← A-Level Religious Studies · AQA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2E Judaism – God
Mini-Lesson

Judaism: God

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Jews believe in one God who has no body. So how can anyone say what God is like?
  2. Mission 2If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?
  3. Mission 3Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?
  4. Mission 4If God has no body, how can Jews call God "King", "Father", or simply "You"?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Jews believe in one God who has no body. So how can anyone say what God is like?

Make a guess: Jews believe in one God who has no body. So how can anyone say what God is like?

Mission 1

One God, no other

One God, no otherno partnersno imagesalone worshippedsource of justiceone God (echad)
  • Judaism is absolute monotheism: one God, with no partners, rivals or parts.
  • Jews say it twice a day in the Shema: God is one (Hebrew echad).
  • God alone is worthy of worship: no intermediaries, no idols (Exodus 20:3–5).
  • Ethical monotheism: the one God is also the source of justice and goodness, and demands them from people. Belief and conduct cannot be separated.
  • The phrase became central in 19th-century Jewish thought (e.g. Hermann Cohen, 1842–1918), but the idea runs through the prophets.
Mission 1Read the source

"The LORD is One"

> "HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE." (Deuteronomy 6:4, JPS 1917)

> "I am the first, and I am the last, and beside Me there is no God." (Isaiah 44:6, JPS 1917)

> "I form the light, and create darkness; I make peace, and create evil; I am the LORD, that doeth all these things." (Isaiah 45:7, JPS 1917)

Q1 What does Isaiah 44:6 add to "one"?

Show answer

God is eternal, first and last, and there is no other god at all.

Q2 How does Isaiah 45:7 rule out a second, evil power?

Show answer

One God is the source of light and darkness alike: no rival god of evil.

Mission 1

Creator, sustainer, judge

Creator, sustainer, judgeCreator"IN THE beginning God createdthe heaven and the earth"(Genesis 1:1)Sustainerrenews "every day, continually, thework of creation" (morning prayer,paraphrase)Judge"shall not the judge of all the earthdo justly?" (Genesis 18:25)
  • Jewish teaching describes God in these roles:
  • Creator: "IN THE beginning God created the heaven and the earth." (Genesis 1:1, JPS 1917) Most Jewish thinkers: creation from nothing.
  • Sustainer / controller: creation is not a one-off. The morning prayer praises God who "in his goodness renews every day, continually, the work of creation" (paraphrase).
  • Eternal: "from everlasting to everlasting, Thou art God" (Psalm 90:2). God does not change (Malachi 3:6).
  • Judge: God rewards and punishes: "shall not the judge of all the earth do justly?" (Genesis 18:25, JPS 1917).
  • Judgement is just and merciful; Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur are the "days of judgement".
Mission 1

No body, no likeness

Sinai: no form"ye saw no manner of form"(Deuteronomy 4:15)
  • Jews believe God is incorporeal: no body, no shape, no physical comparison.
  • At Sinai (Horeb) "ye saw no manner of form" (Deuteronomy 4:15, JPS 1917): so no image of God may be made.
  • Bible phrases like God's "hand" or "voice" are metaphors: "the Torah speaks in human language" (Talmud, Berakhot 31b, paraphrase), a principle Maimonides uses.
  • God is neither male nor female. Hebrew grammar uses "he", but this says nothing about God's nature (more in Mission 4).
Quick check
?Why does Jewish teaching forbid making an image of God?
Mission 1

What God is like: attributes

Attributes of GodAttributeMeaningSourceomnipotentall-powerful–omniscientall-knowing–merciful,omnibenevolent"merciful andgracious"Exodus34:6holyset apart andpureIsaiah 6:3just"judge of all theearth"Genesis18:25eternal"fromeverlasting toeverlasting"Psalm 90:2
  • Jewish teaching describes God as:
  • Omnipotent: all-powerful; nothing is beyond God.
  • Omniscient: all-knowing, including human thoughts and the future.
  • Omnibenevolent / merciful: "merciful and gracious, long-suffering, and abundant in goodness and truth" (Exodus 34:6, JPS 1917): the start of the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, recited on fast days and festivals.
  • Holy: "Holy, holy, holy, is the LORD of hosts" (Isaiah 6:3), set apart and pure.
  • Just and perfect: God's acts are right and complete.
  • God is creator and controller of all things.
  • Many Jewish thinkers (e.g. Maimonides) say such words describe what God does, not what God is in essence.
Mission 1

Maimonides' Thirteen Principles

Maimonides' Thirteen PrinciplesAbout God1–51God exists and is the cause of all2God is one3God has no body4God is eternal (first and last)5only God may be worshippedRevelation6–96prophecy7Moses is the greatest prophet8the Torah is from God9it will not be changedReward and the end10–1310God knows human deeds11rewards and punishes12the Messiah will come13the dead will be raised
  • Moses Maimonides (Rambam, 1138–1204), Commentary on the Mishnah, Sanhedrin chapter 10 (c. 1168).
  • About God (1–5): (1) God exists and is the cause of all; (2) God is one; (3) God has no body; (4) God is eternal (first and last); (5) only God may be worshipped.
  • Revelation (6–9): prophecy; Moses is the greatest prophet; the Torah is from God; it will not be changed.
  • Reward and the end (10–13): God knows human deeds; rewards and punishes; the Messiah will come; the dead will be raised.
  • Sung in Yigdal and recited as Ani Ma'amin ("I believe") in many prayer books.
  • Critics: Hasdai Crescas (c. 1340–1410/11) and Joseph Albo (Sefer ha-Ikkarim, c. 1425) counted fewer principles (Albo: three). Some argue Judaism stresses practice more than creed.
Mission 1

Maimonides: saying what God is not

Saying what God is notAnalogy: narrowing down an unseen object?unseen"God is living"= not lifeless"God is one"= no parts, no equalGod has no body= no limitsEach denial removes an error.
  • The Guide for the Perplexed (c. 1190), Book I, chapters 50–60.
  • Human words describe things with bodies and limits; God has neither. So positive attributes risk limiting God.
  • Negative attributes (via negativa): we know God best by saying what God is not. "God is living" means "God is not lifeless"; "God is one" means "God has no parts and no equal".
  • Each denial brings us closer to the truth, like narrowing down what an unseen object is.
  • Attributes of action: words like "merciful" (Exodus 34:6) describe what God does, not God's essence.
Quick check
?For Maimonides, what does the statement "God is powerful" mean?
Mission 1Diversity

One God, many understandings

One God, many understandingsOrthodoxas in Maimonides' principles: personal,revealing the Torah, rewarding and punishingKabbalah and HasidismEin Sof ("without end"), beyond all thought,revealed through ten sefirotReformethical monotheism is the essence; God knownthrough conscience and historyReconstructionistKaplan: "the power that makes for salvation",not a supernatural personHumanisticJewish identity without belief in God
  • Orthodox: God as in Maimonides' principles: personal, revealing the Torah, rewarding and punishing.
  • Kabbalah and Hasidism: God is Ein Sof ("without end"), beyond all thought, revealed through ten sefirot; some Hasidic teachers say nothing exists apart from God.
  • Reform: ethical monotheism is the essence of Judaism; God known through conscience and history more than through law.
  • Reconstructionist: Mordecai Kaplan (1881–1983) described God as "the power that makes for salvation": a force in nature and people, not a supernatural person.
  • Humanistic Judaism: Jewish identity without belief in God.
  • Orthodox, Reform and Reconstructionist Jews all recite the Shema; they read "one" differently.
Mission 1Evaluate

Is belief in one God the foundation of Judaism?

Is belief in one God the foundation?Claim: monotheism is the essence andfoundation of Judaism.ForThe Shema is the first prayer learned andthe last said; Maimonides' first principlesare about God.Ethics depends on the one God: one God,one moral law for all people.AgainstJudaism stresses practice (halakhah) overcreed; some argue there is no singlerequired belief.Humanistic and many secular Jews keepJewish identity without belief in God.Covenant, Torah and peoplehood may beas central as monotheism.Judge it byEssence for whom: the Torah, the rabbis, orJews today? · Is a foundation the same as themost important thing?
  • Claim: Monotheism is the essence and foundation of Judaism.
  • For: The Shema is the first prayer learned and the last said; Maimonides' first principles are about God.
  • For: Ethics depends on the one God: one God, one moral law for all people.
  • Against: Judaism stresses practice (halakhah) over creed; some argue there is no single required belief.
  • Against: Humanistic and many secular Jews keep Jewish identity without belief in God.
  • Against: Covenant, Torah and peoplehood may be as central as monotheism.
  • Judgement criteria: Essence for whom: the Torah, the rabbis, or Jews today? Is a foundation the same as the most important thing?
Mission check

?A visitor to a synagogue sees the ark, carved lions, a menorah and the two tablets of the Ten Commandments, but no picture or statue of God anywhere. Which belief best explains what is missing?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?

Make a guess: If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?

Mission 2

Maimonides writes a list

  • Moses ben Maimon, called Maimonides or Rambam (1138–1204): rabbi, legal scholar, philosopher, physician.
  • Born in Córdoba, Spain; his family fled persecution; he settled in Fustat (Old Cairo), Egypt.
  • In his Commentary on the Mishnah (Arabic, completed c. 1168) he reached Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1: "All Israel have a share in the world to come" (paraphrase).
  • Who counts as "Israel" here? His answer: anyone who holds thirteen foundations (Hebrew yesodot) of faith.
  • They are known as the Thirteen Principles of Faith.
Mission 2

Thirteen principles, three groups

Thirteen principles, three groupsAbout God (1–5)1God exists and causes all2is one3has no body4is eternal5alone is to be worshippedAbout revelation (6–9)6prophecy7Moses the greatest prophet8the Torah from heaven9the Torah unchangingAbout God and humanity (10–13)10God knows our deeds11reward and punishment12the Messiah13resurrection of the deadGrouping is a teaching aid, not Maimonides'own. Numbers as in Ani Ma'amin.
  • About God (1–5): God exists and causes all · is one · has no body · is eternal · alone is to be worshipped.
  • About revelation (6–9): prophecy · Moses the greatest prophet · the Torah from heaven · the Torah unchanging.
  • About God and humanity (10–13): God knows our deeds · reward and punishment · the Messiah · resurrection of the dead.
  • Principles 6–13: a later mission (see Mission 3).
Mission 2

Principles 1 and 2: God exists; God is one

  • 1. Existence: God exists, is perfect, and is the cause of everything else that exists. Everything depends on God; God depends on nothing.
  • Root: "I am the LORD thy God" (Exodus 20:2), which Maimonides counts as the first commandment: to know that God exists.
  • 2. Unity: God is one, but not one as a pair has one member, nor one as a species, nor one as a body made of parts (paraphrase).
  • God's unity is unique: nothing else is one in this way.
  • Root: "HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE." (Deuteronomy 6:4, JPS 1917)
  • This is Jewish monotheism at its strictest: one God, with no division at all.
Mission 2Read the source

Principle 3: no body

> "for ye saw no manner of form on the day that the LORD spoke unto you in Horeb out of the midst of the fire" (Deuteronomy 4:15, JPS 1917)

  • 3. Incorporeality: God has no body, no shape, and nothing that happens to bodies (moving, resting, being in a place).
  • So what about God's "hand" or "eyes"? Maimonides uses the Talmud's rule: "The Torah speaks in the language of human beings" (paraphrase).
  • These words are figurative: "hand" means power; "eyes" means knowledge.

Q1 What did the Israelites not see at Horeb (Sinai)?

Show answer

Any form: they heard a voice but saw no shape.

Q2 Why does the Torah still use body words for God?

Show answer

To speak in a way ordinary people understand.

Quick check
?A student reads Exodus 15:6, "Thy right hand, O LORD, glorious in power". How would Maimonides explain the word "hand"?
Mission 2

Principles 4 and 5: eternal; worship God alone

  • 4. Eternity: God is first: before everything, without beginning. Later versions add "and last".
  • Roots: "The eternal God is a dwelling-place" (Deuteronomy 33:27, JPS 1917); "I am the first, and I am the last" (Isaiah 44:6, JPS 1917).
  • 5. Worship God alone: prayer and praise go to God only.
  • Not to angels, stars or forces of nature, and not through them as go-betweens.
  • Root: "Thou shalt have no other gods before Me." (Exodus 20:3, JPS 1917)
  • Principle 5 is about practice: what a Jew may do in prayer, not only what a Jew thinks.
Mission 2

Roots, development, living Judaism

Principles 1–5: roots, development, living JudaismPrinciples 1–5Tanakh rootsMaimonidesLivingJudaismExodus 20:2–3Deuteronomy4:15, 6:4,33:27Isaiah 44:6defined beliefs:who is insideJudaismunique unityno body at allnegativeattributesYigdal (c.14th century)Ani Ma'aminleast disputedtoday
  • Biblical roots: Exodus 20:2–3; Deuteronomy 4:15, 6:4, 33:27; Isaiah 44:6.
  • Maimonides' development: turns these into defined beliefs that mark who is inside Judaism; adds philosophical precision (unique unity; no body at all; negative attributes).
  • Living Judaism: the hymn Yigdal (c. 14th century) sings all thirteen at the start or end of services in many synagogues.
  • Ani Ma'amin ("I believe with perfect faith…"), printed in many prayer books after the morning service, turns each principle into a sentence of faith.
  • Principles 1–5 are the least disputed today: almost all Jewish movements affirm one God, beyond the world, to be worshipped alone.
  • AQA: link these to God as one, eternal, omniscient and omnipotent creator.
Quick check
?Which principle would most directly rule out asking an angel to carry a prayer to God?
Mission check

?A children's book shows God as an old man on a throne in the sky. A rabbi following Maimonides wants to explain what is wrong with the picture. Which explanation fits his principles best?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?

Make a guess: Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?

Mission 3

Principle 6: prophecy

  • 6. Prophecy: God communicates with chosen human beings, the prophets.
  • Root: "the Lord GOD will do nothing, but He revealeth His counsel unto His servants the prophets" (Amos 3:7, JPS 1917).
  • In the Guide (II.32–48) Maimonides explains prophecy as the highest human perfection: God's influence reaches a person's intellect and then their imagination.
  • A prophet must be wise and morally perfected; even then, God may withhold prophecy.
Mission 3Read the source

Principle 7: Moses

> "if there be a prophet among you, I the LORD do make Myself known unto him in a vision, I do speak with him in a dream. My servant Moses is not so; … with him do I speak mouth to mouth" (Numbers 12:6–8, JPS 1917)

  • 7. Moses is the greatest of all prophets, before or after him.
  • Maimonides lists four differences (paraphrase): Moses received prophecy awake, not in a dream; directly, not through an angel; without terror; and whenever he chose.
  • "And there hath not arisen a prophet since in Israel like unto Moses" (Deuteronomy 34:10, JPS 1917).

Q1 How does God speak to other prophets, according to Numbers 12?

Show answer

In a vision or a dream.

Q2 Why does principle 7 matter for principle 8?

Show answer

If Moses' prophecy is unique, no later prophet can overrule the Torah he received.

Mission 3

Principles 8 and 9: the Torah from heaven, unchanging

  • 8. Torah from heaven (Torah min ha-shamayim): the whole Torah we now have was given by God to Moses.
  • Every verse is equally divine: a list of Esau's descendants (Genesis 36) as much as "Hear, O Israel" (Maimonides' own example, paraphrase).
  • The Oral Torah, the explanation of the commandments, also comes from God.
  • 9. Unchanging: the Torah will not be replaced, and nothing will be added or taken away. Root: Deuteronomy 12:32 (13:1 in Hebrew numbering).
  • Context: many Christian and Muslim teachers of his time held that a later revelation completed or replaced the Torah; principle 9 denies this.
Quick check
?A prophet appears who works wonders and announces that God has cancelled a commandment of the Torah. How would Maimonides' principles judge him?
Mission 3

Principles 10 and 11: God knows; reward and punishment

  • 10. God knows human deeds and thoughts: "He that fashioneth the hearts of them all, that considereth all their doings" (Psalm 33:15, JPS 1917).
  • 11. Reward and punishment: God rewards those who keep the commandments and punishes those who break them.
  • The greatest reward is the world to come (olam ha-ba); the greatest punishment is for the soul to be cut off (karet).
  • But Maimonides adds: serve God out of love, not for reward. He cites Antigonus: be not like servants who serve their master for a reward (Pirkei Avot 1:3, paraphrase).
  • His image: a child is given sweets to learn; an adult learns for the sake of truth (paraphrase).
Mission 3

Principles 12 and 13: the Messiah and resurrection

  • 12. The Messiah will come: "though it tarry, wait for it" (Habakkuk 2:3, JPS 1917). Do not calculate the date. (Full picture in a later lesson.)
  • 13. Resurrection of the dead (techiyat ha-metim): "many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake" (Daniel 12:2, JPS 1917).
  • Maimonides stressed a spiritual world to come for souls, so some accused him of denying bodily resurrection.
  • His reply, the Treatise on Resurrection (1191): resurrection is real, a miracle, a foundation of the Torah; the risen will later die, and the final reward is for the soul (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Why did Maimonides write his Treatise on Resurrection in 1191?
Mission 3Diversity

The principles today

The principles todayOrthodox8 · Torah fromheavenmost affirm: theboundary ofOrthodox belief12 · Messiahmost affirm13 · resurrectionmost affirmYigdal / Ani Ma'aminin Orthodox prayerbooksMasorti / Conservative8 · Torah from heavenmany reinterpret it: revelation includes ahuman elementReform8 · Torah fromheavenPittsburgh 1885:Torah inspired butwritten by people12 · MessiahPittsburgh: aMessianic Age, not aperson13 · resurrectionPittsburgh: bodilyresurrection rejectedYigdal / Ani Ma'aminReform Yigdalchanges theresurrection lineReconstructionist8 · Torah from heavenKaplan: rejected a supernatural revelationPrinciples 1–5 unite most Jews; 8, 12 and 13divide them most.
  • Orthodox: the principles mark the boundary of Orthodox belief; Yigdal and Ani Ma'amin are in Orthodox prayer books. Some Orthodox scholars note that respected authorities disputed individual principles in the past.
  • Masorti / Conservative: God, Torah and Israel affirmed; revelation includes a human element, so principle 8 is reinterpreted.
  • Reform: the Pittsburgh Platform (1885) rejected bodily resurrection and a personal Messiah (a Messianic Age instead), and saw the Torah as inspired but written by people. Reform versions of Yigdal change the resurrection line.
  • Reconstructionist: Kaplan rejected a supernatural revelation altogether.
  • Principles 1–5 unite most Jews; 8, 12 and 13 divide them most.
  • The list was argued over from the start: Raavad objected to calling sincere Jews heretics over beliefs such as a bodily God; some rabbis in Provence banned Maimonides' books, and copies were burned in Montpellier (c. 1233); Joseph Albo (Sefer ha-Ikkarim, 1425) cut the essentials to three roots.
Quick check
?Which view would most Reform Jews today hold about principle 13?
Mission check

?A synagogue sings Yigdal every Friday night. A member says, "We sing all thirteen, so every Jew has always agreed with all thirteen." Which reply is most accurate?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If God has no body, how can Jews call God "King", "Father", or simply "You"?

Make a guess: If God has no body, how can Jews call God "King", "Father", or simply "You"?

Mission 4

A God who speaks and listens

A God who speaks and listensspeakscallshearsrememberslovesis angryforgivesYou(atah)"Barukh atah": "Blessed are You"
  • The God of the Tenakh is personal: God speaks, calls, hears, remembers, loves, is angry and forgives.
  • Abraham argues with God: "shall not the judge of all the earth do justly?" (Genesis 18:25, JPS 1917).
  • Moses speaks with God "mouth to mouth" (Numbers 12:8); the Psalms speak to God as "Thou".
  • Jewish blessings (berakhot) use the words "Barukh atah": "Blessed are You". God is addressed directly.
  • But God is also incorporeal and beyond human ideas (see Mission 1). How can both be true?
Mission 4Read the source

Genesis 3:8

> "And they heard the voice of the LORD God walking in the garden toward the cool of the day; and the man and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God amongst the trees of the garden." (Genesis 3:8, JPS 1917)

Q1 Which words describe God in human, bodily terms?

Show answer

"walking in the garden"; also a "voice" that can be heard.

Q2 What do the man and woman do, and why might that matter?

Show answer

They hide: the verse is about a broken relationship with a God who comes looking for them.

Mission 4

Reading anthropomorphism

Three readings of Genesis 3:8"And they heard the voice of the LORD Godwalking in the garden toward the cool of theday"Genesis 3:8Targum Onkelos (Aramaic translation)"the voice of the Memra (Word) of the LORDGod"Maimonides, Guide for the Perplexedfigurative: "walking" means God's presencebecoming known
  • Anthropomorphism: describing God in human form or with human feelings (walking, a hand, an arm, regret, anger).
  • Targum Onkelos (Aramaic translation, early centuries CE) often softens these: at Genesis 3:8 they hear "the voice of the Memra (Word) of the LORD God".
  • Maimonides, Guide for the Perplexed (c. 1190), Book I: every bodily word about God is figurative. "Walking" means God's action or presence becoming known; Genesis 1:27's "image" means human intellect, not shape.
  • Rabbinic principle: "the Torah speaks in human language" (Talmud, Berakhot 31b, paraphrase): God is described so people can understand.
  • Kabbalah reads the bodily images symbolically, as the structure of God's ten sefirot.
  • A few medieval Jews read some anthropomorphisms more literally; Maimonides' view became mainstream.
Quick check
?How did Maimonides interpret "walking in the garden" in Genesis 3:8?
Mission 4

King and Father

King and FatherKingFathersovereignty, law,judgementExod 15:18creator, love andcare, disciplineIsa 63:16; Mal2:10; Ps 103:13Avinu Malkeinu"Our Father, our King"
  • King: "The LORD shall reign for ever and ever." (Exodus 15:18, JPS 1917) The standard berakhah calls God Melekh ha-olam, "King of the universe".
  • King means sovereignty (God rules all), law (God commands) and judgement: on Rosh Hashanah Jews proclaim God King (Malkhuyot prayers).
  • Father: "Thou, O LORD, art our Father, our Redeemer from everlasting is Thy name" (Isaiah 63:16, JPS 1917).
  • "Have we not all one father? Hath not one God created us?" (Malachi 2:10, JPS 1917): Father as creator of all, and the basis for treating others as kin.
  • Father means love, care and discipline: "Like as a father hath compassion upon his children" (Psalm 103:13, JPS 1917).
  • Avinu Malkeinu ("Our Father, our King"), said from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur, holds both together: closeness and awe.
Mission 4Diversity

Gendered language about God

Gendered language about Godtraditional Hebrewnew liturgy1231traditional Hebrew, read as metaphor(Orthodox)2feminine images in the Tenakh: "As onewhom his mother comforteth" (Isaiah66:13)3new blessings: God as "source of life"(Falk); gender-neutral English (manyReform and Liberal prayer books)Positions, not a ranking
  • Hebrew grammar uses masculine forms for God; King, Father and Lord are male images.
  • Traditional view: God is neither male nor female (Maimonides); masculine words are a feature of language, not a claim about God.
  • Feminine images exist in the Tenakh: "As one whom his mother comforteth, so will I comfort you" (Isaiah 66:13, JPS 1917); God compared to a mother who cannot forget her baby (Isaiah 49:15).
  • Shekhinah (God's indwelling presence) is grammatically feminine; Kabbalah treats it as the feminine aspect of God.
  • Feminist critique: Judith Plaskow (b. 1947), Standing Again at Sinai (1990): only-male images of God support male power in Jewish life; new images are needed.
  • Liturgy: Marcia Falk, The Book of Blessings (1996), offers new blessings addressing God as "source of life"; many Reform and Liberal prayer books use gender-neutral English.
  • Orthodox prayer books keep the traditional Hebrew, understood as metaphor.
Quick check
?Which statement best represents the traditional Jewish view of calling God "Father"?
Mission 4Evaluate

Should language about God be read literally?

Read literally?Claim: anthropomorphic and genderedlanguage about God should be readliterally.ForWithout human images, God becomesabstract and distant; a "Father" who"walks" is someone people can love andfear.The Torah chose these words; the imagesmay say something true about God'scloseness.AgainstLiteral readings clash with incorporeality(Deuteronomy 4:15; Maimonides' thirdprinciple).Only-male images may shape how peoplesee power in the community (Plaskow).Images can be kept as metaphor: true inwhat they point to, not in their form.Judge it byWhat is lost if the images go? · Can metaphorstill be true? · Who decides how liturgychanges: tradition, community, or individuals?
  • Claim: Anthropomorphic and gendered language about God should be read literally.
  • For (literal force): Without human images, God becomes abstract and distant; a "Father" who "walks" is someone people can love and fear.
  • For: The Torah chose these words; the images may say something true about God's closeness.
  • Against: Literal readings clash with incorporeality (Deuteronomy 4:15; Maimonides' third principle).
  • Against: Only-male images may shape how people see power in the community (Plaskow).
  • Against: Images can be kept as metaphor: true in what they point to, not in their form.
  • Judgement criteria: What is lost if the images go? Can metaphor still be true? Who decides how liturgy changes: tradition, community, or individuals?
Mission 4

Buber: two ways of relating

I–It and I–ThouI–ItIItusing, measuring, describing: an objectI–ThouIThoumeeting with the whole being, mutually, now
  • Martin Buber (1878–1965), Austrian-born Jewish philosopher; Ich und Du (I and Thou, 1923; English 1937).
  • People can say two basic "words": I–It and I–Thou (or I–You).
  • I–It: using, measuring, describing. The other is an object: useful, but held at a distance.
  • I–Thou: meeting the other with your whole being, in the present, mutually. The other is a person, not a thing to use.
  • I–It is necessary for life (work, science); a life with only I–It is not fully human.
  • I–Thou can happen with nature, with people, and with spiritual forms (art, ideas). Buber drew on the warmth of Hasidism.
Mission 4

The Eternal Thou

The Eternal ThouEternal Thounaturepeoplespiritual forms(art, ideas)every true I–Thou meeting glimpses theEternal Thou (Buber, paraphrase)
  • In every true I–Thou meeting, we glimpse the Eternal Thou: God (paraphrase of Buber, I and Thou, Part Three).
  • Every human "Thou" slips back into "It"; the Eternal Thou never becomes an It.
  • So God is known in and through relationships, not as an object of proof or description. God can be addressed, not expressed.
  • Revelation is presence, not information: a meeting that changes us, not a list of facts.
  • This fits prayer as address ("Blessed are You") and the God who calls "Where art thou?" after Genesis 3:8 (Genesis 3:9).
Quick check
?Which is an example of an I–Thou relationship, as Buber describes it?
Mission 4Evaluate

Is Buber's Eternal Thou a good account of God?

Is the Eternal Thou a good account of God?Claim: Buber's Eternal Thou is the best wayto understand the personal God of Judaism.ForIt keeps God personal without giving Goda body: God is "You", not "It".It fits the Bible's God who calls andanswers, and Jewish prayer as directaddress.It links love of God with love of neighbour(Leviticus 19:18).AgainstIt is subjective: how can one tell a meetingwith God from a strong feeling?Franz Rosenzweig (1886–1929), "TheBuilders" (1923): Buber should see theTorah's laws as a place of meeting too.Emmanuel Levinas (1906–1995): therelation to the other is not mutual butasymmetrical; I am responsible first.Judge it byDoes it fit the Jewish tradition as a whole, oronly some parts? · Can knowledge of God benon-descriptive? · Does it make room forhalakhah?
  • Claim: Buber's idea of the Eternal Thou is the best way to understand the personal God of Judaism.
  • For: It keeps God personal without giving God a body: God is "You", not "It".
  • For: It fits the Bible's God who calls and answers, and Jewish prayer as direct address.
  • For: It links love of God with love of neighbour (Leviticus 19:18).
  • Against: It is subjective: how can one tell a meeting with God from a strong feeling?
  • Against: Buber did not accept the Torah's laws as binding revelation; Franz Rosenzweig (1886–1929), in his open letter "The Builders" (1923), urged him to see law as a place of meeting too.
  • Against: Emmanuel Levinas (1906–1995) argued the relation to the other is not mutual but asymmetrical: I am responsible for the other before any meeting.
  • Judgement criteria: Does it fit the Jewish tradition as a whole, or only some parts? Can knowledge of God be non-descriptive? Does it make room for halakhah?
Mission check

?A Jewish student says: "When I pray Avinu Malkeinu, I'm not giving God a description. I'm speaking to God, the way I'd speak to someone I love." Which thinker's idea does this reflect most closely?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Judaism is absolute monotheism: one, eternal, incorporeal God, creator, sustainer and judge, who alone is worshipped and who demands justice (ethical monotheism).
  • Maimonides' Thirteen Principles summarise belief; Jewish traditions interpret the one God differently.
  • Maimonides teaches that we know God best by saying what God is not.

Mission 2

  • Maimonides (1138–1204) set out Thirteen Principles in his Commentary on the Mishnah; principles 1–5 are about God: exists, one, without body, eternal, alone to be worshipped.
  • Body words for God are figurative: "the Torah speaks in the language of human beings".

Mission 3

  • Principles 6–9 are about revelation (prophecy, Moses, Torah from heaven, Torah unchanging); 10–13 about God and humanity (knowledge, reward and punishment, Messiah, resurrection).
  • Today Orthodox Jews affirm all thirteen; Progressive Jews reinterpret especially 8, 12 and 13.

Mission 4

  • The Tenakh's God is personal; images like "walking in the garden" (Genesis 3:8), King and Father are read by most Jews (with Maimonides) as metaphors, since God has no body.
  • Gendered language is debated: tradition says God is neither male nor female; feminist thinkers (Plaskow, Falk) call for new images; Orthodox liturgy keeps the traditional words.
  • Buber: God is the Eternal Thou, met in and through I–Thou relationships, never an It; critics question its subjectivity and its place for law.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Judaism: God for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Jews believe in one God who has no body. So how can anyone say what God is like?
  2. Mission 2If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?
  3. Mission 3Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?
  4. Mission 4If God has no body, how can Jews call God "King", "Father", or simply "You"?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · AQA