← A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · A2 7: Synoptic theme: Conscience, Freedom and Tolerance
Mini-Lesson

Synoptic theme: Conscience, Freedom and Tolerance

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If your conscience tells you to do something wrong, should you still follow it?
  2. Mission 2Is guilt the voice of God, of reason, or of your parents, and should you trust it?
  3. Mission 3When the law and your conscience clash, who should win, and can religion make people more tolerant?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If your conscience tells you to do something wrong, should you still follow it?

Make a guess: If your conscience tells you to do something wrong, should you still follow it?

Mission 1

What is conscience?

Before and afteractBeforeAfter!warnurgeapprove/guiltconscience works at both times
  • Conscience (Latin con-scientia, "knowing with"): our awareness of right and wrong in our own actions.
  • It works before an act (warning, urging) and after it (approval, or guilt and shame).
  • Three big questions:
  • Where does it come from? God, reason, upbringing, society, evolution?
  • Is it reliable? Can it be wrong?
  • Must I obey it? Even against the law, or a religious authority?
  • Religious and non-religious thinkers answer differently.
Mission 1

Aquinas: ratio

Aquinas' ladderConscientiaact: judging this caseST I q.79 a.13can errSynderesishabit: do good, avoid evilST I q.79 a.12Ratioreason, image of GodGenesis 1:27
  • Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologica (1265–1274), I, question 79, articles 12–13.
  • Ratio (reason): placed in every person as a result of being created in the image of God.

> "God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27, WEBBE)

  • For Aquinas the image of God lies above all in our reason: we can know what is good (link: natural law).
  • So, for Aquinas, conscience is not a feeling or a voice: it is reason at work on moral questions.
Mission 1

Synderesis and conscientia

Aquinas' ladderConscientiaact: judging this caseST I q.79 a.13can errSynderesishabit: do good, avoid evilST I q.79 a.12Ratioreason, image of GodGenesis 1:27
  • Synderesis: an inner principle directing a person towards good and away from evil.
  • It holds the first principle of morality: "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided" (ST I-II q.94 a.2).
  • Aquinas: "'Synderesis' is not a power but a habit" (ST I q.79 a.12): a natural, built-in disposition.
  • Conscientia: a person's reason making moral judgements about particular acts: applying synderesis to "this, here, now".
  • Synderesis does not err about the first principle; conscientia can err, through faulty reasoning or wrong information.
Mission 1Read the source

Conscience as an act

Aquinas, Summa Theologica I q.79 a.13 (English Dominican translation, 1920):

> "Properly speaking, conscience is not a power, but an act."

> "For conscience is said to witness, to bind, or incite, and also to accuse, torment, or rebuke."

And the Bible text Aquinas and other Christians draw on:

> "they show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience testifying with them, and their thoughts amongst themselves accusing or else excusing them" (Romans 2:15, WEBBE)

Q1 Name one thing conscience does before an act and one after.

Show answer

Before: binds or incites; after: witnesses, accuses or excuses.

Q2 Why does Romans 2:15 matter for the claim that conscience is universal?

Show answer

Paul says even Gentiles without the law have it "written in their hearts".

Quick check
?Maya knows that she should be fair to others. She reasons that copying her friend's homework would be unfair to the rest of the class, so she decides not to copy it. Which part of Aquinas' account is her decision?
Mission 1

When conscience gets it wrong

Ignorance forkErring consciencestill bindsWas the ignorance your fault?yesnoVinciblenot excusedInvincibleexcusedST I-II q.19 aa.5–6
  • Erring conscience still binds (ST I-II q.19 a.5): acting against your conscience is always wrong, even when conscience is mistaken.
  • But does a mistaken conscience excuse? It depends on the ignorance (q.19 a.6):
  • Vincible ignorance: lack of knowledge for which a person is responsible: they could and should have known (e.g. a doctor who did not read the patient's notes).
  • Invincible ignorance: lack of knowledge for which a person is not responsible: they could not have known (Aquinas' example: a man deceived, without any negligence, into thinking another woman is his wife).
  • Vincible ignorance does not excuse; invincible ignorance does.
  • Aquinas notes whole cultures can err: Julius Caesar reported that the ancient Germans did not think robbery wrong (ST I-II q.94 a.4).
Mission 1Diversity

Other religious views

Views of conscienceReligiousAquinasc. 1225–1274Butler1692–1752Newman1801–1890Catholic teachingGaudium et Spes,1965LutherWorms, 1521Fletcherconscience as a verbNon-religiousFreud1856–1939Fromm1900–1980Piaget1896–1980DarwinDescent of Man,1871Humanistsreason and empathy
  • Joseph Butler (1692–1752), Fifteen Sermons (1726): conscience is the God-given supreme principle of reflection in human nature:

> "Had it strength, as it had right; had it power, as it had manifest authority, it would absolutely govern the world." (Sermon II)

  • John Henry Newman (1801–1890), Letter to the Duke of Norfolk (1875): "Conscience is the aboriginal Vicar of Christ": the voice of God within.
  • Catholic teaching today: conscience is a law written by God in the heart, where a person is alone with God; it must be informed by reason and the Church's teaching (Vatican II, Gaudium et Spes 16, 1965; Catechism 1776–1785, paraphrase).
  • Protestant emphasis: conscience bound by scripture; Luther at Worms (1521) said his conscience was "captive to the Word of God".
  • Joseph Fletcher: conscience is a verb: the activity of deciding, not a store of rules.
Mission 1

Non-religious ideas

Views of conscienceReligiousAquinasc. 1225–1274Butler1692–1752Newman1801–1890Catholic teachingGaudium et Spes,1965LutherWorms, 1521Fletcherconscience as a verbNon-religiousFreud1856–1939Fromm1900–1980Piaget1896–1980DarwinDescent of Man,1871Humanistsreason and empathy
  • Sigmund Freud (1856–1939): conscience is part of the super-ego: rules of parents and society taken in during childhood.
  • Erich Fromm (1900–1980), Man for Himself (1947): authoritarian conscience is the inner voice of an outside authority we fear; humanistic conscience is our own voice calling us back to grow as persons.
  • Jean Piaget (1896–1980), The Moral Judgment of the Child (1932): children move from heteronomous morality (rules from adults, judged by consequences) to autonomous morality (rules agreed, judged by intentions).
  • Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man (1871): a moral sense arises from social instincts plus developed intelligence (paraphrase).
  • Humanists often see conscience as reason and empathy, shaped by experience, with no need for God.
Mission 1

Conscience and moral duty

Two dutiesfollowformconscienceconscience“I shall drink—to the Pope, if youplease,—still, to Conscience first, and to thePope afterwards.”Newman, Letter to the Duke of Norfolk, §5
  • Is there a duty to follow conscience? Aquinas: yes, even when it errs; but also a duty to inform it.
  • Newman, on whether he would put the Pope before conscience:

> "I shall drink—to the Pope, if you please,—still, to Conscience first, and to the Pope afterwards." (Letter to the Duke of Norfolk, §5)

  • Duty runs both ways: a duty to follow conscience, and a duty to form it well (study, advice, prayer, honesty).
  • Following conscience against the law: conscientious objectors refusing to fight; prisoners of conscience, jailed for peaceful belief.
  • Your synoptic theme links conscience, moral duty and freedom: whether the state should respect conscience in law.
Quick check
?Priya feels sick with fear whenever she disobeys her strict older brother, even over things she believes are fine. Which idea best explains this, according to Erich Fromm?
Mission 1Evaluate

Is conscience God-given?

Argument map: is conscience God-given?Conscience is a God-given guide to rightand wrong.ForIt seems universal: every culture has amoral sense (Romans 2:15)It has authority beyond self-interest orfear (Butler, Newman)Aquinas: reason in the image of Godexplains both its reliability and its errorsAgainstConsciences differ across cultures and eras(Aquinas' ancient Germans)Natural explanations: upbringing (Freud,Piaget), evolution (Darwin), societyIf it is God's voice, why does it so oftenerr?Judge it byExplains both agreement and disagreement? ·Is a natural explanation enough? · Makesconscience trustworthy?
  • Claim: Conscience is a God-given guide to right and wrong.
  • For: It seems universal: every culture has a moral sense (Romans 2:15).
  • For: It has authority beyond self-interest or fear (Butler, Newman).
  • For: Aquinas: reason in the image of God explains both its reliability and its errors.
  • Against: Consciences differ across cultures and eras (Aquinas' own example of the ancient Germans).
  • Against: Natural explanations are available: upbringing (Freud, Piaget), evolution (Darwin), society.
  • Against: If it is God's voice, why does it so often err?
  • Judgement criteria: Does the view explain both agreement and disagreement in conscience? Is a natural explanation enough? Does it make conscience trustworthy?
Mission check

?Jonas's conscience tells him to lie to protect a friend's job. He has never stopped to ask whether lying is wrong, though he easily could have. Aquinas holds that lying is wrong. What would Aquinas say about Jonas?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Is guilt the voice of God, of reason, or of your parents, and should you trust it?

Make a guess: Is guilt the voice of God, of reason, or of your parents, and should you trust it?

Mission 2

Freud: the hidden mind

Icebergconsciousunconsciousegosuper-egoego (part)idA common simplification:Freud's own diagrams vary
  • Sigmund Freud (1856–1939), Austrian founder of psychoanalysis; The Ego and the Id (1923); Civilization and Its Discontents (1930).
  • Much of mental life is unconscious: desires and memories we cannot see directly, which still shape what we feel and do.
  • For Freud, conscience is not reason, and not God's voice: it is part of a structure built in early childhood.
  • Freud was an atheist: in The Future of an Illusion (1927) he called religion an illusion rooted in the wish for a protecting father.
  • His method: explain moral feeling, especially guilt, by its psychological origins.
Mission 2

Id, ego and super-ego

Three-part mindIdinstinctive impulsesseeking pleasureSuper-egointernalised ideals;tries to make the egobehave morallyEgomediates between the id, thesuper-ego and realityreality
  • Id: instinctive impulses that seek satisfaction in pleasure; present from birth; wholly unconscious.
  • Ego: mediates between the id and the demands of social interaction and reality; mostly conscious.
  • Super-ego: contradicts the id and, working on internalised ideals from parents and society, tries to make the ego behave morally.
  • The super-ego has two sides: the ego-ideal (who I should be) and conscience (what I must not do, punished by guilt).
  • Moral life is a struggle among the three, much of it unconscious.
Mission 2Read the source

The rider and the judge

Freud, The Ego and the Id (1923), chapters 2, 3 and 5 (paraphrase):

  • The ego is like a rider on a horse: it has to hold in check the greater strength of the id; often the rider can only guide the horse where it wants to go anyway.
  • The super-ego keeps the character of the father; the stronger the early authority, the more severely the super-ego later rules the ego as conscience or as an unconscious sense of guilt.
  • The sense of guilt is the tension between the ego and the super-ego's demands; it can be fierce even when the person has done nothing wrong.

Q1 Why is the super-ego called "heir" of childhood authority?

Show answer

It takes over the parents' commands and punishments inside the mind.

Q2 According to Freud, does strong guilt prove a real wrong was done?

Show answer

No: guilt measures super-ego tension, not wrongdoing.

Quick check
?Daniel finds a wallet full of cash. He wants to keep it, but hears his late father's voice saying "Thieves are worthless." He decides to hand it in, telling himself it may earn him a reward. Which part of Freud's model makes the final decision?
Mission 2

Guilt: Aquinas and Freud

Two routes to guiltAquinaswrong actconscientia accusesrepentanceFreudsuper-ego tensionguilt (conscious orunconscious)analysis
  • Aquinas: guilt follows when conscientia accuses after a wrong act (ST I q.79 a.13). It is a rational verdict: it can be checked, corrected and resolved by repentance and forgiveness.
  • Freud: guilt is the super-ego's aggression turned on the ego. It may be unconscious, irrational and out of proportion; resolved by understanding its origins in analysis.
  • Healthy and unhealthy guilt: Aquinas would say guilt over a real wrong is fitting; Freud warns that guilt is often excessive (as in obsessional neurosis and melancholia).
  • Both agree guilt can mislead: for Aquinas through an erring conscience; for Freud through a harsh super-ego.
Mission 2Diversity

Aquinas and Freud compared

Comparison tableSourceAquinasreason, placed in us asthe image of GodFreudparents and society,taken in duringchildhoodGodAquinaspresent: synderesis ispart of God's designFreudabsent: God is itself aprojection of thefather; the super-egoexplains the "voice"Moral decision-makingAquinasconscious reasoningfrom first principles toa caseFreudthe ego negotiatingbetween id, super-egoand reality, largelyunconsciousCan it err?Aquinasyes (conscientia,through ignorance orbad reasoning)Freudyes (super-ego can beharsh, outdated orneurotic)Common groundconscience is formed over time; guilt is notalways a reliable guide
  • Source: Aquinas: reason, placed in us as the image of God · Freud: parents and society, taken in during childhood.
  • God: Aquinas: present: synderesis is part of God's design · Freud: absent: God is itself a projection of the father; the super-ego explains the "voice".
  • Moral decision-making: Aquinas: conscious reasoning from first principles to a case · Freud: the ego negotiating between id, super-ego and reality, largely unconscious.
  • Can it err? Aquinas: yes (conscientia, through ignorance or bad reasoning) · Freud: yes (super-ego can be harsh, outdated or neurotic).
  • Common ground: conscience is formed over time; guilt is not always a reliable guide.
Mission 2

Does conscience exist at all?

Umbrellaconscience?cultureenvironmentgenetic predispositioneducation
  • Some argue "conscience" is an umbrella term: a name for many factors involved in moral decisions, not one faculty.
  • Factors: culture (moral norms differ), environment (family, peers), genetic predisposition (twin studies of empathy and self-control), education.
  • On this view, asking "what does my conscience say?" means "what do my upbringing, culture and reasoning together incline me to?"
  • Replies: Aquinas would say these factors shape conscientia, but synderesis, the shared first principle, is universal. Butler: conscience has authority, not just influence.
  • A middle view: conscience is real as an activity (judging one's own acts), even if it has many sources (compare Fletcher).
Mission 2Evaluate

Is conscience a good moral guide?

Argument map: is conscience a good moral guide?Conscience is a reliable guide to moraldecisions.ForPersonal and immediate, with authorityover self-interest (Butler)It can resist unjust orders: FranzJägerstätter (1907–1943) refused to fightfor Hitler’s armyAn informed conscience joins principle andsituation (Aquinas)AgainstCan be shaped by prejudice: Huck Finn'sconscience tells him to turn in Jim (Twain,1884)Freud: the super-ego can be harsh,irrational or outdatedConsciences conflict; sincerity does notsettle who is rightJudge it byIs it informed? · Is it checked against reason,others and (for believers) scripture andtradition? · Source or tool?
  • Claim: Conscience is a reliable guide to moral decisions.
  • For: It is personal and immediate, and has authority over self-interest (Butler).
  • For: It can resist unjust orders: e.g. Franz Jägerstätter (1907–1943), an Austrian Catholic farmer executed for refusing to fight for Hitler's army; beatified 2007.
  • For: An informed conscience joins principle and situation (Aquinas).
  • Against: Conscience can be shaped by prejudice. In Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn (1884, ch. 31), Huck's conscience tells him to turn in Jim, an enslaved man; he decides to help Jim instead: "All right, then, I'll go to hell."
  • Against: Freud: the super-ego can be harsh, irrational or outdated.
  • Against: Consciences conflict; sincerity does not settle who is right.
  • Judgement criteria: Is conscience informed? Is it checked against reason, others and (for believers) scripture and tradition? Is it a source or a tool?
Quick check
?Huck Finn's conscience tells him that helping an enslaved man escape is wrong, but he helps him anyway. What does the case most clearly show?
Mission check

?Sofia feels intense guilt for months after a minor car accident, although she was driving carefully and the crash was not her fault. How would Aquinas and Freud each read her guilt?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When the law and your conscience clash, who should win, and can religion make people more tolerant?

Make a guess: When the law and your conscience clash, who should win, and can religion make people more tolerant?

Mission 3

Conscience: the theme's starting point

Conscience: religious and secular views, and moral dutyconscienceReligious viewsSecular viewsAquinasreason: synderesis →conscientiaFreudthe super-egoButlera God-givenauthority withinFrommauthoritarian vshumanisticNewmanan echo of God'svoicePiagetmoral developmentMoral dutyKant: a good will acts from duty · Aquinas:follow conscience, and inform it well
  • Conscience: the judgement a person makes about right and wrong in a particular case.
  • Religious views: Aquinas: reason applying moral principles (synderesis → conscientia); Butler: a God-given authority within; Newman: an echo of God's voice.
  • Secular views: Freud: the super-ego, parental and social rules taken in; Fromm: authoritarian vs humanistic conscience; Piaget: moral development.
  • This theme asks a further question: what should happen when a person's conscience collides with the state, or with other people's beliefs?
Mission 3

Moral duty

Conscience: religious and secular views, and moral dutyconscienceReligious viewsSecular viewsAquinasreason: synderesis →conscientiaFreudthe super-egoButlera God-givenauthority withinFrommauthoritarian vshumanisticNewmanan echo of God'svoicePiagetmoral developmentMoral dutyKant: a good will acts from duty · Aquinas:follow conscience, and inform it well
  • A moral duty is what a person is bound to do (or not do), whether they want to or not.
  • Kant: a good will acts from duty, out of respect for the moral law, not from inclination or fear.
  • Aquinas: there is a duty to follow conscience, even if it errs, and a duty to inform it well.
  • Religion and morality: for many believers, duty comes from God (divine command, or natural law built into human nature by God). For humanists and many secular thinkers, duty comes from reason, human welfare or agreement.
  • So a clash of duties is common: duty to obey the law vs duty to follow conscience.
Mission 3Read the source

Obey rulers, or obey God?

Obey rulers, or obey God? Two verses on a balanceRomans 13:1authority comesfrom GodActs 5:29"We must obey Godrather than men."Aquinas, ST I-II q.96 a.4when is a law unjust?Unjust to humangood→ not binding inconscienceAgainst God's law→ must not be obeyed

> "Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." (Romans 13:1, WEBBE)

> "But Peter and the apostles answered, 'We must obey God rather than men.'" (Acts 5:29, WEBBE)

Aquinas defines law as "an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by him who has care of the community, and promulgated" (Summa Theologiae I-II q.90 a.4). In q.96 a.4 he adds (paraphrase): a law serving the ruler's "cupidity or vainglory" is one of the "acts of violence rather than laws" and does not bind in conscience, except to avoid scandal; a law against God's law must not be obeyed at all, citing Acts 5:29.

Q1 Which verse stresses the state's God-given authority?

Show answer

Romans 13:1.

Q2 When, for Aquinas, must a law never be obeyed?

Show answer

When it commands what is contrary to divine law, e.g. idolatry.

Quick check
?A ruler passes a tax that serves only his own luxury, not the common good. What does Aquinas say about obeying it?
Mission 3

The state and the common good

The state and the individualcommon good ⟷ personal libertyTension: the more the state protects thecommon good, the more it may limit personalliberty.Hobbes, Leviathan (1651)give up some freedom for securityAquinaslaw exists for the common goodLockethe state protects life, liberty and propertyMill, On Liberty (1859)the harm principleECHR Article 9holding a belief: absolute · manifesting it: maybe limited by law
  • Common good: the conditions that let everyone in a community, as groups and as individuals, flourish (Catholic social teaching, Gaudium et Spes 26; CCC 1906, paraphrase).
  • Aquinas (c. 1225–1274): law exists for the common good; rulers hold power to serve it.
  • Thomas Hobbes (1588–1679), Leviathan (1651): without a strong sovereign, life is "nasty, brutish, and short"; citizens give up some freedom for security.
  • John Locke (1632–1704): the state exists to protect life, liberty and property; it may be resisted if it betrays that trust.
  • Tension: the more the state protects the common good, the more it may limit personal liberty.
Mission 3

Personal liberty and its limits

The state and the individualcommon good ⟷ personal libertyTension: the more the state protects thecommon good, the more it may limit personalliberty.Hobbes, Leviathan (1651)give up some freedom for securityAquinaslaw exists for the common goodLockethe state protects life, liberty and propertyMill, On Liberty (1859)the harm principleECHR Article 9holding a belief: absolute · manifesting it: maybe limited by law
  • J. S. Mill (1806–1873), On Liberty (1859): the harm principle. Power may be used against a person's will only "to prevent harm to others". "Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign."
  • So a person's own good is not enough reason for the state to force them.
  • European Convention on Human Rights, Article 9: freedom of thought, conscience and religion. Holding a belief is absolute; manifesting it may be limited by law where necessary for public safety, order, health, morals or others' rights (paraphrase).
  • UDHR Article 18 states the same freedom; its limits come in the general clause, Article 29.
  • Critics of Mill: "harm" is hard to define; communities (and many religious thinkers) argue some shared moral goods also need protection.
Quick check
?Which law would Mill's harm principle most clearly rule out?
Mission 3

Prisoners of conscience

Amnesty's prisoner of conscience testDetained?yesBecause of belief oridentity?yesUsed or advocatedviolence?yesnot aprisonerofconsciencenoPrisoner of conscience(Amnesty)1961Peter Benenson, 'The Forgotten Prisoners',The Observer: the appeal that foundedAmnesty International
  • Term popularised by Peter Benenson (1921–2005), "The Forgotten Prisoners", The Observer, 28 May 1961: the appeal that founded Amnesty International.
  • Prisoner of conscience (Amnesty): someone jailed for their beliefs or identity (religion, politics, conscience, ethnicity, sexuality) who has not used or advocated violence.
  • Examples: Liu Xiaobo (1955–2017), Nobel Peace Prize 2010, died in custody; conscientious objectors jailed in the UK under the Military Service Act 1916 for refusing to fight.
  • Amnesty adopted Nelson Mandela as a prisoner of conscience in 1962, but withdrew that status in 1964 after his conviction for sabotage, because he would not renounce armed struggle; it continued to oppose his treatment.
  • Scriptural models: the three young men who refuse to worship the king's image (Daniel 3:16–18); the apostles (Acts 5:29).
Quick check
?Which person best fits Amnesty International's definition of a prisoner of conscience?
Mission 3

Religion as a source of tolerance

Religion: sources of tolerance and of intoleranceToleranceIntoleranceQur'an 2:256, 109:6Luke 9:54–56Matthew 5:44Locke, 1689 (but heexcluded atheists)Dignitatis Humanae,1965Corrymeela, 1965persecutionwars of religionsectarian violenceFundamentalism: from The Fundamentals(1910–1915)reaction against modern secular culture ·selective return to "fundamentals" · absoluteauthority of a text · sharp us-vs-themboundaries. Most fundamentalists are notviolent.Scholars disagree about causes: religion, orpolitics and national identity?
  • Tolerance: accepting the right of others to hold and live by beliefs you disagree with.
  • Islam: "There is no compulsion in religion." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall); "Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion." (Qur'an 109:6, Pickthall)
  • Christianity: Jesus rebukes disciples who want fire on a Samaritan village (Luke 9:54–56); love of enemies (Matthew 5:44); the Golden Rule (Matthew 7:12).
  • John Locke, A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689): faith is inward persuasion, which force cannot produce, so the state should not compel belief (paraphrase). But he excluded some: "those are not at all to be tolerated who deny the being of a God."
  • Catholic Church, Dignitatis Humanae (1965): religious freedom rests on human dignity; no one may be forced to act against conscience (paraphrase).
  • Northern Ireland: the Corrymeela Community (founded 1965 by Presbyterian chaplain Ray Davey) brings people across divides together.
Mission 3

Religion and intolerance; fundamentalism

Religion: sources of tolerance and of intoleranceToleranceIntoleranceQur'an 2:256, 109:6Luke 9:54–56Matthew 5:44Locke, 1689 (but heexcluded atheists)Dignitatis Humanae,1965Corrymeela, 1965persecutionwars of religionsectarian violenceFundamentalism: from The Fundamentals(1910–1915)reaction against modern secular culture ·selective return to "fundamentals" · absoluteauthority of a text · sharp us-vs-themboundaries. Most fundamentalists are notviolent.Scholars disagree about causes: religion, orpolitics and national identity?
  • History offers religious persecution, wars of religion and sectarian violence; scholars disagree how far religion, rather than politics or national identity, is the cause.
  • Fundamentalism: the name comes from The Fundamentals (1910–1915), essays defending core Protestant doctrines (e.g. biblical inerrancy) against liberal theology. Later applied to movements in many religions.
  • Common features (Marty and Appleby, The Fundamentalism Project, 1991–1995, paraphrase): reaction against modern secular culture; selective return to "fundamentals"; absolute authority of a text; sharp us-vs-them boundaries.
  • Karen Armstrong (b. 1944), The Battle for God (2000): fundamentalisms are modern movements, often driven by fear that secular society wants to destroy faith (paraphrase).
  • Most fundamentalists are not violent; many groups reject the label as an outsider's insult.
Quick check
?Which statement about fundamentalism is accurate?
Mission 3Evaluate

Does religion do more to promote tolerance or intolerance?

Does religion do more to promote tolerance or intolerance?Religion does more to promote intolerancethan tolerance.ForExclusive truth claims; history ofpersecution; sectarian divisionDawkins, The God Delusion (2006): beliefwithout evidence shelters extremismAgainstTexts teach non-compulsion and love ofenemies (Qur'an 2:256; Matthew 5:44)Reconciliation work (Corrymeela); violenceoften has political causes in religious dressJudge it byOne thing or many? · Religious or politicalcauses? · Teachings or actions? · Secularintolerance?
  • Claim: Religion does more to promote intolerance than tolerance.
  • For: Exclusive truth claims can make outsiders seem wrong or dangerous; history of persecution; sectarian division.
  • For: Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion (2006): even moderate faith teaches that belief without evidence is a virtue, which shelters extremism (paraphrase).
  • Against: Major texts teach non-compulsion and love of enemies (Qur'an 2:256; Matthew 5:44); religious freedom was argued for on religious grounds (Locke, Dignitatis Humanae).
  • Against: Reconciliation work (Corrymeela) and religious campaigners for others' freedom; violence often has political causes in religious dress.
  • Judgement criteria: Is "religion" one thing, or many? Are the causes religious or political? Do we judge by teachings or by followers' actions? Is secular intolerance comparable?
Mission 3

Making the synoptic link

Synoptic bridges from Conscience, Freedom and Tolerance(a) at least one other unitAS 7 medical ethicsconscientiousobjection (Doogan2014)A2 8 philosophyfreedom of belief,atheismConscience, Freedom and ToleranceHuman experiencelaw (Lee v Ashers Baking Co, 2018) · politics· Northern Ireland society(b) other aspects of human experience
  • Part (a) links this theme to at least one other unit; part (b) to other aspects of human experience.
  • Medical ethics (AS 7): conscientious objection to abortion. Doogan (UK Supreme Court, 2014): the conscience clause covers only taking part "hands-on" in treatment.
  • Philosophy of religion (A2 8): freedom of belief and atheism; Locke's exclusion of atheists.
  • Law and society: Lee v Ashers Baking Co (UK Supreme Court, 2018): a Belfast bakery could not be compelled to decorate a cake with a message (support for same-sex marriage) its owners disagreed with; no discrimination against the customer as a person was found. Some saw protection of conscience; others feared wider refusals of service.
  • Skill tip: in the synoptic (a), name the other unit and make the link explicit in each paragraph, not just at the end.
Mission check

?In a fictional country, every pupil must recite a loyalty pledge daily. A family refuses for reasons of conscience; after a peaceful protest, the parents are jailed. Which statement is accurate?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Aquinas: ratio (reason, from the image of God); synderesis (habit directing to good, away from evil); conscientia (reason judging particular acts). Erring conscience binds; vincible ignorance does not excuse, invincible does.
  • Religious views: Butler (supreme principle), Newman (voice of God), Catholic teaching (informed conscience), Fletcher (a verb). Non-religious: Freud, Fromm, Piaget, Darwin, humanists.
  • Conscience brings a duty to follow it and a duty to form it.

Mission 2

  • Freud: psychosexual stages; the super-ego, heir of the Oedipus complex, holds internalised parental and social ideals; guilt is tension between super-ego and ego, often unconscious.
  • Aquinas and Freud compared: reason v the unconscious; God present v God explained; guilt as verdict v guilt as tension. Some argue "conscience" is an umbrella term.

Mission 3

  • Conscience and moral duty can clash with the law: Romans 13:1 stresses the state's authority; Acts 5:29 and Aquinas set limits to it.
  • The state protects the common good (Aquinas, Hobbes, Locke); Mill's harm principle and ECHR Article 9 protect personal liberty; Amnesty defends prisoners of conscience who have not used violence.
  • Religion can promote tolerance (Qur'an 2:256, Locke, Dignitatis Humanae, Corrymeela) and intolerance; fundamentalism is a modern, contested category.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Synoptic theme: Conscience, Freedom and Tolerance for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If your conscience tells you to do something wrong, should you still follow it?
  2. Mission 2Is guilt the voice of God, of reason, or of your parents, and should you trust it?
  3. Mission 3When the law and your conscience clash, who should win, and can religion make people more tolerant?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA