← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4B Christianity – 3 Practices that shape and express religious identity
Mini-Lesson

Christianity: Practices that shape and express religious identity

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1When Christians share bread and wine, what do they believe they are really receiving?
  2. Mission 2Why do some churches share bread every day and others only once a month?
  3. Mission 3Can a painting, a song or a string of beads bring someone closer to God?
Mission 1

Mission 1: When Christians share bread and wine, what do they believe they are really receiving?

Make a guess: When Christians share bread and wine, what do they believe they are really receiving?

Mission 1

One meal, many names

  • Eucharist (Greek: "thanksgiving"), Mass (Catholic), Divine Liturgy (Orthodox), Holy Communion (Anglican, many Protestants), the Lord's Supper or Breaking of Bread (Baptists, many evangelicals).
  • All look back to Jesus' Last Supper with his disciples, the night before he died.
  • Sacrament: "an outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace" (Book of Common Prayer, Catechism, 1662).
  • Grace: God's free, undeserved love and help.
  • Catholics and Orthodox count seven sacraments; most Protestants two (baptism and the Eucharist); Baptists often say ordinance, not sacrament.
  • The big question: how, if at all, is Christ present in the bread and wine?
Mission 1Read the source

"This is my body"

> "He took bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke and gave it to them, saying, "This is my body which is given for you. Do this in memory of me." Likewise, he took the cup after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which is poured out for you."" (Luke 22:19–20, WEBBE)

> "For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed." (John 6:55, WEBBE)

  • Two key phrases: "This is my body" and "in memory of me" (Greek anamnesis, "remembrance"; Catholic and Orthodox teaching takes this as a remembrance that makes the saving event present, memorialists as a recalling of it).

Q1 Which phrase do Catholics stress most, and which do Baptists stress most?

Show answer

Catholics: "This is my body"; Baptists: "Do this in memory of me".

Q2 How does John 6:55 support a literal reading?

Show answer

It calls Jesus' flesh real food and his blood real drink.

Mission 1

Transubstantiation

Substance and accidentsaccidents:appearance, taste,texturesubstance:breadconsecrationaccidents:unchangedsubstance:the Body of ChristCatholic teaching: transubstantiation
  • Catholic teaching: at the consecration, the whole substance of the bread and wine is changed into the substance of Christ's body and blood.
  • The accidents (appearance, taste, texture, chemistry) remain those of bread and wine.
  • Terms from Aristotle: substance = what a thing is; accidents = how it appears to the senses.
  • Defined at the Fourth Lateran Council (1215); confirmed at the Council of Trent (1551) against the Reformers.
  • Christ is wholly present in each part, even a crumb; so the consecrated hosts are kept in the tabernacle and adored.
  • This is the Catholic meaning of Real Presence: Christ truly, really and substantially present.
Mission 1Read the source

Aquinas on the change

> "the whole substance of the bread is changed into the whole substance of Christ's body, and the whole substance of the wine into the whole substance of Christ's blood. Hence this is not a formal, but a substantial conversion; nor is it a kind of natural movement: but, with a name of its own, it can be called "transubstantiation."" (Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica III, Q. 75, Art. 4, English Dominican trans.)

  • In natural change, one form gives way to another in the same underlying matter (wood becomes ash). Here the whole substance changes, and the appearance remains.
  • Only God, the source of all being, can do this (Aquinas' argument in the same article).

Q1 Why does Aquinas say the change is not "a kind of natural movement"?

Show answer

No natural process changes a whole substance while leaving its appearance.

Q2 Why does the bread still taste like bread?

Show answer

The accidents remain; only the substance has changed.

Quick check
?According to Catholic teaching on transubstantiation, what changes at the consecration?
Mission 1

Transignification and transfinalization

Meaning and purposeAn analogy"just metal"gift and promisemeaning changed (transignification)purpose changed (transfinalization)Rome: only with a real change of being(Mysterium Fidei, 1965)
  • 1950s–60s: some Catholic theologians, e.g. Piet Schoonenberg (1911–1999) and Edward Schillebeeckx (1914–2009, The Eucharist, 1967), re-expressed the change without Aristotle's physics.
  • Transignification: the meaning of the bread changes. A thing's reality lies in what it is for persons; once Christ gives it as his self-gift, it means his body.
  • Transfinalization: the purpose (end) of the bread changes: no longer ordinary food, but the means of communion with Christ.
  • Analogy often used: a letter or a ring is "just paper" or "just metal", yet it really becomes a gift and a promise.
  • Pope Paul VI, Mysterium Fidei (1965): these terms are acceptable only if they include transubstantiation, a real change of being.
  • Schillebeeckx himself held that the new meaning rests on a real change made by Christ, not on believers' feelings.
  • Your spec names transignification alongside transubstantiation.
Mission 1

Real Presence beyond Rome

In, with and underLuther: sacramental unionbread(remains bread)Christ'spresenceinwithunderLuther: "in and under"; later Lutheranconfessions: "in, with and under"
  • Orthodox: a real change (metabole) of bread and wine into Christ's body and blood, through the Holy Spirit (the epiclesis, the prayer calling down the Spirit). How it happens is left a mystery.
  • Martin Luther (1483–1546): Christ's body and blood are truly present "in and under" the bread and wine (Large Catechism, 1529); the bread remains bread. Later Lutheran confessions say "in, with and under". Lutherans call this sacramental union.
  • Consubstantiation: the label others give to this view: both substances present at once. Many Lutherans reject the term as too Aristotelian.
  • Anglicans: a range. Article XXVIII (1571) rejects transubstantiation; the body of Christ is received "only after an heavenly and spiritual manner". Anglo-Catholics hold a strong Real Presence.
  • John Calvin (1509–1564): a spiritual Real Presence: by the Spirit, believers truly feed on Christ, who is in heaven.
Mission 1

Memorialism

  • Huldrych Zwingli (1484–1531): the Supper is a memorial of Christ's death and a pledge of the community's faith.
  • "This is my body" means "This signifies my body", as Jesus says "I am the door" (John 10:9).
  • Christ's risen body is at the right hand of God; it cannot be in many places at once.
  • "It is the spirit who gives life. The flesh profits nothing." (John 6:63, WEBBE)
  • Marburg Colloquy (1529): Luther and Zwingli agreed on 14 of 15 articles but split on this one.
  • Baptists today: the Lord's Supper is an ordinance and memorial; Christ is present spiritually among his people, not in the elements. Many stress it is not "merely" a memorial: it is a real meeting with the risen Lord in faith.
Quick check
?A Baptist minister says: "The bread stays bread; we remember Christ's death and he meets us by his Spirit." Which approach does this express?
Mission 1Diversity

A map of views

A spectrum of views on the breadreally changedremains bread;remembrance12345Anglicans: a range1Catholicsubstance changed; appearance remains2Orthodoxreal change (metabole); a mystery3Lutheransacramental union: bread remains; Christreally present4Reformed, many Anglicansspiritual presence, to faith5Zwingli; Baptistsmemorial; Christ among believers
ViewBread after consecrationChrist presentWho
Transubstantiationsubstance changed; appearance remainsreally, substantiallyCatholic
Real change (metabole)changed; mysteryreallyOrthodox
Sacramental union ("consubstantiation")remains breadreally, in, with, underLutheran
Spiritual presenceremains breadspiritually, to faithReformed, many Anglicans
Memorialremains breadin remembrance; among believersZwingli; Baptists, many evangelicals
Mission 1Evaluate

Is there any common ground?

Is there any common ground?There is real common ground incontemporary understandings of theEucharistForAll hold that Jesus commanded it, that itproclaims his death (1 Corinthians 11:26)and unites believers (1 Corinthians 10:17)Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (WorldCouncil of Churches, Lima, 1982) foundagreementMany memorialists speak of a real spiritualpresence; many Catholics stress meaningand relationshipAgainstWhether the bread becomes Christ's bodystill divides: it affects adoration and whomay share communionCatholics and Orthodox do not, in general,share communion with ProtestantsJudge it byIs agreement on practice enough withoutagreement on presence? · Are the theoriesdifferent answers or different languages?
  • Claim: There is real common ground in contemporary understandings of the Eucharist.
  • For: all hold that Jesus commanded it, that it proclaims his death (1 Corinthians 11:26) and unites believers (1 Corinthians 10:17).
  • For: ecumenical dialogue: Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (World Council of Churches, Lima, 1982) found agreement on thanksgiving, anamnesis, the Spirit's role and fellowship.
  • For: many memorialists speak of a real spiritual presence; many Catholics stress meaning and relationship.
  • Against: the core question, whether the bread becomes Christ's body, still divides; this affects worship (adoration) and who may share communion.
  • Against: Catholics and Orthodox do not, in general, share communion with Protestants, a sign that differences are not merely verbal.
  • Judgement criteria: Is agreement on practice enough without agreement on presence? Are the theories different answers or different languages?
Quick check
?Why did Pope Paul VI's Mysterium Fidei (1965) caution against transignification?
Mission check

?After a service, a few crumbs of consecrated bread fall to the floor. Which response fits Catholic belief best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do some churches share bread every day and others only once a month?

Make a guess: Why do some churches share bread every day and others only once a month?

Mission 2Read the source

Luke's Last Supper

> "He received a cup, and when he had given thanks, he said, "Take this and share it amongst yourselves, for I tell you, I will not drink at all again from the fruit of the vine, until God's Kingdom comes."" (Luke 22:17–18, WEBBE)

> "He took bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke and gave it to them, saying, "This is my body which is given for you. Do this in memory of me."" (Luke 22:19, WEBBE)

> "Likewise, he took the cup after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which is poured out for you."" (Luke 22:20, WEBBE)

  • Setting: a Passover meal (Luke 22:15), remembering Israel's rescue from Egypt.
  • Luke alone has two cups: one before the bread (17), one "after supper" (20).

Q1 What does Jesus tell the disciples to do?

Show answer

Take, share, and repeat the bread action "in memory of me".

Q2 Which phrase looks to the future?

Show answer

"Until God's Kingdom comes": the meal anticipates the Kingdom.

Mission 2

What did Jesus' actions mean?

Meanings of the Last Suppernew covenantsacrificeremembranceKingdomcommandLuke 22:17–20Catholic emphasis: the Mass makespresent the one sacrifice of the crossBaptist emphasis: an ordinance toremember his death "until he comes"
  • New covenant: Jesus' death begins the promised new relationship between God and his people (Jeremiah 31:31).
  • Sacrifice: "given for you", "poured out for you": his death is an offering for others.
  • Command: "Do this": the Church must keep repeating the meal.
  • Remembrance (anamnesis): for Catholics and Orthodox, not just recalling but making the saving event present; for Baptists, a recalling and proclaiming of Christ's death.
  • Kingdom: each celebration looks ahead to the feast of God's Kingdom.
  • Catholic reading: Jesus instituted the Mass and the priesthood; the Mass makes present the one sacrifice of the cross (it does not repeat it).
  • Baptist reading: Jesus gave an ordinance to remember his death "until he comes" (1 Corinthians 11:26); the cross was once for all, so the Supper offers no sacrifice.
Mission 2

The Catholic Mass

Two layouts for Holy CommunionCatholic MassBaptistaltartabernacle withred sanctuarylamppeople comeforward toreceivepulpitcommuniontablebread and smallcups passedalong the rows
  • Celebrated daily; Catholics must attend on Sundays and holy days of obligation.
  • Liturgy of the Word (readings, homily), then Liturgy of the Eucharist.
  • Only an ordained priest may consecrate, using the words of institution at the altar.
  • Unleavened hosts; the cup is sometimes offered to the people too.
  • Receivers fast for one hour and should not be conscious of serious (mortal) sin; First Holy Communion at about age 7–8.
  • Remaining hosts are kept in the tabernacle; the red sanctuary lamp shows Christ present.
  • Importance: the "source and summit" of the Christian life (Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium 11, 1964).
Mission 2

The Baptist Lord's Supper

Two layouts for Holy CommunionCatholic MassBaptistaltartabernacle withred sanctuarylamppeople comeforward toreceivepulpitcommuniontablebread and smallcups passedalong the rows
  • Held weekly in some churches, monthly in many; often after the sermon.
  • Led by the minister, or by elders or deacons: there is no priest; all believers are priests (1 Peter 2:9).
  • A communion table, not an altar: a meal, not a sacrifice.
  • The leader reads Jesus' words at the Last Supper (often 1 Corinthians 11:23–26).
  • Bread (sometimes an ordinary loaf) and small individual cups of wine or, often, non-alcoholic grape juice, passed to people in their seats.
  • Often everyone eats and drinks together, to show unity.
  • Usually an open table: all who love and trust Christ may share, whatever their church.
  • Importance: obedience to Christ's command, remembrance, fellowship. Less frequent sharing is meant to keep it special, not to make it unimportant.
Quick check
?Why do Baptist churches use a table rather than an altar for the Lord's Supper?
Mission 2Diversity

Other practices

  • Orthodox Divine Liturgy: leavened bread and wine mixed with warm water, given together on a spoon; infants receive communion from baptism; the altar is behind the iconostasis (icon screen); blessed bread (antidoron) is shared with all, including visitors.
  • Anglican Holy Communion: kneeling at the altar rail; bread and a common cup; practice ranges from Anglo-Catholic to evangelical.
  • Pentecostal: usually a memorial meal, often with spontaneous prayer and praise.
  • Quakers and The Salvation Army hold no outward Eucharist: all of life can be a meeting with Christ.
  • Your spec: "the importance of sacraments in some denominations": compare these with Catholic and Orthodox life built around the Eucharist.
Mission 2

What is shared across traditions

Shared core of Holy CommunionCatholicBaptisttabernaclepriestdailyopen tableindividualcupstablebothbread andwinewords ofinstitutionthanksgivingconfessionLord's PrayerAlsoOrthodox: leavened bread and wine on aspoon. Anglican: kneeling at the altar rail; acommon cup.
  • Bread and wine (or grape juice), as Jesus used.
  • Words of institution from the Gospels or 1 Corinthians 11:23–26.
  • Thanksgiving prayer (the meaning of Eucharist).
  • Confession or self-examination before receiving.
  • The Lord's Prayer in most traditions.
  • A community act: never just private; "we, who are many, are one body" (1 Corinthians 10:17, WEBBE).
  • Remembrance of Jesus' death and hope of his return.
Mission 2

The experience of believers

  • Reflection and self-awareness: "let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread" (1 Corinthians 11:28, WEBBE); many pray, confess and prepare beforehand.
  • Forgiveness and peace: a renewed sense of being forgiven and accepted.
  • Union with Christ: Catholics and Orthodox speak of receiving Christ himself; Baptists of meeting him by faith and Spirit.
  • Belonging: sharing one loaf with others, across age, class and background.
  • Strength for life: "food for the journey"; sent out to serve (the Catholic dismissal: "Go forth").
  • Experience varies: some speak of intense awareness of God; for others it is quiet, routine faithfulness.
Mission 2

Implications for communities

  • Identity: Catholics say "the Eucharist makes the Church"; a Catholic parish is built around the Mass.
  • Unity and division: Catholics and Orthodox do not, as a rule, share communion with other churches; many Protestants offer an open table. Mixed-church families and ecumenical services feel this division sharply.
  • Service: sharing bread at the table links to sharing food with the hungry (e.g. church food banks).
  • New questions: during the COVID-19 lockdowns (2020), churches debated online communion: some allowed people to share bread at home; Catholics encouraged spiritual communion (desiring Christ when unable to receive).
Quick check
?Which practice is shared by both Catholic and Baptist celebrations?
Mission 2Evaluate

Does belief shape practice more than anything else?

Does belief shape practice?Differences in Eucharistic practice arecaused mainly by differences in beliefForLasting presence → tabernacle, adoration;memorial → table, open sharingA sacrificial view needs a priest and altar;a meal view needs neitherAgainstHistory and culture matter too: individualcups and grape juice spread with19th-century hygiene and temperancemovementsChurches with similar beliefs (e.g. differentAnglican parishes) still practise verydifferentlyJudge it byCan each practice be traced to a belief? ·What else (history, culture, authority)explains it?
  • Claim: Differences in Eucharistic practice are caused mainly by differences in belief.
  • For: belief in Christ's lasting presence → tabernacle, adoration, reverence for crumbs; belief in a memorial → table, open sharing.
  • For: a sacrificial view needs a priest and altar; a meal view needs neither.
  • Against: history and culture matter too: e.g. individual cups and grape juice spread with 19th-century hygiene and temperance movements, not new doctrine.
  • Against: churches with similar beliefs (e.g. different Anglican parishes) still practise very differently.
  • Judgement criteria: Can each practice be traced to a belief? What else (history, culture, authority) explains it?
Quick check
?Which statement gives the Catholic understanding of the sacrifice in the Mass?
Mission check

?A Catholic and her Baptist friend attend each other's churches. Each is surprised. Which pair of surprises best fits the two traditions?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Can a painting, a song or a string of beads bring someone closer to God?

Make a guess: Can a painting, a song or a string of beads bring someone closer to God?

Mission 3

May God be pictured?

May God be pictured? A timelineExodus 20:4"You shall not make foryourselves an idol"726–843Iconoclasts (ByzantineEmpire) against imagesc. 675–749John of Damascus: in theincarnation God becamevisible, so Christ can bepictured787Second Council of Nicaea:icons may be venerated,not worshipped1524Reformation: Zwingli'sZurich removes imagesfrom churchesReformationLuther keeps images asteaching aids
  • "You shall not make for yourselves an idol, nor any image of anything that is in the heavens above" (Exodus 20:4, WEBBE).
  • Against images: the Iconoclasts of the Byzantine Empire (726–843); in the Reformation, Zwingli's Zurich removed images from churches (1524), as did many Reformed churches.
  • For images: John of Damascus (c. 675–749), On the Divine Images: God cannot be pictured, but in the incarnation God became visible, so Christ can be.
  • Second Council of Nicaea (787): icons may be venerated (honoured), not worshipped; the honour passes to the one shown.
  • Luther kept images as teaching aids; Catholic and Orthodox churches are full of them.
Mission 3

The Nativity in art

The Nativity in artOrthodox icon (layout)star raymanger like atombchild: swaddlingbands like graveclothesdark caveJoseph apart,troubledmidwives washingthe childWestern paintingsArtistWorkDateGiottoNativityc. 1305BotticelliMystic Nativityc. 1500CorreggioHoly Nightc. 1530
  • Orthodox icon (e.g. 15th-century Russian icons): a dark cave, a manger like a tomb, swaddling bands like grave clothes; Joseph apart, troubled; midwives washing the child (he is truly human). Interpretation: the birth already points to the cross and resurrection.
  • Giotto, Nativity, Scrovegni Chapel, Padua (c. 1305): a real stable, human tenderness between mother and child; part of a cycle telling the whole story.
  • Correggio, Holy Night (c. 1530, Dresden): light streams from the child: "the light of the world".
  • Botticelli, Mystic Nativity (c. 1500, National Gallery, London): angels embrace humans; a Greek inscription links the birth to the end times.
  • Global art: artists from Africa, Asia and Latin America place the Nativity in their own cultures: God shares every human life.
  • Role in devotion: crib scenes (Francis of Assisi, Greccio, 1223) and Christmas cards invite wonder at the incarnation.
Mission 3

The crucifixion in art

Two ways of showing the crucifixionChristus triumphansuprighteyes opencrownedvictoryChristus patienshead bowedbody saggingsufferingWorkDateGrünewald, Isenheim Altarpiece1512–1516Chagall, White Crucifixion1938Dalí, Christ of St John of theCross1951
  • Christus triumphans (early medieval): Christ upright, eyes open, sometimes crowned: the cross as victory (e.g. the San Damiano cross, Assisi, 12th century).
  • Christus patiens (from the 13th century): head bowed, body sagging: the cross as suffering love (e.g. Cimabue's crucifixes).
  • Grünewald, Isenheim Altarpiece (1512–1516): Christ's body covered in sores, painted for a hospital treating a skin disease. Patients saw that Christ shared their suffering.
  • Dalí, Christ of St John of the Cross (1951, Kelvingrove, Glasgow): seen from above, no wounds or blood; the cross floats above a bay with fishing boats: a cosmic, peaceful vision.
  • Chagall, White Crucifixion (1938, Chicago): a Jewish artist paints Jesus as a Jew in a prayer shawl, amid persecution of Jews: suffering of the innocent.
  • Role in devotion: the crucifix in Catholic homes and churches, the Stations of the Cross in Lent; many Protestant churches prefer an empty cross (he is risen), though Lutherans often keep the crucifix.
Quick check
?Why did Grünewald show Christ's body covered with sores in the Isenheim Altarpiece?
Mission 3

Art as devotion

  • Icons are "windows" onto heaven: Orthodox Christians kiss them, light candles before them and pray with them at home in an "icon corner".
  • Icons follow strict traditions; the painter (or "writer") prays and fasts.
  • Catholic devotion: statues, the crucifix, Stations of the Cross, the Christmas crib.
  • Protestant churches often have plain walls; art serves teaching (stained glass, illustrated Bibles) rather than devotion.
  • Art can teach (the "Bible of the poor"), move (feeling the story) and focus prayer.
Mission 3

Music in worship

Music in worship by traditionTraditionTypical musicCatholicGregorian chant; hymns,modern Mass settingsOrthodoxsung liturgy: unaccompaniedvoices onlyLutherancongregational chorales;BachReformedmetrical psalms (Zwingli: nomusic in worship)MethodistCharles Wesley's hymnsAfricanAmericanspirituals and gospelPentecostal,Charismaticworship songs with a bandTaizéshort chants, repeatedQuakerstraditionally silence
  • Bible: "teaching and admonishing one another with psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs" (Colossians 3:16, WEBBE).
  • Catholic: Gregorian chant; today also hymns and modern settings of the Mass.
  • Orthodox: traditionally unaccompanied voices only; the liturgy is almost entirely sung.
  • Lutheran: congregational chorales (Luther, "A Mighty Fortress", c. 1529); J. S. Bach's cantatas and St Matthew Passion (1727).
  • Reformed: metrical psalms (Genevan Psalter, 1562); Zwingli allowed no music in worship.
  • Methodist: Charles Wesley's hymns teach doctrine in song.
  • African American spirituals and gospel: hope and freedom under oppression.
  • Pentecostal and Charismatic: contemporary worship songs with a band; extended times of praise.
  • Taizé: short chants repeated meditatively; Quakers: traditionally silence.
Mission 3Read the source

Augustine on church singing

> "How did I weep, in Thy Hymns and Canticles, touched to the quick by the voices of Thy sweet-attuned Church! The voices flowed into mine ears, and the Truth distilled into my heart" (Augustine, Confessions IX.6, trans. Pusey)

> "Yet when it befalls me to be more moved with the voice than the words sung, I confess to have sinned penally, and then had rather not hear music." (Confessions X.33)

  • Augustine, after his baptism (387), weeps at the singing in Milan; later he worries.

Q1 What does music do for Augustine in IX.6?

Show answer

It carries truth into his heart and moves him to devotion.

Q2 What is the danger he names in X.33?

Show answer

Enjoying the sound more than the words: music as pleasure rather than worship.

  • The saying "he who sings prays twice" is often credited to Augustine, but it is not found in his works.
Quick check
?Which tradition traditionally uses only unaccompanied voices in its liturgy?
Mission 3

Public and private prayer

  • Public (with others): set liturgy (the Mass, the Divine Liturgy, the Book of Common Prayer, 1549/1662), the Lord's Prayer (Matthew 6:9–13), intercessions; in evangelical and Pentecostal churches, extempore (unscripted) prayer.
  • Private (alone): "when you pray, enter into your inner room, and having shut your door, pray to your Father who is in secret" (Matthew 6:6, WEBBE).
  • Forms: adoration, confession, thanksgiving, intercession.
  • Private methods: Bible reading with prayer (lectio divina), the Ignatian examen (reviewing the day), silent waiting.
  • "Pray without ceasing" (1 Thessalonians 5:17): prayer as a way of life, not just an activity.
Mission 3

Aids to prayer

Aids to prayerRosary (Catholic)crucifixfive decadesof ten beadsPrayer rope(Orthodox)knotsIcon cornericoncandle
  • Rosary (Catholic): beads guide Hail Marys and Our Fathers while meditating on events (the mysteries) of Jesus' and Mary's lives.
  • Prayer rope (Orthodox, komboskini or chotki): knots for repeating the Jesus Prayer, "Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner".
  • Icons, candles, incense: "Let my prayer be set before you like incense" (Psalm 141:2, WEBBE).
  • Crucifix, prayer books, Anglican prayer beads, devotional apps.
  • Protestant concern: "don't use vain repetitions" (Matthew 6:7, WEBBE). Reply: repetition is meant to quiet the mind and focus on God, not to win a hearing by many words.
Mission 3

Identity and experience

Identity and experiencecreative expressionIdentitybadges of a tradition: Orthodox iconsand chant, Lutheran chorales, Methodisthymns, Black gospel, Pentecostal praisebandsExperienceawe and God's presence; connection, notcause: the beauty itself is not GodCritiquedistraction: an aesthetic thrill may bemistaken for religious experience(Augustine, Confessions X.33)
  • Identity: creative forms mark who a community is: Orthodox icons and chant, Lutheran chorales, Methodist hymns, Black gospel, Pentecostal praise bands. Diaspora churches keep their identity in their songs and languages.
  • Vehicle for religious experience: art and music can carry a sense of awe and God's presence. The Rus' Primary Chronicle tells how envoys of Prince Vladimir of Kyiv, at worship in Constantinople (c. 987), said they did not know whether they were in heaven or on earth (paraphrase).
  • Connection, not cause: believers say God uses beauty; the beauty itself is not God.
  • Critics: an aesthetic thrill may be mistaken for religious experience; Augustine's own worry (X.33).
Mission 3Evaluate

Do creative expressions help or hinder devotion?

Are creative expressions essential to devotion?Art, music and aids to prayer are essentialto Christian devotionForThe incarnation makes the visible a way tothe invisible (John of Damascus); theyteach, move, unite and express identityMany believers report experiences of Godthrough icons, hymns and the rosaryAgainstRisk of idolatry (Exodus 20:4) or emptyrepetition (Matthew 6:7); attention on theart, not GodQuakers and some Reformed Christiansworship deeply without images orinstrumentsJudge it byEssential, helpful, or optional? · Does the aidpoint beyond itself? · Does it fit the tradition'stheology?
  • Claim: Art, music and aids to prayer are essential to Christian devotion.
  • For: the incarnation makes the visible a way to the invisible (John of Damascus); they teach, move and unite; they express identity.
  • For: many believers report experiences of God through icons, hymns and the rosary.
  • Against: risk of idolatry (Exodus 20:4) or empty repetition (Matthew 6:7); attention on the art, not God.
  • Against: Quakers and some Reformed Christians worship deeply without images or instruments, so these are not essential.
  • Judgement criteria: essential, helpful, or optional? Does the aid point beyond itself? Does it fit the tradition's theology?
  • Paper 4 essays: weigh different denominations' views; a judgement that distinguishes "essential" from "valuable" is stronger than a yes/no.
Quick check
?Which statement reflects the Second Council of Nicaea's teaching about icons?
Mission check

?At a Baptist church a teenager says the band's worship song made her feel God's presence. Her Orthodox friend says the same about kissing an icon. A sceptic says both just felt the effect of beauty. Which response would a Christian believer most likely give?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Transubstantiation (Catholic): the substance becomes Christ's body and blood; the accidents remain (Lateran IV, Aquinas, Trent).
  • Transignification and transfinalization re-express the change as a change of meaning and purpose. Luther: sacramental union ("consubstantiation").
  • Memorialism (Zwingli, most Baptists): "Do this in memory of me"; Christ present spiritually among believers, not in the bread.

Mission 2

  • Luke 22:17–20: Passover setting, new covenant, "given for you", "Do this in memory of me".
  • Catholic Mass: daily, priest, altar, transubstantiation, reservation; "source and summit".
  • Baptist Lord's Supper: less frequent, table, open, remembrance.
  • Shared practices include words of institution, thanksgiving and self-examination; believers speak of reflection, forgiveness and belonging.

Mission 3

  • Art: debated (Exodus 20:4; Nicaea II, 787). Nativity art stresses incarnation; crucifixion art moves between victory and suffering.
  • Music varies by denomination, from unaccompanied Orthodox chant to Pentecostal praise; prayer is public and private, with aids such as the rosary and the Jesus Prayer.
  • 3.2d: creative expressions express identity and can be vehicles of religious experience; critics warn of distraction and idolatry.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Christianity: Practices that shape and express religious identity for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1When Christians share bread and wine, what do they believe they are really receiving?
  2. Mission 2Why do some churches share bread every day and others only once a month?
  3. Mission 3Can a painting, a song or a string of beads bring someone closer to God?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel