4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Make a guess: Two people return a lost wallet. Why would Kant say only one of them acted morally?
Q1 Why can the lying promise not even be thought of as a universal law?
Promising would cease to exist, so the lie could not work.
Q2 Is the test about whether universal lying would have bad results?
No: it is about whether the maxim contradicts itself.
Task: show how Kant's categorical imperative applies to handing in a friend's essay as your own.
Kant's test is logical, not a forecast: a maxim fails because it cannot be willed for everyone, not because of what happens next. Next: Kant's postulates, his critics and his defenders.
Make a guess: A killer asks where your friend is hiding. Can Kant's ethics cope with hard cases like this?
Q1 Why does Ross say I still owe my friend something?
The prima facie duty of fidelity remains; it was only overridden.
Q2 What does Ross use, instead of Kant's universal-law test, to decide between duties?
Intuitive judgement in the particular situation.
Issue: Is Kantian ethics too reliant on reason?
Kant prizes the motive that holds when feelings fail; critics say a good morality must also prize the feelings. Next: how does Kant compare with Bentham?
Make a guess: Can you practise being brave the way you practise the piano?
Q1 According to Aristotle, which comes first: just acts or a just character?
Just acts, repeated until they become a settled character.
Q2 Why does the stone example matter?
It shows virtues are not natural instincts; they must be formed.
Task: explain Aristotle's doctrine of the mean.
Courage is trained like a skill, but it is not "more is better": it is the right response, done until it becomes your character. Next: who revived virtue ethics, and can it guide hard choices?
Make a guess: If a bank robber is brave, is bravery still a virtue?
For Aristotle, a "virtue" aimed at a bad end is not a virtue at all; critics still ask whether that reply makes the theory hard to use in real dilemmas. Next: virtue ethics in action on theft and lying.
Mission 1
Mission 2
Mission 3
Mission 4
You've worked through Deontology, Virtue Ethics and the works of scholars for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Your stars: 0 / 0