← A-Level Religious Studies · AQA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2A Buddhism – Good conduct and key moral principles
Mini-Lesson

Buddhism: Good conduct and key moral principles

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If there is no fixed self, who chooses to act, and who is to blame?
  2. Mission 2Buddhists keep precepts that no god commands. So what happens when one is broken?
  3. Mission 3Pali texts show the Buddha eating meat he was given. So must a Buddhist be vegetarian to avoid harm?
  4. Mission 4A soldier asked the Buddha if warriors who die in battle go to heaven. Why did he refuse to answer?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Buddhism: Self, death and afterlife.

Mission 1

Mission 1: If there is no fixed self, who chooses to act, and who is to blame?

Make a guess: If there is no fixed self, who chooses to act, and who is to blame?

Mission 1

Why conduct matters

  • Good conduct (sila) is the first of the three trainings and the base of the whole path.
  • It is not obedience to a creator: no god commands it. It is training: conduct that leads to less suffering for oneself and others.
  • One verse sums up the Buddha's teaching in three parts:

> "Not to commit any sin, to do good, and to purify one's mind, that is the teaching of (all) the Awakened." (Dhammapada 183, Müller 1881)

  • "Sin" is Müller's 1881 word; Buddhists today say unskilful or unwholesome action, not offence against God.
  • Ethics matters for this life (calm, trust, no remorse), for future lives (karma) and for awakening (a clear mind).
Mission 1

Intention is karma

  • "It is intention (cetana), monks, that I call karma": having intended, one acts by body, speech and mind (paraphrase, Nibbedhika Sutta, Anguttara Nikaya 6.63).
  • So karma is not the outward act alone: it is the will behind the act.
  • Two people may do the same thing (give money) with different intentions (kindness; showing off): the karmic weight differs.
  • An accident with no intention to harm is not karmically the same as deliberate harm.
  • Intention shapes the mind that acts again: habits form, and character is built.
  • Your spec term: karma.
Mission 1Read the source

The mind comes first

> "All that we are is the result of what we have thought: it is founded on our thoughts, it is made up of our thoughts. If a man speaks or acts with an evil thought, pain follows him, as the wheel follows the foot of the ox that draws the carriage." (Dhammapada 1, Müller 1881)

  • Verse 2 is the pair: speak or act "with a pure thought" and happiness follows "like a shadow that never leaves him".

Q1 What does the image of the wheel and the ox say about how results follow actions?

Show answer

They follow as surely as a cart wheel follows the ox: the result is tied to the mind that acted.

Q2 Where does the verse place the source of good and bad action?

Show answer

In the mind: thought comes first, then speech and action.

  • Dhammapada chapter 1, "The Twin-Verses", is the standard source for intention.
Mission 1

Kusala and akusala

Roots of actionactionroots in the mindgreed(lobha)hatred(dosa)delusion(moha)akusala(unhealthy)generosity(non-greed)loving-kindness(non-hatred)wisdom(non-delusion)kusala(healthy)
  • Kusala: healthy, skilful, wholesome. Akusala: unhealthy, unskilful, unwholesome.
  • The test is the root in the mind, not a rule. Three akusala roots: greed (lobha), hatred (dosa), delusion (moha): the three poisons.
  • Three kusala roots: non-greed (generosity), non-hatred (loving-kindness), non-delusion (wisdom).
  • Kusala acts lead to happiness and are praised by the wise; akusala acts lead to harm for oneself and others (Kalama Sutta, Anguttara Nikaya 3.65, paraphrase).
  • "Healthy" fits the image of the Buddha as a doctor: akusala states are a sickness of the mind.
  • Your spec translates kusala as "healthy" and akusala as "unhealthy".
Quick check
?Two people each give £50 to a children's hospital. One gives out of care for the sick children; the other gives so that her name appears on the donors' board. How would most Buddhists assess the two acts?
Mission 1Diversity

The Buddha and the Jains on intention

  • According to the Upali Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 56), the Jains of the Buddha's time held that bodily action (the "rod" of the body) is the most blameworthy kind of action.
  • In the Upali Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 56) the Buddha argues that mental action is the most blameworthy (paraphrase).
  • His example: a Jain who keeps a strict vow against killing tiny creatures, yet walks about and unknowingly crushes them: is he guilty? The Jain lay follower Upali admits that his own teacher does not count unintended harm as greatly blameworthy, so the weight lies in the mind after all.
  • So for Buddhists, careless harm still matters (heedlessness is itself unskilful), but deliberate harm weighs most.
  • This is why Buddhist ethics is often called an ethic of intention. This is the Buddhist account of the debate; Jain teaching also weighs intention, and stresses great care not to harm even insects.
Mission 1

Karma is not fate

  • The Buddha rejects three views that make effort pointless (Titthayatana Sutta, Anguttara Nikaya 3.61, paraphrase):
  • Everything is caused by past karma; everything is caused by a creator God; everything happens without cause.
  • If any were true, there would be no reason to choose what is right now.
  • Not all pain comes from past karma: illness can come from bile, phlegm, wind, seasons, careless living or assault, as well as karma (Sivaka Sutta, Samyutta Nikaya 36.21, paraphrase).
  • So karma is a tendency, not a script: past actions shape conditions; present intention decides the response.
  • Say: "karma conditions, it does not compel" — not: "karma means everything is fated".
Mission 1

Responsible without a fixed self

Stream, not selfQuestions of King Milinda, Book II (paraphrase)1 mangoplanted2 tree growsfrom it3 mangoestaken by a thiefDifferent mango, same causal stream: stilltheft.
  • Anatta: there is no fixed, unchanging self. So who is responsible?
  • Questions of King Milinda (Book II, paraphrase): a man steals mangoes and argues that they are not the mangoes the owner planted. He is still guilty: the stolen mangoes grew from those planted.
  • In the same way, the person who acts and the person who meets the result are neither the same nor another: a continuous stream of causes.
  • Responsibility follows the causal continuity, not a soul.

> "By oneself the evil is done, by oneself one suffers; by oneself evil is left undone, by oneself one is purified." (Dhammapada 165, Müller 1881)

Quick check
?A student says: "If karma decides everything, nothing I choose now makes any difference." Which response fits the Buddha's teaching?
Mission 1Evaluate

How free are we, if everything is conditioned?

How free are we, if everything is conditioned?Claim: Buddhism leaves room for real freewill and moral responsibility.ForThe Buddha rejects fatalism: not allexperience comes from past karma (AN3.61; SN 36.21).Mindfulness opens a gap between afeeling and a reaction: the more aware themind, the freer the choice.AgainstDependent origination: every mental eventis conditioned, so a choice is one moreconditioned event.Without a self, it is unclear who chooses;critics say "responsibility" is only a labelfor a causal chain.One replyA middle way: neither strict determinismnor uncaused choice; freedom comes indegrees and grows with practice. Criticsanswer that this is not what they mean byfree will.Judge it byDoes "conditioned" mean "determined"? ·Does responsibility require a self? · Does theMilinda reply work?
  • Claim: Buddhism leaves room for real free will and moral responsibility.
  • For: The Buddha rejects fatalism and denies that all experience comes from past karma (AN 3.61; SN 36.21).
  • For: Mindfulness opens a gap between a feeling and a reaction: the more aware the mind, the freer the choice (a point many modern Buddhist teachers stress).
  • Against: Dependent origination says every mental event is conditioned; a choice is one more conditioned event.
  • Against: Without a self, it is unclear who chooses; critics say "responsibility" becomes only a label for a causal chain.
  • Another view: some Buddhists reply with a middle way: neither strict determinism nor uncaused choice; freedom comes in degrees and grows with practice. Critics answer that a freedom produced by prior conditions and training is not what they mean by free will.
  • Judgement criteria: Does "conditioned" mean "determined"? Does responsibility require a self? Does the Milinda reply work?
Mission 1

Keown: kusala as virtue

  • Damien Keown, The Nature of Buddhist Ethics (1992): an action is kusala because it expresses and builds virtue, not because its results are good.
  • He compares this with virtue ethics: the goal is a person whose intentions are wholly rooted in generosity, kindness and wisdom.
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944): wholesome roots are trained through sila, so good conduct becomes natural rather than forced (paraphrase of his teaching on the path).
  • Other readings: some scholars see karma-based ethics as closer to consequentialism (kusala because it leads to happiness).
Mission 1Worked answer

Intention, source, development

Question: Explain the importance of intention in Buddhist ethics.

  • Point: For Buddhists, karma is intention. Source: the Buddha's teaching in Anguttara Nikaya 6.63 that intention is what he calls karma. Development: so an action is kusala or akusala according to the root in the mind (greed, hatred, delusion, or their opposites), not just its outward form.
  • Point: Intention shapes future character. Source: Dhammapada 1–2: pain follows an evil thought "as the wheel follows the foot of the ox"; happiness follows a pure thought "like a shadow". Development: repeated intentions become habits, so training the mind is training conduct.
  • Point: Contrast sharpens the answer: the Buddha's emphasis on mental action against the Jain stress on bodily action (Majjhima Nikaya 56).
  • AO1 tip: accurate terms (kusala, akusala, cetana), a source for each point, and a developed explanation, not a list.
Mission check

?A driver, fully alert and keeping to the speed limit, hits a dog that runs into the road. A second driver deliberately swerves to hit a dog for fun, but misses. Which judgement fits Buddhist teaching on intention?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Buddhists keep precepts that no god commands. So what happens when one is broken?

Make a guess: Buddhists keep precepts that no god commands. So what happens when one is broken?

Mission 2

Training rules, not commandments

The five precepts"I undertake the training ruleto abstain from …"Abstain fromGrow instead1Killing or harming livingbeingspanatipataloving-kindness(metta) andcompassion2Taking what is notgivenadinnadanagenerosity (dana)3Sexual misconductkamesu micchacaracontentment andfaithfulness4False speechmusavadatruthfulness5Intoxicating drinks anddrugs that causeheedlessnesssura-meraya-majja-pamadatthanamindfulness andclarity
  • Each precept is a sikkhapada: a training rule (literally a "step of training").
  • The formula is spoken in the first person: "I undertake the training rule to abstain from …" (sikkhapadam samadiyami).
  • No god gives them and no one enforces them on lay people: they are undertaken voluntarily, usually after going for refuge.
  • Breaking one is not a sin against God. It is akusala action with karmic results (see Mission 1); the response is to recognise it, resolve again and retake the precept.
  • They describe how an awakened person naturally behaves; for everyone else they are aspirations to train towards.
Mission 2

The five precepts

The five precepts"I undertake the training ruleto abstain from …"Abstain fromGrow instead1Killing or harming livingbeingspanatipataloving-kindness(metta) andcompassion2Taking what is notgivenadinnadanagenerosity (dana)3Sexual misconductkamesu micchacaracontentment andfaithfulness4False speechmusavadatruthfulness5Intoxicating drinks anddrugs that causeheedlessnesssura-meraya-majja-pamadatthanamindfulness andclarity
  • I undertake the training rule to abstain from:
  • 1 Killing or harming living beings (panatipata).
  • 2 Taking what is not given (adinnadana).
  • 3 Sexual misconduct (kamesu micchacara).
  • 4 False speech (musavada).
  • 5 Intoxicating drinks and drugs that cause heedlessness (sura-meraya-majja-pamadatthana).
  • Lay Buddhists in Theravada countries often chant them in Pali at the temple, after the three refuges.
  • The fifth protects the other four: an intoxicated mind breaks precepts more easily.
  • Your spec term: ahimsa (non-harming) is the principle behind the first precept (see Mission 3).
Mission 2

The positive side

  • Each restraint has a positive quality to grow:
  • 1 not harming → loving-kindness (metta) and compassion.
  • 2 not stealing → generosity (dana).
  • 3 no sexual misconduct → contentment and faithfulness.
  • 4 no false speech → truthfulness.
  • 5 no intoxicants → mindfulness and clarity.
  • This pairing is widely taught today (e.g. the Triratna "positive precepts"; Thich Nhat Hanh's Five Mindfulness Trainings, which reword the precepts as commitments).
  • So the precepts are about building character, not only avoiding acts (kusala roots).
Quick check
?A lay Buddhist lies to her manager to cover a mistake, then regrets it. What response best fits the precepts as training rules?
Mission 2

When is a precept broken?

  • Theravada commentaries list factors that must all be present for a full breach. For the first precept (paraphrase, as set out by Bhikkhu Bodhi):
  • 1 a living being; 2 knowing it is a living being; 3 the intention to kill; 4 an effort to kill; 5 death results.
  • So stepping on an unseen ant does not break the first precept; intending to kill and failing is still akusala, though the precept is not fully broken.
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944), Going for Refuge and Taking the Precepts (1981): the precepts are abstentions (virati): the moment of choosing not to act is itself wholesome.
  • Seriousness also varies with the being harmed, the strength of the intention and the effort used.
Mission 2

Eight and ten precepts

Graded precepts227Patimokkhafully ordained bhikkhus(Theravada Vinaya)10dasa silanovices; + not accepting gold andsilver (money)8uposatha dayslay people on observance daysand retreat: third becomescelibacy, + 3 rules5five preceptslay Buddhistsmore rules ↑ · fuller renunciation
  • Eight precepts: kept by many lay Buddhists on uposatha (observance) days and on retreat. The third becomes celibacy, and three more are added: no food after midday; no entertainment or adornment; no high or luxurious beds.
  • Ten precepts (dasa sila): kept by novices (samaneras and samaneris), and by some lay women renunciants (e.g. dasa sil matas in Sri Lanka).
  • Ten = the eight, with entertainment and adornment as separate rules (7 and 8), plus 10: not accepting gold and silver (money).
  • Fully ordained monks (bhikkhus) keep the Patimokkha: 227 rules in the Theravada Vinaya.
Mission 2Diversity

Theravada and Mahayana

Precepts in Theravada and MahayanaTheravadaMahayanaMain setfive precepts atalmost every layceremony;monastics keepthe Vinayacloselybodhisattvaprecepts: 10major, 48 minorEmphasismainly restraintsadds positiveduties: help,protect, teachothers; in EastAsia, no meatExampletextthe Vinaya: 227rules forbhikkhusBrahmajalaSutra (Chinese,c. 5th centuryCE)Flexi-bilityBodhi: theindispensablebase of the path,never outgrownintention andcompassion mayweigh morethan the letter(skilful means)
  • Theravada: the five precepts are chanted at almost every lay ceremony; monastics keep the Vinaya closely; the precepts are mainly restraints.
  • Mahayana: many keep the bodhisattva precepts, e.g. the Brahmajala Sutra (Chinese, c. 5th century CE): 10 major and 48 minor precepts. They add positive duties (to help, protect and teach others) and, in East Asia, a ban on eating meat.
  • Intention and compassion may weigh more than the letter: some Mahayana texts allow a bodhisattva to break a precept through skilful means to prevent greater harm (see Mission 4).
  • Japan: Jodo Shinshu priests have married since its founder Shinran (1173–1263); from 1872 the government permitted marriage for all clergy. Many Japanese priests marry today.
  • Peter Harvey, An Introduction to Buddhist Ethics (2000): the precepts are shared by all schools, but Mahayana places them within the bodhisattva's aim of benefiting all beings.
  • Bodhi: in Theravada the precepts are the indispensable base of the path, never to be outgrown.
Mission 2

Precepts and the six perfections

The six perfections6 prajnawisdom1 danagiving2 silaethics3 kshantipatience4 viryaenergy5 dhyanameditationthe preceptsEach is perfected only when joined withwisdom.
  • Mahayana sets ethics within the six perfections (paramitas) of the bodhisattva: giving (dana), ethics (sila), patience (kshanti), energy (virya), meditation (dhyana), wisdom (prajna).
  • Distinctive features: practised for the sake of all beings, not oneself; each is "perfected" only when joined with wisdom (seeing the emptiness of giver, gift and receiver).
  • The precepts fall under the second perfection, sila; generosity comes first.
  • Full treatment of the perfections and the bodhisattva path.
Mission 2Evaluate

Are the precepts still relevant today?

Are the precepts still relevant today?Claim: The traditional precepts are still asufficient guide for Buddhists today.ForShort, shared by all schools and easy toapply; they cover the main harms in anysociety.As training rules they are flexible:intention and circumstance are taken intoaccount.AgainstModern questions (online speech, factoryfarming, recreational drugs, digital piracy)need interpretation the wording does notgive.Some monastic rules (e.g. not handlingmoney) are hard to keep in moderneconomies.Judge it byIs the spirit or the letter more important? ·Who interprets them: the individual, thesangha, or tradition? · Do the dasa sila stillregulate the monastic sangha effectively?
  • Claim: The traditional precepts are still a sufficient guide for Buddhists today.
  • For: They are short, shared by all schools and easy to apply; they cover the main harms in any society.
  • For: As training rules they are flexible: intention and circumstance are taken into account.
  • Against: Modern questions (online speech, factory farming, recreational drugs, digital piracy) need interpretation the wording does not give; hence reworded trainings (Thich Nhat Hanh).
  • Against: Some monastic rules (e.g. not handling money) are hard to keep in modern economies; some monasteries use lay stewards, others are criticised for laxity.
  • Judgement criteria: Is the spirit or the letter more important? Who interprets them: the individual, the sangha, or tradition? Do the dasa sila still regulate the monastic sangha effectively?
Quick check
?A Buddhist sets a mousetrap, but the mouse escapes. Using the traditional factors for breaking the first precept, which judgement is correct?
Mission check

?On an observance day a lay Buddhist has taken the eight precepts. Late in the evening she forgets the rule and eats a meal. Which response best fits how Buddhists understand the precepts?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Pali texts show the Buddha eating meat he was given. So must a Buddhist be vegetarian to avoid harm?

Make a guess: Pali texts show the Buddha eating meat he was given. So must a Buddhist be vegetarian to avoid harm?

Mission 3

What ahimsa means

  • Ahimsa: non-harming, non-violence towards all living beings. The word is shared with Hindu and Jain traditions.
  • In Buddhism it is expressed in the first precept: to abstain from killing or harming living beings (see Mission 2).
  • It covers all sentient beings: humans, animals, insects.

> "All men tremble at punishment, all men fear death; remember that you are like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter." (Dhammapada 129, Müller 1881)

  • The reason given is empathy: put yourself in the other's place.
  • "Nor cause slaughter": ahimsa covers causing others to kill, not only killing yourself.
  • Your spec term: ahimsa (untranslated in exam questions).
Mission 3

Why harm matters: four reasons

  • Karma: harming from hatred or greed is akusala and brings suffering to the one who harms (see Mission 1).
  • Rebirth: all beings circle in samsara; an animal may have been a human, even one's mother, in a past life (Samyutta Nikaya 15.14–19, paraphrase).
  • Compassion (karuna) and loving-kindness (metta): the wish that all beings be well.
  • Interdependence: harming others damages the web of conditions one also depends on.
  • Ahimsa is applied with intention in view: deliberate harm weighs most (see Mission 1).
Mission 3

Animals as fellow beings

Animals as fellow beingsanimalshumanssixrealmsrebirth can pass between the human andanimal realms
  • The animal realm is one of the six realms of rebirth; animals suffer, fear and seek happiness.
  • The Jataka tales tell of the Buddha's past lives, many as animals, often acting with great compassion.
  • The Buddha rejected animal sacrifice: in the Kutadanta Sutta (Digha Nikaya 5) he describes an ideal sacrifice in which no animals are killed (paraphrase).
  • Practices today: releasing animals (life release, common in East Asia and Tibet); caring for temple animals; avoiding pesticides where possible.
  • Hard cases: pests, animal experiments for medicine, farming. Buddhists weigh intention, need and degree of harm, and come to different conclusions.
Quick check
?A Buddhist restaurant owner never kills an animal herself, but orders live lobsters to be boiled by her chef. How would most Buddhists judge this in the light of Dhammapada 129?
Mission 3Diversity

Meat-eating

Meat and monastics1111Theravadamonks eat what they are given; meatmust be "pure in three respects": notseen, heard or suspected to be killed forthem (Majjhima Nikaya 55)22222East Asian Mahayanamonastics are vegetarian (LankavataraSutra; Brahmajala Sutra)33Tibetanmeat widely eaten, partly because ofclimate; the 14th Dalai Lama encouragesvegetarianism
  • Theravada: monks eat what they are given on almsround. The Buddha allows meat that is pure in three respects: the monk has not seen, heard or suspected that the animal was killed for him (Jivaka Sutta, Majjhima Nikaya 55, paraphrase).
  • Pali texts show the Buddha himself accepting meat offered as alms, e.g. pork from the householder Ugga (Anguttara Nikaya 5.44, paraphrase).
  • When Devadatta demanded that monks be made vegetarian, the Buddha refused to make it a rule (Vinaya, Cullavagga VII, paraphrase). Many Theravada lay people eat meat; some are vegetarian.
  • East Asian Mahayana: monastics are vegetarian. The Lankavatara Sutra (ch. 8) and the bodhisattva precepts of the Brahmajala Sutra forbid eating meat, since all beings have been one's relatives.
  • Tibetan: meat is widely eaten, partly because of climate. The 14th Dalai Lama (b. 1935) encourages vegetarianism and tried it himself, but health problems led doctors to advise some meat.
Mission 3Read the source

Right livelihood and the Lotus Sutra

  • Pali Canon: a lay follower should not trade in weapons, living beings, meat, intoxicants or poison (Vanijja Sutta, Anguttara Nikaya 5.177, paraphrase).
  • Lotus Sutra, chapter 14 ("Peaceful Practices"): a bodhisattva should not keep close company with those who hunt, fish, butcher, or raise animals for slaughter (paraphrase).

Q1 Which kinds of work would the Vanijja Sutta rule out today?

Show answer

E.g. arms dealing, people trafficking, running an abattoir, selling recreational drugs or poisons.

Q2 What does the Lotus passage add to the Pali text?

Show answer

It concerns the company a bodhisattva keeps, not just one's own trade: the setting of life should support non-harming.

Quick check
?Which of these jobs would the Vanijja Sutta (Anguttara Nikaya 5.177) most clearly rule out for a lay Buddhist?
Mission 3

The embryo: when does a life begin?

Three conditions for conceptionparents'unionmother'sfertiletimebeing tobe reborn(gandhabba)conceptionMajjhima Nikaya 38 (paraphrase)
  • Conception needs three conditions: the parents' union, the mother's fertile time, and the presence of the being to be reborn (the gandhabba) (Mahatanhasankhaya Sutta, Majjhima Nikaya 38, paraphrase).
  • So in traditional teaching, consciousness is present from conception: the embryo is a being in the round of rebirth.
  • The Vinaya expels a monk who deliberately kills a human being, and gives cases of monks who caused abortions among them (Parajika 3, paraphrase).
  • A human birth is precious and hard to gain: ending it destroys a rare chance to practise the Dhamma.
Mission 3Diversity

Abortion and embryo research

  • Damien Keown, Buddhism and Bioethics (1995): traditional sources treat life as beginning at conception, so abortion and embryo destruction break the first precept.
  • The 14th Dalai Lama: abortion is in general an act of killing and negative, but each case should be judged by its circumstances (e.g. serious danger or disability) (paraphrase of a 1993 interview).
  • Japan: abortion is relatively common; many families hold mizuko kuyo rites, memorials for aborted or miscarried children, expressing grief and responsibility. Some praise these as compassionate; others criticise temples for profiting from guilt.
  • Embryo research: some Buddhists oppose destroying embryos; others argue compassion for patients and the intention to heal can weigh in favour. No single "Buddhist view".
  • Common ground: the intention behind a decision matters, and the decision is made mindful of karmic weight.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does ahimsa require vegetarianism?

Does ahimsa require vegetarianism?Claim: A Buddhist who takes ahimsaseriously must be vegetarian.ForBuying meat causes slaughter throughdemand: "nor cause slaughter"(Dhammapada 129).Mahayana sutras (Lankavatara,Brahmajala) and leading teachers (theDalai Lama) urge it.AgainstThe Buddha refused to makevegetarianism a rule and allowed meatpure in three respects (MN 55).Monks must accept what they are given;refusing can be attachment to purity;climate and health may make it hard(Tibet).Judge it byIs intention or result the key to karma? · Doesmodern industrial farming change the "notkilled for me" test? · Should the Buddha's ruleor later Mahayana teaching decide?
  • Claim: A Buddhist who takes ahimsa seriously must be vegetarian.
  • For: Buying meat causes slaughter through demand: "nor cause slaughter" (Dhammapada 129).
  • For: Mahayana sutras (Lankavatara, Brahmajala) and leading teachers (the Dalai Lama) urge it; compassion for all beings points that way.
  • Against: The Buddha himself refused to make vegetarianism a rule and allowed meat pure in three respects (MN 55).
  • Against: Monks must accept what they are given; refusing food can be attachment to purity; climate and health may make it hard (Tibet).
  • Judgement criteria: Is intention or result the key to karma? Does modern industrial farming change the "not killed for me" test? Should the Buddha's rule or later Mahayana teaching decide?
Quick check
?Which belief best explains why many traditional Buddhists regard ending a pregnancy as a breach of the first precept?
Mission check

?A Theravada monk on almsround is given curry containing chicken by a family who cooked it for themselves. A Chinese Buddhist nun visiting with him is given the same food. Which statement best describes what their traditions teach?
Mission 4

Mission 4: A soldier asked the Buddha if warriors who die in battle go to heaven. Why did he refuse to answer?

Make a guess: A soldier asked the Buddha if warriors who die in battle go to heaven. Why did he refuse to answer?

Mission 4

The ideal: non-violence

  • Ahimsa (see Mission 3) rules out deliberate killing of humans most of all.

> "For hatred does not cease by hatred at any time: hatred ceases by love, this is an old rule." (Dhammapada 5, Müller 1881)

> "Victory breeds hatred, for the conquered is unhappy." (Dhammapada 201, Müller 1881)

  • War is driven by the three poisons: greed (land, wealth), hatred, delusion (us and them).
  • The greatest victory is over oneself: one who conquers himself is "the greatest of conquerors" (Dhammapada 103, Müller 1881).
  • Monks may not go to watch an army in the field, stay with it more than three nights, or visit its drills and parades (Vinaya, Pacittiya 48–50, paraphrase); serving royal soldiers may not be ordained without release (Mahavagga I.40, paraphrase).
Mission 4Read the source

The Yodhajiva Sutta

Yodhajiva's questionSamyutta Nikaya 42.3 (paraphrase)the BuddhaYodhajivaheaven of theslain?1declines2declinesthird time:the warrior's mind: intention to strikethem downhell of the slainweeps: deceived byhis teacherstakes refuge

Samyutta Nikaya 42.3 (paraphrase):

  • Yodhajiva ("warrior"), the headman of a village of professional soldiers, tells the Buddha his teachers taught that a warrior who dies fighting is reborn among the "devas (gods) of those slain in battle". What does the Buddha say?
  • Twice the Buddha declines to answer and tells him to leave the question.
  • Asked a third time, he answers: in battle the warrior's mind is already low and misdirected, set on the thought that these beings should be struck down and destroyed.
  • If he dies like that, he is reborn not in heaven but in hell, in the hell "of those slain in battle"; if he holds the wrong view, hell or the animal womb.
  • Yodhajiva weeps: not at the Buddha's words, but because he was deceived by his teachers for so long. He takes refuge.

Q1 Why is the warrior's rebirth bad, on the Buddha's account?

Show answer

His intention at death is to kill: karma follows intention.

Q2 Why might the Buddha refuse at first?

Show answer

The truth was painful; he answers only when the soldier sincerely insists.

Quick check
?In the Yodhajiva Sutta, why does the Buddha say a warrior who dies fighting has a bad rebirth?
Mission 4

The Buddha's example

The Rohini riverRohini riverSakyas(the Buddha's clan)KoliyasWhich is worth more: water, or thewarriors' blood?they make peaceJataka and Dhammapada commentaries
  • The Rohini river: the Sakyas (the Buddha's own clan) and the Koliyas are about to fight over water in a drought. The Buddha asks which is worth more, water or the warriors' blood; they make peace (Jataka and Dhammapada commentaries, paraphrase).
  • Vidudabha's army: three times the Buddha sits in thin shade on the road where the king will march against the Sakyas; three times the king turns back. The fourth time, the Buddha does not intervene: the Sakyas' karma ripens (Dhammapada commentary, paraphrase).
  • War between kings: told of a victory, the Buddha says that the killer begets a killer and the conqueror a conqueror (Samyutta Nikaya 3.15, paraphrase).
  • Lessons drawn: mediate where possible; see conflict's causes; but violence has karmic consequences on all sides.
Mission 4

Kings, protection and Ashoka

  • Buddhist texts describe an ideal righteous king (cakkavatti) who rules by Dhamma, not the sword, but who gives protection to his people (Cakkavatti-sihanada Sutta, Digha Nikaya 26, paraphrase).
  • Ashoka (Mauryan emperor, ruled c. 268–232 BCE): after conquering Kalinga (c. 260 BCE) he records deep remorse for the slaughter and turns to "conquest by Dhamma" (Rock Edict XIII).
  • But Ashoka kept an army and warned the forest peoples that he still had power (same edict).
  • So the tradition holds two things in tension: non-violence as the ideal, and rulers' duty to protect.
Mission 4Diversity

Buddhists who have justified war

Buddhists and war: a timelinec. 260 BCEAshoka conquers Kalinga;remorse, then "conquest byDhamma", but he keeps anarmy2nd centuryBCESri Lanka: KingDutthagamani fights Elara"for the Dhamma" (told inthe Mahavamsa, 5th–6thcentury CE)up to 1945Japan: many Zen and otherleaders support militarism;several sects later apologise1983–2009Sri Lankan civil war: manySinhalese Buddhists arguedefence of the island andthe Dhamma can justify war
  • Sri Lanka: the Mahavamsa (5th–6th century CE chronicle) tells how King Dutthagamani (2nd century BCE) fought the Tamil king Elara with a relic in his spear "for the Dhamma". When he grieves over the dead, arahants tell him only "one and a half" true people were killed: one who had taken refuge and one who kept the precepts (paraphrase).
  • Tessa J. Bartholomeusz (d. 2001), In Defense of Dharma: Just-War Ideology in Buddhist Sri Lanka (2002): during the civil war (1983–2009) many Sinhalese Buddhists, including monks, argued that defending the island and the Dhamma could justify war. She argues Buddhist ethics in practice is shaped by context, not one pacifist rule.
  • Japan: many Zen and other leaders supported militarism up to 1945 (documented by Brian Victoria, Zen at War, 1997); several sects later apologised.
  • Most Buddhists see these as departures from the Buddha's teaching; the debate is how far they show a real strand of Buddhist thought.
Mission 4

Mahayana: compassion and skilful means

  • Upayakausalya Sutra (Skill in Means; Mahayana, early centuries CE) (paraphrase): a ship's captain (the Buddha in a past life) learns that a robber plans to kill 500 merchants. Out of compassion for the merchants, and for the robber, who would suffer terribly for the crime, he kills the robber and accepts the karmic cost himself.
  • Some Mahayana thinkers draw from this that killing with pure compassion, to prevent greater harm, may be justified in extreme cases.
  • Lotus Sutra, chapter 20: the bodhisattva Never Disparaging bows to everyone, saying they will become Buddhas; when people beat him with sticks and stones, he steps back and bows again (paraphrase): non-retaliation rooted in respect for every being's Buddha nature.
  • So Mahayana sources point both ways: radical non-violence, and exceptional compassionate force.
Quick check
?A Mahayana Buddhist uses the story of the ship's captain in the Upayakausalya Sutra to discuss killing in war. Which conclusion is closest to the story itself?
Mission 4

Buddhists in the armed forces

  • Most Buddhist-majority countries (e.g. Thailand, Sri Lanka, Myanmar) have armies, many with conscription and Buddhist chaplains.
  • In the UK, Buddhists serve in the armed forces, which appoint a Buddhist chaplain.
  • Arguments for serving: protecting the vulnerable is compassionate; intention can be defensive; roles include peacekeeping, medicine, disaster relief.
  • Arguments against: right livelihood excludes trading in weapons (AN 5.177); a soldier may be ordered to kill; the Yodhajiva Sutta warns about the mind of the killer.
  • Some Buddhists take non-combat roles or are conscientious objectors.
Mission 4

Weapons of mass destruction

Who is harmed?future generationsanimals and landcivilianscombat-antsconventional weapon: combatantsWMD: reaches every ring
  • WMD (nuclear, chemical, biological) kill indiscriminately: civilians, children, animals, and future generations through radiation and pollution.
  • So almost all Buddhist voices oppose them: they breach ahimsa on a vast scale, and no intention can be precise enough to justify them.
  • Josei Toda, second president of Soka Gakkai (Japanese Nichiren lay movement), issued a Declaration Against Nuclear Weapons in 1957; Soka Gakkai International still campaigns for abolition.
  • The 14th Dalai Lama (Nobel Peace Prize 1989) calls for the elimination of nuclear weapons and for "inner disarmament" as the root of outer disarmament; in 1987 he proposed Tibet as a zone of ahimsa.
  • A debated question: can possessing WMD as a deterrent be justified if the intention is to prevent war? Most Buddhist leaders say no; some argue it reduces suffering.
Mission 4Evaluate

Can a Buddhist ever fight?

Can a Buddhist ever fight?Claim: Ahimsa means a Buddhist shouldnever take part in war.ForDhammapada 5 and 201; the YodhajivaSutta; the Vinaya's distance from armies;the Buddha's example of mediation.Hatred and fear in battle make akusalaintention almost unavoidable.AgainstRulers have a duty to protect (DN 26);Ashoka kept an army after Kalinga.Mahayana skilful means (UpayakausalyaSutra) allows compassionate force inextreme cases; Bartholomeusz showsBuddhists reasoning from context.Judge it byIs the ideal for monks or for everyone? · Canintention in war be compassionate? · Do theMahavamsa and Japan show Buddhism or itsdistortion? · Is defence different from attack?
  • Claim: Ahimsa means a Buddhist should never take part in war.
  • For: Dhammapada 5 and 201; the Yodhajiva Sutta; the Vinaya's distance from armies; the Buddha's example of mediation.
  • For: Hatred and fear in battle make akusala intention almost unavoidable.
  • Against: Rulers have a duty to protect (DN 26); Ashoka kept an army after Kalinga.
  • Against: Mahayana skilful means (Upayakausalya Sutra) allows compassionate force in extreme cases; Bartholomeusz shows Buddhists reasoning from context.
  • Judgement criteria: Is the ideal for monks or for everyone? Can intention in war be compassionate? Do the Mahavamsa and Japan show Buddhism or its distortion? Is defence different from attack?
  • AO2 tip: weigh the strongest form of each view, then reach your own justified conclusion.
Mission check

?A Buddhist police officer must decide whether to use force to stop an armed attacker threatening a crowd. Which reasoning is closest to the Yodhajiva Sutta and the Upayakausalya Sutra taken together?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Good conduct (sila) is training, not obedience; it is the base of meditation and wisdom.
  • Intention (cetana) is karma: acts are kusala (healthy) or akusala (unhealthy) according to their roots in greed, hatred, delusion or their opposites.
  • Karma conditions but does not compel; responsibility rests on causal continuity, not a fixed self; how much freedom this leaves is debated.

Mission 2

  • The precepts are training rules (sikkhapada), undertaken voluntarily, not commandments; breaking one is akusala and is met by renewed resolve.
  • Five for lay people, eight on observance days, ten (dasa sila) for novices; each restraint has a positive quality to grow.
  • Mahayana keeps the precepts within the bodhisattva aim (bodhisattva precepts, six perfections); Theravada stresses them as the unshakeable base.

Mission 3

  • Ahimsa (non-harming) is the principle of the first precept: do not kill, nor cause killing (Dhammapada 129).
  • Theravada allows meat that is not seen, heard or suspected to be killed for oneself; East Asian Mahayana monastics are vegetarian; Tibetans often eat meat; the Dalai Lama encourages vegetarianism.
  • Traditional teaching places the start of life at conception; Buddhist views on abortion and embryo research differ (Keown; the Dalai Lama; mizuko kuyo in Japan).

Mission 4

  • The ideal is non-violence: hatred ceases by love (Dhammapada 5); the Yodhajiva Sutta denies heaven to warriors who die with killing in mind.
  • The Buddha's example: mediation (Rohini river), but no protection from karma; rulers' duty to protect sits in tension with ahimsa (DN 26, Ashoka).
  • Views differ: just-war reasoning in Sri Lanka (Mahavamsa; Bartholomeusz) and wartime Japan; Mahayana skilful means; near-universal opposition to WMD (Toda; the Dalai Lama).
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Buddhism: Good conduct and key moral principles for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If there is no fixed self, who chooses to act, and who is to blame?
  2. Mission 2Buddhists keep precepts that no god commands. So what happens when one is broken?
  3. Mission 3Pali texts show the Buddha eating meat he was given. So must a Buddhist be vegetarian to avoid harm?
  4. Mission 4A soldier asked the Buddha if warriors who die in battle go to heaven. Why did he refuse to answer?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · AQA