🚀 Judaism: Judaism, gender and sexuality; judaism and science
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2E Judaism – Judaism, gender and sexuality; 2E Judaism – Judaism and science
Mini-Lesson
Judaism: Judaism, gender and sexuality; judaism and science
6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Some Jewish women stay married against their will for years. How can a divorce be "chained"?
Mission 2The first woman rabbi was ordained in 1935 and murdered at Auschwitz. Why did it take until 1972 for another?
Mission 3Jewish law calls sex a mitzvah. So why does it also set so many limits on it?
Mission 4If women were left out of the story at Sinai, can Jewish tradition be retold without breaking it?
Mission 5The Jewish calendar counts about 5,800 years since creation. Science says 13.8 billion. Must one be wrong?
Mission 6Can studying the stars and the cells of the body be a way of loving God?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Some Jewish women stay married against their will for years. How can a divorce be "chained"?
Make a guess: Some Jewish women stay married against their will for years. How can a divorce be "chained"?
Mission 1
The home: a small sanctuary
Judaism is lived as much at home as in the synagogue: Shabbat meals, festivals, kashrut, prayer, study.
The home is often called a mikdash me'at ("small sanctuary"): the table like the Temple altar.
> "and thou shalt teach them diligently unto thy children, and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thy house" (Deuteronomy 6:7, JPS 1917)
Parents are the first teachers of Torah; the Pesach seder is built around children's questions.
Shalom bayit (peace in the home) is a high value: family harmony is a religious goal.
Mission 1
Traditional roles
Orthodox Judaism teaches distinct but complementary roles for men and women.
Women are exempt from most time-bound positive mitzvot (e.g. tefillin, fixed public prayer) (Mishnah Kiddushin 1:7); a common explanation is their role in the home and with children.
Three mitzvot traditionally linked with women (Mishnah Shabbat 2:6): niddah (family purity), separating challah from dough, and lighting Shabbat candles.
Jewish identity passes through the mother in Orthodox and Masorti Judaism.
Men: public prayer in a minyan, Torah study as a lifelong duty, leading services.
Mission 1Read the source
A woman of valour
> "A woman of valour who can find? for her price is far above rubies." (Proverbs 31:10, JPS 1917)
> "She openeth her mouth with wisdom; and the law of kindness is on her tongue." (Proverbs 31:26, JPS 1917)
Eshet chayil ("woman of valour", Proverbs 31:10–31) is sung by many husbands and families at the Friday night table.
The woman in the poem runs a household, trades, buys a field and teaches with wisdom.
Q1 Which qualities does verse 26 praise?
Show answer
Wisdom and kindness in speech: teaching.
Q2 How could a feminist and a traditionalist read the poem differently?
Show answer
Traditional: honour for the wife's home role; feminist: praise only in relation to a husband's household, or evidence of women's economic power.
Mission 1
Why roles have changed
Society outside religion: women's education, paid work and leadership became normal in the 20th century.
Secular rights: UK votes for women (1918, equal in 1928); Sex Discrimination Act 1975; Equality Act 2010. Religious bodies have some exemptions, but expectations changed.
Different understandings of Torah and Halakhah:
Orthodox: halakhah is divine and binding; change happens only within it.
Progressive (Reform, Liberal): Torah reflects its time; equality is a Jewish value that can override old rules.
Masorti (Conservative): halakhah binding but developing; many egalitarian rulings since the 1970s.
Interpretations of equality: equal dignity with different roles (Orthodox), or equal roles (Progressive)?
Quick check
?Why are Orthodox women exempt from many time-bound positive mitzvot?
Mission 1
Women and Torah education
The Mishnah (Sotah 3:4) records a debate: Ben Azzai says a man should teach his daughter Torah; Rabbi Eliezer opposes teaching daughters Torah (paraphrase).
For centuries most women learned practical halakhah and prayer at home, not Talmud in yeshivah.
Sarah Schenirer (1883–1935) founded the Bais Yaakov schools for Orthodox girls in Kraków (1917), with rabbinic approval.
Today: advanced women's Torah study centres (e.g. Drisha in New York, Nishmat and Matan in Jerusalem); Haredi girls' schools teach Bible and law but usually not Talmud.
Progressive Judaism: identical Jewish education for girls and boys, including bat mitzvah with Torah reading.
Mission 1
Agunah: the chained woman
Step 1 of 3
> "he writeth her a bill of divorcement, and giveth it in her hand, and sendeth her out of his house" (Deuteronomy 24:1, JPS 1917)
Jewish divorce needs a get: a document the husband gives freely to his wife, before a beth din (rabbinic court).
A civil divorce alone does not end a Jewish marriage in Orthodox law.
Agunah (plural agunot): a "chained" woman whose husband refuses to give a get, or has disappeared.
She cannot remarry in Orthodox law; children of a new relationship would be mamzerim, restricted in whom they may marry.
A man without a get faces fewer consequences: the system is unequal.
Mission 1
Breaking the chains
Prenuptial agreements: the husband agrees in advance to pay daily support until he gives a get (e.g. used by the United Synagogue and in the USA).
UK law: the Divorce (Religious Marriages) Act 2002 lets a civil court delay the final divorce until a religious divorce is given.
Pressure: some batei din name refusers publicly; Israel's rabbinical courts can impose sanctions, even prison.
Masorti: a clause in the ketubah (marriage contract) committing both to the beth din (the "Lieberman clause", 1954); in some cases annulment.
Reform and Liberal: civil divorce, or their own egalitarian get, so the problem largely does not arise.
Quick check
?Which situation makes a woman an agunah in Orthodox Jewish law?
Mission 1
Minyan: who counts?
Minyan: a quorum of ten adults needed for parts of public prayer (e.g. Kaddish, Kedushah, Torah reading).
Orthodox: ten men over bar mitzvah; women may attend but do not count. A mechitzah (partition) separates seating.
Masorti / Conservative: a 1973 ruling allowed women to count; most UK Masorti communities now count women, some do not.
Reform and Liberal: women and men count equally; mixed seating.
Women's prayer groups and partnership minyanim (from 2002) let Orthodox women read Torah and lead some parts of the service, while ten men still form the minyan.
Mission 1
The Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance
JOFA, founded 1997 in New York by Blu Greenberg (b. 1936); a UK branch followed.
Aim: expand women's roles within halakhah. Greenberg's motto: where there is a rabbinic will, there is a halakhic way.
On agunot: promotes prenuptial agreements, supports International Agunah Day (the Fast of Esther), campaigns against get refusal.
On minyan: supports women's prayer groups and partnership minyanim; women's Torah reading and leadership in ritual.
Critics: many Orthodox rabbis say partnership minyanim break with tradition; some feminists say working within halakhah leaves women unequal.
Mission 1Evaluate
Can women be equal to men in Judaism?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Women can be fully equal to men in Judaism.
For: Progressive Judaism already gives equal roles; women in the home are central to Jewish life.
For: JOFA and Masorti show change within halakhah is possible (prenups, partnership minyanim).
Against: in Orthodox law only men give a get or form a minyan: structural inequality remains.
Against: if equality means identical roles, much of traditional Judaism must change; many women choose distinct roles.
Judgement criteria: equal dignity or equal roles? Who decides: halakhah, the community, women themselves?
Mission check
?Ruth, an Orthodox woman, is separated from her husband. He refuses a get unless she gives up her share of their house. Which response would Orthodox feminists, who seek change within halakhah, be most likely to support?
The agunah problem shows how Jewish movements weigh law and equality: Orthodox feminists seek remedies within halakhah, Progressive Jews change the rules.
Mission 2
Mission 2: The first woman rabbi was ordained in 1935 and murdered at Auschwitz. Why did it take until 1972 for another?
Make a guess: The first woman rabbi was ordained in 1935 and murdered at Auschwitz. Why did it take until 1972 for another?
Mission 2
What is a rabbi?
Rabbi: "my teacher". A scholar of Torah and halakhah, not a priest: no sacrifices, no special holiness.
Roles today: teaching, deciding questions of halakhah, preaching, pastoral care, leading a community.
Semikhah: ordination, a certificate that the holder may teach and decide halakhah.
A knowledgeable adult Jew can lead prayers without being a rabbi (in Orthodox practice, a man leads); the question is who may hold authority.
So the debate is about authority, tradition and equality, not about holiness.
Mission 2
Regina Jonas
Regina Jonas (1902–1944), Berlin. Studied at the Liberal rabbinical college in Berlin.
Her thesis (1930) asked: can a woman hold rabbinic office according to halakhic sources? She argued yes.
Ordained privately in December 1935 by Rabbi Max Dienemann (Liberal): the first woman rabbi.
Taught, preached and gave pastoral care as Nazi persecution grew.
Deported to Theresienstadt in 1942, where she kept up rabbinic work; murdered at Auschwitz in 1944.
Largely forgotten until her papers were found in an archive in 1991.
Mission 2
From 1972: women rabbis today
1972:Sally Priesand, ordained by the American Reform seminary (Hebrew Union College).
1975:Jackie Tabick, the first British woman rabbi (Leo Baeck College, Reform).
1977:Julia Neuberger (b. 1950), ordained at Leo Baeck College; rabbi of the South London Liberal Synagogue, the first British woman to lead her own congregation; later a member of the House of Lords (2004) and Senior Rabbi of West London Synagogue (2011–2020).
1985:Amy Eilberg, first Conservative (Masorti) woman rabbi.
2009:Sara Hurwitz, first graduate of the Orthodox women's programme later called Yeshivat Maharat (New York).
Today women serve as rabbis across Reform, Liberal, Reconstructionist and Masorti Judaism.
Quick check
?Which statement about early women rabbis is accurate?
Mission 2
Why Jewish feminism arose
Second-wave feminism (1960s–70s) asked why women were shut out of public life; many leading secular feminists were Jewish (e.g. Betty Friedan).
Jewish women asked the same of Judaism: no minyan, no aliyah, no ordination, no get without the husband.
1971–72: Ezrat Nashim, a group of Conservative Jewish women, issued a "Call for Change": count women in the minyan, let them be witnesses, rabbis and cantors.
Rachel Adler, "The Jew Who Wasn't There" (1971): halakhah treats women as outside the full community (paraphrase;).
Jewish feminist theology goes further: rethinking God-language, Torah and history from women's experience (Plaskow).
Impact: new rituals (naming ceremonies for girls, bat mitzvah, women's Rosh Chodesh groups), women scholars, and equal-rights campaigns beyond the synagogue.
Mission 2Read the source
Judge and king
> "Now Deborah, a prophetess, the wife of Lappidoth, she judged Israel at that time." (Judges 4:4, JPS 1917)
> "one from among thy brethren shalt thou set king over thee" (Deuteronomy 17:15, JPS 1917)
Maimonides, Laws of Kings 1:5 (paraphrase): from "king" (not "queen"), the rabbis learned that only men are appointed to positions of authority (serarah) in Israel.
Q1 How do supporters of women rabbis use Judges 4:4?
Show answer
A woman led and judged Israel, so female authority has biblical precedent.
Q2 How do Orthodox opponents use Deuteronomy 17:15?
Show answer
Through Maimonides, it limits communal authority to men; Deborah is treated as an exception or as an adviser.
Mission 2
Orthodox objections
Authority: Maimonides' rule against women in serarah.
Obligation: women are exempt from time-bound mitzvot like fixed prayer, so they cannot fulfil men's obligation as prayer leaders.
Community rules: a woman does not count in a minyan, and traditionally does not serve as a witness.
Modesty: concerns about kol isha (a woman's singing voice) and tzniut.
Tradition: no precedent in rabbinic history; fear of copying Reform.
Many Orthodox women answer: the roles are different but of equal dignity; the home and teaching are already leadership.
Mission 2
Orthodox women leaders today
Yoatzot halakhah (halakhic advisers), trained from 1997 at Nishmat in Jerusalem: answer women's questions on family purity laws.
Maharat title (from 2009); some graduates use Rabba or Rabbi. Rabbi Avi Weiss led this.
Opposition: the Rabbinical Council of America (2010, 2015) and the Orthodox Union (2017) ruled against ordaining or appointing women as clergy.
UK: Dina Brawer became the first British Orthodox woman ordained (2018, through Yeshivat Maharat); the United Synagogue does not appoint women rabbis.
Open Orthodox supporters: the modern rabbi is mainly a teacher and pastor, not the ancient serarah.
Quick check
?Which reason do many Orthodox authorities give for not ordaining women as rabbis?
Mission 2Diversity
Responses across movements
Haredi: reject women rabbis and feminist change as against Torah; strong honour for women's home role.
Modern Orthodox: many welcome women scholars and advisers but stop at ordination; a minority (Open Orthodox) ordain women.
Masorti / Conservative: ordain women since 1985 (JTS decision 1983), arguing from halakhic development.
Reform and Liberal: full equality; already in 1922 the American Reform rabbis (CCAR) said women could not justly be denied ordination.
Feminist critique of all: equal access to roles is only the start; the tradition itself must change (see Mission 4).
Quick check
?Which movement first ordained women rabbis, and on what basis?
Mission 2Evaluate
Development or break?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: The ordination of women is a genuine development of Judaism, not a break with it.
For: precedents (Deborah; learned women like Beruriah); Jonas argued from halakhic sources.
For: the modern rabbinate is teaching and care; women already teach Torah and give rulings (yoatzot).
Against: Maimonides' rule and the minyan and witness laws are long-standing halakhah.
Against: many Orthodox see it as importing secular feminism; the RCA and OU reject it.
Judgement criteria: what is the source of authority (halakhah, ethics, community)? What counts as continuity? Whose voice decides?
Mission check
?A Modern Orthodox synagogue appoints a woman as "scholar in residence" to teach Torah and answer questions on family purity laws, but not as rabbi. What does this best show?
The debate about women rabbis is about authority: Progressive Jews ground it in equality, Orthodox Jews in halakhah, and Orthodox feminists look for room inside the law.
Mission 3
Mission 3: Jewish law calls sex a mitzvah. So why does it also set so many limits on it?
Make a guess: Jewish law calls sex a mitzvah. So why does it also set so many limits on it?
Mission 3
Sex as a mitzvah
In Judaism, sex within marriage is holy, not shameful; marriage is called kiddushin, "holiness".
Procreation: "Be fruitful, and multiply" (Genesis 1:28, JPS 1917) is counted as the first mitzvah. The school of Hillel (Mishnah Yevamot 6:6): at least a son and a daughter.
Companionship and pleasure: a husband owes his wife onah, her "conjugal rights" (Exodus 21:10, JPS 1917): a duty to her, not to himself.
So sex has value even when children are not possible (e.g. after menopause).
Holiness also brings boundaries: when, with whom and how.
Mission 3Read the source
One flesh
> "Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife, and they shall be one flesh." (Genesis 2:24, JPS 1917)
> "If he take him another wife, her food, her raiment, and her conjugal rights, shall he not diminish." (Exodus 21:10, JPS 1917)
Q1 What does "one flesh" suggest sex is for, beyond children?
Show answer
A deep, lasting union between partners.
Q2 Whose right does Exodus 21:10 protect?
Show answer
The wife's: her husband must not reduce her food, clothing or conjugal rights.
Mission 3
Celibacy and marriage
"It is not good that the man should be alone" (Genesis 2:18, JPS 1917): marriage is the norm.
Judaism has no celibate clergy: rabbis are expected to marry.
Talmud (Yevamot 62b–63b, paraphrase): a man without a wife lives without joy, blessing or goodness.
One sage, Ben Azzai, stayed unmarried to study Torah; the Talmud records him as an exception, and criticised.
Single people are full members of the community; marriage is valued, not forced.
Marriage is a covenant; divorce (with a get) is allowed when it fails.
Quick check
?What does the mitzvah of onah (Exodus 21:10) require?
Mission 3
Prohibited relations
Leviticus 18 and 20 list the arayot ("nakedness"): forbidden relations.
They include incest, adultery, sex during niddah (a woman's monthly period and the days after), male–male intercourse ("Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind", Leviticus 18:22, JPS 1917) and bestiality.
Gilui arayot (forbidden relations) is one of three sins a Jew must die rather than commit (Sanhedrin 74a).
Sex before marriage: forbidden in Orthodox halakhah; many progressive Jews accept committed relationships before marriage.
Mission 3Diversity
Same-sex relationships
Orthodox: Leviticus 18:22 forbids male–male intercourse; rabbis also forbid sex between women (a lesser, rabbinic ban). Orientation itself is not a sin; acts are what halakhah addresses. Same-sex marriage is not recognised.
Orthodox responses vary: a 2010 US "Statement of Principles" (many Modern Orthodox rabbis) urged welcome and dignity for gay Jews; the UK Chief Rabbi's guide for Orthodox schools (2018) addresses LGBT+ pupils' wellbeing.
Masorti / Conservative (US): since 2006 allows gay and lesbian rabbis; since 2012 same-sex ceremonies.
Reform and Liberal: full equality: same-sex marriages, LGBT+ rabbis; Leviticus 18:22 read as tied to its ancient context, or outweighed by the dignity of every person made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).
Mission 3
Transgender matters
Many Orthodox authorities: a person's halakhic sex is fixed by the body at birth; surgery raises bans (e.g. on castration, Leviticus 22:24; Deuteronomy 22:5 on dress). Pastoral responses differ.
A minority Orthodox view: Rabbi Eliezer Waldenberg (1915–2006) held that after surgery a person's halakhic sex can change in some respects.
Reform and Liberal: affirm transgender and non-binary Jews; e.g. the US Union for Reform Judaism resolution (2015); liturgy for transition.
Question for all: how ancient categories (male, female) apply to modern medicine.
Spec: "transgender matters".
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the view of most Orthodox rabbis on same-sex relationships?
1972, as an Orthodox writer: defended niddah and mikveh as a cycle of death and rebirth; later (1993) rejected her own essay, saying purity laws harm women.
Argues halakhah must be rebuilt with women's voices as full partners.
Brit Ahuvim ("lovers' covenant"): a marriage ceremony based on a partnership contract, not on the traditional act of acquisition (kinyan) in which the man acquires the wife.
It is open to same-sex couples.
Critics (Orthodox): rejects the halakhic form of kiddushin.
Mission 3Evaluate
Is halakhah on sex relevant today?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Halakhah on sex is relevant in the 21st century.
For: It values sex as holy, protects the wife's rights (onah) and builds respect and boundaries into marriage.
For: Many Orthodox couples say niddah renews intimacy each month.
Against: Laws on same-sex relations and gender clash with modern equality; LGBT+ Jews may feel excluded.
Against: Most progressive Jews do not keep niddah; Adler argues purity language harms women.
Judgement criteria: Relevant to whom? Is halakhah fixed or developing? Can ancient laws be kept while their reasons are reinterpreted?
Mission check
?Avi, an Orthodox Jew, plans to take a job that will keep him away from home for months at a time. His wife has not agreed. Which Jewish teaching is most directly relevant?
In halakhah sex is a holy duty owed to a partner, which is why it comes with limits as well as rights.
Mission 4
Mission 4: If women were left out of the story at Sinai, can Jewish tradition be retold without breaking it?
Make a guess: If women were left out of the story at Sinai, can Jewish tradition be retold without breaking it?
Mission 4
Why Jewish feminism arose
Step 1 of 3
1960s–70s: second-wave feminism changed women's roles in work, law and education. Many Jewish women asked why their religious lives had not changed too.
Their questions: women could not be counted in a minyan, lead most prayer, be rabbis, or end their own marriages.
1971: Rachel Adler, then Orthodox, published "The Jew Who Wasn't There": women in halakhah treated like those exempt from many commandments.
1972: the group Ezrat Nashim presented a "Call for Change" to Conservative rabbis.
Jewish feminist theology goes further: it asks how texts, memory and images of God were shaped by men, and how they could include women.
Some feminists, such as Judith Plaskow, argue that women were left unaddressed even in the story of Sinai. Rachel Adler's answer, for marriage, is to rebuild from within Jewish sources rather than leave them.
Mission 4
Traditional marriage: acquisition and the agunah
Jewish marriage begins with kiddushin. Classical halakhah describes it as kinyan (acquisition): "a woman is acquired in three ways", by money, by document or by intercourse (Mishnah Kiddushin 1:1, paraphrase).
Today: the groom gives a ring before witnesses; the ketubah sets out his duties to his wife.
Divorce: only the husband can give a get (bill of divorce): "he writeth her a bill of divorcement, and giveth it in her hand" (Deuteronomy 24:1, JPS 1917).
If he refuses, or disappears, she cannot remarry under halakhah: she is an agunah ("chained"; plural agunot).
Your spec uses the term agunot untranslated.
Defenders: kinyan is a legal form, not ownership of a person; the ketubah protects wives.
Mission 4
Adler: Brit Ahuvim, the lovers' covenant
Rachel Adler (b. 1943), Engendering Judaism: An Inclusive Theology and Ethics (1998), chapter 5.
Her diagnosis (paraphrase): a marriage built on acquisition makes one partner the subject and the other the object. The agunah problem follows from that.
Her proposal: Brit Ahuvim ("covenant of lovers"), a marriage between two subjects.
She builds it from a different part of halakhah: the law of partnership (shutafut), used for business partners.
In the ceremony both partners place a symbolic item of value into a shared bag and lift it together: a partnership, not a purchase.
Both make promises; neither acquires the other.
Quick check
?Why does Adler build Brit Ahuvim on the Jewish law of partnership rather than on kiddushin?
Mission 4
Dissolving and reconfiguring
Dissolution: a partnership can be ended by the partners. So a Brit Ahuvim can be dissolved without a husband's get: no one can be left an agunah.
Adler also proposes a ritual for ending, so that a broken covenant is marked honestly before the community.
Inclusive: the ceremony works for same-sex couples as well as for a woman and a man.
Reconfiguring the tradition (paraphrase): Adler does not invent from nothing. She reads Jewish sources again and rebuilds from materials already inside them.
Adler's view is one of several Jewish views on marriage and same-sex relationships: Orthodox teaching keeps marriage as kiddushin between a man and a woman.
Mission 4Diversity
Orthodox and Progressive responses
Orthodox: Torah and halakhah are given by God, so change must come within halakhah. Responses to agunot: prenuptial agreements that put pressure on a husband to give a get; rabbinic courts using sanctions.
Conservative: the Lieberman clause (1954) added to the ketubah lets a rabbinic court act if a husband refuses a get.
Reform and Liberal: egalitarian worship, women rabbis, inclusive God-language, women's names (the matriarchs) in the Amidah. Many accept civil divorce or use egalitarian marriage documents.
Reconstructionist and Renewal: most open to Plaskow's new midrash and to ceremonies like Brit Ahuvim.
Critics of Plaskow and Adler: a covenant "reshaped" by each generation may stop being the covenant given at Sinai.
Quick check
?A woman's husband refuses for years to give her a get. Which response would most Orthodox rabbis support?
Mission check
?Two business friends, Dina and Leah, sign a contract to run a café together. Either can end the partnership by agreement, and the assets are shared. Which idea from Jewish marriage debates does this arrangement most closely match?
Adler and Plaskow both use Jewish sources to include women: Adler rebuilds marriage as a partnership; Plaskow widens the memory of Sinai.
Mission 5
Mission 5: The Jewish calendar counts about 5,800 years since creation. Science says 13.8 billion. Must one be wrong?
Make a guess: The Jewish calendar counts about 5,800 years since creation. Science says 13.8 billion. Must one be wrong?
Mission 5
How science challenges religion
Modern science asks for evidence and reason: claims are tested, not accepted on authority.
Some discoveries seem to clash with a plain reading of Genesis:
The Big Bang (from the 1920s–60s): the universe began about 13.8 billion years ago.
Evolution (Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 1859): life developed over billions of years by natural selection.
Genetics: humans can now read and edit DNA, raising new ethical questions.
Jewish responses range from rejection of some findings to full acceptance with a re-reading of Torah.
Your spec's three strands: evidence and reason; specific discoveries; science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking.
Mission 5
Maimonides: study nature, love God
Maimonides (1138–1204), Mishneh Torah, Foundations of the Torah 2:2 (paraphrase): contemplating God's works and seeing God's boundless wisdom in them leads to love and awe of God (full study in Mission 6).
So studying nature is a religious duty, not a threat.
> "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament showeth His handiwork" (Psalm 19:1, JPS 1917, where it is verse 2)
He also taught: where reason proves something, a Torah verse that seems to contradict it should be read figuratively (Guide for the Perplexed II.25, paraphrase).
Many Jews today use this to welcome science: discovering how nature works shows more of God's wisdom.
Mission 5Read the source
Bereshit
> "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth." (Genesis 1:1, JPS 1917)
Bereshit: "in the beginning", the first word of the Torah and the Hebrew name of Genesis.
Rashi (1040–1105), on Genesis 1:1 (paraphrase): the plain sense is "At the beginning of God's creating the heaven and the earth…"; the verse does not set out to teach the order of creation.
Nachmanides (Ramban, 1194–1270), on Genesis 1:1 (paraphrase): God created from absolute nothing a tiny substance, no bigger than a mustard seed, from which everything else came.
Creatio ex nihilo (creation from nothing): God alone is eternal; the world had a beginning (Saadia Gaon; Maimonides).
Q1 According to Rashi, what is Genesis 1 not trying to teach?
Show answer
The scientific order in which things were made.
Q2 Why do many Jews welcome the Big Bang?
Show answer
It describes a universe with a beginning, as bereshit does; Ramban's "mustard seed" is often compared to it.
Quick check
?Which statement about Jewish readings of Genesis 1 is accurate?
Mission 5Diversity
Responses to evolution
Step 1 of 4
Rejection (many Haredi Jews): six literal days; species created separately. Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson (1902–1994), the Lubavitcher Rebbe, argued in letters that science offers theories about the distant past, not proof.
Embrace through mysticism: Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook (1865–1935), first Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi of Mandatory Palestine: evolution, as gradual ascent towards perfection, fits kabbalistic teaching (paraphrase).
Modern Orthodox: Rabbi Jonathan Sacks (1948–2020), The Great Partnership (2011): science explains how things work; religion asks what they mean (paraphrase). Rabbi Natan Slifkin (b. 1975), The Challenge of Creation (2006): Torah and evolution are compatible; some Haredi rabbis banned his books in 2004–05.
Progressive (Reform, Liberal): accept evolution fully; Genesis teaches values (one Creator, a good world, human dignity), not biology.
Most Jewish movements found evolution less of a crisis than many Christian groups did: the Oral Torah had long allowed non-literal readings.
Mission 5
How old is the universe?
The Jewish calendar counts years from creation: Rosh Hashanah 2026 began the year 5787.
Science: the universe is about 13.8 billion years old; the Earth about 4.5 billion.
Jewish responses:
Literal: the world is under 6,000 years old; it was made mature (with apparent age), so evidence of age does not show real age (Schneerson's view).
Earlier worlds: a midrash says God "built worlds and destroyed them" before this one (Bereshit Rabbah 3:7, paraphrase); Rabbi Israel Lipschutz (1782–1860) linked it to fossils.
Day = age:yom (day) can mean a long period; the calendar counts from Adam, not from the first moment.
Relativity: Gerald Schroeder (next screen).
Mission 5
Gerald Schroeder: six days and 15 billion years
Step 1 of 3
Gerald Schroeder (b. 1938), MIT-trained physicist living in Jerusalem; Genesis and the Big Bang (1990), The Science of God (1997).
Einstein's relativity: time passes at different rates in different frames of reference.
The six days are told from the perspective of creation's beginning; the universe has since stretched by a factor of about a million million (10¹²).
So six days "then" equal about 15 billion years "now". Each day is half the one before: about 8, 4, 2, 1, ½ and ¼ billion years.
From Adam, time is counted in human terms: hence about 5,800 years.
Critics: scientists say the calculation uses relativity loosely; some religious critics say it reads modern science into Torah (when science changes, so must the reading).
Quick check
?How does Gerald Schroeder reconcile the six days of Genesis with the age of the universe?
Mission 5
Genetic engineering: permission to heal
Gene therapy (fixing faulty genes), embryo screening and GM crops: science as a stimulus to Jewish ethical thinking.
The Torah requires a person who injures another to "cause him to be thoroughly healed" (Exodus 21:19, JPS 1917).
The Talmud reads this as permission for the doctor to heal (Bava Kamma 85a, paraphrase): medicine is not interfering with God.
Pikuach nephesh (saving life) overrides almost every other mitzvah, so research that could cure disease is widely seen as a duty.
Humans as God's partners in creation: improving the world (Genesis 2:15: to "dress it and to keep it", JPS 1917).
Example: Dor Yeshorim (founded 1983) confidentially tests young Orthodox Jews for genetic diseases such as Tay-Sachs before matches are made.
Mission 5Diversity
Where are the limits?
Therapy vs enhancement: most rabbis support curing disease; many oppose "designer" changes for looks or intelligence.
Embryos: many authorities allow screening embryos (PGD) to avoid serious disease, since an embryo outside the womb has lower status (Rabbi Moshe Tendler, 1926–2021); others urge caution (Rabbi J. David Bleich, b. 1936). (More in an earlier lesson.)
Mixing kinds: Leviticus 19:19 forbids breeding "with a diverse kind". Most authorities say it covers cross-breeding and grafting, not gene splicing, so GM foods are generally treated as kosher; a minority disagree.
Playing God / eugenics: memories of Nazi racial science make many Jews wary of "improving" humans.
Progressive Jews: support research, with strong regulation and fair access.
Quick check
?Which reason do many Jewish authorities give for supporting gene therapy for serious disease?
Mission 5Evaluate
Is Judaism compatible with science?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Jewish belief is fully compatible with scientific thinking.
For: Maimonides made studying nature a path to loving God; reason can reshape how a verse is read.
For: Rashi and the Oral Torah never required a literal, scientific Genesis; Kook and Sacks welcome evolution.
Against: many Haredi Jews reject evolution and an old universe; the Slifkin ban shows real conflict.
Against: Schroeder-style harmonising may change Torah to fit each new theory (critics' view).
Judgement criteria: Which Jews? Compatible with scientific findings, or with science's method (evidence over authority)? Does science answer the questions Judaism asks?
Mission check
?A student says: "Judaism must reject the Big Bang, because Genesis 1:1 says God created the heaven and the earth." Which reply best reflects mainstream Jewish thought?
The clash is about how to read Genesis, not whether God created. Jews divide over evolution and the age of the world, but almost all welcome science as the study of God's works.
Mission 6
Mission 6: Can studying the stars and the cells of the body be a way of loving God?
Make a guess: Can studying the stars and the cells of the body be a way of loving God?
Mission 6
Three great works
Maimonides (Rambam, 1138–1204): rabbi, philosopher and court physician in Fustat (Old Cairo).
Commentary on the Mishnah (Arabic, c. 1168): explains each Mishnah; includes the Thirteen Principles.
Mishneh Torah (Hebrew, c. 1180): a complete code of Jewish law, in 14 books.
Guide for the Perplexed (Arabic, c. 1190): philosophy for a Jew torn between Torah and reason.
One aim runs through all three: to know God truly, and to live by the Torah with understanding.
Mission 6Read the source
Nature reveals God's glory
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Foundations of the Torah 2:2 (paraphrase):
How does a person come to love and fear God?
By contemplating God's great and wonderful works and creatures, and seeing in them God's wisdom, which has no limit.
At once the person loves, praises and longs to know God, as David said:
> "My soul thirsteth for God, for the living God" (Psalm 42:2, JPS 1917)
Then, reflecting more, the person draws back in awe, knowing how small and dark they are before God's knowledge:
> "When I behold Thy heavens, the work of Thy fingers, the moon and the stars, which Thou hast established; What is man, that Thou art mindful of him?" (Psalm 8:3–4, JPS 1917)
Q1 Which response comes first, love or awe?
Show answer
Love: wonder at God's wisdom.
Q2 What makes the person feel small?
Show answer
Comparing their own knowledge with the wisdom shown in creation.
Mission 6
Science as a path to God
For Maimonides, studying nature (physics, astronomy, biology) is not a distraction from religion: it is a commandment, part of loving God.
The rabbis' "Account of Creation" (Ma'aseh Bereshit) he identifies with physics; the "Account of the Chariot" (Ma'aseh Merkavah) with metaphysics.
He used the best science of his day (Aristotle's, Ptolemy's astronomy) and wrote medical works himself.
Glory of God: the order of nature shows God's wisdom: "How manifold are Thy works, O LORD! In wisdom hast Thou made them all" (Psalm 104:24, JPS 1917).
Today: many Jews see scientific study as a way to wonder at creation; some worry that science replaces wonder with explanation (see Mission 5).
AQA: link Maimonides to science's emphasis on evidence and reason.
Quick check
?A Jewish medical student says, "Every hour I study the human heart, I understand more of God's wisdom and feel how little I know." Which teaching of Maimonides does this best illustrate?
Mission check
?A Jewish astronomer is asked: "Doesn't explaining how stars form leave no room for God?" Which answer would Maimonides most likely give?
For Maimonides, science and Torah are two routes to the same God. Next: what Jews hope for at the end of days.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
The home is a "small sanctuary"; Orthodox Judaism teaches complementary roles, Progressive Judaism equal roles; society, secular rights and readings of Torah drive the debate.
An agunah is "chained" when a husband refuses a get; remedies include prenups, the UK 2002 Act and court pressure; Reform and Liberal Jews avoid the problem.
Minyan: Orthodox counts ten men; most Masorti and all Reform and Liberal communities count women; Orthodox feminists (JOFA) seek change within halakhah.
Mission 2
Regina Jonas (ordained 1935, murdered 1944) was the first woman rabbi; Reform ordained Sally Priesand in 1972, Britain's Jackie Tabick and Julia Neuberger followed (1975, 1977), Masorti in 1985, a small Orthodox stream from 2009.
Jewish feminism grew from second-wave feminism and Jewish women's exclusion from minyan, ordination and divorce rights, and has changed ritual, scholarship and leadership.
Orthodox objections rest on Maimonides' rule on authority, minyan and witness laws; Reform rests on equality as a Jewish value.
Mission 3
In Judaism, sex within marriage is a mitzvah: for procreation, and for closeness and pleasure (onah, the wife's right).
Celibacy is not an ideal: marriage is the norm, and rabbis marry.
Orthodox Jews forbid same-sex acts while many stress welcome for gay Jews; Reform and Liberal Jews affirm same-sex marriage.
Reform and Liberal Jews affirm transgender Jews; Rachel Adler rebuilds marriage as a partnership (Brit Ahuvim).
Mission 4
Adler: traditional marriage rests on acquisition, which leaves agunot; Brit Ahuvim is a partnership of equals that the partners can dissolve.
Mission 5
Science's evidence-based method and discoveries (Big Bang, evolution, genetics) challenge literal readings of Genesis; Jewish responses run from rejection (many Haredim) to full acceptance (Progressive), with Kook, Sacks and Slifkin in between.
Bereshit: Rashi says Genesis 1 does not teach the order of creation; Ramban's tiny first substance and creatio ex nihilo fit a universe with a beginning; Schroeder uses relativity to make six days equal about 15 billion years.
Genetic engineering: healing is permitted and a duty (Exodus 21:19; pikuach nephesh), with limits on enhancement and wariness of eugenics.
Mission 6
Contemplating nature reveals God's wisdom and glory, leading to love and then awe.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Judaism: Judaism, gender and sexuality; judaism and science for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1Some Jewish women stay married against their will for years. How can a divorce be "chained"?
Mission 2The first woman rabbi was ordained in 1935 and murdered at Auschwitz. Why did it take until 1972 for another?
Mission 3Jewish law calls sex a mitzvah. So why does it also set so many limits on it?
Mission 4If women were left out of the story at Sinai, can Jewish tradition be retold without breaking it?
Mission 5The Jewish calendar counts about 5,800 years since creation. Science says 13.8 billion. Must one be wrong?
Mission 6Can studying the stars and the cells of the body be a way of loving God?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.