🚀 Hinduism: Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 2)
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4C Hinduism – 1 Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Hinduism: Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 2)
6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1How did one elderly monk with almost no money spread Krishna devotion across the world?
Mission 2One Hindu's supreme God is Vishnu, another's Shiva, another's the Goddess. Same religion?
Mission 3Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
Mission 4Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
Mission 5Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
Mission 6Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?
Mission 1
Mission 1: How did one elderly monk with almost no money spread Krishna devotion across the world?
Make a guess: How did one elderly monk with almost no money spread Krishna devotion across the world?
Mission 1
Roots: Chaitanya and Gaudiya Vaishnavism
ISKCON: the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, founded in New York in 1966. Popularly "the Hare Krishnas".
It belongs to Gaudiya Vaishnavism, the Bengal ("Gauda") devotional tradition.
Founder of that tradition: Chaitanya Mahaprabhu (1486–1534), who led ecstatic group chanting of Krishna's names (sankirtan) in the streets.
Key texts: the Bhagavad Gita and the Bhagavata Purana (Srimad Bhagavatam).
Here Krishna is not only an avatar of Vishnu: he is the supreme God himself, the source of Vishnu and all forms. This is why your spec calls Krishna the heart of the bhakti movements.
ISKCON sees itself as part of an unbroken chain of teachers (parampara) back to Chaitanya and Krishna.
Mission 1
Krishna consciousness
Krishna consciousness: every soul's original nature is to love and serve Krishna. We forget this and identify with the body.
The soul (jiva) is eternal, both one with Krishna in quality and different from him: achintya-bhedabheda ("inconceivable oneness and difference", Chaitanya's teaching).
So ISKCON rejects Advaita's impersonal Brahman as the highest truth: God is a person.
Goal: pure loving devotion (prema bhakti) and return to Krishna's eternal realm, not merging into Brahman.
In this age of quarrel (Kali Yuga) the easiest path is chanting God's names.
The maha-mantra: "Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare / Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare".
Quick check
?Why does ISKCON reject the Advaita Vedanta goal of merging into Brahman?
Mission 1
Why did it grow?
Religious reasons
A clear, personal God and a simple daily practice (chanting) open to anyone.
An authority: an ancient lineage, a guru, and English translations with commentary.
Cultural reasons
1960s counterculture: young Westerners looking beyond materialism and drugs; communal living.
Celebrity: George Harrison produced the "Hare Krishna Mantra" single (1969) and gave Bhaktivedanta Manor (Hertfordshire, 1973).
Diaspora: from the 1970s, Indian Hindus in Britain and America joined temples in large numbers: Vaishnava worship they knew, explained in English to their children.
Mission 1Read the source
Surrender to Krishna
> "Give Me thy heart! adore Me! serve Me! cling / In faith and love and reverence to Me! / So shalt thou come to Me! I promise true, / For thou art sweet to Me!" (Bhagavad Gita 18:65, Arnold 1885)
> "Fly to Me alone! / Make Me thy single refuge! I will free / Thy soul from all its sins!" (Bhagavad Gita 18:66, Arnold 1885)
ISKCON reads these verses as the summit of the Gita: give up all other paths and surrender to Krishna as a person.
Q1 What four responses does Krishna ask for in 18:65?
Show answer
Give the heart, adore, serve, cling in faith and love.
Q2 Why does this suit ISKCON better than an Advaita reading?
Show answer
Krishna speaks as a person to be loved and relied on, not as impersonal reality.
Mission 1Evaluate
"ISKCON is a divergence from traditional Hinduism."
Step 1 of 4
For divergence: converts from outside Indian birth and caste; it seeks converts, unlike most Hindu traditions; one God (Krishna) is supreme and other deities are servants of Krishna; strict rules most Hindus do not follow; a global, centrally governed organisation; it has sometimes avoided the word "Hindu".
Against: its theology is 500 years old (Chaitanya); its texts are classic Hindu scriptures; Gaudiya temples in India recognise it; most of its members in Britain are Hindus of Indian origin; Hindu bodies in Britain treat it as Hindu.
Deeper question: is there one "traditional" Hinduism to diverge from? (.)
Judge it by: beliefs, practice, membership, organisation: which matters most for "traditional"?
Mission check
?A British Gujarati family who have always worshipped Krishna at home begin attending an ISKCON temple. Which feature of ISKCON is most likely to be new to them?
ISKCON's beliefs are old Gaudiya Vaishnavism; what was new was its global mission, its converts and its organisation.
Mission 2
Mission 2: One Hindu's supreme God is Vishnu, another's Shiva, another's the Goddess. Same religion?
Make a guess: One Hindu's supreme God is Vishnu, another's Shiva, another's the Goddess. Same religion?
Mission 2
Three theistic traditions
Theistic: centred on a personal Supreme God (saguna Brahman).
Vaishnavism: Vishnu (and his avatars) supreme. Shaivism: Shiva supreme. Shaktism: the Goddess, Devi or Shakti, supreme.
Each has its own scriptures (beside the Vedas), temples, festivals, marks, saints and schools.
They grew over many centuries, especially from the time of the epics and Puranas (c. 300 BCE–1000 CE).
Smartas worship several deities as equal forms of one Brahman.
Many Hindus respect all the deities while devoting themselves to one.
Mission 2
Vaishnavism
Step 1 of 2
Supreme deity: Vishnu, with Lakshmi; worshipped especially as his avatars Krishna and Rama.
Bhakti: loving devotion and surrender (prapatti) to God, who saves by grace; chanting the divine names.
Ritual worship: temple and home puja to the murti; offering food that becomes prasad; the tulsi plant; great temples such as Tirupati, Srirangam and Puri.
Moral and ethical values: dharma as Vishnu's order; many Vaishnavas are strict vegetarians; humility and service of other devotees.
Mark: a vertical U- or V-shaped tilak on the forehead.
Mission 2
Shaivism
Step 1 of 2
Supreme deity: Shiva, with Parvati; worshipped in the lingam, a smooth, rounded stone pillar, symbol of formless divine presence.
Bhakti: Tamil poet-saints, the 63 Nayanars; the five-syllable mantra Om Namah Shivaya; festival Maha Shivaratri.
Ritual worship: pouring water and milk over the lingam and offering bilva leaves; temples such as Varanasi's Kashi Vishwanath and the twelve Jyotirlingas.
Asceticism: Shiva is the great yogi; many sadhus are Shaiva, with ash (vibhuti), matted hair and rudraksha beads.
Schools: Shaiva Siddhanta (Tamil, based on the Agamas); Kashmir Shaivism (non-dual; Abhinavagupta, c. 950–1016); Lingayats or Virashaivas (Basava, 12th century), who wear a small lingam on the body.
Mark: three horizontal lines of ash (tripundra).
Quick check
?A devotee with three horizontal lines of ash on her forehead pours water over a lingam and chants "Om Namah Shivaya". Which tradition is she most likely to follow?
Mission 2
Shakti: power as Goddess
Step 1 of 2
Shakti: "power", "energy": the creative power of the divine.
In many traditions every god has a shakti, pictured as his consort: Lakshmi with Vishnu, Parvati with Shiva, Saraswati with Brahma.
A common saying (from the Saundarya Lahari, paraphrase): Shiva united with Shakti can create; without her he cannot even stir.
In Shaktism, the Goddess, Devi or Mahadevi, is not only a consort but the Supreme reality: she brings forth Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva.
She is worshipped as the Divine Mother: both gentle and fierce.
"In some contexts" one manifestation, such as Durga or Kali, is worshipped as the true form of the Divine.
Mission 2Read the source
Uma teaches the gods
Kena Upanishad (Swami Paramananda's translation, 1919). The gods cannot recognise a mysterious being. Indra runs towards it, but it disappears:
> "Then he saw in that very space a woman beautifully adorned, Uma of golden hue, daughter of Haimavat (Himalaya)." (3:12)
> "She (Uma) said: 'It is Brahman. It is through the victory of Brahman that ye are victorious.'" (4:1)
Uma is a name of Parvati, Shiva's consort.
Q1 Who knows what the gods do not?
Show answer
Uma, the Goddess: she reveals Brahman to Indra.
Q2 Why might Shaktas value this passage?
Show answer
The Goddess appears as the one who knows and reveals the ultimate reality.
Mission 2
Forms of the Goddess
Durga: the warrior, riding a lion. In the Devi Mahatmya (c. 5th–6th century; part of the Markandeya Purana) the gods' powers join to form her, and she slays the buffalo-demon Mahishasura.
Kali: dark, fierce, garlanded with skulls; destroys evil and ego; loved as Mother (e.g. by Ramakrishna, 1836–1886).
Lakshmi (wealth, good fortune), Saraswati (learning, music), Parvati (devoted wife and mother).
Village goddesses (grama-devatas) protect local communities.
Festivals: Navaratri (nine nights), Durga Puja (Bengal), Kali Puja. Shakti Peethas: shrines where, the story says, parts of the goddess Sati's body fell.
Quick check
?Which statement is accurate about Shakti in Shaktism?
Mission 2
Lipner and Sivananda on the Goddess
J Lipner (Hindus, 1994/2010), paraphrase:
The divine feminine is central to Hinduism, not an add-on: the Goddess can be gentle consort and independent, fierce power.
Worship of a goddess as supreme fits his polycentric picture: one of many centres of devotion, each able to stand for the whole.
S Sivananda (1887–1963), paraphrase:
Shakti is the dynamic power of the one Brahman; Shiva (pure consciousness) and Shakti (power) cannot be separated.
Worship of the Divine Mother, e.g. at Navaratri, is a valid path: the devotee approaches the one God as Mother.
Mission 2Diversity
Three traditions compared
Vaishnava
Shaiva
Shakta
Supreme
Vishnu (Krishna, Rama)
Shiva
Devi (Durga, Kali …)
Symbol
conch, discus; U-mark
lingam, trident; three lines
lion, sword, Sri Yantra; red kumkum mark (varies)
Bhakti
surrender, divine names
Nayanars, Om Namah Shivaya
Divine Mother devotion
Practice
puja, prasad, tulsi
lingam puja, ash, yoga
Navaratri, puja; Tantra (some)
Ideal
devotee, ethical life
ascetic, yogi
devotee, Tantric adept
Shared: Vedas, karma, samsara, moksha, puja, pilgrimage, bhakti; the other deities are honoured.
Different: the name of the Supreme; scriptures (Pancharatra Samhitas, Shaiva Agamas, Shakta Tantras); views of liberation.
Mission 2Evaluate
Separate religions?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Vaishnavism, Shaivism and Shaktism are best seen as separate religions.
For: Each has its own Supreme God, scriptures, temples, saints, theology and initiation.
For: In history they sometimes competed; some devotees worship only their own deity.
Against: They share the Vedas, dharma, karma, samsara and moksha, and the idea of one Brahman.
Against: Many Hindus move between them: a Vaishnava family may visit a Shiva temple at Shivaratri.
Against: "Religion" is a Western category that may not fit.
Judgement criteria: What makes a religion: beliefs, practices, institutions, self-understanding? Do devotees see themselves as Hindus first?
Mission check
?At Navaratri in a British mandir, devotees honour Durga for three nights, Lakshmi for three and Saraswati for three. A visitor says: "So that's three separate goddesses." Which reply best reflects Shakta belief?
For Shaktas, many goddesses are one Goddess: the power behind the universe, approached as Mother.
Mission 3
Mission 3: Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
Make a guess: Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
Mission 3
Four aims of life
The purusharthas: "aims of a person", four goals a full human life may pursue.
Dharma: right living, duty, virtue.
Artha: wealth, security, success, power.
Kama: pleasure, love, beauty, enjoyment of the senses.
Moksha: liberation from samsara.
All four are legitimate. The question is how they fit together.
Mission 3
Artha: wealth and power
Earning a living, owning property, supporting a family, building a business, and for rulers, governing well.
Without artha, a household cannot give to the poor, support temples or pay for ritual.
The Arthashastra (attributed to Kautilya, compiled c. 2nd century BCE–3rd century CE): a manual of statecraft and economics; wealth as the basis of a stable kingdom.
Artha is good when gained and used within dharma: honestly, generously, without harm.
Mission 3
Kama: pleasure and love
Delight in the senses, music, art, food, friendship, romantic and sexual love within marriage.
The Kama Sutra (Vatsyayana, c. 3rd century CE) is a guide to the art of pleasant living, not only to sex.
Kama shows that Hindu tradition does not reject pleasure: it is one of life's aims.
> "These am I, free from passion and desire; / Yet am I right desire in all who yearn" (Gita 7:11, Arnold)
Krishna is present in desire that is not contrary to dharma (the Sanskrit of 7:11): kama, too, needs dharma's limits.
Mission 3
How the four fit together
Step 1 of 3
Trivarga: the first three, the "group of three" for life in the world.
Dharma frames artha and kama, like the banks of a river: they give the water its course.
Moksha goes beyond the three: it is freedom from the whole cycle in which they are pursued.
Two directions of life: pravritti (engagement with the world: dharma, artha, kama) and nivritti (withdrawal: moksha).
Most Hindus live engaged lives and turn more towards moksha with age.
Mission 3Read the source
Which aim is best?
Manusmriti 2.224 (paraphrase):
Some say the chief good is dharma and artha; others, kama and artha; others, dharma alone; others, artha alone.
The text's answer: the chief good is the three together (trivarga).
Q1 Which aim is missing from the debate in this verse?
Show answer
Moksha: the passage concerns life in the world.
Q2 What is Manu's own answer?
Show answer
All three in balance, not one alone.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the place of artha in Hindu teaching?
Grihastha (householder): pursue artha and kama within dharma; raise a family; support society.
Vanaprastha (retirement): loosen ties; growing vairagya (detachment, freedom from craving).
Sannyasa (renunciation): give up everything for moksha.
Vairagya is the bridge: detachment turns a person from the three worldly aims towards liberation.
Your spec lists the ashrama values as dharma, artha, kama and vairagya, and their relationship with moksha.
Bilimoria (extract 1, paraphrase): the aims form a scheme in which worldly goods are pursued under dharma, while the ideal of moksha pulls the other way, towards renunciation; ethics must manage that tension.
Quick check
?Shanti, a retired grandmother, is giving away possessions and spending more time in prayer. She says: "I no longer crave these things." Which term best describes the value she shows?
Mission 3Evaluate
Is moksha the most important aim?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Moksha is the most important of the four aims.
For: It alone ends samsara; the others are temporary and bind (even punya).
For: Upanishads and Vedanta make liberation the highest goal (parama purushartha).
Against: Dharma is the foundation: without it, no aim is pursued rightly, and moksha is not reached.
Against: For most Hindus the householder's three aims fill most of life; Manusmriti 2.224 praises the three together.
Against: For some bhakti traditions, loving God matters more than liberation itself.
Judgement criteria: Most important for whom, and at which stage of life? For the individual, or for society?
Mission check
?Anjali, 45, runs a successful firm, gives a share of her profit to a hospital, and loves classical music. She plans to hand the firm to her children at 60 and spend her time on pilgrimage and meditation. How does her life fit the four aims?
the four aims make money and pleasure part of a good life, within dharma, with liberation as the horizon. Next: the dharma of class and stage of life.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
Make a guess: Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
Mission 4
Virtue and two kinds of dharma
A virtue is a settled quality of character that shows itself in action.
Hindu texts set out two levels of duty:
Sadharana dharma: duties common to everyone (non-violence, truthfulness, not stealing, purity, self-control). Manusmriti 10.63 gives a list like this for all four varnas (paraphrase).
Varnashrama dharma (svadharma): duties of your class and stage of life.
The three virtues in this mission belong to the first level: non-violence, detachment, self-restraint.
Each is thought to purify the mind and so lead towards moksha (liberation).
Mission 4
Non-violence (ahimsa)
Ahimsa: a- (not) + himsa (harm): not harming any living being in thought, word or deed.
Basis: the same atman (self) is present in every living being, so harming another is harming life that is one with yours.
Karma: Hindus believe harm done returns as suffering in this or a later life.
Its positive side: compassion (daya) and kindness to all.
Many Hindus apply it to diet: vegetarianism, and avoiding beef in particular.
It is weighed against other duties: a warrior may still have to fight (see Mission 6).
Mission 4
Detachment (vairagya)
Vairagya: freedom from craving for objects, pleasure and results.
Not indifference and not laziness: the Gita's ideal is to act fully while letting go of the fruits (nishkama karma, desireless action).
Tyaga: renouncing the fruit of action (Gita 18). Sannyasa: renouncing the world itself, the last ashrama.
Why it matters: desire for results binds the self to karma and rebirth.
Gita 2:47 (Arnold): "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them."
Mission 4
Self-restraint (dama)
Dama or indriya-nigraha: control of the senses and appetites.
Image in Gita 2:58: the wise person draws back the senses from their objects "as the wise tortoise draws its four feet safe / Under its shield" (Arnold).
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad V.2: the creator's one syllable "Da" is heard by gods, humans and demons as three lessons: restrain yourselves, give, be compassionate (paraphrase).
Practised as fasting, celibacy (brahmacharya) in the student stage, moderation in food and speech.
Self-restraint makes the other two virtues possible: anger restrained becomes non-violence; desire restrained becomes detachment.
> "… opened hand / And governed appetites; and piety, / And love of lonely study; humbleness, / Uprightness, heed to injure nought which lives, / Truthfulness, slowness unto wrath, a mind / That lightly letteth go what others prize …" (Bhagavad Gita 16:1–3, Arnold)
Krishna calls this list the divine endowment (daivi sampad): "The Heavenly Birth brings to deliverance" (16:5, Arnold).
Q1 Which phrases name the three virtues of this mission?
Show answer
"heed to injure nought which lives": non-violence; "governed appetites": self-restraint; "a mind that lightly letteth go what others prize": detachment.
Q2 Which phrase also links to non-violence, through control of anger?
Show answer
"slowness unto wrath".
Quick check
?Which description best fits detachment (vairagya) as the Bhagavad Gita teaches it?
Mission 4
The three gunas
Step 1 of 3
Prakriti (matter, nature, including mind) is woven from three gunas (strands, qualities). The idea comes from Samkhya philosophy.
Sattva: light, purity, calm, goodness, knowledge.
Rajas: passion, energy, desire, restlessness.
Tamas: darkness, inertia, dullness, delusion.
All three are present in everything and everyone; their balance shifts and shapes character.
They belong to prakriti, not to the atman, which is beyond them.
> "Sattwan, Rajas, and Tamas, so are named / The qualities of Nature, 'Soothfastness,' / 'Passion,' and 'Ignorance.' These three bind down / The changeless Spirit in the changeful flesh." (Bhagavad Gita 14:5, Arnold)
Mission 4
The virtues of each guna
The Gita sorts food, worship and action by guna (chapters 14, 17, 18):
Sattva
Rajas
Tamas
Qualities
calm, knowledge, contentment, truthfulness
greed, ambition, restless activity
sloth, confusion, carelessness, cruelty
Food (17:8–10)
fresh, mild, nourishing
very spicy, salty, sour, heating
stale, left overnight, rotten
Action (18:23–25)
done as duty, without craving the result
done for gain or show, with great strain
done in delusion, careless of harm to others
So the three virtues are sattvic: they grow as sattva grows.
Many Hindus choose a sattvic diet (often vegetarian, no onion or garlic for some) to support a calm mind.
Quick check
?Which statement about the gunas is accurate in the Bhagavad Gita and Samkhya?
Mission 4
Virtues, varna, ashrama and the aims of life
The Gita links varna to the gunas: duties are "fixed by reason of the Qualities / Planted in each" (18:41, Arnold). A Brahmin's virtues are "serenity, / Self-mastery, religion, purity" (18:42).
Ashramas train the virtues in turn: student (self-restraint, celibacy) → householder (non-violence, generosity, wealth and pleasure within dharma) → forest-dweller (loosening ties) → sannyasi (complete detachment).
Many modern Hindus read guna-based varna as character, not birth; critics note it was used to justify birth-based caste.
Mission 4
Bilimoria on Indian ethics
Purushottama Bilimoria (philosopher of Indian ethics), "Indian ethics", in P. Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics (1991): anthology extract 1. Paraphrase only:
Indian ethics grows from the Vedic idea of rta (cosmic order) into dharma, the order of duties that upholds society and the cosmos.
He distinguishes universal duties binding on all from the particular duties of one's station, and notes the tension between them.
He reads the Gita as a synthesis: act according to your dharma, but without desire for the fruits, which joins the active life to the ideal of renunciation.
He notes the critical question whether such ethics can be separated from a hierarchical social order.
Use him to show why the gunas matter: they explain different natures, and so different duties and virtues.
Mission 4Evaluate
Is virtue the way to liberation?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Living virtuously is enough to achieve moksha.
For: Virtue purifies the mind; the "divine endowment" leads to deliverance (Gita 16:5).
For: desireless action (nishkama karma, Gita 2:47) frees the self from the craving that binds it to karma and rebirth.
Against: Even sattva binds, by attachment to happiness and knowledge (Gita 14:6). The liberated person is gunatita, beyond all three gunas (14:22–25).
Against:Advaita Vedanta (the non-dualist school of Shankara): only knowledge of atman as Brahman liberates; virtue only prepares. Many bhakti (devotional) traditions: liberation comes by God's grace, not merit.
Judgement criteria: What does each school mean by moksha? Is virtue a cause of liberation or a sign of it? Can a person be detached while still doing worldly duty?
Mission check
?Anjali, a Hindu doctor, works long hospital shifts. She does not seek praise or promotion, eats simple vegetarian food, and offers each day's work to God. A colleague says she is "beyond the gunas already". In the Gita's terms, which reply is most accurate?
The three virtues grow sattva; the Gita's highest ideal is freedom from clinging even to that. A later mission: what does non-violence demand in practice?
Mission 5
Mission 5: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
Make a guess: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
It covers thought, word and deed: hatred and cruel speech are himsa too.
It also covers harm you cause or approve through others.
Why: the same atman is in every living being.
> "… sees the Life-Soul resident / In all things living, and all living things / In that Life-Soul contained." (Bhagavad Gita 6:29, Arnold)
Karma: harm returns as suffering, in this life or the next.
Positive side: compassion and respect for all life.
Mission 5
Ahimsa in Hindu tradition
Chandogya Upanishad 3.17.4: non-violence is listed with austerity, generosity, uprightness and truthfulness as the "gifts" of a life lived as sacrifice (paraphrase).
Mahabharata (Anushasana Parva): ahimsa is called the highest dharma (ahimsa paramo dharmah).
Yoga Sutras 2.30–2.35: ahimsa is the first yama (restraint); where it is firmly established, hostility ceases (paraphrase).
Manusmrti 10.63: ahimsa is among the duties common to all four varnas (paraphrase).
But Hindu ahimsa is usually weighed against other duties: sacrifice in the Vedic period, the warrior's duty, self-defence. It means minimising harm rather than an absolute vow.
By contrast, Jains (an Indian tradition with ahimsa at its heart) take it further: monks and nuns vow ahimsa absolutely, some sweeping their path to protect tiny beings; Jains hold that harm binds karma to the soul.
Quick check
?Which statement best shows how Hindu ahimsa differs from Jain ahimsa?
Mission 5
Animals
Animals have atman and are part of samsara: a human may be reborn as an animal, and an animal as a human.
The cow is honoured as a mother (gau mata): she gives milk, and Krishna was a cowherd. Most Hindus do not eat beef; many states in India restrict cow slaughter.
Vegetarianism is widespread and seen as sattvic, but varies: many Bengali and coastal Hindus eat fish; some communities eat meat; some Shakta temples still offer animal sacrifice.
Many Hindus support gaushalas (cow shelters) and avoid leather, silk or products tested on animals; others accept animal testing for human medicine as a lesser harm.
Mission 5Evaluate
Can a person live by ahimsa today?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Ahimsa, meaning never harming any living being, is a realistic standard in the modern world.
For: Millions of Jains and Hindus live as strict vegetarians; ahimsa shapes diet, work and medicine.
For: Ahimsa is about intention and minimising harm, which anyone can practise.
Against: Harm is built into life: farming, transport, medicine. Even the Manusmrti, a Hindu law text, admits that daily housework kills small creatures (3.68).
Against: Modern supply chains hide harm; the Manusmrti says the buyer of meat shares in the killing (5.51).
Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa an absolute rule or an ideal to approach? Does intention or outcome matter more? Is Jain or Hindu ahimsa the standard being tested?
Mission check
?Meera, a Hindu, is choosing a silk sari for a wedding. Ordinary silk is made by boiling silkworms in their cocoons; "ahimsa silk" lets the moths emerge first. She says: "I'm not the one boiling them, so it isn't my concern." Which reply applies Hindu teaching on ahimsa most accurately?
Ahimsa reaches past your own hands to what you buy and approve. A later mission: can a non-violent person ever fight?
Mission 6
Mission 6: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?
Make a guess: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?
Mission 6
Ahimsa meets the warrior's duty
In the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna, a kshatriya (warrior), refuses to fight his relatives at Kurukshetra.
Krishna answers: a warrior's svadharma (own duty) is to fight a righteous war (dharma yuddha); refusing would be sin.
> "Nought better can betide a martial soul / Than lawful war" (Bhagavad Gita 2:31, Arnold)
The atman cannot be killed (2:19–20), so the soldier destroys only bodies.
So in traditional Hindu ethics, ahimsa is the general rule, but force to protect dharma can be a duty for those whose role it is.
Mission 6Read the source
Two ways to read the battle
> "… if thou shunn'st / This honourable field--a Kshattriya-- / If, knowing thy duty and thy task, thou bidd'st / Duty and task go by--that shall be sin!" (Bhagavad Gita 2:33, Arnold)
Literal reading (e.g. Sri Aurobindo, 1872–1950, Essays on the Gita): the Gita really does teach that righteous war can be a duty.
Allegorical reading (Gandhi, Anasaktiyoga, 1929): Kurukshetra is the human heart; the battle is between good and evil impulses; the Gita teaches selfless action and so, in the end, non-violence.
Q1 What does Krishna say Arjuna's refusal would be?
Show answer
Sin: a failure in his duty as a kshatriya.
Q2 How can Gandhi accept this verse yet reject war?
Show answer
He reads the "field" and the "battle" as the inner struggle of the soul, not a call to physical fighting.
Quick check
?Why can Krishna urge Arjuna to fight without abandoning ahimsa, on the traditional reading of the Gita?
Mission 6
Gandhi's ahimsa
Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869–1948).
Influences: his Gujarati Vaishnava home, Jain friends and teachers (e.g. Raychandbhai), the Gita, Tolstoy and the Sermon on the Mount.
Ahimsa for Gandhi is active love, not passivity: refusing to hate, while resisting injustice.
It is the courage of the strong: he wrote (1920, paraphrase) that if the only choice were cowardice or violence, he would choose violence.
Linked with truth: he came to say that "Truth is God". Non-violence is the means; truth is the end.
Is ahimsa a workable standard in the modern world?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Ahimsa is a relevant and viable standard to live by today.
For: Gandhi's non-violent resistance (satyagraha, "truth force") helped win Indian independence (1947) and shaped the US civil rights movement.
For: Modern weapons make war's harm uncontrollable; non-violence may be the only rational path.
Against: Non-violence relies on the opponent's conscience. Gandhi's 1938 advice that Jews in Germany resist non-violently was strongly criticised (e.g. by Martin Buber, 1939).
Against: Independence came with the violence of Partition; India itself keeps an army and nuclear weapons.
Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa a personal virtue or a state policy? Does it require results to be valid? Does dharma yuddha already make ahimsa realistic?
Mission check
?A modern Hindu soldier serves in a United Nations peacekeeping force and says: "I keep ahimsa: I use force only to protect civilians, never in anger, and I'd prefer talks to fighting." Which reading of the Gita is he closest to?
Hindus agree that ahimsa matters; they differ on whether protecting dharma can ever require force. A later mission: the paths of yoga.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
ISKCON (1966) brings Chaitanya's Gaudiya Vaishnava bhakti to the world: Krishna is the supreme person; chant his names.
Mission 2
Vaishnavism (Vishnu supreme; bhakti, puja, ethical life), Shaivism (Shiva supreme; lingam, bhakti, asceticism) and Shaktism (Devi supreme) are the main theistic traditions.
Shakti is the creative power of the divine, pictured as Goddess; for Shaktas she is supreme, worshipped as Durga, Kali and others; right-hand devotion and left-hand Tantra.
Lipner: the divine feminine is central and polycentric; Sivananda: Shakti is Brahman's power, approached as Mother.
Whether they are separate religions or one family is debated.
Mission 3
Four purusharthas: dharma, artha, kama, moksha; dharma frames artha and kama; moksha goes beyond all three.
Relative importance is debated: Manusmriti 2.224 praises the three together; Vedanta makes moksha the highest aim.
Ashrama values: dharma, artha, kama, then vairagya (detachment) turning towards moksha.
Mission 4
In Hindu teaching, non-violence, detachment and self-restraint are duties for all (sadharana dharma) that purify the mind.
In the Gita and Samkhya, the three gunas (sattva, rajas, tamas) make up nature; the virtues are sattvic, but liberation lies beyond all three.
Mission 5
Ahimsa is non-harming in thought, word and deed, based on atman in all beings and on karma.
Mission 6
Traditional Hindu ethics weighs ahimsa against a warrior's duty: dharma yuddha allows just war under strict rules.
Gandhi read the Gita as an inner battle and made ahimsa a political force through satyagraha.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Hinduism: Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 2) for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1How did one elderly monk with almost no money spread Krishna devotion across the world?
Mission 2One Hindu's supreme God is Vishnu, another's Shiva, another's the Goddess. Same religion?
Mission 3Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
Mission 4Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
Mission 5Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
Mission 6Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.