← A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · A2 6 Islam in a Contemporary Context – Origins and beliefs of Sunni and Shi'a Islam
Mini-Lesson

Islam in a Contemporary Context: Origins and beliefs of Sunni and Shi'a Islam

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1The Prophet died in 632. Who should lead next, and why does the answer still divide Muslims?
  2. Mission 2For 1,300 years there was a caliph, then in 1924 there wasn't. What did a caliph actually do?
  3. Mission 3Most Shi'a Muslims say a guide chosen by God has been hidden for over 1,000 years. Who leads them now?
  4. Mission 4A battle lost in 680 is mourned by millions every year. Why do Shi'a Muslims keep remembering it?
Mission 1

Mission 1: The Prophet died in 632. Who should lead next, and why does the answer still divide Muslims?

Make a guess: The Prophet died in 632. Who should lead next, and why does the answer still divide Muslims?

Mission 1

The question in 632

The question in 632632 CEthe Prophet Muhammad dies;revelation has endedWho should lead?What kind ofauthority?Muslims answered differentlySunni IslamShi'a Islam
  • 632 CE: the Prophet Muhammad dies in Madinah. Muslims believe he is the last prophet: revelation has ended (33:40).
  • But the community still needs leadership: to lead prayer, keep unity, judge, defend.
  • Two questions are tangled together:
  • Who should lead?
  • What kind of authority does the leader have: political only, or religious guidance too?
  • Muslims answered differently. The answers became Sunni and Shi'a Islam.
  • "Muhammad is no more than a messenger: many Were the messenger that passed away before him." (Qur'an 3:144, Yusuf Ali) Abu Bakr recited this verse on the day of the Prophet's death.
  • CCEA spelling: Medina, Mecca.
Mission 1

The Sunni account: Abu Bakr

The Saqifah: the Sunni account1At the Saqifah of Banu Sa'idaAnsarThe Ansar (Madinan helpers) meet to choosea leader.2They are joinedAbu BakrUmarAbu UbaydahUmar pledges bay'ah to Abu Bakr; the othersfollow.3Next day, in the mosquethe wider communityThe community pledges bay'ah.
  • While the Prophet's family prepared his burial, the Ansar (Madinan helpers) met at the Saqifah (meeting hall) of Banu Sa'ida to choose a leader.
  • Abu Bakr, Umar and Abu Ubaydah joined them. Umar pledged loyalty (bay'ah) to Abu Bakr; the others followed; the wider community pledged next day in the mosque.
  • Why Abu Bakr? The Prophet's companion in the cave during the Hijrah, "the second of two" (9:40); an early believer; father of Aishah; and asked by the Prophet to lead the prayers in his last illness (Bukhari; paraphrase).
  • Title: Khalifat Rasul Allah, successor (caliph) of the Messenger of God: a political leader, not a prophet.
  • Sunni view: the Prophet named no successor; the community chose by consensus.
Mission 1

The Shi'a account: Ali

The Prophet's familythe ProphetMuhammadAli ibn Abi TalibcousinsdaughterFatimahmarriedHasanHusainAbu BakrAishahfather of Aishah
  • Ali ibn Abi Talib: the Prophet's cousin, raised in his house, among the first to believe, married to his daughter Fatimah; father of Hasan and Husain.
  • Ghadir Khumm, March 632, on the way back from the Farewell Pilgrimage: the Prophet took Ali's hand and said, "For whomever I am his mawla (master), Ali is his mawla" (paraphrase; reported in Shi'a and Sunni collections, e.g. Tirmidhi).
  • Shi'a: this was designation (nass): God's choice of Ali as leader, announced by the Prophet.
  • Hadiths of the family: the Two Weighty Things, the Qur'an and the Prophet's household (Muslim; paraphrase); "You are to me as Aaron was to Moses, except there is no prophet after me" (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
  • So for Shi'a Muslims, Ali was the rightful leader and first Imam; the Saqifah set aside God's choice.
  • Ali gave allegiance to Abu Bakr later (after Fatimah's death, in Sunni reports) and kept the community's unity.
Mission 1Read the source

The Prophet's family

> "And Allah only wishes to remove all abomination from you, ye members of the Family, and to make you pure and spotless." (Qur'an 33:33, Yusuf Ali)

> "No reward do I ask of you for this except the love of those near of kin." (Qur'an 42:23, Yusuf Ali)

  • Ahl al-bayt: "people of the house", the Prophet's family.
  • Shi'a: 33:33 refers to the "people of the cloak": the Prophet, Ali, Fatimah, Hasan and Husain (a hadith in Muslim tells how he covered them with his cloak). It points to their purity and their right to guide.
  • Sunnis: the verse sits among verses addressed to the Prophet's wives, who are included; Sunnis also love and honour the family.

Q1 What does 33:33 say God wishes for the "Family"?

Show answer

To remove impurity and make them pure.

Q2 Why do the two readings of "the Family" lead to different views of leadership?

Show answer

If the verse marks out Ali's line as purified, it supports their right to guide.

Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes the Shi'a view of the succession in 632?
Mission 1

The four Rightly Guided Caliphs

The four Rightly Guided Caliphs, 632–661 CESunni: the Rashidun ("rightly guided")632Abu Bakr 632–634634Umar 634–644644Uthman 644–656656Ali 656–661661Ali's rule: the first fitna656 Battle of the Camel · 657 Siffin · 661Ali killed in Kufa; Hasan makes peace withMu'awiyaShi'a: Ali is the first Imam
  • Rashidun ("rightly guided"): the Sunni name for the first four caliphs.
  • Abu Bakr (632–634): the Ridda wars bring rebel tribes back; the first gathering of the Qur'an begins.
  • Umar (634–644): named by Abu Bakr; great expansion; the diwan (register of pensions); the Hijri calendar; title Amir al-Mu'minin (Commander of the Believers). Before dying he named a council (shura) of six.
  • Uthman (644–656): chosen by the shura; one standard copy of the Qur'an sent to the cities; accused of favouring his Umayyad relatives; killed by rebels in Madinah.
  • Ali (656–661): chosen in Madinah after Uthman's murder; his rule is torn by civil war.
  • Sunni view: a golden age, the model of just rule by shura and the Sunnah.
  • Your spec: "the Caliphate and the Four Rightly Guided Caliphs".
Quick check
?How did each of the first three Rightly Guided Caliphs come to power?
Mission 1

Ali's caliphate and the first fitna

The four Rightly Guided Caliphs, 632–661 CESunni: the Rashidun ("rightly guided")632Abu Bakr 632–634634Umar 634–644644Uthman 644–656656Ali 656–661661Ali's rule: the first fitna656 Battle of the Camel · 657 Siffin · 661Ali killed in Kufa; Hasan makes peace withMu'awiyaShi'a: Ali is the first Imam
  • Fitna: trial, civil strife. 656–661 is the first fitna.
  • Battle of the Camel (656): Ali against Aishah, Talha and Zubayr, who demanded justice for Uthman.
  • Siffin (657): Ali against Mu'awiya, Uthman's Umayyad kinsman and governor of Syria. Ali accepts arbitration.
  • A group rejects the arbitration ("judgement belongs to God alone") and leaves: the Kharijites.
  • 661: a Kharijite kills Ali at prayer in Kufa. His son Hasan makes peace with Mu'awiya, who becomes caliph.
  • Sunnis: Ali is the fourth Rightly Guided Caliph. Shi'a: Ali is the first Imam; his short rule was the only time the rightful Imam also ruled (with Hasan's months).
  • Political and religious disagreement are now joined: who rules, and who guides.
Mission 1Evaluate

Designation or consensus?

Designation or consensus?The Shi'a account of the succession is bettersupported than the Sunni account.ForGhadir Khumm is reported in Sunnisources too; the Qur'an honours prophets'families.The hasty Saqifah meeting, without theProphet's family present, looks less like afull consensus.AgainstThe Prophet appointed Abu Bakr to leadprayer; most Companions accepted him;Ali himself pledged allegiance."Mawla" has several meanings; nothing inthe Qur'an names Ali.Judge it byWhich sources count (Sunni or Shi'a hadith)? ·Does early acceptance prove legitimacy? · Isleadership political, spiritual, or both?
  • Claim: The Shi'a account of the succession is better supported than the Sunni account.
  • For: Ghadir Khumm is reported in Sunni sources too; the Qur'an honours prophets' families.
  • For: the hasty Saqifah meeting, without the Prophet's family present, looks less like a full consensus.
  • Against: the Prophet appointed Abu Bakr to lead prayer; most Companions accepted him; Ali himself pledged allegiance.
  • Against: "mawla" has several meanings; nothing in the Qur'an names Ali.
  • Criteria: Which sources count (Sunni or Shi'a hadith)? Does early acceptance prove legitimacy? Is leadership political, spiritual, or both?
Mission check

?Two Muslim students argue about a hadith collection. Sara says: "We follow the Sunnah as passed on by all the Companions; the community's agreement keeps it safe." Zahra says: "We follow the Sunnah as explained by the Prophet's family, through Imams protected from error." Which statement is accurate?
Mission 2

Mission 2: For 1,300 years there was a caliph, then in 1924 there wasn't. What did a caliph actually do?

Make a guess: For 1,300 years there was a caliph, then in 1924 there wasn't. What did a caliph actually do?

Mission 2

From caliphate to kingship

From caliphate to kingshipabout thirty yearscaliphate(Rashidun)mulk(kingship)632661dynastiesIbn Khaldun (1332–1406), Muqaddimah: thecaliphate changed gradually into mulk,keeping religious forms for a time.
  • Khalifah (caliph): "successor" or "deputy" of the Messenger, leading the ummah.
  • A well-known hadith: the caliphate would last thirty years, then kingship would follow (Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud; paraphrase).
  • Thirty years after 632 brings us to about 661: the end of Ali's rule and Hasan's peace with Mu'awiya.
  • Ibn Khaldun (1332–1406), Muqaddimah (1377): the caliphate changed gradually into mulk (royal power), keeping religious forms for a time.
  • From 661 the title "caliph" continued, but it was passed down in dynasties.
  • The change joins political and religious disagreement: was a hereditary ruler a true caliph?
Mission 2

The Umayyads (661–750)

Caliphates, 661–1924 CE70090011001300150017001900CEUmayyads 661–750DamascusAbbasids 750–1258Baghdad945 Buyids1055 Seljuks1258 Mongolssack Baghdad3 March 1924: the Ottoman caliphate isabolished
  • Mu'awiya (r. 661–680): capital Damascus; the first caliph to name his own son, Yazid, as heir: the start of hereditary (dynastic) rule.
  • 680: Husain refuses allegiance to Yazid and is killed at Karbala (see Mission 4).
  • Abd al-Malik (r. 685–705): builds the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem (c. 691–2); makes Arabic the language of government; issues coins with Qur'anic words, no images.
  • Expansion: Spain (711), Sindh (711–712), Central Asia; halted in France (Tours/Poitiers, 732).
  • Criticised for worldly kingship and for treating non-Arab converts (mawali) as second class.
  • Umar II (r. 717–720) is remembered by Sunnis for piety and justice, an exception.
  • Overthrown in 750; one Umayyad prince escapes to Spain.
Quick check
?What was new about the way Yazid became caliph in 680?
Mission 2

The Abbasids (750–1258)

Caliphates, 661–1924 CE70090011001300150017001900CEUmayyads 661–750DamascusAbbasids 750–1258Baghdad945 Buyids1055 Seljuks1258 Mongolssack Baghdad3 March 1924: the Ottoman caliphate isabolished
  • A revolt from Khurasan (Persia) under black banners, calling for a ruler "acceptable from the family of Muhammad". Many Shi'a hoped for a descendant of Ali.
  • But power went to descendants of the Prophet's uncle al-Abbas: the Abbasids. Shi'a hopes were disappointed.
  • Baghdad founded 762 as a new capital. Harun al-Rashid (r. 786–809); al-Ma'mun (r. 813–833) supports translation and science (the House of Wisdom).
  • 833: al-Ma'mun's mihna (test) tries to force scholars to say the Qur'an is created. It fails (abandoned c. 848).
  • Result: religious authority rests with the ulama (scholars) and the law schools, not the caliph.
  • From 945 the caliph is a figurehead under the Buyids (Shi'a), then the Seljuk sultans (1055).
  • 1258: the Mongols sack Baghdad and kill the caliph.
Mission 2

What was a caliph for?

The caliph's duties (al-Mawardi)protect the faithenforce the shari'ah; judgejustlydefend the borderscollect zakah and taxesappoint honestofficialsal-Mawardi (974–1058): duties of the caliph
  • Al-Mawardi (974–1058), al-Ahkam al-Sultaniyya (The Ordinances of Government): the classic Sunni theory. He calls the caliph "imam".
  • Duties: protect the faith; enforce the shari'ah and judge justly; defend the borders; collect zakah and taxes; appoint honest officials.
  • Qualifications: just character, knowledge of the law, sound body and mind, courage; descent from Quraysh (the Prophet's tribe).
  • How chosen: by those with authority to "loose and bind" (leading figures), or named by the previous caliph. Both follow the Rashidun (Saqifah; Umar).
  • Limits: the caliph is not a prophet; he cannot change revelation or define doctrine.
  • Sunni authority is thus split: the caliph rules; the ulama interpret.
Quick check
?Which statement fits al-Mawardi's Sunni theory of the caliph?
Mission 2

1924 and after

Caliphates, 661–1924 CE70090011001300150017001900CEUmayyads 661–750DamascusAbbasids 750–1258Baghdad945 Buyids1055 Seljuks1258 Mongolssack Baghdad3 March 1924: the Ottoman caliphate isabolished
  • 3 March 1924: the Turkish Grand National Assembly abolishes the Ottoman caliphate.
  • In India the Khilafat Movement (1919–1924) had campaigned to save it.
  • Ali Abd al-Raziq (1888–1966), Islam and the Foundations of Governance (1925): the Qur'an and Sunnah set no fixed form of state; the caliphate is a human institution. Al-Azhar condemned the book.
  • Today most Muslims live in nation states; the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (1969) links governments.
  • A few movements campaign for a new caliphate. When the group known as ISIS declared one in 2014, many leading Muslim scholars wrote publicly to reject it.
  • For most Muslims the ummah's unity now rests on shared faith, worship and law, not a single ruler.
Mission 2Diversity

Caliph and Imam

Caliph and ImamSunni caliphShi'a Imam(Twelver)Chosen bythecommunity'sleaders, ornominationGod, throughdesignation(nass)LineageQurayshAli andFatimah's lineAuthorityrule and lawenforcementrule andreligiousguidanceFree fromerror?noyes ('ismah)After theline endscaliphateabolished 1924;ulama interpretImam inoccultation;jurists act forhim
Sunni caliphShi'a Imam (Twelver)
Chosen bythe community's leaders, or nominationGod, through designation (nass)
LineageQurayshAli and Fatimah's line
Authorityrule and law enforcementrule and religious guidance
Free from error?noyes ('ismah)
After the line endscaliphate abolished 1924; ulama interpretImam in occultation; jurists act for him (see Mission 3)
  • The same word imam has three uses: prayer leader; Sunni title for the caliph; Shi'a infallible Imam.
Mission 2Evaluate

Was the caliphate after 661 a true caliphate?

Was the caliphate after 661 a true caliphate?After the Rightly Guided Caliphs, thecaliphate was kingship in religious dress.ForHereditary succession (Yazid); the "thirtyyears" hadith; Ibn Khaldun's account ofmulk.Shi'a Muslims: rulers who killed Husaincould not be God's representatives.AgainstLater caliphs led prayers, defendedborders, upheld the shari'ah courts andspread learning.Sunni jurists accepted imperfect rulers toavoid fitna: order under the law matteredmore than an ideal ruler.Judge it byIs a caliphate defined by how the ruler ischosen, or by what he does? · Can politicaland religious authority be separated?
  • Claim: After the Rightly Guided Caliphs, the caliphate was kingship in religious dress.
  • For: hereditary succession (Yazid); the "thirty years" hadith; Ibn Khaldun's account of mulk.
  • For: Shi'a Muslims: rulers who killed Husain could not be God's representatives.
  • Against: later caliphs led prayers, defended borders, upheld the shari'ah courts and spread learning.
  • Against: Sunni jurists accepted imperfect rulers to avoid fitna (civil strife): order under the law mattered more than an ideal ruler.
  • Criteria: Is a caliphate defined by how the ruler is chosen, or by what he does? Can political and religious authority be separated?
Mission check

?A modern Sunni scholar says: "Muslims do not need a caliph to keep the shari'ah, because the scholars and the schools of law have long carried it." Which history best supports her claim?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Most Shi'a Muslims say a guide chosen by God has been hidden for over 1,000 years. Who leads them now?

Make a guess: Most Shi'a Muslims say a guide chosen by God has been hidden for over 1,000 years. Who leads them now?

Mission 3

The party of Ali

Shared core, distinctive beliefShi'a: ImamahSharedone Godthe Qur'anthe Prophet,final messengersalah · fasting · Hajjthe Day of Judgement(the Imamate)
  • Shi'a comes from Shi'at Ali: "the party (followers) of Ali".
  • A minority of Muslims worldwide; the majority in Iran, Iraq, Azerbaijan and Bahrain; large communities in Lebanon, Pakistan, India and Britain.
  • Shared with Sunnis: one God, the Qur'an, the Prophet as the final messenger, salah, fasting, Hajj, the Day of Judgement.
  • The distinctive belief: Imamah (the Imamate): after the Prophet, God appointed Imams from his family to guide the community (see Mission 1).
  • Origins: Ali's designation at Ghadir Khumm (as Shi'a understand it); the martyrdom of Husain at Karbala in 680 (see Mission 4).
Mission 3

Who is an Imam?

Who is an Imam?Shi'a belief: the Imam is…designated(nass)named by theProphet or the Imambefore himinfallible('ismah)protected from sinand errorknowledge('ilm)outer and innermeaning of theQur'anproof of God(hujjah)the earth is neverwithout onenot a prophet: he explains and guardsrevelation
  • Designated (nass): each Imam is named by the Prophet or the Imam before him, by God's command.
  • Ma'sum (infallible): protected by God from sin and error ('ismah).
  • Knowledge ('ilm): the Imam knows the outer and inner meaning of the Qur'an and the Prophet's teaching.
  • Hujjah (proof of God): the earth is never without one (al-Kulayni, al-Kafi; paraphrase).
  • So the Imams' words and actions are an authoritative source beside the Qur'an and the Prophet's Sunnah. Their reported sayings fill Shi'a hadith collections such as al-Kafi (10th century).
  • The Imam is not a prophet: revelation ended with Muhammad. He explains and guards it.
Mission 3Read the source

Verses Shi'a scholars cite

> "He said: 'I will make thee an Imam to the Nations.' He pleaded: 'And also (Imams) from my offspring!' He answered: 'But My Promise is not within the reach of evil-doers.'" (Qur'an 2:124, Yusuf Ali)

> "Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you." (Qur'an 4:59, Yusuf Ali)

  • 2:124: God makes Abraham an Imam after testing him. Shi'a reading: Imamate is God's appointment, and no wrongdoer can hold it; so the Imam must be sinless.
  • 4:59: Shi'a reading: "those charged with authority" are the infallible Imams, since God would not command obedience to someone who might lead into error. Sunni reading: rulers and scholars, obeyed within the limits of God's law.
  • With 33:33 (which speaks of God purifying the Prophet's Family; Shi'a apply it to the Prophet, Ali, Fatimah, Hasan and Husain), these verses ground belief in the Imams.

Q1 In 2:124, who cannot receive God's promise of leadership?

Show answer

Evil-doers, wrongdoers.

Q2 Why do Sunnis and Shi'a read 4:59 differently?

Show answer

They disagree on who holds authority: the Imams, or rulers and scholars.

Mission 3

The Twelve Imams

The Twelve Imams1Alid. 661, Najaf2Hasand. 670, Madinah3Husaind. 680, Karbala4Ali Zayn al-Abidin5Muhammad al-Baqir6Ja'far al-Sadiqd. 7657Musa al-Kazim8Ali al-Ridad. 818, Mashhad9Muhammad al-Jawad10Ali al-Hadi11Hasan al-Askarid. 874, Samarra12Muhammad al-Mahdiin occultationTwelvers: the twelfth Imam is hidden by GodArabiaIranMadinahSamarraKarbalaNajafMashhad
  • 1 Ali (d. 661, Najaf) · 2 Hasan (d. 670, Madinah) · 3 Husain (d. 680, Karbala)
  • 4 Ali Zayn al-Abidin · 5 Muhammad al-Baqir · 6 Ja'far al-Sadiq (d. 765): great teacher of law; Shi'a law is called Ja'fari
  • 7 Musa al-Kazim · 8 Ali al-Rida (d. 818; shrine in Mashhad, Iran) · 9 Muhammad al-Jawad
  • 10 Ali al-Hadi · 11 Hasan al-Askari (d. 874, Samarra) · 12 Muhammad al-Mahdi: believed by Twelvers to be in occultation
  • Shi'a accounts hold that most Imams were killed or poisoned by rulers: a line of martyrs for justice.
  • Their tombs are major places of ziyarah (visiting pilgrimage).
Quick check
?Which belief about the Imams do Twelver Shi'a Muslims hold?
Mission 3

Occultation and the Mahdi

Occultation and the Mahdi (Twelver belief)Twelvers believe…874941todayLesser occultation874–941four deputies inturnGreater occultation from941no named deputy; he isalive, hidden by GodExpectedreturn as the Mahdi, to fill the earthwith justice
  • 874: Twelvers believe the twelfth Imam, Muhammad al-Mahdi, a child, withdrew from view: ghaybah (occultation).
  • Lesser occultation (874–941): he is said to have guided the community through four deputies in turn.
  • Greater occultation (from 941): no named deputy. Twelvers believe he is alive, hidden by God.
  • They expect him to return as the Mahdi ("rightly guided one") to fill the earth with justice as it is now filled with injustice (hadith; paraphrase), with Jesus (Isa) at his side.
  • Intizar (waiting) is active: living justly, praying for his return; his birthday (15 Sha'ban) is celebrated.
  • Sunnis also expect a Mahdi from the Prophet's family before the end, but most do not identify him with the hidden twelfth Imam.
  • Your spec: "the Last Imam, the Mahdi".
Mission 3Diversity

Twelvers, Seveners and others

Twelvers, Isma'ilis and Zaydis1 Ali2 Hasan3 Husain4 Ali Zayn al-Abidinline of ImamsZaydZaydismainly Yemen5 Muhammadal-Baqir6 Ja'far al-Sadiq (d.765)Isma'il and his line7 Musa al-Kazim…Isma'ilisNizaris, Bohras12 Muhammadal-MahdiTwelvers
  • Shi'a groups split over which son carried the Imamate.
  • Twelvers (Ithna 'Ashariyyah): the great majority of Shi'a; twelve Imams; the last in occultation.
  • Isma'ilis ("Seveners"): after Ja'far al-Sadiq (d. 765), they followed his son Isma'il and his line, not Musa al-Kazim. Strictly, "Seveners" were those who held the line ended with the seventh Imam. The Fatimid caliphs were Isma'ili (see Mission 2).
  • Isma'ilis today: Nizaris, led by a living, present Imam, the Aga Khan; Bohras, whose Imam is hidden and who are led by a Da'i.
  • Zaydis ("Fivers"): follow Zayd, son of the fourth Imam; any learned descendant of Hasan or Husain who rises against injustice may be Imam; mainly in Yemen.
  • Your spec: "'Seveners' and 'Twelvers'".
Mission 3

Authority while the Imam is hidden

Authority while the Imam is hiddenGodthe Prophetthe Imams(in the occultation)marja' al-taqlida living jurist, on the hiddenImam's behalfthe believerfollows him (taqlid)wilayat al-faqih (one view)Khomeini: a just jurist should also holdpolitical rule (basis of the Islamic Republic ofIran, 1979). Many jurists, including al-Sistani,give jurists a narrower role.
  • In the greater occultation, Twelvers hold that qualified jurists (mujtahids) represent the Imam's guidance in law.
  • Each believer follows (taqlid) a living marja' al-taqlid ("source of imitation"), e.g. Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani (b. 1930) in Najaf; the marja' receives part of the khums.
  • Wilayat al-faqih (guardianship of the jurist): Ayatollah Khomeini (1902–1989), lectures of 1970: a just jurist should also hold political rule. This became the basis of the Islamic Republic of Iran (1979).
  • Many Shi'a jurists, including al-Sistani, give jurists a narrower role in politics.
  • So authority flows: God → Prophet → Imams → (in occultation) jurists on the Imam's behalf, never replacing him.
Quick check
?A Twelver Shi'a student in Birmingham asks whose rulings she should follow on a new question of medical ethics. What would most Twelver scholars tell her?
Mission 3

Distinctive practices

Shrines of the ImamsIraqIranSamarraKadhimiyaKarbalaNajafMashhadZiyarah to the Imams' shrines. Millions walkto Karbala for Arba'een.
  • Salat and wudu: prayers often combined into three times; forehead on a turbah; feet wiped, not washed; adhan adds "Come to the best of deeds".
  • Khums: a fifth of surplus income each year, half for the Imam's share (given through a marja'), half for needy descendants of the Prophet.
  • Pilgrimage: Hajj, and ziyarah to the Imams' shrines: Najaf, Karbala, Kadhimiya, Samarra, Mashhad. Millions walk to Karbala for Arba'een (see Mission 4).
  • Muta (temporary marriage): a marriage contract for a fixed period with a dowry; Twelvers hold it lawful, citing 4:24; Sunnis hold the Prophet forbade it. Many Shi'a discourage it in practice.
  • Taqiyya (precautionary concealment): hiding one's faith when life is in danger, as Shi'a did under hostile rulers. Cited: 16:106, 3:28. Sunnis also allow concealment under compulsion. Not a general licence to deceive.
Mission 3Evaluate

More alike or more different?

More alike or more different?The differences between Sunni and Shi'aIslam matter more than what they share.ForImamah is a root of faith for Shi'a; itchanges who holds religious authority,which hadith count, and how law is made.Distinct practices (khums, muta, ziyarah,Muharram) mark separate identities;politics has deepened the division.AgainstThe shahadah, Qur'an, salah, sawm, zakahand Hajj are shared; the Amman Messagerecognises both.Sunnis also love the ahl al-bayt andexpect a Mahdi; Sufi orders honour Ali.Judge it byAre differences of authority deeper thandifferences of practice? · Should we judge bydoctrine, daily life, or history?
  • Claim: The differences between Sunni and Shi'a Islam matter more than what they share.
  • Background: in Shi'a teaching Imamah is a root of faith (one of the five Usul al-Din). The Amman Message (2004–2005) is a statement in which hundreds of Sunni and Shi'a scholars recognised each other's schools as Muslim.
  • For: Imamah is a root of faith for Shi'a; it changes who holds religious authority, which hadith count, and how law is made.
  • For: distinct practices (khums, muta, ziyarah, Muharram) mark separate identities; politics has deepened the division.
  • Against: the shahadah, Qur'an, salah, sawm, zakah and Hajj are shared; the Amman Message recognises both.
  • Against: Sunnis also love the ahl al-bayt and expect a Mahdi; Sufi orders honour Ali.
  • Criteria: Are differences of authority deeper than differences of practice? Should we judge by doctrine, daily life, or history?
  • Your spec: "the contemporary significance of the division".
Mission check

?A Shi'a scholar teaches that a ruling of the sixth Imam, Ja'far al-Sadiq, settles a legal question, even though the Prophet's own words on it were not recorded. Why does he treat the Imam's word as authoritative?
Mission 4

Mission 4: A battle lost in 680 is mourned by millions every year. Why do Shi'a Muslims keep remembering it?

Make a guess: A battle lost in 680 is mourned by millions every year. Why do Shi'a Muslims keep remembering it?

Mission 4

680: a refusal

From Makkah towards Kufa, 680MakkahKarbalaKufaDamascusIraqArabiaEuphratesInvited by letters from Kufa, the party sets outfrom Makkah. Route approximate.
  • Husain (Hussein): son of Ali and Fatimah, grandson of the Prophet; for Shi'a Muslims the third Imam.
  • 680: Mu'awiya dies; his son Yazid demands an oath of allegiance (bay'ah). Husain refuses: Yazid's rule is unjust and hereditary (see Mission 2).
  • Letters from Kufa in Iraq invite Husain to lead them. He sets out from Makkah with his family and a small band of companions.
  • Husain's stated aim (Shi'a sources, paraphrase): not pride or power, but to reform the community of his grandfather, to enjoin good and forbid evil.
  • Yazid's governor in Kufa crushes support; the Kufans do not come.
Mission 4

Ten days at Karbala

Ten days at Karbala2 Muharram 61 AHForced to camp at Karbala, by theEuphrates.7 MuharramCut off from the river: days of thirst.10 Muharram, Ashura10 October 680: Husain, hiscompanions and family are killed.CaptivesThe women and children, led byZaynab, are taken to Kufa andDamascus.
  • 2 Muharram 61 AH: Husain's party is forced to camp at Karbala, by the Euphrates.
  • 7 Muharram: the army cuts them off from the river. Days of thirst follow.
  • 10 Muharram, Ashura (10 October 680): Husain's companions and family fall one by one.
  • Abbas, his half-brother, is killed trying to bring water; his infant son Ali al-Asghar is struck by an arrow.
  • Husain is killed; his head is taken to Kufa and Damascus.
  • The women and children, led by his sister Zaynab, are taken captive. Zaynab speaks out boldly in Yazid's court. His son Ali Zayn al-Abidin, too ill to fight, survives as the fourth Imam.
Quick check
?Why did Husain refuse to give allegiance to Yazid?
Mission 4

Muharram rituals

Muharram ritualsmajlisgatheringrawdaevents retold day bydaymarthiya, nawhaelegies, lamentsmatambeating the chest ingriefalambanners in processionsabilfree water
  • The first ten days of Muharram build up to Ashura. Black clothes; no weddings or celebrations.
  • Majlis (pl. majalis): gatherings in a husayniyyah or imambargah where a speaker recounts the events, day by day (rawda).
  • Marthiya and nawha: elegies and laments, sung by the gathering.
  • Matam: rhythmic beating of the chest in grief.
  • Processions: banners (alam), a replica of Husain's tomb (South Asia), a riderless horse for Husain's horse; in Iran, ta'ziyeh passion plays.
  • Sabil: free water and drinks given to passers-by, remembering the thirst at Karbala.
  • Your spec: "the rituals that take place during the first ten days of Muharram culminating on Ashura".
Mission 4

Pilgrimage to Karbala

Arba'een: walking to KarbalaKarbalaNajafabout 80 kmEuphrates= free food, water and rest on the wayArba'een: 40 days after Ashura (20 Safar).Millions walk to Karbala, many from Najaf.
  • Husain's shrine, and Abbas's beside it, stand in Karbala, Iraq: among the holiest places for Shi'a Muslims.
  • Pilgrims visit (ziyarah) on Ashura and through the year; they recite Ziyarat Ashura, a greeting and lament for Husain.
  • Arba'een: 40 days after Ashura (20 Safar), millions walk to Karbala, many from Najaf, about 80 km; local people give free food, water and rest on the way.
  • Under Saddam Hussein these gatherings were restricted; after 2003 they grew hugely.
  • Pilgrimage brings Husain's story into the body: thirst, walking, sacrifice.
Quick check
?At a majlis in Birmingham on the 7th night of Muharram, a speaker describes the cutting-off of water at Karbala and the gathering weeps. What is the main purpose of this ritual?
Mission 4

Ashura and Shi'a identity

  • Identity: Ashura is where Shi'a Muslims most visibly say who they are: lovers of the ahl al-bayt, people who refuse injustice.
  • Community: local associations (anjuman) organise processions; families sponsor majalis and food as a vow (nazr); children learn the nawhas.
  • In Britain: processions in London and other cities; open majalis and blood drives invite neighbours in.
  • Sunni Muslims also mark 10 Muharram: the Prophet fasted that day, remembering God's saving of Moses (Bukhari; paraphrase). Many Sunnis, especially in South Asia, also honour Husain.
Mission check

?A Shi'a youth group in a British city leads Ashura with a majlis, a procession with an alam, and a blood donation stall. Which statement best explains this combination?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Sunnis: the Prophet named no successor; the community chose Abu Bakr by consensus; the four Rightly Guided Caliphs are a model of just rule.
  • Shi'a: the Prophet designated Ali at Ghadir Khumm; leadership belongs to the purified family, the ahl al-bayt, through the Imams.
  • The first fitna (656–661) joined political and religious disagreement and hardened the division.

Mission 2

  • From 661 the caliphate became dynastic: Umayyads (Damascus, 661–750), Abbasids (Baghdad, 750–1258), later rival and Ottoman caliphs until 1924.
  • Sunni theory (al-Mawardi): the caliph protects the faith and enforces the shari'ah; the ulama interpret it. The Shi'a Imam is designated and infallible.
  • Whether the dynastic caliphate was a true caliphate or kingship remains debated.

Mission 3

  • Shi'a Muslims believe God appointed twelve (or, for Isma'ilis, a different line of) Imams from the Prophet's family: designated, infallible, sources of guidance.
  • Twelvers believe the twelfth Imam has been in occultation since 874/941 and will return as the Mahdi; jurists (marja') act for him meanwhile.
  • Distinctive practices: combined prayers, turbah and wudu, khums, ziyarah, muta, taqiyya.

Mission 4

  • 10 Muharram 61 AH (680 CE): Husain, refusing to approve Yazid's unjust rule, was killed at Karbala with his family and companions.
  • Muharram rites (majlis, rawda, nawha, matam, processions, ziyarah, Arba'een) mourn Husain and renew loyalty to justice and to the ahl al-bayt.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islam in a Contemporary Context: Origins and beliefs of Sunni and Shi'a Islam for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1The Prophet died in 632. Who should lead next, and why does the answer still divide Muslims?
  2. Mission 2For 1,300 years there was a caliph, then in 1924 there wasn't. What did a caliph actually do?
  3. Mission 3Most Shi'a Muslims say a guide chosen by God has been hidden for over 1,000 years. Who leads them now?
  4. Mission 4A battle lost in 680 is mourned by millions every year. Why do Shi'a Muslims keep remembering it?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA