← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Exam skills
Mini-Lesson

Exam skills

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Two students know the same facts. Why does one score far higher on an "explain" question?
  2. Mission 2Two students reach opposite conclusions and both get top marks. How is that possible?
  3. Mission 3The exam prints a philosopher's argument in front of you. How do you take it apart in about 45 minutes?
  4. Mission 4Why do the highest marks go to answers that reach beyond the topic in the question?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Two students know the same facts. Why does one score far higher on an "explain" question?

Make a guess: Two students know the same facts. Why does one score far higher on an "explain" question?

Mission 1

What AO1 rewards

What AO1 rewards: four strandsAO1knowledge and understanding of religion andbeliefThought andteachingreligious,philosophical andethical ideasInfluenceon individuals,communities andsocietiesSimilarities anddifferencestheir causes andsignificanceApproachesto the study ofreligion and beliefselectexplainsupport
  • AO1: knowledge and understanding of religion and belief.
  • Every board uses the same four strands:
  • Thought and teaching: religious, philosophical and ethical ideas.
  • Influence: how beliefs shape individuals, communities and societies.
  • Similarities and differences: their causes and significance.
  • Approaches to the study of religion and belief.
  • AO1 is not "write all you know". It is select, explain, support.
Mission 1

Your AO1 tasks

Your AO1 tasks: EdexcelEdexcel · AO1 command wordsExplore8 marks · AO1Clarify (anthology extract)10 marks · AO1
  • Explore (8 marks, AO1): "investigating different reasons, concepts and ideas".
  • Clarify (10 marks, AO1): "identify key ideas and explain key concepts". Used on the printed anthology extract (see Mission 3).
  • Specialist language is assessed through how you select and use it.
Mission 1

Select: answer this question, not the topic

Select: answer this question, not the topicEverything you knowabout evilFocus: Hick'ssoul-making theodicy3–4 points on Hickaccuratebutoff-focus
  • Underline the focus: whose view? which aspect? which part of the topic?
  • "Examine Hick's soul-making theodicy" is not "write about the problem of evil".
  • Choose 3–4 main points that answer it fully; drop the rest.
  • Watch small words: "different views", "two ways", "the influence of", "compare".
  • Material that is accurate but off-focus earns little or nothing.
Quick check
?The question is "Examine Hick's soul-making theodicy." Which material is most relevant?
Mission 1

Develop each point

Develop each pointPointHick builds on Irenaeus: image → likenessExplain: what does it mean?freely developed goodness is worth morethan goodness simply givenSupport: scholar, text, exampleEvil and the God of Love (1966): a "vale ofsoul-making" (Keats' phrase)Significance: why does it matter?so God creates at an epistemic distance
  • A point alone is identification. Marks come from development.
  • Point → explain it (what does it mean?) → support it (scholar, text, example) → significance (why does it matter to the belief or to believers?).
  • Two well-developed points beat six bare ones.
  • Use connectives that show understanding: "because", "this means", "so", "which is why".
Mission 1

Scholars, sources and terms

Develop each pointPointHick builds on Irenaeus: image → likenessExplain: what does it mean?freely developed goodness is worth morethan goodness simply givenSupport: scholar, text, exampleEvil and the God of Love (1966): a "vale ofsoul-making" (Keats' phrase)Significance: why does it matter?so God creates at an epistemic distance
  • Name the scholar and the idea: "Hick (Evil and the God of Love, 1966) argues…", not just "Hick says evil is good".
  • Paraphrase accurately; quote only short phrases you are sure of.
  • Use sources of wisdom and authority where relevant: scripture with reference, a council, a creed.
  • Specialist terms, used correctly and explained once: e.g. "epistemic distance", "theodicy", "eschatological".
  • Show difference within traditions where the question allows (e.g. Catholic and Protestant; Sunni and Shi'a).
Mission 1Read the source

What a top AO1 answer shows

CCEA's A2 grade descriptions (spec section 5) say that at grade A, for AO1, candidates characteristically:

  • "address the question specifically"
  • "use extensive relevant evidence, examples and scholarship"
  • "use an extensive range of technical language and vocabulary"
  • Eduqas' top-band AO1 descriptor uses similar words: thorough, accurate, relevant knowledge, with an extensive range of scholarly views (paraphrase).

Q1 Which phrase rewards selection rather than quantity?

Show answer

"address the question specifically"; "relevant".

Q2 Name one thing both descriptors reward besides knowledge.

Show answer

Scholarship or scholarly views; also accurate technical language.

Mission 1Worked answer

One developed AO1 paragraph

One developed AO1 paragraph: Examine Hick's soul-making theodicyExamine Hick's soul-making theodicy.PHick (1922–2012) builds on Irenaeus(c. 130–c. 202): humans are made inGod's image but must grow into hislikeness.EGoodness that is freely developed isworth more than goodness simplygiven.SIn Evil and the God of Love (1966),Hick says the world is a "vale ofsoul-making" (a phrase he takes fromKeats), where challenges and sufferingmake growth possible.SigSo God creates at an epistemicdistance: not obvious, so humans canfreely choose to love him.

Question: Examine Hick's soul-making theodicy.

  • Point: Hick (1922–2012) builds on Irenaeus (c. 130–c. 202): humans are made in God's image but must grow into his likeness.
  • Explain: goodness that is freely developed is worth more than goodness simply given.
  • Support: in Evil and the God of Love (1966), Hick says the world is a "vale of soul-making" (a phrase he takes from Keats), where challenges and suffering make growth possible.
  • Significance: so God creates at an epistemic distance: not obvious, so humans can freely choose to love him.
Quick check
?Which addition would gain the least credit in an AO1 answer?
Mission 1

Common faults

Select: answer this question, not the topicEverything you knowabout evilFocus: Hick'ssoul-making theodicy3–4 points on Hickaccuratebutoff-focus
  • Narrative: telling a story (a scholar's life; a parable retold) without explaining its point.
  • Listing: many names or terms, none explained.
  • Generalising: "Christians believe…" where traditions differ.
  • Name-dropping: a scholar's name with no idea attached, or the wrong idea attached.
  • Drifting into evaluation: "This is a weak argument because…" in an AO1 part.
  • Long introductions: start answering in the first sentence.
Mission 1

Similarities, differences and influence

Develop each pointPointHick builds on Irenaeus: image → likenessExplain: what does it mean?freely developed goodness is worth morethan goodness simply givenSupport: scholar, text, exampleEvil and the God of Love (1966): a "vale ofsoul-making" (Keats' phrase)Significance: why does it matter?so God creates at an epistemic distance
  • If a question says compare or different views: set ideas side by side and say why they differ (different sources, different starting points, different contexts).
  • If it says influence: show the belief changing something: worship, ethics, community life, law.
  • These strands are named in every board's AO1, so they can be asked directly.
  • E.g. Augustine and Hick both defend God's goodness, but Augustine looks back to the Fall; Hick looks forward to growth.
Quick check
?A student writes: "Hick says humans are at an epistemic distance from God." Which next sentence develops this point best?
Mission check

?Question: "Explain Bentham's hedonic calculus." Which opening shows the strongest AO1 approach?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Two students reach opposite conclusions and both get top marks. How is that possible?

Make a guess: Two students reach opposite conclusions and both get top marks. How is that possible?

Mission 2

What AO2 rewards

What AO2 rewards: analyse and evaluateAnalysebreak apartconnectspot assumptionsEvaluateweighjudgejustifyMarks reward the quality of reasoning, notAO2: the larger share of the A-levelAQA, Edexcel, Eduqas: 60% · CCEA: 56%
  • AO2: analyse and evaluate aspects of, and approaches to, religion and belief, including their significance, influence and study.
  • Analyse: break an issue into parts; see how they connect; spot assumptions.
  • Evaluate: weigh arguments and reach a judgement you can justify.
  • Marks reward the quality of reasoning, not which side you take.
  • Across the full A-level, AO2 is the larger share: 60% on AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas; 56% on CCEA (AS units split evenly).
Mission 2

Your AO2 tasks

Your AO2 tasks: EdexcelEdexcel · AO2 command wordsAssess (12)48 AO2Analyse (20)515 AO2Evaluate (30)525 AO2AO1AO2
  • Assess (12): 4 AO1 + 8 AO2. "Reasoned argument of factors to reach a judgement."
  • Analyse (20): 5 AO1 + 15 AO2. Used on the anthology extract (see Mission 3): connections and "logical chains of reasoning".
  • Evaluate (30): 5 AO1 + 25 AO2. The Section C essay (see Mission 4): "a supported judgement".
  • Each mixes a little AO1 into a mainly AO2 task: knowledge serves the argument.
Mission 2

Read the statement first

Read the statement first: strength words"Xisthemostconvincingview:itprovesitscase.""most"needs a comparisonwith other views"proves"a high bar: is "makesprobable" enough?Also watch: only · fully · fails · irrelevant
  • Underline the key terms and decide what they mean before you argue.
  • Strength words: "most", "only", "fully", "fails", "proves", "irrelevant". They decide what you must show.
  • "The most convincing" requires a comparison with other views.
  • "Proves" sets a high bar: is "makes probable" enough?
  • Define terms in the introduction; return to them in the conclusion.
Quick check
?"Hick's theodicy is the most convincing response to the problem of evil." Evaluate this view. What does the word "most" require?
Mission 2

A line of argument

An evaluative paragraph, rung by rungPointa reason for your thesisCounterthe strongest opposing viewResponseis it valid? does it prove less than it claims?Weighwhich carries more weight, and why?Mini-judgementlink back: "This shows that…"
  • State your thesis early: a one-sentence answer to the question.
  • Each paragraph argues, not just reports: a reason for your thesis, or a challenge you then answer.
  • End each paragraph with a mini-judgement that links back: "This shows that…".
  • Your conclusion should follow from the paragraphs; no new arguments at the end.
Mission 2

Counter-arguments and responses

An evaluative paragraph, rung by rungPointa reason for your thesisCounterthe strongest opposing viewResponseis it valid? does it prove less than it claims?Weighwhich carries more weight, and why?Mini-judgementlink back: "This shows that…"
  • Give the strongest form of the opposing view, not a weak one ("steel-man", not "straw-man").
  • Then respond: Is it valid? Is it based on a false assumption? Does it prove less than it claims?
  • Use scholars as voices in a debate: "Phillips objects that…; Hick could reply that…".
  • Avoid "Some people think… Others think…" lists that never weigh anything.
Mission 2Evaluate

Two justified judgements

Two justified judgements from one argument map"Hick's theodicy successfully defends thegoodness of God."ForFreely chosen goodness needs realchallenge; Irenaeus gives a long traditionAgainstPhillips: a loving God would not usesuffering such as the Holocaust as ameans; much suffering destroys peopleJudge it byCan a good end justify such means? Does anafterlife hope answer the problem, or dependon what cannot be shown?Student 1succeeds, if hiseschatology isacceptedStudent 2fails, because themeans areunjustifiabletop band possibletop band possible
  • Claim: "Hick's theodicy successfully defends the goodness of God."
  • For: Freely chosen goodness needs a world with real challenge; Irenaeus' image-to-likeness gives a long tradition behind it.
  • Against: D. Z. Phillips: a loving God would not use suffering such as the Holocaust as a means to growth (paraphrase); much suffering destroys rather than builds people.
  • Criteria: Can a good end justify such means? Does an afterlife hope (Hick's eschatology) answer the problem, or depend on what cannot be shown?
  • Student 1 judges that Hick succeeds, if his eschatology is accepted. Student 2 judges that he fails, because the means are unjustifiable. Both can reach the top band.
Mission 2

Making the judgement

Two justified judgements from one argument map"Hick's theodicy successfully defends thegoodness of God."ForFreely chosen goodness needs realchallenge; Irenaeus gives a long traditionAgainstPhillips: a loving God would not usesuffering such as the Holocaust as ameans; much suffering destroys peopleJudge it byCan a good end justify such means? Does anafterlife hope answer the problem, or dependon what cannot be shown?Student 1succeeds, if hiseschatology isacceptedStudent 2fails, because themeans areunjustifiabletop band possibletop band possible
  • A judgement can be qualified: "succeeds only if…", "succeeds for moral evil but not for natural evil".
  • It must be justified: name the criterion that decided it.
  • It must be consistent with your paragraphs.
  • Sitting on the fence ("both sides have good points") is not a judgement; a reasoned partial agreement is.
  • Avoid "I believe" without reasons; personal insight means your reasoning, not your preference.
Quick check
?Which sentence is evaluation rather than description?
Mission 2Worked answer

One evaluative paragraph

An evaluative paragraph, rung by rungPointa reason for your thesisCounterthe strongest opposing viewResponseis it valid? does it prove less than it claims?Weighwhich carries more weight, and why?Mini-judgementlink back: "This shows that…"

Statement: "Hick's theodicy successfully defends the goodness of God."

  • Point: Hick's strongest case concerns moral evil: growth needs real choices with real consequences.
  • Counter: But Phillips argues that a loving God would not use suffering such as the Holocaust as a means to anyone's growth.
  • Response: Hick could reply that the world needs real, not token, danger, and that growth is completed after death.
  • Weigh: That reply depends on an eschatology that cannot be verified, so it convinces those who already accept it more than it answers the critic.
  • Mini-judgement: So Hick defends God's goodness only if his afterlife hope is granted.
Quick check
?A student argues in every paragraph that the design argument is weak, then concludes: "Overall, the design argument is convincing." What is the main problem?
Mission check

?"Situation ethics is too vague to guide moral decisions." Evaluate this view. Which plan shows the strongest AO2 approach?
Mission 3

Mission 3: The exam prints a philosopher's argument in front of you. How do you take it apart in about 45 minutes?

Make a guess: The exam prints a philosopher's argument in front of you. How do you take it apart in about 45 minutes?

Mission 3

Section B: what you get

Section B: a printed excerpt, two partsExcerpt printed inthe paperyou don't bring the anthology(a) Clarify10 marks · AO1(b) Analyse20 marks · 5 AO1 +15 AO2≈ 45–50 min for the sectionsuggested
  • Each paper's Section B: one two-part question on an excerpt from the A Level Religious Studies Anthology.
  • The excerpt is printed in the paper; you don't bring the anthology.
  • Part (a), Clarify (10 marks, AO1): "identify key ideas and explain key concepts".
  • Part (b), Analyse (20 marks: 5 AO1, 15 AO2): connections and "logical chains of reasoning" leading to judgements about importance.
  • Extracts are not tied to one topic: Mackie may be used for any suitable topic.
  • About 45–50 minutes for the section.
Mission 3

Locating the argument

Mark up the excerpt before you writeT1K23O→Tthesis: what is the author trying toshow?1-2-3steps: premises and moves, numberedKkey terms: words used in a special wayOobjections the author answers→target: whose view is attacked?
  • Before writing, mark up the excerpt:
  • Thesis: what is the author trying to show? (Often near the start or end.)
  • Steps: the premises and moves that lead there. Number them.
  • Key terms: words the author defines or uses in a special way.
  • Objections the author answers, and how.
  • Target: whose view is being attacked?
  • Then decide: which 3–4 ideas does this question need?
Mission 3Read the source

Mackie, "Evil and Omnipotence" (Extract 1, paraphrase)

J. L. Mackie (1917–1981), Mind (1955); in B. Mitchell (ed.), The Philosophy of Religion (OUP), ch. 5.

  • The problem of evil is a logical problem, not a scientific one: it asks whether beliefs are consistent, not what the evidence shows.
  • Three propositions: God is omnipotent; God is wholly good; evil exists. Theists hold all three; Mackie says they contradict each other.
  • The contradiction needs two further premises, which he calls quasi-logical rules: good opposes evil and eliminates it as far as it can; there are no limits to what an omnipotent being can do.
  • An adequate solution gives up one proposition; most attempted solutions are fallacious, keeping all three in words only.

Q1 Why does Mackie call the problem "logical"?

Show answer

It concerns consistency of beliefs, not evidence about the world.

Q2 What are the "quasi-logical rules" for?

Show answer

They turn three merely uneasy beliefs into a formal contradiction.

Quick check
?Which statement best captures Mackie's central claim?
Mission 3

Mackie's "fallacious solutions" (paraphrase)

Mackie's problem: three propositionsGod is omnipotentGod is wholly goodevil existsall three heldby theistscontradictionQuasi-logical rules (added premises)good opposes eviland eliminates it asfar as it canno limits to what anomnipotent being cando"Fallacious solutions"keep all three in words onlyCounterpartgood cannot exist without evilMeansevil is a means to goodBetter universethe universe is better with some evilFree willevil comes from human free will
  • Good cannot exist without evil (evil as its counterpart): this limits God's power by a logical rule, and at most needs a tiny amount of evil.
  • Evil is a means to good: an omnipotent God would not need means.
  • The universe is better with some evil: first-order evils (pain) make possible second-order goods (sympathy, courage); but then second-order evils (cruelty, malice) need a further explanation.
  • Evil comes from human free will: Mackie's key reply: why could God not make people who always freely choose the good?
  • Paradox of omnipotence: can an omnipotent being make things it cannot control?
Mission 3

Part (a): Clarify

Part (a) Clarify and part (b) Analyse(a) Clarifyidentify key ideasexplain key conceptsfrom the passageno evaluation(b) Analysedeconstructlogical chains ofreasoningconnectionsjudgements ofimportance
  • Clarify = identify key ideas + explain key concepts. AO1 only: no evaluation.
  • Work from the passage: name the idea, explain it, show where it sits in the argument.
  • You may quote short phrases from the printed excerpt; always explain them.
  • Use the author's terms (e.g. "quasi-logical rules", "fallacious solutions").
  • Brief context helps (who is Mackie answering?), but the passage is the focus.
Quick check
?Part (a) asks: "Clarify the ideas illustrated in this passage about the problem of evil." Which plan fits best?
Mission 3

Linking the extract to wider content

Linking Mackie's extract to wider contentAugustinetheodicy Mackie's"solutions" resembleIrenaeus / Hicktheodicy Mackie's"solutions" resemblePlantinga (b. 1932)free will defence(1974)Rowe (1979)shifts to theevidential problemMackie (1955)"Evil and Omnipotence"Flew (1955)made a similar compatibilist point to Mackie's
  • Part (b) rewards connections beyond the passage.
  • Augustine and Irenaeus/Hick: the theodicies Mackie's "solutions" resemble.
  • Alvin Plantinga (b. 1932), God, Freedom, and Evil (1974): the free will defence. If freedom is real (libertarian), God cannot make creatures freely choose only good; it is possible that any free creatures would sometimes go wrong.
  • William Rowe (1931–2015), 1979: shifts to the evidential problem.
  • Flew (1955) made a similar compatibilist point to Mackie's.
  • Link by argument, not by name: show how each one meets a specific step in Mackie.
Mission 3

Part (b): Analyse

Part (a) Clarify and part (b) Analyse(a) Clarifyidentify key ideasexplain key conceptsfrom the passageno evaluation(b) Analysedeconstructlogical chains ofreasoningconnectionsjudgements ofimportance
  • "Deconstruct" the issue: what does Mackie's case depend on?
  • Build chains: if X, then Y, because Z.
  • Make judgements of importance: which step carries the most weight? Which objection hits hardest?
  • 15 of the 20 marks are AO2: knowledge is used, not displayed.
  • Typical focus: an idea in the passage, analysed against other scholars or views.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does Mackie show that belief in God is irrational?

Does Mackie show that belief in God is irrational?Mackie shows that theism is logicallyinconsistent, so believing it is irrational.ForIf the three propositions are inconsistent,no one can rationally hold all threeThe "fallacious solutions" each seem tolimit God's power or goodnessAgainstPlantinga: a possible reason for allowingevil (e.g. free will) removes a logicalcontradictionThe quasi-logical rules can be questioned:perhaps a good being does not alwayseliminate evilJudge it byIs logical possibility enough for rationalbelief? · Does libertarian freedom makesense? · Does the evidential problem remain?
  • Claim: Mackie shows that theism is logically inconsistent, so believing it is irrational.
  • For: If the three propositions are inconsistent, no one can rationally hold all three.
  • For: The "fallacious solutions" each seem to limit God's power or goodness.
  • Against: Plantinga: a possible reason for God allowing evil is enough to remove a logical contradiction; free will may be such a reason.
  • Against: The quasi-logical rules can be questioned: perhaps a good being does not always eliminate evil it could prevent (e.g. for greater goods).
  • Judgement criteria: Is logical possibility enough for rational belief? Does libertarian freedom make sense? Does the evidential problem remain even if the logical one fails?
Mission 3Worked answer

An Analyse paragraph

The decisive step: the nature of freedomIs freedom compatible with being caused tochoose? (compatibilism)yesnoMackie's objection isstrongthe free will defencestandsThe debate turns on the nature of freedom, noton evil itself.

Question: Analyse Mackie's view that God could have made people who always freely choose the good.

  • Chain: Mackie's objection works only if freedom is compatible with being caused to choose (compatibilism).
  • Connection: Plantinga's defence assumes libertarian freedom: a choice God fixes is not free.
  • So: the debate turns on the nature of freedom, not on evil itself.
  • Importance: this is the decisive step: if compatibilism is true, Mackie's objection is strong; if not, the free will defence stands.
  • Link to the passage: Mackie's paradox of omnipotence shows he saw this tension.
Mission 3

The other extracts work the same way

Mark up the excerpt before you writeT1K23O→Tthesis: what is the author trying toshow?1-2-3steps: premises and moves, numberedKkey terms: words used in a special wayOobjections the author answers→target: whose view is attacked?
  • Paper 1: Flew and Hare, and Flew and Mitchell, "Theology and Falsification" (extracts 2 and 3); Russell and Copleston, the 1948 debate on the existence of God (extract 4).
  • Paper 2: Barclay on situation ethics; Kant, Groundwork, second section; Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics Book II; extract 4 (replaced from 2028 by a text on medical ethics).
  • The papers on New Testament and on a religion have Section B extracts too.
  • Same method each time: thesis → steps → key terms → objections → connections.
Quick check
?Which scholar's work replies most directly to Mackie's claim that God could make people who always freely choose good?
Mission check

?The paper prints an excerpt from Flew's contribution to "Theology and Falsification". Part (a) asks you to clarify its ideas. Which opening is best?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why do the highest marks go to answers that reach beyond the topic in the question?

Make a guess: Why do the highest marks go to answers that reach beyond the topic in the question?

Mission 4

What "synoptic" means

Synoptic: seeing togethertopic Atopic BthelinkThe link does workexplains · supports · challengesA link only mentioned does no work.
  • Synoptic (Greek: "seeing together"): showing how parts of the course connect.
  • It rewards breadth (knowing several areas) and depth (using them to sharpen one argument).
  • A link is worth marks only if it does work: it explains, supports or challenges your point.
  • A link that is only mentioned ("this also comes up in ethics") does no work.
Mission 4

Your synoptic demands

Your synoptic demands: EdexcelEdexcel · Section COne extended essayEvaluate · 30 marks · the synoptic question525 AO25 AO1 + 25 AO2 · about 45 minutes
  • Section C on each paper: one extended essay, Evaluate, 30 marks (5 AO1, 25 AO2).
  • Edexcel names this question as the paper's synoptic assessment: bring together knowledge from across the course with breadth and depth.
  • It is the last question: protect your time for it (about 45 minutes).
Mission 4

Four kinds of link

Four kinds of synoptic linkShared conceptfree will: in the problem of evil and inmoral responsibilityShared methoddesign argument and religiousexperience: both inductiveInfluenceDarwin: on the design argument andon biblical authorityContrastconscience: Aquinas (reason) vs Freud(super-ego)
  • Shared concept: one idea in two topics. Free will in the problem of evil and in moral responsibility.
  • Shared method: the same kind of argument. The design argument and the argument from religious experience both reason inductively from experience.
  • Influence: one development reshaping another. Darwin's theory affected the design argument and debates on biblical authority.
  • Contrast: the same question answered differently. Conscience for Aquinas (reason) and Freud (super-ego).
Quick check
?Which sentence makes a genuine synoptic link rather than a bolt-on mention?
Mission 4

Edexcel Section C

Building synoptic bridges (Edexcel)Religious language(verification)bears onClaims from religious experienceSection C · Evaluate: every link must feed thejudgement
  • The spec suggests where links lie:
  • Paper 1: the impact of beliefs and values on modern life; the importance of tradition in religious communities; the interpretation and application of religious texts today.
  • Paper 2: concepts shared with philosophy; beliefs and values in the religion you study.
  • Within a paper, link topics too: e.g. religious language (verification) bears on claims from religious experience.
  • Evaluate = 25 AO2 marks: every link must feed the judgement.
Mission 4Worked answer

A Section C paragraph

A Section C paragraphEvaluate the claim that religious experienceprovides a reliable basis for belief in God.PointSwinburne's principle of credulity says weshould trust experience unless there is aspecial reason not to.Synoptic linkBut religious language debates suggest aspecial reason: if claims about God cannot beverified or falsified (Ayer; Flew), reports of"experiencing God" may not be cognitiveclaims at all.WeighSwinburne can reply that he rejectsverificationism; so the judgement depends onwhich theory of meaning is accepted.Mini-judgementThe reliability of religious experience cannotbe judged apart from the debate on religiouslanguage.

Question: Evaluate the claim that religious experience provides a reliable basis for belief in God.

  • Point: Swinburne's principle of credulity says we should trust experience unless there is a special reason not to.
  • Synoptic link: But religious language debates suggest a special reason: if claims about God cannot be verified or falsified (Ayer; Flew), reports of "experiencing God" may not be cognitive claims at all.
  • Weigh: Swinburne can reply that he rejects verificationism; so the judgement depends on which theory of meaning is accepted.
  • Mini-judgement: The reliability of religious experience cannot be judged apart from the debate on religious language.
Mission 4Evaluate

Planning a synoptic answer

Planning a synoptic answer"Freedom matters more to religion thantruth." Evaluate this view.Links forFree will defence (philosophy of religion)Religious freedom and tolerance (ethics;Locke, Dignitatis Humanae)Qur'an 2:256: no compulsion in religionLinks againstReligions claim truth about GodFreedom valued because truth must befreely embraced (Dignitatis Humanae)Exclusive truth claims (e.g. John 14:6)Wider experienceLaws on freedom of religion and belief(ECHR Article 9)Judge it byAre freedom and truth rivals, or does oneserve the other? · Which traditions stresswhich?
  • Question: "Freedom matters more to religion than truth." Evaluate this view.
  • Links for: free will defence (philosophy of religion); religious freedom and tolerance (ethics; Locke, Dignitatis Humanae); Qur'an 2:256, no compulsion in religion.
  • Links against: religions claim truth about God; freedom is valued because truth must be freely embraced (Dignitatis Humanae); exclusive truth claims (e.g. John 14:6, Jesus as the only way to the Father).
  • Wider experience: laws on freedom of religion and belief (ECHR Article 9).
  • Judgement criteria: Are freedom and truth rivals, or does one serve the other? Which traditions stress which?
Quick check
?Which pair of arguments share the same method, giving a sound "shared method" link?
Mission check

?A student writing on conscience wants one synoptic link to philosophy of religion. Which link does the most work?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • AO1 rewards selected, accurate, developed knowledge: thought and teaching, influence, similarities and differences.
  • Develop every point: explain → support (scholar, source, example) → significance; use specialist terms correctly.
  • Explore (8) and Clarify (10) are AO1 only.

Mission 2

  • AO2 rewards analysis and evaluation: a line of argument, the strongest counter-argument with a response, and a justified, consistent judgement.
  • Read strength words in the statement ("most", "only", "proves"); they decide what you must show.

Mission 3

  • Section B: a printed excerpt; part (a) Clarify (10, AO1); part (b) Analyse (20: 5 AO1, 15 AO2).
  • Locate the argument first: thesis, steps, key terms, objections, target.
  • Mackie: God omnipotent, wholly good, evil exists: logically inconsistent, given quasi-logical rules; fallacious solutions; free will objection, answered by Plantinga.

Mission 4

  • Synoptic means seeing together: links by shared concept, shared method, influence or contrast, each used to explain, support or challenge.
  • Section C: the Evaluate essay (30 marks) is each paper's synoptic question.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Exam skills for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Two students know the same facts. Why does one score far higher on an "explain" question?
  2. Mission 2Two students reach opposite conclusions and both get top marks. How is that possible?
  3. Mission 3The exam prints a philosopher's argument in front of you. How do you take it apart in about 45 minutes?
  4. Mission 4Why do the highest marks go to answers that reach beyond the topic in the question?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel