← A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Religious Studies (A4614) · A2 7: Global issues
Mini-Lesson

Global issues

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Can a war ever be just, and who sets the rules for fighting one?
  2. Mission 2If a weapon keeps the peace only because it is never used, is owning it right or wrong?
  3. Mission 3Should punishment pay back the past or protect the future, and may a state ever take a life?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Can a war ever be just, and who sets the rules for fighting one?

Make a guess: Can a war ever be just, and who sets the rules for fighting one?

Mission 1

From pacifism to just war

How just war theory evolved106–43 BCCicero: war only to live inpeace unharmed313Constantine: Edict of Milan413–426Augustine, City of Godc. 1140Gratian's Decretum: intoChurch law13th c.Aquinas, ST II-II q. 40: threeconditionsc.1483–1546Vitoria: both sides maybelieve they are just1625Grotius, On the Law of Warand Peace1899, 1907Hague Conventions1945UN Charter1949Geneva Conventions1977Additional Protocol I;Walzer, Just and UnjustWars2005Responsibility to Protect(UN)2006Orend, The Morality of War
  • Many early Christian writers (e.g. Tertullian, Origen) opposed Christians fighting, though some Christians did serve as soldiers. Jesus taught "love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44) and told Peter, "Put your sword back into its place" (Matthew 26:52).
  • After Constantine (Edict of Milan, 313) Christians shared responsibility for the Roman Empire and its defence.
  • Augustine of Hippo (354–430), City of God (413–426): war is always a tragedy, caused by sin, but can be a duty to restore peace and punish wrong.
  • Peace is "the tranquillity of order" (City of God XIX.13, Dods translation): war is justified only as a way back to it.
  • Also cited: Romans 13:4 (the ruler "doesn't bear the sword in vain") and John the Baptist's advice to soldiers, which does not tell them to leave the army (Luke 3:14).
Mission 1Read the source

Augustine: the wise man's grief

Augustine, City of God XIX.7 (Dods translation, 1871):

> "…it is the wrong-doing of the opposing party which compels the wise man to wage just wars…"

> "As if he would not all the rather lament the necessity of just wars, if he remembers that he is a man…"

Q1 According to Augustine, what makes a war just?

Show answer

Wrongdoing by the other side, which must be resisted or punished.

Q2 Why does the wise man lament even a just war?

Show answer

It is still misery and human wrongdoing; feeling no pain at war shows a loss of human feeling.

Mission 1Read the source

Aquinas' three conditions

Aquinas' three conditionsjust warauthority1just cause2rightintention3Aquinas, ST II-II q. 40 a. 1

Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40, a. 1 (English Dominican translation):

> "In order for a war to be just, three things are necessary."

  • 1. Authority of the sovereign: only a public authority, responsible for the common good, may declare war; not a private person.
  • 2. Just cause: those attacked deserve it "on account of some fault": e.g. a wrong that must be righted.
  • 3. Right intention: to advance good and avoid evil, aiming at peace. Aquinas, quoting Augustine, condemns "the cruel thirst for vengeance" and "the lust of power".
  • The idea of double effect is traced to Aquinas (q. 64, a. 7, on killing in self-defence): an act may have two effects, only one intended.
Quick check
?A ruler with authority and a genuine grievance goes to war, but mainly to seize land and take revenge. Which of Aquinas' conditions fails?
Mission 1

Jus ad bellum: going to war

Three stages of just warbefore: jus ad bellumjust causelegitimate authorityright intentionlast resortreasonable chance of successproportionalityduring: jus in bellodiscriminationproportionality of meansno means evil in themselves (malain se)double effectafter: jus post bellumproportiondiscriminationcompensationrehabilitationwar crimes trials
  • Jus ad bellum (Latin: right to war): when is it just to start a war? Later thinkers added to Aquinas' three:
  • Just cause (e.g. self-defence against aggression); legitimate authority; right intention.
  • Last resort: peaceful means (diplomacy, sanctions) tried or clearly hopeless.
  • Reasonable chance of success: no hopeless sacrifice of lives.
  • Proportionality: the good expected must outweigh the harm war will cause.
  • Often also: public declaration, and comparative justice (one side's grievance clearly outweighs the other's).
  • The Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992) §2309 lists modern conditions in this tradition.
Mission 1

Jus in bello: fighting justly

Three stages of just warbefore: jus ad bellumjust causelegitimate authorityright intentionlast resortreasonable chance of successproportionalityduring: jus in bellodiscriminationproportionality of meansno means evil in themselves (malain se)double effectafter: jus post bellumproportiondiscriminationcompensationrehabilitationwar crimes trials
  • Jus in bello (right conduct in war): how must a war be fought? Applies to both sides, whether or not their cause is just.
  • Discrimination: distinguish combatants from non-combatants; never target civilians.
  • Proportionality of means: no more force than the military aim needs.
  • No means evil in themselves (mala in se): e.g. torture, mass rape, poison gas.
  • Double effect (Aquinas): a strike on a military target that foreseeably kills some civilians may be allowed, if the deaths are not intended, not the means to the goal, and proportionate.
Mission 1

Non-combatant immunity

The principle of distinctioncombatantsmay be targetednon-combatantsimmune: civilians,wounded, prisonershard casesdual-use targets · fighters among civilians ·dronesGeneva Conventions (1949)Additional Protocol I (1977)
  • Non-combatant immunity: civilians, wounded soldiers and prisoners may not be deliberately attacked.
  • In law: Geneva Conventions (1949) and Additional Protocol I (1977): the "principle of distinction".
  • G. E. M. Anscombe (1919–2001), "Mr Truman's Degree" (1956): she opposed Oxford honouring President Truman, because choosing to kill the innocent as a means to an end (Hiroshima, Nagasaki) is murder.
  • Problems: area bombing in the Second World War (e.g. Dresden, 1945); fighters hiding among civilians; dual-use targets (power stations, bridges); drones far from any battlefield.
  • Michael Walzer (b. 1935), Just and Unjust Wars (1977): only a "supreme emergency" might override the rule; critics say no exception should exist.
  • Spec: "the issue of non-combatant immunity".
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes jus in bello?
Mission 1

Jus post bellum: justice after war

Three stages of just warbefore: jus ad bellumjust causelegitimate authorityright intentionlast resortreasonable chance of successproportionalityduring: jus in bellodiscriminationproportionality of meansno means evil in themselves (malain se)double effectafter: jus post bellumproportiondiscriminationcompensationrehabilitationwar crimes trials
  • Jus post bellum: how should a war end, and what does the winner owe?
  • Brian Orend, The Morality of War (2006), and Walzer: a just peace should vindicate the rights that were violated, not seek revenge.
  • Principles: proportion (no humiliating, punitive peace); discrimination (punish leaders responsible, not a whole people); compensation; rehabilitation (rebuilding institutions); war crimes trials with fair procedure.
  • Examples often discussed: the Treaty of Versailles (1919), criticised as punitive; the Nuremberg trials (1945–46) and the Marshall Plan (from 1948) as models of justice and rebuilding.
  • Augustine's aim, peace as order restored, is the root of the idea.
Mission 1

How the theory evolved

How just war theory evolved106–43 BCCicero: war only to live inpeace unharmed313Constantine: Edict of Milan413–426Augustine, City of Godc. 1140Gratian's Decretum: intoChurch law13th c.Aquinas, ST II-II q. 40: threeconditionsc.1483–1546Vitoria: both sides maybelieve they are just1625Grotius, On the Law of Warand Peace1899, 1907Hague Conventions1945UN Charter1949Geneva Conventions1977Additional Protocol I;Walzer, Just and UnjustWars2005Responsibility to Protect(UN)2006Orend, The Morality of War
  • Cicero (106–43 BC): war only to live in peace unharmed.
  • Augustine (5th c.) and Gratian's Decretum (c. 1140) brought the idea into Church law; Aquinas (13th c.) set the three conditions.
  • Francisco de Vitoria (c. 1483–1546): on Spain's conquest of the Americas, both sides may sincerely believe they are just; differences of religion are no just cause.
  • Hugo Grotius (1583–1645), On the Law of War and Peace (1625): just war as international law based on natural law, binding whatever one's religion.
  • 20th century: Hague (1899, 1907) and Geneva Conventions; UN Charter (1945): force only in self-defence (Article 51) or with Security Council authority.
  • Today: Walzer (1977); "Responsibility to Protect" (UN, 2005).
Mission 1

Applying the theory to real wars

  • Applying the theory means testing each criterion with evidence, and admitting where people disagree.
  • Gulf War (1991): UN Security Council authority; aim to reverse the invasion of Kuwait; widely judged to meet jus ad bellum; debate over in bello (e.g. attacks on infrastructure).
  • Iraq War (2003): no explicit new UN authorisation; the main stated cause (weapons of mass destruction) was not borne out; Pope John Paul II and many church leaders opposed it; supporters cited earlier UN resolutions and the removal of a brutal regime.
  • Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine (2022): Ukraine's defence is claimed under self-defence (UN Charter Art. 51); questions of in bello and post bellum remain live.
Mission 1Evaluate

Is just war theory successful?

Is just war theory successful?Just war theory is successful, as a theoryand in practiceForIt sets limits states accept in law (UNCharter, Geneva Conventions); citizens andchurches can criticise their owngovernmentsIt holds together Christian love ofneighbour (protecting the innocent) andrealism about evilAgainstEvery side claims a just cause; criteria suchas "proportionality" and "last resort" arevagueModern war (bombing, drones, WMD)makes discrimination hard; pacifists say itgives war a moral coverJudge it byas a theory or in practice? · can it fit modernweapons? · who judges?
  • Claim: Just war theory is successful, as a theory and in practice.
  • For: It sets limits states accept in law (UN Charter, Geneva Conventions); it lets citizens and churches criticise their own governments.
  • For: It holds together Christian love of neighbour (protecting the innocent) and realism about evil.
  • Against: Every side claims a just cause; criteria such as "proportionality" and "last resort" are vague.
  • Against: Modern war (bombing, drones, WMD) makes discrimination hard; pacifists say it gives war a moral cover (see Mission 2).
  • Judgement criteria: Success as a theory (clear, consistent) or in practice (does it actually restrain)? Can it fit modern weapons? Who judges whether the criteria are met?
Mission 1Worked answer

Linking a scholar to a criterion

Task: explain one way Aquinas shaped the just war tradition.

  • Point: Aquinas made right intention a separate condition.
  • Source: Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40, a. 1: a war with authority and just cause can still be unlawful "through a wicked intention".
  • Develop: so motives matter: a war fought for revenge or greed is unjust even if provoked.
  • Link: this lies behind the modern ban on reprisals against civilians and on a punitive peace (jus post bellum).
Mission check

?A state uses a drone to strike an armed group's commander in a house where it knows his family is staying. It argues that their deaths are foreseen but not intended, and are proportionate to the threat. Which principle is it relying on?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a weapon keeps the peace only because it is never used, is owning it right or wrong?

Make a guess: If a weapon keeps the peace only because it is never used, is owning it right or wrong?

Mission 2

Why weapons of mass destruction are different

Weapons of mass destruction and the lawweapon typemain treatynuclearNon-Proliferation Treaty (1968);Treaty on the Prohibition ofNuclear Weapons (2017; the UKhas not joined)chemicalChemical Weapons Convention(1993)biologicalBiological Weapons Convention(1972)The jus in bello problemcannot discriminate between soldiers andcivilians · harm hard to call proportionate
  • WMD: nuclear, chemical, biological and radiological weapons, able to kill vast numbers at once.
  • Hiroshima (6 August 1945) and Nagasaki (9 August 1945): the only nuclear weapons used in war.
  • Effects: blast and fire over whole cities; radiation sickness and cancers for decades; possible "nuclear winter" after a large exchange.
  • So they struggle to meet jus in bello: they cannot discriminate between soldiers and civilians, and their harm is hard to call proportionate.
  • Law: Biological Weapons Convention (1972); Chemical Weapons Convention (1993); Non-Proliferation Treaty (1968); Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (2017; the UK and other nuclear states have not joined).
  • Second Vatican Council (Gaudium et Spes, 1965, §80): any act of war aimed at destroying whole cities is a crime against God and humanity (paraphrase).
Mission 2

Deterrence: the peace of fear

DeterrenceState AState Bthreat ofretaliationMADmutually assured destructionpeace kept?act utilitarian(Bentham)weigh likelypleasures and pains:decades of peace v asmall chance ofcatastropheparadox ofdeterrencecan it be right tothreaten what wouldbe wrong to do?
  • Deterrence: possessing nuclear weapons, ready to use them, so that no enemy dares attack. MAD (mutually assured destruction): each side could destroy the other.
  • Bentham (act utilitarian): weigh this policy's likely pleasures and pains: peace kept for decades (extent, duration) against a small chance of catastrophic suffering (intensity).
  • Mill (rule utilitarian): which general rule maximises happiness: "Possess, never use first" or "abolish"?
  • The paradox of deterrence: if using the weapons would be wrong, can it be right to intend or threaten to use them?
  • Catholic teaching moved: John Paul II (1982) judged deterrence acceptable only as a step towards disarmament; Pope Francis (Hiroshima, 2019) called even the possession of nuclear weapons immoral.
Quick check
?How would a rule utilitarian assess nuclear deterrence?
Mission 2Read the source

The way of peace

> "But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also." (Matthew 5:39, WEBBE)

> "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." (Matthew 5:9, WEBBE)

> "They shall beat their swords into ploughshares, and their spears into pruning hooks. Nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more." (Isaiah 2:4, WEBBE)

Q1 Which text do absolute pacifists cite for non-retaliation?

Show answer

Matthew 5:39: turning the other cheek.

Q2 How might a just war Christian read Matthew 5:39?

Show answer

As a rule for personal insults, not for rulers protecting others, citing Romans 13:4.

Mission 2

Absolute pacifism

Kinds of pacifismAbsolute pacifismall war and lethal violence is wrong (Quakers1660, Mennonites, Tolstoy)Relative (contingent) pacifismwar is wrong in almost every caseSelective pacifismrefusing to fight in particular wars judgedunjustNuclear pacifismany war using nuclear (or other massdestruction) weapons is wrongCriticism: Niebuhr (1940)love sometimes requires force against tyrannynuclear pacifism can be held by a just warthinker: it applies the theory, rather thanrejecting it
  • Absolute pacifism: all war and lethal violence is wrong, whatever the cause.
  • Quakers (Religious Society of Friends): the Peace Testimony, from their declaration to Charles II (1660), renouncing outward wars and fighting for any end.
  • Anabaptist churches (Mennonites, Amish): non-resistance, from the Sermon on the Mount.
  • Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910), The Kingdom of God Is Within You (1894): Jesus' command not to resist evil by force applies to states too.
  • Others root nonviolence in other traditions: Gandhi's ahimsa (non-harm) and satyagraha (holding to truth).
  • Criticisms: it may leave the innocent unprotected; Reinhold Niebuhr (1892–1971), "Why the Christian Church Is Not Pacifist" (1940): love sometimes requires force against tyranny.
Mission 2

Relative, selective and nuclear pacifism

Kinds of pacifismAbsolute pacifismall war and lethal violence is wrong (Quakers1660, Mennonites, Tolstoy)Relative (contingent) pacifismwar is wrong in almost every caseSelective pacifismrefusing to fight in particular wars judgedunjustNuclear pacifismany war using nuclear (or other massdestruction) weapons is wrongCriticism: Niebuhr (1940)love sometimes requires force against tyrannynuclear pacifism can be held by a just warthinker: it applies the theory, rather thanrejecting it
  • Relative (contingent) pacifism: war is wrong in almost every case; force may be used only rarely, e.g. as a police action or to stop genocide.
  • Selective pacifism: refusing to fight in particular wars judged unjust (e.g. some objectors to the Vietnam War).
  • Nuclear pacifism: any war using nuclear (or other mass destruction) weapons is wrong, because such weapons can never meet discrimination and proportionality.
  • Nuclear pacifism can be held by a just war thinker: it applies the theory, rather than rejecting it.
  • Some textbooks use "selective pacifism" for opposing only wars that use weapons of mass destruction; check your class notes.
Mission 2

Pacifist movements and pressure groups

  • Fellowship of Reconciliation (1914): Christian pacifists across denominations.
  • Conscientious objectors in the First World War: the Military Service Act (1916) allowed exemptions on grounds of conscience; many objectors were imprisoned.
  • Peace Pledge Union: grew from Dick Sheppard's 1934 pledge to renounce war (named 1936).
  • Pax Christi (1945): Catholic peace movement; CND (Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, 1958), with Bertrand Russell as first president.
  • ICAN (International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons): Nobel Peace Prize 2017, after the nuclear ban treaty.
  • Role: shaping law (conscience clauses, treaties), public opinion and support for objectors.
Quick check
?A Christian says: "I would fight to defend my country from invasion, but I refuse to serve in any war that relies on nuclear weapons." Which position is this?
Mission 2

Can pacifism work?

Can nonviolence work?often cited successesIndianindependence(1947)US civil rightsmovement1989 revolutions inCentral Europe (e.g.Solidarity)Northern Ireland:Good FridayAgreement (1998)hard casesNazi GermanyRwandan genocide(1994)
  • Successes of nonviolence: Indian independence (1947); the US civil rights movement; Poland's Solidarity and the 1989 revolutions in Central Europe.
  • Northern Ireland: churches, peace groups and politicians helped build the peace process leading to the Good Friday (Belfast) Agreement (1998).
  • Research by Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan, Why Civil Resistance Works (2011), argues that nonviolent campaigns have often succeeded more than violent ones.
  • Hard cases: Nazi Germany; the Rwandan genocide (1994): could nonviolence have stopped them?
  • Pacifists reply: war's costs are always underestimated; nonviolent methods are rarely given the resources that war receives.
Mission 2Evaluate

Can nuclear deterrence be justified?

Can nuclear deterrence be justified?Possessing nuclear weapons as a deterrentis morally justifiedForNo war between the major nuclear powerssince 1945 (supporters credit deterrence);the act utilitarian calculation may favour itOne-sided disarmament could inviteblackmail; just war thinkers accept defenceof the innocentAgainstIt depends on a readiness to kill millions ofcivilians: the paradox of deterrence;nuclear pacifists and Pope Francis judgepossession itself wrongAccidents, false alarms and proliferation: asmall risk each year adds up over decadesJudge it byis it wrong to intend what it would be wrongto do? · how to weigh tiny risks ofcatastrophe? · realistic paths to disarmament?
  • Claim: Possessing nuclear weapons as a deterrent is morally justified.
  • For: No war between the major nuclear powers since 1945 (supporters credit deterrence); the act utilitarian calculation may favour it.
  • For: One-sided disarmament could invite blackmail; just war thinkers accept defence of the innocent.
  • Against: It depends on a readiness to kill millions of civilians: the paradox of deterrence; nuclear pacifists and Pope Francis judge possession itself wrong.
  • Against: Accidents, false alarms and proliferation: a small risk each year adds up over decades.
  • Judgement criteria: Is it wrong to intend what it would be wrong to do? How should tiny risks of catastrophe be weighed? Are there realistic paths to disarmament?
Quick check
?Which statement about the Quaker Peace Testimony is accurate?
Mission check

?A country keeps chemical weapons only as a deterrent and promises never to use them first. A critic says: "Even if this has kept the peace, it is wrong, because the policy depends on being willing to do something that is always wrong." Which position is the critic taking?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Should punishment pay back the past or protect the future, and may a state ever take a life?

Make a guess: Should punishment pay back the past or protect the future, and may a state ever take a life?

Mission 3

Five purposes of punishment

Looking back, looking forwardpastfuturethe crimelooks backlooks forwardretributionwhat the offenderdeservesvindicationupholds the law;mainlybackward-lookingbut publicalso affirms rights nowdeterrencediscourage thisoffender and othersprotectionkeep the public saferehabilitationhelp the offenderchangeKant: desertBentham: consequences
  • Retribution: the offender gets what they deserve; punishment fits the crime. Looks back.
  • Deterrence: discourage this offender (individual) and others (general) from crime. Looks forward.
  • Protection: keep the public safe from a dangerous offender.
  • Rehabilitation (reform): help the offender change and return to society.
  • Vindication: uphold the authority of the law and publicly affirm the rights that were violated.
  • Retributive theories (e.g. Kant) look back to guilt; utilitarian theories (e.g. Bentham) look forward to consequences.
Mission 3Read the source

Justice and mercy in the Bible

> "Whoever sheds man's blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image." (Genesis 9:6, WEBBE)

> "You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil…" (Matthew 5:38–39, WEBBE)

> "…he doesn't bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." (Romans 13:4, WEBBE)

  • "Eye for eye" (Exodus 21:24) limited revenge: no more than the harm done (lex talionis).

Q1 Which text grounds the state's right to punish?

Show answer

Romans 13:4: the ruler as God's servant.

Q2 Why might the same reason in Genesis 9:6, the image of God, be used against the death penalty today?

Show answer

The offender, too, bears God's image and keeps a dignity that should not be destroyed.

Mission 3Diversity

Christian views on punishment

  • Augustine and Aquinas: the state may punish, even with death, for the common good; punishment can also be medicinal, aimed at the offender's good.
  • Catholic teaching (Catechism §2266): punishment redresses the disorder caused, protects public order and safety, and should help correct the offender.
  • Quakers: emphasis on reform; Elizabeth Fry (1780–1845) campaigned for humane prisons.
  • Evangelicals vary: some support retribution from Genesis 9:6 and Romans 13; Prison Fellowship (founded 1976) works for reform and restoration.
  • Restorative justice: offender meets victim, takes responsibility and makes amends; supported by many churches, rooted in reconciliation (2 Corinthians 5:18).
  • Most Christians agree punishment must respect the offender's dignity; they differ on how much weight retribution carries.
Quick check
?A judge gives a long sentence, saying: "The public must see that the law means what it says, and the victim's rights must be publicly affirmed." Which purpose is the judge appealing to?
Mission 3

Moral responsibility and diminished responsibility

  • Punishment assumes moral responsibility: the offender acted freely and knew right from wrong.
  • Libertarian: free choice makes retribution deserved. Hard determinist: no one truly deserves punishment, though deterrence and reform may still be useful. Compatibilist: punish uncoerced acts.
  • Diminished responsibility (Homicide Act 1957, s. 2, in England and Wales; Criminal Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1966, s. 5): an abnormality of mental functioning that substantially impairs a person's responsibility reduces murder to manslaughter.
  • Also: insanity (the M'Naghten Rules, 1843); the age of criminal responsibility (10 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland).
  • Christian view: guilt depends on knowledge and freedom; the Catechism (§1735) says responsibility can be diminished by ignorance, fear, habit and other factors.
Mission 3

Capital punishment: the debate

Capital punishment in the UK1950Timothy Evans hanged1953Derek Bentley hanged1957Homicide Act (diminishedresponsibility)1964last executions1965abolished for murder (madepermanent 1969)1966Evans pardoned1973Northern Ireland1998abolished for all crimes1998Bentley's conviction quashed
  • UK: last executions 1964; abolished for murder 1965 (made permanent 1969; Northern Ireland 1973); abolished for all crimes 1998.
  • For: retribution (Kant: justice requires the murderer's death, Metaphysics of Morals, 1797); deterrence; permanent protection; justice for victims' families.
  • For: John Stuart Mill (1868 speech in Parliament) supported it for the worst murders as more humane than lifelong imprisonment.
  • Against: irreversible errors (Timothy Evans, hanged 1950, pardoned 1966; Derek Bentley, hanged 1953, conviction quashed 1998).
  • Against: deterrent effect disputed; ends any chance of reform; risk of unequal application; the sanctity and dignity of every life.
Mission 3

Natural moral law applied

Three theories and capital punishmentNatural lawAquinas: allowed for the common good, bypublic authority only (ST II-II q. 64 a. 2)Catechism §2267 (2018): inadmissibleSituation ethicsagape: the most loving act for everyone?personalism: the person over the lawrelativism: no absolute ruleVirtue ethicsjustice: give each their dueequity: correct the rule where it fits badlymercyvengeance driven by anger: a vice
  • Aquinas (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 64, a. 2): a dangerous offender is like a diseased limb: "it is praiseworthy and advantageous that he be killed in order to safeguard the common good". Only public authority may do this.
  • Primary precepts: preserve life and live in an ordered society: Aquinas saw the death penalty as serving both.
  • Development: John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae (1995) §56: cases where execution is truly necessary are "very rare, if not practically non-existent".
  • Catechism §2267 (revised 2018): the death penalty is inadmissible, because it attacks the dignity of the person; modern prisons can protect society.
  • Debate: does this develop natural law (the common good now met without killing), or contradict Aquinas?
Mission 3

Situation ethics and virtue ethics applied

Three theories and capital punishmentNatural lawAquinas: allowed for the common good, bypublic authority only (ST II-II q. 64 a. 2)Catechism §2267 (2018): inadmissibleSituation ethicsagape: the most loving act for everyone?personalism: the person over the lawrelativism: no absolute ruleVirtue ethicsjustice: give each their dueequity: correct the rule where it fits badlymercyvengeance driven by anger: a vice
  • Situation ethics: is execution the most loving act for everyone: offender, victims, society? Personalism favours the person over the law.
  • Most situationists oppose it: it ends any chance of repentance, and errors cannot be undone. But relativism means no absolute rule: an extreme case is not ruled out in principle.
  • Virtue ethics: what would a just and merciful person do? Aristotle: justice gives each their due; equity corrects the law where its general rule fits a case badly (Nicomachean Ethics V.10).
  • Vengeance driven by anger is a vice (excess); indifference to victims is a deficiency.
  • Virtue ethicists divide: some see execution as just desert; many see it as failing in mercy and practical wisdom.
Mission 3

Utilitarianism applied

  • Bentham: all punishment is itself an evil (pain); it is justified only if it prevents greater evil (Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, 1789, paraphrase).
  • So no punishment where it is groundless, ineffective, unprofitable or needless: e.g. punishing the insane does not deter.
  • On capital punishment, Bentham argued against it (e.g. 1831): it is irreversible and less effective than other penalties.
  • Mill disagreed (1868): for the worst crimes, a swift death may deter more and cause less suffering than life in prison.
  • Rule utilitarian: which general rule, given the risk of wrongful execution, maximises happiness?
  • Criticism: utilitarianism might justify punishing an innocent person if it deterred others: a challenge to justice.
Quick check
?Which statement about natural law and capital punishment is accurate?
Mission 3

Compassion and mercy

  • Mercy: holding back punishment that is deserved, out of compassion. Not the same as excusing the crime.
  • "Therefore be merciful, even as your Father is also merciful." (Luke 6:36, WEBBE); "He who is without sin amongst you, let him throw the first stone at her." (John 8:7, WEBBE)
  • Shakespeare's Portia: "The quality of mercy is not strained" (The Merchant of Venice, IV.1): mercy "seasons" justice.
  • In law: the Royal Prerogative of Mercy; compassionate release of terminally ill prisoners; judges' discretion in sentencing.
  • Forgiveness by victims is a personal choice, not something the law can demand; after the Enniskillen bombing (1987), Gordon Wilson publicly said he bore no ill will to the bombers.
  • Critics: mercy can seem unfair to victims or to other offenders treated more harshly.
Mission 3Evaluate

Can capital punishment ever be justified?

Can capital punishment ever be justified?Capital punishment can be morally justifiedfor the worst crimesForRetribution: some crimes deserve death(Kant); Aquinas allowed it for the commongoodIt may deter and permanently protects;Mill thought it more humane than lifeimprisonmentAgainstIrreversible errors (Evans, Bentley);deterrence unprovenHuman dignity (Catechism §2267, 2018);Finnis: intending death is always wrong;no room for reform or mercyJudge it bybackward- or forward-looking? · can the statebe trusted with irreversible power? · doesdignity belong to offenders too?
  • Claim: Capital punishment can be morally justified for the worst crimes.
  • For: Retribution: some crimes deserve death (Kant); Aquinas allowed it for the common good.
  • For: It may deter and permanently protects; Mill thought it more humane than life imprisonment.
  • Against: Irreversible errors (Evans, Bentley); deterrence unproven.
  • Against: Human dignity (Catechism §2267, 2018); Finnis: intending death is always wrong; no room for reform or mercy.
  • Judgement criteria: Is punishment mainly backward- or forward-looking? Can the state be trusted with irreversible power? Does dignity belong to offenders too?
Mission check

?A man serving life for murder is terminally ill after 25 years in prison and asks for compassionate release. The victim's family say: "He must serve the full sentence because of what he did, whatever good his release might do." Which purpose of punishment are they appealing to?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Augustine: war is a tragic duty to restore peace (the tranquillity of order); Aquinas: authority, just cause, right intention.
  • Jus ad bellum (going to war), jus in bello (discrimination, proportion, double effect, non-combatant immunity) and jus post bellum (a just peace).
  • The theory grew from church teaching into international law (Vitoria, Grotius, UN Charter, Geneva); its success depends on clear criteria and honest judges.

Mission 2

  • WMD struggle to meet discrimination and proportionality; deterrence rests on a threat that raises the paradox of intending a wrong act.
  • Pacifism: absolute (Quakers, Tolstoy), relative/selective, nuclear; movements (FoR, PPU, Pax Christi, CND, ICAN) and its practicality are debated.

Mission 3

  • Five purposes: retribution, deterrence, protection, rehabilitation, vindication; responsibility (and diminished responsibility) shapes what is deserved.
  • Capital punishment: Aquinas allowed it for the common good; Catholic teaching now calls it inadmissible; SE and VE ask about love, justice and mercy; Bentham and Mill disagreed.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Global issues for CCEA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Can a war ever be just, and who sets the rules for fighting one?
  2. Mission 2If a weapon keeps the peace only because it is never used, is owning it right or wrong?
  3. Mission 3Should punishment pay back the past or protect the future, and may a state ever take a life?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · CCEA