← A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · AS 8: God, atheism and the problem of evil; AS 8: The problem of miracle
Mini-Lesson

God, atheism and the problem of evil; The problem of miracle

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why is there malaria? Is that a proof or just a problem?
  2. Mission 2If God made everything and everything God made was good, where did evil come from?
  3. Mission 3Would a world with no pain at all be a better place to grow up in?
  4. Mission 4Could God make people who are free but never choose evil? And if not, was freedom worth it?
  5. Mission 5Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?
  6. Mission 6If a train stops a few feet from a child for an ordinary reason, can it still be a miracle?
  7. Mission 7Could any amount of eyewitness evidence make it reasonable to believe a miracle happened?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why is there malaria? Is that a proof or just a problem?

Make a guess: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why is there malaria? Is that a proof or just a problem?

Mission 1

Moral and natural evil

Moral and natural evilMoralcaused by freeagentsmurderwarcrueltyNaturalcaused bynatureearthquakediseasepredatorsBoundary tray: both at once?famine made worse by corruptionflood worsened by building on flood plains
  • Moral evil: suffering caused by free agents: murder, cruelty, war, neglect.
  • Natural evil: suffering caused by nature: earthquakes, disease, drought, predators.
  • Boundary cases: a famine made worse by corruption; a flood worsened by building on flood plains.
  • Evil names what is bad; suffering names what is felt: pain, fear, grief.
  • Why it matters: theodicies often explain moral evil by free will, but natural evil needs another answer.
Mission 1Read the source

Epicurus' old questions

David Hume (1711–1776), Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779), Part X; Philo speaks:

> "Epicurus's old questions are yet unanswered. Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both able and willing? whence then is evil?"

  • Epicurus (341–270 BCE): the argument is attributed to him by the Christian writer Lactantius (On the Anger of God, ch. 13, c. 314).

Q1 Which two attributes does each question test?

Show answer

Power, "able"; goodness, "willing".

Q2 Why is the third question the hardest?

Show answer

If God has both, evil should not exist; yet it does.

Mission 1

Logical and evidential

Logical and evidentialLogicaldeductiveGod is all-powerfulGod is all-goodevil existscannot allbe trueif it works: God is impossibleEvidentialinductiveamount, intensity,distribution of evilGod probable?if it works: God is improbable, not impossible
  • Logical problem: God's attributes and the existence of evil are inconsistent: both cannot be true. Deductive: if it works, God is impossible.
  • Evidential problem: the amount, intensity and distribution of evil make God's existence improbable. Inductive: it does not claim impossibility.
  • A response to one may not answer the other: showing consistency is not showing likelihood.
Mission 1

Mackie: the inconsistent triad

Mackie's inconsistent triadGod is omnipotentGod is wholly goodevil existsadded rule 1a good being eliminates evil as far as it canadded rule 2there are no limits to what an omnipotentbeing can docontradiction
  • J. L. Mackie (1917–1981), "Evil and Omnipotence", Mind (1955).
  • Three propositions central to theism: God is omnipotent; God is wholly good; evil exists. If any two are true, the third seems false.
  • The contradiction appears once two further rules are added (paraphrase):
  • A good being always eliminates evil as far as it can.
  • There are no limits to what an omnipotent being can do.
  • So a wholly good, omnipotent being would eliminate evil completely; yet evil exists.
  • Mackie: theists must give up one premise or admit their beliefs are inconsistent: religious belief would then be not merely unsupported but irrational.
Quick check
?Why does Mackie add two extra rules to his three propositions?
Mission 1

Mackie against the easy answers

Mackie against the easy answersGod is omnipotentGod is wholly goodevil existscontradiction?"Good cannot exist without evil"Mackie: this limits omnipotence; at most a tinycontrast is needed"Evil is a means to good"Mackie: only a limited being needs means; Godcould produce the good directly"The universe is better with some evil"Mackie: cruelty and cowardice (second-orderevils) arise, and the problem returns"Evil is due to human free will"Mackie: why not make people who alwaysfreely choose good?Paradox of omnipotencecan an omnipotent being make things it cannotcontrol? Either answer limits its power

Mackie rejects four "fallacious solutions" (paraphrase):

  • "Good cannot exist without evil": this limits omnipotence, and at most needs a tiny amount of evil as a contrast.
  • "Evil is necessary as a means to good": only a limited being needs means; an omnipotent God could produce the good directly.
  • "The universe is better with some evil": pain (first-order evil) allows sympathy and courage (second-order goods); but then cruelty and cowardice (second-order evils) arise, needing higher goods, and the problem returns.
  • "Evil is due to human free will": if God could make people who sometimes freely choose good, why not people who always freely choose good?
  • Paradox of omnipotence: can an omnipotent being make things it cannot control? Either answer limits its power.
  • Replies to Mackie (Plantinga's free will defence).
Mission 1

Rowe: the fawn in the forest

Rowe's argumenta forest fire no one sees1intense suffering exists that anall-powerful, all-knowing being couldhave prevented without losing a greatergood2a wholly good, all-knowing being wouldprevent such suffering3so there is no such beingPremise 1 rests on how such cases appear:pointless.Response: sceptical theism (Wykstra, 1984)our failure to see a reason is weak evidencethat there is none
  • William Rowe (1931–2015), "The Problem of Evil and Some Varieties of Atheism", American Philosophical Quarterly (1979).
  • Example: lightning strikes a forest; a fawn is trapped, badly burned, and lies in terrible agony for several days before dying. No one sees it; no one learns from it.
  • (1) There exist instances of intense suffering that an all-powerful, all-knowing being could have prevented without losing a greater good or allowing something as bad or worse.
  • (2) A wholly good, all-knowing being would prevent such suffering.
  • (3) So there is no such being. Premise (1) is supported by how such cases appear: pointless.
  • Rowe calls himself a "friendly atheist": a theist may still be rational in believing.
  • Response: sceptical theism (Stephen Wykstra, 1984): our failure to see a reason is weak evidence that there is none.
Mission 1

Gregory S. Paul: premature deaths

  • Gregory S. Paul (b. 1954), "Theodicy's Problem: A Statistical Look at the Holocaust of the Children" (Philosophy and Theology, 2007).
  • Through most of history, a very large share of children died before adulthood, mostly from natural causes: disease, malnutrition, childbirth.
  • These children died before they could use free will or grow morally, so free-will and soul-making theodicies hardly reach them.
  • The scale of these deaths, he argues, makes a good creator very unlikely: an evidential argument from natural evil.
  • Reply: believers point to an afterlife in which God may make good every life (eschatological justification).
Quick check
?Which statement is a version of the evidential problem of evil?
Mission 1

Living with evil

Living with evilJob: the whirlwind"Where were you when I laid thefoundations of the earth?" (Job 38:4)Protestkeeping faith by arguing with God;Elie Wiesel, Night (1958)Sabr: patient endurance"Lo! we are Allah's and lo! unto Himwe are returning" (Qur'an 2:156)Hope"He will wipe away every tear fromtheir eyes" (Revelation 21:4)
  • The problem is not only philosophical: it is lived. Suffering can destroy or deepen faith.
  • Job curses the day he was born (Job 3), protests to God, and is answered from the whirlwind: "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?" (Job 38:4)
  • Elie Wiesel (1928–2016), Night (1958): a Holocaust survivor's account of faith shaken by the camps.
  • Some Jewish thinkers keep faith through protest, arguing with God; others speak of God hiding.
  • Muslims are taught sabr (patient endurance): "Lo! we are Allah's and lo! unto Him we are returning" (Qur'an 2:156, Pickthall).
  • Christians point to a God who suffers on the cross, and to hope: "He will wipe away every tear from their eyes" (Revelation 21:4).
Mission 1

Solutions for the believer and the atheist

Believer and atheistBelieverAtheistTheodicyGod's reasons forallowing evil(Augustine, Irenaeus)Evidence againstGodMackie, RoweDefenceonly shows God andevil are consistent(Plantinga)Natural explanationa world shaped byevolution, no one toblame (Darwin,1860)Mysteryas in JobHumanist actionwork to reducesuffering in this lifePractical responsefighting sufferingmatters more thanexplaining itAtheism's challengeis there ultimatejustice or hope forvictims?
  • Believer: a theodicy gives God's reasons for allowing evil (Augustine, Irenaeus: –c); a defence only shows God and evil are consistent.
  • Others appeal to mystery (Job) or to practical response: fighting suffering matters more than explaining it.
  • Atheist: evil is evidence against God (Mackie, Rowe); suffering is what we would expect in a natural world shaped by evolution, with no one to blame.
  • Charles Darwin (letter to Asa Gray, 1860) could not believe a good and all-powerful God would design wasps that feed inside living caterpillars (paraphrase).
  • Atheism's own challenge: without God, is there ultimate justice or hope for victims? Humanists answer by working to reduce suffering in this life.
Mission 1Evaluate

"The evidential problem is a greater challenge to belief than the logical problem."

Evidential or logical: which is the greater challenge?"The evidential problem is a greaterchallenge to belief than the logicalproblem."ForMany judge the logical form answered:Plantinga only needs God and evil to bepossibly consistent.The evidential form needs only probability;Rowe's fawn and children's early deathsfrom disease are hard to explain away.AgainstThe logical form, if sound, disproves Godoutright; Mackie argues free-will repliesfail."This suffering seems pointless" mayreflect our limited view (sceptical theism).Probability must be judged on all theevidence, including arguments for God andreligious experience.Judge it byWhat does each argument claim to show? ·Which responses are stronger? · Does abeliever need certainty or onlyreasonableness?
  • For: many philosophers judge the logical form answered: Plantinga only needs to show that God and evil are possibly consistent (see Mission 4).
  • For: the evidential form needs only probability; cases such as Rowe's fawn and the early deaths of children from disease are hard to explain away.
  • Against: the logical form, if sound, disproves God outright; Mackie argues free-will replies fail.
  • Against: "this suffering seems pointless" may reflect our limited view (sceptical theism).
  • Against: probability must be judged on all the evidence, including arguments for God and religious experience.
  • Judge it by: What does each argument claim to show? Which responses are stronger? Does a believer need certainty or only reasonableness?
Mission check

?Malaria still kills many people every year, most of them young children. A doctor says: "I can't prove God doesn't exist, but this much suffering, with no purpose I can see, makes a loving, all-powerful God hard to believe in." How is her argument best classified?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If God made everything and everything God made was good, where did evil come from?

Make a guess: If God made everything and everything God made was good, where did evil come from?

Mission 2

A good creation

Two pictures of realityManicheestwo equal powersLightDarknessdualism rejectedAugustineone Godall things: goodno created evil"God saw everything that he had made, and,behold, it was very good." (Genesis 1:31)
  • Augustine of Hippo (354–430), bishop in North Africa; Confessions (c. 397–400); City of God (413–426).
  • As a young man he followed the Manichees, who taught two equal powers: Good and Evil, Light and Darkness.
  • He came to reject this dualism: there is one God, and everything God made is good.
  • "God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good." (Genesis 1:31)
  • So evil cannot be a created thing. Then what is it?
Mission 2Read the source

Evil as privation

Evil as privationgooda whole appleprivation: missing good"evil was nothing but a privation ofgood" (Confessions III.7)blindness = lack of sightnot a thing: missing sightThe evil will: a deficient cause"it is not efficient, but deficient" (City of GodXII.7)

> "…evil was nothing but a privation of good, until at last a thing ceases altogether to be…" (Confessions III.7, Pusey translation)

> "Let no one, therefore, look for an efficient cause of the evil will; for it is not efficient, but deficient…" (City of God XII.7, Dods translation)

  • Privation (Latin privatio): a lack of a good that should be there. Blindness is not a thing; it is missing sight. Rot is a good apple losing its goodness.
  • An evil will has no positive cause: it is a turning away from God, the highest good, to lesser goods.

Q1 Why can't God be the author of evil, on this view?

Show answer

God creates only things; evil is not a thing but a lack.

Q2 What does "deficient" cause mean?

Show answer

A falling short, a failure, rather than something that produces.

Mission 2

Augustine: the Fall of angels and humans

Augustine's account of the FallGood creationeverything "very good" (Genesis1:31)Angels' fallsome angels, led by Satan, turn inpride: the first evil will (City of GodXI–XII)Human Falldisobedience in Eden (Genesis 3)Consequencesoriginal sin (Romans 5:12; all "in thatone man", City of God XIII.14);disordered nature (Genesis 3:17;Romans 8:22)
  • In Augustine's account, God gave angels and humans free will.
  • Some angels, led by Satan, turned in pride from God to themselves: the first evil will (City of God XI–XII).
  • Humans, tempted, disobeyed in Eden (Genesis 3): the Fall.
  • "Therefore, as sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin, so death passed to all men because all sinned." (Romans 5:12)
  • Augustine: "For we all were in that one man" (City of God XIII.14): all humanity was seminally present in Adam.
  • So all inherit original sin: a damaged nature, inclined to sin, and liable to just punishment.
Mission 2

Augustine on natural evil

Augustine's account of the FallGood creationeverything "very good" (Genesis1:31)Angels' fallsome angels, led by Satan, turn inpride: the first evil will (City of GodXI–XII)Human Falldisobedience in Eden (Genesis 3)Consequencesoriginal sin (Romans 5:12; all "in thatone man", City of God XIII.14);disordered nature (Genesis 3:17;Romans 8:22)
  • For Augustine, after the Fall creation itself is disordered: "the ground is cursed for your sake" (Genesis 3:17); "the whole creation groans and travails in pain together until now" (Romans 8:22).
  • Augustine: natural evil is the just consequence of sin: humans lost their harmony with God, so nature lost its harmony with humans.
  • Some Augustinians add the fallen angels as a cause of disorder in nature.
  • Aesthetic principle: the universe is like a poem "set off with antitheses"; "the beauty of the course of this world is achieved by the opposition of contraries" (City of God XI.18).
  • Plenitude: a full creation, with every level of being, is better than one with only the highest things.
Quick check
?On Augustine's account, what is the best description of evil?
Mission 2

Augustine: soul-deciding, the Cross and reconciliation

Soul-decidingthe Fallsin and death enterthe Cross overcomes evil"in Christ all will be made alive" (1Cor 15:22)judgementthis life decidesheavenby God's graceHell: justpunishmentfor freely chosen sinGod judged it better "to bring good out of evilthan to prevent the evil" (City of God XXII.1)soul-deciding (Hick's term)
  • John Hick called Augustine's theodicy soul-deciding: this life decides each person's eternal destiny, heaven or hell.
  • On this view Hell is just punishment for freely chosen sin; God's grace saves those who are saved.
  • The Cross overcomes evil: Christians believe that through Christ sin and death are defeated: "For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be made alive." (1 Corinthians 15:22)
  • Reconciliation: "God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself" (2 Corinthians 5:19).
  • God "deeming it to be more befitting His power and goodness to bring good out of evil than to prevent the evil from coming into existence" (City of God XXII.1).
  • The Easter Vigil hymn (Exsultet) even sings of Adam's sin as "O happy fault", which gained so great a Redeemer.
Quick check
?Why did Hick call Augustine's theodicy "soul-deciding"?
Mission 2

Challenges: logic and science

Challenges to AugustineSchleiermacher: a contradictionif flawless, it would not fall; if it fell, the flawwas there from the startEvil from nothingwhere did the first evil will come from inperfect angels? (Hick)Evolutionhumansdeath, disease, predation:hundreds of millions of yearsSingle pairhumans descend from apopulation, not one coupleHelleternal punishment for finite sins seemsinconsistent with an all-loving GodInnocent sufferinginfants and animals suffer natural evil, thoughthey have not sinned
  • Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768–1834), The Christian Faith (1821–22): a perfect creation that goes wrong is a contradiction. If it was flawless, it would not fall; if it fell, the flaw was there from the start, and God made it.
  • Where did the first evil will come from in perfect angels? Hick: Augustine needs evil to create itself out of nothing.
  • Evolution: the fossil record shows death, disease and predation for hundreds of millions of years before humans. Order did not become chaos at a human Fall.
  • Single pair: population genetics indicates humans descend from a population, not one couple, which undermines inheriting Adam's sin.
  • Genesis 2–3: many scholars and believers read the Eden story as myth or theology, not history.
Mission 2

Challenges: God's goodness

Challenges to AugustineSchleiermacher: a contradictionif flawless, it would not fall; if it fell, the flawwas there from the startEvil from nothingwhere did the first evil will come from inperfect angels? (Hick)Evolutionhumansdeath, disease, predation:hundreds of millions of yearsSingle pairhumans descend from apopulation, not one coupleHelleternal punishment for finite sins seemsinconsistent with an all-loving GodInnocent sufferinginfants and animals suffer natural evil, thoughthey have not sinned
  • Hell: eternal punishment for finite sins seems inconsistent with an all-loving God.
  • Augustine thought most of humanity a "mass of perdition" (massa damnata), saved only by grace: critics ask how that is good.
  • Inherited guilt: why should anyone be punished for Adam's sin?
  • Innocent suffering: infants and animals suffer natural evil, though they have not sinned.
  • Foreknowledge: God knew angels and humans would fall, yet created them: does responsibility return to God?
Mission 2

Augustinian replies today

Augustinian repliesChallengeAugustinian replyEden is myth,not historyread the Fall theologically: atruth about the humanconditionCatholic teaching: figurativelanguage, but a real primevalevent (Catechism 390)God made evilprivation still widelydefended (Aquinas,McCabe): evil is lack, notthingGod is to blamefor free choicesfree will defence (Plantinga,)natural evilbefore humansfallen angels? Critics say:unfalsifiableStrengthstakes sin and responsibility seriously; fits theChristian story; one good God
  • Many Christians read the Fall theologically: a truth about the human condition (we turn from God) rather than a dated event.
  • Catholic teaching: Genesis 3 uses figurative language but affirms a real primeval event at the start of human history (Catechism 390, paraphrase).
  • Privation is still widely defended (Aquinas; Herbert McCabe): evil as lack, not thing, keeps God the creator of good only.
  • Alvin Plantinga's free will defence builds on Augustine's free-will core (see Mission 4).
  • Some suggest fallen angels could explain natural evil before humans: critics call this unfalsifiable.
  • Strengths: takes sin and human responsibility seriously; fits Christian story of Fall and redemption; consistent with one good God.
Quick check
?Which criticism of Augustine is Schleiermacher's?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Augustine's theodicy spares God from blame for evil."

Does Augustine spare God from blame?"Augustine's theodicy spares God fromblame for evil."ForEvil is not a created thing, so God createsonly good (privation).Free creatures, not God, chose evil; freewill is a great good worth its risk.Evil is overcome by the Cross; God bringsgood out of evil.AgainstA perfect creation could not fall unlessflawed (Schleiermacher); God foreknewthe Fall.Natural evil long predates humans(evolution); single-pair descent isbiologically unlikely.Inherited guilt and eternal Hell sit badlywith omnibenevolence.Judge it byMust the Fall be historical for the theodicy towork? · Is privation a real answer or a play onwords? · Does responsibility pass back to thecreator?
  • For: evil is not a created thing, so God creates only good (privation).
  • For: free creatures, not God, chose evil; free will is a great good worth its risk.
  • For: evil is overcome by the Cross; God brings good out of evil.
  • Against: a perfect creation could not fall unless flawed (Schleiermacher); God foreknew the Fall.
  • Against: natural evil long predates humans (evolution); single-pair descent is biologically unlikely.
  • Against: inherited guilt and eternal Hell sit badly with omnibenevolence.
  • Judge it by: Must the Fall be historical for the theodicy to work? Is privation a real answer or a play on words? Does responsibility pass back to the creator?
Mission check

?A doctor explains that cancer cells are ordinary cells that have lost the controls that normally regulate their growth. A critic says: "So God created cancer: God created evil." What reply would an Augustinian give?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Would a world with no pain at all be a better place to grow up in?

Make a guess: Would a world with no pain at all be a better place to grow up in?

Mission 3

Irenaeus: made in the image, growing into the likeness

Image to likenessimagegiven at creation:reason andfreedomlikenessgrown into: moraland spiritualmaturityimmaturegrowingmature"God said, 'Let's make man in our image, afterour likeness.'" (Genesis 1:26)
  • Irenaeus (c. 130–c. 202), bishop of Lyons; Against Heresies (c. 180), Book IV, chs. 37–39.
  • "God said, 'Let's make man in our image, after our likeness.'" (Genesis 1:26)
  • Irenaeus reads two stages: the image (reason and freedom) is given at creation; the likeness (moral and spiritual maturity, like God) must be grown into.
  • Humans were created immature, like children, not perfect: they could not receive perfection all at once.
  • We learn good by experiencing its opposite, as the tongue learns sweet by tasting bitter (IV.39, paraphrase).
  • So a world with evil and suffering is a place to grow, not a ruined paradise.
Mission 3

Hick: the vale of soul-making

Hick's two stagesstage 1: biologicalevolutionstage 2: soul-makingfree choices in ahard worldGod's presenceepistemic distance (knowledge, not space)so faith and love of God can be free
  • John Hick (1922–2012), Evil and the God of Love (1966), Part IV.
  • He borrows the poet John Keats' phrase (letter of 1819): "Call the world if you Please 'The vale of Soul-making'."
  • The world is not a hedonistic paradise or a pet's cage designed for comfort. It is an environment for making persons.
  • Goodness that grows through free choices in a hard world is worth more than goodness made ready-made.
  • Hick accepts evolution: the first, biological stage of creation; the second, spiritual stage is our free growth.
Mission 3

Epistemic distance

Hick's two stagesstage 1: biologicalevolutionstage 2: soul-makingfree choices in ahard worldGod's presenceepistemic distance (knowledge, not space)so faith and love of God can be free
  • If God's presence were overwhelming, humans could not freely choose to love God: they would be compelled.
  • So God creates humans at an epistemic distance: a distance in knowledge, not space.
  • The world looks "as if there were no God": it is religiously ambiguous.
  • Faith and love of God can then be a free response.
  • The story of the Fall becomes, for Hick, a myth of this distance, not a historical event.
Mission 3Read the source

Suffering that shapes

> "Not only this, but we also rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces perseverance; and perseverance, proven character; and proven character, hope" (Romans 5:3–4, WEBBE)

> "Count it all joy, my brothers, when you fall into various temptations, knowing that the testing of your faith produces endurance." (James 1:2–3, WEBBE)

  • Hebrews 2:10 even speaks of the Son made "perfect through sufferings".

Q1 What chain does Paul describe?

Show answer

Suffering → perseverance → character → hope.

Q2 How does this support Hick?

Show answer

Suffering can be part of how character and faith are formed.

Quick check
?Why, according to Hick, does God create humans at an epistemic distance?
Mission 3

A world without pain?

A world without pain?painless worldlaw-governed worldclimber floatsfalls can killknife turnssoftknives canwoundfire neverburnsfire burnscouragecompassionsciencecouragecompassionsciencesoul-making needs regular natural laws thatcan cause pain

Hick's thought experiment (paraphrase): imagine God prevented every harm.

  • A falling climber floats; a knife turns soft when used to hurt; fire never burns flesh.
  • There would be no danger, so no courage; no need, so no generosity or compassion; no wrong to resist.
  • Science would be impossible: nature would have no reliable laws.
  • So a world fit for soul-making needs regular natural laws that can cause pain.
  • Critics: some of these goods could exist with far less suffering than there is.
Mission 3

Beyond this life

Soul-making beyond this lifebirthdeathHick: continues after deaththe likeness of Godfor all (universal salvation)Romans 8:18"For I consider that the sufferings of thispresent time are not worthy to be comparedwith the glory which will be revealed towardsus."
  • Most people do not complete soul-making in this life.
  • Eschatological justification: the process continues after death, until all reach the likeness of God.
  • "For I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which will be revealed towards us." (Romans 8:18)
  • Universal salvation: Hick holds that all will finally be saved; if any were lost, their suffering would never be justified.
  • Mystery: Hick admits some suffering crushes rather than builds. Even this has a role: if suffering always visibly fitted what people deserved, compassion and goodness would become calculation.
Mission 3

Swinburne on natural evil

Swinburne: natural evil and knowledgenatural processesobserveddisease spreads,floods drown, fireburnsknowledgehow to cause orprevent harmfree, responsiblechoicewe know what ouractions will causecourage, care,sacrificegreat acts madepossibleSwinburne, The Existence of God (1979), ch. 11
  • Richard Swinburne (b. 1934), The Existence of God (1979), ch. 11; Providence and the Problem of Evil (1998).
  • Free choices are serious only if we know what our actions will cause.
  • We learn how to cause or prevent harm by observing natural processes: disease spreads, floods drown, fire burns.
  • So natural evil gives the knowledge needed for responsible free will.
  • Natural evil also makes possible great acts of courage, care and sacrifice.
  • Critics: could God not give this knowledge directly? Must so many suffer so others can learn?
Quick check
?What role does Swinburne give natural evil?
Mission 3

Challenges to soul-making

Challenges to soul-makingUniversal salvation and justicethe unrepentant torturer and his victim sharethe same end; texts on judgement (Matthew25:46)Suffering as a tool?Phillips (2004): love is never expressed byinflicting suffering as a meansScale and unevennessthe Holocaust; some lives crushed, otherseasy: does soul-making need so much, sounevenly?Innocent and animal sufferingchildren who die before any soul-making;animals, with no souls to make on many views
  • Universal salvation unjust? If the unrepentant torturer and his victim share the same end, justice seems ignored; it also conflicts with texts on judgement (Matthew 25:46).
  • Suffering as a tool? D. Z. Phillips (1934–2006), The Problem of Evil and the Problem of God (2004): love is never expressed by inflicting suffering as a means; a God who did so would not be loving.
  • Immensity and unequal distribution: the Holocaust; some lives crushed, others easy. Does soul-making need so much, so unevenly?
  • Innocent suffering: children who die before any soul-making; animals, who have no souls to make on many views.
Mission 3

Strengths, and Augustine compared

Augustine and Irenaeus–Hick comparedAugustineIrenaeus–Hickdirectionlooks backlooks forwardoriginalstateperfectcreationimmatureevila privationpart of growththe Fallhistoricala mythdestinysoul-deciding:heaven or Hellsoul-making: allsavedkey textsGenesis 3;Romans 5:12Genesis 1:26;Romans 5:3–4;Hebrews 2:10Sharedfree will is central; both rely on an afterlife
  • Strengths: fits evolution and a developing world; gives natural evil a purpose; preserves free will; a loving God saves all.
  • Biblical roots: Genesis 1:26; Romans 5:3–4; Hebrews 2:10.
  • Augustine: looks back to a perfect creation and a Fall; evil a privation; soul-deciding; hell.
  • Irenaeus–Hick: looks forward to a perfection still to come; evil part of growth; soul-making; all saved.
  • Both: free will is central; both rely on an afterlife to complete the account.
Mission 3Evaluate

"The need for a vale of soul-making justifies the existence and extent of evil."

Does soul-making justify evil?"The need for a vale of soul-makingjustifies the existence and extent of evil."ForVirtues freely developed are worth morethan ready-made goodness; real danger isneeded for them.Regular natural laws, which can harm, areneeded for science, planning andresponsible choice.An infinite future good may outweighfinite suffering (eschatologicaljustification).AgainstThe extent of suffering far exceeds whatsoul-making seems to need (Holocaust;early deaths of children).Using suffering as a means is incompatiblewith love (Phillips); universal salvation sitsuneasily with justice.Animal suffering over millions of yearsserves no soul-making.Judge it byExistence or extent? · Does an afterlife makethe case, or assume it? · Is a God who usessuffering still good?
  • For: virtues freely developed are worth more than ready-made goodness; a world with real danger is needed for them.
  • For: regular natural laws, which can harm, are needed for science, planning and responsible choice.
  • For: an infinite future good may outweigh finite suffering (eschatological justification).
  • Against: the extent of suffering far exceeds what soul-making seems to need (Holocaust; the early deaths of children).
  • Against: using suffering as a means is incompatible with love (Phillips); universal salvation sits uneasily with justice.
  • Against: animal suffering over millions of years serves no soul-making.
  • Judge it by: existence or extent? Does an afterlife make the case, or assume it? Is a God who uses suffering still good?
Mission check

?A six-year-old dies in an earthquake, before she has had any chance to grow in courage or kindness. Which part of Hick's theodicy is designed to answer the objection that she never had the chance to grow?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Could God make people who are free but never choose evil? And if not, was freedom worth it?

Make a guess: Could God make people who are free but never choose evil? And if not, was freedom worth it?

Mission 4

The free will defence

The free will defencedefence: possible reason, not actual1significantly free creatures + more good thanevil = a more valuable world2if God causes creatures to do only right, theyare not free3so the possibility of moral evil is the price ofmoral goodMackie and Flew (1955)free yet always good? An omnipotent Godcould have made such peoplePlantinga: transworld depravity (possible)possibly every person God could create wouldfreely go wrong at least once
  • Alvin Plantinga (b. 1932), God, Freedom, and Evil (1974).
  • A defence, not a theodicy: it does not claim to know God's actual reasons; it shows God and evil are logically consistent (answering Mackie).
  • A world with significantly free creatures, who do more good than evil, is more valuable than a world without them.
  • If God causes creatures to do only right, they are not free. So God cannot create moral good without allowing the possibility of moral evil.
  • Moral evil comes from creatures' misuse of freedom, not from any lack of God's power or goodness.
  • Natural evil: Plantinga notes it is possible that it too results from free non-human persons (fallen angels), which is enough for consistency.
Mission 4

Couldn't God make people who always choose good?

The free will defencedefence: possible reason, not actual1significantly free creatures + more good thanevil = a more valuable world2if God causes creatures to do only right, theyare not free3so the possibility of moral evil is the price ofmoral goodMackie and Flew (1955)free yet always good? An omnipotent Godcould have made such peoplePlantinga: transworld depravity (possible)possibly every person God could create wouldfreely go wrong at least once
  • Mackie (1955) and Antony Flew (1923–2010): there is no contradiction in people who are free yet always choose good; so an omnipotent God could have made them.
  • This assumes compatibilism: freedom fits with being determined by one's nature.
  • Plantinga assumes libertarian freedom: a free choice is not determined by anything, even by God.
  • Transworld depravity: it is possible that every person God could create would freely go wrong at least once, in any world God could make actual.
  • If so, a world with moral good but no moral evil was not God's to create. Omnipotence means doing whatever is logically possible (Aquinas).
  • Many philosophers judge this enough to answer the logical problem; the evidential problem remains.
Quick check
?Why does Plantinga call his argument a defence rather than a theodicy?
Mission 4

Strengths and weaknesses of the free will defence

Free will defence: strengths and weaknessesStrengthsWeaknessestakes humanresponsibilityseriouslyscale: could God notintervenesometimes?fits Christian, Jewishand Muslim teachingon moral choicevictims: the abuser'sfreedom is respected,the victim'sdestroyedwidely judged toanswer the logicalproblemnatural evil: blamingfallen angels looksad hocmoral evil comesfrom creatures'misuse of freedom,not a lack in Godheaven: if the savedare free yet never sin,why not create thatstate?
  • Strengths: takes human responsibility seriously; fits Christian, Jewish and Muslim teaching on moral choice; widely judged to answer the logical problem.
  • Weakness: scale. Could God not intervene sometimes, to stop a Holocaust, without abolishing freedom?
  • Weakness: victims. The abuser's freedom is respected; the victim's freedom is destroyed.
  • Weakness: natural evil. Blaming fallen angels for earthquakes looks ad hoc to critics.
  • Weakness: heaven. If the saved in heaven are free yet never sin, why could God not create that state from the start?
Mission 4

Process theodicy: a God who persuades

Two models of powerclassical theismprocessworldfrom nothingomnipotentlurepersuades,cannot coerceco-sufferer"the great companion—the fellow-suffererwho understands" (Whitehead)
  • A. N. Whitehead (1861–1947), Process and Reality (1929); David Ray Griffin (1939–2022), God, Power, and Evil: A Process Theodicy (1976).
  • God did not create from nothing (ex nihilo): God shapes a world from a pre-existing chaos.
  • Reality is made of events, each with some power to determine itself.
  • God persuades ("lures") each event towards the good, but cannot coerce it.
  • Evil arises when creatures do not follow God's lure.
  • God has all the power a being could have in such a world, but not unlimited power: so God is not responsible for evil.
Mission 4

Why risk it? The co-suffering God

Two models of powerclassical theismprocessworldfrom nothingomnipotentlurepersuades,cannot coerceco-sufferer"the great companion—the fellow-suffererwho understands" (Whitehead)
  • Griffin: greater complexity brings greater capacity for enjoyment (rich experience) and for suffering: the two cannot be separated.
  • God judged a world capable of great value worth the risk of great suffering.
  • God is not a distant judge but feels every suffering with creatures: in Whitehead's words, "the great companion—the fellow-sufferer who understands".
  • Some Christians link this to the cross: God sharing suffering, not standing outside it.
Quick check
?According to Griffin, why is God not to blame for evil?
Mission 4

Criticisms of process theodicy

Criticisms of process theodicyWorthy of worship?not omnipotent, not creator from nothing: notthe God of classical theismElitismthe rich experiences of some are said to justifythe suffering of manyNo guaranteed victoryGod cannot ensure that evil will be overcomeUnbiblical?conflicts with creation ex nihilo, miracles andresurrectionStrengthsGod is not to blame; fits evolution; God'ssolidarity with sufferers
  • Not the God of classical theism: not omnipotent, not creator from nothing. Is such a God worthy of worship?
  • Elitism: the rich experiences of some are said to justify the suffering of many. Would the victims agree?
  • No guaranteed victory: God cannot ensure evil will be overcome; there is no promise that every tear will be wiped away.
  • Unbiblical? It conflicts with creation ex nihilo and with miracles and resurrection as acts of power.
  • Strengths: God is not to blame; fits evolution; God's solidarity with sufferers is a real comfort.
  • Mackie had already called limiting God's power an "adequate" solution, but not one most theists accept.
Mission 4

Dostoyevsky and Camus: protest

ProtestThe BrothersKaramazov1880 · "Rebellion"The Plague1947 · CamusIvanno future harmony isworth one child'stearsDr Rieuxrefuses to love acreation in whichchildren are torturedticketreturnedsolidarityfight the plagueA critique of theodicy itselfexplaining suffering as justified may itself bemorally wrong
  • Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821–1881), The Brothers Karamazov (1880), Book V, ch. 4, "Rebellion".
  • Ivan tells true stories of children tortured. Even if a future harmony explains everything, he will not accept it: no harmony is worth one child's tears. He "returns his ticket" (paraphrase).
  • Alyosha replies by pointing to Christ, who can forgive because he gave his own blood.
  • Albert Camus (1913–1960), The Plague (1947): after watching a child die in agony, Dr Rieux refuses to love a creation in which children are tortured.
  • Father Paneloux first preaches the plague as punishment; after the child's death he says faith must accept all or nothing.
  • Both critique theodicy itself: explaining suffering as justified may be morally wrong. Camus' answer is solidarity: fight the plague.
Quick check
?Ivan Karamazov accepts that a future harmony might explain children's suffering, yet still "returns his ticket". What is his objection?
Mission 4Evaluate

"Monotheism can be successfully defended in the face of evil."

Can monotheism be defended?"Monotheism can be successfully defendedin the face of evil."Augustineprivation; the Fallcost: science, HellHicksoul-makingcost: suffering as atoolPlantingafree will defencecost: natural evil,scaleGriffinprocess: Godpersuadescost: a limited GodObjection: the evidential problemRowe's fawn; the early deaths of children fromdiseaseObjection: protestDostoyevsky and Camus: justifying sufferingmay itself be wrongJudge it by"Defended" as consistent, as probable, or asworthy of worship? · Which God: classical orprocess? · Does a defence need to convince thesufferer?
  • For: the free will defence shows God and evil are logically consistent (Plantinga).
  • For: soul-making gives evil a purpose; eschatological justification answers scale (Hick).
  • For: process theodicy removes God's blame entirely (Griffin); privation keeps God the author of good only (Augustine).
  • Against: each defence pays a price: Augustine (science, Hell), Hick (suffering as a tool), Griffin (a limited God), free will (natural evil, scale).
  • Against: the evidential problem remains: Rowe's fawn, the early deaths of children from disease (see Mission 1).
  • Against: Dostoyevsky and Camus: justifying suffering may itself be wrong.
  • Judge it by: "defended" as consistent, as probable, or as worthy of worship? Which God: classical or process? Does a defence need to convince the sufferer?
Mission check

?After a mine collapse, a chaplain says: "God was not absent. God was urging every rescuer on and grieving with every family, but God could not simply override the rock or the owners' choices." Which response to evil does this express?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?

Make a guess: Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?

Mission 5

Three answers to one question

Belief and knowledge: two different questionsBelieve God exists?YesNoClaim toknow?YesNoTheist whoclaims to knowAtheist whoclaims to knowAgnostic theistAgnosticatheistNo column: kinds of atheismPositive (strong): asserts "there is no God".Negative (weak): simply lacks belief in God.No row: kinds of agnosticismStrong (permanent): cannot be known byanyone. Weak (temporary): not yet known.
  • Question: does God exist?
  • Theism: yes, God exists.
  • Atheism: from Greek a-theos, "without God": rejection of belief in God or gods.
  • Agnosticism: from Greek a-gnōstos, "not known": we do not (or cannot) know whether God exists.
  • The word agnostic was coined by T. H. Huxley (1825–1895) in 1869; he explained it in his essay "Agnosticism" (1889).
  • Atheism answers "what do you believe?"; agnosticism answers "what can we know?". So one person can be both.
Mission 5

Kinds of atheism and agnosticism

Belief and knowledge: two different questionsBelieve God exists?YesNoClaim toknow?YesNoTheist whoclaims to knowAtheist whoclaims to knowAgnostic theistAgnosticatheistNo column: kinds of atheismPositive (strong): asserts "there is no God".Negative (weak): simply lacks belief in God.No row: kinds of agnosticismStrong (permanent): cannot be known byanyone. Weak (temporary): not yet known.
  • Positive (strong) atheism: asserts "there is no God".
  • Negative (weak) atheism: simply lacks belief in God; makes no claim to disprove God.
  • Practical atheism: lives as if God does not exist, whatever is said.
  • Protest atheism: rejects God on moral grounds, often because of suffering (e.g. Ivan in Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov, 1880).
  • Strong (permanent) agnosticism: God's existence cannot be known by anyone.
  • Weak (temporary) agnosticism: it is not yet known; evidence may settle it.
Quick check
?Priya says: "I have no belief in God. I can't prove there isn't one, and I don't think anyone ever will settle it either way." Which labels fit her best?
Mission 5

Secularisation, atheism and suffering

  • Secularisation: religious thinking, practice and institutions lose social significance (paraphrase of Bryan Wilson, Religion in Secular Society, 1966).
  • Impact: law and public life separate from church teaching (e.g. Sunday trading, divorce law); rise of "no religion"; religion becomes a private choice. Steve Bruce, God is Dead (2002), sees this as long-term.
  • Challenge: Grace Davie, Religion in Britain since 1945 (1994): many are believing without belonging; Peter Berger, The Desecularization of the World (1999): globally, religion is growing.
  • Atheism and evil: the problem of evil is atheism's strongest argument (Epicurus, Hume, J. L. Mackie). Protest atheism: even if God exists, a world with such suffering makes worship wrong.
  • Atheist responses to suffering: no cosmic reason, so the task is human: compassion, medicine, justice.
  • Humanism: a non-religious way of life built on reason, empathy and this one life (fully in a later lesson).
Quick check
?Which observation is used to challenge the claim that Britain has simply become secular?
Mission 5Evaluate

Has secularisation pushed religion aside?

Has secularisation pushed religion aside?Secularisation and atheism have removedreligion from the centre of British societyand culture.ForFalling practice and belonging; law andpublic morality follow public reason, notchurch teaching (Bruce).Atheism and humanism are now publiclyvisible worldviews.AgainstBelieving without belonging (Davie);religion growing worldwide and amongmigrant communities (Berger).Religious groups still run schools, charitiesand food banks, and shape debate oneuthanasia and abortion.Judge it byMeasured by belief, belonging or influence? ·Britain only, or the world? · Decline, or changeof form?
  • Claim: Secularisation and atheism have removed religion from the centre of British society and culture.
  • For: Falling practice and belonging; law and public morality follow public reason, not church teaching (Bruce).
  • For: Atheism and humanism are now publicly visible worldviews.
  • Against: Believing without belonging (Davie); religion growing worldwide and among migrant communities (Berger's later view).
  • Against: Religious groups still run schools, charities and food banks, and shape debate on euthanasia and abortion.
  • Judgement criteria: Measured by belief, belonging or influence? Britain only, or the world? Decline, or change of form?
Mission check

?At a university debate, Sam says: "I'm a scientist. The evidence makes God very unlikely, so I live without God, but I can't rule God out." His opponent says: "Then you are really an agnostic, not an atheist." Which reply is most accurate?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If a train stops a few feet from a child for an ordinary reason, can it still be a miracle?

Make a guess: If a train stops a few feet from a child for an ordinary reason, can it still be a miracle?

Mission 6

Two questions behind every definition

Two questions behind every definition of miracleviolation ofnatural lawnatural eventrealist(a real act of God)anti-realist(a way of seeing)Definitions (not placed on the grid)Humedefinition: violationAquinasbeyond the usual orderSwinburneviolation re-definedHollandnatural event, taken religiously
  • Every definition of miracle answers two separate questions.
  • What kind of event? A violation of natural law, or a natural event that happens at a striking moment?
  • What makes it a miracle? A real act of God in the world (realist), or the meaning the event has within a community of faith (anti-realist)?
  • Keep the two questions apart: a natural event can still be understood realistically as God's act.
Mission 6

Aquinas: beyond the usual order

Aquinas' three degrees of miracleRanked by how far the event exceeds nature1stwhat nature could never do(sun going backwards)2ndwhat nature does, but not in thisorder(sight after blindness)3rdwhat nature does, withoutnatural causes(fever cured at once)Summa Contra Gentiles III.101
  • Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Contra Gentiles III, chapters 100–101 (c. 1259–65).
  • A miracle is done by God outside the order usually followed in nature (paraphrase). God, who made that order, is not bound by it.
  • Three degrees, ranked by how far the event exceeds nature:
  • 1st: God does what nature could never do (his examples: the sun going backwards; the sea opening a path).
  • 2nd: God does what nature can do, but not in this order (someone living after death; seeing after blindness).
  • 3rd: God does what nature does, but without natural causes (a fever cured instantly by God, though medicine could cure it).
  • A realist account: miracles are real divine acts.
Mission 6Read the source

Hume's definition

David Hume (1711–1776), An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding (1748), Section X, "Of Miracles", Part I:

> "A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature; …"

And in Hume's footnote to the same passage:

> "A miracle may be accurately defined, a transgression of a law of nature by a particular volition of the Deity, or by the interposition of some invisible agent."

Q1 What two things must be true for an event to count as a miracle on Hume's footnote definition?

Show answer

A law of nature is broken; the breaking is caused by God's will or by an invisible agent.

Q2 Would Aquinas' third degree count as a miracle on Hume's definition?

Show answer

Arguably not: the cure is something nature does anyway, so no law is clearly broken.

Quick check
?A man who has been blind for years is said to see again instantly when a holy person prays for him. Where would Aquinas place this event?
Mission 6

Holland: the contingency miracle

Holland's train: a contingency miraclelevel crossingchilddriver faints(medical reasons)automatic brakesstops a few feet shortThank God1A child's toy car is stuck on a level crossing.2A train comes round the bend. The driverfaints, for medical reasons.3The brakes apply automatically. The trainstops a few feet from the child.4The mother thanks God.Every step naturally explained
  • R. F. Holland (1923–2013), "The Miraculous", American Philosophical Quarterly (1965).
  • His example (paraphrase): a child's toy car is stuck on a level crossing. A train comes round a bend. The driver faints, for medical reasons; the brakes apply automatically; the train stops a few feet from the child. The mother thanks God.
  • Every step has a natural explanation. No law is broken.
  • Yet the mother calls it a miracle, and Holland says she may: a contingency miracle is a remarkable, beneficial coincidence that is taken religiously as a sign.
  • So a miracle can be a natural event: what matters is its timing and what it means.
Mission 6

Swinburne: religious significance

  • Richard Swinburne (b. 1934), The Concept of Miracle (1970).
  • A miracle is an event of an extraordinary kind, "brought about by a god, and of religious significance".
  • Religious significance: an event that God causes for no purpose would not be a miracle. It must show something about God or answer prayer.
  • He keeps a violation model, but re-defines it: a non-repeatable counter-instance to a law of nature (an event that breaks a law but gives no reason to rewrite it). Defended against Hume in Mission 7.
  • A realist account: miracles are real acts of God, and they mean something.
Mission 6Read the source

Miracles in the Bible

Three New Testament wordsNew Testament Greeksēmeiasignsteratawondersdunameismightyworks / actsof powera sign …points to who Jesus is
  • The Bible has no single word for "miracle". The New Testament uses three Greek words: sēmeia (signs), terata (wonders), dunameis (mighty works, acts of power).

> "Jesus of Nazareth, a man approved by God to you by mighty works and wonders and signs which God did by him amongst you" (Acts 2:22, WEBBE)

> "This beginning of his signs Jesus did in Cana of Galilee, and revealed his glory; and his disciples believed in him." (John 2:11, WEBBE)

  • The point is meaning, not law-breaking: a sign points to who Jesus is and calls for faith.
  • In the Hebrew Bible, God's acts in the Exodus are "signs and wonders" that show his power and his covenant with Israel.

Q1 What does the word "signs" suggest a miracle is for?

Show answer

To reveal something: here, Jesus' glory, leading to faith.

Q2 Which modern definition is closest to John's idea of a sign?

Show answer

Swinburne's "religious significance"; Holland too stresses meaning.

Mission 6

Realist and anti-realist

Two questions behind every definition of miracleviolation ofnatural lawnatural eventrealist(a real act of God)anti-realist(a way of seeing)Definitions (not placed on the grid)Humedefinition: violationAquinasbeyond the usual orderSwinburneviolation re-definedHollandnatural event, taken religiously
  • Realist: "A miracle happened" is true if God really caused the event, whether or not anyone believes it. Aquinas, Hume's definition and Swinburne are realist accounts.
  • Anti-realist: "miracle" expresses how a community of faith sees an event; its truth lies in that way of seeing and living, not in a hidden extra cause.
  • Holland's account is often read as a step towards anti-realism: the event is natural; its being a miracle depends on its being taken religiously. But a believer who takes it so may still hold that God really acted.
  • Critics of anti-realism: most believers mean that God really acted; a miracle that is only a way of seeing may not be what they claim.
  • Anti-realism does not call miracle stories lies: it says miracle-talk is not a claim about an extra cause in the world.
Quick check
?Which statement expresses an anti-realist view of miracles?
Mission 6

Why believers accept that miracles occur

  • Sacred writings: miracle accounts in scripture (e.g. the Exodus, Jesus' healings, the resurrection) are taken as reliable testimony.
  • Faith traditions affirm them: e.g. the Catholic Church investigates and recognises some healings, for example at Lourdes, and requires verified miracles in most canonisations. Many Pentecostal churches expect healing today.
  • Personal experience: answered prayer and religious experience make miracles seem credible from the inside.
  • Different Christians weigh these differently: many Catholic, Orthodox and evangelical Christians accept physical miracles; some liberal Protestants read many accounts as symbolic.
  • Reasons for belief and non-belief today.
Mission 6Evaluate

Do the definitions contradict each other?

Argument map: do the definitions of miracle contradict each other?The definitions of miracle contradict eachother, so the word has no single meaning.ForHume requires a broken law; Holland saysno law need be broken. Both cannot bethe necessary condition.Realist and anti-realist views disagreeabout whether a miracle-claim saysanything about the world.AgainstThey answer different questions: Humeand Aquinas define the event; Holland andSwinburne stress its meaning.Swinburne combines both: anextraordinary event and religioussignificance.Judge it byfits how believers use the word · fits thebiblical idea of a sign · can be tested · makesGod's action credible
  • Claim: The definitions of miracle contradict each other, so the word has no single meaning.
  • For: Hume requires a broken law; Holland says no law need be broken. Both cannot be the necessary condition.
  • For: Realist and anti-realist views disagree about whether a miracle-claim says anything about the world.
  • Against: They answer different questions: Hume and Aquinas define the event; Holland and Swinburne stress its meaning.
  • Against: Swinburne combines both: an extraordinary event and religious significance.
  • Judgement criteria: Does a definition fit how believers use the word? Does it fit the biblical idea of a sign? Can it be tested? Does it make God's action credible?
Quick check
?Which feature is essential to Holland's idea of a contingency miracle?
Mission check

?A child is found alive after six days under a collapsed building, kept alive by an air pocket and a burst water pipe. Ana, a Christian, says: "God really acted here, guiding events, though no law of nature was broken." Ben, also a Christian, says: "Calling it a miracle expresses how our community receives it as gift; it is not a claim about an extra cause." Which classification is correct?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Could any amount of eyewitness evidence make it reasonable to believe a miracle happened?

Make a guess: Could any amount of eyewitness evidence make it reasonable to believe a miracle happened?

Mission 7

Hume: weigh the evidence

Hume's scalesPart Itestimony to amiracleuniformexperience(laws of nature)Is the falsehood of the testimony moremiraculous than the event?Part II: four cracked weightswitnessessusceptibility: love of wonderorigins: "ignorant and barbarous nations"contrary claims
  • David Hume (1711–1776), Scottish empiricist: knowledge comes from experience.
  • An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding (1748), Section X, Part I.
  • A wise person proportions belief to the evidence.
  • A law of nature rests on uniform experience: every observed case, without exception.
  • A miracle report sets testimony against that uniform experience.
  • So the evidence against any miracle is as strong as evidence can be.
  • Hume does not claim miracles are logically impossible. He claims it is never reasonable to believe a report of one.
Mission 7Read the source

Hume's maxim

Hume, Enquiry (1748), Section X, Part I:

> "A wise man, therefore, proportions his belief to the evidence."

> "no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish"

Q1 A friend says she saw a dead man walk. What two possibilities does Hume tell you to compare?

Show answer

That she is mistaken or lying; that the dead man walked.

Q2 Which does Hume think will always be the less miraculous?

Show answer

That the witness is mistaken or lying: people often are; the dead never rise in uniform experience.

Mission 7

Hume: four practical arguments

Hume's scalesPart Itestimony to amiracleuniformexperience(laws of nature)Is the falsehood of the testimony moremiraculous than the event?Part II: four cracked weightswitnessessusceptibility: love of wonderorigins: "ignorant and barbarous nations"contrary claims

Part II adds four points about real miracle reports:

  • Witnesses: no miracle in history is attested by enough people of good sense, education and reputation to rule out error or deceit.
  • Susceptibility: people love surprise and wonder, and enjoy passing on marvellous stories; religious zeal can make even honest people exaggerate.
  • Origins: miracle stories abound chiefly among "ignorant and barbarous nations", and fade as learning grows (Hume's phrase).
  • Contrary claims: "in matters of religion, whatever is different is contrary". Miracles of rival religions are used to prove rival systems, so their testimonies cancel out.
Quick check
?A student writes: "Hume proves that miracles are impossible." Which correction is most accurate?
Mission 7

Swinburne replies to Hume

  • Richard Swinburne (b. 1934), The Concept of Miracle (1970); The Existence of God (1979).
  • Laws of nature: a law describes what normally happens. A non-repeatable counter-instance breaks a law without giving any reason to revise it. So a violation is coherent.
  • More kinds of evidence than testimony: our own memories, others' testimony, physical traces (e.g. medical records), and our understanding of what is physically possible.
  • Principle of testimony: believe what others report unless there is good reason not to.
  • Witnesses: Hume's standards (a "sufficient number" of witnesses of "education"; "barbarous nations") are vague or prejudiced.
  • Contrary claims: reports cancel out only if each miracle supports a doctrine that contradicts the other's. Many miracle reports support no rival doctrine at all.
Mission 7Evaluate

Hume or Swinburne?

Argument map: do Swinburne's responses defeat Hume's challenge?Swinburne's responses defeat Hume'schallenge.ForHume's Part II standards are vague andculturally biased; physical traces andmemories add evidence Hume ignores.Hume's "uniform experience" assumes nomiracle has ever happened: arguablycircular.AgainstHume weighs probabilities: even goodtestimony is far more often wrong thannature is irregular."Non-repeatable" events cannot bere-tested, so how could anyone show alaw was broken rather than just not yetunderstood?Judge it byIs belief about the past ever certain? · Whocarries the burden of proof? · Doesbackground belief in God change theprobabilities?
  • Claim: Swinburne's responses defeat Hume's challenge.
  • For: Hume's Part II standards are vague and culturally biased; physical traces and memories add evidence Hume ignores.
  • For: Hume's "uniform experience" assumes no miracle has ever happened: arguably circular.
  • Against: Hume weighs probabilities: even good testimony is far more often wrong than nature is irregular.
  • Against: "Non-repeatable" events cannot be re-tested, so how could anyone show a law was broken rather than just not yet understood?
  • Judgement criteria: Is belief about the past ever certain? Who carries the burden of proof? Does background belief in God change the probabilities?
Quick check
?A sceptic says: "Christians, Muslims and Hindus all report miracles, so their reports cancel each other out." Which reply is Swinburne's?
Mission 7

Wiles: a God who does not intervene

  • Maurice Wiles (1923–2005), Anglican priest and Oxford theologian; God's Action in the World (1986).
  • God acts in the world as a whole: his single act is creating and sustaining the universe.
  • An interventionist God who heals one person but does not prevent the horrors of Auschwitz or Hiroshima would be arbitrary and partial, and so not worthy of worship (paraphrase).
  • So God does not intervene in particular events. Miracle stories keep value as expressions of faith and meaning.
  • This is the spec's link between miracles and the existence of evil and God: belief in selective miracles sharpens the problem of evil.
Mission 7

Comparing Hume and Wiles

Comparing Hume and WilesHumeWilesstartingpointempiricistphilosopher,sceptical aboutreligionChristiantheologian(Anglicanpriest)kind ofargumentepistemological:what it isreasonable tobelievetheological andmoral: whatGod would doconclusionneverreasonable tobelieve amiracle reportGod does notact byinterventionfaith andGodleaves faithwithout miracleevidencekeeps faith inGod;reinterpretsmiracleShared groundboth reject belief in violation miracles
  • Starting point: Hume: empiricist philosopher, sceptical about religion. Wiles: Christian theologian.
  • Kind of argument: Hume: epistemological (what it is reasonable to believe). Wiles: theological and moral (what God would do).
  • Conclusion: Hume: never reasonable to believe a miracle report. Wiles: God does not act by intervention.
  • Shared ground: both reject belief in violation miracles.
  • Difference: Hume's view leaves faith without miracle evidence; Wiles keeps faith in God and reinterprets miracle.
Quick check
?Which pairing correctly states why each thinker rejects belief in violation miracles?
Mission 7

Hick: a miracle is defined by its meaning

  • John Hick (1922–2012), Philosophy of Religion (1963).
  • Laws of nature are generalisations from what has been observed. If a truly unprecedented event happened, scientists would widen the law to include it.
  • So "violation of a law of nature" is not a coherent definition.
  • A miracle must be defined religiously: an event through which people become vividly aware of God acting towards them (paraphrase).
  • Compare: Swinburne keeps "violation" by calling it a non-repeatable counter-instance; Hick drops it; Holland (see Mission 6) also stresses meaning.
Mission 7

Science, coincidence and the mind

Explanations of a reported healingreportedhealingmisdiagnosiscoincidenceplaceboremissionpsychosomaticchangeact of Godthrough these?possible natural explanationa religious interpretation, not a scientificexplanation
  • Scientific method: observation → hypothesis → experiment, with results that can be repeated. A one-off miracle cannot be re-run in a laboratory.
  • Science can propose natural explanations for reported healings: misdiagnosis, natural remission, the placebo effect, and psychosomatic change (the mind affecting the body).
  • Coincidence: among very many prayers and events, some striking matches are to be expected.
  • But "no scientific explanation yet" does not mean "none ever": believers who rest a miracle on a gap risk a God of the gaps.
  • Many believers reply: God can work through mind and body; science describes how, not whether God is at work.
  • Spec wording: "psychosomatic events or coincidences, for which there is currently no scientific explanation".
Mission 7

What this means for religion

  • If Hume is right: faith cannot be built on miracle reports as evidence. Hume's ironic close: the Christian religion "even at this day cannot be believed by any reasonable person without one" (1748).
  • If Wiles is right: prayer for intervention and some biblical miracles must be rethought; God is creator and sustainer, not an occasional intervener.
  • The resurrection: for most Christians it is the central miracle: "If Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith also is in vain" (1 Corinthians 15:14, WEBBE). Rejecting all miracles is a large step for them.
  • Perennial value: miracle accounts give hope, deepen trust in God and draw communities together (e.g. pilgrimage to Lourdes).
  • Non-belief today: scientific explanation, Hume's challenge and Wiles' moral objection.
Mission check

?Two hundred villagers, including two doctors, say they saw a woman's paralysed arm move freely at once during a festival. A follower of Hume applies the maxim from Part I. What must they ask?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Moral evil comes from free agents; natural (non-moral) evil from nature.
  • Logical problem: Epicurus via Hume; Mackie's inconsistent triad plus two rules. Evidential problem: Rowe's fawn.
  • Paul: premature deaths of children from natural causes.
  • Lived experience of evil, believer and atheist responses.

Mission 2

  • Creation was good; evil is a privation of good with a deficient, not efficient, cause.
  • Angels and humans misused free will; the Fall brought sin and natural disorder (Romans 5:12; seminal presence in Adam).
  • Soul-deciding: this life leads to heaven or just punishment; the Cross overcomes evil. Challenges: Schleiermacher, evolution, single pair, Hell, innocent suffering.

Mission 3

  • Irenaeus: humans made immature, in God's image, growing into God's likeness. Hick: the world is a vale of soul-making; epistemic distance allows free faith; regular laws and second-order goods; eschatological justification and universal salvation.
  • Challenges: universal salvation unjust, suffering as a tool (Phillips), immensity and unequal distribution.
  • Swinburne: natural evil gives knowledge for responsible choice.

Mission 4

  • Free will defence (Plantinga): moral good requires free creatures able to choose evil; answers the logical problem; critics: scale, victims, natural evil.
  • Process theodicy (Whitehead, Griffin): God persuades, cannot coerce, and co-suffers; critics: a God not worth worshipping, elitism, no final victory.
  • Dostoyevsky and Camus protest against justifying suffering at all.

Mission 5

  • Atheism answers what you believe; agnosticism answers what can be known. Atheism can be positive or negative; agnosticism strong or weak.
  • Secularisation is debated: decline (Bruce) or change of form (Davie, Berger).

Mission 6

  • Definitions answer two questions: what kind of event (violation or natural event) and what makes it a miracle (a real act of God, or a community's way of seeing).
  • Aquinas (three degrees beyond the usual order), Hume (transgression of a law of nature) and Swinburne (extraordinary, caused by God, religiously significant) are realist; Holland's contingency miracle is a natural coincidence taken religiously.
  • The Bible speaks of signs, wonders and mighty works: events that point to God and call for faith.

Mission 7

  • Hume: a wise person proportions belief to evidence; uniform experience always outweighs testimony to a miracle; Part II adds witnesses, susceptibility, origins and contrary claims.
  • Swinburne: violations are coherent (non-repeatable counter-instances); more evidence than testimony; contrary claims need not cancel.
  • Wiles: an intervening God would be arbitrary (Auschwitz, Hiroshima), so God acts only through the whole of creation. Hume's objection is about evidence; Wiles' is about God.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through God, atheism and the problem of evil; The problem of miracle for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why is there malaria? Is that a proof or just a problem?
  2. Mission 2If God made everything and everything God made was good, where did evil come from?
  3. Mission 3Would a world with no pain at all be a better place to grow up in?
  4. Mission 4Could God make people who are free but never choose evil? And if not, was freedom worth it?
  5. Mission 5Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?
  6. Mission 6If a train stops a few feet from a child for an ordinary reason, can it still be a miracle?
  7. Mission 7Could any amount of eyewitness evidence make it reasonable to believe a miracle happened?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA