🚀 Islam: Islam and the challenge of secularisation; islam, migration and religious pluralism
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2D Islam – Islam and the challenge of secularisation; 2D Islam – Islam, migration and religious pluralism
Mini-Lesson
Islam: Islam and the challenge of secularisation; islam, migration and religious pluralism
7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1How do Muslims keep their faith in a society that treats religion as private, or as nonsense?
Mission 2Muslims say giving wealth away makes the rest pure. What does Islam think money is for?
Mission 3In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 4Can British Muslims keep their faith whole and still belong fully in Britain?
Mission 5Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
Mission 6The Qur'an says only Islam is accepted by God. Can a Muslim still believe others may be saved?
Mission 7The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Mission 1
Mission 1: How do Muslims keep their faith in a society that treats religion as private, or as nonsense?
Make a guess: How do Muslims keep their faith in a society that treats religion as private, or as nonsense?
Mission 1
Three challenges of secularisation
Secularisation: religion losing influence over society, institutions and minds.
Displacement: science and reason replace religion as the source of truth and moral values.
Privatisation: religion is pushed into the personal sphere: fine at home, out of place in public life.
Militant atheism: religion is not just false but irrational and harmful (Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion, 2006; Sam Harris, The End of Faith, 2004).
Your spec allows study "with exclusive reference to the British context".
Mission 1
Why Islam resists privatisation
For Muslims, Islam is a din: a whole way of life. Many hold that tawhid (God's oneness) leaves no area outside God's guidance.
So prayer five times a day, fasting, diet and dress are public by nature.
Reason: the Qur'an repeatedly calls people to reflect: "in the creation of the heavens and the earth … there are indeed Signs for men of understanding" (Qur'an 3:190, Yusuf Ali). Muslims answer "irrational" with this tradition of reason.
Responses vary: some Muslims become more visibly devout; some keep faith mainly private; some leave religion.
Quick check
?Why do many Muslims find the privatisation of religion especially hard to accept?
Mission 1
Identity: dress and diet
Dress: modest clothing, hijab or niqab for some women, beards and caps for some men. A visible sign of belonging.
Diet: halal ("permitted") food; no pork, blood or alcohol (2:173, 5:3, 5:90). "Eat of what is on earth, Lawful and good" (Qur'an 2:168, Yusuf Ali).
Halal certification for shops and restaurants; halal options in many schools, hospitals and prisons.
Debates: slaughter without pre-stunning (campaigners want it banned; Muslim and Jewish groups defend it); whether stunned meat can be halal (certifiers differ).
Ramadan: fasting at school and work; employers and schools increasingly make room.
Mission 1
Prayer, mosques and self-reliance
Prayer: prayer rooms in workplaces, universities, airports; Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) in lunch breaks.
Places of worship: from rooms in houses (1960s) to purpose-built mosques. Britain's first purpose-built mosque: the Shah Jahan Mosque, Woking (1889). London Central Mosque opened in 1977.
Self-reliance: Muslim schools (the first state-funded, Islamia Primary, London, 1998); Islamic finance without interest; charities such as Islamic Relief (Birmingham, 1984).
Representation: the Muslim Council of Britain (1997) and other bodies speak for different groups.
Your spec: "the self-reliance of the Muslim community".
Mission 1
Democracy: vote or abstain?
Participate: many British Muslims vote; many stand for office. Muslim MPs since 1997; Sadiq Khan elected Mayor of London (2016).
Reasons: shura and the common good; protecting the community; working for justice (4:135).
Abstain: some groups (e.g. Hizb ut-Tahrir, banned in the UK since 2024) have argued that law-making belongs to God alone, so voting for man-made law is forbidden.
In between: vote on issues; lobby; join local government but avoid party politics.
Linked debate: is Islam compatible with democracy at all?
Your spec: "different attitudes to democracy and to involvement in the democratic process".
Quick check
?A British Muslim refuses to vote, saying: "Only God makes law; voting for man-made law is forbidden (haram)." Which group's position does this reflect most closely?
Mission 1
Migration and a British Muslim identity
Migration from the 1950s: South Asia, then East Africa, the Middle East, Somalia and elsewhere.
First generation: kept village customs and languages; mosques run by community elders; imams from abroad.
Later generations: separate religion from culture; English sermons; British-trained imams; "British Muslim" identity.
Diversity: Deobandi, Barelwi, Salafi, Shi'a, Sufi, converts; mosques reflect it.
Two risks Muslims discuss: assimilation (losing faith) and segregation (cutting off from society).
Mission 1Evaluate
"Muslims in Britain can keep their identity without separating from society."
Step 1 of 4
For: dress and diet are largely provided for and protected; many young Muslims hold a British Muslim identity.
For: prayer rooms, Muslim schools, charities and Islamic finance show confident participation.
For: Muslim MPs and a Muslim Mayor of London.
Against: privatisation and militant atheism press faith inwards; some fear assimilation, others choose separation.
Another view: identity changes in every age: later generations separate religion from culture.
Judge it by: What counts as Muslim identity: belief, practice or culture? Who decides? What does society demand?
AO2 tip: weigh the strongest reason on each side before your judgement.
Mission check
?A university lecturer says: "Faith is fine as a private hobby, but it should not shape what students wear, eat or do in public on campus." Which challenge of secularisation does this illustrate?
Secularisation pushes faith out of public life; many Muslims answer by keeping it visible and building their own institutions.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Muslims say giving wealth away makes the rest pure. What does Islam think money is for?
Make a guess: Muslims say giving wealth away makes the rest pure. What does Islam think money is for?
Mission 2
Wealth as a trust
All things belong to God; humans hold wealth on trust. "Believe in Allah and His messenger, and spend of that whereof He hath made you trustees" (Qur'an 57:7, Pickthall).
Wealth is good when used well: "Wealth and sons are allurements of the life of this world: But the things that endure, good deeds, are best" (Qur'an 18:46, Yusuf Ali).
It is also a test (64:15).
Hoarding is condemned (9:34); so is waste: "eat and drink: But waste not by excess" (Qur'an 7:31, Yusuf Ali).
Riba (interest, usury) is forbidden: "Allah hath permitted trade and forbidden usury" (Qur'an 2:275, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 2
Muslim responses to materialism
Materialistic secular values: success measured by income and possessions; consumer culture; religion pushed to the private sphere.
Muslim response 1: wealth is not evil in itself. Khadijah and Uthman were wealthy merchants, honoured by Muslims.
Response 2: true wealth is inner: "Richness is not having many possessions; richness is contentment of the soul" (Bukhari; Muslim; paraphrase).
Response 3: moderation: "neither prodigal nor grudging" (Qur'an 25:67, Pickthall); zuhd (detachment), stressed by Sufis.
Response 4: practical alternatives in Britain: Islamic banking and home finance without riba; ethical investment; giving through mosques and charities.
Muslims differ: some embrace prosperity as blessing; others warn that consumer culture weakens faith and the ummah.
Mission 2
Zakah: the pillar of giving
Step 1 of 3
Zakah: "purification" and "growth". Giving purifies the rest of one's wealth and the giver's heart.
"Of their goods, take alms, that so thou mightest purify and sanctify them" (Qur'an 9:103, Yusuf Ali).
2.5% of savings and trade goods held for a lunar year above the nisab (minimum; usually the value of 85 g of gold or 595 g of silver). Crops and livestock have their own rates.
Origins: commanded with prayer in the Qur'an (2:43); organised and collected under the Prophet in Madinah.
Zakat al-fitr: a small gift of food per person at the end of Ramadan, so the poor can celebrate Eid.
Mission 2Read the source
Who receives zakah?
> "Alms are for the poor and the needy, and those employed to administer the (funds); for those whose hearts have been (recently) reconciled (to Truth); for those in bondage and in debt; in the cause of Allah; and for the wayfarer" (Qur'an 9:60, Yusuf Ali)
Eight categories: the poor, the needy, collectors, new Muslims (or those whose hearts are to be won), freeing captives, debtors, "the cause of Allah", travellers in need.
Q1 Name two groups who receive zakah who are not simply "poor".
Show answer
E.g. debtors; collectors; travellers; captives.
Q2 Why might "those employed to administer" be included?
Show answer
Collecting and distributing zakah is itself a service to the ummah.
Quick check
?Which statement about zakah is accurate?
Mission 2
Sadaqah
Sadaqah (from "truth, sincerity"): voluntary giving, any amount, at any time, to anyone in need.
Hadith widen it beyond money: a smile, removing harm from a path, a kind word (Tirmidhi; Bukhari; paraphrase).
Sadaqah jariyah (ongoing charity), e.g. a well: its good continues after death. A hadith names it with useful knowledge and a righteous child as deeds that go on benefiting the dead (Muslim; paraphrase).
Giving in secret is praised: "if ye conceal them, and make them reach those (really) in need, that is best for you" (Qur'an 2:271, Yusuf Ali).
Never spoiled by boasting: "cancel not your charity by reminders of your generosity or by injury" (Qur'an 2:264, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 2
Khums
Step 1 of 3
Khums: "a fifth". "know that out of all the booty that ye may acquire (in war), a fifth share is assigned to Allah,- and to the Messenger, and to near relatives, orphans, the needy, and the wayfarer" (Qur'an 8:41, Yusuf Ali).
Sunni reading: khums applies to spoils of war and buried treasure.
Twelver Shi'a reading: the word for "acquire" covers all gain; so 20% of each year's surplus (what is left after the year's living costs).
Half, the share of the Imam, goes to a senior scholar (marja') for religious and charitable work; half, the share of the sayyids, to needy descendants of the Prophet.
Twelver Shi'a also pay zakah, on nine named kinds of wealth (crops, livestock, gold and silver coin).
Quick check
?Which statement correctly contrasts Sunni and Twelver Shi'a giving?
Mission 2Evaluate
Is wealth a danger to faith?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: For a Muslim, wealth and possessions are more a danger than a blessing.
For: "The mutual rivalry for piling up (the good things of this world) diverts you" (Qur'an 102:1, Yusuf Ali); wealth is a test (64:15).
For: Consumer culture trains desire; Sufi teachers urged zuhd.
Against: Wealth is from God and enables zakah, sadaqah and Hajj; the Prophet's wife and Companions included merchants.
Against: The danger is attachment, not wealth itself; riba-free finance shows wealth can be gained lawfully.
Criteria: Is the problem having or loving wealth? Who defines "materialism"? Does giving answer the danger?
Mission check
?Aisha, a Twelver Shi'a, gives 20% of her savings left at the end of the year (after living costs) to her marja's office. Hamza, a Sunni, gives 2.5% of savings he has held for a year above the nisab, and buys lunch for a homeless man. Which statement is correct?
Muslims see wealth as a trust from God: zakah, khums and sadaqah return part of it to those in need. Next: sawm, the pillar of fasting.
Mission 3
Mission 3: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Make a guess: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 3
Justice and the aims of punishment
"Allah commands justice, the doing of good" (Qur'an 16:90, Yusuf Ali); "when ye judge between man and man, that ye judge with justice" (Qur'an 4:58, Yusuf Ali).
Muslims believe crimes wrong God, the victim and society.
Aims of punishment in fiqh: retribution (justice for the wronged), deterrence, protection of society, reform and repentance.
Final judgement belongs to God; earthly punishment is limited and needs strict proof.
Mission 3
Hudud: fixed limits
Step 1 of 3
Hudud (singular hadd, "limit"): penalties fixed by Qur'an or Sunna, seen as God's right; a judge may not change them.
Examples: theft (5:38); unlawful sexual relations (24:2); false accusation of unchastity (24:4); armed robbery and spreading terror (hiraba, 5:33); drinking alcohol (from the Sunna).
Strict proof: e.g. four eyewitnesses for adultery (24:4); confession can be withdrawn; theft only above a minimum value and not from need.
Legal maxim: "avert the hudud by doubts" (Tirmidhi; paraphrase). Caliph Umar is reported to have suspended the theft penalty in a famine.
Today: few states apply hudud; many Muslims and scholars question whether they can be applied justly now.
Mission 3
Qisas and diya
Qisas: equal retribution for murder or deliberate injury: "life for life, eye for eye" (5:45). It limits revenge: one life for one life, never more (17:33).
The victim's family chooses: qisas; diya (compensation, "blood money"); or forgiveness.
Diya is also due for accidental killing (4:92), with an act of expiation.
A court must try the case and carry out any sentence: never private revenge.
Forgiveness is praised: "if a person forgives and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from Allah" (Qur'an 42:40, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 3Read the source
Life in the law of equality
> "But if any remission is made by the brother of the slain, then grant any reasonable demand, and compensate him with handsome gratitude, this is a concession and a Mercy from your Lord." (Qur'an 2:178, Yusuf Ali)
> "In the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life to you, o ye men of understanding; that ye may restrain yourselves." (Qur'an 2:179, Yusuf Ali)
Q1 What does 2:178 call the choice to accept compensation instead of retribution?
Show answer
A concession and a mercy from God.
Q2 How can retribution "save life" (2:179)?
Show answer
It deters killing and stops endless blood feuds.
Quick check
?A man is convicted of deliberate murder in a court applying qisas. Who decides whether he faces retribution, pays diya or is forgiven?
Mission 3
Ta'zir and maslaha
Ta'zir: discretionary punishments set by a judge or the state for offences without a fixed penalty: e.g. fraud, bribery, drug dealing, cases where hadd proof fails.
Can be fines, prison, community penalties; aimed at reform and deterrence.
Guided by maslaha (public interest): laws should protect the five essentials named by al-Ghazali (1058–1111): religion, life, intellect, lineage, property.
So the state can make new laws (traffic, cyber-crime) that serve the shari'a's purposes.
Quick check
?Which offence would normally be punished by ta'zir rather than by a hadd penalty or qisas?
Mission 3
The death penalty: a traditionalist case
In classical fiqh, death may be a penalty for: murder (qisas, unless the family forgives); hiraba (5:33); adultery by a married person (from the Sunna); apostasy (disputed today).
Sheikh Ahmad Ash-Sharabasi (1918–1980), a scholar of al-Azhar, Cairo: a traditionalist defence:
The penalty is God's law, not a human invention; Muslims may not set it aside.
It saves life: "in the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life" (2:179) by deterring murder.
It is just: the killer takes a life; justice demands the like.
It is merciful within limits: strict proof, and the family's right to forgive.
Mission 3
Modern voices: limit or pause
Tariq Ramadan (b. 1962), Swiss Muslim scholar: in 2005 he called for an international moratorium on corporal punishment, stoning and the death penalty in Muslim-majority countries.
He does not deny the texts; he argues the conditions for applying them (fair courts, a just society, freedom from poverty) are not met, and that penalties fall mostly on the poor and on women.
So scholars must debate before any such sentence is carried out.
Many Muslims in Britain and elsewhere argue that the Qur'an's preference for forgiveness (2:178, 42:40) points away from executions; others say this sets aside God's law.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes Tariq Ramadan's 2005 call on the death penalty?
Mission 3Evaluate
Can Islamic teachings on punishment be applied today?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Islamic teachings on punishment can be fully applied today.
For: they are revealed law (5:38, 24:2, 2:178); strict proof and forgiveness make them more merciful than they look.
For: qisas with family choice and diya puts victims at the centre, something many modern systems lack.
Against: many Muslims argue that the Qur'an's preference for forgiveness (2:178, 42:40) points away from executions; and errors cannot be undone.
Against: the conditions (just rulers, fair courts, no poverty) are rarely met (Ramadan).
Judge it by: Who should interpret: classical jurists or modern scholars? Is maslaha a reason to adapt? Which aims matter most: retribution, deterrence or reform?
Mission check
?A driver, keeping to the speed limit, accidentally hits and kills a pedestrian who steps into the road. What would classical Islamic law require?
Islamic criminal law ties punishment to intention and to the victim's rights: retribution for the deliberate, compensation for the accidental, mercy for those who forgive.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Can British Muslims keep their faith whole and still belong fully in Britain?
Make a guess: Can British Muslims keep their faith whole and still belong fully in Britain?
Mission 4
Coming to Britain
Step 1 of 4
Small Muslim communities existed earlier: Yemeni and Somali seamen in Cardiff, South Shields and Liverpool; the Shah Jahan Mosque, Woking (1889).
1950s–60s: men from Pakistan (many from Mirpur, Kashmir) and India (Gujarat) came to work in mills and foundries in Lancashire, Yorkshire and the Midlands.
Many planned to return. After the Commonwealth Immigrants Act 1962 tightened entry, wives and children joined them: sojourners became settlers.
1970s–80s: families from Bangladesh (Sylhet); East African Asians expelled from Uganda (1972).
1990s onwards: refugees and migrants from Somalia, Bosnia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and elsewhere; also British converts.
2021 Census, England and Wales: about 3.9 million Muslims (6.5% of the population).
Mission 4
Not one community but many
Ethnic diversity: South Asian heritage is the largest group; also Arab, Somali, Turkish, Iranian, Malaysian, Nigerian, white British and others.
Sunni traditions (most British Muslims): Deobandi (scholarly, reformist; many seminaries), Barelwi (devotional, Sufi-influenced), Salafi, the Tablighi Jamaat (preaching movement).
Shi'a: mainly Twelvers (Ithna 'Ashari); also Isma'ilis (the Nizari Isma'ilis are led by the Aga Khan).
Mosques often began along lines of village, language and school of thought.
Generations differ: many young British-born Muslims separate "culture" from "religion" and choose their own path.
Ahmadis call themselves Muslims; most Sunni and Shi'a Muslims do not accept them as such: an issue about minority groups within Islam.
Quick check
?Why did many Muslim migrant workers of the 1950s–60s change from planning to return home to settling permanently in Britain?
Mission 4
Freedom of religion and pluralism
European Convention on Human Rights (1950), Article 9: freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including to manifest belief "in worship, teaching, practice and observance". Limits allowed to protect public safety and the rights of others.
UK law: Human Rights Act 1998 brings Article 9 into British courts; Equality Act 2010 makes religion or belief a protected characteristic.
Religious pluralism: a modern secular state lets many faiths and none live side by side; the state favours none in law (in practice the Church of England remains established).
Test cases: R (Begum) v Denbigh High School (2006): the House of Lords upheld a school's refusal of the jilbab, since its uniform already included Muslim dress options.
Influence on Muslim thought: living as one faith among many sharpens debates about exclusivism and inclusivism (3:85; see Mission 6).
Mission 4Read the source
Diversity as a sign
> "O mankind! Lo! We have created you male and female, and have made you nations and tribes that ye may know one another. Lo! the noblest of you, in the sight of Allah, is the best in conduct." (Qur'an 49:13, Pickthall)
> "There is no compulsion in religion." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall)
Q1 According to 49:13, why do nations and tribes exist?
Show answer
So that people may know one another.
Q2 Which verse could a British Muslim use to support freedom of religion for all?
Show answer
2:256: faith cannot be forced.
Mission 4
Segregation, assimilation, integration
Segregation: communities live separate lives: different streets, schools, workplaces.
Assimilation: a minority is absorbed into the majority culture and loses what makes it distinct.
Integration: full part in shared life (work, law, politics) while keeping a distinct faith.
After riots in Oldham, Burnley and Bradford (2001), the Cantle Report (2001) found communities living "parallel lives".
Causes debated: cheap housing near the mills, discrimination, choice to live near family and mosque, and others moving away.
Most British Muslim bodies reject both segregation and assimilation and argue for integration.
Mission 4
Food, dress, practice, education
Food: halal meat; school meals and workplace canteens; disputes about whether halal meat must be unstunned.
Dress: hijab worn widely; the face veil (niqab) debated in schools, courts and work. Some women choose no headscarf.
Practice: Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) in work or school time; prayer rooms; fasting in Ramadan during exams.
Education: evening Qur'an classes (madrasas); state-funded Muslim schools since 1998 (Islamia Primary, Brent); RE and sex education debates.
Self-reliance: communities built their own mosques, halal shops, funeral services, charities (e.g. Islamic Relief, Birmingham, 1984) and Islamic banking.
Mission 4Diversity
Taking part in democracy?
Participation (majority view): vote, stand for election, lobby. Basis: shura (consultation): believers are those "whose affairs are a matter of counsel" (Qur'an 42:38, Pickthall); also the common good (maslaha) and keeping agreements.
Examples: first Muslim MP (1997); first Muslim to serve in the Cabinet (2010); a Muslim Mayor of London (2016).
Rejection (a small minority): sovereignty belongs to God alone, so man-made law cannot be supported; voting is avoided. Hizb ut-Tahrir argued this; it was banned in the UK in 2024.
Quietism: some Salafis avoid politics but obey the law.
Quick check
?A Muslim teenager in Bradford wears hijab, prays at school, plays in a mixed football team and plans to study law. Which term best describes her approach?
Mission 4
The Muslim Council of Britain
Founded 1997: an umbrella body of affiliated mosques, schools, charities and professional groups (it reports over 500).
Aims: a united voice for British Muslims; the common good; fighting discrimination.
Work: guidance to mosques (e.g. during Covid-19); Visit My Mosque days (from 2015); voter guides; advocacy on Islamophobia.
First woman Secretary-General: Zara Mohammed (2021).
Criticisms: not elected by ordinary Muslims; weighted to some Sunni South Asian groups; Shi'a, Sufi and other bodies (e.g. the British Muslim Forum, 2005) formed their own voices.
UK governments have largely avoided formal engagement with it since 2009; the MCB calls this unjust.
Mission 4Evaluate
Can Muslims keep their identity in secular Britain?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Muslims in Britain can fully belong without losing their religious identity.
For: strong legal protection (Article 9, Equality Act); thriving mosques, schools, halal economy; many British-born Muslims are both confident Muslims and active citizens.
For: 49:13 gives religious grounds for taking part.
For: so does the shura tradition (consultation, 42:38).
Against: secular values (privacy of religion, alcohol-based social life, sexual ethics) pull young people away; some lose practice.
Against: Islamophobia and discrimination push some towards separate lives; dress codes and halal rules still cause conflict.
Judge it by: What counts as "identity": belief, practice, or community? Is assimilation ever possible without loss? Who decides?
Quick check
?Which criticism of the Muslim Council of Britain is most often made by other Muslims?
Mission check
?A Muslim nurse in a London hospital asks to wear a long-sleeved tunic and a close-fitting headscarf, and to take her prayer break at a set time. The hospital agrees, with hygiene rules followed. What does this show?
Keeping a faith whole in a secular society is often a matter of negotiation: what is essential, and what can adapt?
Mission 5
Mission 5: Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
Make a guess: Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
Mission 5
Justice at the heart of revelation
'Adl and qist: justice, fairness, putting things in their right place.
Muslims believe God sent prophets with scripture and "the Balance (of Right and Wrong), that men may stand forth in justice" (Qur'an 57:25, Yusuf Ali).
"Allah commands justice, the doing of good, and liberality to kith and kin" (Qur'an 16:90, Yusuf Ali).
The poor: zakah is their right, not a favour (9:60;). Surah 107 links denying the Judgement with failing to feed the poor.
The oppressed (mustad'afun): the Qur'an asks why believers do not act for "those who, being weak, are ill-treated (and oppressed)" (Qur'an 4:75, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 5Read the source
Justice even against yourself
> "O ye who believe! stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to Allah, even as against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be (against) rich or poor" (Qur'an 4:135, Yusuf Ali)
> "let not the hatred of others to you make you swerve to wrong and depart from justice. Be just: that is next to piety" (Qur'an 5:8, Yusuf Ali)
Q1 Against whom must a believer be ready to give just witness?
Show answer
Themselves, parents, relatives; rich or poor alike.
Q2 What must not bend a Muslim's justice, according to 5:8?
Show answer
Hatred of others, even enemies.
Mission 5
Enjoining good, forbidding wrong
Al-amr bil-ma'ruf wal-nahy 'an al-munkar: "enjoining what is right, and forbidding what is wrong" (Qur'an 3:104, Yusuf Ali); also 3:110 and 9:71 (believing men and women).
Hadith: whoever sees a wrong should change it with his hand; if he cannot, with his tongue; if he cannot, with his heart, the weakest faith (Muslim; paraphrase).
Fard kifaya: a communal duty. If enough people do it, the rest are released. ("Let there arise out of you a band of people", 3:104.)
Protecting rights (classical limits): no spying ("spy not on each other", 49:12); no breaking into homes; act only on wrongs that are open and agreed; never cause a greater harm.
Historic office: the muhtasib (market inspector) checked weights, prices and public conduct.
Quick check
?What does it mean to call "enjoining good and forbidding wrong" a fard kifaya?
Mission 5
Ali Shari'ati: religion as revolution
Ali Shari'ati (1933–1977), Iranian sociologist; doctorate in Paris (1964), where he read Frantz Fanon and debated existentialists and Marxists.
Marxist influence: history as a struggle between oppressors and oppressed (he read Cain and Abel this way). But he rejected Marxist materialism: faith drives liberation.
Red Shi'ism of Ali (protest, martyrdom, justice) vs Black Shi'ism of the Safavids (state religion, passive mourning, waiting).
Criticism: of religion serving power, in the caliphs' official Sunnism and in apolitical, clerical Shi'ism.
Husayn at Karbala: a model of active resistance to tyranny, not only grief.
Lectures at the Husayniyeh Ershad, Tehran (1967–72); imprisoned (1973–75); died in England in 1977. His ideas inspired many young revolutionaries of 1979.
Mission 5
Abdal Hakim Murad: the forgotten revolution
Abdal Hakim Murad (Timothy Winter, b. 1960), Cambridge scholar; founding Dean of Cambridge Muslim College.
Essay "Islamic Spirituality: the Forgotten Revolution" (1990s): modern Islamist revivalism is outward, angry and political; it has forgotten the purification of the soul (tazkiyah) (paraphrase).
Anger without inner change produces extremism and fails the oppressed.
Traditionalist Sufi approach: renew the heart through the classical spiritual tradition; then just action follows.
"Activism within": the first struggle is with the self (the greater jihad).
Support often cited: "Verily never will Allah change the condition of a people until they change it themselves (with their own souls)." (Qur'an 13:11, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 5
Liberationist approaches
Liberationist: reading the Qur'an from the side of the poor and oppressed, and acting to change unjust structures, not only to give charity.
Farid Esack (b. 1959), South Africa: fought apartheid with the Call of Islam movement, alongside Christians and others; Qur'an, Liberation and Pluralism (1997): God sides with the oppressed (paraphrase).
Asghar Ali Engineer (1939–2013), India: Islam and Liberation Theology (1990): Islam began as a movement for the weak against the rich of Makkah (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement best describes a liberationist approach in Islam?
Mission 5Evaluate
"The struggle for justice must begin within the self."
Step 1 of 4
For: 13:11; Murad's "activism within": change begins by purifying the heart (tazkiyah).
For: Murad: outward activism without tazkiyah turns to anger.
Against: 4:75 demands action for the oppressed now; liberationists such as Esack: waiting for inner perfection serves the oppressor.
Against: enjoining good with the hand comes first in the hadith; Shari'ati called for active resistance.
Another view: inner and outer struggle belong together: justice (4:135) and a purified heart are two sides of one faith.
Judge it by: What does the Qur'an put first? What has worked in history (e.g. South Africa)? Who suffers while Muslims wait?
History to weigh: Iran 1979.
AO2 tip: compare two named thinkers directly, not one after the other.
Mission check
?A Muslim food-bank volunteer says: "Food parcels are not enough. The Qur'an sides with the oppressed (4:75), so we must also campaign against the low wages and bad housing that cause poverty, with people of any faith." Which approach is this?
Justice is a command for every Muslim; thinkers differ on whether to start with society or the soul.
Mission 6
Mission 6: The Qur'an says only Islam is accepted by God. Can a Muslim still believe others may be saved?
Make a guess: The Qur'an says only Islam is accepted by God. Can a Muslim still believe others may be saved?
Mission 6
One religion, many prophets
Islam means "submission" to God. Muslims believe it is the religion of every prophet, from Adam to Muhammad.
Abraham, Moses and Jesus are prophets of Islam in this sense: they submitted to the one God.
Muslims believe God sent earlier scriptures: Tawrat (to Moses), Zabur (to David), Injil (to Jesus).
The Qur'an is the final revelation; Muhammad is the seal of the prophets (33:40).
So Islam does not see itself as a new religion, but as the original one restored.
Mission 6Read the source
The one religion
> "The Religion before Allah is Islam (submission to His Will)" (Qur'an 3:19, Yusuf Ali)
> "The same religion has He established for you as that which He enjoined on Noah … and that which We enjoined on Abraham, Moses, and Jesus" (Qur'an 42:13, Yusuf Ali)
> "We make no difference between one and another of them: And we bow to Allah (in Islam)." (Qur'an 2:136, Yusuf Ali)
Q1 Does 3:19 mean the religion founded in 7th-century Arabia, or submission to God in any age?
Show answer
Both readings exist: this is the key debate.
Q2 What does 2:136 say about the earlier prophets?
Show answer
Muslims believe in all of them and make no distinction among them.
Mission 6
People of the Book
Ahl al-kitab: Jews and Christians, who received earlier scripture. Sabians are named too (2:62). Classical law treated Zoroastrians in a similar way.
Shared ground: their food and marriage to their chaste women are lawful for Muslims (5:5). "Our Allah and your Allah is one" (Qur'an 29:46, Yusuf Ali).
Call to common terms: "come to common terms as between us and you: That we worship none but Allah" (Qur'an 3:64, Yusuf Ali).
Mixed verdicts: some of them "stand (For the right)" (Qur'an 3:113, Yusuf Ali); others are criticised for changing God's word (2:75).
Tahrif (alteration): did they change the text of their scriptures, or only its meaning? Muslim scholars differ.
Quick check
?Which statement about the People of the Book in the Qur'an is accurate?
Mission 6
Exclusivism
Step 1 of 3
Exclusivism: salvation only through Islam as brought by Muhammad.
> "If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah), never will it be accepted of him" (Qur'an 3:85, Yusuf Ali)
Many classical scholars: once the message has properly reached someone, salvation requires accepting it.
Some reported that 3:85 abrogated the gentler 2:62 (a report from Ibn Abbas in al-Tabari's commentary).
Hadith: any Jew or Christian who hears of the Prophet and dies without believing in his message is among the people of the Fire (Muslim; paraphrase).
Exclusivism is about salvation, not about how to treat others: many exclusivists also defend kindness and justice to non-Muslims (60:8).
Your spec: "its basis in the Qur'an, 3:85".
Mission 6
Inclusivism
Step 1 of 3
Inclusivism: Islam is the fullest truth, but sincere followers of other faiths may also be saved.
Abrahamic: "Those who believe … and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures), and the Christians and the Sabians,- any who believe in Allah and the Last Day, and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord" (Qur'an 2:62, Yusuf Ali). Repeated at 5:69.
Different paths: "To each among you have we prescribed a law and an open way" (Qur'an 5:48, Yusuf Ali).
Non-Abrahamic: "there never was a people, without a warner having lived among them" (Qur'an 35:24, Yusuf Ali). Some Muslims ask whether figures in other traditions were such warners.
Example: the Mughal prince Dara Shikoh (1615–1659), Majma' al-Bahrayn (The Meeting of the Two Seas, 1655), compared Sufi and Hindu Upanishadic ideas.
Pluralism goes further: all religions are equally valid paths. Most Muslim inclusivists stop short of this.
Mission 6
Good deeds without faith?
No reward: the deeds of those who reject faith become "floating dust scattered about" (Qur'an 25:23, Yusuf Ali).
Hadith: Aisha asked about Ibn Jud'an, a generous man of the pre-Islamic era; the Prophet said his deeds would not benefit him, because he never once asked God to forgive his sins on the Day of Judgement, that is, he never believed in it (Muslim; paraphrase).
Some reward: "anyone who has done an atom's weight of good, see it!" (Qur'an 99:7, Yusuf Ali).
The Prophet's uncle Abu Talib, who protected him but did not accept Islam, receives the lightest punishment (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
Mercy: "My mercy extendeth to all things" (Qur'an 7:156, Yusuf Ali). Many argue God judges each person by what reached them.
Your spec: "whether good deeds without faith in God or Islam are rewarded by God".
Quick check
?A Muslim says: "Islam is the complete truth, but a sincere Christian who lives righteously may still be rewarded by God (2:62)." Which view is this?
Mission 6
Muslims who disagree about who is Muslim
Takfir: declaring another Muslim an unbeliever. Mainstream scholars treat it with great caution.
The Amman Message (2004–05): hundreds of scholars recognised eight schools (four Sunni, Ja'fari and Zaydi Shi'a, Ibadi, Zahiri) and forbade takfir of their followers.
Ahmadiyya (founded 1889, India): Ahmadis regard themselves as Muslims. Most Sunni and Shi'a scholars hold that their belief about prophethood after Muhammad puts them outside Islam. Pakistan declared them non-Muslim by law (1974).
In Britain, Ahmadis have their own mosques, e.g. the Fazl Mosque, London (1926); most other Muslim bodies do not include them.
Sufis and Salafis: some Salafis condemn Sufi practices such as visiting shrines; Sufis defend them from Qur'an and Sunnah.
Your spec: "attitudes within Islam to minority Muslim groups".
Mission 6Evaluate
"Islam is an exclusivist religion."
Step 1 of 4
For: 3:85 and the hadith in Muslim; the finality of the Prophet (33:40); classical majority views on salvation after the message has reached someone.
Against: 2:62, 5:69 and 5:48; every people had a warner (35:24); the word islam means submission (Madjid); mercy "extendeth to all things" (7:156).
Another view: Islam is exclusive about truth but inclusive about mercy: God alone judges who received the message properly.
Judge it by: Which verses are read in light of which? Is abrogation accepted? Does "Islam" mean a community or an attitude? Is the question salvation, or how Muslims treat others?
Mission check
?A Muslim hospital chaplain is asked by a dying Hindu patient: "Will God reward my lifetime of charity?" Which reply expresses an inclusivist Muslim view that reaches beyond the People of the Book?
Muslims share the same verses but weigh them differently. Freedom of religion and minority rights come next.
Mission 7
Mission 7: The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Make a guess: The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Mission 7Read the source
No compulsion
> "Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error" (Qur'an 2:256, Yusuf Ali)
> "There is no compulsion in religion. The right direction is henceforth distinct from error." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall)
Setting (reported from Ibn Abbas, Abu Dawud): some Madinan Muslims had sons raised as Jews and wanted to force them into Islam. The verse forbade it.
Related: "wilt thou then compel mankind, against their will, to believe!" (Qur'an 10:99, Yusuf Ali).
Q1 Why can there be no compulsion, according to the verse?
Show answer
Truth is already clear from error; faith must be a free response.
Q2 Why does the setting matter?
Show answer
It shows the verse applied even to Muslims' own children.
Mission 7
How far does 2:256 reach?
All agree: forced conversion is invalid, because faith is in the heart.
Some classical scholars: 2:256 was abrogated by later verses of war (9:5, 9:29).
Others: it was never abrogated, but applies to People of the Book, who may keep their religion under protection.
Most modern scholars: a universal principle of freedom of belief, backed by 10:99 and 18:29 ("Let him who will believe, and let him who will, reject (it)" (Qur'an 18:29, Yusuf Ali)).
The hard question: does 2:256 also protect a Muslim who leaves Islam?
Quick check
?Which statement about Qur'an 2:256 is accurate?
Mission 7
Apostasy in classical law
Ridda: apostasy, leaving Islam. Murtadd: an apostate.
Qur'an: condemns apostasy and warns of punishment in the Hereafter (2:217, 4:137). It names no worldly penalty.
Hadith: whoever changes his religion is to be killed (Bukhari; paraphrase). Another hadith lists leaving religion and separating from the community among the three cases where life may be taken (Bukhari, Muslim).
Classical rulings (the four Sunni schools): an adult, sane, willing male apostate is invited to repent; if he refuses, death. Hanafis: a woman is imprisoned, not executed. Ja'fari law is similar, but stricter for a man born Muslim.
Other effects: marriage dissolved; no inheritance from Muslim relatives.
Context: early apostasy often meant revolt: the Ridda wars under Abu Bakr (632–633).
Mission 7
Apostasy laws today
Death penalty possible: in a few states, e.g. Iran and Saudi Arabia, courts may apply it, though executions for apostasy alone are rare.
Civil effects only: e.g. Egypt has no apostasy crime, but in 1995 a court declared the scholar Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd an apostate and dissolved his marriage; he moved to the Netherlands.
Traditional view: the classical ruling stands, because the hadith are sound.
Reformist view: the penalty was for treason and armed revolt, not change of belief; 2:256 and 18:29 protect belief (e.g. Abdullah Saeed and Hassan Saeed, Freedom of Religion, Apostasy and Islam, 2004).
Hadd debate: some scholars hold a fixed penalty cannot rest on a single-chain hadith alone.
Quick check
?Which argument do reformist scholars such as Abdullah Saeed use about apostasy?
Mission 7
Freedom of expression and offence
The Satanic Verses (1988): protests in Britain, a book burned in Bradford (January 1989); Ayatollah Khomeini's fatwa (February 1989).
Cartoons of the Prophet: Denmark (2005); the Charlie Hebdo attack in Paris (2015), condemned by the Muslim Council of Britain and most Muslim bodies.
Responses from sources: "Revile not ye those whom they call upon besides Allah" (Qur'an 6:108, Yusuf Ali): respect for others' faith; "when the ignorant address them, they say, 'Peace!'" (Qur'an 25:63, Yusuf Ali).
Legal routes: England's blasphemy law protected only Christianity, and was abolished in 2008; the Racial and Religious Hatred Act (2006) covers incitement to hatred, not insult.
Muslims' own freedom: Switzerland banned new minarets by referendum (2009); bans on face-coverings.
Your spec: "Muslim responses to issues of freedom of religious expression in society".
Mission 7Evaluate
"Islam supports freedom of belief."
Step 1 of 4
For: 2:256, 18:29; no worldly penalty for apostasy in the Qur'an.
Against: classical law punished apostasy by death; some states today restrict conversion, blasphemy and minority worship.
Another view: distinguish the Qur'an, classical law (fiqh) and state practice: they may answer differently.
Judge it by: freedom to hold, to practise, or to change a belief? Which sources carry most weight? Does historical context limit a ruling?
Mission check
?A modern Muslim scholar notes: "The people punished for leaving Islam in the Prophet's time had also joined armies fighting the Muslims. And 2:256 forbids forcing belief." Which conclusion is she most likely drawing?
The same verse, 2:256, sits beside classical rulings on apostasy and dhimma. How Muslims read their context decides the answer.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Secularisation: displacement, privatisation and militant atheism; Islam as din resists privatisation.
Identity is kept through dress, diet, prayer, mosques and self-reliant institutions; Muslims differ on voting.
Mission 2
Wealth belongs to God and is held on trust; hoarding, waste and riba are condemned.
Zakah (2.5% above the nisab, eight groups), sadaqah (voluntary, any good deed) and, for Twelver Shi'a, khums (a fifth of yearly surplus).
Muslim responses to materialism: wealth is not evil, but true wealth is contentment; moderation and riba-free finance.
Mission 3
Three categories: hudud (fixed, strict proof), qisas (retribution, with diya or forgiveness by the family), ta'zir (discretion, guided by maslaha).
Death penalty: a traditionalist defence (Ash-Sharabasi); many Muslims stress forgiveness instead.
Tariq Ramadan calls for a moratorium.
Mission 4
Muslim migration to Britain grew from the 1950s; family settlement after 1962 built mosques, halal food and schools; British Muslims are diverse in ethnicity and school of thought.
Segregation, assimilation and integration are different responses; most Muslim bodies seek integration, protected by freedom of religion (Article 9).
The Muslim Council of Britain (1997) aims to speak for British Muslims; its representativeness is debated.
Mission 5
Justice ('adl) is central: 57:25, 4:135, 5:8; the poor have a right to zakah; the Qur'an calls for action for the oppressed (4:75).
Shari'ati: revolutionary "red Shi'ism"; Murad: the forgotten inner revolution; liberationists (Esack, Engineer) side with the poor.
Mission 6
Muslims see Islam (submission) as the religion of all prophets (3:19, 42:13, 2:136); Jews and Christians are People of the Book.
Exclusivists stress 3:85; inclusivists stress 2:62, 5:48 and 35:24; pluralism goes further than most Muslims accept.
Debates also arise over who counts as Muslim (Amman Message; Ahmadiyya).
Mission 7
2:256: no compulsion in religion; all agree forced conversion is invalid; its reach to apostasy is debated.
Classical law punished apostasy; reformists link the penalty to treason.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Islam: Islam and the challenge of secularisation; islam, migration and religious pluralism for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1How do Muslims keep their faith in a society that treats religion as private, or as nonsense?
Mission 2Muslims say giving wealth away makes the rest pure. What does Islam think money is for?
Mission 3In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
Mission 4Can British Muslims keep their faith whole and still belong fully in Britain?
Mission 5Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
Mission 6The Qur'an says only Islam is accepted by God. Can a Muslim still believe others may be saved?
Mission 7The Qur'an says "no compulsion in religion". So why do some laws punish leaving Islam?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.