🚀 Old Testament: The nature of God in the Old Testament; the Prophet Jeremiah; themes in the Book of Ezekiel; synoptic assessment theme: Leadership, Text and Alienation
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · A2 3 Themes in the Old Testament – The nature of God in the Old Testament; A2 3 Themes in the Old Testament – The Prophet Jeremiah; A2 3 Themes in the Old Testament – Themes in the Book of Ezekiel; A2 3 Themes in the Old Testament – Synoptic assessment theme: Leadership, Text and Alienation
Mini-Lesson
Old Testament: The nature of God in the Old Testament; the Prophet Jeremiah; themes in the Book of Ezekiel; synoptic assessment theme: Leadership, Text and Alienation
7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1One sentence about God is repeated across the Old Testament. Why did a prophet quote it in anger?
Mission 2The same scriptures call God merciful and order whole cities destroyed. How have readers made sense of that?
Mission 3A prophet stood at the Temple gate and said God would destroy it. Why was that almost a death sentence?
Mission 4A prophet told God, "You deceived me," and cursed the day he was born. Why is that in the Bible?
Mission 5Why would a prophet lie on his side for 390 days and refuse to mourn his own wife?
Mission 6When the Temple is ash and the people say "our hope is lost", what can a prophet still promise?
Mission 7Can ancient scriptures guide modern leaders and ethics, and why do they call sin a broken bond?
Mission 1
Mission 1: One sentence about God is repeated across the Old Testament. Why did a prophet quote it in anger?
Make a guess: One sentence about God is repeated across the Old Testament. Why did a prophet quote it in anger?
Mission 1
What is a creedal statement?
Step 1 of 5
A creed is a short, fixed summary of belief, said aloud by a community.
Deuteronomy 26:1–11: a farmer brings the firstfruits of the harvest to the sanctuary and recites God's saving acts.
The creed tells a story: a wandering ancestor ("My father was a Syrian ready to perish"), slavery in Egypt, a cry to God, rescue "with a mighty hand", the gift of the land (26:5–9).
God is known by what he has done: he hears, sees and rescues the oppressed (26:7).
Gerhard von Rad (1901–1971), "The Form-Critical Problem of the Hexateuch" (1938), called this a "short historical creed", one of Israel's oldest confessions (compare Deuteronomy 6:20–24; Joshua 24:2–13). Later scholars dispute its early date; many now see it as Deuteronomic.
Mission 1
Exodus 34: God reveals his name
Setting: after the golden calf (Exodus 32), the covenant is broken. Moses asks to see God's glory (33:18).
God passes by, hidden: Moses sees only his back (33:20–23). Moses brings new tablets (34:1–4).
God then "proclaimed" his name, not a story of deeds but a description of character (34:6–7).
So this is an alternative creed: who God is, not only what he has done.
Moses responds by asking forgiveness for a "stiff-necked people" (34:9).
Mission 1Read the source
The character of God
> "The LORD! The LORD, a merciful and gracious God, slow to anger, and abundant in loving kindness and truth, keeping loving kindness for thousands, forgiving iniquity and disobedience and sin; and who will by no means clear the guilty, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, and on the children's children, on the third and on the fourth generation." (Exodus 34:6–7, WEBBE)
raḥum (merciful): related to reḥem, womb: a parent's tender love.
ḥannun (gracious): undeserved favour. 'erekh 'appayim (slow to anger): literally "long of nostrils".
Mercy reaches "thousands"; punishment reaches "the third and … fourth generation": the imbalance is deliberate.
In Jewish worship these verses are the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, said on festivals and in the prayers for forgiveness before and on Yom Kippur.
Q1 Which part of the verses stresses justice rather than mercy?
Show answer
The final clause: by no means clearing the guilty; visiting iniquity on descendants.
Q2 What does "thousands" against "the fourth generation" suggest?
Show answer
Mercy far outweighs judgement.
Mission 1
The formula traced
Step 1 of 7
Numbers 14:18: after the spies' report, Moses quotes God's words back to him to plead for pardon: "slow to anger, and abundant in loving kindness". God pardons, but that generation will not enter the land (14:20–23).
Psalm 86:15: an individual in distress appeals to the formula.
Psalm 103:8: praises the merciful God and leaves out the punishment clause: "He has not dealt with us according to our sins" (103:10).
Psalm 145:8–9: widens it: "The LORD is good to all. His tender mercies are over all his works."
Joel 2:13: "Tear your heart and not your garments": the formula grounds a call to repent; God "relents from sending calamity".
Jonah 4:2: Jonah quotes it as a complaint: he fled because he knew God would spare Nineveh, Israel's enemy.
Quick check
?How does Jonah 4:1–3 use the formula of Exodus 34:6–7?
Mission 1Read the source
A struggle within the heart of God
> "When Israel was a child, then I loved him, and called my son out of Egypt." (Hosea 11:1, WEBBE)
> "How can I give you up, Ephraim? How can I hand you over, Israel? How can I make you like Admah? How can I make you like Zeboiim? My heart is turned within me, my compassion is aroused." (Hosea 11:8, WEBBE)
Hosea: northern prophet, c. 750–722 BCE. Ephraim = the northern kingdom.
11:1–4: God as a parent: teaching the child to walk, lifting, feeding.
11:5–7: the child turns away; Assyria will rule; judgement is deserved.
11:8–9: God argues with himself. Admah and Zeboiim were destroyed with Sodom (Deuteronomy 29:23). "Turned" uses the verb for the overthrow of Sodom: God's heart is overturned instead of Israel.
"I am God, and not man" (11:9): divine holiness shows itself as mercy, not as wrath.
Q1 What image of God replaces the judge or king in 11:1–4?
Show answer
A loving parent with a small child.
Q2 Why does God refuse to destroy Ephraim in 11:9?
Show answer
Because he is God, not a human: his holiness is shown in compassion.
Mission 1
Widow, orphan and foreigner
Three groups with no land, no male protector, or no kin: the widow, the fatherless and the foreigner (ger, resident alien).
Law: "You shall not wrong an alien … for you were aliens in the land of Egypt" (Exodus 22:21); God hears their cry (22:23).
Provision: the third-year tithe feeds Levite, foreigner, fatherless and widow (Deuteronomy 14:28–29; 26:12–13); the forgotten sheaf and the gleanings are left for them (24:19–22).
Protection: "Cursed is he who withholds justice from the foreigner, fatherless, and widow" (Deuteronomy 27:19).
Prophets: "Defend the fatherless. Plead for the widow" (Isaiah 1:17); the Temple is no refuge for those who "oppress the foreigner, the fatherless, and the widow" (Jeremiah 7:6).
?What reason does Deuteronomy most often give for Israel's duty to the foreigner, fatherless and widow?
Mission 1
Mercy and judgement held together
Exodus 34:7 keeps judgement inside the creed of mercy. Numbers 14 does too; Psalm 103 omits it; Jonah 4 is angry at mercy.
Rabbinic tradition speaks of two attributes, mercy (middat ha-raḥamim) and justice (middat ha-din), with mercy prevailing.
In synagogue liturgy the Thirteen Attributes stop before "will by no means clear the guilty", reading it as "and clearing (the penitent)".
Christian readers see the same God who is "merciful and gracious" and link the formula to the cross and forgiveness; Marcion (2nd century) set an Old Testament God of wrath against a New Testament God of love; the early Church rejected his view as heresy.
Phyllis Trible (b. 1932; God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality, 1978) traced raḥum to the womb, finding a maternal image of divine compassion.
Mission 1Evaluate
Is the God of the Old Testament essentially compassionate?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Compassion is the defining characteristic of God in the Old Testament.
For: God names himself first as "merciful and gracious" (Exodus 34:6); the formula recurs across law, psalms and prophets.
For: Hosea 11: even deserved judgement is overturned by compassion; the vulnerable are protected by law (Exodus 22; Deuteronomy 24).
Against: The same verse keeps punishment across generations (34:7); other texts present a warrior God who commands destruction (see Mission 2).
Against: Compassion is often for Israel; Jonah's anger shows its reach to enemies was contested.
Against: Texts come from many centuries; seeking one "essential" character may flatten a varied library.
Judgement criteria: Which texts are central (creeds) and which marginal? Does mercy limit judgement or sit beside it? Should the canon be read as a whole, or each text in its own setting?
Mission 1Worked answer
Tracing the formula
Task: "Explain how Exodus 34:6–7 is developed elsewhere in the Old Testament."
Point: Exodus 34:6–7 describes God's character: merciful, gracious, slow to anger, yet not clearing the guilty.
Develop 1: Moses uses it in intercession (Numbers 14:18), and God pardons.
Develop 2: Psalm 103:8–10 drops the judgement clause; Psalm 145:9 extends mercy to "all his works".
Develop 3: Joel 2:13 uses it to call for repentance; Jonah 4:2 resents its reach to Nineveh.
Link: The formula becomes a living creed, reapplied to new crises.
Mission check
?A worshipper prays in a crisis: "You are slow to anger and rich in steadfast love; do not treat us as our sins deserve." Which Old Testament passage is this prayer closest to?
The same words about God are prayed, preached and protested against; their meaning shifts with the crisis. Next: the warrior God and herem.
Mission 2
Mission 2: The same scriptures call God merciful and order whole cities destroyed. How have readers made sense of that?
Make a guess: The same scriptures call God merciful and order whole cities destroyed. How have readers made sense of that?
Mission 2
God as warrior at the sea
Exodus 14: Israel is trapped between Pharaoh's army and the sea.
Moses: "The LORD will fight for you, and you shall be still" (14:14). Israel does not fight; God acts.
The Egyptians cry: "the LORD fights for them" (14:25).
Exodus 15:1–21, the Song of the Sea: "The LORD is a man of war. The LORD is his name" (15:3).
Miriam's song (15:21) is often thought one of the oldest pieces of Hebrew poetry.
Here the warrior God rescues slaves from an oppressor: war is liberation.
Mission 2
God fighting on Israel's side
Numbers 21:1–3: Israel vows to "utterly destroy" Canaanite cities if God gives victory; the place is named Hormah, from the same root as ḥerem.
Deuteronomy 2:31–35; 3:1–7: the kings Sihon and Og are defeated; whole cities destroyed "with the women and the little ones" (2:34).
Deuteronomy 7: the seven nations of Canaan are to be destroyed; no covenant, no intermarriage, their altars broken (7:1–5).
Reason given: to keep Israel from idolatry, because Israel is a "holy people", chosen out of love, not size (7:6–8).
Gerhard von Rad (1901–1971), Holy War in Ancient Israel (1951): the pattern of "holy war": God goes before the army, fear falls on the enemy, the victory is God's; herem completes it.
Mission 2Read the source
The law of herem
> "When you draw near to a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace to it." (Deuteronomy 20:10, WEBBE)
> "But of the cities of these peoples that the LORD your God gives you for an inheritance, you shall save alive nothing that breathes; but you shall utterly destroy them" (Deuteronomy 20:16–17, WEBBE)
ḥerem: something devoted to God, removed from human use; in war, the destruction of people and goods as an offering to God.
Distant cities (20:10–15): offer peace first; if refused, kill the men; women, children and goods are taken.
Cities of the land (20:16–18): total destruction, "that they not teach you to follow all their abominations".
Fruit trees must be spared: "is the tree of the field man, that it should be besieged by you?" (20:19).
Q1 Which cities are to be offered peace first?
Show answer
Cities far away, outside the promised land: 20:15.
Q2 What reason does 20:18 give for herem in the land?
Show answer
To stop Israel learning the other nations' worship.
Mission 2
Herem in Joshua 6–11
Step 1 of 4
Jericho (6): the city "shall be devoted … to the LORD"; all destroyed (6:17, 21). Rahab, a Canaanite who sheltered the spies, is spared with her family (6:25).
Achan (7): an Israelite who keeps devoted goods is himself destroyed: herem binds insiders too.
Ai (8), the Gibeonites (9), who trick Joshua into a treaty and live; the southern and northern campaigns (10–11).
Summary: Joshua "utterly destroyed all that breathed, as the LORD … commanded" (10:40); God hardened their hearts (11:20).
Tensions in the text: Judges 1 lists many Canaanite cities not taken (Judges 1:21, 27); Canaanites remain "to this day".
Quick check
?According to Deuteronomy 20:10–20, which group was to be offered terms of peace before an attack?
Mission 2
The Amalekites
Exodus 17:8–16: Amalek attacks Israel at Rephidim; Joshua fights while Moses' hands are raised. "I will utterly blot out the memory of Amalek" (17:14); "war with Amalek from generation to generation" (17:16).
Deuteronomy 25:17–19: Amalek "struck the rearmost of you, all who were feeble behind you" and "didn't fear God". Israel must "blot out the memory of Amalek".
1 Samuel 15: Samuel commands Saul to destroy Amalek entirely, "infant and nursing baby" (15:3). Saul spares King Agag and the best animals (15:9).
Saul is rejected as king: "to obey is better than sacrifice" (15:22).
God "grieved" that he made Saul king (15:11, 35), though God "will not lie nor repent" (15:29): a tension the text leaves standing.
In Jewish tradition, Amalek became a symbol of gratuitous evil against the weak; the passage is read on the Sabbath before Purim (Haman is called an Agagite, Esther 3:1).
Quick check
?Why is Saul rejected in 1 Samuel 15?
Mission 2
The warrior in the prophets
Isaiah 59: injustice fills Judah; no one intervenes, so God acts: "He put on righteousness as a breastplate, and a helmet of salvation on his head" (59:17).
The enemy here is injustice, including Israel's own; "A Redeemer will come to Zion, and to those who turn from disobedience" (59:20).
Isaiah 63:1–6: a warrior comes from Edom (Bozrah), garments red: "I have trodden the wine press alone" (63:3). God's judgement on the nations, and rescue of his people.
The image moves from national conquest to God's final judgement and salvation.
Christian reuse: the armour of God (Ephesians 6:14–17); the winepress (Revelation 14:19–20; 19:13–15).
Mission 2
How readers interpret herem
Ancient setting: the Mesha Stele (Moab, c. 840 BCE) records that King Mesha "devoted" the people of the Israelite town of Nebo to his god (Ashtar-)Chemosh: herem was shared Near-Eastern war practice and language.
Hyperbole: "no one remaining" is victory rhetoric; Joshua and Judges themselves show Canaanites remaining.
Late ideology: many scholars date these texts to the 7th–6th centuries BCE (Deuteronomistic school), long after events; many archaeologists find little sign of a single violent conquest (e.g. Kathleen Kenyon (1906–1978) at Jericho). On this view the point was loyalty to God, not a war plan.
Judgement: some readers see God judging Canaanite wickedness (Genesis 15:16; Deuteronomy 9:4–5), a unique, unrepeatable act.
Spiritual reading:Origen (c. 185–c. 254), Homilies on Joshua: the wars are the soul's struggle against vices.
Restriction:Maimonides (1138–1204), Mishneh Torah (Laws of Kings 6:1): peace must be offered to every city first, even in the land; he notes that the seven nations have long since vanished (Laws of Kings 5:4), and many later authorities held that Amalek, too, can no longer be identified.
Susan Niditch, War in the Hebrew Bible (1993): herem appears both as sacrifice to God and as justice against sin, alongside other war ideologies in the Bible.
Mission 2Evaluate
Can the violent God be reconciled with the compassionate God?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: The warrior God of herem cannot be reconciled with the compassionate God of Exodus 34:6–7.
For: Commands to kill "infant and nursing baby" (1 Samuel 15:3) seem to contradict "slow to anger" and care for the vulnerable.
For: Critics say no context excuses such texts; they have been used to justify real violence (e.g. colonial conquest).
For: Marcion took this view in the 2nd century; some modern critics (e.g. Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion, 2006) call the Old Testament God morally monstrous.
Against: Exodus 34:7 already joins mercy and judgement; the warrior God of Exodus 14–15 liberates slaves.
Against: If herem texts are hyperbolic or late ideology, God's character is not described by an actual genocide.
Against: Jewish and Christian traditions limited the commands (peace first, Amalek unidentifiable; spiritual reading), so the texts are not read alone.
Judgement criteria: Is the issue what happened, or what the text endorses? Can the canon correct itself? Does judgement on wickedness differ from cruelty? How far does ancient context explain, or excuse?
Mission 2Worked answer
Explaining herem
Task: "Explain the concept of herem."
Point: Herem means "devoted": people and goods given wholly to God by destruction.
Source: Deuteronomy 20:16–17: in the cities of the land, "save alive nothing that breathes".
Develop: The stated aim is to prevent idolatry (20:18); distant cities are offered peace (20:10).
Example: Jericho is "devoted … to the LORD" (Joshua 6:17), but Rahab is spared; Achan's theft brings herem on him.
Context: Moab's Mesha Stele uses the same idea, so herem belonged to wider ancient war practice.
Quick check
?Which reading of the conquest uses Joshua and Judges themselves as evidence?
Mission check
?A modern preacher says: "Our battle is against injustice, and God himself puts on righteousness as armour." Which Old Testament war tradition is this closest to?
The warrior image runs from Pharaoh's sea, through conquest and herem, to God's armour against injustice. How readers hold that beside Exodus 34 is the live question.
Mission 3
Mission 3: A prophet stood at the Temple gate and said God would destroy it. Why was that almost a death sentence?
Make a guess: A prophet stood at the Temple gate and said God would destroy it. Why was that almost a death sentence?
Mission 3
Jeremiah's world
Jeremiah, from a priestly family of Anathoth near Jerusalem (1:1), is called in the 13th year of Josiah, 627 BCE (1:2).
622: Josiah's reform; a law book found in the Temple; worship centralised in Jerusalem (2 Kings 22–23).
609: Josiah killed at Megiddo; Jehoiakim (609–598) rules under Egypt, then Babylon.
605: Babylon defeats Egypt at Carchemish; 597: first deportation (King Jehoiachin).
Zedekiah (597–586) rebels; Jerusalem and the Temple fall to Babylon in 587/586 BCE.
Jeremiah preaches for about 40 years, through the end of the kingdom. His scribe Baruch writes down his words (Jeremiah 36).
Mission 3
The call (Jeremiah 1:4–19)
Before birth: "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you … I have appointed you a prophet to the nations" (1:5).
Objection: "I don't know how to speak; for I am a child" (1:6). Hebrew na'ar: a youth.
Word: God touches his mouth: "I have put my words in your mouth" (1:9). Task: "to uproot and to tear down, to destroy and to overthrow, to build and to plant" (1:10).
Almond branch:shaqed (almond) sounds like shoqed (watching): God watches over his word (1:11–12).
Boiling pot tipping from the north: disaster from the north (1:13–14), later Babylon.
Strength: "a fortified city, an iron pillar, and bronze walls" against kings, priests and people (1:18).
Mission 3Read the source
The Temple sermon
> "Don't trust in lying words, saying, 'The LORD's temple, the LORD's temple, the LORD's temple, are these.'" (Jeremiah 7:4, WEBBE)
> "Has this house, which is called by my name, become a den of robbers in your eyes? Behold, I myself have seen it," says the LORD. (Jeremiah 7:11, WEBBE)
Belief attacked: Zion is inviolable: God's house will never fall (strengthened when Jerusalem survived Assyria in 701 BCE).
Condition: safety only if they do justice, protect "the foreigner, the fatherless, and the widow", stop idolatry (7:5–7).
Shiloh: God's earlier sanctuary was destroyed; the Temple will go the same way (7:12–14).
God forbids Jeremiah to pray for the people (7:16); obedience, not sacrifice, was the Exodus command (7:22–23).
Jeremiah 26 tells what followed: priests and prophets call for his death; the officials declare him not worthy of death, and elders recall Micah's similar warning (26:8, 16–18).
Q1 What phrase do the people repeat as a guarantee?
Show answer
"The LORD's temple", three times.
Q2 Why does Jeremiah mention Shiloh?
Show answer
It proves God's sanctuary can be destroyed when the people are unfaithful.
Mission 3
Injustice and the monarchy
Jeremiah 22:13–17 (Jehoiakim): "Woe to him who builds his house by unrighteousness … who uses his neighbour's service without wages" (22:13).
Contrast with his father Josiah: "He judged the cause of the poor and needy … Wasn't this to know me?" (22:16). To know God is to do justice.
Jeremiah 21:1–14 (Zedekiah): during Babylon's siege the king asks for a miracle like those of old. Answer: "I myself will fight against you" (21:5); the warrior God turned against Judah.
"I set before you the way of life and the way of death": surrender to the Chaldeans (Babylonians) and live (21:8–9). This sounded like treason.
The house of David must "Execute justice in the morning" (21:12).
Mission 3
The undoing of creation (Jeremiah 4:23–28)
"I saw the earth and, behold, it was waste and void, and the heavens, and they had no light" (4:23).
Hebrew tohu wa-vohu: the same words as the formless earth before creation (Genesis 1:2).
Mountains quake, no people, no birds, fruitful land a desert (4:24–26): creation reversed by the people's sin.
Yet: "I will not make a full end" (4:27): even here, a limit.
The vision links social and religious failure to the whole cosmos.
Quick check
?What belief was Jeremiah attacking in the Temple sermon (Jeremiah 7)?
Mission 3
Can people change? (Jeremiah 34:8–22)
Step 1 of 3
During the siege, Zedekiah and the people make a covenant to free their Hebrew slaves (34:8–10).
When the Babylonian army withdraws for a time, they take the slaves back (34:11, 21–22).
They had sealed the covenant by cutting a calf in two and walking between its parts (34:18), invoking that fate on themselves.
Bitter wordplay: "I proclaim to you a liberty … to the sword, to the pestilence, and to the famine" (34:17).
The intractability of human nature: "Can the Ethiopian change his skin, or the leopard his spots?" (13:23); "The heart is deceitful above all things" (17:9).
Mission 3Read the source
Psalm 44: a public lament
> "All this has come on us, yet we haven't forgotten you. We haven't been false to your covenant." (Psalm 44:17, WEBBE)
> "Wake up! Why do you sleep, Lord? Arise! Don't reject us forever." (Psalm 44:23, WEBBE)
A communal lament after military defeat: "you … don't go out with our armies" (44:9).
It contradicts Jeremiah's explanation: the nation claims it has kept the covenant and suffers anyway.
Two voices in the canon: disaster as punishment for a broken covenant (Jeremiah) and as innocent suffering that God must answer (Psalm 44).
Q1 How does Psalm 44:17 challenge Jeremiah's message?
Show answer
It denies the covenant was broken; suffering is undeserved.
Q2 What does the psalmist ask God to do?
Show answer
Wake up, rise, help and redeem: 44:23, 26.
Mission 3Read the source
The new covenant
> "I will put my law in their inward parts, and I will write it in their heart. I will be their God, and they shall be my people." (Jeremiah 31:33, WEBBE)
Setting: the Book of Consolation (Jeremiah 30–33), promises of return after exile.
Not like the covenant "which they broke" at the Exodus (31:32).
Inward: law on the heart, not stone tablets. Universal knowledge: "they will all know me, from their least to their greatest" (31:34). Forgiveness: "I will remember their sin no more" (31:34).
Same people ("Israel and … Judah", 31:31), same God, same formula: "I will be their God". New: the heart is changed, answering 13:23 and 17:9.
Also in chapter 31: Rachel weeping (31:15); "everyone will die for his own iniquity" (31:30): individual responsibility.
Q1 What problem of the old covenant does the new one solve?
Show answer
Israel broke it; now God writes the law within them.
Quick check
?Which feature is part of the new covenant in Jeremiah 31:31–34?
Mission 3Evaluate
How new is the new covenant?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Jeremiah's new covenant is a radically new relationship with God, not a renewal.
For: It is explicitly "not according to the covenant" of the Exodus (31:32); the law moves from stone to heart.
For: Christians read it as fulfilled in Jesus: "the new covenant in my blood" (Luke 22:20; 1 Corinthians 11:25); Hebrews 8:8–12 quotes it in full.
Against: The content is the same: "my law" and "I will be their God" (31:33). In Jewish reading it is the renewal of Torah within Israel's heart.
Against: Deuteronomy already calls for the law "on your heart" (Deuteronomy 6:6); the idea develops existing faith.
Against: Reading it as replacement of Israel (supersessionism) is rejected by many Christians today, as well as by Jews.
Judgement criteria: Does "new" refer to content, form, or people? Should the text be read in its exilic setting or through later use? What does 31:31's "Israel and Judah" imply?
Mission 3Worked answer
The Temple sermon in context
Task: "Explain Jeremiah's condemnation of the Temple."
Point: Jeremiah attacks trust in the Temple as a guarantee of safety (7:4).
Develop: God's presence is conditional on justice for the vulnerable and on loyalty (7:5–7); without these, it is "a den of robbers" (7:11).
Source: Shiloh shows God can abandon his sanctuary (7:12–14).
Context: After 701 BCE many believed Zion could not fall; Jeremiah 26 shows the danger of saying otherwise.
Link: The same logic drives his condemnation of Jehoiakim (22:13–17): knowing God means doing justice.
Mission check
?After a national disaster, two religious leaders speak. One says: "We broke faith with God; this is the consequence." The other says: "We kept faith, and still we suffer. God, wake up!" Which pairing of Old Testament texts matches these two voices?
The canon keeps both voices: judgement for a broken covenant and protest from those who suffer anyway. Next: Jeremiah's own private protests to God.
Mission 4
Mission 4: A prophet told God, "You deceived me," and cursed the day he was born. Why is that in the Bible?
Make a guess: A prophet told God, "You deceived me," and cursed the day he was born. Why is that in the Bible?
Mission 4
The "confessions" of Jeremiah
Among Jeremiah's public oracles (chapters 11–20) are private poems: Jeremiah speaking to God, not for him.
Often called the confessions (a modern scholars' label; they confess pain, not sin).
Set texts: 12:1–6; 15:10–21; 17:14–18; 20:7–13; 20:14–18.
Themes: why the wicked prosper; loneliness and persecution; doubt about God's faithfulness; the burden of the word.
They use the language of the Psalms' individual laments.
Mission 4
The lament form
Hermann Gunkel (1862–1932), Einleitung in die Psalmen (1933, completed by Joachim Begrich; English Introduction to Psalms, 1998): classed psalms by form (Gattung); the individual lament is the most common.
Typical elements (not always all, not always in this order):
(1) Address: "LORD …"
(2) Complaint: about me, about enemies, about God ("How long?").
(3) Petition: "Hear", "Heal", "Save".
(4) Motivation: reasons for God to act (his reputation, love, the dead cannot praise him).
(5) Expression of trust: "But I trust in your loving kindness" (Psalm 13:5).
(6) Vow of praise or praise itself.
Claus Westermann (1909–2000), Praise and Lament in the Psalms (1954; English 1981): lament usually moves towards praise.
Mission 4Read the source
Psalm 30: lament remembered
> "I cried to you, LORD. I made supplication to the Lord: 'What profit is there in my destruction, if I go down to the pit? Shall the dust praise you? Shall it declare your truth?'" (Psalm 30:8–9, WEBBE)
> "You have turned my mourning into dancing for me. You have removed my sackcloth, and clothed me with gladness" (Psalm 30:11, WEBBE)
Psalm 30 is a thanksgiving that recalls a lament: distress, cry, rescue, praise.
So it shows the whole movement of lament in one psalm: a template.
30:6–7: false security ("I shall never be moved"), then God "hid your face".
30:9 is a motivation: a dead worshipper cannot praise God.
Superscription: "for the Dedication of the Temple"; in Jewish prayer it is said in the daily morning service and linked with Hanukkah.
Q1 Which element of the lament form is 30:9?
Show answer
Motivation: a reason God should act.
Q2 Where in Psalm 30 is the move from lament to praise clearest?
Show answer
30:11–12: mourning into dancing; "I will give thanks to you forever".
Mission 4
Jeremiah 12:1–6 and 15:10–21
12:1–4: "You are righteous, LORD … yet I would like to plead a case with you. Why does the way of the wicked prosper?" (12:1). A legal challenge to God (theodicy).
12:5–6: God's reply is no answer: "If you have run with the footmen … how can you contend with horses?" Worse is coming; even his family betrays him.
15:10: "Woe is me, my mother, that you have borne me, a man of strife".
15:16: once God's words were "a joy and the rejoicing of my heart".
15:18: "Will you indeed be to me as a deceitful brook, like waters that fail?": a stream that dries up in summer.
15:19–21: God calls the prophet to repent ("If you return …"), then renews the promise of the call: "a fortified bronze wall" (15:20; compare 1:18).
Quick check
?How does God respond to Jeremiah's complaint in 12:1–6?
Mission 4
Jeremiah 17:14–18
Petition: "Heal me, O LORD, and I will be healed. Save me, and I will be saved; for you are my praise" (17:14).
Complaint: the people mock him: "Where is the LORD's word? Let it be fulfilled now" (Jeremiah 17:15). Unfulfilled warnings make him look a false prophet (Deuteronomy 18:22;).
Protest of innocence: he did not want the day of disaster (17:16).
Petition against enemies: "Bring on them the day of evil" (17:18): an imprecation, as in many psalms.
No reply from God is recorded.
Mission 4Read the source
Jeremiah 20:7–9
> "LORD, you have persuaded me, and I was persuaded. You are stronger than I, and have prevailed. I have become a laughingstock all day. Everyone mocks me." (Jeremiah 20:7, WEBBE)
> "If I say that I will not make mention of him, or speak any more in his name, then there is in my heart as it were a burning fire shut up in my bones. I am weary with holding it in. I can't." (Jeremiah 20:9, WEBBE)
"Persuaded" translates pittitani: also enticed, even deceived. Other translations: "You deceived me" (e.g. King James Version, NIV).
His message ("Violence and destruction!", 20:8) brings only mockery; friends whisper "Terror on every side!" (20:10).
Yet he cannot stop: the word is a fire within.
20:11–13: sudden trust and praise: "Sing to the LORD!" (20:13).
Q1 What two forces pull Jeremiah in opposite directions?
Show answer
Mockery makes him want to stop; the word burns in him and will not let him.
Q2 Which lament elements appear in 20:11–13?
Show answer
Expression of trust; praise.
Mission 4
Jeremiah 20:14–18: the darkest poem
"Cursed is the day in which I was born" (20:14). Compare Job 3.
He curses the messenger who brought news of his birth (20:15–16), wishes he had died in the womb (20:17).
Ends with a question: "Why did I come out of the womb to see labour and sorrow …?" (20:18).
No trust, no praise, no reply: the lament form broken.
Placed straight after the praise of 20:13: the editors set hope and despair side by side.
It echoes his call: "Before I formed you in the womb" (1:5) becomes a curse on the womb.
Quick check
?What makes Jeremiah 20:14–18 stand out from most individual laments?
Mission 4Evaluate
Autobiography or liturgy?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: The confessions are Jeremiah's own record of his inner struggle.
For: They are tied to his life: his family (12:6), his call (15:20; 20:14–18 echo chapter 1), mockery of his unfulfilled word (17:15).
For:John Bright (1908–1995), Jeremiah (1965) and many commentators read them as genuine personal prayers.
Complication:Walter Baumgartner (1887–1970), Die Klagegedichte des Jeremia (1917), showed that the poems use the standard forms of the Psalms' laments, yet still judged them Jeremiah's own.
Against:Henning Graf Reventlow (1929–2010), Liturgie und prophetisches Ich bei Jeremia (1963): the "I" is the prophet speaking for the community in worship.
Against:Robert Carroll (1941–2000), Jeremiah (1986): the book's editors created the suffering-prophet figure.
Judgement criteria: Can a set form express real feeling? Do the personal details fit only one man? Does the meaning for believers depend on the answer?
Mission 4Worked answer
Showing the lament form
Task: "Explain how Jeremiah 20:7–13 reflects the form of a personal lament."
Address and complaint: "LORD, you have persuaded me … Everyone mocks me" (20:7).
Complaint (enemies): friends wait for his fall (20:10).
Trust: "the LORD is with me as an awesome mighty one" (20:11).
Petition: "let me see your vengeance on them" (20:12).
Praise: "Sing to the LORD!" (20:13). Like Psalm 30, the poem moves from distress to praise; 20:14–18 then breaks that pattern.
Mission check
?A believer writes in a journal: "Why do cheats get rich while I lose everything? You seem like a stream that runs dry. Yet I will still trust you, and I will thank you when you rescue me." Which description fits best?
The confessions show a prophet arguing with God in the language of prayer; the lament form gave him words, and in 20:14–18 even the form breaks.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Why would a prophet lie on his side for 390 days and refuse to mourn his own wife?
Make a guess: Why would a prophet lie on his side for 390 days and refuse to mourn his own wife?
Mission 5
A prophet in exile
Step 1 of 4
597 BC: Babylon (Nebuchadnezzar) takes Jerusalem; King Jehoiachin, priests and leading citizens are deported. Ezekiel goes with them.
He lives at Tel Aviv by the river Chebar, a canal near Nippur in Babylonia (1:1–3; 3:15).
593 BC: "the fifth year of King Jehoiachin's captivity" (1:2): his call.
Zedekiah rules what is left of Judah. The exiles hope for a quick return; prophets in Jerusalem and Babylon promise peace.
587/586 BC: Jerusalem falls, the Temple burns. The book pivots here: judgement (chapters 1–24), oracles against nations (25–32), hope (33–48).
Last dated oracle: 571 BC (29:17). Ezekiel's whole ministry is among exiles, not in the land.
Mission 5
The call (2:1–3:15)
It follows the throne-chariot vision (chapter 1): "the likeness of the LORD's glory" (1:28) appears in an unclean, foreign land.
"Son of man" (Hebrew ben adam): "mortal", a reminder of the gap between the prophet and God's glory. Used about 90 times.
The Spirit enters him and sets him on his feet (2:2): Ezekiel is moved by the Spirit throughout the book.
Sent to "a nation of rebels" (2:3), a "rebellious house". Success is not promised: "whether they will hear, or whether they will refuse… they will know that there has been a prophet amongst them" (2:5).
Made tough: "I have made your forehead as a diamond, harder than flint" (3:9).
He goes "in bitterness" (3:14) and sits "overwhelmed amongst them seven days" (3:15).
Compare Jeremiah 1:4–19: both are given God's words; Jeremiah's mouth is touched, Ezekiel eats a scroll.
Mission 5Read the source
Eating the scroll
> "He spread it before me. It was written within and without; and lamentations, mourning, and woe were written in it." (Ezekiel 2:10, WEBBE)
> "He said to me, 'Son of man, eat this scroll that I give you and fill your belly and your bowels with it.' Then I ate it. It was as sweet as honey in my mouth." (Ezekiel 3:3, WEBBE)
The message is written, complete, before he speaks: a prophet of the book as well as the voice.
He must take it inside himself: the word becomes part of his body, as his sign-acts will show.
Q1 What is the scroll's content, and how does it taste?
Show answer
Lament and woe; sweet as honey.
Q2 Why might bitter words taste sweet?
Show answer
Obeying God's word is sweet to the prophet, though the message is grim; compare Psalm 19:10.
Mission 5
The priestly prophet
"Ezekiel the priest, the son of Buzi" (1:3): probably of the Zadokite priestly line of the Jerusalem Temple.
"The thirtieth year" (Ezekiel 1:1) may be his age: the age priests began service (Numbers 4:3). An interpretation, not certain.
Priestly concerns run through the book:
Holiness and uncleanness: he protests at unclean food (4:14); idolatry "defiles" the land and Temple.
The glory (kavod) of God: it leaves the defiled Temple (10:18; 11:23) and returns to a new one (43:4).
Law and ritual: close links with the Holiness Code (Leviticus 17–26); chapters 40–48 are a priest's plan of Temple, land and worship.
The recognition formula "you will know that I am the LORD" (about 70 times; 6:7): judgement and restoration both aim at Israel knowing God.
So Ezekiel joins two roles: priest (holiness, Temple) and prophet (word, warning). Some scholars stress the tension; others the unity.
Quick check
?Which feature of the book best shows that Ezekiel was a priestly prophet, not only a prophet who was also a priest by birth?
Mission 5
Sign-acts: the siege (4:1–5:17)
A symbolic action (sign-act) acts out the message; it does not only illustrate it but is believed to set the word in motion.
Brick and iron pan (4:1–3): he draws Jerusalem on a brick and "besieges" it. "This shall be a sign to the house of Israel" (4:3).
Lying on his side (4:4–8): 390 days on the left for Israel, 40 on the right for Judah, "each day for a year" (4:6): bearing their iniquity.
Siege rations (4:9–17): mixed-grain bread, weighed food and water. Told to bake it on human dung (unclean), he protests as a priest (4:14); God allows cow dung (4:15). Sign of exile in an unclean land.
Shaving with a sword (5:1–4): hair weighed in three parts: one burnt, one struck with the sword, one scattered to the wind; a few hairs kept in his robe (a remnant).
"This is Jerusalem" (5:5): the city has rebelled more than the nations around her.
Mission 5
Sign-acts: exile baggage (12:1–28)
He packs exile's baggage by day, digs through the wall in the evening, and goes out with his face covered (12:3–7).
"I am your sign. As I have done, so will it be done to them" (12:11).
The prince (12:10–14): Zedekiah will flee by night and be taken to Babylon, yet "not see it" (fulfilled: he was blinded, 2 Kings 25:4–7).
Ezekiel eats and drinks trembling (12:17–20): the fear of a besieged land.
Two sayings answered (12:21–28): "The days are prolonged, and every vision fails" (12:22) and "he prophesies of times that are far off" (12:27). God: "None of my words will be deferred any more" (12:28).
The audience did not doubt that prophets speak; they doubted that this prophet's doom was soon.
Mission 5
The death of his wife (24:15–27)
"I will take away from you the desire of your eyes with one stroke; yet you shall neither mourn nor weep" (24:16).
He speaks in the morning; his wife dies in the evening; he does as commanded (24:18).
No mourning rites: no uncovered head, bare feet, covered lips or mourners' bread (24:17).
The people ask what it means. Answer: God will profane the Temple, "the desire of your eyes" (24:21), and their children in Jerusalem will fall.
When it comes, they too will be too stunned to mourn: "Ezekiel will be a sign to you" (24:24).
A fugitive will bring news; then Ezekiel's muteness (3:26) will end: "your mouth will be opened" (24:27; fulfilled 33:21–22).
The most personal sign-act: the prophet's grief becomes the message.
Quick check
?In Ezekiel 24, why is Ezekiel told not to mourn his wife?
Mission 5
Oracles of judgement: the land and the end (6; 7)
Chapter 6: to the "mountains of Israel" (6:3), where hill-shrines (high places) and idols stood. Sword, famine, plague; bones scattered round the altars.
Survivors in exile will remember "how I have been broken with their lewd heart" (6:9): God is hurt by idolatry, not only angry.
Chapter 7: the fall of Jerusalem: "An end! The end has come on the four corners of the land" (7:2).
"The day" is near (7:7, 10, 12): buying and selling stop, silver and gold cannot save, priests, elders and king fail (7:26–27).
God "will judge you according to your ways" (7:3): judgement fits conduct.
Refrain in both: "you will know that I am the LORD" (6:7; 7:4).
Mission 5
False prophets and two unfaithful wives (13; 16; 23)
Chapter 13: "foolish prophets, who follow their own spirit, and have seen nothing" (13:3). They say "Peace" when there is no peace and whitewash a cracked wall (13:10). Women who make magic bands "to hunt souls" (13:18) are condemned.
Chapter 16: Jerusalem as a foundling girl, abandoned at birth; God passes by: "Though you are in your blood, live!" (16:6), raises and marries her. She turns to other lovers (idolatry and foreign alliances). Harsh judgement follows, yet: "I will establish an everlasting covenant with you" (16:60).
Chapter 23: two sisters, Oholah (Samaria) and Oholibah (Jerusalem) (23:4), unfaithful with Egypt, Assyria and Babylon. Jerusalem is worse than Samaria.
The marriage metaphor follows Hosea and Jeremiah, but it is far more graphic: shame is meant to shock the exiles into seeing their history as betrayal.
Mission 5Evaluate
"Chapters 16 and 23 still speak with authority today."
Step 1 of 4
For: they expose idolatry and political compromise as betrayal of a covenant love, not a broken rule.
For: chapter 16 ends with grace: God remembers the covenant and forgives (16:60–63).
Against: feminist scholars (Renita Weems, Battered Love, 1995; J. Cheryl Exum, Plotted, Shot, and Painted, 1996) argue the imagery links God's love with violence against a woman, and readers can take it as permission.
Against: the shame is placed on female sexuality; male elites, the real decision-makers, are hidden behind the metaphor.
Another view: read it as a metaphor for a city and its rulers, with the violence belonging to invading armies; or read it against the grain (resisting the text's own viewpoint), with the critique included.
Judge it by: Can a text's purpose be separated from its imagery? Who is the intended audience (male exiled elite)? How do Jewish and Christian communities use these chapters in worship today (rarely read aloud)?
Mission 5Evaluate
Was Ezekiel's behaviour abnormal?
Claim: Ezekiel's visions, muteness and sign-acts show a disturbed personality.
For: August Klostermann (1877) suggested catalepsy (a trance-like state with a rigid body); Edwin Broome ("Ezekiel's Abnormal Personality", 1946) proposed paranoid schizophrenia; the philosopher Karl Jaspers (1947) also wrote a psychiatric study. David Halperin (Seeking Ezekiel, 1993) reads chapters 16 and 23 through Ezekiel's psychology.
Against: sign-acts are a known prophetic genre (Isaiah 20; Jeremiah 13, 19, 27). Walther Zimmerli (1907–1983) and Moshe Greenberg (1928–2010) read them as deliberate, public performances.
Against: diagnosing a man from a text written and edited for others is unreliable: the book is shaped literature, not a case-file.
Another view: some acts (390 days on one side) may have been carried out in part each day, or reported as vision.
Judge it by: Does a psychological reading explain the message, or only the messenger? Does "abnormal" mean "unhealthy" or "uncommon"? Would a believer accept that God can use unusual experience?
Mission check
?A modern protest group sits silently outside a closed hospital for 40 days, holding an empty bed frame. Their leader says: "We are not explaining the loss. We are the loss, until people see it." Which feature of Ezekiel's ministry before the fall does this most closely resemble?
Before the fall, Ezekiel's words and his body both announce the end. Next: what does he say when the end has come?
Mission 6
Mission 6: When the Temple is ash and the people say "our hope is lost", what can a prophet still promise?
Make a guess: When the Temple is ash and the people say "our hope is lost", what can a prophet still promise?
Mission 6
The news arrives (33:21–33)
"In the twelfth year of our captivity… one who had escaped out of Jerusalem came to me, saying, 'The city has been defeated!'" (33:21).
The evening before, Ezekiel's muteness ends: "my mouth was opened, and I was no longer mute" (33:22), as promised in 24:27.
Survivors left in Judah claim the land: "Abraham was one… we are many" (33:24). Ezekiel: no, their idolatry and violence continue (33:25–29).
The exiles now treat him as a celebrity: "a very lovely song… they hear your words, but they don't do them" (33:32).
Turning point: doom has come true, so his voice is now trusted to speak hope.
Mission 6
The watchman, again (33:1–9)
A watchman sees the sword coming and blows the trumpet (33:2–6).
If he warns and people ignore it, they are responsible. If he stays silent, "his blood I will require at the watchman's hand" (33:6).
"So you, son of man, I have set you a watchman to the house of Israel" (33:7). The same commission was given at the start (3:16–21); repeated here it reopens his ministry.
The role is pastoral: warning one person at a time, so that each can still turn.
Mission 6
Individual responsibility (33:10–20; chapter 18)
The exiles despair: "Our transgressions and our sins are on us… How then can we live?" (33:10).
God: "I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live. Turn, turn… For why will you die, house of Israel?" (33:11).
Past righteousness does not save one who turns to sin; past wickedness does not condemn one who turns back (33:12–16).
They complain: "The way of the Lord is not fair" (33:17). God: "I will judge every one of you after his ways" (33:20).
The fuller version is chapter 18: the proverb "The fathers have eaten sour grapes, and the children's teeth are set on edge" (18:2) is rejected. "The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father" (18:20).
Purpose: this generation is not trapped by its parents' sins or its own past. It can turn now.
Mission 6
The Shepherds of Israel (34)
"Woe to the shepherds of Israel who feed themselves! Shouldn't the shepherds feed the sheep?" (34:2). Shepherds = kings and leaders.
They did not heal the sick, bind the broken or seek the lost, but "ruled over them with force and with rigor" (34:4). So the flock was scattered.
God takes over: "I myself will be the shepherd of my sheep" (34:15). "I will seek that which was lost… bind up that which was broken" (34:16).
God also judges between sheep: fat sheep that trample the pasture and push the weak (34:17–22).
"One shepherd… even my servant David" (34:23): a future king of David's line, under God.
A "covenant of peace" (34:25): safety, rain, harvest.
Leaders are judged by how they treat the weakest. (Link: the A2 3 synoptic theme on leadership.)
Mission 6Read the source
A new heart (36:16–32)
> "I will sprinkle clean water on you, and you will be clean… I will also give you a new heart, and I will put a new spirit within you. I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you a heart of flesh." (Ezekiel 36:25–26, WEBBE)
Why? "I don't do this for your sake, house of Israel, but for my holy name" (36:22). Exile made the nations say God could not protect his people (36:20).
Order: gather from the nations (36:24) → cleanse (priestly washing) → new heart and spirit → "I will put my Spirit within you" (36:27) → obedience → "You will be my people, and I will be your God" (36:28).
Shame follows forgiveness: "you will remember your evil ways… and you will loathe yourselves" (36:31).
Q1 Who acts in 36:25–27?
Show answer
God, at every step.
Q2 Compare 18:31, "make yourself a new heart". What has changed?
Show answer
In 18 the people are told to do it; in 36 God promises to do it.
Quick check
?In Ezekiel 36:16–32, what reason does God give for restoring Israel?
Mission 6
The valley of dry bones (37:1–14)
Step 1 of 3
The Spirit sets him in a valley "full of bones" (37:1), very dry. "Son of man, can these bones live?" "Lord GOD, you know" (37:3).
Two stages: he prophesies, and bones join, with sinews, flesh, skin, but no breath (37:7–8). He prophesies to the breath (ruach: breath, wind, spirit), and "they lived, and stood up on their feet, an exceedingly great army" (37:10).
Meaning given in the text: "these bones are the whole house of Israel… 'Our bones are dried up, and our hope is lost'" (37:11).
"I will open your graves… and I will bring you into the land of Israel" (37:12): national restoration from the "death" of exile.
Later Jewish and Christian readers also heard in it the hope of bodily resurrection (e.g. in rabbinic discussion; read in many churches at Easter or Pentecost).
Mission 6
Two sticks, one people (37:15–28)
A sign-act of hope: two sticks, "For Judah" and "For Joseph, the stick of Ephraim" (37:16), joined "into one stick" (37:17).
North (Israel) and south (Judah), split since about 930 BC, will be "one nation… They will no longer be two nations" (37:22).
"My servant David will be king over them" (37:24).
"A covenant of peace… an everlasting covenant… my sanctuary amongst them forever more" (37:26).
"My tent also will be with them. I will be their God, and they will be my people" (37:27): God's presence is the goal of the whole restoration.
Mission 6
The New Temple (40:1–42:20)
Date: "the twenty-fifth year of our captivity… the fourteenth year after the city was struck" (40:1): about 573 BC.
"In the visions of God" he is set on "a very high mountain" (40:2). A man "like… bronze" with a measuring reed (40:3) measures gates, courts, chambers and the sanctuary.
Ezekiel must "declare all that you see to the house of Israel" (40:4).
Purpose of the walls: "to make a separation between that which was holy and that which was common" (42:20). Holiness is built into the plan: a priestly vision.
Next comes the climax: "the LORD's glory came into the house by the way of the gate which faces towards the east" (43:4), the way it had left (11:23).
Debate: a blueprint to build after return, or an ideal picture of a holy community? The second Temple (completed 515 BC) did not follow it.
Mission 6
The renewed creation (47:1–12); God outside the Temple
Step 1 of 4
Water flows "from under the threshold of the temple eastward" (47:1), ankle-deep, knee-deep, waist-deep, then "a river that I could not pass through" (47:5).
It reaches the Dead Sea, and "the waters of the sea will be healed, and everything will live wherever the river comes" (47:9).
Trees whose "fruit will be for food, and its leaf for healing" (Ezekiel 47:12). Worship renews the whole land: echoes of Eden (Genesis 2:10).
God's presence outside the Temple:
The glory first appears in Babylonia by the Chebar (1:1–3, 28): unclean, foreign land.
The glory leaves the defiled Temple (10:18; 11:23).
"I will be to them a sanctuary for a little while in the countries where they have come" (11:16).
The new city's name: "The LORD is there" (48:35).
So God is not bound to one building. Many historians think this helped Judaism survive exile (prayer, Torah study, later the synagogue).
Quick check
?Which passage most directly shows Ezekiel's discovery that God's presence can be found outside the Jerusalem Temple?
Mission 6Evaluate
Was Ezekiel the "father of individualism"?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Ezekiel replaced Israel's corporate idea of sin and guilt with individual responsibility.
For: 18:4, 18:20 and 33:12–20 judge each person "after his ways"; the sour-grapes proverb is rejected; the watchman warns individuals.
Against: Paul Joyce (Divine Initiative and Human Response in Ezekiel, 1989) argues the point is the responsibility of this generation as a whole: it cannot blame its ancestors. The addressee is still "house of Israel".
Against: individual responsibility was not new: Deuteronomy 24:16 already forbids punishing children for parents' crimes; and much of Ezekiel stays corporate (chapters 16, 23, 36, 37).
For: even before the fall, chapter 9 marks out individuals who "sigh and… cry" over the city's sins to be spared (9:4).
Judge it by: Who is addressed (one person or the nation)? What did the exiles need to hear? Does "individualism" read a modern idea back into the text?
Mission 6Evaluate
Hope: God's gift or the people's task?
The tension: "make yourself a new heart" (18:31) versus "I will also give you a new heart" (36:26).
Divine initiative: after the fall the stress is on God: for his name (36:22), by his Spirit (36:27; 37:14), on dead bones that can do nothing (37:3).
Human response: the call to "turn" (33:11) stays; the watchman still warns; the new heart leads to walking in God's statutes (36:27).
Joyce's reading: both held together: radical responsibility, and the admission that only God can make the people able to respond.
For Jews and Christians today: the new heart and Spirit link to Jeremiah's new covenant (Jeremiah 31:31–34); many Christians see their fulfilment in the gift of the Spirit (Acts 2).
Judge it by: Does hope that depends wholly on God weaken responsibility? Does hope that depends on human effort survive despair like 37:11? Which suits a people who "pine away" (33:10)?
Mission check
?A school is closed after a scandal caused by its former leaders. At a meeting a parent says: "Our children can't be blamed for what the old governors did. Each family now decides how to respond, but only a new board can make a fresh start possible." Which pair of Ezekiel's teachings after the fall does this combine?
After the fall, Ezekiel joins two messages: you are not trapped by the past, and God will make a new beginning possible.
Mission 7
Mission 7: Can ancient scriptures guide modern leaders and ethics, and why do they call sin a broken bond?
Make a guess: Can ancient scriptures guide modern leaders and ethics, and why do they call sin a broken bond?
Mission 7
Texts that shape and limit leaders
In the Old Testament (A2 3), leaders stand under God's word, not above it:
The king's law: the king must copy the law and read it all his life (Deuteronomy 17:18–19).
Prophets confront kings: Nathan to David (2 Samuel 12); Elijah to Ahab over Naboth's vineyard (1 Kings 21); Amos against King Jeroboam II, before the priest Amaziah at Bethel (Amos 7:10–17).
Reform by the book: Josiah's covenant to keep "the words of this covenant that were written in this book" (2 Kings 23:3).
Ezra reads the Law to the people; the Levites "gave the sense, so that they understood the reading" (Nehemiah 8:8).
Synoptic task: link to at least one other unit (e.g. A2 1 Synoptic Gospels, A2 7 Global Ethics, A2 8 Philosophy) and to human experience.
Mission 7Read the source
A king under the law
> "It shall be, when he sits on the throne of his kingdom, that he shall write himself a copy of this law in a book … It shall be with him, and he shall read from it all the days of his life…" (Deuteronomy 17:18–19, WEBBE)
Nathan to David:
> "You are the man!" (2 Samuel 12:7, WEBBE)
Q1 Whose authority is higher in Deuteronomy 17: the king's or the law's?
Show answer
The law's: the king must learn and keep it.
Q2 What does Nathan's challenge show about leadership in Israel?
Show answer
A prophet speaking God's word could condemn even the king for abusing power, here over Bathsheba and Uriah.
Mission 7
Leaders using texts in society
For justice: Martin Luther King Jr quoted Amos: "let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream" (Amos 5:24) in the civil rights movement (1963).
For liberation: the Exodus has inspired abolitionists, Black churches and liberation theologians.
For power: James VI and I, The True Law of Free Monarchies (1598), used scripture to support the divine right of kings.
For division: the Dutch Reformed Church's 1974 report used texts such as Babel (Genesis 11) to support apartheid; the church later rejected this (1986 onwards).
The same scriptures have been read for and against those in power.
Quick check
?Which Old Testament passage most directly limits a ruler's power by making him subject to God's law?
Mission 7Evaluate
Do sacred texts make leadership better?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Religious texts give leaders a sound basis for leadership in religion and society.
For: they place leaders under a higher standard (Deuteronomy 17; Nathan); they give a vision of justice for the poor (Amos; Micah 6:8).
For: leaders such as King and Tutu drew moral courage and public language from scripture.
Against: the same texts were used for divine right, slavery and apartheid: a text can legitimise power as easily as check it.
Against: in a plural society, laws based on one community's scripture may exclude others.
Judgement criteria: does the text check the leader, or does the leader control the text? Whose interpretation? Religious community or wider society?
Mission 7
Ways of using texts for ethics
Rules: commands apply directly (e.g. the Ten Commandments); a form of divine command ethics.
Principles: the commands express deeper values, such as "love your neighbour as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18), "act justly, … love mercy, and … walk humbly with your God" (Micah 6:8).
Paradigm: Christopher J. H. Wright (b. 1947), Old Testament Ethics for the People of God (2004): Israel's laws are a model society; Christians ask what principles they embody and apply them in new settings.
Character and community: scripture forms a people with virtues, rather than giving a rulebook (Stanley Hauerwas, b. 1940).
Link to A2 7 (Global Ethics): compare with natural law, utilitarianism and virtue ethics.
Mission 7
Texts ahead of their time, and hard texts
Ahead of their time: love for the foreigner (Leviticus 19:34); a weekly rest even for servants, livestock and the stranger (Deuteronomy 5:14); leaving the harvest's edges for the poor (Leviticus 19:9).
Hard texts: laws regulating slavery (Exodus 21); herem (devoting enemies to destruction); the death penalty for many offences; texts on women's subordination.
Jewish interpretation has long read these through Oral Torah and rabbinic tradition; Christians through Christ and the New Testament.
The question is not only "what does the text say?" but "how does it apply now?"
Quick check
?A Christian ethicist argues that Old Testament laws on gleaning show God's concern for the poor, so a modern society should design ways to share its surplus. Which approach is this?
Mission 7Evaluate
Are religious texts a valid guide for ethics today?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Religious texts remain a valid guide for contemporary ethics.
For: believers hold them to be God's word, whose core values (justice, mercy, care for the stranger) are timeless.
For: principles and paradigms can be applied to new issues (economics, ecology, migration).
Against: cultural distance: many laws reflect an ancient society; selecting some and rejecting others needs a standard outside the text.
Against: the Euthyphro dilemma (Plato): is something good because God commands it, or commanded because it is good? If the latter, reason may be enough.
Against: new issues (IVF, AI, climate) are not addressed directly.
Judgement criteria: rules or principles? Who interprets? A guide for believers, or for society as a whole?
Mission 7
Sin as alienation in Genesis 3–11
Step 1 of 4
From God: the man and woman hide "from the presence of the LORD God" (Genesis 3:8).
From self: "they knew that they were naked" (Genesis 3:7): shame and fear enter.
From others: blame ("The woman whom you gave to be with me", Genesis 3:12); Cain kills Abel: "Am I my brother's keeper?" (Genesis 4:9).
From creation: the ground is cursed; work becomes toil (Genesis 3:17–19).
Between peoples: Babel ends in scattering and confusion (Genesis 11).
Hebrew words: chata' (to miss the mark), pesha' (rebellion), avon (iniquity, guilt).
Mission 7Read the source
Separated
> "I heard your voice in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; so I hid myself." (Genesis 3:10, WEBBE)
> "But your iniquities have separated you and your God, and your sins have hidden his face from you, so that he will not hear." (Isaiah 59:2, WEBBE)
> "Against you, and you only, I have sinned, and done that which is evil in your sight…" (Psalm 51:4, WEBBE)
Q1 Which two alienations appear in Genesis 3:10?
Show answer
From God (he hides) and from himself (fear and shame at his nakedness). Blaming the woman follows in 3:12.
Q2 Psalm 51 is linked to David after Nathan's rebuke. Why might David say he has sinned against God "only", when he harmed Uriah and Bathsheba?
Show answer
Sin is first a break with God, though it also wrongs others; the psalm stresses that relationship.
Mission 7
Theology of sin as estrangement
Step 1 of 4
Paul: the divided self: "the good which I desire, I don't do" (Romans 7:19).
Augustine (354–430): "Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee" (Confessions I.1, Pusey's translation). Sin is love turned in on itself.
Søren Kierkegaard (1813–1855), The Sickness unto Death (1849): sin as despair before God: not willing to be oneself, or defiantly willing to be oneself apart from God.
Paul Tillich (1886–1965), Systematic Theology vol. 2 (1957): sin is estrangement from the ground of being (God), from other beings and from oneself.
Restoration: "I will also give you a new heart" (Ezekiel 36:26); the law written "in their heart" (Jeremiah 31:33); in Christian belief, atonement is reconciliation (at-one-ment).
Mission 7
Secular accounts of alienation
Ludwig Feuerbach (1804–1872), The Essence of Christianity (1841): God is a projection of humanity's own best qualities; religion alienates people from their own nature.
Karl Marx (1818–1883), Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts (1844): workers are alienated from their labour, its product, each other and their human nature; religion is "the opium of the people" (1844), a comfort that keeps people from changing their conditions.
Existentialists (e.g. Sartre): alienation as part of the human condition, without God.
Link to A2 8 (synoptic theme): the claim that religion is "world evading, perpetuating humanity's oppression and alienation".
These agree with the Bible that humans are estranged, but disagree on the cause and cure.
Mission 7Evaluate
Is sin best understood as alienation?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Alienation is the most helpful way to understand sin today.
For: it fits Genesis 3–4 and the prophets: sin breaks relationships with God, others, self and creation.
For: it speaks to modern experience (loneliness, broken communities) and connects with psychology and secular thought.
Against: it may soften sin into a feeling or a condition; scripture also speaks of guilt, rebellion and law-breaking (pesha', avon) needing forgiveness.
Against: secular thinkers explain alienation without sin or God (Feuerbach, Marx); some argue religion itself causes alienation.
Judgement criteria: does the model keep personal responsibility? Does it explain the need for forgiveness and atonement? Does it fit both the texts and experience?
Mission check
?A novel shows a successful businessman who cheats his partner. He loses the friendship, cannot face his family and feels he no longer knows who he is. He avoids church and stops praying. Which statement fits Tillich's view of sin best?
The Bible's language of hiding, blame and separation makes sin a broken relationship, and salvation its healing. Next synoptic theme: faith, morality and the state.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Deuteronomy 26 is a creed of God's saving acts; Exodus 34:6–7 is a creed of his character: merciful, gracious, slow to anger, faithful, yet just.
The formula recurs in Numbers 14, Psalms 86, 103 and 145, Joel 2 and Jonah 4, each time reapplied; in Hosea 11 compassion overturns judgement.
God's compassion becomes law: protection for the widow, the fatherless and the foreigner, grounded in the memory of Egypt.
Mission 2
God is pictured as a warrior who rescues (Exodus 14–15), fights for Israel (Numbers 21; Deuteronomy 2–3, 7) and commands herem in the land (Deuteronomy 20; Joshua 6–11; Amalek in 1 Samuel 15).
The prophets turn the image to God's war on injustice and final judgement (Isaiah 59, 63).
Readers interpret herem through ancient context, hyperbole, late ideology, divine judgement, spiritual reading and rabbinic restriction; whether it can be reconciled with the compassionate God is debated.
Mission 3
Jeremiah (called 627 BCE) preaches through Judah's last decades: the Temple is no guarantee (7:4, 11, 14); kings must do justice (22:13–17; 21:12).
Sin undoes creation (4:23–28) and resists change (34:8–22; 13:23); Psalm 44 answers with a lament of the faithful.
The new covenant (31:31–34) promises the law written on the heart, universal knowledge of God and forgiveness; how "new" it is is read differently by Jews and Christians.
Mission 4
Jeremiah's private poems (12:1–6; 15:10–21; 17:14–18; 20:7–13; 20:14–18) protest to God about the wicked, his suffering and his calling.
The individual lament has address, complaint, petition, motivation, trust and praise; Psalm 30 shows the whole movement from distress to praise.
Scholars debate whether the confessions are personal, liturgical or editorial; 20:14–18 ends without the turn to praise.
Mission 5
Ezekiel, a priest deported in 597 BC, was called in 593 by the river Chebar: sent to a "rebellious house", he ate a scroll of woe.
Before the fall he announced judgement in oracles (6, 7, 13, 16, 23) and sign-acts (4, 5, 12, 24): siege, exile and a grief too deep to mourn.
Scholars debate the violent marriage imagery and whether his behaviour shows illness or deliberate prophetic performance.
Mission 6
The news of the fall (33) reopens Ezekiel's mouth: the watchman now calls each person to turn and live.
Hope comes from God: true shepherd (34), new heart and Spirit (36), dry bones raised and two sticks joined (37), a holy Temple with the glory returned (40–43) and a river of life (47).
God's presence is found in exile too: "a sanctuary for a little while" (11:16); "The LORD is there" (48:35).
Mission 7
Old Testament texts put leaders under God's law and the prophets' challenge; leaders since have used scripture both to check and to legitimise power.
Texts can guide ethics as rules, principles, paradigms (C. J. H. Wright) or character formation; critics point to cultural distance, hard texts and the Euthyphro dilemma.
Sin as alienation from God, others, self and creation runs from Genesis 3–11 through Paul, Augustine, Kierkegaard and Tillich; Feuerbach and Marx offer secular accounts.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Old Testament: The nature of God in the Old Testament; the Prophet Jeremiah; themes in the Book of Ezekiel; synoptic assessment theme: Leadership, Text and Alienation for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1One sentence about God is repeated across the Old Testament. Why did a prophet quote it in anger?
Mission 2The same scriptures call God merciful and order whole cities destroyed. How have readers made sense of that?
Mission 3A prophet stood at the Temple gate and said God would destroy it. Why was that almost a death sentence?
Mission 4A prophet told God, "You deceived me," and cursed the day he was born. Why is that in the Bible?
Mission 5Why would a prophet lie on his side for 390 days and refuse to mourn his own wife?
Mission 6When the Temple is ash and the people say "our hope is lost", what can a prophet still promise?
Mission 7Can ancient scriptures guide modern leaders and ethics, and why do they call sin a broken bond?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.