← A-Level Religious Studies · AQA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2E Judaism – Self, death and afterlife
Mini-Lesson

Judaism: Self, death and afterlife

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1What are humans for? What does Judaism say the point of a life is?
  2. Mission 2How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?
  3. Mission 3The early Hebrew Bible says little about heaven. Where did Jewish hope of life after death come from?
  4. Mission 4Some Jewish mystics say a soul can return to finish unfinished work. Where does that idea come from?
Mission 1

Mission 1: What are humans for? What does Judaism say the point of a life is?

Make a guess: What are humans for? What does Judaism say the point of a life is?

Mission 1

Made in the image of God

Made in the image of Godtzelem Elohim ("image of God")reasonmoral freedomcreativityrelating to Godnot a body shape: God has none
  • "And God created man in His own image, in the image of God created He him; male and female created He them." (Genesis 1:27, JPS 1917)
  • Tzelem Elohim ("image of God"): not a body shape (God has none) but human reason, moral freedom, creativity and the ability to relate to God.
  • Every person has equal and infinite worth: humanity began with one person, so "whoever saves a single life saves a whole world" (Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5, paraphrase).
  • So how a person treats others is part of how they honour God.
Mission 1

Two inclinations

Two inclinationsheartyetzer hatov(good)yetzer hara(selfish)Torah and mitzvot"Love the LORD thy God with all thyheart"with both inclinations (Mishnah Berakhot9:5)
  • Every person has a yetzer hatov (good inclination) and a yetzer hara (evil, or selfish, inclination).
  • The Torah: "the imagination of man's heart is evil from his youth" (Genesis 8:21, JPS 1917). Hebrew yetzer = "imagination", "inclination".
  • The yetzer hara is not evil in itself: a midrash says without it no one would build a house, marry or have children (Genesis Rabbah 9:7).
  • The task is to direct it, not destroy it. "Love the LORD thy God with all thy heart": with both inclinations (Mishnah Berakhot 9:5).
  • Torah and the mitzvot train the yetzer hatov; it is said to mature at bar/bat mitzvah age.
  • No original sin: each person is born free to choose. "Therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19).
Mission 1

Purpose 1: obedience

ObedienceDeuteronomy 10:12fear · walk in His ways · love · serve613 mitzvot: ritual and ethicaleatingworkingrestingfamilybusinessordinary life made holyBlessing: "who has made us holy with hiscommandments"
  • "what doth the LORD thy God require of thee, but to fear the LORD thy God, to walk in all His ways, and to love Him, and to serve the LORD thy God with all thy heart and with all thy soul" (Deuteronomy 10:12, JPS 1917).
  • "fear God, and keep His commandments; for this is the whole man." (Ecclesiastes 12:13, JPS 1917)
  • Obedience means keeping the 613 mitzvot of the covenant: ritual and ethical.
  • The mitzvot make ordinary life holy: eating, working, resting, family, business.
  • Obedience is an act of love, not just duty: Jews bless God "who has made us holy with his commandments".
  • For Orthodox Jews this is often seen as the primary purpose: the others follow from it.
Mission 1

Purpose 2: repairing the world

Tikkun olam: layersIn prayerAleinu: "to perfect the world under thekingdom of the Almighty" (paraphrase)In Mishnah lawrulings "for the sake of tikkun ha-olam" (socialorder), Mishnah Gittin 4Kabbalah: Isaac Luria (1534–1572)divine light scattered in sparks at creation;each mitzvah helps gather themTodaysocial justice and environmental work,especially in Reform and Liberal Judaism;humans as partners with God
  • Tikkun olam: "repair of the world".
  • In prayer: the Aleinu hopes "to perfect the world under the kingdom of the Almighty" (paraphrase).
  • In Mishnah law: some rulings are made "for the sake of tikkun ha-olam" (social order) (Mishnah Gittin 4).
  • In Kabbalah: Isaac Luria (1534–1572): at creation, divine light was scattered in sparks; each mitzvah helps gather them, repairing the world.
  • Today: especially in Reform and Liberal Judaism, social justice and environmental work.
  • Humans, made in God's image, are partners with God in completing creation.
Mission 1

Purpose 3: bringing the Messiah

The Messianic AgeMashiach: a human descendant of King Davidexiles gatheredto IsraelTemple rebuiltpeaceIsaiah 2:4knowledge of GodIsaiah 11:9ViewThe Messianic AgeMaimonidesworld keeps its normalcourse; political and spiritualchangeOthersmiraculous change of nature,then resurrection of the deadReligiousZionists (Kook)State of Israel (1948): "thebeginning of the flowering ofredemption"Some Haredigroupsoppose a state before theMessiahReforman age of justice and peace byhuman effort; no personalMessiah
  • Mashiach ("anointed one"): a human descendant of King David, not a divine being. Maimonides' 12th Principle: Jews await his coming.
  • The Messianic Age: peace ("nation shall not lift up sword against nation", Isaiah 2:4, JPS 1917); exiles gathered to Israel; Temple rebuilt; the earth "full of the knowledge of the LORD" (Isaiah 11:9).
  • Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11–12): the world will follow its normal course; the change is political and spiritual, not supernatural.
  • Others: a miraculous transformation of nature, followed by the resurrection of the dead.
  • Human part: if Israel kept two Shabbats properly, they would be redeemed at once (Talmud, Shabbat 118b, paraphrase). Chabad Hasidim stress hastening the Messiah through mitzvot.
  • Diversity: Religious Zionists, following Rav Abraham Isaac Kook (1865–1935), see the State of Israel (founded 1948) as "the beginning of the flowering of redemption" (Prayer for the State of Israel); some Haredi groups oppose a state before the Messiah; Reform hopes for a Messianic Age of justice and peace brought by human effort, without a personal Messiah (Pittsburgh Platform, 1885).
Quick check
?Which view of the Messianic Age did Maimonides hold?
Mission 1Evaluate

Is obedience the most important purpose of life?

Is obedience the most important purpose?Claim: for Jews, obedience to God'scommandments is the most importantpurpose of life.ForThe Torah sums up life as keeping thecommandments (Deuteronomy 10:12–13;Ecclesiastes 12:13).Tikkun olam happens through the mitzvot,so obedience comes first.Bringing the Messiah also depends onkeeping the mitzvot.AgainstMany Reform and secular Jews putrepairing the world first; ritual obedienceis optional for them.Love of God and neighbour may be thedeeper aim; obedience is the means.Judge it byCan the purposes be ranked, or do theydepend on each other? · Which Jewishmovement's view is weighed? · Is "mostimportant" about time, value, or what Godcommands?
  • Claim: For Jews, obedience to God's commandments is the most important purpose of life.
  • For: The Torah sums up life as keeping the commandments (Deuteronomy 10:12–13; Ecclesiastes 12:13).
  • For: Tikkun olam happens through the mitzvot, so obedience comes first.
  • For: Bringing the Messiah also depends on keeping the mitzvot.
  • Against: Many Reform and secular Jews put repairing the world first; ritual obedience is optional for them.
  • Against: Love of God and neighbour may be the deeper aim; obedience is the means.
  • Judgement criteria: Can the purposes be ranked, or do they depend on each other? Which Jewish movement's view is weighed? Is "most important" about time, value, or what God commands?
Mission check

?On Tu Bishvat, a Jewish youth group plants trees and says it is doing "tikkun olam". Which idea best explains how many Jews link this to the purpose of life?
Mission 2

Mission 2: How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?

Make a guess: How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?

Mission 2

Mashiach: the anointed one

  • Messiah comes from Hebrew mashiach, "anointed": a person marked with oil for a task God gives.
  • In the Tanakh, kings and priests were anointed: "Samuel took the horn of oil, and anointed him" (1 Samuel 16:13, JPS 1917), of David.
  • Even the Persian king Cyrus is called "His anointed" (Isaiah 45:1, JPS 1917) for freeing the exiles.
  • Later hope focused on one future king from David's line: the King Messiah (Melekh ha-Mashiach).
  • He is a human being, not divine; Jews pray for him, they do not pray to him.
Mission 2Read the source

Swords into plowshares

Swords into plowsharesswordspearplowsharepruning hookMicah 4:3 · almost the same in Isaiah 2:4vinefig treeMicah 4:4 only

> "they shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruninghooks; nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more." (Micah 4:3, JPS 1917; almost the same in Isaiah 2:4)

> "But they shall sit every man under his vine and under his fig-tree; and none shall make them afraid" (Micah 4:4, JPS 1917)

  • Isaiah 2:2–4 and Micah 4:1–3 share one vision: "in the end of days" all nations stream to "the mountain of the LORD'S house" in Jerusalem to learn God's ways.
  • "For out of Zion shall go forth the law" (Isaiah 2:3, JPS 1917).

Q1 What do the nations do with their weapons?

Show answer

Turn them into farm tools: war ends.

Q2 What does Micah add to Isaiah's picture?

Show answer

Each person safe under their own vine and fig tree, with no one to make them afraid.

Mission 2

The Messianic Age in the prophets

  • A king of David's line: "a shoot out of the stock of Jesse" (Isaiah 11:1, JPS 1917), filled with God's spirit.
  • Judge: God "shall judge between the nations" (Isaiah 2:4); the king judges the poor "with righteousness" (Isaiah 11:4).
  • Ingathering: God "will assemble the dispersed of Israel" (Isaiah 11:12, JPS 1917).
  • Temple rebuilt; Jerusalem a centre of worship for all nations.
  • Knowledge of God: "the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD, as the waters cover the sea" (Isaiah 11:9, JPS 1917).
  • Herald: Elijah, before "the great and terrible day of the LORD" (Malachi 4:5, JPS 1917; 3:23 in Hebrew).
Quick check
?Which detail appears in Micah 4 but not in Isaiah 2?
Mission 2

Maimonides on the Messiah

Maimonides' test for the MessiahA king of David's line; studies Torah;keeps the mitzvotpresumed MessiahRebuilds the Temple? Gathers theexiles?Yescertainly the MessiahFails or is killednot the MessiahLaws of Kings 11:4Side noteNo miracles needed; nature unchanged: "theworld follows its normal course"Laws of Kings 12:1
  • Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings, chapters 11–12 (paraphrase):
  • Who: a king from the house of David, who studies Torah, keeps the mitzvot and leads Israel to keep them.
  • Test: if he rebuilds the Temple and gathers the exiles, he is certainly the Messiah. If he fails or is killed, he was not.
  • He need not work miracles.
  • Nature unchanged: "the world follows its normal course"; the wolf lying with the lamb (Isaiah 11:6) is a metaphor for peace among nations.
  • Purpose: not power or pleasure, but freedom to study Torah and know God.
  • Do not calculate the date. (Principle 12: wait for him.)
Mission 2

Bringing the Messiah: a purpose of life

  • AQA's three purposes: obedience to God's commandments; bringing the Messiah; repairing the world (tikkun olam).
  • The Talmud links them: asked when he will come, the Messiah answers "To-day, if ye would but hearken to His voice!" (Psalm 95:7, JPS 1917, cited in Sanhedrin 98a).
  • So keeping mitzvot is active waiting: each good deed brings redemption nearer.
  • Tikkun olam: working for justice and peace prepares the world for the Messianic Age.
  • Relative importance: many Orthodox Jews put obedience first (the Messiah comes through Torah); many Progressive Jews put tikkun olam first (people build the Messianic Age).
Mission 2Diversity

Orthodox and Progressive today

Views of the Messiah todaypersonal MessiahChabad Hasidimcampaign to hasten the Messiah throughmitzvotOrthodoxa personal Messiah of David's lineReligious Zioniststhe return to the Land: "the beginning ofredemption"Masorti / Conservativehope affirmed; person or symbol leftopenReforma Messianic Age, not a personMessianic AgeOff the line: some Haredi groups (e.g.Satmar)a human-made state forces the end; only theMessiah should restore IsraelNot a ranking
  • Orthodox: a personal Messiah of David's line; the Amidah prays daily for "the sprout of David"; principle 12 in Ani Ma'amin.
  • Chabad Hasidim: campaign to hasten the Messiah through mitzvot.
  • Religious Zionists (Rav Kook, 1865–1935): the return to the Land is "the beginning of redemption".
  • Some Haredi groups (e.g. Satmar): a human-made state forces the end; only the Messiah should restore Israel.
  • Reform: the Pittsburgh Platform (1885) spoke of "the establishment of the kingdom of truth, justice, and peace among all men": a Messianic Age, not a person. Reform prayer books replaced "redeemer" with "redemption".
  • Masorti / Conservative: the Messianic hope affirmed; whether a person or a symbol is left open.
Quick check
?Which view would most Reform Jews hold about the Messiah?
Mission check

?A leader of David's line rallies thousands to free Jerusalem from an empire, wins early battles and is then killed. His followers had called him the Messiah. How would a Jew following Maimonides judge the claim?
Mission 3

Mission 3: The early Hebrew Bible says little about heaven. Where did Jewish hope of life after death come from?

Make a guess: The early Hebrew Bible says little about heaven. Where did Jewish hope of life after death come from?

Mission 3

She'ol: the place of the dead

  • In most of the Tenakh, the dead go down to She'ol: a dark, silent place under the earth.
  • Everyone goes there, righteous and wicked alike: Jacob says he will "go down to the grave to my son mourning" (Genesis 37:35, JPS 1917; Hebrew She'ol).
  • It is a place of shades, cut off from praise: "For in death there is no remembrance of Thee; in the nether-world who will give Thee thanks?" (Psalm 6:5, JPS 1917)
  • No reward, no punishment: "there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave" (Ecclesiastes 9:10, JPS 1917).
  • So the early focus is this life: blessing, long life, children, land.
Mission 3Read the source

Saul and Samuel at En-dor

She'ol: the place of the deadthe earthShe'olall the deadEn-dor1 Samuel 28:13"coming up out of the earth"1 Samuel 28:13, JPS 1917

1 Samuel 28:11–20 (JPS 1917). Before a battle, God no longer answers Saul. He has banned those who call up the dead, but now visits a woman at En-dor.

> "I see a godlike being coming up out of the earth." (1 Samuel 28:13, JPS 1917)

> "And Samuel said to Saul: 'Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up?'" (1 Samuel 28:15, JPS 1917)

  • Samuel repeats God's judgement on Saul and adds: "to-morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me" (1 Samuel 28:19, JPS 1917).
  • The dead exist, keep their identity and memory, and are below.
  • Calling them up is forbidden (Deuteronomy 18:10–11).

Q1 Where does Samuel come from?

Show answer

Up out of the earth: She'ol.

Q2 What does "be with me" suggest about where righteous and wicked go?

Show answer

The same place: Samuel and Saul alike.

Quick check
?What does 1 Samuel 28 suggest about the dead?
Mission 3

The soul

  • Nefesh: life, a living being. God breathed "the breath of life; and man became a living soul" (Genesis 2:7, JPS 1917).
  • Ruach: spirit, wind; neshamah: breath, later the highest level of the soul.
  • At death: "the dust returneth to the earth as it was, and the spirit returneth unto God who gave it" (Ecclesiastes 12:7, JPS 1917).
  • Each morning Jews pray: the soul God gave is pure, and God will one day take it and restore it (Talmud Berakhot 60b, paraphrase).
  • The rabbis held body and soul together: a lame man and a blind man rob an orchard together, and are judged together (Sanhedrin 91a–b, paraphrase).
Mission 3

Resurrection of the dead

Afterlife: how the ideas developedearly TenakhShe'ol: all the dead go down2nd centuryBCEDaniel 12:2: resurrection (onmany scholars' dating)c. 200 CEMishnah: resurrection; olamha-ba; Gan Eden, Gehinnomc. 1168Maimonides: principle 13,resurrection16th centuryIsaac Luria: gilgul1885Pittsburgh Platform(American Reform):immortality of the soul only

> "And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to reproaches and everlasting abhorrence." (Daniel 12:2, JPS 1917)

  • Also: "Thy dead shall live, my dead bodies shall arise" (Isaiah 26:19, JPS 1917); Ezekiel's dry bones (Ezekiel 37), first about the nation's revival.
  • The Pharisees taught resurrection; the Sadducees denied it.
  • The Mishnah: whoever says resurrection is not taught in the Torah has no share in the world to come (Sanhedrin 10:1, paraphrase).
  • Daily Amidah: God "revives the dead" (mechayeh ha-metim).
  • Thirteen Principles: principle 13, resurrection of the flesh.
  • Modern attitudes: Orthodox Jews affirm a literal, bodily resurrection (one reason for burial, not cremation); many Progressive Jews do not.
Mission 3

Judgement, olam ha-ba, Gan Eden, Gehinnom

  • Judgement: each soul is judged after death; the final judgement follows the resurrection.
  • Olam ha-ba: "the world to come": the realm of souls after death, or the renewed world after resurrection (sources use both).
  • "This world is like a vestibule before the world to come" (Pirkei Avot 4:16, paraphrase): life now prepares for it.
  • Gan Eden (paradise): the reward of the righteous.
  • Gehinnom (Gehenna): named after the valley of Hinnom, outside Jerusalem (Jeremiah 7:31); a place of purification, mostly for at most twelve months (Mishnah Eduyot 2:10).
  • So mourners say Kaddish for eleven months, not twelve.
  • "The righteous of all nations have a share in the world to come" (Tosefta Sanhedrin 13:2, paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement about Gehinnom fits mainstream rabbinic teaching?
Mission 3

Immortality of the soul and the Pittsburgh Platform

  • Later Jewish thought stressed the immortal soul: medieval philosophers (Saadia, Maimonides) and Moses Mendelssohn, whose Phaedon (1767) argued for immortality as endless moral growth.
  • Pittsburgh Platform (American Reform, 1885), paragraph 7:
  • "We reassert the doctrine of Judaism that the soul is immortal" (Pittsburgh Platform, 1885).
  • It rejects "the beliefs both in bodily resurrection and in Gehenna and Eden (Hell and Paradise) as abodes for everlasting punishment and reward" (Pittsburgh Platform, 1885).
  • Reform prayer books changed "who revives the dead" to "who gives life to all" (mechayeh ha-kol); recent ones offer both.
  • Today: Orthodox Jews hold resurrection and an immortal soul; many Reform and Liberal Jews hold immortality only, or leave the question open.
Mission 3

Afterlife and the justice of God

  • The Tenakh promises reward in this life for keeping the covenant (Deuteronomy 11:13–14).
  • But experience disagrees: "Wherefore doth the way of the wicked prosper?" (Jeremiah 12:1, JPS 1917).
  • Daniel's hope of resurrection arose in a time of persecution, when the faithful were dying for their faith (2nd century BCE, on many scholars' dating).
  • Link: if God is just, wrongs not put right in this life must be put right beyond it.
  • The rabbis: the reward for mitzvot is not in this world (Kiddushin 39b, paraphrase).
  • Tension: Avot 1:3 says serve God not for reward; many Progressive Jews put God's justice into human action in this world.
Mission 3

Reincarnation in Kabbalah

  • Gilgul (gilgul neshamot, "rolling of souls"): in some kabbalistic thought, a soul may return in another body.
  • Found in the Bahir and the Zohar; developed by Isaac Luria (1534–1572) in Safed, recorded by Hayyim Vital.
  • Purpose: to repair (tikkun) what was left undone, or fulfil mitzvot not yet completed.
  • Living Judaism: a bedtime prayer in many prayer books forgives wrongs done "in this gilgul or another".
  • Rejected by Saadia Gaon (882–942) as foolishness; most Reform Jews do not hold it.
Mission 3Evaluate

Are beliefs about the afterlife still relevant for Jews today?

Are beliefs about the afterlife still relevant for Jews today?Beliefs about judgement and the afterliferemain relevant for Jews today.ForThey are in the daily liturgy (Amidah,morning blessings) and in mourning(Kaddish, burial).They answer the problem of God's justicewhen the righteous suffer.AgainstThe Tenakh is mostly silent; Judaismstresses this world and the mitzvot.Pittsburgh and many Progressive Jewsreject bodily resurrection and literalGehenna and Eden.Judge it byRelevant to belief or to practice? · To whichJews? · Does "relevant" require being literal?
  • Claim: Beliefs about judgement and the afterlife remain relevant for Jews today.
  • For: They are in the daily liturgy (Amidah, morning blessings) and in mourning (Kaddish, burial).
  • For: They answer the problem of God's justice when the righteous suffer.
  • Against: The Tenakh is mostly silent; Judaism stresses this world and the mitzvot.
  • Against: Pittsburgh and many Progressive Jews reject bodily resurrection and literal Gehenna and Eden.
  • Judgement criteria: Relevant to belief or to practice? To which Jews? Does "relevant" require being literal?
Quick check
?A Hasidic Jew says a soul may return to complete a mitzvah left undone. Which idea is this?
Mission check

?At a funeral, an Orthodox rabbi and a Reform rabbi both speak of the person "living on". Which pairing most fairly matches their usual beliefs?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Some Jewish mystics say a soul can return to finish unfinished work. Where does that idea come from?

Make a guess: Some Jewish mystics say a soul can return to finish unfinished work. Where does that idea come from?

Mission 4

What Kabbalah is

Timelinec. 1180Sefer ha-Bahir (Provence)c. 1280sthe Zohar (Castile, Spain)1534–1572Isaac Luria, in Safed18th c.Hasidism
  • Kabbalah: "received tradition". The main stream of Jewish mysticism: seeking direct experience and knowledge of God.
  • Esoteric (hidden): traditionally taught only to mature, learned students; the Mishnah limits teaching the mysteries of creation and of God's chariot (Hagigah 2:1).
  • Key stages: Sefer ha-Bahir (Provence, c. 1180) · the Zohar (Spain, c. 1280s) · Isaac Luria in Safed (1534–1572) · then Hasidism.
  • Kabbalists keep halakhah fully; mysticism deepens the commandments, it does not replace them.
Mission 4

The Zohar

  • Zohar ("Radiance"): a mystical commentary on the Torah, mostly in Aramaic.
  • Traditionally attributed to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai (2nd century CE).
  • It appeared in 13th-century Castile through Moses de León (c. 1240–1305).
  • Gershom Scholem (1897–1982), Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism (1941): de León was the main author. Many traditional Jews hold that it preserves ancient teaching.
  • Role: for many Jews, especially Hasidic and Sephardi communities, a sacred text alongside Talmud; read for its hidden meanings of Torah; shaped prayer and custom.
Quick check
?Which statement about the Zohar is accurate?
Mission 4

Tikkun: repairing the world

Lurianic cycleTzimtzumlight withdraws to leave aspaceShevirat ha-kelimthe vessels breakSparks in kelippotsparks of holiness trapped in"husks"Tikkunmitzvot and prayer withintention free the sparks
  • Isaac Luria's account (16th century, Safed):
  • Tzimtzum: En Sof ("without end": God as infinite, in kabbalistic thought) "contracts" to make room for a world.
  • Shevirat ha-kelim: vessels meant to hold divine light break; sparks of holiness fall, trapped in kelippot ("husks").
  • Tikkun ("repair"): Jews free the sparks through mitzvot, prayer with intention and holy living.
  • When repair is complete, the Messiah comes.
  • Every act counts: ordinary deeds have cosmic effects.
  • Modern "tikkun olam" (social action) borrows the word.
Mission 4

Gilgul: the return of souls

Gilgul path1231life 1: a commandment left undone2life 2: the soul returns3life 3: completes its tikkunthen it restsNot samsarafinite: the soul aims to complete its repair,then rests
  • Gilgul neshamot: "the rolling of souls": reincarnation in some kabbalistic thought.
  • First taught in the Bahir (c. 1180); developed in the Zohar; fully systematised by Luria in Gate of Reincarnations (written down by Hayyim Vital, 1542–1620).
  • Why return? to fulfil commandments not yet kept, to repair a sin, or to complete the soul's tikkun.
  • Kabbalists use it to explain God's justice: why the righteous suffer or a child dies young (finishing a past task).
  • The Zohar links it to levirate marriage (Deuteronomy 25:5): the dead brother's soul returns in the child.
  • Not endless: the soul aims to complete its repair, then rests. Not the same as Hindu samsara and karma.
Mission 4Read the source

"Twice, yea thrice"

> "Lo, all these things doth God work, twice, yea thrice, with a man, To bring back his soul from the pit, that he may be enlightened with the light of the living." (Job 33:29–30, JPS 1917)

  • Plain sense: God rescues a person from death more than once in this life.
  • Kabbalistic reading (Zohar, paraphrase): a soul may be sent back into the world more than once to complete its repair.

Q1 Which words do kabbalists read as more than one life?

Show answer

"twice, yea thrice"

Q2 Why is this a reading, not the plain sense?

Show answer

The verse itself speaks of rescue from the pit; gilgul is found in it by mystical interpretation.

Mission 4Diversity

Who accepts gilgul?

  • Rejected by Saadia Gaon (882–942), Book of Beliefs and Opinions (933): a foreign idea, not Jewish.
  • Not among Maimonides' Thirteen Principles; not in the Talmud.
  • Widely accepted in Hasidic, many Haredi and many Sephardi communities, following the Zohar and Luria.
  • Modern Orthodox: many treat it as a permitted but optional belief.
  • Reform and Liberal: generally do not teach it; focus on this life and the soul's immortality (Pittsburgh Platform, 1885, §7).
  • Can sit beside resurrection: kabbalists taught that soul-sparks shared across lives are restored at the end.
Quick check
?Which statement about Jewish views of reincarnation is accurate?
Mission 4Evaluate

Does gilgul fit Jewish belief about life after death?

Argument mapReincarnation fits Jewish belief about lifeafter death.ForIt supports God's justice: suffering andearly death can be explained across lives.It is part of a long Jewish tradition (Bahir,Zohar, Luria) accepted by many Jewstoday.AgainstIt is absent from the Torah's plain senseand the Talmud; She'ol, resurrection andolam ha-ba are the older framework.Saadia Gaon called it foreign; Maimonides'principles omit it.Judge it byMust a belief be in Torah's plain sense? · Howmuch weight does mystical tradition carry? ·Does it fit God's justice better thanresurrection alone?
  • Claim: Reincarnation fits Jewish belief about life after death.
  • For: it supports God's justice: suffering and early death can be explained across lives.
  • For: it is part of a long Jewish tradition (Bahir, Zohar, Luria) accepted by many Jews today.
  • Against: it is absent from the Torah's plain sense and the Talmud; She'ol, resurrection and olam ha-ba are the older framework.
  • Against: Saadia Gaon called it foreign; Maimonides' principles omit it.
  • Judgement criteria: must a belief be in Torah's plain sense? How much weight does mystical tradition carry? Does it fit God's justice better than resurrection alone?
  • 15-mark (AO2) tip: weigh the arguments and reach a justified judgement; refer to a source of wisdom such as the Zohar or Saadia.
Mission check

?A kabbalist explains a baby's death after a few days: the soul came back only to finish one small task from an earlier life, and, its work complete, it returned. Which pair of ideas does this explanation join?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Humans are made in God's image, with infinite worth, free will and two inclinations.
  • Purposes of life include obedience to the mitzvot and tikkun olam; Jews weigh them differently.
  • Bringing the Messiah: views of the Messianic Age range from Maimonides' natural age to Reform's age without a personal Messiah.

Mission 2

  • Messiah (mashiach, "anointed") is a human king of David's line; the prophets picture an age of peace, judgement, ingathering and knowledge of God (Isaiah 2, Micah 4, Isaiah 11).
  • Maimonides: the Messiah is known by rebuilding the Temple and gathering the exiles; nature is unchanged.
  • Orthodox Jews await a personal Messiah; Reform Jews look to a Messianic Age that people help to build.

Mission 3

  • The Tenakh's She'ol became, in later Judaism, judgement, olam ha-ba, Gan Eden, Gehinnom and the resurrection of the dead (Daniel 12:2).
  • At En-dor (1 Samuel 28), Samuel comes up out of the earth: the dead live on, shadowy, in She'ol.
  • Orthodox Jews affirm bodily resurrection (principle 13); the Pittsburgh Platform (1885) kept only the immortal soul.
  • Belief in an afterlife is tied to God's justice; some kabbalists teach gilgul (reincarnation).

Mission 4

  • Kabbalah is Jewish mysticism; the Zohar (13th-century Spain, attributed to Shimon bar Yochai) is its central text.
  • Luria's tikkun repairs the world through mitzvot; gilgul (reincarnation), accepted by some Jews and rejected by others, lets a soul return to complete its repair.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Judaism: Self, death and afterlife for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1What are humans for? What does Judaism say the point of a life is?
  2. Mission 2How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?
  3. Mission 3The early Hebrew Bible says little about heaven. Where did Jewish hope of life after death come from?
  4. Mission 4Some Jewish mystics say a soul can return to finish unfinished work. Where does that idea come from?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · AQA