🚀 Teleological approaches to moral decision making
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · AS 7: Teleological approaches to moral decision making
Mini-Lesson
Teleological approaches to moral decision making
5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Could right and wrong be worked out like a sum of pleasures and pains?
Mission 2Are some pleasures worth more than others, and when may society stop you chasing yours?
Mission 3If one person's suffering would make thousands happier, must a utilitarian say yes?
Mission 4If love is the only rule, does a Christian still need any other moral rules?
Mission 5Is "do the most loving thing" a guide anyone can use, or does it ask too much of us?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Could right and wrong be worked out like a sum of pleasures and pains?
Make a guess: Could right and wrong be worked out like a sum of pleasures and pains?
Mission 1
Judging by results
Step 1 of 3
Teleological (from telos, end or goal): an act is judged by the goal it achieves.
Consequentialist: what makes an act right or wrong is its consequences, not the act in itself or the motive.
Utilitarianism: the right act is the one with the best consequences for happiness: the most pleasure and least pain overall.
Founded in its classic form by Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832), An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (printed 1780, published 1789).
Contrast: deontological ethics (Kant, natural law) judge the act itself, by duty or rule.
Mission 1
Bentham's world
Enlightenment: morality and law should rest on reason and evidence, not tradition or religious authority.
Empiricism: Hume had grounded morals in human feelings of pleasure and approval.
The phrase "greatest happiness for the greatest numbers" had already appeared in Francis Hutcheson (1725); Bentham also credited Joseph Priestley and the Italian penal reformer Cesare Beccaria (1764).
Industrial Revolution Britain: growing cities, harsh punishments, a chaotic legal system that Bentham attacked in A Fragment on Government (1776).
Bentham wanted a science of morals and law that anyone could check.
Mission 1Read the source
Two sovereign masters
Bentham, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789), chapter I, paragraph 1:
> "Nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do, as well as to determine what we shall do."
Two claims: pleasure and pain determine what we do (a claim about human psychology), and point out what we ought to do (a moral claim).
Q1 Which words make the moral claim?
Show answer
"point out what we ought to do"
Q2 Which words make the psychological claim?
Show answer
"determine what we shall do"
Mission 1
The principle of utility
Step 1 of 3
Utility: the tendency of an act to produce pleasure, benefit or happiness, or to prevent pain.
Principle of utility: approve an act if it tends to increase the happiness of those affected; disapprove if it tends to decrease it.
"The greatest happiness of the greatest number" (A Fragment on Government, 1776): the measure of right and wrong.
Hedonism: pleasure is the only thing good in itself; pain the only thing bad in itself. Happiness = pleasure and the absence of pain.
Equality: "everybody to count for one, nobody for more than one" (Bentham's rule, as Mill reports it).
Quantity only: kinds of pleasure do not differ in value. Bentham: push-pin (a children's game) is as valuable as poetry, if it gives as much pleasure.
Quick check
?Bentham's opening sentence combines two kinds of hedonism. Which pairing is correct?
Mission 1
The hedonic calculus
Bentham's way of measuring the pleasure or pain an act will cause (IPML, chapter IV), seven factors:
Intensity: how strong? · Duration: how long?
Certainty: how likely? · Propinquity (remoteness): how soon?
Fecundity: will it lead to more pleasure? · Purity: is it free from pain afterwards?
Extent: how many people are affected?
Bentham's own memory verse: "Intense, long, certain, speedy, fruitful, pure— / Such marks in pleasures and in pains endure."
Quick check
?Reading for pleasure tends to make further pleasures possible: new interests, friendships and skills. Which factor of the hedonic calculus does this describe?
Mission 1
Act utilitarianism
Act utilitarianism: judge each act, in its own situation, by its consequences. No act is right or wrong in itself.
So lying, or breaking a promise, can be right if it produces the greatest balance of pleasure over pain here.
Relativist: the right act is relative to the situation and its consequences; only the principle of utility is fixed.
Bentham applied it above all to law and government: a law is good if it increases the community's happiness.
Mission 1
Bentham the reformer
Law: punishment is itself a pain, so it is justified only if it prevents greater pain. Bentham attacked cruel and useless punishments.
Prisons: the Panopticon (1791), a design to make prisons reform rather than simply punish.
Democracy: wider voting rights and secret ballots, so government serves the happiness of all, not a privileged few.
Animals: "The question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?" (IPML, chapter XVII, footnote).
Private morality: an unpublished essay (c. 1785) argued that homosexual acts should not be punished, since they cause no harm.
Followers ("philosophical radicals") influenced the Reform Act 1832 and the Poor Law of 1834.
Mission 1Evaluate
Is Bentham's act utilitarianism a good guide?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Bentham's act utilitarianism is a good way to decide what is right.
For: Simple and practical; based on something everyone recognises (pleasure and pain); every person counts equally.
For: Looks at real consequences; secular, so usable by anyone; inspired real reforms (and includes animals).
Against: Can justify injustice: harming an innocent minority if the majority gain enough pleasure.
Against: Consequences are hard to predict; pleasures are hard to measure and compare; motives and rights seem to count for nothing.
Judgement criteria: Can pleasure be measured? Does justice for individuals matter more than totals? Is pleasure really the only good?
Mission 1Worked answer
Using the calculus
Task: explain how Bentham's hedonic calculus would decide whether a town should replace a park with a car park.
Point: Bentham would compare the pleasure and pain each option produces for everyone affected.
Apply the factors: extent (many shoppers vs local families), duration (permanent loss of green space), fecundity (exercise and community events lead to further pleasures), purity (pollution afterwards).
Develop: The option with the greater balance of pleasure over pain is right. No act is right in itself: this is act utilitarianism.
Link: The answer could change with the facts (no act is right or wrong in itself), which is both a strength (flexibility) and a weakness (uncertainty).
Mission check
?A city council can afford either a big fireworks festival or a free vaccination clinic. Which reasoning is Bentham's act utilitarianism?
Bentham's answer might well be the clinic. But he would reach it by adding up pleasure and pain, not by ranking kinds of pleasure.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Are some pleasures worth more than others, and when may society stop you chasing yours?
Make a guess: Are some pleasures worth more than others, and when may society stop you chasing yours?
Mission 2
Mill and the "pig philosophy" objection
John Stuart Mill (1806–1873), raised by his father James Mill as a utilitarian; Bentham was a family friend.
Works: On Liberty (1859); Utilitarianism (magazine 1861, book 1863); The Subjection of Women (1869).
Critics mocked Bentham's theory as "a doctrine worthy only of swine": if all pleasures are equal, a pig's contentment is as good as a human life.
Mill keeps the greatest happiness principle, but argues that pleasures differ in quality, not only quantity.
Mission 2
Higher and lower pleasures
Step 1 of 3
Higher pleasures: of the mind: intellect, imagination, feelings, moral sentiments (learning, art, friendship, doing good).
Lower pleasures: of the body: food, drink, sex, rest.
Higher pleasures are worth more in kind: a small amount can outweigh a large amount of lower pleasure.
Competent judges: the test is what people who have experienced both prefer.
Mill does not say lower pleasures are bad. They matter; they are simply not the best.
Mission 2Read the source
Socrates dissatisfied
Mill, Utilitarianism (1863), chapter 2:
> "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied."
Mill adds (paraphrase): if the fool or the pig thinks otherwise, it is because they know only their own side of the question.
Q1 Why does Mill trust Socrates' judgement over the fool's?
Show answer
Socrates has experienced both kinds of pleasure; the fool only one.
Q2 What does "dissatisfied" admit about higher pleasures?
Show answer
They can bring frustration; their value is in quality, not ease.
Quick check
?According to Mill, how do we know which of two pleasures is the higher one?
Mission 2
The harm principle
On Liberty (1859), chapter 1:
> "…the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others."
Society may not compel you for your own good: it may advise, persuade and warn.
Liberty of thought and speech, of tastes and pursuits, and of association.
Mill's example (paraphrase): you may stop someone stepping onto an unsafe bridge if there is no time to warn them; if they know the risk, the choice is theirs.
Why it is utilitarian: free people develop themselves and discover new truths, which increases happiness in the long run.
Quick check
?Which law can Mill's harm principle justify most clearly?
Mission 2
Mill the reformer
The Subjection of Women (1869): the legal subordination of women is wrong and holds back human happiness.
As an MP, Mill proposed votes for women in the debates on the Reform Act 1867 (defeated).
Defended freedom of speech, representative government and wider education.
Change in law and social attitudes: Mill's arguments are still used for decriminalising private conduct that harms no one else.
Mission 2Evaluate
The sovereignty of the individual
Step 1 of 4
Mill: "Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign." (On Liberty, chapter 1)
Claim: In ethics, the individual should be sovereign over their own life.
For: Respects autonomy; people know their own good best; protects minorities from the majority's tastes.
Against: Few acts affect only oneself (addiction, suicide and their effects on families); the vulnerable may need protection; many Christians hold that life is a gift held in trust from God (sanctity of life).
Judgement criteria: Is any act truly "self-regarding"? Who decides what counts as harm? Can sovereignty and community be balanced?
Mission 2
Rules from experience
Objection to Bentham: there is no time to calculate before every act.
Mill (paraphrase): humanity has been learning the effects of actions throughout its history. Those lessons are stored in secondary principles (rules such as "do not lie", "keep promises").
Sailors do not calculate the stars before every voyage; they take the Nautical Almanac, already calculated (Utilitarianism, chapter 2).
So in normal life we follow the rules; the principle of utility settles conflicts between them.
Mission 2
Rule utilitarianism: strong and weak
Rule utilitarianism: an act is right if it follows a rule which, if generally followed, produces the greatest happiness.
Strong rule utilitarianism: never break a well-founded rule, even when breaking it would bring more happiness this time.
Weak rule utilitarianism: follow the rules normally, but break one in an exceptional case where obeying would clearly cause more harm.
Example: "do not lie" maximises trust in general. Strong: keep it always. Weak: may lie to save a life.
Quick check
?A doctor's rule is to keep patients' information confidential. Which describes a weak rule utilitarian doctor?
Mission 2
Was Mill a rule utilitarian?
Mill never uses the term. "Rule utilitarianism" was named in the 20th century; J. O. Urmson (1953) argued Mill held a version of it.
Others read Mill as an act utilitarian who used rules as rules of thumb.
Either way, Mill gives rules a far bigger place than Bentham.
Mission 2Evaluate
Is rule utilitarianism better than act utilitarianism?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Rule utilitarianism is a better basis for moral decisions than act utilitarianism.
For: Protects justice and rights (no punishing the innocent for the majority's pleasure); quicker; predictable; promotes trust and the common good.
Against: J. J. C. Smart (1956): if a rule should be broken whenever breaking it produces more happiness, rule utilitarianism collapses into act utilitarianism; if not, it is irrational "rule worship".
Against (higher pleasures): who decides what is "higher"? The ranking can look elitist and culturally biased.
Judgement criteria: Can rules be justified only by consequences? What about exceptional cases? Does it promote justice better?
Mission check
?A council can fund either a free library with evening classes, or more free fast-food vouchers that would give more people more total pleasure. Which response is Mill's?
Mill changed utilitarianism twice: some pleasures are higher, and rules and liberty matter. Critics ask whether he is still a utilitarian at all.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If one person's suffering would make thousands happier, must a utilitarian say yes?
Make a guess: If one person's suffering would make thousands happier, must a utilitarian say yes?
Mission 3
Preference utilitarianism
Step 1 of 2
Maximise the satisfaction of preferences (or interests), not pleasure: what people would choose, on reflection.
R. M. Hare (1919–2002), Moral Thinking (1981): put yourself in the place of everyone affected.
Peter Singer (b. 1946), Animal Liberation (1975), Practical Ethics (1979; 3rd edition 2011): equal consideration of interests.
Any being that can suffer has interests, so animals count. Favouring humans simply for being human is speciesism.
Respects choices that do not maximise pleasure (e.g. a person who prefers truth to comfort).
Quick check
?Mira, fully informed, refuses a treatment that would make her feel better, because it would cloud her mind and she prefers to stay clear-headed. Which form of utilitarianism most clearly supports respecting her choice?
Mission 3Read the source
Mill and the golden rule
Mill, Utilitarianism (1863; text of the 7th edition, 1879), chapter 2:
> "In the golden rule of Jesus of Nazareth, we read the complete spirit of the ethics of utility. To do as one would be done by, and to love one's neighbour as oneself, constitute the ideal perfection of utilitarian morality."
William Paley (1743–1805), The Principles of Moral and Political Philosophy (1785) (paraphrase): God wills the happiness of his creatures, so doing good to others in obedience to God is virtue: a theological utilitarianism.
Q1 Which two biblical commands does Mill link to utility?
Show answer
The golden rule, Matthew 7:12; love your neighbour, Leviticus 19:18 and Mark 12:31.
Q2 How does Paley ground utility differently from Bentham?
Show answer
In God's will and eternal happiness, not only in nature's "two masters".
Mission 3Diversity
Christian utilitarianism?
Compatible: concern for the neighbour's welfare; Jesus healing and feeding crowds; Fletcher's "agapeic calculus" (see Mission 5); Paley's theological utilitarianism.
Incompatible: Paul rejects doing evil "that good may come" (Romans 3:8); some acts are wrong in themselves (Catholic teaching, Veritatis Splendor 1993); sanctity of life: every person has a worth that cannot be traded.
Different goal: Christian ethics aims at holiness and love of God, not only happiness in this life.
Many Protestant ethicists use consequences as one factor among others; Catholic moral theology rejects pure consequentialism.
Spec: "Christian utilitarianism".
Mission 3
Can pleasure be measured?
Problems: pleasures are subjective; different kinds cannot be put on one scale; consequences are hard to predict; how far ahead should we count?
Problems: who counts? Future generations, animals, people far away?
Replies: rough estimates are enough for most choices; rules store past experience (Mill's almanac); preferences can be asked about and compared.
Practice: modern health systems measure "quality-adjusted life years" to compare treatments: a utilitarian kind of measure.
Mission 3
Utilitarianism in today's world
Public policy: cost–benefit analysis in transport, health and climate decisions; triage in emergencies.
Effective altruism: Singer, The Life You Can Save (2009): give where it reduces the most suffering.
Law and social attitudes: Bentham and Mill's arguments shaped reforms on punishment, voting, women's rights and private conduct.
"Ethics of the planet"? For: it is the shared language of governments, economists and global charities. Against: human rights (the 1948 Universal Declaration) set limits on what totals can justify; most of the world's people still decide moral questions through religious traditions.
Quick check
?Which is the strongest form of the objection that utilitarianism can justify injustice?
Mission 3Evaluate
Is utilitarianism a helpful method?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Utilitarianism provides a helpful method of moral decision-making.
For: Clear principle; impartial ("everybody to count for one"); takes real consequences seriously; usable by believers and non-believers alike; adaptable (rule, preference).
For: Has driven reforms widely seen as progress; extends concern to animals and distant strangers.
Against: Can justify injustice to minorities; ignores motives, rights and special duties (to family, promises).
Against: Measurement and prediction problems; no intrinsic wrongs: no act is wrong in itself, so any act could be permitted if the consequences are good enough; may encourage immoral acts "for the greater good".
Judgement criteria: Is pleasure (or preference) the only intrinsic good? Does it promote justice? Can it work in contemporary society? Is it compatible with religious ethics?
Line of argument: the claim is strong against act utilitarianism, weaker against rule utilitarianism.
Support: Bentham's calculus could approve punishing an innocent person if enough people gain.
Counter: Mill's rules (e.g. fair trials) maximise happiness generally; a weak rule utilitarian keeps them in almost all cases.
Critique of the counter: Smart: then either rules collapse into act utilitarianism, or they become "rule worship".
Judgement: decided by your own criteria (e.g. can rules be justified only by consequences?), stated and defended.
Mission check
?A hospital could secretly test a new drug on one unwilling patient, and the results would save thousands. Which statement about utilitarian responses is accurate?
Utilitarians do not all say yes. But they all answer by asking about consequences, which is exactly what their critics question.
Mission 4
Mission 4: If love is the only rule, does a Christian still need any other moral rules?
Make a guess: If love is the only rule, does a Christian still need any other moral rules?
Mission 4
Three ways to make a moral decision
Step 1 of 3
Joseph Fletcher (1905–1991), American Episcopal priest and ethicist; Situation Ethics: The New Morality (1966).
Legalism: fixed rules decide in advance, for every case. Fletcher: it puts the law before people (his examples: some Pharisees; rigid Catholic and Protestant moral codes).
Antinomianism ("against law"): no rules or principles at all; each decision is spontaneous. Fletcher: it is unprincipled and chaotic.
Situationism: the middle way. Enter each situation with the moral rules of your community as guides, but set any of them aside if love is better served.
Mission 4
The "new morality" of the 1960s
After 1945, many in Britain and America questioned inherited authority: in church, family, sexual morality and law.
John A. T. Robinson (1919–1983), Bishop of Woolwich, Honest to God (1963), chapter 6, "The New Morality": Christians should be guided by love alone, not by a code handed down from above.
Robinson drew on Bonhoeffer, Tillich and Bultmann; he gave evidence for the defence in the 1960 Lady Chatterley's Lover trial.
Fletcher's book three years later turned the idea into a method.
Mission 4
Agape: a love that is chosen
Greek has several words for love (the New Testament mainly uses agape and philia). C. S. Lewis, The Four Loves (1960), describes four: storge (affection), philia (friendship), eros (romantic love), agape (self-giving love; Lewis calls it "charity").
Agape is the love of God shown in Jesus: unconditional, self-giving, for every neighbour, including enemies.
Fletcher: agape is an act of the will, not a feeling. It is not the same as liking someone.
It always seeks the neighbour's good, and it can be "calculating": it thinks hard about consequences.
Mission 4Read the source
Love in Luke and Paul
Asked what the law requires, a lawyer gives the two great commandments, ending "…and your neighbour as yourself." He asks, "Who is my neighbour?" Jesus tells of a Samaritan who cares for a wounded Jewish traveller after a priest and a Levite pass by (Luke 10:25–36). Then:
> He said, "He who showed mercy on him." Then Jesus said to him, "Go and do likewise." (Luke 10:37, World English Bible, British Edition)
> Love is patient and is kind. (1 Corinthians 13:4)
> But now faith, hope, and love remain—these three. The greatest of these is love. (1 Corinthians 13:13)
Q1 Why might Fletcher use this parable?
Show answer
On one common reading, the priest and Levite let religious rules or caution come first; the Samaritan put the wounded man's need first.
Q2 In 1 Corinthians 13, what is love compared with?
Show answer
Faith and hope: love is the greatest.
Mission 4
Jesus and Paul: situationists?
Sabbath: Jesus defends his hungry disciples for picking grain, citing David eating the holy bread (Mark 2:23–26; 1 Samuel 21:1–6).
> "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath." (Mark 2:27)
He heals on the Sabbath, asking whether it is lawful to do good or harm (Mark 3:1–6).
The whole law hangs on love of God and neighbour (Matthew 22:37–40).
Paul: "Love therefore is the fulfilment of the law." (Romans 13:10)
But: Jesus also says he came not to abolish the law but to fulfil it (Matthew 5:17), and makes some rules stricter (divorce, Mark 10:2–12). Whether Jesus was a situationist is disputed.
Quick check
?A hospital policy says visitors must leave at 8 p.m. A nurse lets a man stay past 8 p.m. with his dying wife, while still enforcing the policy for other visitors. Which approach does the nurse's decision best illustrate?
Mission 4
The boss principle and four working principles
Pragmatism: a moral choice must work in practice, towards love's goal.
Relativism: rules are relative to the situation; but always relative to love, which is not relative. ("Relative", not "anything goes".)
Positivism: love is accepted by faith, as a free commitment, not proved by reason ("theological positivism"). Christians start from "God is love" (1 John 4:8).
Personalism: people, not laws or things, are at the centre. Ask "who is helped?", not "what is the rule?"
Mission 4
The six propositions
Step 1 of 2
Fletcher's six propositions (paraphrase):
1. Only love is intrinsically good; nothing else is good in itself.
2. Love is the ruling norm of Christian decision; it replaces all laws.
3. Love and justice are the same: justice is love distributed to everyone affected.
4. Love wills the neighbour's good, whether we like them or not.
5. Only the end (love) justifies the means.
6. Love decides situationally, not by rules prescribed in advance.
Quick check
?A situationist says: "Agape cannot be shared only with those close to me; it must be weighed out fairly among everyone affected." Which of Fletcher's propositions is this?
Mission 4
Conscience: a verb, not a noun
Fletcher rejects conscience as a thing (noun): an inner voice, a faculty, or a store of rules.
Conscience is what we do (verb): the work of making a decision, creatively, in a real situation.
It looks forward (deciding what to do), not mainly backward (guilt over what was done).
So there is no ready-made answer inside us; each person must work out what love requires.
Mission 4
What kind of theory?
Teleological: judges an act by its end (telos): love.
Consequentialist: what makes an act right is its loving outcome for the people involved.
Relativist: the right act varies with the situation, though love itself is absolute.
Christian: Fletcher presents it as Christian ethics; love is the one absolute, accepted by faith.
Unlike utilitarianism, the good to be maximised is agape, not pleasure (comparison in Mission 5).
Mission 4Worked answer
Explaining the theory
Step 1 of 3
Task: explain why Fletcher saw situation ethics as a middle way.
Point: Fletcher rejected legalism (rules before people) and antinomianism (no principles at all).
Scholar and source: He made agape the only absolute (Situation Ethics, 1966), drawing on Jesus: "The Sabbath was made for man" (Mark 2:27).
Develop: Rules remain useful guides from the community's experience, but love may set them aside, as the Samaritan put the wounded man's need first (Luke 10:37).
Link: So the theory is relativist in method but has one fixed norm, which is why Fletcher calls it a middle way.
Mission check
?A school forbids phones in exams. A student whose mother is in hospital asks to keep hers switched on with the invigilator. Which comment is most clearly situationist reasoning?
For Fletcher, rules are like a map drawn from past journeys. Use it, but if love sees a better path in this place, take it.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Is "do the most loving thing" a guide anyone can use, or does it ask too much of us?
Make a guess: Is "do the most loving thing" a guide anyone can use, or does it ask too much of us?
Mission 5
How to apply situation ethics
Step 1 of 4
1. The situation: what exactly is happening, and what is at stake?
2. The people: who is affected? (personalism: persons, not rules, come first.)
3. The rules: what guidance does the community's experience give? (useful, not binding.)
4. Love's verdict: which choice brings the most agape to everyone affected? (pragmatism, relativism, with love as the one absolute.)
Fletcher's answers can differ from case to case, by design.
Mission 5
Fletcher's own case: Mrs Bergmeier
From Fletcher's book (paraphrase): at the end of the Second World War, a German mother is held in a Soviet camp in Ukraine. Her husband and children, back in Berlin, are searching for her.
Only the sick and the pregnant are being released. She asks a guard to make her pregnant; she is released and reunited with her family.
The family welcome the baby, and love him for what he did for them.
Fletcher asks: did she do right? The rule against adultery is set beside the good of her husband, her children and the new child.
Fletcher's point is the question, not a fixed answer: legalism cannot even see the dilemma.
Quick check
?When Fletcher judges Mrs Bergmeier's choice, which question is the situationist's main test?
Mission 5
Situation ethics and utilitarianism
Similar: both are teleological and consequentialist; both judge acts case by case; both reject fixed rules as final.
Fletcher borrows the utilitarian procedure: an "agapeic calculus", seeking the greatest amount of neighbour welfare for the largest number of neighbours (paraphrase).
Different: the good maximised is agape, not pleasure or happiness.
Different: Fletcher's starting point is a faith commitment (positivism); utilitarianism claims to rest on observable facts about pleasure and pain.
Your spec: "the relationship between situation ethics and utilitarianism".
Mission 5Read the source
Barclay's critique
William Barclay (1907–1978), Scottish New Testament scholar, Ethics in a Permissive Society (1971), chapter 4 (paraphrase):
Agrees: love is central; rigid legalism is wrong; morality needs freedom.
Extreme cases: most of Fletcher's examples are extraordinary. Ordinary life needs ordinary rules; hard cases do not show we can do without law.
Too much freedom: deciding everything alone, with no ready answer, is a burden most people are not ready to carry.
People need law: as a child is trained by habit, people need rules; without love, freedom easily becomes licence.
Grace is missing: Fletcher says little about God's power to change people.
Q1 What does Barclay accept from Fletcher?
Show answer
Love is central; legalism is wrong.
Q2 Why does he think law is still needed?
Show answer
Most people do not want total freedom; rules train us, and freedom without love becomes licence.
Quick check
?Which criticism of situation ethics does Barclay make?
Mission 5
Is Fletcher's agape really religious?
Religious, yes: agape comes from the New Testament (1 Corinthians 13; Luke 10); positivism means accepting "God is love" by faith.
Not really: the method never needs God; love could mean "wanting the best for the person involved". A humanist could use it unchanged.
Fletcher himself later left Christian belief and was named Humanist of the Year by the American Humanist Association (1974).
Individualistic and subjective? Without absolute rules, each person decides alone; two people may reach opposite "loving" answers.
Reply: love is not whatever I feel; it is judged by its effects on others, and community rules still guide.
Mission 5Diversity
How churches responded
Catholic: Pope Pius XII criticised "situation ethics" in 1952, and the Holy Office (1956) forbade it in Catholic teaching; Veritatis Splendor (1993) teaches that some acts are always wrong.
Protestant critics: Paul Ramsey, Deeds and Rules in Christian Ethics (1967): love itself needs rules ("rule agapism").
Liberal Protestants: Robinson and others welcomed the stress on persons over codes.
Evangelicals: generally reject it: scripture's commands are God's revealed will, not optional guides.
Mission 5Evaluate
Is situation ethics a helpful method?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Situation ethics is a helpful method of moral decision-making.
For: Person-centred; flexible in hard cases; avoids legalism's cruelty; one clear principle; rooted in Jesus' ethic of love.
Against: Consequences are hard to predict; love's verdict is subjective; it can seem to justify adultery or killing (Barclay; Pius XII).
Against: It may promote immoral behaviour by those who rationalise their wishes as "love"; it may be humanism with Christian words.
Judgement criteria: Can ordinary people use it day to day? Is agape the only intrinsic good? Does it keep what religious rules protect? Does it need God?
Quick check
?Which strength of situation ethics does even Barclay, a critic, accept?
Mission check
?Priya, a manager, finds that a colleague has made a small false expense claim. Out of love for his struggling family, she keeps quiet. Which response is a criticism of situation ethics in Barclay's style?
Barclay's challenge is not that love is wrong. It is that ordinary people need rules to learn to love well. Weigh that against Fletcher's hard cases.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Utilitarianism is teleological and consequentialist: the right act produces the greatest happiness of the greatest number. For Bentham, pleasure is the only good, measured by quantity.
The hedonic calculus: intensity, duration, certainty, propinquity, fecundity, purity, extent. Act utilitarianism judges each act afresh (relativist).
Mission 2
Mill: pleasures differ in quality; higher (mental) pleasures outweigh lower (bodily) ones, by the verdict of competent judges.
Harm principle: power over a person is justified only to prevent harm to others. Rule utilitarianism (strong and weak) follows rules that maximise happiness; critics say it collapses into act utilitarianism or becomes rule worship.
The individual is sovereign over self: a contested ideal.
Mission 3
Preference utilitarianism (Hare, Singer) satisfies interests, and animals count. Evaluation: measurement, prediction, justice for minorities, no act wrong in itself; rule and preference forms reply in part.
Christian utilitarianism: Mill's golden rule and Paley's theology; critics cite Romans 3:8, intrinsic wrongs and the sanctity of life.
Mission 4
Fletcher's situation ethics (1966) is a middle way between legalism and antinomianism; Robinson's "new morality" (1963) is its setting.
Agape (self-giving love, willed not felt) is the only absolute: the boss principle; the four working principles are pragmatism, relativism, positivism and personalism; the six propositions explain love's role.
Conscience is a verb: the act of deciding. Fletcher drew on Jesus (Luke 10; Mark 2:27) and Paul (1 Corinthians 13; Romans 13:10).
Mission 5
Applying situation ethics: the situation, the people, the rules as guides, then love's verdict.
Close to utilitarianism in method (an "agapeic calculus"), but the good is agape. Critics: Barclay (extreme cases; the need for law; too much freedom), Catholic teaching (Pius XII, Veritatis Splendor), Ramsey; is agape really religious, and is the method subjective?
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Teleological approaches to moral decision making for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1Could right and wrong be worked out like a sum of pleasures and pains?
Mission 2Are some pleasures worth more than others, and when may society stop you chasing yours?
Mission 3If one person's suffering would make thousands happier, must a utilitarian say yes?
Mission 4If love is the only rule, does a Christian still need any other moral rules?
Mission 5Is "do the most loving thing" a guide anyone can use, or does it ask too much of us?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.