4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Make a guess: Is "do the most loving thing" a guide anyone can use, or does it ask too much of us?
William Barclay (1907–1978), Scottish New Testament scholar, Ethics in a Permissive Society (1971), chapter 4 (paraphrase):
Q1 What does Barclay accept from Fletcher?
Love is central; legalism is wrong.
Q2 Why does he think law is still needed?
Most people do not want total freedom; rules train us, and freedom without love becomes licence.
Barclay's challenge is not that love is wrong. It is that ordinary people need rules to learn to love well. Weigh that against Fletcher's hard cases.
Make a guess: Can you practise being brave the way you practise the piano?
Q1 According to Aristotle, which comes first: just acts or a just character?
Just acts, repeated until they become a settled character.
Q2 Why does the stone example matter?
It shows virtues are not natural instincts; they must be formed.
Task: explain Aristotle's doctrine of the mean.
Courage is trained like a skill, but it is not "more is better": it is the right response, done until it becomes your character. Next: who revived virtue ethics, and can it guide hard choices?
Make a guess: If a bank robber is brave, is bravery still a virtue?
For Aristotle, a "virtue" aimed at a bad end is not a virtue at all; critics still ask whether that reply makes the theory hard to use in real dilemmas. Next: virtue ethics in action on theft and lying.
Make a guess: Is it ever right to steal bread to survive, or to lie to protect a friend?
Task: explain how situation ethics might be applied to lying.
The same promise, lie or theft can be judged three different ways: by the purpose of the act, by love in the situation, or by what it shows and shapes in character.
Mission 1
Mission 2
Mission 3
Mission 4
You've worked through Normative ethical theories (part 2) for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Your stars: 0 / 0