🚀 Islam in a Contemporary Context: Contemporary issues; synoptic assessment theme: Conflict, Freedom of Belief and Orthodoxy
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · A2 6 Islam in a Contemporary Context – Contemporary issues; A2 6 Islam in a Contemporary Context – Synoptic assessment theme: Conflict, Freedom of Belief and Orthodoxy
Mini-Lesson
Islam in a Contemporary Context: Contemporary issues; synoptic assessment theme: Conflict, Freedom of Belief and Orthodoxy
7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Equal before God but different in law: what does Islam teach about men, women and the family?
Mission 2One verse seems to put husbands in charge. How have Muslim women scholars read it differently?
Mission 3Muslim women have argued the veil is oppression, faith and protest. How can one cloth mean all three?
Mission 4If life belongs to God, can a Muslim ever end a pregnancy, use IVF or switch off a ventilator?
Mission 5In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 6The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Mission 7Who decides what counts as true Islam, and what happens to those who disagree?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Equal before God but different in law: what does Islam teach about men, women and the family?
Make a guess: Equal before God but different in law: what does Islam teach about men, women and the family?
Mission 1Read the source
Spiritual equality
> "O mankind! Be careful of your duty to your Lord Who created you from a single soul and from it created its mate" (Qur'an 4:1, Pickthall)
> "For Muslim men and women,- for believing men and women, for devout men and women, for true men and women … for them has Allah prepared forgiveness and great reward." (Qur'an 33:35, Yusuf Ali)
> "Whosoever doeth right, whether male or female, and is a believer, him verily we shall quicken with good life" (Qur'an 16:97, Pickthall)
Q1 What does 4:1 say about the origin of men and women?
Show answer
Both come from a single soul.
Q2 What does 33:35 suggest about reward from God?
Show answer
Men and women who share the same virtues receive the same forgiveness and reward.
Mission 1
Qur'an and Hadith on men and women
Same worth: both are God's servants and trustees (khalifa); in the Qur'an, Adam and his wife both disobey and both repent: "Our Lord! We have wronged ourselves." (Qur'an 7:23, Pickthall). Eve is not blamed alone.
Hadith: women are the "twin halves" of men (paraphrase; Sunan Abu Dawud, no. 236); the best of you are those best to their families (paraphrase; Jami' al-Tirmidhi, no. 3895); "your mother" is named three times before "your father" as most deserving of kindness (paraphrase; Sahih al-Bukhari, no. 5971).
Different roles (traditional view): men must maintain (nafaqa) wife and family; so in law, shares and duties differ. "they (women) have rights similar to those (of men) over them in kindness, and men are a degree above them" (Qur'an 2:228, Pickthall).
Contested texts: a hadith calls women "deficient in intellect and religion" (paraphrase; Sahih al-Bukhari, no. 304). Traditional scholars link it to rules on witness and exemption from prayer during menstruation; many modern Muslims read it as context-bound or question how it is used.
So most Muslims hold equal worth before God; they disagree on how far legal differences follow (feminist readings).
Mission 1
Women in early Islam
Khadijah (d. 619): a wealthy merchant who employed Muhammad, proposed marriage, and was the first person to accept Islam.
'A'isha (d. 678): one of the main sources of hadith (over two thousand reports), consulted on law and corrected leading Companions.
Umm Salama: tradition says her question why the Qur'an spoke of men led to the revelation of 33:35.
Nusayba bint Ka'b: fought to defend the Prophet at Uhud (625).
Al-Shifa' bint 'Abdullah: taught reading and writing; reported to have supervised the Madinah market under 'Umar.
Umm Waraqa: the Prophet let her lead the people of her household in prayer (Sunan Abu Dawud, no. 592; its scope is debated).
Quick check
?Which early Muslim woman is correctly matched with her role?
Mission 1
The family as foundation
Marriage is a sunnah: the Prophet's way, strongly encouraged.
"He ordained between you love and mercy." (Qur'an 30:21, Pickthall); spouses are "raiment" (clothing, protection) for each other (2:187).
The home is the first school of faith: children learn prayer, the Qur'an, halal food and good character there.
Duties: parents raise and educate children; children honour parents, especially in old age (17:23); the extended family supports its members.
Traditional roles: the husband provides; the wife is the heart of the home. A wife's own earnings and property remain hers (4:32).
Mission 1
Marriage and divorce in law (Surah 4)
Step 1 of 3
Nikah is a contract: offer and acceptance, witnesses (required by most Sunni schools), and the bride's consent (a hadith requires it: Sahih al-Bukhari, no. 5136). Most scholars today hold that a forced marriage is invalid; some classical schools let a father marry off a daughter who had never married.
Wali (guardian): most schools require the bride's guardian; the Hanafi school allows an adult woman to contract her own marriage.
Mahr: "give unto the women (whom ye marry) free gift of their marriage portions" (Qur'an 4:4, Pickthall). It belongs to the wife.
Polygyny: up to four wives, on condition of justice (4:3); yet "Ye will not be able to deal equally between (your) wives" (Qur'an 4:129, Pickthall). Many modern scholars and states treat monogamy as the norm; some states ban or restrict polygyny.
Divorce: permitted but discouraged. The husband's talaq with a waiting period ('idda, 2:228), revocable twice (2:229); the wife's khul' (she returns the mahr); or a judge's dissolution for harm. First, arbiters from both families should try to reconcile (4:35).
Twelver Shi'a also allow temporary marriage (mut'a); Sunnis forbid it.
Mission 1
Inheritance
Before Islam, many Arab women inherited nothing; the Qur'an forbids inheriting women "against their will" (Qur'an 4:19, Yusuf Ali) and gives them fixed shares.
"to the male the equivalent of the portion of two females" (Qur'an 4:11, Pickthall), for sons and daughters.
Reason given: the son must maintain a family and pay mahr; the daughter's share is hers alone.
Not always double: each parent of a deceased with children receives a sixth (4:11); maternal siblings share equally (4:12).
Debate: most scholars hold the shares fixed by revelation. Some modern Muslims argue that where women share the duty of maintenance, the reason for the difference no longer applies.
Up to one third of an estate may be left by will (wasiyya) to non-heirs.
Quick check
?According to mainstream Muslim teaching today, which feature is essential to a valid nikah?
Mission 1
Awra and modesty
'Awra: the parts of the body that must be covered in prayer and before people outside the close family.
Men: from navel to knee (majority view).
Women, before men who are not close relatives: the whole body except face and hands (majority of Hanafi, Maliki and Shafi'i jurists; Hanafis also allow the feet); many Hanbali jurists also include the face (hence the face-veil, niqab).
Both are told to "lower their gaze and be modest": the command to men comes first (Qur'an 24:30–31, Pickthall).
Mission 1
Women in worship
Women pray, fast, give zakah and perform Hajj as equal duties; women are excused prayer and fasting during menstruation (fasts made up later).
Mosques: "Do not prevent the female servants of Allah from the mosques of Allah" (paraphrase; Sahih al-Bukhari, no. 900). Friday prayer is obligatory for men, optional for women; other hadith praise prayer at home.
Rows: men in front, women behind or in a separate area. Some British mosques have had no women's space; campaigns have pushed for change.
Leading prayer: a woman may lead women (Shafi'i and Hanbali view; reported of 'A'isha and Umm Salama). Most scholars of every school forbid women leading mixed congregations; a few reformers dissent (see Mission 2).
Women serve as scholars, Qur'an teachers and preachers to women; female hadith scholars were common in the medieval period.
Mission 1
Religion, culture and change
Culture vs religion: forced marriage, "honour"-based violence, denying daughters their inheritance, and lavish dowry from the bride's family (South Asian jahez, unlike the Qur'anic mahr) come from local custom, and most scholars condemn them as against Islamic law.
Responses differ: some see this as a return to the rights Islam first gave; others fear secular norms will erode the family.
Mission 1Evaluate
Are women and men equal in Islam?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Islam teaches full equality between men and women.
For: equal creation and reward (4:1, 33:35, 16:97); the Qur'an gave women property, inheritance, mahr and consent in the 7th century; early women's leadership (Khadijah, 'A'isha).
For: many differences in practice come from culture, not revelation.
Against: legal texts give different shares and rights (4:11; men "a degree above", 2:228; talaq mostly in the husband's hand).
Against: "equal but different" may still mean unequal in power: critics within and outside Islam argue this.
Judgement criteria: Does equality mean identical rights, or equal worth with different roles? Are legal rules fixed or tied to 7th-century conditions? Which counts more: text, history or today's practice?
Quick check
?Which statement expresses the traditional Muslim view of men and women?
Mission check
?At a family meeting, an uncle says: "Islam says daughters get half because they are worth half." His niece, a law student, replies: "Our sources teach that men and women are equal before God; any difference in shares rests on duties, not worth." Which statement is accurate?
Most Muslims hold that men and women are equal in worth before God; they debate how far law, roles and culture should follow from that. A later mission: Muslim feminist readings and the veil (see Mission 2).
Mission 2
Mission 2: One verse seems to put husbands in charge. How have Muslim women scholars read it differently?
Make a guess: One verse seems to put husbands in charge. How have Muslim women scholars read it differently?
Mission 2
Equal before God
Muslims believe men and women come from one soul: "created you from a single person, created, of like nature, His mate" (Qur'an 4:1, Yusuf Ali).
Same duties of faith, same reward: "If any do deeds of righteousness,- be they male or female - and have faith, they will enter Heaven" (Qur'an 4:124, Yusuf Ali).
Qur'an 33:35 names believing men and women, side by side, ten times over, with one promise: forgiveness and great reward.
So most Muslims agree on spiritual equality. The debate is about roles in family and society.
Mission 2
Women in early Islam
Khadijah: a trader who employed Muhammad, proposed marriage, and was the first to accept his message.
Aisha: a leading teacher of the first generation; she narrated over two thousand hadith, and senior Companions brought her questions of law.
Umm Salamah: hadith collections report she asked why the Qur'an spoke of men and not women; 33:35 followed (al-Nasa'i, Ahmad; Tirmidhi reports the question from Umm 'Umara).
Nusaybah bint Ka'b defended the Prophet at Uhud (625).
Women prayed in the Prophet's mosque. Hadith: do not stop the women servants of God from the mosques of God (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Your spec: "women as participants in and leaders of worship".
Mission 2
Surah 4: family law
Surah 4 is called al-Nisa', "Women". Much of it is family law.
Marriage: a contract; the bride's consent; the mahr (dower) is hers (4:4). Up to four wives, but "if ye fear that ye shall not be able to deal justly (with them), then only one" (Qur'an 4:3, Yusuf Ali).
Kindness: "live with them on a footing of kindness and equity" (Qur'an 4:19, Yusuf Ali).
Inheritance: women inherit in their own right; a son's share is twice a daughter's (4:11). Classical reason: the man must support the family; her share is hers alone.
Conflict and divorce: arbiters from both families (4:35); a settlement if the husband is cruel (4:128); divorce rules in 2:228–232.
Mission 2Read the source
Qur'an 4:34
> "Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means." (Qur'an 4:34, Yusuf Ali)
The verse goes on: if a husband fears nushuz (Yusuf Ali: "disloyalty and ill-conduct") from his wife: admonish her; then separate beds; then a word Yusuf Ali renders "beat them (lightly)" (paraphrase).
Pickthall renders the opening "Men are in charge of women".
Key Arabic words: qawwamun (maintainers; in charge), faddala (has given more, or preferred), daraba (to strike; it has many other senses).
Q1 What two reasons does the verse give for men's role?
Show answer
God has given one more than the other; men spend of their means.
Q2 Why does the translation matter here?
Show answer
Each English version already chooses a reading of qawwamun and daraba.
Mission 2
Classical readings
Step 1 of 3
Most classical scholars read qawwamun as the husband's authority and duty to provide and protect, within the household.
They read the three steps as a ladder of last resort, and limited the third:
Not on the face, not to injure. Ibn Abbas is reported as saying: with a tooth-stick or the like (al-Tabari's commentary).
Aisha reported that the Prophet never struck a woman or a servant (Muslim).
A hadith: the best of you are those best to their wives (Tirmidhi; paraphrase).
Many jurists (e.g. al-Shafi'i) said that not striking at all is better.
So even traditional readings restricted the verse. The modern question is whether it gives permission at all.
Quick check
?Which statement about classical Muslim readings of 4:34 is accurate?
Mission 2
Amina Wadud
Amina Wadud (b. 1952), American Muslim scholar: Qur'an and Woman: Rereading the Sacred Text from a Woman's Perspective (1992); Inside the Gender Jihad (2006).
Method: read each verse in its first context, alongside the whole Qur'an, guided by its universal principles (justice, the oneness of God).
Qawwamun is not built-in superiority: it depends on the husband actually providing ("because they support them").
Nushuz is also used of husbands (4:128), so it means a breakdown of marital harmony, not a wife's disobedience alone.
The striking clause restricted a violent practice in 7th-century Arabia; the Qur'an's direction is towards ending it.
In 2006 she wrote that she now says "no" to applying the clause literally at all (paraphrase).
In 2005 she led a mixed congregation in Friday prayer in New York: most scholars objected; others supported her.
Mission check
?A student meets the word zawj (spouse, pair) in a verse about marriage. She lists every place the Qur'an uses it, notices it is used of both partners equally, and reads the verse in that light. Which approach is she using?
The words of the text are fixed for Muslims; how to read them is the debate. Next: the veil.
Mission 3
Mission 3: Muslim women have argued the veil is oppression, faith and protest. How can one cloth mean all three?
Make a guess: Muslim women have argued the veil is oppression, faith and protest. How can one cloth mean all three?
Mission 3
Words for the veil
Hijab: literally "screen" or "curtain". Today usually a headscarf covering hair and neck.
Khimar: head-covering (24:31). Jilbab: outer garment or cloak (33:59).
Niqab: face-veil, eyes visible. Burqa: full covering with a mesh over the eyes. Chador: Iranian full-length cloak.
Awra: the parts of the body to be covered in public.
Hanafi and Maliki scholars, the Ja'fari Shi'a school and many others: a woman covers all but face and hands. Many Hanbali and some Shafi'i scholars require the face to be covered too.
A small number of modern scholars argue the headscarf itself is not obligatory.
Mission 3Read the source
Modesty for men and women
> "Say to the believing men that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty: that will make for greater purity for them" (Qur'an 24:30, Yusuf Ali)
> "And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty; that they should not display their beauty and ornaments except what (must ordinarily) appear thereof; that they should draw their veils over their bosoms" (Qur'an 24:31, Yusuf Ali)
33:59 asks the Prophet's wives, daughters and the believing women to draw their outer garments around them, "that they should be known (as such) and not molested" (Qur'an 33:59, Yusuf Ali).
A hadith: modesty (haya') is a branch of faith (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Q1 Who is told to be modest first?
Show answer
Men: 24:30 comes before 24:31.
Q2 What phrase do scholars argue over?
Show answer
"Except what must ordinarily appear": face and hands, or less.
Quick check
?Which statement about the Qur'an's teaching on modest dress is accurate?
Mission 3
States and the veil
Step 1 of 3
Unveiling by law: Iran under Reza Shah banned the veil in public (1936). Turkey's secular republic discouraged it and later banned headscarves in universities and state offices (lifted in stages, 2010–2013).
Rights by secular law: Tunisia's Code of Personal Status (1956) banned polygamy and gave women judicial divorce.
Veiling by law: after the 1979 revolution, Iran made hijab compulsory (law of 1983). Protests followed the death of Mahsa Amini in the custody of the morality police (2022).
Bans in Europe: France banned conspicuous religious symbols in state schools (2004) and face-coverings in public (2010).
Britain: no ban. Research (e.g. Afshar, the later screen) finds many younger British Muslim women choose hijab for themselves.
Mission 3
Haleh Afshar
Haleh Afshar (1944–2022), Iranian-born British professor of politics and women's studies, University of York; Baroness Afshar from 2007.
Islam and Feminisms: An Iranian Case-Study (1998): women in the Islamic Republic used Islamic arguments to win back rights in education, work and family law.
Islamic feminism: women can claim equality from within their faith, not only from secular feminism.
Her research with young British Muslim women who cover: many chose it themselves, sometimes against family wishes, as faith and as identity (paraphrase).
She opposed compulsion both ways: forced veiling in Iran and forced unveiling by bans.
Quick check
?Which claim fits Haleh Afshar's view of Muslim women and the veil?
Mission 3Diversity
Why Muslim women cover, or do not
Obedience: a duty from God (24:31, 33:59), held by most scholars.
Identity: being visibly Muslim, especially as a minority.
Freedom: some say covering means being judged by mind, not body.
Protest: against Western consumer culture, or against a regime (Iran before 1979).
Not covering: some Muslim women hold that modesty is in conduct, not in a scarf; others face pressure or danger if they cover.
Culture or religion? Burqa, chador and niqab differ by region: culture shapes how Islam is lived.
Mission 3Evaluate
"The veil is a symbol of oppression."
Step 1 of 4
For: some Muslim reformers saw veiling and seclusion as barriers to education and public life. Where the law forces it (Iran), it is imposed by the state. Family pressure is real for some women.
Against: many women choose it freely (Afshar). Bans also take away choice.
Another view: the cloth has no single meaning: oppression or resistance depends on choice and context.
Judge it by: Who chose it? Who is speaking for the women? Is the meaning religious, cultural or political? Does a ban or a law help women?
Mission check
?In one country the law forces women to cover their hair in public. In another, the law fines women who cover their faces in public. Muslim women protest in both. Which idea, defended by Muslim feminists such as Afshar, links the two protests?
The same cloth can be duty, identity, freedom or a weapon of empire. Context and choice decide its meaning.
Mission 4
Mission 4: If life belongs to God, can a Muslim ever end a pregnancy, use IVF or switch off a ventilator?
Make a guess: If life belongs to God, can a Muslim ever end a pregnancy, use IVF or switch off a ventilator?
Mission 4
Life as God's gift and trust
Sanctity of life: for Muslims, life is sacred because God gives it and God alone decides its term.
"Nor can a soul die except by Allah's leave, the term being fixed as by writing" (Qur'an 3:145, Yusuf Ali).
Humans are khalifah (stewards, 2:30): life is held in trust (amanah), not owned.
Life is a test: God "created Death and Life, that He may try which of you is best in deed" (Qur'an 67:2, Yusuf Ali).
So suffering may have meaning, and patience (sabr) is a virtue (2:155–156).
CCEA spellings: Sharia, Mecca, Medina.
Mission 4Read the source
As if he slew the whole people
> "if any one slew a person - unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land - it would be as if he slew the whole people: and if any one saved a life, it would be as if he saved the life of the whole people." (Qur'an 5:32, Yusuf Ali)
> "take not life, which Allah hath made sacred, except by way of justice and law" (Qur'an 6:151, Yusuf Ali)
Q1 What value does 5:32 give to a single life?
Show answer
The value of all humanity.
Q2 What exception does 6:151 allow?
Show answer
Taking life "by way of justice and law": e.g. a court's lawful sentence.
So in Islam, sanctity of life is very strong but not stated without exception.
Mission 4
When does a person begin?
Step 1 of 3
The Qur'an describes stages in the womb: drop, clinging clot, lump of flesh, bones clothed with flesh, "then we developed out of it another creature" (23:12–14).
Hadith (Ibn Mas'ud): each stage lasts forty days; then an angel breathes in the soul (ruh) (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Most jurists: ensoulment at about 120 days (four months).
Others, from another hadith (Muslim), place a key change at about 40 days.
Before ensoulment the embryo is not yet a full person, but it is life with sanctity, to be protected.
After ensoulment, harming it is like harming a living person.
Quick check
?Why do many Muslim jurists treat abortion at 16 weeks differently from abortion at 20 weeks?
Mission 4
Abortion: what is agreed
"Kill not your children for fear of want: We shall provide sustenance for them as well as for you" (Qur'an 17:31, Yusuf Ali). Many apply this to abortion for economic reasons.
After ensoulment (c. 120 days): all schools forbid abortion.
Exception widely accepted by modern scholars: when the mother's life is in real danger: she is an established life with duties to others, and the greater harm is avoided.
Abortion is never just a personal choice: the life is God's, and the father and family have a stake.
Mission 4Diversity
Before 120 days
Hanafi: many permit with a serious reason (e.g. health of mother or child) before 120 days; some call it makruh.
Maliki: most forbid from conception.
Shafi'i: views differ; some permit before 40 or 80 days; al-Ghazali (1058–1111) forbade it from conception, the wrong growing graver at each stage.
Hanbali: many permit in the first 40 days.
Twelver Shi'a: generally forbidden from conception, except to save the mother's life; Iran's law (2005) allows abortion before four months for severe fetal abnormality.
Modern rulings: the Islamic Fiqh Council in Makkah (1990) allowed abortion before 120 days for grave, confirmed fetal abnormality.
Mission 4
The embryo in the laboratory
IVF often makes spare embryos. May they be used for research (e.g. stem cells)?
Many Sunni bodies (e.g. the Islamic Fiqh Council in Makkah, 2003) and many Shi'a jurists in Iran: yes, for surplus embryos, donated with consent, before implantation, for healing.
Reasons: the embryo outside the womb is not ensouled and cannot develop alone; research serves maslaha (public good) and saving life (5:32).
Against: creating embryos for research, cloning humans, and selling embryos are widely forbidden.
Some scholars reject all destructive embryo research: the embryo is potential human life from conception.
Mission 4
Assisted conception: Sunni and Shi'a
Children are a blessing; seeking a cure for infertility is encouraged. "He leaves barren whom He will" (42:50) is read as a test, not a ban on treatment.
Sunni consensus (e.g. al-Azhar, 1980): IVF is permitted for a married couple, using their own egg and sperm, during the marriage.
Forbidden for Sunnis: donor sperm, donor eggs, donor embryos and surrogacy: they mix lineage (nasab), which the shari'a protects, and resemble adultery.
Twelver Shi'a: some maraji', including Ayatollah Khamenei, allow donor eggs and, with conditions, donor sperm; other maraji' are more restrictive.
So Iran offers treatments that most Sunni countries ban.
Quick check
?A married Sunni couple cannot conceive because the wife has no viable eggs. A clinic offers IVF with eggs from an anonymous donor. What would most Sunni scholars say?
Mission 4
Euthanasia
Active euthanasia (deliberately ending a patient's life) and assisted suicide: haram. Life's term is God's (3:145); "nor kill (or destroy) yourselves" (Qur'an 4:29, Yusuf Ali).
Hadith: no one should wish for death because of a hardship that befalls them (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Suffering borne with patience is believed to wipe away sins (Bukhari; paraphrase).
Allowed by most scholars: withdrawing futile treatment so that death comes naturally; strong pain relief whose aim is relief, not death.
Many Muslim bodies accept brain death (e.g. the Islamic Fiqh Academy, 1986), so life support may then be switched off.
Duty of family and community: care, hospice and presence, so no one feels a burden.
Mission 4
Suicide
Suicide is haram: life is a trust from God (4:29).
Hadith warn of serious punishment for one who kills himself (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Yet many scholars stress mercy: one who is mentally ill may not be fully responsible, and God alone judges. Funeral prayer is normally still offered.
"Despair not of the Mercy of Allah" (Qur'an 39:53, Yusuf Ali).
Today Muslim communities increasingly treat suicide prevention and mental health as a religious duty of care.
If this topic affects you, talk to someone you trust.
Quick check
?Which practice do most Muslim scholars permit at the end of life?
Mission 4Evaluate
Is the sanctity of life absolute in Islam?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: In Islam, the sanctity of life is absolute.
For: life and death belong to God (3:145, 67:2); killing one is like killing all (5:32).
For: euthanasia, assisted suicide and abortion after ensoulment (unless the mother's life is at risk) are forbidden by all schools.
Against: the Qur'an itself allows life to be taken "by way of justice and law" (6:151): qisas, just war.
Against: many permit early abortion for serious reasons, abortion to save the mother, research on spare embryos and switching off life support after brain death.
Judge it by: Is sanctity the same as "never end life"? Does a gradual view of the embryo weaken or refine it? Who decides: jurist, doctor or family?
Mission check
?After successful IVF, a married Sunni couple in Belfast have three spare frozen embryos. Which option would many Sunni scholarly bodies accept?
Muslims hold life sacred as God's trust; jurists draw careful lines: ensoulment, lineage, futility of treatment, to protect it.
Mission 5
Mission 5: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Make a guess: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 5
Justice and the aims of punishment
"Allah commands justice, the doing of good" (Qur'an 16:90, Yusuf Ali); "when ye judge between man and man, that ye judge with justice" (Qur'an 4:58, Yusuf Ali).
Muslims believe crimes wrong God, the victim and society.
Aims of punishment in fiqh: retribution (justice for the wronged), deterrence, protection of society, reform and repentance.
Final judgement belongs to God; earthly punishment is limited and needs strict proof.
CCEA: Islamic teaching on justice, law and punishment (spelling Sharia).
Mission 5
Hudud: fixed limits
Step 1 of 3
Hudud (singular hadd, "limit"): penalties fixed by Qur'an or Sunna, seen as God's right; a judge may not change them.
Examples: theft (5:38); unlawful sexual relations (24:2); false accusation of unchastity (24:4); armed robbery and spreading terror (hiraba, 5:33); drinking alcohol (from the Sunna).
Strict proof: e.g. four eyewitnesses for adultery (24:4); confession can be withdrawn; theft only above a minimum value and not from need.
Legal maxim: "avert the hudud by doubts" (Tirmidhi; paraphrase). Caliph Umar is reported to have suspended the theft penalty in a famine.
Today: few states apply hudud; many Muslims and scholars question whether they can be applied justly now.
Mission 5
Qisas and diya
Qisas: equal retribution for murder or deliberate injury: "life for life, eye for eye" (5:45). It limits revenge: one life for one life, never more (17:33).
The victim's family chooses: qisas; diya (compensation, "blood money"); or forgiveness.
Diya is also due for accidental killing (4:92), with an act of expiation.
A court must try the case and carry out any sentence: never private revenge.
Forgiveness is praised: "if a person forgives and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from Allah" (Qur'an 42:40, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 5Read the source
Life in the law of equality
> "But if any remission is made by the brother of the slain, then grant any reasonable demand, and compensate him with handsome gratitude, this is a concession and a Mercy from your Lord." (Qur'an 2:178, Yusuf Ali)
> "In the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life to you, o ye men of understanding; that ye may restrain yourselves." (Qur'an 2:179, Yusuf Ali)
Q1 What does 2:178 call the choice to accept compensation instead of retribution?
Show answer
A concession and a mercy from God.
Q2 How can retribution "save life" (2:179)?
Show answer
It deters killing and stops endless blood feuds.
Quick check
?A man is convicted of deliberate murder in a court applying qisas. Who decides whether he faces retribution, pays diya or is forgiven?
Mission 5
Ta'zir and maslaha
Ta'zir: discretionary punishments set by a judge or the state for offences without a fixed penalty: e.g. fraud, bribery, drug dealing, cases where hadd proof fails.
Can be fines, prison, community penalties; aimed at reform and deterrence.
Guided by maslaha (public interest): laws should protect the five essentials named by al-Ghazali (1058–1111): religion, life, intellect, lineage, property.
So the state can make new laws (traffic, cyber-crime) that serve the shari'a's purposes.
Quick check
?Which offence would normally be punished by ta'zir rather than by a hadd penalty or qisas?
Mission 5
The death penalty: a traditionalist case
In classical fiqh, death may be a penalty for: murder (qisas, unless the family forgives); hiraba (5:33); adultery by a married person (from the Sunna); apostasy (disputed today).
Sheikh Ahmad Ash-Sharabasi (1918–1980), a scholar of al-Azhar, Cairo: a traditionalist defence:
The penalty is God's law, not a human invention; Muslims may not set it aside.
It saves life: "in the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life" (2:179) by deterring murder.
It is just: the killer takes a life; justice demands the like.
It is merciful within limits: strict proof, and the family's right to forgive.
Mission 5
Modern voices: limit or pause
Many Muslims in Britain and elsewhere argue that the Qur'an's preference for forgiveness (2:178, 42:40) points away from executions; others say this sets aside God's law.
Many Muslim-majority countries keep the death penalty for murder; some have abolished it.
Mission 5Evaluate
Can Islamic teachings on punishment be applied today?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Islamic teachings on punishment can be fully applied today.
For: they are revealed law (5:38, 24:2, 2:178); strict proof and forgiveness make them more merciful than they look.
For: qisas with family choice and diya puts victims at the centre, something many modern systems lack.
Against: many Muslims argue that the Qur'an's preference for forgiveness (2:178, 42:40) points away from executions; and errors cannot be undone.
Judge it by: Who should interpret: classical jurists or modern scholars? Is maslaha a reason to adapt? Which aims matter most: retribution, deterrence or reform?
Mission check
?A driver, keeping to the speed limit, accidentally hits and kills a pedestrian who steps into the road. What would classical Islamic law require?
Islamic criminal law ties punishment to intention and to the victim's rights: retribution for the deliberate, compensation for the accidental, mercy for those who forgive.
Mission 6
Mission 6: The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Make a guess: The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Mission 6Read the source
No compulsion
> "Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error" (Qur'an 2:256, Yusuf Ali)
> "There is no compulsion in religion. The right direction is henceforth distinct from error." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall)
Setting (reported from Ibn Abbas, Abu Dawud): some Madinan Muslims had sons raised as Jews and wanted to force them into Islam. The verse forbade it.
Related: "wilt thou then compel mankind, against their will, to believe!" (Qur'an 10:99, Yusuf Ali).
Q1 Why can there be no compulsion, according to the verse?
Show answer
Truth is already clear from error; faith must be a free response.
Q2 Why does the setting matter?
Show answer
It shows the verse applied even to Muslims' own children.
Quick check
?Which statement about Qur'an 2:256 is accurate?
Mission 6
From dhimmi to citizen
Step 1 of 2
Ottoman reforms: the edicts of 1839 and 1856 declared all subjects equal, whatever their religion; the jizya was abolished.
Modern states: most Muslim-majority constitutions give equal citizenship; Egypt's Coptic Christians are citizens, not dhimmis.
Tensions: limits on church building in some states; blasphemy laws (e.g. Pakistan) used against Christians and Ahmadis; ISIS re-imposed jizya (2014), condemned by most Muslim scholars.
Dhimmis: non-Muslims protected under classical Muslim rule in return for a poll tax, the jizya.
The Marrakesh Declaration (2016): hundreds of Muslim scholars and leaders called for full citizenship rights for religious minorities, citing the Charter of Madinah.
Mission 6
Apostasy in classical law
Ridda: apostasy, leaving Islam. Murtadd: an apostate.
Qur'an: condemns apostasy and warns of punishment in the Hereafter (2:217, 4:137). It names no worldly penalty.
Hadith: whoever changes his religion is to be killed (Bukhari; paraphrase). Another hadith lists leaving religion and separating from the community among the three cases where life may be taken (Bukhari, Muslim).
Classical rulings (the four Sunni schools): an adult, sane, willing male apostate is invited to repent; if he refuses, death. Hanafis: a woman is imprisoned, not executed. Ja'fari law is similar, but stricter for a man born Muslim.
Other effects: marriage dissolved; no inheritance from Muslim relatives.
Context: early apostasy often meant revolt: the Ridda wars under Abu Bakr (632–633).
Mission 6
Apostasy laws today
Death penalty possible: in a few states, e.g. Iran and Saudi Arabia, courts may apply it, though executions for apostasy alone are rare.
Civil effects only: e.g. Egypt has no apostasy crime, but in 1995 a court declared the scholar Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd an apostate and dissolved his marriage; he moved to the Netherlands.
Traditional view: the classical ruling stands, because the hadith are sound.
Reformist view: the penalty was for treason and armed revolt, not change of belief; 2:256 and 18:29 protect belief (e.g. Abdullah Saeed and Hassan Saeed, Freedom of Religion, Apostasy and Islam, 2004).
Hadd debate: some scholars hold a fixed penalty cannot rest on a single-chain hadith alone.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Article 18, includes freedom to change religion. The Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam (1990) places rights within Shari'a.
Quick check
?Which argument do reformist scholars such as Abdullah Saeed use about apostasy?
Mission 6
Freedom of expression and offence
The Satanic Verses (1988): protests in Britain, a book burned in Bradford (January 1989); Ayatollah Khomeini's fatwa (February 1989).
Cartoons of the Prophet: Denmark (2005); the Charlie Hebdo attack in Paris (2015), condemned by the Muslim Council of Britain and most Muslim bodies.
Responses from sources: "Revile not ye those whom they call upon besides Allah" (Qur'an 6:108, Yusuf Ali): respect for others' faith; "when the ignorant address them, they say, 'Peace!'" (Qur'an 25:63, Yusuf Ali).
Legal routes: England's blasphemy law protected only Christianity, and was abolished in 2008; the Racial and Religious Hatred Act (2006) covers incitement to hatred, not insult.
Muslims' own freedom: Switzerland banned new minarets by referendum (2009); bans on face-coverings (see Mission 3).
Mission 6Evaluate
"Islam supports freedom of belief."
Step 1 of 4
For: 2:256, 18:29; no worldly penalty for apostasy in the Qur'an.
For: dhimma protected worship for centuries; the Marrakesh Declaration.
Against: classical law punished apostasy by death; some states today restrict conversion, blasphemy and minority worship.
Against: dhimmis were tolerated but unequal.
Another view: distinguish the Qur'an, classical law (fiqh) and state practice: they may answer differently.
Judge it by: freedom to hold, to practise, or to change a belief? Which sources carry most weight? Does historical context limit a ruling?
Your synoptic theme: "the significance of community in maintaining faith".
Mission check
?A modern Muslim scholar notes: "The people punished for leaving Islam in the Prophet's time had also joined armies fighting the Muslims. And 2:256 forbids forcing belief." Which conclusion is she most likely drawing?
The same verse, 2:256, sits beside classical rulings on apostasy and dhimma. How Muslims read their context decides the answer.
Mission 7
Mission 7: Who decides what counts as true Islam, and what happens to those who disagree?
Make a guess: Who decides what counts as true Islam, and what happens to those who disagree?
Mission 7
Orthodoxy without a church
Orthodoxy: "right belief", as a community defines it. Heresy: a belief the community judges to break with it.
Sunni Islam has no single church or council to define doctrine.
Orthodoxy forms through the Qur'an and Sunnah as read by scholars, and through ijma (consensus of scholars).
Sunnis call themselves ahl al-sunna wa'l-jama'a: people of the Prophet's way and of the community.
Short creeds and theological schools (Ash'ari, Maturidi) set out core belief from the 10th century.
Shi'a: authority lies with the Imams; for Twelvers today, with senior scholars (marja') whom believers follow.
Mission 7
Drawing the line
Kufr: unbelief. Bid'a: innovation in religion. Ridda: apostasy (leaving Islam).
Takfir: declaring another Muslim an unbeliever.
The Kharijites (from 657): broke with Caliph 'Ali, called Muslims who committed grave sins unbelievers, and killed 'Ali (661).
For most Muslims since, they are the warning example of takfir taken to violence; modern extremists are often called "Kharijites" by their critics.
> "say not unto one who offereth you peace: 'Thou art not a believer,'" (Qur'an 4:94, Pickthall)
Al-Ghazali (d. 1111) warned against declaring anyone who says the Shahada an unbeliever (see Mission 6).
Mission 7
When rulers enforced orthodoxy
The Mihna ("trial", 833–c. 848): Caliph al-Ma'mun required scholars and judges to affirm the Mu'tazili belief that the Qur'an is created.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780–855) refused, holding the Qur'an is the uncreated speech of God; he was imprisoned and flogged.
Later caliphs ended the Mihna; Ibn Hanbal's view became Sunni orthodoxy.
Lesson often drawn: orthodoxy in Islam came to rest with the scholars and the community, not the state.
Al-Hallaj (executed 922): the Sufi whose saying "I am the Truth" was judged heretical, later honoured by many Sufis.
Quick check
?How is orthodoxy mainly defined in Sunni Islam?
Mission 7Read the source
Unity and its limits
> "And hold fast, all of you together, to the cable of Allah, and do not separate." (Qur'an 3:103, Pickthall)
The Amman Message (2004; agreed by about 200 scholars from 50 countries, 2005), paraphrase:
Forbids declaring the followers of any of these schools unbelievers (takfir).
Only qualified scholars may issue fatwas.
Q1 What does 3:103 ask of Muslims?
Show answer
To stay united, holding together to God's "cable".
Q2 How does the Amman Message turn 3:103 into a rule?
Show answer
By naming broad limits of orthodoxy and banning takfir within them.
Mission 7Diversity
The Ahmadiyya: who is a Muslim?
Founded by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (1835–1908), Punjab, 1889. Ahmadis practise the Five Pillars and call themselves Muslims.
Most Sunni and Shi'a scholars hold that Ahmadi belief in a prophet after Muhammad breaks the finality of prophethood: "the Seal of the Prophets" (Qur'an 33:40, Pickthall).
Ahmadis reply that Ghulam Ahmad brought no new law and is subordinate to Muhammad (the smaller Lahore group regards him as a reformer, not a prophet).
Pakistan declared Ahmadis non-Muslim (1974) and later made it an offence for them to "pose as Muslims" (1984). Many have faced violence.
Debate: a community may define its own boundaries; does that ever justify state penalties?
Mission 7
Human rights and freedom of belief
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Article 18: freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including freedom to change religion.
Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam (1990, Organisation of the Islamic Conference): forbids compelling anyone to change religion or to atheism; places all rights within the Sharia.
Supporters: Cairo grounds rights in God. Critics: it does not clearly protect leaving Islam.
"There is no compulsion in religion." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall): many modern scholars read this as ruling out worldly punishment for belief alone; classical law punished apostasy (see Mission 6).
Spec spellings: Sharia, Salat.
Mission 7
Community keeps faith alive
Ummah: the worldwide community of believers; "The believers are naught else than brothers" (Qur'an 49:10, Pickthall).
Faith is sustained by shared practice: Salat in congregation, Friday prayer, Ramadan, Hajj, family life, the mosque.
Sociologist Peter Berger (1929–2017), The Sacred Canopy (1967): beliefs stay plausible when a community shares them (a plausibility structure).
Positive: belonging, support, learning; strength for minorities.
Negative: pressure to conform; exclusion of dissenters or of minority groups.
Quick check
?A Muslim student moves from a large Muslim community to a city where she knows no Muslims, and finds daily prayer harder to keep. Which idea best explains this?
Mission 7
Reform and renewal
Tajdid (renewal): a hadith says God will send someone each century to renew the religion (Abu Dawud, paraphrase).
Islah (reform) and ijtihad (fresh reasoning from the sources).
Modernist reformers: Muhammad Abduh (1849–1905); Muhammad Iqbal (1877–1938), The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam (1930); Fazlur Rahman (1919–1988), Islam and Modernity (1982).
Purifying reform: Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab (1703–1792) called Muslims back to strict Tawhid, rejecting shrine practices.
So "reform" can mean opening up or tightening: both claim a return to the sources.
Is "an Islamic Reformation" a useful idea? Some call for one; others say there is no single church to reform, and the Christian Reformation also brought wars.
Mission 7
Religion resolving conflict
Qur'an 49:9–10: when believers fight, "make peace between them justly" (49:9, Pickthall).
Sunni–Shi'a: in 1959 Mahmud Shaltut, head of al-Azhar, ruled that Muslims may follow the Shi'a Ja'fari school.
A Common Word Between Us and You (2007): 138 Muslim scholars wrote to Christian leaders: both faiths share love of God and of neighbour (based on Qur'an 3:64).
Marrakesh Declaration (2016): scholars affirm the rights of religious minorities in Muslim-majority countries, citing the Charter of Medina.
Critics: declarations are easy; the test is practice on the ground.
Mission 7
From Islam outwards
The synoptic theme asks you to apply these questions to another unit. Same questions, other tradition:
Orthodoxy: Christianity used councils and creeds (Nicaea, 325; Chalcedon, 451); Islam relies on scholarly consensus.
Heresy: both have tried and punished dissenters (the Mihna; heresy trials in medieval and Reformation Europe).
Freedom of belief: both now include voices for and against full freedom to convert.
Reformation: the 16th-century Reformation divided Western Christianity; ask whether reform in Islam works the same way.
Conflict: in Northern Ireland, churches and groups such as Corrymeela have worked for reconciliation.
Mission 7Evaluate
Does defining orthodoxy protect or divide?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Defining orthodoxy does more harm than good to a religious community.
For: takfir has justified violence (Kharijites to modern extremists); state-enforced orthodoxy persecutes (Mihna; Ahmadis in Pakistan).
For: boundaries can silence reformers and minorities.
Against: without boundaries a tradition loses its identity; 3:103 calls for unity around shared truth.
Against: broad, scholar-led definitions (the Amman Message) can reduce conflict by naming who is inside.
Judge it by: Who defines orthodoxy, the state or the community? What follows from the label: debate or punishment? Does freedom of belief allow both?
Mission check
?In a Christian country in the 1600s, a church court tries a preacher for denying the Trinity; a reforming group defends him. Using ideas from this mission, which comparison with Islam is most accurate?
Every tradition must decide where its edges are; how it treats those at the edge tests its claims about freedom and community.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
The Qur'an teaches spiritual equality: one soul (4:1), the same reward (33:35, 16:97); Adam and his wife sin and repent together.
Traditional law gives different duties: men maintain; inheritance shares differ (4:11); divorce routes differ (talaq, khul', judicial). Consent and mahr belong to the woman.
Awra: navel to knee for men; most jurists: all but face and hands for women. Culture shapes dress, marriage customs and inheritance practice.
Mission 2
Most Muslims agree men and women are spiritually equal (4:1, 4:124, 33:35); debate is about family roles.
Classical scholars read 4:34 as household authority with striking as a limited last step; feminist readers (Wadud) read the role as conditional and the striking clause as a restriction on its way to ending.
Mission 3
Qur'an 24:30–31 and 33:59 ask modesty of men and women; most scholars require women to cover all but face and hands.
Afshar: Islamic feminism and women's own choice, against compulsion in either direction.
Mission 4
Life is God's gift and trust (3:145, 5:32, 67:2); only "justice and law" may take it (6:151).
Ensoulment at about 120 days (hadith); abortion after it forbidden; before it, schools differ; the mother's life is a widely accepted exception.
IVF within marriage is permitted for Sunnis; donor gametes and surrogacy forbidden (lineage); some Shi'a maraji' allow donors; many allow research on spare embryos.
Euthanasia and suicide are haram; withdrawing futile treatment is allowed; mercy and care are stressed.
Mission 5
Three categories: hudud (fixed, strict proof), qisas (retribution, with diya or forgiveness by the family), ta'zir (discretion, guided by maslaha).
Death penalty: a traditionalist defence (Ash-Sharabasi); many Muslims stress forgiveness instead.
Mission 6
2:256: no compulsion in religion; all agree forced conversion is invalid; its reach to apostasy is debated.
Classical law punished apostasy; reformists link the penalty to treason.
Mission 7
Sunni orthodoxy rests on scholarly consensus, not a church; takfir, the Kharijites and the Mihna show the dangers when boundaries are enforced by force.
Human rights debates (UDHR 1948, Cairo 1990, 2:256) and community (ummah, Berger) shape how freely faith is held and kept.
Reform (tajdid, islah, ijtihad) and peacemaking (49:9, Amman Message, A Common Word, Marrakesh) show religion resolving conflict; the same questions apply to other traditions.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Islam in a Contemporary Context: Contemporary issues; synoptic assessment theme: Conflict, Freedom of Belief and Orthodoxy for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1Equal before God but different in law: what does Islam teach about men, women and the family?
Mission 2One verse seems to put husbands in charge. How have Muslim women scholars read it differently?
Mission 3Muslim women have argued the veil is oppression, faith and protest. How can one cloth mean all three?
Mission 4If life belongs to God, can a Muslim ever end a pregnancy, use IVF or switch off a ventilator?
Mission 5In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 6The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Mission 7Who decides what counts as true Islam, and what happens to those who disagree?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.