga daily and keeps Diwali with family, but rarely visits a mandir and is unsure about rebirth. Using the strands of Hindu identity, which description fits her best?
Mission 4

Mission 4: One law book says women must be honoured and also never independent. What do Hindus make of that?

Make a guess: One law book says women must be honoured and also never independent. What do Hindus make of that?

Mission 4

Stridharma: a woman's duty

  • Dharma is duty by one's place in life; stridharma is the dharma of women (stri, woman).
  • Classical texts set it mainly within the household: serving husband and family, keeping rituals of the home, raising children.
  • The ideal of the pativrata: a wife devoted to her husband, as Sita (Ramayana) and Savitri (Mahabharata) are remembered.
  • Texts were written by men, mostly Brahmin, for an ideal society; lived practice varied by region, jati and era.
  • Example: Tryambakayajvan's Stridharmapaddhati (18th century, Thanjavur), a rulebook for wives.
  • Many Hindu women also hold religious roles of their own: fasts (vratas) for family welfare, household puja, singing bhajans.
Mission 4Read the source

Two voices in the Manusmriti

Two voicesManusmriti (smriti)3.56where women arehonoured, the godsrejoice5.147–148, 9.3never independent:protected by father,husband, sonboth are paraphrases

Manusmriti 3.56 (paraphrase): where women are honoured, the gods rejoice; where they are not honoured, all rites bring no reward.

Manusmriti 5.147–148 and 9.3 (paraphrase): a woman should never act independently; she is protected by her father in childhood, her husband in youth and her sons in old age.

Q1 What do the two passages share?

Show answer

Both assume men are responsible for women: honour and protection.

Q2 Why can both feminists and traditionalists quote the Manusmriti?

Show answer

It both honours women and limits their independence.

  • The Manusmriti is smriti (remembered tradition), not shruti; many Hindus treat it as a product of its time.
Mission 4

Marriage at the centre

Wedding ritesacred fire1234567saptapadiseven steps around the sacred firekanyadanthe father gives his daughter in marriagerites vary by region
  • Vivaha (marriage) is one of the samskaras (life-cycle rites) and opens the grihastha (householder) stage.
  • Traditionally a sacred, lifelong bond, not a contract: the couple take seven steps (saptapadi) around the sacred fire.
  • Kanyadan: the father gives his daughter in marriage; she joins her husband's family.
  • For women, classical texts treat marriage as their main samskara, in place of the student initiation boys receive.
  • Children: the householder's duty includes continuing the family and its rites.
  • Many Hindu marriages are arranged (by families, with the couple's consent); "love marriages" are increasingly common.
Mission 4

Sons and daughters

  • Sons: traditionally perform the parents' funeral rites (antyeshti) and the ancestral offerings (shraddha); the eldest son lights the pyre.
  • Manusmriti 9.138 explains putra (son) as one who saves his father from a hell called put (paraphrase): a basis of son preference.
  • Sons usually stay in the family home and care for parents in old age.
  • Daughters: honoured as Lakshmi in the home, but often called "another's wealth" (paraya dhan), since they leave at marriage.
  • Today many daughters perform last rites, and inheritance law gives daughters equal shares (see Mission 5).
Mission 4

Shiva and Shakti: Saivism and gender

ArdhanarishvaraParvatiShivaArdhanarishvarathe lord who is half woman
  • In Saivism, Shiva is supreme; he is never without Shakti, divine power, often worshipped as the goddess Parvati.
  • Ardhanarishvara ("the lord who is half woman"): Shiva and Parvati as one form, right half male, left half female.
  • Many Saivas read this as complementarity: male and female are equal halves of the divine.
  • In Shaktism the Goddess (Devi) is herself supreme.
  • Women saints honoured in Shaiva traditions: Karaikkal Ammaiyar (Tamil, c. 6th century); Akka Mahadevi (Virashaiva, 12th century, Karnataka); Lal Ded (Kashmir, 14th century).
  • Critics: honour for a goddess does not guarantee equality for women in society.
  • Spec wording: "significance within Saivism".
Mission 4

Brahmacharya and celibacy

  • Brahmacharya: (1) the student stage of life; (2) celibacy and self-control in general.
  • The student stage, with the sacred-thread initiation (upanayana), was traditionally for boys of the three upper varnas.
  • Yet the Upanishads name women thinkers: Gargi and Maitreyi debate and question in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (3.6, 3.8; 2.4).
  • Atharva Veda 11.5.18 links a girl's brahmacharya to finding a good husband (paraphrase): some read this as evidence of early education for girls.
  • Celibacy is honoured in sannyasa (renunciation) and by many gurus; Gandhi took a vow of brahmacharya in 1906.
  • Women renunciants today: e.g. Sri Sarada Math (founded 1954), led by women monks.
  • Most Hindus see marriage, not celibacy, as the normal path; celibacy is a calling for some, or for later life.
Quick check
?Which statement about brahmacharya is accurate?
Mission 4

Changing roles of men and women

  • Education and work: Hindu women now work in every profession; many families value daughters' education as highly as sons'.
  • Religious roles: women priests (pujaris) trained in some places (e.g. by the Shankar Seva Samiti and Jnana Prabodhini in Pune); women gurus (e.g. Anandamayi Ma, 1896–1982; Mata Amritanandamayi, b. 1953).
  • Roles of men: more shared housework and child care in many families; but the provider role and son preference persist.
  • Diaspora: British Hindu women lead temple committees and teach in Hindu schools.
  • Many Hindus reinterpret stridharma as mutual duties of partners; traditionalists see the old roles as complementary, not unequal.
Mission check

?Priya, a British Hindu surgeon, keeps a weekly vrata for her family and says: "Stridharma for me means caring duties shared with my husband, not obeying him." How is her view best described?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Sati was banned in 1829. Did change for Hindu women come from inside the tradition or outside?

Make a guess: Sati was banned in 1829. Did change for Hindu women come from inside the tradition or outside?

Mission 5

An encounter with empire

Reform timeline1829Sati banned in Bengal1856Widow remarriage law (British law)1950Constitution: equality; no discrimination bysex1955–56Hindu Code: monogamy, divorce,daughters inherit1961Law on dowry1987Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act2005Daughters gain equal rights in ancestralfamily property
  • From the late 1700s, Britain ruled more and more of India: new laws, missionary schools, Western ideas of rights and reason.
  • Missionaries and officials often attacked Hindu practice, especially the treatment of women.
  • Hindu reformers answered in two ways at once: they used Western arguments and went back to Hindu texts to show that harmful customs were not true dharma.
  • Later, India's secular state (from 1947) gave women rights by law, outside religion.
  • So change came from three sources: reformers within, colonial rule, and the secular state. How much from each is debated.
Mission 5

Sati

  • Sati: a widow burning herself, or being burned, on her husband's funeral pyre. Named after the goddess Sati, though in her story she was not a widow.
  • Never universal: practised mainly among some higher castes in some regions; cases rose in early 19th-century Bengal.
  • Defenders praised it as the supreme act of a pativrata (devoted wife); opponents called it murder, often under family pressure.
  • Banned in Bengal in 1829 (Governor-General William Bentinck), after Hindu reformers' campaigns. Ram Mohan Roy (1772–1833) argued from Hindu law books that sati was not required.
  • A case in Rajasthan in 1987 (Roop Kanwar) led to the Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act 1987, which also bans glorifying sati.
Mission 5

Rights from a secular state

Reform timeline1829Sati banned in Bengal1856Widow remarriage law (British law)1950Constitution: equality; no discrimination bysex1955–56Hindu Code: monogamy, divorce,daughters inherit1961Law on dowry1987Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act2005Daughters gain equal rights in ancestralfamily property
  • The Constitution (1950): equality before the law (Article 14), no discrimination by sex (Article 15); every adult woman can vote.
  • The Hindu Code (1955–56): Hindu Marriage Act (monogamy, divorce); Hindu Succession Act (daughters inherit); adoption and guardianship laws. Ambedkar resigned as Law Minister in 1951 partly because the bill was delayed.
  • 2005: daughters gain equal rights in ancestral family property.
  • Laws on dowry (1961), sex selection (1994), domestic violence (2005).
  • Outside religion: education, jobs and cities changed roles of men and women; many men now share work once called women's.
  • Some Hindus welcomed this as true dharma; others saw state interference in religious law.
Mission 5

Hardy and Flood: feminist readings

  • Gavin Flood (b. 1954), An Introduction to Hinduism (1996): stridharma is the ideal of the Brahmin law books; women's own religious lives (vratas, household rites, goddess worship) have their own power and meaning (paraphrase).
  • Friedhelm Hardy (1943–2004): in emotional bhakti, women saints such as Andal (Tamil, 8th century) and Mirabai (16th century) speak with authority of their love for Krishna (paraphrase).
  • Feminist question: does honouring goddesses and women saints raise women's status, or sit alongside real inequality?
  • Feminist approaches look for women's voices inside the tradition, and test texts by their effects on women's lives.
  • Spec wording: "feminist and liberationist approaches", with the ideas of F Hardy and G Flood.
Mission 5Evaluate

Is feminism an issue in Hinduism today?

Inside or outside?InsideRoyargued from theshastrasbhakti saintsgave women voiceOutsideBritish law1829 sati ban; 1856widow remarriagesecular stateConstitution andHindu Codeeconomyeconomic changeBothmost reforms needed Hindu argumentsand state law
  • Claim: Feminism is still a live issue in Hinduism today.
  • For: dowry, son preference and widow stigma persist; some texts limit women's independence.
  • For: Dalit feminists show women are still unequal within caste.
  • Against: law gives equal rights; many Hindu women lead, teach and serve as priests.
  • Against: some Hindu women say their own religious lives (vratas, goddess worship, women saints) give them resources, so a Western-style feminism is not needed.
  • Judgement criteria: issue in teaching, or in culture? Which women: urban or rural, upper-caste or Dalit? Measured by law or by daily life?
Quick check
?Which question would a feminist approach to Hinduism, as discussed by Flood and Hardy, ask?
Mission 5

Change from inside or outside?

Inside or outside?InsideRoyargued from theshastrasbhakti saintsgave women voiceOutsideBritish law1829 sati ban; 1856widow remarriagesecular stateConstitution andHindu Codeeconomyeconomic changeBothmost reforms needed Hindu argumentsand state law
  • Inside: Roy argued from the shastras; bhakti saints gave women voice.
  • Outside: British law (1829 sati ban; 1856 widow remarriage), the secular Constitution and Hindu Code, economic change.
  • Both: most reforms needed Hindu arguments and state law.
  • Impact on men: new laws changed fathers' and husbands' duties (shared property, no dowry, divorce), and many men's roles at home.
Mission check

?A Hindu temple trust in Britain votes to let women lead the main arti. Supporters cite women saints and the Manusmriti's teaching that where women are honoured, the gods rejoice. Which kind of reform is this most like?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Is wanting money a spiritual failure, or can wealth serve God and the poor in Hindu teaching?

Make a guess: Is wanting money a spiritual failure, or can wealth serve God and the poor in Hindu teaching?

Mission 6

Artha among the four aims

Four aimsdharmarighteousness, duty: the framearthawealth, prosperitykamapleasure, lovepursued within dharmamokshaliberation
  • The purusharthas, four aims of human life: dharma (righteousness, duty), artha (wealth, prosperity), kama (pleasure, love), moksha (liberation).
  • Artha is a legitimate aim, especially for the grihastha (householder), who supports family, guests, students and renunciants.
  • The rule: artha and kama are pursued within dharma, and all point towards moksha.
  • Wealth gained by adharma (cheating, harm) or hoarded without giving brings bad karma.
  • Dana (giving) is a duty of the householder.
  • So the Hindu attitude: neither "wealth is evil" nor "wealth is everything".
Mission 6

Practical Vedanta: serving God in the poor

  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902) reinterpreted Advaita Vedanta for action.
  • If Brahman is in every being, serving people is serving God: daridra narayana, "God in the poor".
  • From his teacher Ramakrishna: serve living beings as Shiva (shiva jnane jiva seva).
  • Ramakrishna Mission (founded 1897): hospitals, schools, disaster relief, rural development, for all faiths and castes.
  • Motto: for one's own liberation and the welfare of the world.
Quick check
?Which belief underlies Vivekananda's Practical Vedanta?
Mission 6

Liberationist approaches: Hardy and Flood

  • Liberationist approaches read religion from the side of the poor and oppressed, and ask what it does for them.
  • Gavin Flood, An Introduction to Hinduism (1996): modern Hindu movements turned renunciation into social service (Vivekananda, Gandhi's sarvodaya) (paraphrase).
  • Friedhelm Hardy, The Religious Culture of India (1994): the love (bhakti) strand of Indian religion valued low-caste and poor devotees, a resource for liberation (paraphrase).
  • Examples: the Ramakrishna Mission; Gandhi's sarvodaya; Vinoba Bhave's land gifts; Dalit movements.
  • Critique: charity may relieve poverty without changing the structures (caste, land) that cause it.
Mission check

?A British Hindu software engineer earns well. She gives a share to a temple kitchen and volunteers at a homeless shelter, saying: "Earning is my duty; sharing it is my duty too." Which Hindu idea fits her view best?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Diversity is a fact; pluralism, inclusivism and exclusivism are views about it.
  • Ishtadeva, Rig Veda 1.164.46 and Gita 4:11 support openness; Gita 9:23 and Radhakrishnan show ranking (inclusivism).
  • "Vedanta as religion" (Vivekananda): every faith is a partial expression of Vedanta; Hindutva and some sects are exclusivist in different senses.
  • It is welcomed by Neo-Vedantins and rejected by theistic Vaishnavas (Madhva's Dvaita, ISKCON) and by many in other faiths.

Mission 2

  • Migration from the 1950s (Gujarat, Punjab, East Africa, Sri Lanka) built a diverse British Hindu community of about 1 million (2021).
  • Article 9 protects religious freedom, within limits (Shambo, 2007).

Mission 3

  • Secularisation pushes religion into private life.
  • Hindu identity is built from belief, practice, lifestyle, worship and belonging, so British Hindu identity is both shared and diverse.

Mission 4

  • Stridharma sets women's duty within the household; the Manusmriti both honours women and limits their independence.
  • Hindus hold different views on celibacy (brahmacharya).
  • Many Saivas read Ardhanarishvara as equal halves of the divine.

Mission 5

  • Under British rule, reformers such as Ram Mohan Roy argued from the shastras against sati and for women's rights; laws followed (1829 sati ban; 1856 widow remarriage).
  • Flood and Hardy direct attention to women's own religious voices.

Mission 6

  • Artha (wealth) is one of the four aims of life: legitimate within dharma, shared through dana.
  • Practical Vedanta (Vivekananda, Ramakrishna Mission) is a liberationist approach: serving God in the poor.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: Religion and society for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If all paths lead to God, can a Hindu still think one path is best?
  2. Mission 2Can you keep a 3,000-year-old tradition alive in a Leicester terrace or a London suburb?
  3. Mission 3Yoga, karma, Diwali lights: does the West understand Hinduism, and what makes someone a British Hindu?
  4. Mission 4One law book says women must be honoured and also never independent. What do Hindus make of that?
  5. Mission 5Sati was banned in 1829. Did change for Hindu women come from inside the tradition or outside?
  6. Mission 6Is wanting money a spiritual failure, or can wealth serve God and the poor in Hindu teaching?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel