← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4C Hinduism – 4 Social and historical developments; Paper 4C Hinduism – 5 Works of scholars
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: Social and historical developments; works of scholars

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Under British rule, two Hindu reformers both rejected image worship. Why did they still disagree?
  2. Mission 2How did a temple priest who spoke no English shape how the world sees Hinduism?
  3. Mission 3What makes someone a Hindu: belief, birth, or loving India as a holy land?
  4. Mission 4Gandhi said his politics came from his religion. Was he a saint, a politician, or both at once?
  5. Mission 5Ancient hymns, ancient astronomers, a universe billions of years old: does science fit Hindu belief?
  6. Mission 6If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?
  7. Mission 7Is the soul one with God, part of God, or forever different from God?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Hinduism: Sources of authority.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Under British rule, two Hindu reformers both rejected image worship. Why did they still disagree?

Make a guess: Under British rule, two Hindu reformers both rejected image worship. Why did they still disagree?

Mission 1

India in the 19th century

Reformers timelineIndia in the 19th centurylate 1700sEast India Company controlsmuch of India1800Serampore mission, nearCalcutta1835Macaulay's Minute: Englisheducation1858British Crown rules directlyRam Mohan Roy1772born, Bengal1820The Precepts of Jesus1828Brahmo Sabha founded,Calcutta1829sati banned in Bengal1833dies in BristolDayananda Saraswati1824born, Gujarat1875Arya Samaj founded,Bombay; Satyarth Prakash1883dies1886first DAV school
  • Foreign rule: after centuries of Muslim rulers (the Mughals), the British East India Company controlled much of India from the late 1700s; the British Crown ruled directly from 1858.
  • Islamic influence: Persian was the language of government; Islam's strict monotheism challenged image worship.
  • Christian missions: missionaries (e.g. at Serampore, near Calcutta, from 1800) criticised Hindu worship, caste and the treatment of women.
  • Western learning: English education spread (Macaulay's Minute, 1835); ideas of reason, science and progress questioned tradition. A first wave of secularisation.
  • Orientalists (e.g. William Jones, 1746–1794) translated Sanskrit texts and praised India's ancient wisdom.
  • Hindu responses ranged from defending tradition unchanged to reforming it. Two of the best-known reformers: Ram Mohan Roy and Dayananda Saraswati.
Mission 1

Ram Mohan Roy

Reformers timelineIndia in the 19th centurylate 1700sEast India Company controlsmuch of India1800Serampore mission, nearCalcutta1835Macaulay's Minute: Englisheducation1858British Crown rules directlyRam Mohan Roy1772born, Bengal1820The Precepts of Jesus1828Brahmo Sabha founded,Calcutta1829sati banned in Bengal1833dies in BristolDayananda Saraswati1824born, Gujarat1875Arya Samaj founded,Bombay; Satyarth Prakash1883dies1886first DAV school
  • Ram Mohan Roy (1772–1833), a Bengali brahmin; worked for the East India Company.
  • Learned Persian and Arabic (and met Islamic monotheism), Sanskrit (the Upanishads) and English (Christian and Enlightenment thought).
  • Translated Upanishads into Bengali and English: he argued that they teach one formless God, and that image worship was a later corruption.
  • Admired Jesus' moral teaching (The Precepts of Jesus, 1820) but rejected the Trinity; worked with Unitarian Christians.
  • Often called the "father of the Bengal renaissance". He died in Bristol in 1833, while visiting Britain.
Mission 1

The Brahmo Samaj

  • Roy founded the Brahmo Sabha in Calcutta in 1828; it became the Brahmo Samaj ("society of Brahman").
  • Beliefs: one eternal, formless God; the Upanishads read with reason; no images, no animal sacrifice, no priestly mediators.
  • Worship: congregational: Upanishad readings, hymns, prayers and sermons, like a Protestant service.
  • Universal in spirit: its worship was meant to be open to people of any faith who sought the one God.
  • Later leaders: Debendranath Tagore (1817–1905) gave it a covenant and creed and gave up belief in the Vedas' infallibility; Keshab Chandra Sen (1838–1884) took it in a more radical, universalist direction, and the movement split (1866, 1878).
  • Influential among educated Bengalis; always a small movement.
Mission 1

Roy as social reformer

  • Sati (a widow burning on her husband's pyre): Roy argued from the shastras that it was not required, and campaigned against it. The British banned it in Bengal in 1829.
  • Argued for women's property rights and education; against polygamy.
  • Criticised caste divisions and the power of priests.
  • Founded schools teaching both Western science and Indian learning.
  • His method: reform from within, appealing to Hindu scripture and to reason at the same time.
Quick check
?Which belief was central to the Brahmo Samaj under Ram Mohan Roy?
Mission 1

Dayananda Saraswati

Reformers timelineIndia in the 19th centurylate 1700sEast India Company controlsmuch of India1800Serampore mission, nearCalcutta1835Macaulay's Minute: Englisheducation1858British Crown rules directlyRam Mohan Roy1772born, Bengal1820The Precepts of Jesus1828Brahmo Sabha founded,Calcutta1829sati banned in Bengal1833dies in BristolDayananda Saraswati1824born, Gujarat1875Arya Samaj founded,Bombay; Satyarth Prakash1883dies1886first DAV school
  • Dayananda Saraswati (1824–1883), born in Gujarat.
  • The story told of his youth: at 14, keeping a night vigil for Shiva, he saw a mouse running over the image and eating the offerings. He decided a God who could not protect his own offerings was not in the image.
  • Became a wandering sannyasi; studied Sanskrit grammar and the Vedas under the blind teacher Virajananda at Mathura, who rejected post-Vedic texts.
  • Debated orthodox pandits, Christian missionaries and Muslim scholars.
  • Founded the Arya Samaj ("society of noble ones") in Bombay in 1875; it grew strongest in the Punjab.
  • Main work: Satyarth Prakash (The Light of Truth, 1875).
Mission 1

The Arya Samaj

  • Back to the Vedas: only the four Veda samhitas are revealed and infallible; later texts are accepted only where they agree with them.
  • One formless God. Rejects image worship, avatars and the Puranic stories.
  • Worship: havan (offerings into a sacred fire) with Vedic mantras.
  • Varna by merit, not birth: a person's varna depends on qualities and actions. Opposed untouchability and child marriage; supported widow remarriage and education for girls.
  • The Vedas are believed to contain all true knowledge, including the principles of science.
  • Shuddhi (purification): a rite to (re)admit converts to Christianity or Islam, and others, into the Hindu fold.
  • Sharp criticism of Christianity and Islam, and of much popular Hinduism. Founded schools and colleges (DAV schools, from 1886).
Mission 1Diversity

Roy and Dayananda compared

Roy and Dayananda comparedRam MohanRoyDayanandaSaraswatiAuthorityUpanishads +reasonFour VedasamhitasaloneGodOne, formlessOne, formlessImagesRejectedRejectedCasteCriticisedVarna bymerit, notbirthWomenAgainst sati;for propertyrights,educationFor education,widowremarriage;against childmarriageOtherreligionsLearned fromIslam andChristianity;universalistCriticisedIslam andChristianity;shuddhiWesternideasWelcomedreason andscienceSciencealready in theVedasOrganisationBrahmoSamaj, 1828:small, eliteArya Samaj,1875: larger,popularBothone formless God; images rejected; eachclaimed to restore an original, purer Hinduism
Ram Mohan RoyDayananda Saraswati
AuthorityUpanishads + reasonFour Veda samhitas alone
GodOne, formlessOne, formless
ImagesRejectedRejected
CasteCriticisedVarna by merit, not birth
WomenAgainst sati; for property rights, educationFor education, widow remarriage; against child marriage
Other religionsLearned from Islam and Christianity; universalistCriticised Islam and Christianity; shuddhi
Western ideasWelcomed reason and scienceScience already in the Vedas
OrganisationBrahmo Samaj, 1828: small, eliteArya Samaj, 1875: larger, popular
  • Both claimed to restore an original, purer Hinduism. They disagreed about where it is found and how open to be to other faiths.
Quick check
?Which teaching belongs to Dayananda but not to Ram Mohan Roy?
Mission 1

Significance and influence

  • Interfaith: Roy opened dialogue with Islam and Christianity; Dayananda answered them with polemic and debate.
  • Nationalism: the Arya Samaj gave many Hindus pride in a Vedic past; Arya Samajis such as Lala Lajpat Rai (1865–1928) were leading nationalists. Shuddhi and its stress on Hindu identity fed later Hindu nationalism.
  • Tolerance: the Brahmo ideal of one God behind all religions passed into Neo-Vedanta (see Mission 2).
  • Social reform: both helped to make the reform of caste, women's lives and education part of modern Hindu identity.
  • "Hinduism": both presented Hinduism as one religion with a clear scriptural core, a step towards seeing it as a world religion.
  • Use the Foy extract (2) here (paraphrase only): test each of its claims about these movements against this screen.
Mission 1Evaluate

Whose idea of Hinduism was more successful?

Whose idea of Hinduism was more successful?Dayananda's vision of Hinduism was moresuccessful than Roy's.ForThe Arya Samaj became a massmovement, with schools and collegesacross North India; the Brahmo Samajstayed small.Dayananda drew only on Indian sources,so he could not be accused of copyingChristianity.AgainstRoy's ideas (reason, social reform, one Godbehind all faiths) passed into Neo-Vedantaand into modern Indian law and education.Dayananda's "Vedas alone" left out mostliving Hindu practice: murtis, Puranas,bhakti, festivals.Both were selective; critics say eachreshaped Hinduism to answer Westerncriticism.Judge it bynumbers and lasting institutions · faithfulnessto Hindu tradition · impact on social reform ·effect on relations with other faiths
  • Claim: Dayananda's vision of Hinduism was more successful than Roy's.
  • For: The Arya Samaj became a mass movement, with schools and colleges across North India; the Brahmo Samaj stayed small.
  • For: Dayananda drew only on Indian sources, so he could not be accused of copying Christianity.
  • Against: Roy's ideas (reason, social reform, one God behind all faiths) passed into Neo-Vedanta and into modern Indian law and education.
  • Against: Dayananda's "Vedas alone" left out most living Hindu practice: murtis, Puranas, bhakti, festivals.
  • Against: both were selective; critics say each reshaped Hinduism to answer Western criticism.
  • Judgement criteria: numbers and lasting institutions; faithfulness to Hindu tradition; impact on social reform; effect on relations with other faiths.
Mission check

?A Hindu group in Birmingham meets weekly to make offerings into a sacred fire while reciting Vedic mantras. Its hall has no murtis, and its teachers say a person's varna depends on character, not birth. Whose movement does it most likely come from?
Mission 2

Mission 2: How did a temple priest who spoke no English shape how the world sees Hinduism?

Make a guess: How did a temple priest who spoke no English shape how the world sees Hinduism?

Mission 2

Ramakrishna: a priest of the Mother

Ramakrishna and VivekanandaSri Ramakrishna1836born in a Bengal village1856priest at the Dakshineswar KalitemplethenTantric, Vaishnava, Advaita (underTotapuri)1866practises Islam1874practises Christianity1886diesSwami Vivekananda1863born in Calcutta1881meets Ramakrishna1893Parliament of the World'sReligions, Chicago1894Vedanta Society of New York1896London lectures: PracticalVedanta1897Ramakrishna Mission founded1902dies, aged 39
  • Sri Ramakrishna (1836–1886), born Gadadhar Chattopadhyay in a Bengal village; little schooling, no English.
  • From 1856, priest at the Dakshineswar Kali temple near Calcutta.
  • He longed to see the Goddess Kali as his Divine Mother; his disciples record that he had overwhelming visions of her.
  • He then followed many disciplines, guided by different teachers: Tantric practice; Vaishnava devotional moods; and Advaita, under the monk Totapuri, reaching nirvikalpa samadhi (absorption without any sense of difference).
  • His wife Sarada Devi (1853–1920) became his disciple and is revered as the Holy Mother.
  • His sayings were recorded by a disciple, "M" (Mahendranath Gupta), in the Kathamrita (The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna).
Mission 2

As many faiths, so many paths

Many pathsTantraVaishnavaAdvaitaIslamChristianity"As many faiths, so many paths" (paraphrase)
  • According to his disciples, Ramakrishna also practised Islam (1866) and Christianity (1874) for short periods, and reported experiences of God through each.
  • His conclusion (paraphrase): "As many faiths, so many paths": each religion, sincerely followed, leads to the same God.
  • His image (paraphrase): one water is called jal, pani and "water" by different people; so one God has many names.
  • God is both formless and with form; Brahman and Shakti are one, like fire and its power to burn.
Mission 2

Images, caste, and the world

  • Image worship: unlike the Brahmos (see Mission 1), Ramakrishna worshipped the Mother in her murti; for him the image was a real meeting point with God.
  • He met Brahmo leaders, especially Keshab Chandra Sen, who made him known among educated Bengalis.
  • Caste: stories tell of him humbling his brahmin pride by cleaning the latrine of a low-caste servant.
  • A saying recorded by his disciples: serve living beings as Shiva, not out of pity (shiva jnane jiva seva). Vivekananda built on it.
  • Use the Foy extract (2) for Ramakrishna here (paraphrase only).
Quick check
?What did Ramakrishna conclude from practising several religious paths?
Mission 2

Vivekananda

Ramakrishna and VivekanandaSri Ramakrishna1836born in a Bengal village1856priest at the Dakshineswar KalitemplethenTantric, Vaishnava, Advaita (underTotapuri)1866practises Islam1874practises Christianity1886diesSwami Vivekananda1863born in Calcutta1881meets Ramakrishna1893Parliament of the World'sReligions, Chicago1894Vedanta Society of New York1896London lectures: PracticalVedanta1897Ramakrishna Mission founded1902dies, aged 39
  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902), born Narendranath Datta in Calcutta; Western-educated; a member of the Brahmo Samaj, sceptical of visions.
  • Met Ramakrishna in 1881 and became his leading disciple; after Ramakrishna's death (1886) he became a sannyasi and travelled across India, shocked by its poverty.
  • 1893: spoke at the Parliament of the World's Religions in Chicago; became famous overnight.
  • Lectured in the USA and Britain; founded the Vedanta Society of New York (1894).
  • Returned to India a hero; founded the Ramakrishna Mission (1897). Died aged 39.
Mission 2Read the source

Chicago, 11 September 1893

Vivekananda's opening address (paraphrase):

  • He greeted the audience as "Sisters and Brothers of America".
  • He said he was proud to belong to a religion that had taught the world tolerance and universal acceptance: Hindus not only tolerate other religions but accept all religions as true.
  • He quoted a Hindu hymn: as rivers from different sources all reach the sea, so the different paths people take, straight or crooked, all lead to God.
  • He hoped the Parliament would end sectarianism, bigotry and fanaticism.

Q1 Whose teaching is he echoing?

Show answer

Ramakrishna's "as many faiths, so many paths".

Q2 What image of Hinduism did this give Western listeners?

Show answer

A tolerant, universal, philosophical religion.

Mission 2

Neo-Vedanta

Neo-Vedanta webAdvaita at thecentreexperience(anubhava)every soulpotentiallydivinefour yogastruth behindall religionsfriendly toscienceRadhakrishnanNeo-Vedantaterm used by the Indologist Paul Hacker
  • Neo-Vedanta (term used by Indologist Paul Hacker, 1913–1979): the modern form of Vedanta taught by Vivekananda and his successors.
  • Advaita at the centre: Brahman is the one reality; every soul is potentially divine.
  • Experience (anubhava), not only scripture, is the ground of religion: religion is "realisation".
  • Four yogas (Vivekananda's lectures, 1895–96): karma, bhakti, jnana and raja yoga, suited to different temperaments, all leading to the same goal.
  • Universal: Vedanta is presented as the eternal truth behind all religions, and as friendly to science.
  • Continued by thinkers such as Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan (1888–1975), The Hindu View of Life (1927).
Mission 2

Practical Vedanta and the Ramakrishna Mission

Practical VedantaBrahman in every beingsoserving people is worshipping GodGod in the poor: daridra narayanaRamakrishna Mission (1897)Belur Math, near Kolkatahospitalsschoolsreliefruraldevelopment"for one's own liberation and for the good ofthe world"
  • Practical Vedanta (lectures in London, 1896): if Brahman is in every being, then serving people is worshipping God.
  • Vivekananda spoke of God in the poor (daridra narayana) and attacked "don't-touch-ism" (untouchability) and neglect of the masses and of women.
  • Shankara's Advaita centred on renunciation and knowledge; Vivekananda reinterpreted it as a call to social service.
  • Ramakrishna Mission (1897), with Belur Math near Kolkata as headquarters. Motto: "for one's own liberation and for the good of the world".
  • Today: hospitals, schools, colleges, rural development, relief after disasters, in India and beyond.
  • A liberationist approach: working to lift the poor and oppressed, seeing service to them as service to God.
Quick check
?Why can the Ramakrishna Mission's work be called a liberationist Hindu approach?
Mission 2

Neo-Vedanta and Hindutva

Neo-Vedanta and HindutvaNeo-VedantaHindutva1231 Neo-Vedanta onlyuniversal, spiritual; all religions true paths;Hindu pride grounded in tolerance2 Overlapnational pride; many Hindutva organisationshonour Vivekananda3 Hindutva only (Savarkar)Hindu identity as cultural and national; India asboth fatherland and holy land
  • Neo-Vedanta: universal, spiritual; all religions true paths; Hindu pride grounded in tolerance.
  • Hindutva (V. D. Savarkar, 1883–1966, Essentials of Hindutva, 1923): Hindu identity as a cultural and national identity; a Hindu is one for whom India is both fatherland and holy land (see Mission 3).
  • Overlap: Vivekananda called Indians to strength and national pride; many Hindutva organisations honour him.
  • Difference: his universalism (all paths true) sits uneasily with exclusivist readings of national identity; scholars and Hindus debate how far he can be claimed by either side.
  • Non-violence: Gandhi (see Mission 4) joined a Neo-Vedanta universalism to ahimsa and satyagraha; Vivekananda stressed strength and fearlessness more than non-violence.
  • Implications to weigh: interfaith relations, nationalism, tolerance.
Mission 2

Influence in India and the West

  • In the West: Vedanta Societies; yoga and meditation; writers drawn to Vedanta. Vedanta became the best-known Hindu philosophy outside India.
  • Popular image: Hinduism as tolerant, mystical and philosophical.
  • Hinduism as a world religion: a universal message, not only an Indian heritage.
  • In India: pride and confidence under colonial rule; a model of service; Vivekananda's birthday is India's National Youth Day.
Mission 2Evaluate

Is Neo-Vedanta a faithful development of Hinduism?

Is Neo-Vedanta a faithful development of Hinduism?Neo-Vedanta is a faithful development ofHindu tradition.ForIt rests on the Upanishads and Advaita;tolerance has deep Hindu roots.Practical Vedanta draws a real ethicalconclusion from "atman is Brahman".AgainstIt centres one school (Advaita) andsidelines theistic and ritual Hinduism.Rambachan: it shifts authority fromscripture to experience. Hacker: itsinclusivism shaped Hinduism for Westernaudiences.Judge it byfaithfulness to sources · fit with how mostHindus practise · fruits (service, tolerance) ·whether all living traditions change
  • Claim: Neo-Vedanta is a faithful development of Hindu tradition.
  • For: it rests on the Upanishads and Advaita; tolerance has deep Hindu roots.
  • For: Practical Vedanta draws a real ethical conclusion from "atman is Brahman".
  • Against: it centres one school (Advaita) and sidelines theistic and ritual Hinduism.
  • Against: Rambachan: it shifts authority from scripture to experience; Hacker: its inclusivism shaped Hinduism for Western audiences.
  • Judgement criteria: faithfulness to sources; fit with how most Hindus practise; fruits (service, tolerance); whether all living traditions change.
Mission check

?A volunteer at a Ramakrishna Mission hospital treats patients of every faith free of charge. She says: "When I serve a patient, I am worshipping God." Which idea from Practical Vedanta explains her view?
Mission 3

Mission 3: What makes someone a Hindu: belief, birth, or loving India as a holy land?

Make a guess: What makes someone a Hindu: belief, birth, or loving India as a holy land?

Mission 3

Savarkar: "Hindu-ness"

Savarkar's testFatherlandin IndiaHoly landin IndiapitribhumipunyabhumiIndianMuslims,IndianChristiansHindutva(Savarkar)HindusSikhsJainsBuddhistsSavarkar's definition, not the view of Sikhs,Jains or Buddhists themselves
  • Hindutva = "Hindu-ness". Set out by V. D. Savarkar (1883–1966) in Essentials of Hindutva (1923), written in prison.
  • Savarkar, himself a rationalist, separated Hindutva (a people's culture, history and nation) from Hinduism (religious belief).
  • His definition (paraphrase): a Hindu is someone who regards India (Bharatvarsha) as both pitribhumi (fatherland) and punyabhumi (holy land).
  • So Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists count: their faiths began in India.
  • Muslims and Christians, even if Indian for generations, do not fully belong: their holy lands are elsewhere.
Quick check
?On Savarkar's definition, which person counts as a Hindu?
Mission 3

The Sangh Parivar

Sangh ParivarVHP (1964)religious leaders andcampaignsBJP (1980)the political partyWingsstudent, labour andyouth (e.g. BajrangDal)Social service bodiesSangh Parivar:"family oforganisations"RSS (root)Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh ·founded 1925, Nagpur · daily shakhas
  • Sangh Parivar = "family of organisations" around the RSS (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, "National Volunteer Organisation"), founded 1925 in Nagpur by K. B. Hedgewar.
  • RSS: daily shakhas (branches) for physical training, discipline and "character-building"; M. S. Golwalkar (1906–1973) led it 1940–1973.
  • VHP (Vishva Hindu Parishad, 1964): religious leaders and campaigns, e.g. for a Rama temple at Ayodhya.
  • BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party, 1980): the political party; it has led India's government since 2014.
  • Others: student, labour and youth wings (e.g. Bajrang Dal), and social service bodies.
  • Ayodhya: the Babri Masjid was demolished in 1992; the Supreme Court gave the site for a temple (2019); the Ram Mandir was consecrated in 2024.
Mission 3

Neo-Vedanta and Hindutva compared

Neo-Vedanta and HindutvaShared rootsthe 19th-century Hindu renaissance;Vivekananda as a heroNeo-VedantaHindutvaWhatHinduismisa universalspiritual truththe nationalculture of IndiaOtherreligionsall are truepaths to onereality(inclusivism)Hindus aretolerant, butminorities mustaccept Hinduculture; critics:exclusivismAimspiritual andsocial servicea strong, unitedHindu nationKeyfiguresVivekananda,RamakrishnaMission,RadhakrishnanSavarkar; theRSS (Hedgewar,Golwalkar)
  • Shared roots: both look back to the 19th-century Hindu renaissance and to Vivekananda as a hero; both want Hindu pride after colonial rule.
  • Neo-Vedanta (Vivekananda, Ramakrishna Mission, Radhakrishnan): Hinduism is a universal spiritual truth; all religions are paths to one reality; the aim is spiritual and social service.
  • Hindutva: Hinduism is the national culture of India; the aim is a strong, united Hindu nation.
  • Tolerance: Neo-Vedanta accepts all faiths as true paths (inclusivism); Hindutva supporters say Hindus are tolerant but minorities must accept Hindu culture; critics call this exclusivism.
  • Politics: Gandhi's non-violent, interfaith nationalism vs Hindutva's cultural nationalism.
Quick check
?Which statement best captures a key difference between Neo-Vedanta and Hindutva?
Mission 3Diversity

Hindus on Hindutva

Hindus on HindutvaWhoViewSupporterscultural, not theocratic;includes all Indic faiths;corrects foreign rule and anunfair secularismGandhian andNeo-Vedantincriticstrue Hinduism is tolerant anduniversal; Hindutva makes it apolitical identitySecular andliberal Hindusit threatens minorities' equalcitizenship (Ayodhya 1992,Gujarat 2002)Dalit criticsit speaks for upper-casteHinduism and hides casteinequalityMany Sikhs,Jains andBuddhistsreject being counted as"Hindu"Scholars (e.g.ChristopheJaffrelot)study it as ethnic nationalism;supporters reject this label
  • Supporters: Hindutva is cultural, not theocratic; it includes all Indic faiths; it corrects centuries of foreign rule and an unfair secularism. India's Supreme Court in 1995 described Hindutva as indicating a "way of life".
  • Gandhian and Neo-Vedantin critics: true Hinduism is tolerant and universal; Hindutva turns a spiritual tradition into a political identity.
  • Secular and liberal Hindus: Hindutva threatens minorities' equal citizenship; they point to violence in Ayodhya (1992) and Gujarat (2002).
  • Dalit critics: Hindutva speaks for upper-caste Hinduism and hides caste inequality.
  • Many Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists: reject being counted as "Hindu".
  • Scholars, e.g. Christophe Jaffrelot (The Hindu Nationalist Movement and Indian Politics, 1996), study it as ethnic nationalism; supporters reject this label.
Mission 3Evaluate

"Hindutva is the only effective Hindu response to secularisation."

The only effective response?"Hindutva is the only effective Hinduresponse to secularisation."ForIt has mass support and electoral success.It gives a clear identity in a fast-changingsociety.It has brought Hindu symbols back intopublic life.AgainstOther responses also work: Neo-Vedanta'suniversal spirituality.Devotional movements (ISKCON,Swaminarayan) grow without politics; theRamakrishna Mission serves the poor."Effective" for whom? Critics say it securespower but divides society and narrowsHinduism.Judge it byWhat counts as "effective": numbers, depth offaith, social harmony? · Is Hindutva mainlyreligious at all?
  • For: it has mass support and electoral success; it gives a clear identity in a fast-changing society; it has brought Hindu symbols back into public life.
  • Against: other responses also work: Neo-Vedanta's universal spirituality; devotional movements (ISKCON, Swaminarayan) that grow without politics; reform movements serving the poor (Ramakrishna Mission).
  • Against: "effective" for whom? Critics say it secures power but divides society and narrows Hinduism.
  • Judge it by: what counts as "effective" (numbers, depth of faith, social harmony)? Is Hindutva mainly religious at all?
Mission check

?A Jain businessman and a Muslim teacher were both born in Mumbai and have never left India. On Savarkar's definition of Hindutva, how would they be classed?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Gandhi said his politics came from his religion. Was he a saint, a politician, or both at once?

Make a guess: Gandhi said his politics came from his religion. Was he a saint, a politician, or both at once?

Mission 4

A life in four places

A life in four placesEuropeAfricaIndia12341Porbandar, Gujaratborn 18692London, 1888–1891trained as a lawyer3South Africa, 1893–1914first satyagraha campaigns; communalfarms: Phoenix, Tolstoy Farm4India, 1915–1948independence movement; Salt March toDandi (1930); shot 30 January 1948
  • Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869–1948), born in Porbandar, Gujarat, into a Vaishnava family; his mother was deeply devout, with Jain neighbours and friends.
  • London (1888–1891): trained as a lawyer; first read the Bhagavad Gita (in Edwin Arnold's English) with Theosophist friends.
  • South Africa (1893–1914): campaigned for Indians' rights; first satyagraha campaigns; founded communal farms (Phoenix, Tolstoy Farm).
  • India (1915–1948): led the independence movement; Salt March (1930); Quit India (1942); independence and Partition (1947).
  • Shot on 30 January 1948 by Nathuram Godse, a Hindu nationalist who blamed him for concessions to Muslims and Pakistan.
  • Called Mahatma ("great soul") and Bapu ("father").
Mission 4

Truth is God; all life is one

Root and branchesahimsa (non-violence)Satya"Truth is God"AdvaitaAll life is oneroots
  • Gandhi's central idea: Satya (truth). He moved from "God is Truth" to "Truth is God" (c. 1929–31), so that even atheists seeking truth were included.
  • Advaita Vedanta: ultimate reality is one, Brahman; the self (atman) in each being is not different from it.
  • He drew a moral conclusion: he believed in "the essential unity of man and … of all that lives" (Young India, 4 Dec 1924).
  • So harming another is harming oneself: ahimsa (non-violence) follows from unity.
  • He held Advaita loosely: he also worshipped a personal God as Rama and called himself a sanatani (traditional) Hindu.
Mission 4

Satyagraha: holding firmly to truth

Root and branchessatyagrahatruth-force: active,never violentahimsa (non-violence)Satya"Truth is God"AdvaitaAll life is oneroots
  • Satyagraha = satya (truth) + agraha (firm grasp): "truth-force" or "soul-force". Coined in South Africa (c. 1906–08).
  • Not "passive resistance": it is active, but never violent.
  • Aim: not to defeat the opponent but to convert them, by accepting suffering rather than inflicting it.
  • Methods: non-cooperation, civil disobedience, strikes, boycotts of foreign cloth, fasting.
  • Rules: openness (tell the authorities in advance), discipline, no hatred.
  • Example: the Salt March (1930): about 390 km to Dandi to make salt in defiance of the British salt tax.
Mission 4Read the source

Brahmacharya and the Gita

> "Dwelling 'mid solitudes, in diet spare, / With body, speech, and will tamed to obey, / Ever to holy meditation vowed, / From passions liberate, quit of the Self, / Of arrogance, impatience, anger, pride; / Freed from surroundings, quiet, lacking nought-- / Such an one grows to oneness with the BRAHM" (Bhagavad Gita 18:52–53, Arnold 1885)

  • Brahmacharya: literally "conduct leading to Brahman". Gandhi took a vow of celibacy in 1906, but used the word for control of all the senses: food, speech, sleep, sex.
  • He saw self-restraint as the source of the inner strength a satyagrahi needs.
  • Gandhi called the Gita his "dictionary of daily reference" (Autobiography, Part IV) and read Kurukshetra as the inner war of good and evil, not a call to fight.

Q1 Which disciplines in these verses match Gandhi's brahmacharya?

Show answer

Spare diet; body, speech and will controlled; freedom from passion and pride.

Q2 What is the goal the verses promise?

Show answer

Oneness with Brahman.

Quick check
?How did Gandhi understand brahmacharya?
Mission 4

Swaraj: rule over yourself

Root and branchessatyagrahatruth-force: active,never violentbrahmacharyacontrol of all thesensesswarajself-rule: India andeach personswadeshilocal goods, khadiahimsa (non-violence)Satya"Truth is God"AdvaitaAll life is oneroots
  • Swaraj = self-rule. For Gandhi it meant two things: India governing itself, and each person governing their own desires.
  • Hind Swaraj (1909, written in Gujarati): Indian freedom would be empty if India simply copied Western industrial civilisation.
  • Swadeshi ("of one's own country"): use local goods; the spinning wheel (charkha) and homespun cloth (khadi) became symbols of self-reliance.
  • Ideal: self-governing, simple village communities.
  • Science and medicine: in Hind Swaraj (ch. on doctors) he attacked Western medicine for treating bodies without changing the habits that made them ill; he preferred diet, nature cure and self-control. Later he accepted some modern treatment (e.g. an operation in 1924).
Mission 4

Untouchability, Partition, all religions

Root and branchessatyagrahatruth-force: active,never violentbrahmacharyacontrol of all thesensesswarajself-rule: India andeach personswadeshilocal goods, khadiuntouchabilitya sin, not trueHinduismall religionsequal respect for allahimsa (non-violence)Satya"Truth is God"AdvaitaAll life is oneroots
  • Untouchability: he called it a sin and not true Hinduism; used the name Harijan ("people of God") and ran temple-entry campaigns.
  • But he defended varna as a division of work by birth without high or low. B. R. Ambedkar (1891–1956) replied that caste must be destroyed, not reformed. Many Dalits find "Harijan" patronising.
  • Partition: he opposed dividing India ("vivisection"); in 1946–48 he walked through riot areas and fasted for Hindu–Muslim peace.
  • Universal religion: all religions are true, and all imperfect; equal respect for all religions (sarva dharma samabhava). His prayer meetings used the Gita, the Qur'an and Christian hymns.
  • Implications: interfaith, tolerance, a civic nationalism open to all faiths.
Quick check
?Which statement about Gandhi's view of caste is accurate?
Mission 4Diversity

Who claims Gandhi?

Who claims Gandhi?WhoView ofGandhiReasonMost Hindusin India"Father ofthe Nation"birthday, 2October, is anational holidayHindunationalistssome honourhim; othersblame himpatriotism, cowprotection; orPartition,"favouringMuslims"OrthodoxHindus ofhis dayopposed himtemple entrybroke purityrulesDalitthinkerscriticalAmbedkar: adefender of castein a reformer'sclothesNon-Hinduworldan inspirationMartin LutherKing Jr; UN Dayof Non-Violence,2 October
  • Most Hindus in India: "Father of the Nation"; his birthday (2 October) is a national holiday.
  • Hindu nationalists: some honour his patriotism and cow protection; others, like Godse, blamed him for Partition and for favouring Muslims.
  • Orthodox Hindus of his day: opposed his temple-entry campaigns as breaking purity rules.
  • Dalit thinkers: Ambedkar saw him as a defender of caste in a reformer's clothes.
  • The non-Hindu world: an inspiration for Martin Luther King Jr (Montgomery 1955–56), the US civil rights movement and others; the UN marks 2 October as the International Day of Non-Violence.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Gandhi's achievements were more political than religious."

Political or religious?"Gandhi's achievements were more politicalthan religious."ForHis lasting results were political: massnon-violent protest, independence, asecular constitution.Many followers used his methods withouthis religion.He was a skilled lawyer and organiser.AgainstHe said his politics was his religion inaction: satyagraha, ahimsa andbrahmacharya are religious disciplines.His Gita reading changed how manyHindus see the text.His fasts were religious acts ofself-purification.Mixed recordPartition and violence he could not stop;caste reform judged too slow by Dalits; hislate "experiments" testing his celibacy arewidely criticised.Judge it byCan "political" and "religious" be separated inhis world view? · Which achievementsoutlasted him? · Whose verdict counts:Hindus, Dalits, or the wider world?
  • For: his lasting results were political: mass non-violent protest, independence, a secular constitution. Many followers used his methods without his religion. He himself was a skilled lawyer and organiser.
  • Against: he said his politics was his religion in action; satyagraha, ahimsa and brahmacharya are religious disciplines. His Gita reading changed how many Hindus see the text. His fasts were religious acts of self-purification.
  • Mixed record: Partition and violence he could not stop; caste reform judged too slow by Dalits; his late "experiments" testing his celibacy are widely criticised.
  • Judge it by: Can "political" and "religious" be separated in Gandhi's world view? Which achievements outlasted him? Whose verdict counts: Hindus, Dalits, or the wider world?
Quick check
?Why did Gandhi insist that satyagraha must never use violence?
Mission 4Worked answer

Linking belief to action

Belief to actionBeliefAll life is one (Advaita); Truth is God.SourceBhagavad Gita, read as the inner battle;self-restraint in Gita 18:52–53.DevelopmentSo he chose satyagraha: open, non-violentresistance that aims to convert the opponent,backed by brahmacharya.ExampleThe Salt March (1930): pilgrimage on foot,fasting, prayer, with a political target, the salttax.

Question: Examine how Gandhi's religious beliefs shaped his political methods.

  • Belief: all life is one (Advaita); Truth is God.
  • Source: Bhagavad Gita, read as the inner battle; self-restraint in Gita 18:52–53.
  • Development: so he chose satyagraha: open, non-violent resistance that aims to convert the opponent, backed by the self-discipline of brahmacharya.
  • Example: the Salt March (1930) united religious symbolism (pilgrimage on foot, fasting, prayer) with a political target (the salt tax).
  • Use your anthology extract 2 (Foy, ed., Man's Religious Quest) to support a point, in your own words.
Mission check

?A modern climate group blocks a road. Its leaders tell the police in advance, refuse to strike back when removed, and say they hope to change drivers' hearts. Which feature of Gandhi's satyagraha does this group not yet show?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Ancient hymns, ancient astronomers, a universe billions of years old: does science fit Hindu belief?

Make a guess: Ancient hymns, ancient astronomers, a universe billions of years old: does science fit Hindu belief?

Mission 5

Why science is a test for any religion

  • Modern science asks for evidence and reason: claims are tested, and can be revised.
  • Religions often rest on revelation (for Hindus, shruti, "what is heard": the Vedas) and on tradition.
  • So science can challenge a tradition in three ways:
  • Method: is faith reasonable without evidence?
  • Discoveries: an old universe (Big Bang), evolution (Darwin).
  • Ethics: new powers (genetic engineering) raise new moral questions.
  • Hindus have answered in very different ways, from "no conflict at all" to firm rejection of parts of science.
Mission 5

Science inside the tradition

Indian sciencearound the turn of the eraAyurveda: Charaka Samhita(internal medicine) and SushrutaSamhita (surgery) compiled499 CEAryabhata, Aryabhatiya: the earthturns on its axis; π close to3.1416; eclipses explained byshadows598–c. 668 CEBrahmagupta: rules forcalculating with zero andnegative numbers0, −1
  • Many Hindus point out that Indian thinkers did science long before modern Europe.
  • Astronomy: Aryabhata (476–c. 550 CE), Aryabhatiya (499 CE): the earth turns on its axis; a value of π close to 3.1416; explained eclipses by shadows.
  • Brahmagupta (598–c. 668 CE): rules for calculating with zero and negative numbers.
  • Medicine: Ayurveda ("knowledge of long life"). The Charaka Samhita (internal medicine) and the Sushruta Samhita (surgery), compiled in the centuries around the turn of the era.
  • Astronomy grew partly from religious need: jyotisha set the right times for Vedic rituals.
Mission 5

Samkhya: classifying matter

Samkhya: 24 principlespurushapureconsciousnessseparate: notone of the 24prakriti (matter, nature)3 gunas: sattva, rajas,tamas1intellect1ego-sense1mind15 senses55 organs of action55 subtle elements55 gross elementsspace, air, fire, water, earth51+1+1+1+5+5+5+5 = 24 tattvas
  • Samkhya ("enumeration") is one of the six classical schools (darshanas); its key text is the Samkhya Karika (c. 4th–5th century CE).
  • Two ultimate realities: purusha (pure consciousness) and prakriti (matter, nature).
  • Prakriti is made of three gunas: sattva (clarity), rajas (energy), tamas (inertia).
  • It unfolds into twenty-four principles (tattvas), ending in the five gross elements: space, air, fire, water, earth.
  • Some Hindus see this as an early, reasoned classification of matter: an ancestor of science.
  • Others note it is a philosophy of liberation, not experiment: it classifies matter to free purusha from it.
Mission 5

"It was all in the Vedas"

  • Some Hindus hold that modern discoveries were revealed in the Vedas long ago.
  • Dayananda Saraswati (1824–1883), founder of the Arya Samaj, Satyarth Prakash (1875): the Vedas are the source of all true knowledge, including science (paraphrase).
  • Popular claims today: flying machines (vimanas) in the epics; nuclear weapons; "Vedic mathematics".
  • Critics, including many Hindu scientists and historians: these readings put modern ideas back into ancient texts; they can make Indian science look like myth and hide its real achievements.
  • Supporters: the Vedas are eternal knowledge, so modern science rediscovers what the rishis saw.
Mission 5Read the source

Days and nights of Brahma

Cycles and a Big BangHindu cosmology: cycleskalpa≈ 4.32 billionyearsdawnnightuniverses emerge and dissolve again andagainModern cosmology: one Big BangnowBig Bangdawn of a cycle?many Hindus say it fits

Bhagavad Gita 8.18 (Edwin Arnold, 1885):

> "When that vast Dawn doth break, th' Invisible / Is brought anew into the Visible; / When that deep Night doth darken, all which is / Fades back again to Him Who sent it forth"

  • Hindu cosmology is cyclical: universes emerge and dissolve again and again.
  • A kalpa (a "day of Brahma") is usually reckoned at 4.32 billion years.
  • Many Hindus say the Big Bang fits: it can be the dawn of the present cycle, and the vast scale of time matches modern cosmology.

Q1 According to the passage, where does everything go at "Night"?

Show answer

Back into the one who sent it forth: the unmanifest source.

Q2 Name one difference between this picture and a single Big Bang.

Show answer

Cycles without first beginning, against one beginning about 13.8 billion years ago.

Mission check

?A Hindu doctor says: "Ayurveda and modern medicine are both ways of knowing the body. I use what the evidence supports, and I see my healing work as my dharma." Which response to science is closest to hers?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?

Make a guess: If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?

Mission 6

Vedanta: the end of the Veda

Vedanta mapUpanishadsBrahmaSutrasBhagavadGitaVedanta"end of the Veda"Advaitanon-dualShankara, c.700–750 CE(trad.788–820)Vishishtadvaitaqualifiednon-dualRamanujaDvaitadualMadhva
  • Vedanta means "end of the Veda": the Upanishads, the last and most philosophical part of the Vedas.
  • It became a darshana (school of philosophy), also called Uttara Mimamsa: inquiry into the later Veda.
  • Every Vedanta school comments on three texts, the prasthana-traya (triple foundation): the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras (Badarayana; date uncertain) and the Bhagavad Gita.
  • The central question: how are Brahman, the atman (self) and the world related?
  • Three great answers: Advaita (non-dual; Shankara), Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dual; Ramanuja), Dvaita (dual; Madhva). Ramanuja and Madhva.
Mission 6

Shankara in context

  • Shankara (also Sankara, Shankaracharya): c. 700–750 CE by many scholars; traditionally 788–820 CE. Born in Kerala.
  • Became a sannyasi (renouncer) young; disciple of Govinda, whose teacher Gaudapada had already taught non-duality (Mandukya Karika).
  • Wrote commentaries (bhashyas) on the Brahma Sutras, the main Upanishads and the Gita.
  • Rivals: Mimamsa ritualists, who held that ritual action is the heart of the Veda; and Buddhists, who denied a permanent self. Shankara argued against both: liberation comes through knowledge of the eternal self.
  • Tradition says he founded monasteries (mathas) at Sringeri, Puri, Dwarka and Jyotirmath, and organised orders of renouncers.
  • Sources: shruti above all (Upanishads read as the only valid means of knowing Brahman), the Brahma Sutras and Gita, and Gaudapada's teaching; reason supports scripture.
Mission 6

One without a second

BrahmanNirguna Brahmanwithout qualities"neti, neti"not this, not thissat-chit-anandaseen through mayaSagunaBrahman /Ishvaraeveryday levelworld ofmany thingsatman=atman =Brahman
  • For Shankara's Advaita, Brahman alone is ultimately real: "one only, without a second" (Chandogya 6:2:1, paraphrase).
  • Nirguna Brahman: without qualities; beyond thought and words. It can only be described by negation: neti, neti ("not this, not this", Brihadaranyaka 2:3:6).
  • Positively, it is described as sat-chit-ananda: being, consciousness, bliss.
  • Saguna Brahman (with qualities) or Ishvara (the Lord): Brahman as seen from within the world: creator, worshipped as Vishnu, Shiva or the Goddess. Real at the everyday level, not the final truth.
  • Shankara teaches that atman is Brahman: the true self is not a part of Brahman but Brahman, fully.
Mission 6Read the source

"You are that"

  • Chandogya Upanishad 6 (paraphrase): Uddalaka teaches his son Shvetaketu. Salt dissolved in water cannot be seen, yet every sip tastes of it (6:13). The subtle essence pervades everything; "that is the Self, and you are that" (tat tvam asi).
  • Shankara reads "you are that" as identity: the self and Brahman are one, not two.
  • The Gita on the self (Arnold):

> "Never the spirit was born; the spirit shall cease to be never; / Never was time it was not; End and Beginning are dreams!" (Bhagavad Gita 2:20, Arnold)

Q1 What does the salt show about Brahman?

Show answer

It is present everywhere, though not seen.

Q2 How does Shankara read "you are that"?

Show answer

As strict identity of atman and Brahman.

Mission 6

Adhyasa: superimposition

Rope and snakedusklampsuperimposed: snakelight comes: the snake fadesknowledge removes the error;the rope never changed
  • Adhyasa: seeing one thing as another. Shankara opens his Brahma Sutra commentary with it.
  • Rope and snake: at dusk a rope looks like a snake. The snake is superimposed on the rope. You feel real fear; but there was only ever a rope.
  • Shell and silver: mother-of-pearl glints like silver.
  • In the same way we superimpose body, mind and individuality onto the self ("I am tall", "I am sad"), and the qualities of the self onto body and mind.
  • Advaitins call the power by which the one Brahman appears as many maya.
  • Ignorance (avidya) does not make the rope vanish; knowledge removes the snake. So, for Shankara, liberation is by jnana (knowledge).
Quick check
?In Shankara's image of the rope mistaken for a snake, what stands for Brahman?
Mission 6

Maya and avidya

  • Maya (in Advaita): the power by which the one Brahman appears as many. Often translated "illusion", but the world is not "nothing".
  • Advaitins call maya indescribable: not real (it is not there in the final truth) and not unreal (it is experienced; it is not like a "son of a barren woman").
  • Avidya: ignorance in the individual; it hides Brahman and projects the world.
  • Samsara is the result: the self takes itself to be a body-mind with karma, and is reborn.
  • Brahman with a range of meanings: nirguna (beyond qualities), saguna (with qualities), Ishvara (Lord and creator), atman (the self within).
Mission 6

Three levels of reality

Three levels of realityUltimate (paramarthika)Brahman alonecancelled by the level aboveMundane, empirical (vyavaharika)people, gods, karma, dharma, science,worship: fully real for uscancelled by the level aboveIllusory (pratibhasika)dreams, the snake in the rope: real only whilethe mistake lastsShankara himself mostly contrasts twostandpoints (everyday and ultimate); later
  • Advaitins distinguish three levels:
  • Illusory (pratibhasika): dreams, the snake in the rope. Real only while the mistake lasts.
  • Mundane, empirical (vyavaharika): the everyday world of people, gods, karma, dharma, science and worship. Fully real for us: you must still keep your promises and avoid the bus.
  • Ultimate (paramarthika): Brahman alone.
  • Each level is cancelled only by the one above: waking cancels the dream; knowing Brahman cancels the separateness of the world.
  • Shankara himself mostly contrasts two standpoints (everyday and ultimate); later Advaitins set out three.
Quick check
?A follower of Shankara cares for her elderly parents out of duty. On which level of reality does that duty belong?
Mission 6

Liberation, bhakti and moral action

  • Bondage (for Shankara): avidya. Liberation (moksha): direct knowledge that atman is Brahman. It is not produced by any action; it is the removal of ignorance.
  • Jivanmukti: one can be liberated while still alive.
  • Karma yoga and dharma: they do not liberate, but they purify the mind and make it ready for knowledge.
  • Bhakti is valuable but inferior for Shankara: devotion to a personal God belongs to the everyday level, where worshipper and worshipped seem two. It prepares the mind; it does not give final knowledge.
  • The Gita: Shankara reads it as teaching that knowledge is the direct means to moksha; action and devotion lead towards it.
Mission 6

Influence and scholars

  • Advaita became the most widely known school of Vedanta: carried by the Shankaracharyas of the mathas, the Smarta tradition and later Advaitins.
  • Scholars (e.g. Gavin Flood, An Introduction to Hinduism, 1996) note that this modern prominence can hide how many Hindus follow theistic Vedanta and bhakti.
  • J Hopkins (Thomas J. Hopkins, The Hindu Religious Tradition, 1971) tells Hindu history as a "great and growing synthesis" of traditions. Apply it: Shankara drew the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras and Gita into one system, against Buddhist and ritualist rivals.
  • P Bowes (Pratima Bowes, The Hindu Religious Tradition: A Philosophical Approach, 1977), paraphrase: she treats non-dualism as one of several Hindu ways of conceiving the divine, beside devotional theism, and finds the tradition's depth in not being confined to any one of them.
  • Read with the anthology extracts (3) Smart and (4) Brockington (paraphrase only).
Mission 6Evaluate

Does Advaita give the best account of Vedanta?

Does Advaita give the best account of Vedanta?Shankara's Advaita is the most convincingreading of the Upanishads.ForIt takes "you are that" and "one without asecond" at full strength.Adhyasa explains how one reality canappear as many, using ordinaryexperience.AgainstRamanuja: where does avidya live? Not inBrahman (pure knowledge); not in theindividual self (itself a product of avidya).Devotional: an impersonal Brahman leavesno one to love; bhakti is demoted.Ethical: if separateness is not ultimatelyreal, why care for others?Reply (to the ethical point)Because the other is your own self:harming them harms you.Judge it byfidelity to shruti · coherence of avidya · fit withHindu practice · consequences for ethics
  • Claim: Shankara's Advaita is the most convincing reading of the Upanishads.
  • For: It takes "you are that" and "one without a second" at full strength.
  • For: Adhyasa explains how one reality can appear as many, using ordinary experience.
  • Against (Ramanuja): where does avidya live? Not in Brahman, who is pure knowledge; not in the individual self, which is itself a product of avidya.
  • Against (devotional): an impersonal Brahman leaves no one to love; bhakti, central to most Hindus, is demoted.
  • Against (ethical): if separateness is not ultimately real, why care for others? Reply: because the other is your own self, harming them harms you.
  • Judgement criteria: fidelity to shruti; coherence of avidya; fit with Hindu practice; consequences for ethics.
Quick check
?Why does Shankara treat bhakti as inferior to jnana?
Mission check

?A student reads that, for Shankara, the world is maya. She concludes: "So Advaitins think nothing we do here matters." How would a follower of Shankara reply?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Is the soul one with God, part of God, or forever different from God?

Make a guess: Is the soul one with God, part of God, or forever different from God?

Mission 7

Ramanuja in context

  • Ramanuja: traditionally 1017–1137 CE; many scholars place him later in the 11th–12th centuries. Born near Chennai; taught at Srirangam, Tamil Nadu.
  • First studied Advaita, and disagreed with his teacher's reading of the Upanishads.
  • Became leader of the Sri Vaishnava tradition after Yamuna, devoted to Vishnu (Narayana) and Lakshmi (Sri).
  • Sources: the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras and Gita; the Pancharatra temple scriptures; and the Tamil hymns of the Alvars, poet-saints of loving devotion to Vishnu.
  • Works: Sri Bhashya (on the Brahma Sutras), a Gita commentary, Vedartha Sangraha.
  • Context: he gives bhakti a Vedanta foundation, answering Shankara from within the same texts.
Mission 7

The world as God's body

Body of GodBrahman = Vishnusoul, inner controllermatter (achit)souls (chit)his bodyreal, distinct, yet inseparable
  • Vishishtadvaita ("non-duality of the qualified") is the school of Ramanuja (11th–12th century), a devotee of Vishnu. For Ramanuja there is one reality, Brahman, but it is qualified by souls and matter.
  • Brahman is Vishnu: personal, with infinite good qualities (saguna). Not beyond all qualities.
  • Souls (chit) and matter (achit) are real and eternal. They are the body of God; God is their inner soul and controller.
  • As a body belongs to a person and cannot exist apart, the world belongs to God: inseparable, yet distinct.
  • "You are that" means: you, whose inner self is Brahman, belong to that Brahman. Not strict identity.
  • The world is not illusion. Maya is God's wonderful creative power.
Mission 7

Bondage and liberation for Ramanuja

  • Bondage: karma (beginningless) contracts the soul's knowledge; it identifies with bodies and is reborn.
  • Liberation (moksha): the soul's knowledge expands; after death it enjoys the bliss of God in Vaikuntha, Vishnu's heaven.
  • The liberated soul becomes like God in bliss and purity, but never identical with God. It remains itself, in loving service.
  • Means: bhakti (continuous loving meditation on God) and prapatti (surrender), with God's grace.
  • Dharma is not abandoned: duties are done as worship of God.
  • The difference from Shankara is radical: for Ramanuja, bhakti is the highest path, and the personal relationship with God is never dissolved.
Mission 7Read the source

The Gita's last word

Krishna's final teaching to Arjuna:

> "Give Me thy heart! adore Me! serve Me! cling / In faith and love and reverence to Me! / So shalt thou come to Me!" (Bhagavad Gita 18:65, Arnold)

> "And let go those— / Rites and writ duties! Fly to Me alone! / Make Me thy single refuge! I will free / Thy soul from all its sins!" (Bhagavad Gita 18:66, Arnold)

  • Ramanuja's claim: the Gita's climax is bhakti and surrender to a personal God who saves by grace. Sri Vaishnavas call 18:66 the "final verse" of surrender.
  • Shankara's claim: giving up all duties to "fly to Me" points to renunciation and knowledge of the one Self; devotion prepares for it.

Q1 Which words in 18:66 support Ramanuja's reading?

Show answer

"Make Me thy single refuge! I will free": surrender and God's saving action.

Q2 Why can both claim the Gita?

Show answer

It teaches knowledge, action and devotion; each ranks them differently.

Quick check
?For Ramanuja, how is the world related to Brahman?
Mission 7

Madhva: five eternal differences

Five differences12435God (Vishnu)independentsoulsdependentmatterdependent1God and souls2God and matter3soul and soul4soul and matter5matter and matter
  • Madhva (traditionally 1238–1317 CE), from Udupi, Karnataka, where he set up the Krishna temple.
  • Dvaita: dualism. For Madhva, Vishnu alone is independent; everything else is dependent on him.
  • Five eternal differences: God and souls; God and matter; soul and soul; soul and matter; matter and matter.
  • He reads Chandogya 6:8:7 as "atat tvam asi": "you are not that". A soul is a reflection of God, never God.
  • Souls are graded: some are fit for liberation; some remain in samsara; some go to darkness. A unique and much-debated teaching.
  • Liberation: by bhakti grounded in right knowledge of God, through Vishnu's grace. Liberated souls enjoy bliss, each to its own capacity.
Mission 7Diversity

Three schools compared

Three schools comparedShankaraAdvaitaRamanujaVishishtadvaitaMadhvaDvaitaBrahmanNirguna;beyondqualitiesVishnu, with allgood qualitiesVishnu,whollyindependentAtman and BrahmanIdenticalDistinct butinseparable(body of God)EternallydifferentThe worldAppearance(maya)Real; God's bodyReal;dependent onGodBondageAvidya(ignorance)Karma contractsknowledgeKarma;ignorance ofGod'ssupremacyLiberationKnowingatman isBrahmanBliss with God,like him, not himBliss in God'spresence,gradedMain meansJnanaBhakti, prapatti,graceBhakti withknowledge,graceImageRope andsnakeBody and soulReflectionand original
Shankara: AdvaitaRamanuja: VishishtadvaitaMadhva: Dvaita
BrahmanNirguna; beyond qualitiesVishnu, with all good qualitiesVishnu, wholly independent
Atman and BrahmanIdenticalDistinct but inseparable (body of God)Eternally different
The worldAppearance (maya)Real; God's bodyReal; dependent on God
BondageAvidya (ignorance)Karma contracts knowledgeKarma; ignorance of God's supremacy
LiberationKnowing atman is BrahmanBliss with God, like him, not himBliss in God's presence, graded
Main meansJnanaBhakti, prapatti, graceBhakti with knowledge, grace
ImageRope and snakeBody and soulReflection and original
Quick check
?Which teaching is distinctive of Madhva among the three teachers?
Mission 7

Influence: bhakti schools and Chaitanya

LineageAlvars (Tamilhymns)RamanujaSri VaishnavismMadhvaMadhva's linelink debatedby scholarsChaitanya(1486–1534)GaudiyaVaishnavismISKCON
  • Sri Vaishnavism continues Ramanuja's teaching in South India; later it divided over how far grace needs human effort.
  • Ramanuja's thought gave philosophical respectability to devotion: a personal God, real souls, a real world.
  • Chaitanya (1486–1534), Bengal: Krishna (with Radha) as the supreme God; ecstatic sankirtan (congregational chanting of God's names).
  • Gaudiya (Bengal) Vaishnavas teach achintya-bhedabheda: souls are inconceivably one with and different from God. Like Ramanuja: personal God, real souls, bhakti as highest.
  • The Gaudiya tradition traces its lineage through Madhva's line (scholars debate the link). ISKCON comes from it.
  • Shankara's influence ran into Advaita and, in modern times, Neo-Vedanta (see Mission 2).
Mission 7

Scholars on Shankara and Ramanuja

  • J Hopkins (Thomas J. Hopkins, The Hindu Religious Tradition, 1971) tells Hindu history as a "great and growing synthesis". Apply it: Ramanuja joined the Tamil Alvars' devotion to Sanskrit Vedanta, giving temple bhakti an intellectual foundation.
  • P Bowes (Pratima Bowes, The Hindu Religious Tradition: A Philosophical Approach, 1977), paraphrase: non-dualism (Shankara) and devotionalism with "qualified monotheism" (Ramanuja) are both Hindu ways of conceiving the divine; the tradition's depth lies in not being confined to one.
  • Extract (4) (Brockington, on bhakti in the South) sets Ramanuja among the Alvars and Sri Vaishnava teachers; extract (3) (Smart) compares the Vedanta schools. Paraphrase only.
  • Strengths of Ramanuja: fits the devotion of most Hindus; keeps the world and persons real; reads the Gita's climax naturally.
  • Weaknesses: must explain how God can have a body without being limited or touched by its suffering; Advaitins say he weakens "you are that".
Mission 7Evaluate

Shankara or Ramanuja?

Shankara or Ramanuja?Ramanuja gives a better account ofHinduism than Shankara.ForMost Hindus worship a personal God;Ramanuja makes that worship the highestpath.He avoids the problem of where avidyalives; the world is simply real.AgainstShankara takes the identity texts ("you arethat") more literally.Advaita can include bhakti at the everydaylevel, while pointing beyond it.Madhva's challenge to both: only eternaldifference keeps God truly supreme.Judge it byfidelity to shruti · coherence · fit with Hindupractice · what it means for the relationshipwith God
  • Claim: Ramanuja gives a better account of Hinduism than Shankara.
  • For: Most Hindus worship a personal God; Ramanuja makes that worship the highest path.
  • For: He avoids the problem of where avidya lives; the world is simply real.
  • Against: Shankara takes the identity texts ("you are that") more literally.
  • Against: Advaita can include bhakti at the everyday level, while pointing beyond it.
  • Against (Madhva's challenge to both): only eternal difference keeps God truly supreme.
  • Judgement criteria: fidelity to shruti; coherence; fit with Hindu practice; what it means for the relationship with God.
Quick check
?How does Ramanuja's reading of Bhagavad Gita 18:66 differ from Shankara's?
Mission check

?A devotee at a Vishnu temple prays: "All souls and all matter are your body, Lord; nothing exists apart from you. Let me serve you for ever, sharing your bliss, though never becoming you." Which teacher's Vedanta does this prayer fit best?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Foreign rule, Christian and Islamic challenges and Western reason pushed 19th-century Hindus to reform or defend their tradition.
  • Ram Mohan Roy (Brahmo Samaj, 1828): one formless God from the Upanishads and reason; against sati; open to other faiths. Dayananda Saraswati (Arya Samaj, 1875): the four Vedas alone; havan; varna by merit; shuddhi.

Mission 2

  • Ramakrishna (1836–1886): Kali devotee and mystic; experiences through many paths led him to teach "as many faiths, so many paths"; he accepted both images and the formless.
  • Vivekananda (1863–1902): Chicago 1893; Neo-Vedanta (Advaita, experience, four yogas, all religions true); Practical Vedanta and the Ramakrishna Mission (1897): serving people as God.
  • Neo-Vedanta and Hindutva share national pride but differ on universalism; Gandhi linked Neo-Vedanta to non-violence.

Mission 3

  • Savarkar (1923): a Hindu treats India as both fatherland and holy land; the Sangh Parivar (RSS, VHP, BJP) builds on this.
  • Hindus are divided: supporters see cultural pride and fair treatment; critics see exclusion of minorities and a politicised Hinduism.

Mission 4

  • Gandhi (1869–1948) joined religion and politics: Truth is God; all life is one; so non-violence (ahimsa) and satyagraha.
  • Brahmacharya (control of all senses, Gita 18:52–53) and swaraj (self-rule of person and nation) gave satyagraha its strength.
  • Hindus, Dalits and the wider world judge him differently: Father of the Nation, defender of caste, or global model of non-violence.

Mission 5

  • Science tests religion by its method, its discoveries and its new ethical powers; Hindus respond in many ways.
  • Indian astronomy and medicine (Aryabhata, Charaka, Ayurveda) and Samkhya's classification of matter show science within the tradition.

Mission 6

  • Vedanta interprets the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras and Gita; Shankara's Advaita holds that Brahman alone is real and atman is Brahman.
  • The world appears through maya and avidya, by adhyasa (superimposition, like a rope seen as a snake); there are illusory, mundane and ultimate levels of reality.
  • Liberation is by knowledge; dharma, karma yoga and bhakti prepare the mind but are lower; critics question avidya, devotion and ethics.

Mission 7

  • Ramanuja (Vishishtadvaita): souls and matter are real and form God's body; liberation is loving communion with Vishnu, like him but not him, reached by bhakti, surrender and grace.
  • Madhva (Dvaita): five eternal differences; God alone independent; souls graded; "you are not that".
  • Both claim the Gita; Ramanuja makes bhakti the highest path where Shankara makes it preparatory; his thought shapes later bhakti schools, including Chaitanya's.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: Social and historical developments; works of scholars for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Under British rule, two Hindu reformers both rejected image worship. Why did they still disagree?
  2. Mission 2How did a temple priest who spoke no English shape how the world sees Hinduism?
  3. Mission 3What makes someone a Hindu: belief, birth, or loving India as a holy land?
  4. Mission 4Gandhi said his politics came from his religion. Was he a saint, a politician, or both at once?
  5. Mission 5Ancient hymns, ancient astronomers, a universe billions of years old: does science fit Hindu belief?
  6. Mission 6If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?
  7. Mission 7Is the soul one with God, part of God, or forever different from God?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel