← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4C Hinduism – 1 Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 1)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?
  2. Mission 2If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?
  3. Mission 3When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?
  4. Mission 4How can Hindus say God is beyond every word and also worship God with flowers in a temple?
  5. Mission 5If the universe is made, kept and destroyed again and again, who does each job, and is it one God?
  6. Mission 6Why would God come down to earth as a prince in exile, or a cowherd who steals butter?
Mission 1

Mission 1: What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?

Make a guess: What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?

Mission 1

Dharma: what holds things up

Three levels of dharmacosmicsun, seasonssocialfamily, societypersonalmy dutydhr: to hold, uphold, support
  • Dharma comes from the root dhr: to hold, uphold, support.
  • English needs many words for it: duty, righteousness, law, virtue, religion, the right way.
  • It also means a thing's nature: the dharma of fire is to burn; of water, to flow.
  • So dharma is at once cosmic (how the world is ordered), social (how society works) and personal (how I should live).
  • A much-quoted saying: dharma protects those who protect it (Manusmriti 8.15, paraphrase).
Mission 1

Rta: the order before dharma

Rta to dharmafirstRig Veda: rta, the true order ofcosmos, ritual and truthful speech;guarded by Varuna and Mitralaterdharma takes over: the order thatsustains cosmos and societyGitasvadharma (one's own dharma)and nishkam karma
  • In the Rig Veda, rta is the true order of things: the sun's path, the seasons, the rivers' flow, the right performance of sacrifice, and truthful speech.
  • The gods, especially Varuna and Mitra, guard rta; anrta is falsehood and disorder.
  • In later texts the word dharma takes over much of this role: the order that sustains cosmos and society.
  • R. C. Zaehner (1913–1974), Hinduism (1962): treats dharma as the successor to the Vedic rta, the one law that binds the cosmic, social and moral orders (paraphrase).
  • Your spec asks for implications for belief and practice: ritual done rightly, truthfulness and duty all keep the world in order.
Mission 1

Sanatana dharma: the eternal way

Universal and personalsvadharmavarna + ashramasanatana (sadharana) dharmafor everyonenon-violence · truthfulnessnot stealing · puritycontrol of the sensesManusmriti 10.63tension(Arjuna)
  • Sanatana means eternal: without beginning or end.
  • Sanatana dharma has two common uses:
  • 1. A name for the religion. Many Hindus prefer it to "Hinduism" (a name from outside): their way is not founded at a point in time but is eternal truth.
  • 2. Universal dharma. Duties for everyone, whatever their class or stage of life (also called sadharana dharma, common dharma).
  • Manusmriti 10.63 (paraphrase) sums them up: non-violence, truthfulness, not stealing, purity, control of the senses.
Mission 1

Universal and personal dharma

Universal and personalsvadharmavarna + ashramasanatana (sadharana) dharmafor everyonenon-violence · truthfulnessnot stealing · puritycontrol of the sensesManusmriti 10.63tension(Arjuna)
  • Alongside universal dharma, each person has svadharma: their own dharma.
  • Traditionally this is fixed by varna (class) and ashrama (stage of life): varnashrama dharma.
  • Krishna to Arjuna:

> "this is better, that one do / His own task as he may, even though he fail, / Than take tasks not his own, though they seem good." (Gita 3:35, Arnold)

  • Tension: Arjuna's universal dharma says "do not harm"; his svadharma as a warrior says "fight a just war". The Gita is built on that conflict.
Quick check
?Which is an example of sanatana (universal) dharma rather than varnashrama dharma?
Mission 1Read the source

When dharma declines

  • Adharma: the opposite of dharma: disorder, injustice, unrighteousness. It harms the world, society and the self, and brings bad karma.

> "When Righteousness / Declines, O Bharata! when Wickedness / Is strong, I rise, from age to age, and take / Visible shape, and move a man with men, / Succouring the good, thrusting the evil back, / And setting Virtue on her seat again." (Gita 4:7–8, Arnold)

  • Arnold translates dharma as "Righteousness" and adharma as "Wickedness".
  • Tradition pictures dharma as a bull that loses a leg in each of four ages (yugas); many Hindus believe we live in the last, the Kali Yuga.

Q1 According to the passage, why does Krishna take visible form?

Show answer

To protect the good, destroy evil and re-establish dharma.

Q2 What does "from age to age" suggest about time?

Show answer

Dharma declines and is restored again and again: time is cyclical.

Mission 1

Dharma, karma, ahimsa: Bilimoria

P. Bilimoria, "Indian ethics", in P. Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics (1991): anthology extract 1. Main points (paraphrase):

  • Indian ethics begins with rta: right order in the cosmos and in ritual.
  • Dharma becomes the normative order: duties fitting one's place in society and stage of life (later codified in the Dharma Shastras).
  • Karma links every act to its result across lives, so ethics has consequences beyond this life.
  • Ahimsa, stressed by renouncer movements (Jain and Buddhist among them), becomes a universal value that can conflict with duties such as a warrior's.
  • The Gita answers the tension: do your dharma without desire for its fruit (nishkam karma).
Mission 1

Who decides what dharma requires?

  • Sources (Manusmriti 2.6, 2.12, paraphrase): the Veda (shruti); smriti (remembered tradition); the conduct of good people; and what satisfies one's own conscience.
  • So the community matters: families, teachers, sampradayas (traditions) and gurus interpret dharma for new situations.
  • Dharma applies in many contexts: personal (honesty, self-control), family (care of parents), professional (a doctor's dharma to heal), societal (just rule, care for the poor).
  • Dharma is context-sensitive: the epic shows people weighing duties against each other.
Quick check
?Which is listed in Hindu tradition as a source for knowing dharma?
Mission 1Evaluate

Universal or personal dharma first?

Argument mapUniversal (sanatana) dharma matters morethan the dharma of one's own class andstage of life.ForIt binds everyone; non-violence and truthare the "summary" of dharma (Manusmriti10.63).Reformers such as Gandhi appealed touniversal values to attack untouchability.AgainstThe Gita (3:35, 18:47): doing your owndharma, even imperfectly, is better thananother's.Society works only if each role is filled;svadharma gives the universal a concreteshape.Judge it byWhich fits the texts? · Which guides realchoices? · Which fits a modern, plural society?
  • Claim: Universal (sanatana) dharma matters more than the dharma of one's own class and stage of life.
  • For: It binds everyone; non-violence and truth are the "summary" of dharma (Manusmriti 10.63).
  • For: Reformers appealed to universal values such as non-violence and equal dignity to attack untouchability (e.g. Gandhi).
  • Against: The Gita (3:35, 18:47) says doing your own dharma, even imperfectly, is better than another's.
  • Against: Society works only if each role is filled; svadharma gives the universal a concrete shape.
  • Judgement criteria: Which fits the texts? Which guides real choices? Which fits Hinduism in a modern, plural society?
Mission check

?Dr Mehta, a Hindu surgeon, says: "Not harming and telling the truth are duties for everyone. But as a doctor I also have duties others don't: I must cut people open to heal them." Which pair of ideas is she using?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?

Make a guess: If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?

Mission 2

Karma: action and its results

Seed to fruitactiondeed, word,thoughtimpressionresultthis life or alater onenot fate: new seeds are planted every day
  • Karma means action, and the results that action brings.
  • Every intentional act (in deed, word or thought) leaves an impression that will bear fruit, now or in a later life.
  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad IV.4.5 (paraphrase): as a person acts, so they become; doing good, one becomes good; doing evil, one becomes evil. What a person desires shapes what they do.
  • Karma is not fate: today's choices make tomorrow's karma.
  • Karma is not a judge's sentence: most Hindus see it as a moral law of cause and effect, like a seed growing into a plant.
Mission 2

Karma and universal order

Order webrta: cosmic orderdharma: righteous livingkarma: the law of action andconsequencessamsara: the cycle of livesforallbeings,allpeoples
  • In the Vedas, rta is the order of the cosmos: seasons, sacrifice and truthful conduct all fit one pattern (more in Mission 1).
  • Karma carries that order into moral life: every act has a fitting consequence, so the universe is just in the long run.
  • It applies to all beings, of every people and every birth; it is not a rule for Hindus only.
  • Who runs the law? Some schools see it as impersonal; theistic Vedanta (e.g. Ramanuja, Madhva) teaches that God dispenses the fruits of action.
  • Righteous living (dharma) produces good karma; adharma produces suffering.
  • Your spec: "karma and the importance of eternal and universal order", "the law of action and consequences".
Mission 2Read the source

Samsara: the cycle of lives

Samsara cyclebirthlifedeathrebirthkarmathe subtle body carries karmagod (deva)humananimalplantheaven (svarga)hell (naraka)both temporarymoksha
  • Samsara: the cycle of birth, death and rebirth, driven by karma and by desire and ignorance.

> "To man's frame / As there come infancy and youth and age, / So come there raisings-up and layings-down / Of other and of other life-abodes, / Which the wise know, and fear not." (Gita 2:13, Arnold)

> "Some Jivas (individual Souls) enter wombs to be embodied; others go into immovable forms, according to their deeds and knowledge." (Katha 5:7, Paramananda)

  • What travels? The atman, with a subtle body (sukshma sharira) that carries the karmic impressions.

Q1 What comparison does Gita 2:13 make?

Show answer

Moving to a new body is like moving from childhood to youth to old age in one body.

Q2 What decides the next birth in Katha 5:7?

Show answer

Deeds and knowledge.

Quick check
?Priya's grandfather says: "Your karma is not your fate." What does he most likely mean?
Mission 2

Three kinds of karma

Three arrowssanchita: accumulatedstored from past livesprarabdha: fruit-bearingalready shot: working out inthis lifekriyamana or agami: karma inthe makingon the bow: still in your hands
  • Sanchita (accumulated): the whole store of karma from past lives, not yet bearing fruit. Arrows in the quiver.
  • Prarabdha (fruit-bearing): the part of that store that has begun to work out in this life: body, family, lifespan. An arrow already shot: it cannot be called back.
  • Kriyamana or agami (karma in the making): karma made now by present acts. The arrow being fitted to the bow: still in your hands.
  • Liberation, on the common Vedanta account: knowledge burns sanchita, stops new kriyamana sticking; prarabdha runs its course until this body dies.
Mission 2

Realms and types of rebirth

Samsara cyclebirthlifedeathrebirthkarmathe subtle body carries karmagod (deva)humananimalplantheaven (svarga)hell (naraka)both temporarymoksha
  • Rebirth can be as a god (deva), a human, an animal, or an immovable form such as a plant (Katha 5:7). Tradition speaks of 8,400,000 forms of life.
  • Realms (lokas): heavenly worlds (svarga), the earth, and hell-worlds (naraka). Time in heaven or hell is temporary: when the karma is used up, the soul is born again.
  • Chandogya Upanishad V.10.7 (paraphrase): those of good conduct soon enter a good birth; those of bad conduct a low birth, even as an animal.
  • So neither heaven nor hell is the final goal. The goal is moksha: release from the whole cycle (see Mission 3).
  • Your spec: "types of reincarnation" and beliefs about the self, death and the afterlife.
Mission 2

Why a human birth matters

  • Animals and other beings mostly live out their karma; they do not choose with full moral awareness.
  • Humans can reflect, choose and act deliberately: they make new karma and can seek moksha.
  • So a human birth is precious and rare: an opportunity, not a reward to waste.
  • Gods also live out good karma in heaven, and must be reborn when it is spent.
Mission 2

Good karma still binds

Two chainsbad karma (iron)bindsgood karma (gold)binds toonishkam karmaaction without desire for itsfruit: it does not bind
  • Good deeds bring good results, but a good result is still a result: it ties the soul to more births, even in heaven. A golden chain still binds.
  • Sakam karma: action done with desire for its fruit (reward, praise, heaven). It binds.
  • Nishkam karma: action done without desire for its fruit, as duty or as offering to God. It does not bind.
  • Karma yoga: the path of selfless action; purifies the mind and leads towards liberation.
Mission 2Read the source

Krishna on action

Krishna teaches Arjuna (Arnold translation, 1885):

> "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them." (Gita 2:47, Arnold)

> "As the kindled flame / Feeds on the fuel till it sinks to ash, / So unto ash, Arjuna! unto nought / The flame of Knowledge wastes works' dross away!" (Gita 4:37, Arnold)

Q1 Does Krishna tell Arjuna to stop acting?

Show answer

No: act, but without craving the result.

Q2 What does knowledge do to karma in 4:37?

Show answer

Burns it up, as fire burns fuel to ash.

Mission 2Evaluate

Is karma fair?

Argument mapKarma is a just way of explaining why livesturn out differently.ForEveryone receives what their own actsproduce: no favourites, no randomness.It gives a reason to act well, and hope: thefuture is not fixed.AgainstNo one remembers past lives: is it just tosuffer for what you cannot recall?It can be misused to blame the poor, thesick or the disabled; many Hindus rejectthat use.If the past shapes my present, how freeam I? Response: prarabdha sets thesituation, not the choice.Judge it byDoes it fit experience? · Does it leave room forfree will? · Does it lead to compassion or toblame?
  • Claim: Karma is a just way of explaining why lives turn out differently.
  • For: Everyone receives what their own acts produce: no favourites, no randomness.
  • For: It gives a reason to act well, and hope: the future is not fixed.
  • Against: No one remembers past lives; can it be just to suffer for what you cannot recall?
  • Against: It can be misused to blame the poor, the sick or the disabled for their condition; many Hindus reject that use.
  • Against: If my present is shaped by the past, how free am I? Response: prarabdha sets the situation, not the choice.
  • Judgement criteria: Does it fit experience? Does it leave room for free will? Does it lead to compassion or to blame?
Mission check

?A Hindu teacher is revered as jivanmukta: liberated while still alive. Yet he falls ill and dies like anyone else. Followers ask why. Which answer fits the teaching on karma?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?

Make a guess: When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?

Mission 3

Moksha: release from the cycle

Exit from the wheelsamsarabirth, death, rebirthheaven: still insidekarmadesireignorancemoksha
  • Moksha means release or liberation: freedom from samsara, the cycle of birth, death and rebirth.
  • In Hindu teaching, what binds the self is karma, desire and avidya (ignorance of the true self).
  • Moksha is believed to end all three: no more rebirth, even in heaven.
  • It is the highest of the four aims of life, and for many Hindus the purpose of life itself.
  • Your spec: "the significance of moksha".
Mission 3

Free while still alive?

  • Jivanmukti: liberation while still in a body. Many traditions, especially Advaita, hold that the liberated live on until their fruit-bearing karma (prarabdha) runs out (see Mission 2).
  • The jivanmukta acts without selfish desire, is calm in pleasure and pain, and makes no new binding karma.
  • Videhamukti: liberation at death, when the body falls away.
  • Many theistic traditions see full liberation as coming after death, in God's presence.
Mission 3Diversity

What is moksha like?

What is moksha like?TraditionThe self in mokshaAdvaita(Shankara)atman is Brahman: likerivers entering the sea, noseparate selfVishishtadvaita(Ramanuja)the soul keeps its identity,serving God in VaikunthaDvaita (Madhva)eternally distinct anddependent; bliss in God'spresenceGaudiya(Chaitanya)loving service of Krishna(prema), valued even abovemokshaSamkhya andYogakaivalya: the self's"aloneness", freed frommatter
  • Advaita (Shankara): realising that atman is Brahman. Nothing new is gained: ignorance ends. Like rivers entering the sea, losing name and form (Mundaka Upanishad 3.2.8, paraphrase).
  • Vishishtadvaita (Ramanuja): the soul keeps its identity and enjoys God's bliss for ever, serving him in his realm (Vaikuntha).
  • Dvaita (Madhva): the soul is eternally distinct and dependent; liberated souls enjoy bliss in God's presence.
  • Gaudiya Vaishnavism (Chaitanya; ISKCON today): loving service of Krishna (prema) is the highest goal, valued even above moksha.
  • Classical Samkhya and Yoga: kaivalya, the self's "aloneness", freed from matter.
Quick check
?Which description of moksha would a follower of Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita give?
Mission 3

Many paths to one goal

Paths up one mountainmokshajnanaknowledgekarmaactionbhaktidevotionrajameditation
  • Jnana yoga (knowledge): study, reflection and meditation that remove ignorance. Suits the reflective. Central for Advaita.
  • Karma yoga (action): duty done without desire for its fruit (Gita 2:47). Suits the active.
  • Bhakti yoga (devotion): loving worship of a personal God. Suits the emotional; open to all, whatever their birth.
  • Raja yoga (meditation, after Patanjali) is often counted as a fourth path.
  • The Gita weaves the paths together; most Hindus follow more than one (detail in a later lesson).
Quick check
?Ravi spends an hour a day in meditation on the question "Who am I?", seeking to see that he is not the body or the mind. Which path is he following?
Mission check

?A Bengali devotional song says: "I want to taste sugar, not to become sugar." What view of the final goal does it express?
Mission 4

Mission 4: How can Hindus say God is beyond every word and also worship God with flowers in a temple?

Make a guess: How can Hindus say God is beyond every word and also worship God with flowers in a temple?

Mission 4

Brahman

Brahman, Brahma, BrahminBrahmanthe one ultimate realityBrahmathe creator godBrahminthe priestly varnaThree different words: not to be confused
  • Brahman: the one ultimate reality, the source and ground of everything. From a root meaning "to grow, expand": the "great" or "vast".
  • Not a god among gods: all gods, people and things depend on Brahman.
  • Both transcendent (beyond the world) and immanent (within it).
  • Isha Upanishad 1 (Paramananda translation, 1919): "All this, whatsoever exists in the universe, should be covered by the Lord."
  • Hindus hold two ways of seeing Brahman, often together: nirguna and saguna.
  • Not to be confused with Brahma (the creator god) or a Brahmin (priestly varna).
Mission 4

Nirguna and saguna

Water and icenirgunawithout qualitiesformlesssagunawith qualitiesformse.g. Vishnu, Shiva, theGoddessOne Brahmanone substance, formless or in formAn image often used: an analogy, not scripture
  • Guna: quality. Nir: without. Sa: with.
  • Nirguna Brahman: Brahman without qualities: beyond form, name, description and thought. Impersonal.
  • Saguna Brahman: Brahman with qualities: a personal God who loves, creates, protects and can be worshipped, e.g. as Vishnu, Shiva or the Goddess.
  • Many Hindus say these are not two Brahmans but one reality seen in two ways.
  • Schools differ: Advaita (non-dualist Vedanta, following Shankara) treats nirguna Brahman as the highest truth; Ramanuja, Madhva and many Vaishnavas hold that Brahman is always a personal God with qualities (for them "nirguna" means free of any bad quality).
  • An image often used: water and ice. The same substance, formless or in form.
Mission 4Read the source

Kena Upanishad 1:3–8

Kena Upanishad (Swami Paramananda's translation, 1919):

> "There the eye does not go, nor speech, nor mind. We do not know That; we do not understand how It can be taught." (1:3)

> "That which cannot be thought by mind, but by which, they say, mind is able to think: know that alone to be the Brahman, not this which people worship here." (1:5; 1:6 in most editions)

  • In this translation, verses 1:4–8 repeat the pattern for speech, mind, eye, ear and breath (1:5–9 in most editions).

Q1 Why can't the eye see Brahman?

Show answer

Brahman is what makes seeing possible; it is the "eye of the eye", not an object.

Q2 What does "not this which people worship here" mean?

Show answer

Any form people worship is not the whole of Brahman, which lies beyond every form.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes saguna Brahman?
Mission 4

Neti neti: not this, not this

Neti netiobjectsbodysensesmindBrahman (centre left blank)neti neti: "not this, not this" (BrihadaranyakaUpanishad)
  • The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (2.3.6, paraphrase) describes Brahman as "not this, not this" (neti neti); the sage Yajnavalkya repeats it (e.g. 4.4.22).
  • The via negativa: say what Brahman is not, since any positive word would limit it.
  • Not a body, not the senses, not the mind, not any object: every description falls short.
  • The same idea as Kena 1:3: "There the eye does not go, nor speech, nor mind."
  • Criticism: if nothing can be said, how can anyone know or love Brahman? Saguna answers this.
Quick check
?A Hindu student says: "Brahman is not a body, not a thought, not anything I can point to." Which idea is she expressing?
Mission 4

Why both matter: Brahman in deities, world and scripture

Where Brahman is metDeitiesforms of sagunaBrahmanImagesGod present in themurti (many Hindus)WorldBrahman pervades allthingsScripturethe Vedas: Brahmanin soundBrahman
  • Deities: for most Hindus, Vishnu, Shiva, the Goddess and others are forms of saguna Brahman. A worshipper may treat one as supreme (an ishta-devata, chosen deity).
  • Images: in a murti, many Hindus believe God is truly present, so it is bathed, dressed and offered food. Some Hindus (e.g. the Arya Samaj) reject image worship.
  • World: Brahman pervades all things (Isha 1), so rivers, cows and people can be honoured as sacred.
  • Scripture: the Vedas are seen as Brahman in sound (shabda-brahman); the syllable Om stands for Brahman: "This Word is indeed Brahman" (Katha 2:16, Paramananda).
  • Importance: saguna Brahman makes bhakti possible; nirguna Brahman is the goal of jnana and meditation. Many Hindus worship forms while believing Brahman is beyond them.
Mission 4

Lipner and Sivananda

  • Julius Lipner (b. 1946), Hindus: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices (1994; 2nd edn 2010), paraphrase:
  • Hinduism is polycentric: many centres of divine focus, each of which a worshipper may treat as supreme, without denying the others.
  • So "polytheism" misdescribes it: the many deities are ways in which the one divine makes itself available to people.
  • Swami Sivananda (1887–1963;), e.g. All About Hinduism (1947), paraphrase:
  • Brahman is one, called by many names; the forms of God are real aids for the mind, which cannot hold the formless at first.
  • Worship of forms leads on towards knowledge of the formless: saguna and nirguna are steps on one path.
Mission 4Diversity

What kind of belief in God?

Labels for beliefLabelMeaningFits / noteMonismonly onereality; worldand selves notseparate fromBrahmanAdvaitaMonotheismone personalGod, supremeover allmanyVaishnavas,Shaivas,ShaktasHenotheismone godworshipped assupreme,others notdeniedVedic hymns(term madepopular byMax Müller)Polytheismmany godshow someoutsidersdescribe it;many Hindusreject thislabelPanentheismall is in God,but God ismore than alloften used ofRamanujaHindus disagree: different labels fit differentschools and practices
  • Monism: only one reality; the world and selves are not separate from Brahman (Advaita).
  • Monotheism: one personal God, supreme over all (many Vaishnavas, Shaivas, Shaktas).
  • Henotheism: worshipping one god as supreme without denying others (a term made popular by Max Müller, applied to Vedic hymns).
  • Polytheism: many gods; how some outsiders describe Hindu worship; many Hindus reject this label.
  • Panentheism: all is in God, but God is more than all (often used of Ramanuja).
  • Hindus disagree among themselves; different labels fit different schools and practices.
Mission 4Evaluate

Is Hinduism monotheistic?

Is Hinduism monotheistic?Hinduism is best understood asmonotheistic.ForAll deities are forms of one Brahman (RigVeda 1.164.46: the wise call the one bymany names).Many devotees treat one God as supreme(Lipner's polycentrism).AgainstAdvaita's nirguna Brahman is not apersonal God: that is monism, notmonotheism.In village and family practice, many deitiesare worshipped side by side, close topolytheism in practice.Judge it byWhich school? · Belief or practice? · DoWestern categories fit Hinduism at all?
  • Claim: Hinduism is best understood as monotheistic.
  • For: All deities are forms of one Brahman (Rig Veda 1.164.46, paraphrase: the wise call the one by many names).
  • For: Many devotees treat one God as supreme (Lipner's polycentrism).
  • Against: Advaita's nirguna Brahman is not a personal God: that is monism, not monotheism.
  • Against: In village and family practice, many deities are worshipped side by side for different needs, close to polytheism in practice.
  • Judgement criteria: Which school? Belief or practice? Do Western categories fit Hinduism at all?
Mission check

?Anil, a Hindu, offers flowers to a murti of Krishna each morning. In the evening he meditates silently, trying to let go of every image and thought. A friend says he is being inconsistent. Which reply best fits widely held Hindu belief?
Mission 5

Mission 5: If the universe is made, kept and destroyed again and again, who does each job, and is it one God?

Make a guess: If the universe is made, kept and destroyed again and again, who does each job, and is it one God?

Mission 5

One reality, three functions

The Trimurti cyclesagunaBrahmanBrahmacreatesVishnupreservesShivadestroys
  • Trimurti: "three forms". Three functions of saguna Brahman (God with qualities):
  • Brahma: creator. Vishnu: preserver (sustainer). Shiva: destroyer (and transformer).
  • The three work as a cycle: what is created is sustained, then dissolved, then created again.
  • For many Hindus they are not three separate gods competing but three faces of the one divine power behind the universe.
  • In Hindu belief time is a wheel, not a straight line: the cycle repeats over vast ages. One "day of Brahma" is traditionally 4.32 billion years, and an equal night follows.
  • The idea appears in later texts such as the Maitri Upanishad and the Puranas, more than in the Vedas.
  • A clear case of Brahman "represented in deities".
Mission 5

Brahma, the creator

Symbols of the TrimurtiBrahma: creatorfour heads (four directions) · water pot, prayerbeads, Vedas · swan (hamsa) · partnerSaraswatiVishnu: preserverconch, discus, mace, lotus · serpent Ananta ·eagle Garuda · partner LakshmiShiva: destroyertrident, crescent moon, Ganga in his hair ·lingam · bull Nandi · partner ParvatiNataraja, "lord of the dance"ring of firedrum:creationflame:destructionraised hand:protectionfoot on adwarf:ignorance
  • Hindus believe Brahma creates the universe at the start of each cycle and is the source of the Vedas.
  • Often shown with four heads (facing the four directions, linked with the four Vedas), sitting on a lotus.
  • Holds a water pot, prayer beads and a book; his partner is Saraswati, goddess of learning; his vehicle a swan (hamsa).
  • In Vaishnava stories he is born from a lotus growing from Vishnu's navel.
  • Today he is rarely worshipped: very few temples (the best known at Pushkar, Rajasthan).
  • Puranic stories explain this; another reason often given: creation is complete for this cycle, so devotion turns to the God who sustains and saves.
Mission 5

Vishnu, the preserver

Symbols of the TrimurtiBrahma: creatorfour heads (four directions) · water pot, prayerbeads, Vedas · swan (hamsa) · partnerSaraswatiVishnu: preserverconch, discus, mace, lotus · serpent Ananta ·eagle Garuda · partner LakshmiShiva: destroyertrident, crescent moon, Ganga in his hair ·lingam · bull Nandi · partner ParvatiNataraja, "lord of the dance"ring of firedrum:creationflame:destructionraised hand:protectionfoot on adwarf:ignorance
  • In Hindu belief Vishnu sustains the universe and protects dharma (right order).
  • Shown with four arms holding a conch (shankha), a discus (chakra), a mace (gada) and a lotus (padma); often blue-skinned.
  • Rests on the serpent Ananta (Shesha) on the cosmic ocean between cycles.
  • Partner: Lakshmi, goddess of good fortune; vehicle: the eagle Garuda.
  • Comes down as an avatar when dharma declines: e.g. Rama and Krishna (see Mission 6).
  • For Vaishnavas, Vishnu is the Supreme God, not only one of three.
Mission 5

Shiva, the destroyer

Symbols of the TrimurtiBrahma: creatorfour heads (four directions) · water pot, prayerbeads, Vedas · swan (hamsa) · partnerSaraswatiVishnu: preserverconch, discus, mace, lotus · serpent Ananta ·eagle Garuda · partner LakshmiShiva: destroyertrident, crescent moon, Ganga in his hair ·lingam · bull Nandi · partner ParvatiNataraja, "lord of the dance"ring of firedrum:creationflame:destructionraised hand:protectionfoot on adwarf:ignorance
  • In Hindu belief Shiva dissolves the universe at the end of each cycle, so that it can be renewed: destruction as transformation.
  • Also destroys ignorance and ego: a great yogi, meditating on Mount Kailash.
  • Nataraja, "lord of the dance": dancing in a ring of fire; drum (creation), flame (destruction), raised hand (protection), foot on a dwarf (ignorance).
  • Other symbols: trident, third eye, crescent moon, the River Ganga in his hair; worshipped often as the lingam.
  • Partner: Parvati; vehicle: the bull Nandi.
  • For Shaivas, Shiva is the Supreme God who performs all cosmic acts.
Quick check
?Which pairing of deity and role is correct?
Mission 5

Many deities, one Brahman

One and manyGaneshaHanumanLakshmiSaraswatiMuruganDurgaForms or aspects of the one Brahman, not rivalgods (most Hindus)
  • Hindus worship many deities: Ganesha, Hanuman, Lakshmi, Saraswati, Murugan, Durga and more.
  • For most Hindus these are forms or aspects of the one Brahman, not rival gods.
  • In the Gita (11:15), Arjuna sees within Krishna's universal form "Brahma, sitting lone / Upon His lotus-throne" (Arnold): the gods are all contained in the one.
  • Ishta-devata: a person's chosen deity, worshipped as supreme for them.
  • Lipner (Hindus, 1994/2010, paraphrase): Hindu worship is polycentric: each deity can be a centre of supreme devotion without denying the others.
  • Sivananda (All About Hinduism, 1947, paraphrase): one God appears in many forms to suit worshippers' natures; the forms are aids to reach the one.
Quick check
?Which statement best expresses how many Hindus relate the many deities to Brahman?
Mission check

?Ravi, a Shaiva, says: "Shiva creates, keeps and dissolves the world." His friend Kiran, a Vaishnava, says: "Vishnu sustains all, and Brahma was born from his navel." Both accept the Trimurti. Which statement best explains how?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Why would God come down to earth as a prince in exile, or a cowherd who steals butter?

Make a guess: Why would God come down to earth as a prince in exile, or a cowherd who steals butter?

Mission 6

Avatar: a descent

Avatar: descentVishnudescentthe worldavatar: freely, torestore dharmabirthdeathrebirthreincarnationrebirth: driven bykarma
  • Avatar (Sanskrit avatara): "descent", a "crossing down".
  • God, especially Vishnu, the preserver (see Mission 5), comes into the world in a form.
  • Why: to restore dharma when it declines, protect the good and remove evil.
  • Not a reincarnation: an avatar is not driven by karma; God descends freely, out of compassion.
  • Most Vaishnavas believe the avatar is fully divine, not a human who became holy.
  • Context: Vishnu sustains the cosmic order; as dharma decays through the yugas, he descends when needed.
Mission 6Read the source

"from age to age"

Bhagavad Gita 4:7–8 (Edwin Arnold's verse translation, 1885), Krishna speaks:

> "When Righteousness

> Declines, O Bharata! when Wickedness

> Is strong, I rise, from age to age, and take

> Visible shape, and move a man with men,"

  • 4:8 continues: "Succouring the good, thrusting the evil back, / And setting Virtue on her seat again."

Q1 What does "from age to age" suggest about how often avatars come?

Show answer

Again and again, in each cosmic age, whenever dharma declines.

Q2 What does "move a man with men" tell us?

Show answer

God lives among people in a human form: close enough to be known and loved.

Mission 6

The ten avatars

The ten avatars1Matsyafish2Kurmatortoise3Varahaboar4Narasimhaman-lion5Vamanadwarf6Parashuramaaxe7Ramabow8Krishnaflute9/the Buddhaor Balaramalotus / plough10Kalkiyet to comeLists vary: the Bhagavata Purana gives morethan twentyRama: Treta YugaKrishna: end of the Dvapara YugaKalki: yet to come, end of the Kali Yuga
  • A common list, the dashavatara: Matsya (fish), Kurma (tortoise), Varaha (boar), Narasimha (man-lion), Vamana (dwarf), Parashurama, Rama, Krishna, the Buddha or Balarama, Kalki (yet to come, at the end of the Kali Yuga).
  • Placed in the yugas: Rama in the Treta Yuga; Krishna at the end of the Dvapara Yuga.
  • Lists vary: the Bhagavata Purana gives more than twenty avatars and says they are "innumerable".
  • Some see a pattern from sea creatures to humans; most Hindus read the list as divine rescue, not as a theory of evolution.
Quick check
?How does an avatar differ from an ordinary reincarnation, according to Vaishnava belief?
Mission 6

Rama: the account

Ramayana routeAyodhyaLanka14 yearsof exile inthe forestTraditional locations; route stylised
  • Prince Rama of Ayodhya, eldest son of King Dasharatha; seventh avatar of Vishnu (Valmiki's Ramayana;).
  • Exiled for 14 years to keep his father's promise to Queen Kaikeyi; Sita and Lakshmana go with him.
  • The demon-king Ravana abducts Sita; with Hanuman and the monkey army, Rama defeats Ravana in Lanka.
  • Rama returns to rule: Rama-rajya, the ideal just kingdom; celebrated at Diwali and Rama Navami.
  • Retold in Tulsidas's Ramcharitmanas (16th century), where Rama is clearly God, and in Ramlila plays.
  • Devotees repeat his name, Ram, as a mantra.
Mission 6

Rama: the ideal man and many dharmas

Rama's dharmassonputra dharma: keepshis father's wordbrotherloyal to Lakshmanaand Bharatahusbandpati dharma: rescuesSitakingraja dharma: rules forthe people's goodclash of dharmas: as king, he sends Sita away
  • Maryada purushottama: "the best of men, who keeps the limits".
  • Son (putra dharma): accepts exile at once to keep his father's word.
  • Brother: loyalty to Lakshmana and Bharata, who rules only as his regent.
  • Husband (pati dharma): crosses the ocean and fights a war to rescue Sita.
  • King (raja dharma): rules for the people's good, even at personal cost.
  • Clash of dharmas: hearing his people doubt Sita's purity, Rama, as king, sends her away. Many Hindus find this deeply painful; some say the later book (Uttara Kanda) is an addition; others see the sacrifice of a king's private happiness.
  • Other debated episodes: killing Vali from hiding; the punishment of the Shudra ascetic Shambuka (Uttara Kanda).
Mission 6

Krishna

Krishna's lifeChildVrindavan: steals butter;lifts Mount GovardhanYouthplays the flute; the gopisand RadhaAdultking of Dwarka; teachesArjuna the Gita
  • Eighth avatar of Vishnu; for many Vaishnavas the Supreme God himself.
  • Born in Mathura in a prison; raised among cowherds in Vrindavan by Yashoda and Nanda.
  • Stories of the child: stealing butter, defeating the serpent Kaliya, lifting Mount Govardhan to shelter the villagers.
  • The youth: playing the flute; dancing with the gopis (cowherd women), especially Radha: a picture of the soul's love for God.
  • The adult: king of Dwarka; guide of the Pandavas; teacher of the Gita to Arjuna.
  • Sources: the Mahabharata, the Harivamsha, and the Bhagavata Purana (book 10). Festival: Janmashtami.
Mission 6

Krishna and the bhakti movements

Bhakti timelinec. 6th–9th c.Alvars: Tamil poet-saints,songs to Vishnuc. 9th–10th c.Bhagavata Purana:Krishna's life as divine love12th c.Jayadeva, Gita Govinda:Radha and Krishna1479–1531Vallabha: devotion to thechild Krishna1486–1534Chaitanya, Bengal:Gaudiya Vaishnavism,sankirtan16th c.Mirabai: Krishna as heronly husband16th c.Surdas: blind poet ofKrishna's childhood1966ISKCON founded in NewYork by Prabhupada1973Bhaktivedanta Manor,Hertfordshire
  • Bhakti: loving devotion to a personal God, open to all castes and to women.
  • Alvars (Tamil poet-saints, c. 6th–9th centuries): ecstatic songs to Vishnu.
  • Bhagavata Purana (c. 9th–10th century): Krishna's life as the model of divine love.
  • Jayadeva, Gita Govinda (12th century): songs of Radha and Krishna.
  • Chaitanya Mahaprabhu (1486–1534), Bengal: Gaudiya Vaishnavism; ecstatic group chanting (sankirtan); Krishna as the Supreme Lord, Radha his divine energy.
  • Vallabha (1479–1531): devotion to the child Krishna. Mirabai (16th century), Rajput princess-poet: Krishna as her only husband. Surdas (16th century): blind poet of Krishna's childhood.
  • So Krishna is often seen as the heart of the bhakti movements.
Mission 6

ISKCON

Bhakti timelinec. 6th–9th c.Alvars: Tamil poet-saints,songs to Vishnuc. 9th–10th c.Bhagavata Purana:Krishna's life as divine love12th c.Jayadeva, Gita Govinda:Radha and Krishna1479–1531Vallabha: devotion to thechild Krishna1486–1534Chaitanya, Bengal:Gaudiya Vaishnavism,sankirtan16th c.Mirabai: Krishna as heronly husband16th c.Surdas: blind poet ofKrishna's childhood1966ISKCON founded in NewYork by Prabhupada1973Bhaktivedanta Manor,Hertfordshire
  • International Society for Krishna Consciousness: founded in New York, 1966, by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada (1896–1977).
  • Stands in Chaitanya's Gaudiya lineage: Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead; Vishnu and the other avatars come from him.
  • Practice: chanting the Hare Krishna mantra on beads (16 rounds daily for initiates); temple worship; distributing sanctified food (prasadam); books such as Bhagavad-gita As It Is.
  • Four regulative principles: no meat, fish or eggs; no intoxicants; no gambling; no sex outside marriage.
  • In Britain: Bhaktivedanta Manor (Hertfordshire), given by George Harrison in 1973.
  • Many Hindus welcome it as authentic Gaudiya Vaishnavism; some see it as a Western movement or disagree with its ranking of Krishna above Vishnu.
Quick check
?Which belief is distinctive of Gaudiya Vaishnavism and ISKCON?
Mission 6

Lipner and Sivananda on avatars

  • J Lipner (Hindus, 1994/2010), paraphrase:
  • "Avatar" means a crossing down: the transcendent God comes within reach of human beings.
  • The idea answers a need: a God beyond the world becomes someone who can be seen, loved and imitated.
  • Avatars take many forms because God acts to meet the needs of each age.
  • S Sivananda (1887–1963), paraphrase:
  • Avatars come to restore dharma and to give devotees a form to love; meditating on Rama or Krishna and repeating the divine name purifies the mind.
  • Rama's life teaches duty; Krishna's teaches love and selfless action; both lead the devotee beyond forms to the one Brahman.
Mission 6Evaluate

Is Krishna the ideal avatar?

Is Krishna the ideal avatar?Krishna, rather than Rama, is the idealavatar.ForMany call Krishna the full (purna) avatar;the Bhagavata Purana calls him Godhimself.He gives the Gita's teaching on all threepaths and inspires the widest bhaktimovements, worldwide through ISKCON.AgainstRama is the model of dharma in every role;Krishna's tactics in the war trouble somereaders.Rama-bhakti is huge too: Tulsidas, theRamanandis, Hanuman's devotion.Many Hindus say avatars are not ranked:each fits the needs of its age.Judge it byIdeal for what: moral example or object oflove? · Which tradition's view? · Can God'sacts be judged by human morality?
  • Claim: Krishna, rather than Rama, is the ideal avatar.
  • For: Many call Krishna the full (purna) avatar; the Bhagavata Purana calls him God himself.
  • For: He gives the Gita's teaching on all three paths, and inspires the widest bhakti movements, worldwide through ISKCON.
  • Against: Rama is the model of dharma in every role; Krishna's tactics in the war (e.g. urging a half-truth to defeat Drona) trouble some readers.
  • Against: Rama-bhakti is huge too: Tulsidas, the Ramanandis, Hanuman's devotion; "Ram" is the name on many Hindus' lips at death.
  • Against: Many Hindus say avatars are not ranked: each fits the needs of its age.
  • Judgement criteria: Ideal for what: moral example or object of love? Which tradition's view? Can God's acts be judged by human morality?
Mission check

?A newspaper calls a firefighter who rescued children "an avatar of courage". A Vaishnava Hindu says the word has lost its religious meaning. What is missing from the newspaper's use?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Dharma (from dhr, "uphold"): the order that sustains the cosmos, society and the person; the successor to Vedic rta.
  • Sanatana dharma: the eternal way (a name for the religion) and the universal duties of all; svadharma: duties of one's own class and stage of life.
  • Bilimoria: rta → dharma, karma across lives, ahimsa; the Gita's answer is desireless duty.

Mission 2

  • Karma: action and its fitting results, a law within the universal order; samsara: rebirth driven by karma, desire and ignorance (Gita 2:13; Katha 5:7).
  • Three kinds: accumulated (sanchita), fruit-bearing (prarabdha), karma in the making (kriyamana/agami).
  • Human birth is the chance to act freely and seek moksha; selfless action (nishkam karma, karma yoga) does not bind (Gita 2:47).

Mission 3

  • Moksha: release from samsara by ending karma, desire and ignorance; jivanmukti is liberation while alive.
  • Advaita: realising identity with Brahman; theistic traditions: eternal loving relationship with God.

Mission 4

  • Brahman is the one ultimate reality: nirguna (without qualities, beyond words) and saguna (with qualities, a personal God).
  • Kena 1:3–8: Brahman is what makes speech, mind and senses work, "not this which people worship here"; neti neti: not this, not this.
  • Brahman is represented in deities, the world and scripture; Lipner calls Hinduism polycentric; Sivananda sees forms as steps to the formless.

Mission 5

  • In Hindu belief the Trimurti is three functions of saguna Brahman: Brahma creates, Vishnu preserves, Shiva destroys (and renews).
  • Many deities, one Brahman; Vaishnavas, Shaivas and Shaktas each see their deity as supreme over the three.
  • Lipner: polycentric worship; Sivananda: many forms as aids to reach the one.

Mission 6

  • An avatar is a free descent of God, especially Vishnu, to restore dharma "from age to age" (Gita 4:7–8).
  • Rama is the ideal man, keeping dharma as son, brother, husband and king, though his choices, such as sending Sita away, are debated.
  • Krishna is loved as child, lover and teacher; for many he is God himself.
  • Krishna is at the heart of bhakti movements (Alvars, Chaitanya, Mirabai) and ISKCON; Lipner and Sivananda show why God in a form matters.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: Religious beliefs, values and teachings (part 1) for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?
  2. Mission 2If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?
  3. Mission 3When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?
  4. Mission 4How can Hindus say God is beyond every word and also worship God with flowers in a temple?
  5. Mission 5If the universe is made, kept and destroyed again and again, who does each job, and is it one God?
  6. Mission 6Why would God come down to earth as a prince in exile, or a cowherd who steals butter?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel