← A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · AS 7: Life and death issues; AS 7: Developments in bioethics; AS 7: Other aspects of human experience
Mini-Lesson

Life and death issues; Developments in bioethics; Other aspects of human experience

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1When does a developing human start to count as someone, and would that settle the abortion debate?
  2. Mission 2Can ending a pregnancy ever be a side-effect rather than a choice, and what should the law do about it?
  3. Mission 3If someone in great pain asks to die, whose life is it to end: theirs, a doctor's, or God's?
  4. Mission 4Is switching off a machine morally different from giving a lethal injection?
  5. Mission 5Is a child a gift or a right, and who decides what happens to embryos made in a lab?
  6. Mission 6If we can choose or change an embryo's genes, where does curing disease end and designing children begin?
  7. Mission 7Do people need God to be good, or can religion get in the way of being good?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Deontological ethics.

Mission 1

Mission 1: When does a developing human start to count as someone, and would that settle the abortion debate?

Make a guess: When does a developing human start to count as someone, and would that settle the abortion debate?

Mission 1

Stages and circumstances

Stages of developmentTimes after fertilisation. Weeks of pregnancy,as doctors count them, start at the last period:about 2 weeks more.day 0fertilisation (conception): azygote with its own geneticcodedays 6–10implantation in the wombabout day 14primitive streak; twinning nolonger possibleto 8 weeksembryo (8 weeks = about 10weeks of pregnancy)after 8weeksfetus; brain and nervoussystem develop throughpregnancy22–24 weeksof pregnancyviability: could surviveoutside the womb withmedical helpbirth
  • Abortion: the deliberate ending of a pregnancy so that the embryo or fetus dies. (A miscarriage is a spontaneous loss.)
  • Conception (fertilisation): a zygote with its own genetic code. Implantation in the womb about 6–10 days later.
  • About 14 days: the primitive streak appears; twinning is no longer possible.
  • Embryo up to 8 weeks after fertilisation (about 10 weeks of pregnancy, as doctors count from the last period); then fetus. Brain and nervous system develop through pregnancy.
  • Viability: the point at which a fetus could survive outside the womb with medical help, now around 22–24 weeks of pregnancy.
  • Circumstances in which abortion is sought: risk to the woman's life or health; serious fetal anomaly; pregnancy after rape or incest; social and economic reasons (age, poverty, relationships, other children).
Mission 1

When does moral status begin?

When does moral status begin?From conceptionfull status from day 0Gradualiststatus grows; markers: 14 days, sentience,viabilityAt birth (or later)status begins at birthconception14 daysviabilitybirthstatus ↑ · development → (not to scale)
  • Moral status: having interests or rights that others must respect. Three main answers:
  • From conception: a new human life begins; development after that is continuous, with no clear later line. Its potential to become a person gives it full status now.
  • Gradualist: status grows with development. Key markers: 14 days, sentience (the capacity to feel), viability.
  • At birth (or later): only then is there an independent being with experiences of its own; before that, the woman's interests decide.
  • Potentiality debated: critics say a potential person is not yet an actual one (an acorn is not an oak). Defenders reply that the embryo is an actual human organism developing its own potential.
  • Twinning objection: before 14 days one embryo can become two, so is it yet "an individual"?
Quick check
?Which argument is a gradualist view of the embryo and fetus?
Mission 1Read the source

Life before birth

Life before birth: the textsPsalm 139:13 (WEBBE)"For you formed my inmost being. You knit metogether in my mother's womb."Jeremiah 1:5 (WEBBE)"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you.Before you were born, I sanctified you."Didache 2:2 (late 1st or early 2nd century)forbids killing a child by abortion (paraphrase)Exodus 21:22–25: readings differon some readings, treats causing amiscarriage differently from killing a person

> "For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother's womb." (Psalm 139:13, WEBBE)

> "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you. Before you were born, I sanctified you." (Jeremiah 1:5, WEBBE)

  • Christians who hold the sanctity of life from conception read these as showing that God knows and forms each person before birth.
  • The Didache (late 1st or early 2nd century), an early Christian manual, forbids killing a child by abortion (Didache 2:2, paraphrase).
  • Other Christians note that the psalm is poetry about God's care, not a statement of when personhood begins; and that Exodus 21:22–25 treats causing a miscarriage differently from killing a person, on some readings.

Q1 What do both passages claim about God's relation to a person before birth?

Show answer

God forms and knows them in the womb.

Q2 Why do some Christians say these verses do not settle the abortion question?

Show answer

They are poetic or prophetic texts about God's care, not definitions of moral status.

Mission 1

The personhood debate

Warren's five traits of personhoodTraitfetus(Warren)consciousness (esp. of pain)~reasoningself-motivated activitycommunicationself-awareness~ at most rudimentary, late in pregnancyWarrena fetus is not a person (Warren, "On the Moraland Legal Status of Abortion", 1973)Criticsthe same test seems to exclude newborns.Warren argued infanticide is still wrong forother reasons.
  • Person: a being with full moral status. Is every human a person, or only those with certain capacities?
  • Mary Anne Warren (1946–2010), "On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion" (The Monist, 1973): five traits central to personhood: consciousness (especially of pain), reasoning, self-motivated activity, communication, self-awareness. A fetus has at most a rudimentary form of the first (it may feel pain late in pregnancy), so Warren argues it is not a person.
  • Critic: the same test seems to exclude newborns. Warren argued infanticide is still wrong for other reasons.
  • Peter Singer: no fetus is a person; what may matter is sentience, which gives a being interests (fuller treatment in Mission 2).
  • Religious view: personhood is not earned by capacities; it comes with being a human being created by God (the image of God).
Mission 1

The rights of the woman

Thomson's violinistyoua famous violinistnine monthshe needs your kidneys to livea right to life ≠ a right to use another's bodyso abortion may be permissible even if thefetus is a person (Thomson, 1971,paraphrase)
  • The debate is not only about the fetus. The woman has a right to life, health, and bodily autonomy.
  • Judith Jarvis Thomson (1929–2020), "A Defense of Abortion" (Philosophy & Public Affairs, 1971): grant, for argument's sake, that the fetus is a person.
  • Her violinist example (paraphrase): you wake up connected to a famous violinist who needs your kidneys for nine months to live. You may unplug, though he dies: his right to life does not give him a right to use your body.
  • So abortion may be permissible even if the fetus is a person.
  • Critics: in most pregnancies the woman is not kidnapped (responsibility); abortion kills, while unplugging only stops saving; the fetus is the woman's own child.
  • Rights of the unborn: those who hold the conception view say the right not to be killed outweighs other rights.
Mission 1

Feminist views

  • Pro-choice feminists: women cannot be equal while they lack control over pregnancy; the burden of a ban falls on women alone.
  • Care ethics: Carol Gilligan's In a Different Voice (1982) studied women deciding about abortion. Many reasoned through relationships and responsibility, not abstract rights.
  • Pro-life feminists (e.g. Feminists for Life, USA): abortion lets society avoid supporting pregnant women, mothers and carers; equality should not require ending a pregnancy.
  • Sidney Callahan, "Abortion and the Sexual Agenda" (1986): a pro-life feminist case that abortion serves a male-centred view of sexuality (paraphrase).
  • Some feminists criticise sex-selective abortion as discrimination against girls.
  • So "feminist" does not mean one view: feminists agree that women's lives and voices must be central, and disagree on what follows.
Quick check
?What is Thomson's violinist argument designed to show?
Mission 1Diversity

Religious views

Religious views on abortionView of the unbornMay be allowedCatholic Churchprotected absolutelyfrom conceptiondirect abortion: never(gravely wrong)Orthodox and many evangelical Christianswrong fromconceptionlife-saving exceptionsChurch of Englandstrong opposition toabortionstrictly limitedconditions, e.g. threat tothe mother's life orhealthMethodist Church (Britain)not acceptable ascontraceptionmay be the lesser evilin some circumstancesOrthodox Judaismmother's life first in adangerous birth, untilmost of the child hasemerged (MishnahOhalot 7:6)mainly for seriousthreats to the motherReform Judaism–more widely thanOrthodoxIslam (many scholars)soul breathed in at120 days (hadith)after 120 days only tosave the mother's life;before, schools differ
  • Catholic Church: human life is to be protected absolutely from conception; direct abortion is gravely wrong (Catechism 2270–2271; Evangelium Vitae, 1995, §62). Indirect cases.
  • Orthodox Churches and many evangelical Christians also hold that abortion is wrong from conception, with life-saving exceptions.
  • Church of England: combines strong opposition to abortion with recognition that, in strictly limited conditions (e.g. a threat to the mother's life or health), it may be morally preferable to any alternative (General Synod statements since the 1980s).
  • Methodist Church in Britain: abortion is not acceptable as a form of contraception, but may be the lesser evil in some circumstances.
  • Judaism: the Mishnah (Ohalot 7:6) puts the mother's life first in a dangerous birth, until most of the child has emerged. Orthodox authorities allow abortion mainly for serious threats to the mother; Reform Judaism allows more.
  • Islam: many scholars teach the soul is breathed in at 120 days (hadith in al-Bukhari and Muslim). After that, abortion is forbidden except to save the mother's life; before, schools differ.
Mission 1

Secular views

  • Humanists UK: supports a woman's right to choose, weighing the welfare of the woman and the stage of development; does not treat the early embryo as a person.
  • Utilitarian views weigh the interests of all affected; Singer gives weight to sentience, so later abortion is more serious than early.
  • Secular opposition exists too: Don Marquis, "Why Abortion Is Immoral" (Journal of Philosophy, 1989): killing is wrong because it takes away a future like ours; a fetus has such a future, so abortion is seriously wrong (paraphrase).
  • Disability-rights critics (religious and secular): abortion for fetal anomaly can send the message that disabled lives are worth less.
  • The religious/secular split is again not tidy.
Mission 1Evaluate

Would settling personhood settle abortion?

Argument map: would settling personhood settle abortion?"If we knew when a person begins, wewould know when abortion is wrong."ForMost agree it is wrong to kill an innocentperson: status is the key premise of thedebateSanctity-of-life arguments and Warren'sargument both turn on what the fetus isAgainstThomson: even if the fetus is a person, thewoman's bodily rights may permitabortionMarquis: wrongness rests on the loss of afuture, not on present personhoodIf personhood is uncertain, the questionbecomes how to act under uncertainty(some argue: give the benefit of the doubt)Judge it byAre status and rights separable? · Can a linebe drawn without being arbitrary? · Howmuch weight does uncertainty carry?
  • Claim: If we knew when a person begins, we would know when abortion is wrong.
  • For: Most agree it is wrong to kill an innocent person; status is the key premise of the debate.
  • For: Sanctity-of-life arguments and Warren's argument both turn on what the fetus is.
  • Against: Thomson: even if the fetus is a person, the woman's bodily rights may permit abortion.
  • Against: Marquis: wrongness rests on the loss of a future, not on present personhood.
  • Against: If personhood is uncertain, the question becomes how to act under uncertainty (some argue: give the benefit of the doubt).
  • Judgement criteria: Are status and rights separable? Can a line be drawn without being arbitrary? How much weight does uncertainty carry?
Quick check
?How do most Muslim jurists understand the significance of the 120th day of pregnancy?
Mission check

?Three people discuss a pregnancy at 16 weeks. Ava: "Even if it is a person, no one can be forced to give their body to keep someone alive." Ben: "It is a human being from conception, and human beings have worth because God made them." Cal: "It deserves more protection now than at two weeks, and less than at 30 weeks." Which matches each view correctly?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can ending a pregnancy ever be a side-effect rather than a choice, and what should the law do about it?

Make a guess: Can ending a pregnancy ever be a side-effect rather than a choice, and what should the law do about it?

Mission 2

Natural law applied

  • Primary precepts: preservation of life and reproduction. Secondary precept: never directly kill the innocent.
  • Catholic natural law applies this from conception, so direct abortion (abortion as an end or a means) is always gravely wrong (Evangelium Vitae, 1995, §62).
  • Even a good motive (helping a frightened woman) cannot make a direct killing good.
  • Aquinas himself (following Aristotle) held that the rational soul arrives some weeks after conception; the Church today protects life from conception, given uncertainty and the continuity of development.
Mission 2

Therapeutic abortion and double effect

Double effect and abortionConditionsABC1act good in itself2bad effect foreseen,not intended3not the means to thegood4proportionate reasonAremoving a cancerous womb (hysterectomy):the fetus' death is foreseen, not intendedBectopic pregnancy: removing the damagedtube (salpingectomy), widely accepted byCatholic moralistsother ectopic methods are debatedCdirectly ending the fetus' life to ease adangerous birth: death is the means
  • Therapeutic abortion: ending a pregnancy to save the woman's life or protect her health.
  • Natural law uses double effect: an act with a good and a bad effect may be done if the act is good in itself, the bad effect is foreseen but not intended, it is not the means to the good, and there is a proportionate reason.
  • Cancerous womb: removing the womb (hysterectomy) treats the mother's disease; the fetus' death is foreseen, not intended. Permitted.
  • Ectopic pregnancy: removing the damaged fallopian tube (salpingectomy) is widely accepted by Catholic moralists; some other methods are debated among them.
  • Not permitted: directly ending the fetus' life to save the mother (e.g. killing it to ease a dangerous birth): here death is the means.
  • Critics: the difference can seem artificial when the fetus dies either way; proportionalists would weigh the outcomes directly.
Quick check
?A pregnant woman at 10 weeks has an ectopic pregnancy in her fallopian tube, which is about to rupture. Surgeons remove the damaged tube with the embryo inside it. How would most Catholic natural law thinkers judge this?
Mission 2

Situation ethics applied

Situation ethics applied to abortionFletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)a patient in a psychiatric hospital, pregnantafter rape: love would permit abortion(paraphrase)Agapethe most loving actfor all involved: thewoman, the fetus,others affectedPersonalismthe woman's life andwellbeing comebefore a rulePragmatismthe answer dependson the case: a childwho could not becared for may tip thebalanceRelativismdepends on the case:rape or risk to healthmay tip the balanceLove can point either waylove might also argue against abortion insome situations
  • Agape: the most loving act for all the people involved, including the woman, the fetus, and others affected.
  • Fletcher was a strong supporter of legal abortion. In Situation Ethics (1966) he discusses a patient in a psychiatric hospital pregnant after rape, and argues love would permit abortion (paraphrase).
  • Personalism: the woman's life and wellbeing come before a rule.
  • Pragmatism and relativism: the answer depends on the case: rape, risk to health, or a child who could not be cared for may tip the balance.
  • Love might also argue against abortion in some situations; situation ethics does not make every abortion right.
  • Critics: who counts the fetus' interests in the calculation? A choice based on love in one case may be unsafe as a social rule.
Mission 2

Virtue ethics and utilitarianism

  • Utilitarianism: weigh the happiness or preferences of all affected. Bentham's calculus or Singer's preference utilitarianism usually favour allowing abortion, especially early, when the fetus has no preferences.
  • A rule utilitarian may also weigh the social effects of a permissive or a restrictive law.
Mission 2

Singer and Glover evaluated

Singer and Glover evaluatedSingerGlover (1977)What matterssentience, rationality,self-awareness;species alone has nomoral weight("speciesism")the reasons killing iswrong: ending aworthwhile consciouslife; overridingsomeone's wishesEarly fetushas none of thesethese reasons barelyapply; conception isnot a clear lineStrengtha consistent principleapplied to all beingstakes the woman'ssituation and theside-effects of lawseriouslyWeaknessbirth is not a decisiveline either: newbornslack the status ofpersons. Singeraccepts this; widelyrejectedif the wrong is onlyabout presentconsciousness, whatprotects thetemporarilyunconscious?Religious critiqueboth measure worth by capacities, not bybeing human; most Christians: every humanlife has equal dignity
  • Singer: belonging to the species Homo sapiens has no moral weight in itself (speciesism). What matters is sentience, rationality and self-awareness. An early fetus has none of these.
  • Strength: a consistent principle applied to all beings. Weakness: on the same view, birth is not a decisive line either, so newborns lack the status of persons. Singer accepts this, and disability-rights groups and many others strongly reject it.
  • Glover (Causing Death and Saving Life, 1977): the main reasons killing is wrong (ending a worthwhile conscious life; overriding someone's wishes) barely apply to an early fetus; he doubts that conception gives a clear line (paraphrase).
  • Strength: takes the woman's situation and the side-effects of law seriously. Weakness: if the wrong of killing is only about present consciousness, critics ask what protects the temporarily unconscious.
  • Religious critique: both measure worth by capacities, not by being human; most Christians say every human life has equal dignity.
Quick check
?How would a situation ethicist approach a request for an abortion?
Mission 2

The slippery slope

  • Argument: once abortion is allowed for serious reasons, it will come to be allowed for lesser ones; or the value placed on all vulnerable life will fall.
  • Examples given: abortion for less serious fetal conditions; sex-selective abortion; Singer's views on newborns, cited as the "next step".
  • Replies: the law can and does draw lines (time limits, grounds); allowing one practice does not force allowing another; the evidence is disputed.
  • The argument is mostly about law and society, not about whether a single abortion is right.
  • Spec link: "the slippery slope argument" (also used for euthanasia).
Mission 2

The law and the state

Abortion law: a timeline1861E&WOffences Against the Person Act:abortion a crime (Scotland: commonlaw)1967GBAbortion Act: legal if two doctorsagree a legal ground applies1973USARoe v Wade1990GBHFE Act: 24-week limit for mostgrounds; no limit for risk to life,grave permanent injury or seriousfetal disability2018Irelandreferendum repealed theconstitutional ban2019NIdecriminalised by Westminster (the1967 Act never applied)2020NIAbortion (Northern Ireland)Regulations: on request to 12weeks; to 24 weeks for risk tohealth; no limit for severe fetalimpairment, fatal fetal abnormalityor risk to life2022USADobbs overturned Roe: the questionreturns to the states2026E&WCrime and Policing Act: a womanacting in relation to her ownpregnancy removed from thecriminal lawE&W = England and Wales; GB = Great Britain;NI = Northern Ireland
  • Great Britain: abortion remains a crime (in England and Wales under the Offences Against the Person Act 1861; in Scotland under common law), except as allowed by the Abortion Act 1967: two doctors must agree that a legal ground applies.
  • Crime and Policing Act 2026: a woman acting in relation to her own pregnancy is removed from the criminal law in England and Wales; the rules for doctors and others are unchanged.
  • Since 1990 (Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act): a 24-week limit for most grounds; no limit where there is risk to the woman's life, grave permanent injury, or a substantial risk of serious fetal disability.
  • Northern Ireland: the 1967 Act never applied. Abortion was decriminalised in 2019 by Westminster; the Abortion (Northern Ireland) Regulations 2020 allow it on request to 12 weeks, to 24 weeks for risk to health, and without limit for severe fetal impairment, fatal fetal abnormality, or risk to life.
  • Conscientious objection: medical staff may refuse to take part directly, except to save life (Abortion Act 1967, s. 4).
  • Elsewhere: USA: Roe v Wade (1973) overturned by Dobbs (2022), returning the question to the states. Ireland: the 2018 referendum repealed the constitutional ban.
  • State responsibilities: protect life, protect women's health, respect conscience: states weigh these differently.
Mission 2Evaluate

How far should law follow natural law?

Argument map: how far should law follow natural law?"Human law on abortion should be basedon natural law's protection of life fromconception."ForAquinas: human law derives its authorityfrom natural law; protecting the innocentis a core purpose of lawIf the unborn are human beings, a law thatpermits killing them is unjust, whatevermost people believeAgainstAquinas: human law should not forbidevery vice, only those most harmful toothers (ST I-II q.96 a.2)In a plural society, law cannot rest on apremise many reject; banning abortion canpush it into unsafe practiceJudge it byIs the issue one of protecting others, or ofprivate morality? · Can law be just withoutconsensus? · What happens in practice whenlaws change?
  • Claim: Human law on abortion should be based on natural law's protection of life from conception.
  • For: Aquinas: human law derives its authority from natural law; protecting the innocent is a core purpose of law.
  • For: If the unborn are human beings, a law that permits killing them is unjust, whatever most people believe.
  • Against: Aquinas himself held that human law should not forbid every vice, only those most harmful to others, which most can avoid (ST I-II q. 96 a. 2).
  • Against: In a plural society, law cannot rest on a premise (life is sacred from conception) that many reject; banning abortion can push it into unsafe practice.
  • Judgement criteria: Is the issue one of protecting others, or of private morality? Can law be just without consensus? What happens in practice when laws change?
Quick check
?Which statement about abortion law in the UK is accurate?
Mission 2Worked answer

Applying a theory

Issue: "Natural law is the most effective approach to abortion."

  • Point: Natural law gives a clear and consistent rule: innocent life is protected from conception, so direct abortion is always wrong.
  • Source: Primary precept of preservation of life; Evangelium Vitae §62.
  • Develop: Double effect keeps it humane in the hardest cases: the cancerous womb and ectopic pregnancy.
  • Counter: Hursthouse and Fletcher: the woman's situation and character matter; a rule may fail the case of rape or serious risk to health.
  • Mini-judgement: Its clarity is a strength only if its premise about the embryo's status is accepted; the essay must test that premise, not just state it.
  • AO2 tip: weigh the strongest form of each side, then reach a reasoned judgement on the issue as set.
Mission check

?A woman 14 weeks pregnant is diagnosed with an aggressive cancer of the cervix. Doctors advise radiotherapy to the pelvis at once; it will almost certainly cause the fetus to die. A second doctor suggests first ending the pregnancy so that treatment is simpler. What would Catholic natural law conclude?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If someone in great pain asks to die, whose life is it to end: theirs, a doctor's, or God's?

Make a guess: If someone in great pain asks to die, whose life is it to end: theirs, a doctor's, or God's?

Mission 3

What the words mean

Types of euthanasiaactivean act causesdeathpassivetreatmentwithheld orwithdrawnvoluntarypersonrequestsnon-voluntaryperson cannotconsentinvoluntaryperson couldconsent, notasked orrefusestreated as murder in everylegal system: illegaleverywherelethalinjection onrequestfeedingwithdrawn inPVSAssisted suicidethe person takes the final act, with meanssupplied by someone else
  • Euthanasia (Greek eu "good" + thanatos "death"): deliberately ending a person's life, or allowing it to end, for that person's sake.
  • Active euthanasia: someone does something that causes death (e.g. a doctor gives a lethal injection).
  • Passive euthanasia: treatment that would keep the person alive is withheld or withdrawn, so that they die.
  • Assisted suicide: the person takes the final act themselves, with means supplied by someone else. Physician-assisted suicide: the helper is a doctor.
  • Assisted dying: the term used in many current laws and bills for physician-assisted suicide for terminally ill adults.
  • Not euthanasia: stopping treatment that no longer helps, where the aim is not death (see Mission 4).
Mission 3

Whose choice? Three types

Types of euthanasiaactivean act causesdeathpassivetreatmentwithheld orwithdrawnvoluntarypersonrequestsnon-voluntaryperson cannotconsentinvoluntaryperson couldconsent, notasked orrefusestreated as murder in everylegal system: illegaleverywherelethalinjection onrequestfeedingwithdrawn inPVSAssisted suicidethe person takes the final act, with meanssupplied by someone else
  • Voluntary: the life is ended at the person's request or with their consent. Typical case: an incurable or terminal illness.
  • Non-voluntary: the person cannot consent (e.g. a newborn, or someone in a persistent vegetative state, PVS). Someone representing their interests decides.
  • Involuntary: the person could consent but is not asked, or refuses. Treated as murder in every legal system; almost no one defends it.
  • PVS: the body is kept alive (breathing, sleep–wake cycles) but there are no signs of awareness, for months or years.
  • The two distinctions combine: e.g. voluntary active (lethal injection on request), non-voluntary passive (feeding withdrawn in PVS).
Mission 3Read the source

Sanctity of life

Two scales of valueSanctity of life: value givenGod-given; image of God (Genesis 1:27)a lifetime →valueQuality of life: value depends on attributesawareness, relationships, absence ofunbearable paina lifetime →valuecan fallBoth are used in medicine.
  • Sanctity of life: human life is sacred, holy, because it is given by God and bears God's image. Its religious origin is in the Hebrew Bible.

> "God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27, WEBBE)

> "You shall not murder." (Exodus 20:13, WEBBE)

> "The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away. Blessed be the LORD's name." (Job 1:21, WEBBE)

Q1 What reason does Genesis give for treating every human life as sacred?

Show answer

Every human is made in God's image, whatever their condition.

Q2 What does Job 1:21 suggest about who may decide when a life ends?

Show answer

Life is God's gift; the time of death belongs to God.

Mission 3

Sanctity of life in Christian teaching

  • Strong sanctity of life: innocent human life must never be deliberately ended, whatever its quality. Its value does not depend on health, ability or awareness.
  • Christians also cite the body as a "temple of the Holy Spirit" (1 Corinthians 6:19) and Jesus' care for the sick.
  • Catholic teaching today: Catechism of the Catholic Church 2276–2279; John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae (1995), §65.
  • Weak sanctity of life (held by some Christians): life is precious and God-given, but not of absolute value; love may sometimes allow death to come or be hastened.
  • Sanctity of life is not vitalism (keeping alive at all costs): most sanctity views allow burdensome treatment to stop.
Quick check
?A man has been in a persistent vegetative state for four years. His wife, who holds lasting power of attorney for his health, asks that his tube feeding be withdrawn, and he dies. Which type of euthanasia is this, using the definitions in this mission?
Mission 3

Quality of life

Two scales of valueSanctity of life: value givenGod-given; image of God (Genesis 1:27)a lifetime →valueQuality of life: value depends on attributesawareness, relationships, absence ofunbearable paina lifetime →valuecan fallBoth are used in medicine.
  • Quality of life: a life has value because of what it contains or makes possible, not just because it is human.
  • Used in medicine to weigh treatments (e.g. the QALY, a "quality-adjusted life year", used in UK health planning).
  • Jonathan Glover (b. 1941), Causing Death and Saving Life (1977): what matters is not being alive but having a life worth living, chiefly conscious life.
  • Peter Singer (b. 1946), Rethinking Life and Death (1994): the traditional sanctity-of-life ethic is collapsing; the worth of a human life varies (paraphrase).
  • Critics: who judges a life "not worth living"? Disability-rights campaigners warn the idea devalues disabled lives.
  • Some religious believers also use quality-of-life reasoning, alongside sanctity, when deciding about treatment.
Mission 3

Personhood

Who counts as a person?Religious viewevery living human isa personCapacity viewonly beings withcapacities arepersonspersonhood comeswith human nature,given by God; aperson in PVS orwith dementia is stilla personLocke, 1690"a thinkingintelligent being,that has reason andreflection, and canconsider itself asitself" (II.xxvii.9,added in 2nd edition,1694)Fletcher, 1972"Indicators ofHumanhood":self-awareness,self-control, a senseof time, relating toothersSinger, 1979Practical Ethics:rational,self-conscious,aware of having apast and a future
  • Personhood debate: is every living human a person (a being with full moral status), or only humans with certain capacities?
  • John Locke (1632–1704), An Essay concerning Human Understanding (1690; II.xxvii.9, added in the 2nd edition, 1694): a person is "a thinking intelligent being, that has reason and reflection, and can consider itself as itself".
  • Joseph Fletcher (1905–1991), "Indicators of Humanhood" (1972): a list of capacities (e.g. self-awareness, self-control, a sense of time, relating to others); below a minimum of brain function, he argued, there is no person.
  • Singer: a person is a rational, self-conscious being, aware of having a past and a future (Practical Ethics, 1979). Killing a person against their wishes is gravely wrong because it frustrates their preferences.
  • Religious reply: personhood is given by God with human nature itself, not earned by capacities; a person in PVS or with dementia is still a person.
Quick check
?Which statement expresses a sanctity-of-life view, rather than a quality-of-life view?
Mission 3

Autonomy and rights

Autonomy: a concept webautonomyRight to refusetreatmentalready lawfulRight to die?contested: if I have aright to life, may Iwaive it?Mill's harmprinciple (1859)over his own bodyand mind theindividual issovereign; restrictliberty only toprevent harm toothersLimit: futurefreedomMill: no one may sellthemselves intoslavery; does achoice to die do thesame?Limit: pressureis the request fullyfree? depression,pain, costLimit: burdena sense of being aburden on othersChristianstewardshiplife is held in trust,not owned
  • Autonomy (Greek "self-law"): the right of a competent person to make decisions about their own life and body.
  • Right to die arguments: if I have a right to life, I may waive it; refusing treatment is already lawful, so why not ask for help to die?
  • Sovereignty of the individual: J. S. Mill (1806–1873), On Liberty (1859): "Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign." Society may restrict liberty only to prevent harm to others.
  • Critics: Mill himself said one may not sell oneself into slavery, since that ends future freedom; does a choice to die do the same?
  • Is a request to die ever fully free? Pressure from depression, pain, cost or a sense of being a burden.
  • Christian reply: life is held in trust (stewardship), not owned; freedom is for living well with others.
Mission 3

The law: a snapshot

The law: a snapshotEuropeNorth America12345671England and Walesencouraging or assisting suicide a crime(Suicide Act 1961). Bill passed the Commons(2025), ran out of time in the Lords (April2026)2Scotlandbill rejected by the Scottish Parliament(March 2026)3Netherlands, 2002euthanasia on request, strict conditions4Belgium, 2002euthanasia on request, strict conditions5Switzerlandassisting suicide not a crime unless fromselfish motives6Oregon, 1997assisted suicide for terminally ill adults7Canada, 2016medical assistance in dyingEngland and Wales1961Suicide Act1993Bland2009Purdy2010DPP policyLaw as at November 2026
  • England and Wales: Suicide Act 1961: suicide is no longer a crime, but encouraging or assisting suicide is (up to 14 years). Active euthanasia is murder or manslaughter.
  • Northern Ireland has the same position on assisting suicide (Criminal Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1966, s. 13).
  • DPP policy (2010, after the Purdy case, 2009): lists factors that make prosecution for assisting suicide more or less likely, such as a wholly compassionate motive.
  • Airedale NHS Trust v Bland (House of Lords, 1993): feeding could be withdrawn from Tony Bland, in PVS after the Hillsborough disaster; the court treated it as withdrawing treatment no longer in his interests, not as killing.
  • Elsewhere: Netherlands and Belgium (both 2002): euthanasia on request under strict conditions. Oregon (1997): assisted suicide for terminally ill adults. Canada (2016): medical assistance in dying. Switzerland: assisting suicide is not a crime unless done from selfish motives.
  • Recent bills for terminally ill adults: the Scottish Parliament rejected one (March 2026); one for England and Wales passed the Commons (2025) but ran out of time in the Lords (April 2026).
Mission 3

Palliative care

  • Palliative care: care that relieves pain and distress (physical, emotional, spiritual) when a cure is no longer possible. It neither hastens nor postpones death.
  • Cicely Saunders (1918–2005), a Christian nurse and doctor, founded St Christopher's Hospice, London (1967), the first modern hospice. Her idea of "total pain": suffering has physical, emotional, social and spiritual sides.
  • Many opponents of euthanasia argue: good palliative care removes most reasons to ask for it.
  • Supporters reply: some suffering cannot be relieved, and some people value control over the manner and time of death.
Mission 3Diversity

Religious and secular views

Religious and secular viewsViewReason or noteCatholic and Orthodox Christiansalways wronginnocent life must neverbe deliberately ended;refusing disproportionatetreatment and pain reliefthat may shorten life areallowedChurch of England (official)has opposedchanging the lawpalliative care; protectingthe vulnerableIndividual Anglicans, e.g. Desmond Tutupublicly supportedassisted dying(2014)Anglicans differHans Küng (liberal Catholic voice)a responsible choiceto dieA Dignified Dying (1995,with Walter Jens)Humanists UK, Dignity in Dyingback a change in thelawautonomy andcompassionSome disability-rights campaigners (e.g. NotDead Yet UK)opposefear pressure onvulnerable peopleNot simply "religious against secular"
  • Catholic and Orthodox Christians: euthanasia and assisted suicide are always wrong; refusing disproportionate treatment and pain relief that may shorten life are allowed.
  • Church of England: has opposed changing the law, stressing palliative care and protection of the vulnerable. But individual Anglicans differ: e.g. Desmond Tutu (1931–2021) publicly supported assisted dying (2014).
  • Liberal Christian voices: e.g. Hans Küng (1928–2021), a dissenting Catholic theologian, argued for a responsible choice to die in A Dignified Dying (1995, with Walter Jens).
  • Secular supporters: Humanists UK and Dignity in Dying back a change in the law, on grounds of autonomy and compassion.
  • Secular opponents: some disability-rights campaigners (e.g. Not Dead Yet UK) and many palliative-care doctors fear pressure on vulnerable people.
  • So the divide is not simply "religious against secular".
Quick check
?On Singer's view of personhood, why would it be gravely wrong to kill a competent adult who wants to go on living?
Mission check

?Ruth, 80, has advanced dementia and no longer recognises anyone. Her son says: "Mum always said she never wanted to live like this. Her life lacks everything that made it hers." Her daughter, a Christian, says: "She is still Mum and still loved by God. We should keep caring for her, though not with treatments that only burden her." Which analysis is correct?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Is switching off a machine morally different from giving a lethal injection?

Make a guess: Is switching off a machine morally different from giving a lethal injection?

Mission 4

Natural law applied

Natural law applied to euthanasiado good, avoid evilPrimary preceptpreservation of life (also orderedsociety)Secondary preceptnever directly kill the innocentvoluntaryeuthanasiaassisted suicideAquinas on suicide: ST II-II q.64 a.5against natural self-love, injures thecommunity, takes what belongs to God(paraphrase)
  • Primary precept: preservation of life. A secondary precept follows: never directly kill an innocent human being.
  • Aquinas on suicide (Summa Theologiae II-II q. 64 a. 5, paraphrase): it goes against natural self-love, injures the community, and takes what belongs to God.
  • So voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide are wrong: the person's consent does not change what the act is.
  • Also against ordered society: doctors would become agents of death.
  • Natural law is absolutist here: no exceptions for hard cases.
Mission 4

Double effect and proportionate means

The double effect testConditionsmorphinefor painlethalinjection1act good in itselfrelieving pain2death foreseen, notintended3death not the meansof relief4proportionate reasonsevere pain at the endof lifeLethal injection fails conditions 2 and 3: deathis intended, and it is the means.
  • Double effect: an act with a good and a bad effect may be done if the act is not wrong in itself, the bad effect is not intended or the means to the good, and there is a proportionate reason.
  • Pain relief: strong painkillers given to relieve pain may be right even if they may shorten life, as long as death is foreseen, not intended (Pius XII, 1957; Catechism 2279).
  • Proportionate means (1980 Declaration, paraphrase): no one must accept treatment that is too burdensome or out of proportion to its expected benefit. Refusing it is accepting death, not causing it.
  • (Older terms: ordinary and extraordinary means.)
  • So natural law separates euthanasia from good end-of-life care by intention and proportion, not by whether the doctor acts or omits.
  • Critics: intention is hidden; a large dose "to relieve pain" might be euthanasia in disguise.
Quick check
?A Catholic man with advanced lung disease refuses to go back on a ventilator, knowing he will die within days. He says, "I am not trying to die; I just cannot bear this treatment any longer." How would natural law, as taught by the Catholic Church, judge his choice?
Mission 4

Situation ethics applied

Situation ethics appliedFletcherMorals and Medicine (1954), chapter"Euthanasia: Our Right to Die"A competent, terminally ill patient asks to dieAgapeif ending a life onrequest is the mostloving act, it is rightPersonalismthe person in painmatters more thanthe rule "never kill"Pragmatismdoes a rule againsteuthanasia actuallyhelp this patient?Relativismdepends on the case:love might refuse arequest made underfamily pressure
  • Joseph Fletcher argued for voluntary euthanasia years before Situation Ethics (1966): Morals and Medicine (1954), chapter "Euthanasia: Our Right to Die".
  • Agape: the only intrinsic good. If ending a life on request is the most loving act in the situation, it is right.
  • Personalism: the person in pain matters more than the rule "never kill".
  • Pragmatism: does a rule against euthanasia actually help this patient?
  • Relativism: the answer depends on the case: love might also refuse a request made under family pressure.
  • Fletcher also used personhood ("indicators of humanhood") to argue that ending life where no person remains need not be wrong.
  • Critics: one person's calculation of love could justify non-voluntary euthanasia; a society may need firm rules to protect the vulnerable.
Mission 4

Virtue ethics and utilitarianism

  • Peter Singer (preference utilitarian): if a competent person prefers to die, respecting that preference is right; "respect a person's desire to live or die" is one of his new commandments (Rethinking Life and Death, 1994).
  • A rule utilitarian may still oppose legalisation if the rule would lead to more harm (pressure, mistakes, lost trust).
Mission 4

Acts and omissions

Rachels: Smith and JonesSmithdrowns his cousinJoneslets his cousin drownsame motive (an inheritance),same resultkilling?letting dieRachels (1975), paraphrase
  • Acts and omissions doctrine: actively killing is morally worse than letting someone die, even if the result is the same.
  • Defenders: in letting die, the disease causes death; the doctor stops fighting it. UK law follows this line (Bland, 1993).
  • James Rachels (1941–2003), "Active and Passive Euthanasia" (New England Journal of Medicine, 1975): Smith drowns his young cousin for an inheritance; Jones means to, but watches the boy slip and drown. Neither is less guilty (paraphrase).
  • So, Rachels argues, if letting die is allowed, a quicker, kinder lethal injection may be better: passive euthanasia can mean a slower death.
  • Glover (Causing Death and Saving Life, 1977) also denies that the difference between act and omission has moral weight of its own; what matters is the outcome and the reasons.
Quick check
?What is the point of Rachels' Smith and Jones example?
Mission 4

The doctor–patient relationship and trust

  • The Hippocratic Oath (Greek, c. 4th century BCE) includes a promise not to give a deadly drug to anyone who asks (paraphrase).
  • Trust argument against: if doctors may end lives, patients (especially the old, disabled or poor) may fear them; medicine's purpose of healing is blurred.
  • Doctors' consciences: should any doctor be required to take part? Bills and laws normally include a right to opt out.
  • Trust argument for: patients may trust doctors more if they know their wishes at the end will be honoured, openly rather than in secret.
  • Professional bodies differ: the British Medical Association moved to a neutral position in 2021; many palliative-care doctors remain opposed.
  • Patients' trust also depends on doctors being honest about prognosis and options.
Mission 4

The slippery slope

The slippery-slope argumentThe argument's claimadultsterminally illvoluntary,adultsnon-terminalcannot askthose whosafeguards?Logical formargues from the reasons: if autonomy is thereason, why only the terminally ill?Empirical formpoints to changes where laws exist2005Netherlands: Groningen Protocolfor newborns2014Belgium: age limit for childrenremoved2021Canada: extended to people whosedeath is not foreseeableReplieseach change was debated and voted on, notinevitable; safeguards and reporting can holda line
  • Slippery slope: allowing voluntary euthanasia in limited cases will lead, step by step, to cases now thought wrong.
  • Logical form: if autonomy is the reason, why limit it to the terminally ill? If relief of suffering is the reason, why limit it to those who can ask?
  • Empirical form: points to change where laws exist, e.g. the Netherlands' Groningen Protocol for newborns (2005); Belgium's removal of an age limit for children (2014); Canada extending medical assistance in dying to people whose death is not foreseeable (2021).
  • Replies: each change was debated and voted on, not inevitable; strict safeguards and reporting can hold a line; the evidence is read differently by each side.
  • Opponents add: pressure on people who feel a burden, and on disabled people.
Mission 4Evaluate

Can a person have complete autonomy over their own life?

Argument map: complete autonomy over one's own life?"A competent adult should have completeautonomy over their own life, including howand when it ends."ForMill's harm principle: over one's own bodythe individual is sovereign; refusingtreatment is already allowedSinger and Glover: respecting a person'sconsidered wish to die respects them as apersonAgainstNo one chooses alone: pain, depression,money and fear of being a burden shapechoicesOthers must act (doctors, nurses); naturallaw and many Christians: life is held intrust from GodSome argue autonomy dominates onlybecause shared values have thinned; itmay not be enough on its ownJudge it byIs the choice truly free and informed? · Whoelse must act? · Can safeguards protect thevulnerable? · Is life a gift, a possession, orboth?
  • Claim: A competent adult should have complete autonomy over their own life, including how and when it ends.
  • For: Mill's harm principle: over one's own body the individual is sovereign. Refusing treatment is already allowed.
  • For: Singer and Glover: respecting a person's considered wish to die respects them as a person.
  • Against: No one chooses alone: choices are shaped by pain, depression, money and fear of being a burden.
  • Against: Others must act (doctors, nurses), so it is not purely self-regarding; natural law and many Christians: life is held in trust from God.
  • Against: some argue autonomy dominates only because shared values have thinned; it may not be enough on its own.
  • Judgement criteria: Is the choice truly free and informed? Who else must act? Can safeguards protect the vulnerable? Is life a gift, a possession, or both?
Quick check
?Which argument is an example of the logical form of the slippery slope?
Mission 4Worked answer

Applying a theory

Issue: "Situation ethics is a better approach to voluntary euthanasia than natural law."

  • Point: Situation ethics responds to the actual patient: if a competent, terminally ill woman in unrelievable pain asks to die, agape and personalism may require helping her.
  • Source: Fletcher, Morals and Medicine (1954): a "right to die" in such cases.
  • Counter: Natural law protects the vulnerable with a fixed rule, and double effect already allows strong pain relief.
  • Develop: The test is whether a case-by-case approach can be safe across a whole health system, or only at one bedside.
  • Mini-judgement: It answers the single case well, but must meet the slippery slope and trust objections to answer the question about law.
  • AO2 tip: end each paragraph with a mini-judgement that answers the issue set, not just a summary.
Mission check

?A hospice doctor gives a dying patient increasing doses of morphine to control severe pain, knowing this may shorten his life by some hours. In another hospital, a doctor gives a patient a drug whose only purpose is to stop the heart, at the patient's request. What would natural law conclude?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Is a child a gift or a right, and who decides what happens to embryos made in a lab?

Make a guess: Is a child a gift or a right, and who decides what happens to embryos made in a lab?

Mission 5

Infertility and IVF

How IVF worksStimulatehormones stimulate the ovariesCollecteggs are collectedFertilisewith sperm in a laboratory dish (orICSI: one sperm injected into an egg)Growembryos grow for about 5 daysTransferusually one embryo is transferred tothe wombSpare embryosfrozen for later use · donated to others ·donated to research · allowed to perish
  • Infertility: not becoming pregnant after 12 months or more of regular unprotected sex (World Health Organization definition). Causes may lie with either partner, or be unexplained.
  • It can bring grief, strain on relationships, and a sense of loss.
  • IVF (in vitro fertilisation, "in glass"): hormones stimulate the ovaries; eggs are collected; they are fertilised with sperm in a laboratory; embryos grow for about 5 days; usually one is transferred to the womb.
  • First IVF birth: Louise Brown, Oldham, 1978 (Robert Edwards and Patrick Steptoe).
  • Variants: ICSI (one sperm injected into an egg); donor eggs, sperm or embryos.
  • Spare embryos are often frozen for later use, donated to others or to research, or allowed to perish.
Mission 5

The status of the embryo in IVF

The status of the embryoFull statuse.g. Catholicteaching: ahuman beingfromfertilisation,treated as apersonSpecialstatusWarnockReport(1984), UKlaw: respectandprotection,not that dueto a personNo intrinsicstatussome secularviews, e.g.Singer: nosentience orinterests;valued forwhat it meansto others
  • IVF usually creates more embryos than are transferred. What is owed to an embryo in a dish?
  • Full status (e.g. Catholic teaching): the embryo is a human being from fertilisation, to be treated as a person; discarding or freezing embryos wrongs them.
  • Special status (Warnock Report, 1984; UK law): the embryo deserves respect and protection, but not the full protection given to a person.
  • No intrinsic status (some secular views, e.g. Singer): an early embryo has no sentience or interests; its value lies in what it means to others.
  • The same personhood and potentiality arguments as for abortion apply (see Mission 1), but there is no pregnant woman whose rights compete.
Quick check
?Which statement best expresses the "special status" view of the embryo taken in UK law since the Warnock Report?
Mission 5Read the source

Children as gift

Love and life in one actCatholic teaching (Donum Vitae, 1987)lovelifeconjugal act: joinedlovelifeIVF: separatedThe conjugal act of husband and wife joins:unitive meaning (love) · procreative meaning(life)

> "God blessed them. God said to them, 'Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it.'" (Genesis 1:28, WEBBE)

> "Behold, children are a heritage of the LORD. The fruit of the womb is his reward." (Psalm 127:3, WEBBE)

  • The Bible tells of infertility as real grief: Sarah (Genesis 16–18, 21), Hannah (1 Samuel 1), Elizabeth (Luke 1).
  • Sarai gives her servant Hagar to Abram to bear a child for her (Genesis 16:1–4): often cited in surrogacy debates, as a story that ends in rivalry and pain.

Q1 What does Psalm 127:3 suggest about whether a child can be owed to anyone?

Show answer

Children are a heritage and gift from God, not something earned or owed.

Q2 How might a Christian use Genesis 1:28 to support IVF?

Show answer

Having children is blessed by God; medicine may help a couple fulfil that blessing.

Mission 5

Catholic teaching

Love and life in one actCatholic teaching (Donum Vitae, 1987)lovelifeconjugal act: joinedlovelifeIVF: separatedThe conjugal act of husband and wife joins:unitive meaning (love) · procreative meaning(life)a child is not something owed to anyone, buta gift (Catechism 2378, paraphrase)
  • Donum Vitae (Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, 1987): a child should be conceived through the conjugal act of husband and wife, which joins the unitive (love) and procreative (life) meanings of sex. IVF separates them.
  • Donor gametes and surrogacy bring a third party into marriage and are rejected.
  • Even IVF with the couple's own gametes is not accepted, though a child conceived by IVF has full dignity and is to be loved.
  • Dignitas Personae (2008): the loss and freezing of embryos in IVF are grave wrongs.
  • Catechism 2378 (paraphrase): a child is not something owed to anyone, but a gift.
  • Treatments that help the conjugal act achieve conception (e.g. treating a hormonal cause) are welcomed.
Mission 5Diversity

Other views

Views on IVF and related practicesIVF, ownDonorsSurrogacySpareembryosCatholicnononoloss andfreezing:gravewrongsChurch of England, many Protestantsmarriedcouplesconcern(anonymity)deepreservationsconcernSome evangelicalsif nonediscarded––none tobediscardedJudaismwidelyaccepteddebated(donorsperm)––Islammarriedcouplemost Sunni:no; someShi'a:permitmost Sunni:no–Secular: procreative liberty (Robertson, 1994)a strong right to decide whether and how tohave childrenSome feminist criticsphysical risks of egg collection; pressure onwomen to keep trying– not covered here
  • Church of England and many Protestant churches: IVF can be a good use of God-given medical skill for married couples; concern about spare embryos and donor anonymity.
  • Some evangelicals accept IVF only if no embryos are discarded (e.g. creating only as many as will be transferred).
  • Judaism: having children is a commandment (Genesis 1:28); IVF is widely accepted, often under rabbinic supervision; use of donor sperm is debated.
  • Islam (most Sunni scholars): IVF is permitted for a married couple using their own eggs and sperm; donor gametes and surrogacy are forbidden. Some Shi'a authorities permit donation.
  • Secular views: procreative liberty (John Robertson, Children of Choice, 1994): people have a strong right to decide whether and how to have children; utilitarians weigh the great good of a wanted child.
  • Some feminist critics point to the physical risks of egg collection and the pressure on women to keep trying.
Quick check
?Why does the Catholic Church teach that IVF is wrong even when a married couple use their own eggs and sperm?
Mission 5

Surrogacy

Types of surrogacyher eggTraditional (partial)the surrogate's owneggIVF embryoGestational (full)an embryo made byIVF from the intendedparents' or donors'gametesUK lawSurrogacy Arrangements Act 1985:commercial surrogacy banned; reasonableexpenses only. The surrogate is the legalmother at birth; the intended parents applyfor a parental order.
  • Surrogacy: a woman carries a pregnancy for others who will raise the child.
  • Traditional (partial): the surrogate's own egg. Gestational (full): an embryo made by IVF from the intended parents' or donors' gametes.
  • UK law: Surrogacy Arrangements Act 1985 (after the "Baby Cotton" case, 1985): commercial surrogacy is banned; only reasonable expenses may be paid. The surrogate is the legal mother at birth; the intended parents apply for a parental order.
  • For: an act of generous love; may be the only way for some couples to have a genetically related child.
  • Against: risk of treating children and women's bodies as commodities; exploitation in international commercial surrogacy; painful disputes if the surrogate wishes to keep the child.
  • Most Christian churches have deep reservations; Catholic teaching rejects it.
Mission 5

Ownership and rights

  • Principle of ownership: can anyone own an embryo or gametes? Are they property, persons, or something between?
  • Evans v United Kingdom (European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, 2007): Natallie Evans' embryos were made with her then partner before her cancer treatment. After they separated he withdrew consent. UK law requires both to consent to use, so the embryos were destroyed. The Court found no breach of her rights.
  • Right to found a family (European Convention on Human Rights, Article 12) protects marriage and family life, but courts have not treated it as a right to be provided with a child.
  • The child's rights: people conceived from donations made since April 2005 can learn their donor's identity at 18.
  • Christian voices often prefer the language of stewardship and gift to ownership.
Mission 5

The HFEA

Regulating fertility treatment: a timeline1978Louise Brown, first IVF birth(Oldham)1984Warnock Report1985Surrogacy Arrangements Act1990HFE Act creates the HFEA2005donor anonymity ends (donationsfrom April 2005)2007Evans v United Kingdom (EuropeanCourt of Human Rights)2008HFE Act: "supportive parenting";same-sex couples both legalparents
  • Warnock Report (1984), chaired by Mary Warnock (1924–2019): recommended regulating IVF and embryo research, with the 14-day rule.
  • Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 created the HFEA (Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority).
  • The HFEA licenses and inspects fertility clinics and embryo research; sets a Code of Practice; keeps a register of donors and of treatment cycles; limits how long embryos and gametes may be stored.
  • HFE Act 2008: the clinic must consider a child's need for "supportive parenting" (replacing "the need for a father"); same-sex couples can both be legal parents.
  • Critics: some religious groups say it permits too much; some scientists and patients say it restricts too much. Supporters: a model of regulation by public debate.
Mission 5

Sex, marriage, family and society

  • Sex and procreation separated: conception without intercourse, and intercourse without conception (contraception): Catholic teaching rejects both separations; many others accept them.
  • New family forms: single parents by choice, same-sex couples, donor-conceived children with several "parents" (genetic, gestational, social).
  • Concerns: the child's welfare and identity; treating children as products; unequal access (cost, NHS rules differ by area).
  • Responses: what makes a family is love and care, not biology alone; many donor-conceived people value openness about their origins.
  • Christians differ: some see these families as departing from the Genesis pattern of marriage; others stress welcome and care for every child.
Quick check
?In Evans v United Kingdom (2007), why could Natallie Evans not use the frozen embryos?
Mission 5Evaluate

Is there a right to have a child?

Argument map: is there a right to have a child?"People have a right to use reproductivetechnology to have a child."ForProcreative liberty: reproduction is centralto many lives; the state should not block itwithout strong reasonIf fertile couples may have childrenwithout permission, why should infertilecouples face barriers?AgainstA right to try is not a right to a child: noone can be owed a person (Catholicteaching: a child is a gift)The child's welfare and the interests ofdonors, surrogates and embryos limit anysuch rightJudge it byWhose rights are in play (parents, child,donor, surrogate, embryo)? · Is the rightnegative (not to be stopped) or positive (to beprovided for)? · What should public healthservices fund?
  • Claim: People have a right to use reproductive technology to have a child.
  • For: Procreative liberty: reproduction is central to many lives; the state should not block it without strong reason.
  • For: If fertile couples may have children without permission, why should infertile couples face barriers?
  • Against: A right to try is not a right to a child: no one can be owed a person (Catholic teaching: a child is a gift).
  • Against: The child's welfare and the interests of donors, surrogates and embryos limit any such right.
  • Judgement criteria: Whose rights are in play (parents, child, donor, surrogate, embryo)? Is the right negative (not to be stopped) or positive (to be provided for)? What should public health services fund?
Mission check

?A married couple use IVF with their own eggs and sperm. They create one embryo only, and it is transferred to the wife's womb, so no embryo is frozen or discarded. Which statement is accurate?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If we can choose or change an embryo's genes, where does curing disease end and designing children begin?

Make a guess: If we can choose or change an embryo's genes, where does curing disease end and designing children begin?

Mission 6

Embryo research and the 14-day rule

The first 14 daysFertilisationday 0Blastocystday 5–6Primitive streakabout day 14: twinning no longerpossible; the nervous systembegins to formResearch limit (UK)never beyond 14 days, or once the primitivestreak appears · HFE Act 1990 · Warnock1984
  • Embryo research: studying human embryos (usually spare IVF embryos, sometimes made for research) to understand infertility, miscarriage, genetic disease and early development.
  • UK law (HFE Act 1990): research is allowed only under an HFEA licence, and never beyond 14 days after fertilisation, or once the primitive streak appears.
  • Why 14 days? After it, twinning is no longer possible and the nervous system begins to form (Warnock Report, 1984).
  • Embryos used in research may never be placed in a woman.
  • Laws differ: e.g. Germany's Embryo Protection Act (1990) forbids destructive embryo research.
  • Status question: full status, special status, or none?
Mission 6

Stem cells and cord blood

Sources of stem cellsEmbryonicfrom a 5–6-day embryo (blastocyst);pluripotent: almost any cell type; the embryois destroyed; first human lines 1998Adult (e.g. bone marrow)more limited; used in treatment for decades;no embryo destroyediPS cellsadult cells reprogrammed to anembryonic-like state (Yamanaka, 2006)Cord bloodfrom the umbilical cord and placenta afterbirth; blood-forming stem cells
  • Stem cells can divide and become specialised cells. Hope: repairing damaged tissue (e.g. in Parkinson's disease, spinal injury, diabetes).
  • Embryonic stem cells: taken from a 5–6-day embryo (blastocyst); pluripotent (can become almost any cell type). Taking them destroys the embryo. First human lines: 1998.
  • Adult stem cells (e.g. bone marrow): more limited, but used in treatment for decades; no embryo destroyed.
  • Induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS cells): adult cells reprogrammed to an embryonic-like state (Shinya Yamanaka, 2006; Nobel Prize 2012).
  • Cord blood: blood from the umbilical cord and placenta after birth, rich in blood-forming stem cells; used to treat leukaemia and other blood disorders; can be donated to public banks or stored privately.
  • Catholic teaching supports research with adult, iPS and cord-blood stem cells, and opposes embryonic stem-cell research (Dignitas Personae, 2008).
Quick check
?Why do many people who oppose embryonic stem-cell research support research using cord blood?
Mission 6

PGD and saviour siblings

PGD: testing embryos1 IVF embryosembryos made by IVF2 Cells testedone or a few cells taken and tested for aserious genetic condition (e.g. cystic fibrosis,Huntington's disease)3 Transferan unaffected embryo is transferred to thewombSaviour siblingembryos also tested for a tissue match with asick older child (Quintavalle, 2005)
  • PGD (pre-implantation genetic diagnosis): one or a few cells are taken from IVF embryos and tested for a serious genetic condition (e.g. cystic fibrosis, Huntington's disease); unaffected embryos are transferred.
  • In the UK the HFEA decides which conditions may be tested for. Sex selection for non-medical reasons is illegal.
  • Saviour siblings: embryos are tested to find one whose tissue matches a sick older child, so cord blood or bone marrow can help them. The House of Lords upheld the HFEA's power to allow this (Quintavalle, 2005, the Hashmi family case).
  • For: prevents serious suffering; parents can have a healthy child.
  • Against: affected embryos are discarded; it may express a judgement that disabled lives are worth less; a saviour sibling might be valued as a means (Kant's objection).
  • Catholic teaching rejects PGD because it involves selecting and discarding embryos (Dignitas Personae §22).
Mission 6

Cloning

Cloning by nuclear transferbody cellnucleuseggown nucleus removednucleus put into the egg: an embryo withthe donor's DNAReproductiveembryo to a womb:illegal in the UKTherapeuticstem cells; theembryo is destroyedDolly the sheep, 1996, Roslin Institute
  • Cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer: the nucleus of a body cell is put into an egg whose own nucleus has been removed; the egg develops as an embryo with the donor's DNA.
  • Dolly the sheep (born 1996, Roslin Institute, Scotland): the first mammal cloned from an adult cell.
  • Reproductive cloning (to make a born human clone) is illegal in the UK and most countries.
  • Therapeutic (research) cloning: making a cloned embryo to obtain matched stem cells; possible under HFEA licence; the embryo is destroyed.
  • Objections: risks of abnormality; a clone's sense of identity and an "open future"; making children to a pattern; the embryo's status; "playing God".
  • Replies: a clone would be a separate person, like a late-born identical twin; therapeutic cloning could cure disease.
Mission 6

Mitochondrial donation

Mitochondrial donationMaternal spindletransferunfertilised eggsmother'sdonorPronuclear transferfertilised eggs:embryos created anddestroyedparents'donorfaulty mitochondriahealthy (donor)nuclear DNA from the parents37 mitochondrial genes from the donor;nuclear DNA from the parentsDebatea germline change: passed on throughdaughters
  • Mitochondria: tiny structures in cells that supply energy; they have their own small set of genes (37), passed down through the mother.
  • Mitochondrial disease can be severe or fatal. Mitochondrial donation replaces faulty mitochondria with healthy ones from a donor egg, using IVF.
  • Two methods: maternal spindle transfer (eggs) and pronuclear transfer (fertilised eggs, so embryos are created and destroyed).
  • UK first to allow it: Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Mitochondrial Donation) Regulations 2015; HFEA licenses each case (Newcastle clinic first licensed, 2017).
  • Called "three-parent babies": the child has a tiny amount of donor DNA; nuclear DNA (which shapes appearance and personality) is from the parents.
  • Debate: a germline change, passed on through daughters; embryo destruction in pronuclear transfer; long-term safety. Catholic teaching opposes it; the Church of England urged caution in 2015.
Quick check
?Which of these is reproductive cloning?
Mission 6

'Designer' babies

From treatment to designtreatmentdesign12345Treat diseasePGD for cystic fibrosis1Prevent diseasemitochondrial donation2Saviour siblingembryo chosen for a tissue match3Non-medical selectione.g. sex, intelligence4Genome editing for enhancementa 'designer' baby5Scholars (paraphrase)Savulescu (2001)parents should select the child expected tohave the best lifeSandel (2007)the drive to mastery erodes seeing children asgiftsHabermas (2003)a designed person may not see themselves assole author of their own life
  • 'Designer' baby: a child whose genes are chosen or changed for non-medical traits (e.g. height, intelligence) rather than to avoid disease.
  • Genome editing (e.g. CRISPR) can change genes in embryos. In 2018 He Jiankui announced the birth of twin girls whose genes he had edited; he was widely condemned and imprisoned in China (2019).
  • Editing embryos for reproduction is illegal in the UK.
  • Julian Savulescu, "Procreative Beneficence" (Bioethics, 2001): parents should select, of the possible children, the one expected to have the best life (paraphrase).
  • Michael Sandel, The Case Against Perfection (2007): the deeper problem is not safety but the drive to mastery; it erodes seeing children as gifts and humility before what we are given (paraphrase).
  • Jürgen Habermas, The Future of Human Nature (2003): a designed person may not be able to see themselves as the sole author of their own life (paraphrase).
Mission 6

The theories applied

The theories appliedNatural lawSituationethicsVirtue ethicsEmbryo researchdestroying anembryo breaksthe precept topreserve lifeagape mayfavourresearch thatcures diseasevaries:compassionsupportscuring diseaseCloningseparatesreproductionfrom themarital actFletcherwelcomedlaboratoryreproductionas responsiblevaries: whatwould a wise,humbleperson do?'Designer' babiesenhancementmay be anapparent goodFletcher(1974)welcomedgenetic controlSandel'shumility warnsagainst design
  • Natural law: the embryo is a human life from conception, so destroying it for research breaks the precept to preserve life, however good the aim; cloning separates reproduction from the marital act. Treating disease is a real good; enhancement may be an apparent good.
  • Situation ethics: Fletcher, The Ethics of Genetic Control (1974), welcomed genetic control and laboratory reproduction as deliberate, responsible, so more human, than chance (paraphrase). Agape may favour research that cures disease; for Fletcher an early embryo is not a person.
  • Virtue ethics: what would a compassionate, wise and humble person do? Compassion supports curing disease; Sandel's humility warns against design; practical wisdom asks where treatment ends.
Mission 6

Science, technology and Christian ethics

Christian ethics and technologyChristian ethics and technologyStewardshipco-creators andstewards (Genesis1:28; 2:15)HealingJesus' healingministry supportstreating diseasePlaying God?warnings againstpride (Tower ofBabel, Genesis 11)Image of Godevery human hasequal dignity,whatever theirgenesDisability critiqueselecting against acondition may saypeople with it areless welcome (Asch)Inequalitythe rich could passon advantages intheir genes
  • Co-creators and stewards: humans are made in God's image and given responsibility over creation (Genesis 1:28; 2:15); medicine and science can be ways of loving the neighbour.
  • Jesus' healing ministry supports treating disease.
  • "Playing God": warnings against pride and overreach (e.g. the Tower of Babel, Genesis 11:1–9). Critics: all medicine "interferes"; the real question is which interventions respect human dignity.
  • Limits: many Christians accept therapy (healing) but reject enhancement (design), and reject destroying embryos.
  • Christian ethicists differ: Catholic teaching sets firm limits; some Protestant ethicists accept embryo research up to 14 days.
Mission 6

Equal dignity

Christian ethics and technologyChristian ethics and technologyStewardshipco-creators andstewards (Genesis1:28; 2:15)HealingJesus' healingministry supportstreating diseasePlaying God?warnings againstpride (Tower ofBabel, Genesis 11)Image of Godevery human hasequal dignity,whatever theirgenesDisability critiqueselecting against acondition may saypeople with it areless welcome (Asch)Inequalitythe rich could passon advantages intheir genes
  • Spec: how new reproductive technologies could undermine the equal dignity of individuals.
  • Disability critique (e.g. Adrienne Asch, 1946–2013): selecting against a condition can send the message that people living with it are less welcome.
  • Eugenics: the history of state programmes to "improve" the population warns against ranking human lives.
  • Inequality: if enhancement is bought privately, the rich could pass on advantages in their genes.
  • Equality of status: Habermas: the designer and the designed would no longer meet as equals.
  • Replies: preventing suffering is not a judgement on disabled people; parents choosing is not state eugenics; regulation can keep access fair.
  • Christian basis: every human being bears the image of God and has equal dignity, whatever their genes.
Mission 6Evaluate

Should embryos be used to cure disease?

Argument map: should embryos be used to cure disease?"It is right to destroy early human embryosin research that may cure serious disease."ForBefore 14 days an embryo has no nervoussystem and cannot suffer; the potentialrelief of suffering is greatSpare IVF embryos will perish anyway;using them shows more respect thanwasting themAgainstIf the embryo has the status of a person(Catholic teaching), no benefit to othersjustifies killing itAlternatives (adult, iPS, cord-blood stemcells) may make it unnecessary; treatingembryos as material may weaken respectfor all human lifeJudge it byWhat is the embryo's status? · Are therealternatives? · Does the 14-day rule expressrespect, or is it an arbitrary line?
  • Claim: It is right to destroy early human embryos in research that may cure serious disease.
  • For: An embryo before 14 days has no nervous system and cannot suffer; the potential relief of suffering is great.
  • For: Spare IVF embryos will perish anyway; using them shows more respect than wasting them.
  • Against: If the embryo has the status of a person (Catholic teaching), no benefit to others justifies killing it.
  • Against: Alternatives (adult, iPS, cord-blood stem cells) may make it unnecessary; and treating embryos as material may weaken respect for all human life.
  • Judgement criteria: What is the embryo's status? Are there alternatives? Does the 14-day rule express respect, or is it an arbitrary line?
Mission check

?A clinic in another country offers to test a couple's IVF embryos and pick the one predicted to have the highest intelligence. No disease is involved. Which statement accurately applies the views in this mission?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Do people need God to be good, or can religion get in the way of being good?

Make a guess: Do people need God to be good, or can religion get in the way of being good?

Mission 7

Three ways morality might depend on God

Three ways morality might depend on GodExistenceKnowledgeMotivationExampleDCTrevelationfinal justiceDependence: depends on God?yesyesyesMiddle view (many believers)yespartly—Independencenonono
  • Dependence: morality depends on religion. Three versions:
  • Existence: there is no right or wrong without God (divine command theory).
  • Knowledge: we cannot know right and wrong reliably without revelation.
  • Motivation: without God and final justice, people have no strong reason to be moral.
  • Independence: morality stands on its own: reason, human nature, sympathy or social agreement are enough.
  • Many believers take a middle view: God is the ultimate source of goodness, but people can know much of it by reason and conscience (natural law).
  • Keep the three versions apart: a critic may reject one and accept another.
Mission 7

Autonomy, heteronomy, theonomy

Autonomy, heteronomy, theonomyAutonomy“self-law” · Kantmy reasonlawHeteronomy“other-law” · Kantoutside the willdesire, fear, reward,commandlawTheonomy“God-law” · TillichGod as ground of beingmy deepestselflaw
  • Immanuel Kant (1724–1804), Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785).
  • Autonomy ("self-law"): the rational will gives the moral law to itself. Only this gives an act moral worth.
  • Heteronomy ("other-law"): the will is moved by something outside reason: desire, fear, reward, or a command obeyed because it is commanded.
  • Kant still links duty and religion: in Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason (1793) religion is recognising our duties as divine commands.
  • Paul Tillich (1886–1965), Systematic Theology, vol. 1 (1951): theonomy ("God-law") is neither. God is the ground of our being, so God's law is the deepest law of our own nature, not an alien rule.
  • Tillich: heteronomy breeds rebellion; autonomy alone grows empty; theonomy unites them.
Quick check
?A Christian says: "When I keep God's law I am not obeying an outside master. It is the deepest law of who I really am." Which concept best fits this?
Mission 7Read the source

A law written in the heart

> "… when Gentiles who don't have the law do by nature the things of the law, these, not having the law, are a law to themselves, in that they show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience testifying with them …" (Romans 2:14–15, WEBBE)

> "I will put my law in their inward parts, and I will write it in their heart." (Jeremiah 31:33, WEBBE)

  • Paul: people without the Jewish law still know much of what it requires.
  • Many Christians read this as support for independence of knowledge (conscience, natural law) with dependence of existence (the law is God's).

Q1 What do the Gentiles in Romans 2 lack, and what do they still have?

Show answer

They lack the written law; they have its work written in their hearts and a conscience.

Q2 Which concept from the earlier screen is closest to Jeremiah 31:33?

Show answer

Theonomy: God's law becomes the person's own inner law.

Mission 7

Dawkins: good without God

Dawkins: Darwinian roots of moralityDawkins: Darwinian rootskin altruismreciprocal altruismreputationgenerosity as signalmisfiring rule of thumbkindness to strangers
  • Richard Dawkins (b. 1941), The God Delusion (2006), chapters 6–7.
  • Our moral sense has Darwinian roots: kin altruism, reciprocal altruism, reputation, and generosity as a signal. These shaped "rules of thumb" that now misfire usefully, as kindness to strangers.
  • The point of morality for the atheist: being good only for reward or from fear of God is not real morality. Someone who would be cruel if God did not exist reveals a poor moral character (paraphrase).
  • We do not really take morals from scripture: believers pick and choose texts, guided by a changing moral Zeitgeist (spirit of the age).
  • Responses: explaining where moral feelings came from does not show whether they are true or binding; many theists accept evolution as God's means; Alister McGrath (b. 1953) and Joanna Collicutt McGrath, The Dawkins Delusion? (2007), argue Dawkins misreads religion.
Mission 7

Rachels: pointless without religion, or opposed to it?

  • James Rachels (1941–2003).
  • "Morality is pointless without religion": the claim that without God there is no final justice and no reason to be good. In The Elements of Moral Philosophy (1986, ch. 4) Rachels examines this and rejects it: morality has its own reasons: the interests of the people our acts affect.
  • "Morality is opposed to religion": "God and Human Attitudes", Religious Studies (1971):
  • (1) If any being is God, it must be worthy of worship.
  • (2) Worship means total submission: giving up your role as an autonomous moral agent.
  • (3) A moral agent can never give that up. So no being could be worthy of worship; so there is no God (paraphrase).
  • Replies: worship of a perfectly good God need not mean giving up judgement: trusting a wiser being can itself be rational; theonomy denies that God's law is alien.
  • Spec wording: morality "as pointless without religion" and "as opposed to religion".
Quick check
?Which argument belongs to Rachels rather than to Dawkins?
Mission 7

Does religion make people behave better?

Does religion make people behave better?For a linkteachingcommunityaccountabilitycharityAgainstgood non-believersscandalsviolencehypocrisyevidence contested
  • Reasons given for a link: teaching (commandments, parables, the Five Pillars, the Eightfold Path); community and example; accountability before God; practice (prayer, confession) that builds character; organised charity (hospitals, schools, food banks).
  • "By their fruits you will know them." (Matthew 7:20, WEBBE). "Faith, if it has no works, is dead" (James 2:17, WEBBE).
  • Reasons given against: many non-religious people are just as moral; abuse scandals and religious violence; hypocrisy; Sharpe and Dawkins: doctrine can override compassion.
  • Evidence is contested: some studies link generosity to belonging to a religious community more than to belief itself; results vary by country and by how behaviour is measured.
  • A philosophical point: even if believers behaved better, that would not settle whether morality depends on God.
Mission 7

Faith in the public square

  • The public square: law, politics and public debate.
  • Include religion: Richard John Neuhaus (1936–2009), The Naked Public Square (1984): a public life stripped of religion loses a main source of moral values. Rowan Williams (b. 1950), Faith in the Public Square (2012): faith brings a voice for the poor and for human dignity.
  • Limit religion: John Rawls (1921–2002), Political Liberalism (1993): laws should be justified by public reason that all citizens can share, not by doctrines some reject.
  • A middle way: Jürgen Habermas (1929–2026): religious citizens may speak in religious terms, but laws need reasons translated into language all can accept.
  • UK examples: 26 Church of England bishops sit in the House of Lords; churches and faith groups take part in debates on assisted dying and poverty.
Quick check
?A bishop tells a parliamentary debate that every life is a gift from God, and then restates his case against assisted dying in terms of protecting vulnerable people, which any citizen can assess. Whose account of faith in the public square describes this two-step approach?
Mission 7Evaluate

Does morality depend on religion?

Argument map: does morality depend on religion?Morality depends on religion.ForObjective moral truth needs a sourcebeyond human mindsFinal justice gives morality a point;scripture and tradition guide and motivateTheonomy: religion can deepen, not deny,moral agencyAgainstEuthyphro dilemmaPeople know right and wrong withoutrevelation (even Romans 2:14–15 says so)Dawkins: evolved moral senseRachels: worship conflicts with autonomyBoth waysFaith groups' public voice on poverty anddignity; concern about imposing doctrineon othersJudge it byWhich kind of dependence (existence,knowledge, motivation)? · Are the abusesreligion's nature or its misuse? · Can secularethics ground objective duties?
  • Claim: Morality depends on religion.
  • For: objective moral truth needs a source beyond human minds; final justice gives morality a point; scripture and tradition guide and motivate; theonomy shows religion can deepen, not deny, moral agency.
  • Against: the Euthyphro dilemma; people know right and wrong without revelation (even Romans 2:14–15 says so); Dawkins: evolved moral sense; Rachels: worship conflicts with autonomy.
  • Both ways: faith groups' public voice on poverty and dignity; concern about imposing doctrine on others.
  • Judgement criteria: Which kind of dependence (existence, knowledge, motivation)? Are the abuses religion's nature or its misuse? Can secular ethics ground objective duties?
Mission check

?A hospital chaplain says: "Patients' suffering matters, and anyone can see that. I believe God made us able to see it, and that caring for them is also God's will." Which position does the chaplain hold?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Views on the moral status of the embryo and fetus: from conception, gradualist, or from birth; potentiality and twinning arguments are central.
  • Personhood (Warren, Singer) and the woman's rights (Thomson) are separate questions; Marquis argues against abortion without religious premises.
  • Religious, secular and feminist views each contain real diversity.

Mission 2

  • Catholic natural law forbids direct abortion but, through double effect, permits treatments such as removing a cancerous womb or an ectopic tube.
  • Situation ethics decides by agape case by case; Hursthouse asks what a virtuous person would do; Singer and Glover deny that early fetuses have the status of persons.
  • The law in Great Britain rests on grounds and a 24-week limit for most grounds; Northern Ireland's 2020 Regulations differ.

Mission 3

  • Euthanasia can be active or passive, and voluntary, non-voluntary or involuntary; in assisted suicide the person takes the last act.
  • Sanctity of life (religious: life is God-given and bears God's image) and quality of life (secular: life needs certain attributes to have value) give different answers; autonomy adds the person's own choice.
  • The personhood debate asks whether moral status comes with being human or with capacities such as self-awareness.

Mission 4

  • Natural law forbids directly ending innocent life but, through double effect and proportionate means, allows strong pain relief and refusal of burdensome treatment.
  • Situation ethics (Fletcher) can support voluntary euthanasia out of love; Rachels and Glover reject the moral weight of acts versus omissions; slippery-slope and trust arguments concern the law, not only the single case.

Mission 5

  • IVF fertilises eggs in a laboratory; spare embryos raise the question of the embryo's status (full, special or none).
  • Catholic teaching rejects IVF, donors and surrogacy (the conjugal act; a child is a gift); many Protestants, Jews and Sunni Muslims accept IVF for married couples with their own gametes; secular views stress procreative liberty and the child's welfare.
  • The HFEA (1990 Act) licenses clinics and research; consent, ownership and surrogacy are governed by UK law (Evans, 2007; Surrogacy Arrangements Act 1985).

Mission 6

  • UK law licenses embryo research up to 14 days and PGD for serious disease; reproductive cloning and embryo editing for reproduction are illegal. Embryonic stem cells require destroying embryos; adult, iPS and cord-blood stem cells do not.
  • Mitochondrial donation has been licensed case by case since 2015.
  • Natural law (protect embryonic life), situation ethics (Fletcher's welcome to genetic control) and virtue ethics (compassion, humility) give different answers; equal dignity and "giftedness" frame the debate about design.

Mission 7

  • Dependence (existence, knowledge, motivation) vs independence; Kant's autonomy vs heteronomy; Tillich's theonomy unites them.
  • Challenges: Dawkins (evolved morality; good without God), Rachels (worship vs autonomy).
  • Faith in the public square; religion and moral behaviour.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Life and death issues; Developments in bioethics; Other aspects of human experience for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1When does a developing human start to count as someone, and would that settle the abortion debate?
  2. Mission 2Can ending a pregnancy ever be a side-effect rather than a choice, and what should the law do about it?
  3. Mission 3If someone in great pain asks to die, whose life is it to end: theirs, a doctor's, or God's?
  4. Mission 4Is switching off a machine morally different from giving a lethal injection?
  5. Mission 5Is a child a gift or a right, and who decides what happens to embryos made in a lab?
  6. Mission 6If we can choose or change an embryo's genes, where does curing disease end and designing children begin?
  7. Mission 7Do people need God to be good, or can religion get in the way of being good?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA