← GCSE English Literature · AQA · GCSE English Literature revision
⭐ 0
AQA GCSE English Literature (8702) · The Sign of Four
Mini-Lesson

The Sign of Four

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1The thieves are caught in chapter 10. Why are there two more?
  2. Mission 2Why does Holmes's story open and close with cocaine?
  3. Mission 3Why is Watson glad when the treasure box is empty?
  4. Mission 4Who has the best right to the Agra treasure?
  5. Mission 5Does the danger come from abroad, or from Britain's own men?
  6. Mission 6Small calls his crime justice. Does the novel agree?
  7. Mission 7Why does Doyle's London keep vanishing into fog?
Mission 1

The thieves are caught in chapter 10. Why are there two more?

Make a guess: The thieves are caught in chapter 10. Why are there two more?

The Sign of Four · structure and the detective storyScreen 1

Twelve chapters, two stories

Twelve chapters, two storiesSmall's storyThe investigation(London)The crime (the past)I–IIIBaker Street and theLyceumIVThaddeus's roomsV–VIPondicherry LodgeVII–VIIIToby and the IrregularsIXa disguiseXriver chase and captureXIthe iron box1857Agra fortthe Andaman Islandsconvict settlement1878Morstan disappears1882Major Sholto diesthe treasure foundXII: Small's storythe crime's past told at last
ChaptersWhereWhat happens
I–IIIBaker Street, then the Lyceum TheatreMary Morstan brings her case: a missing father, six pearls, a letter
IVThaddeus Sholto's roomsThaddeus retells his father's deathbed confession
V–VIPondicherry Lodge, NorwoodBartholomew Sholto dead in a locked room; the treasure gone
VII–XAcross London and down the ThamesToby the dog, the Irregulars, a disguise, a river chase
XI–XIIA cabin, Camberwell, Baker StreetAn iron box is opened; Jonathan Small tells his story
  • The detective story moves forward over a few days in London.
  • The story of the crime reaches back to India in 1857.
The Sign of Four · structure and the detective storyScreen 2

How your exam asks this

  • Paper 1 Section B: one question on the novel. You write about a printed extract, then about the novel as a whole. Usually 30 marks.
  • Marks reward your response and quotations (AO1), methods of language, form and structure (AO2) and context (AO3).
  • Closed book: learn your key quotations. Essay practice is for class.
  • AQA calls the novel The Sign of Four, the title of the 1890 book; the magazine and some editions call it The Sign of the Four.
The Sign of Four · structure and the detective storyScreen 3

The rules of the game

  • Edgar Allan Poe's story The Murders in the Rue Morgue (1841) set the pattern: a genius detective, a friend who narrates, a baffled police force, a locked room.
  • Doyle keeps every convention: Holmes, Watson as narrator, Athelney Jones of Scotland Yard, a room locked "on the inside" (ch 5).
  • Clues are laid out for the reader: a wooden-leg print, tiny bare footprints, a poisoned thorn.
  • The detective explains last: "You know my methods," Holmes tells Watson (ch 6).
Extract The Sign of Four · structure and the detective storyScreen 4

How did the killer get in?

How did the killer get in?1“How came he, then?” I reiterated. “The door is2locked, the window is inaccessible. Was it3through the chimney?”4“The grate is much too small,” he answered. “I5had already considered that possibility.”6“How then?” I persisted.7“You will not apply my precept,” he said,8shaking his head. “How often have I said to you9that when you have eliminated the impossible10whatever remains, however improbable, must11be the truth? We know that he did not come12through the door, the window, or the chimney.13We also know that he could not have been14concealed in the room, as there is no15concealment possible. Whence, then, did he16come?”17“He came through the hole in the roof,” I cried.1231door2window3chimneyThe Sign of Four, Chapter VI

“How came he, then?” I reiterated. “The door is locked, the window is inaccessible. Was it through the chimney?”

“The grate is much too small,” he answered. “I had already considered that possibility.”

“How then?” I persisted.

“You will not apply my precept,” he said, shaking his head. “How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth? We know that he did not come through the door, the window, or the chimney. We also know that he could not have been concealed in the room, as there is no concealment possible. Whence, then, did he come?”

“He came through the hole in the roof,” I cried.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter VI "Sherlock Holmes Gives a Demonstration"
Tap the evidenceScreen 5
?Tap the words where Holmes states the rule that solves the locked room. (Use the extract on screen 4.)

Tap a word in the extract.

“ , ?” . “ , . ?”

“ ,” . “ .”

“ ?” .

“ ,” , . “ , , ? , , . , . , , ?”

“ ,” .

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter VI "Sherlock Holmes Gives a Demonstration"
Quick checkScreen 6
?Holmes solves the case, so why does Doyle have Watson tell the story?
The Sign of Four · structure and the detective storyScreen 7

The crime's own story

Stories inside Watson's storyWatson's narrativeThaddeus's story of his father'sconfession (ch IV)Small's narrative (ch XII)Watson writes afterwards
  • By chapter 10 we know who and how. Chapter 12 gives the why.
  • Small's embedded narrative: his own story told inside Watson's, from the 1857 Indian Rebellion to the night at Norwood.
  • Holmes says there is "nothing at all new to me in the latter part of your narrative, except that you brought your own rope" (ch 12).
  • Chapter 11 closes the third strand: the empty box and Watson's proposal.
Mission checkScreen 8

?The thieves are caught in chapter 10. Why are there two more?
Mission 2

Why does Holmes's story open and close with cocaine?

Make a guess: Why does Holmes's story open and close with cocaine?

The Sign of Four · HolmesScreen 1

The first page

  • Holmes is using cocaine, "a seven-per-cent. solution", three times a day for months (ch 1).
  • In 1890 cocaine was legal in Britain and sold by chemists in tonics and medicines; it was not tightly controlled until 1916.
  • Watson objects as "a medical man": it is "a pathological and morbid process".
  • Holmes's reply: "My mind," he said, "rebels at stagnation."
Extract The Sign of Four · HolmesScreen 2

No case, no point

No case, no point1“None. Hence the cocaine. I cannot live2without brain-work. What else is there to3live for? Stand at the window here. Was4ever such a dreary, dismal, unprofitable5world? See how the yellow fog swirls6down the street and drifts across the7dun-coloured houses. What could be more8hopelessly prosaic and material? What is9the use of having powers, doctor, when one10has no field upon which to exert them?11Crime is commonplace, existence is12commonplace, and no qualities save those13which are commonplace have any function14upon earth.”11rhetorical questions: four in a rowThe Sign of Four, Chapter I

“None. Hence the cocaine. I cannot live without brain-work. What else is there to live for? Stand at the window here. Was ever such a dreary, dismal, unprofitable world? See how the yellow fog swirls down the street and drifts across the dun-coloured houses. What could be more hopelessly prosaic and material? What is the use of having powers, doctor, when one has no field upon which to exert them? Crime is commonplace, existence is commonplace, and no qualities save those which are commonplace have any function upon earth.”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter I "The Science of Deduction". Watson has just asked whether Holmes has a case.
Method → effectScreen 3
?Holmes ends his complaint to Watson. (Use the extract on screen 2.)
Show the extract (screen 2)

“None. Hence the cocaine. I cannot live without brain-work. What else is there to live for? Stand at the window here. Was ever such a dreary, dismal, unprofitable world? See how the yellow fog swirls down the street and drifts across the dun-coloured houses. What could be more hopelessly prosaic and material? What is the use of having powers, doctor, when one has no field upon which to exert them? Crime is commonplace, existence is commonplace, and no qualities save those which are commonplace have any function upon earth.”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter I "The Science of Deduction". Watson has just asked whether Holmes has a case.
Crime is commonplace, existence is commonplace

Step 1 Which method does Doyle give Holmes here?

Step 2 What effect does it have?

The Sign of Four · HolmesScreen 4

The reasoning machine

The watch deductionObservation, then deduction (ch I)ObservationInferencedints and marks allover the casea careless ownerfour pawnbroker'snumbers scratchedinside the caseoften short of money(at low water)thousands of scratchesround the key-holean unsteady hand
  • Observation then deduction: red earth on Watson's shoe means Wigmore Street; the stamps in his desk mean a telegram (ch 1).
  • From a watch, he reads Watson's brother's life: "I never guess."
  • Watson: "You really are an automaton,—a calculating-machine!" (ch 2).
  • Holmes: "A client is to me a mere unit,—a factor in a problem."
  • He also uses chemistry, disguise, a dog and the Baker Street Irregulars.
The Sign of Four · HolmesScreen 5

Brilliant, and flawed

  • Mood swings: "the blackest depression" between cases (ch 3).
  • Vanity: Watson notes his "egotism" over the brochure (ch 1).
  • Coldness about women: "Women are never to be entirely trusted,—not the best of them" (ch 9). Watson calls it "this atrocious sentiment".
  • Not infallible: Toby leads them to the wrong barrel (ch 7).
  • Last line: "there still remains the cocaine-bottle" (ch 12).
Pick the strongestScreen 6
?Which sentence best analyses how Doyle presents Holmes in the extract on screen 2?
Show the extract (screen 2)

“None. Hence the cocaine. I cannot live without brain-work. What else is there to live for? Stand at the window here. Was ever such a dreary, dismal, unprofitable world? See how the yellow fog swirls down the street and drifts across the dun-coloured houses. What could be more hopelessly prosaic and material? What is the use of having powers, doctor, when one has no field upon which to exert them? Crime is commonplace, existence is commonplace, and no qualities save those which are commonplace have any function upon earth.”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter I "The Science of Deduction". Watson has just asked whether Holmes has a case.
Quick checkScreen 7
?On the last page, Watson will marry and Jones gets the credit. Holmes replies: "For me," said Sherlock Holmes, "there still remains the cocaine-bottle." What does this ending suggest most strongly?
Mission checkScreen 8

?Why does Holmes's story open and close with cocaine?
Cocaine frames the caseCh I: no case, sococaineCh II: a clientChs III–X: work,no drugCh XII: caseclosed: ‘thecocaine-bottle’the case ends where it began
Mission 3

Why is Watson glad when the treasure box is empty?

Make a guess: Why is Watson glad when the treasure box is empty?

The Sign of Four · Watson and Mary MorstanScreen 1

Watson, the narrator

  • An army doctor wounded by "a Jezail bullet" in the Afghan campaign (ch 1); now "a half-pay surgeon" (ch 7).
  • He tells the story retrospectively: "as she has often told me" (ch 5) hints at the future.
  • Holmes mocks his writing for adding "romanticism" to "an exact science" (ch 1).
  • So the romance plot is Watson's: he notices what Holmes ignores.
The Sign of Four · Watson and Mary MorstanScreen 2

Mary Morstan

Mary Morstan's connectionsMaryMorstanWatsonHolmesMrs. CecilForresterCaptainMorstanmissingsince 1878ThaddeusSholtoromanceclientgoverness,treated as afrienddaughtera pearl eachyear
  • A governess to Mrs. Cecil Forrester; her father, Captain Morstan, vanished in 1878 (ch 2).
  • Watson sees "a firm step and an outward composure"; Holmes calls her "a model client".
  • Watson also writes of "the angelic fashion of women" (ch 7): a Victorian ideal of the gentle, self-sacrificing woman.
  • Some readers see her as mainly an object of Watson's love; others point to her calm, her judgement, and Holmes's view that she "had a decided genius that way" (ch 12).
Extract The Sign of Four · Watson and Mary MorstanScreen 3

Why Watson stays silent

Yet there were two thoughts which sealed the words of affection upon my lips. She was weak and helpless, shaken in mind and nerve. It was to take her at a disadvantage to obtrude love upon her at such a time. Worse still, she was rich. If Holmes’s researches were successful, she would be an heiress. Was it fair, was it honourable, that a half-pay surgeon should take such advantage of an intimacy which chance had brought about? Might she not look upon me as a mere vulgar fortune-seeker? I could not bear to risk that such a thought should cross her mind. This Agra treasure intervened like an impassable barrier between us.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter VII "The Episode of the Barrel". Watson is escorting Mary home from Pondicherry Lodge.
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the words that show the treasure as something blocking Watson's way to Mary. (Use the extract on screen 3.)

Tap a word in the extract.

. , . . , . , . , , ? ? . .

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter VII "The Episode of the Barrel". Watson is escorting Mary home from Pondicherry Lodge.
The Sign of Four · Watson and Mary MorstanScreen 5

Honour, money and class

  • Watson calls himself "an army surgeon with a weak leg and a weaker banking-account" (ch 2) and "a half-pay surgeon" (ch 7).
  • His fear: Mary might think him "a mere vulgar fortune-seeker".
  • A gentleman's honour meant not using a woman's weakness or wealth to his advantage.
  • Mary cares more for others: "It is for Mr. Thaddeus Sholto that I am anxious" (ch 9).
Extract The Sign of Four · Watson and Mary MorstanScreen 6

The box is opened

The barrierWatsonMaryWatsonMaryCh VIIlike an impassablebarrier between usMary may be rich:Watson stays silentCh XIthe golden barrier wasgone from between usthe box is empty:Watson speaks

As I listened to the words and realised what they meant, a great shadow seemed to pass from my soul. I did not know how this Agra treasure had weighed me down, until now that it was finally removed. It was selfish, no doubt, disloyal, wrong, but I could realise nothing save that the golden barrier was gone from between us. “Thank God!” I ejaculated from my very heart.

She looked at me with a quick, questioning smile. “Why do you say that?” she asked.

“Because you are within my reach again,” I said, taking her hand. She did not withdraw it. “Because I love you, Mary, as truly as ever a man loved a woman. Because this treasure, these riches, sealed my lips. Now that they are gone I can tell you how I love you. That is why I said, ‘Thank God.’”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XI "The Great Agra Treasure". Mary has just said, "The treasure is lost."
Method → effectScreen 7
?Watson's reaction to the empty box. (Use the extract on screen 6.)
Show the extract (screen 6)

As I listened to the words and realised what they meant, a great shadow seemed to pass from my soul. I did not know how this Agra treasure had weighed me down, until now that it was finally removed. It was selfish, no doubt, disloyal, wrong, but I could realise nothing save that the golden barrier was gone from between us. “Thank God!” I ejaculated from my very heart.

She looked at me with a quick, questioning smile. “Why do you say that?” she asked.

“Because you are within my reach again,” I said, taking her hand. She did not withdraw it. “Because I love you, Mary, as truly as ever a man loved a woman. Because this treasure, these riches, sealed my lips. Now that they are gone I can tell you how I love you. That is why I said, ‘Thank God.’”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XI "The Great Agra Treasure". Mary has just said, "The treasure is lost."
the golden barrier was gone from between us

Step 1 Which method does Doyle use here?

Step 2 What effect does it have?

Quick checkScreen 8
?Chapter 11 ends: "Whoever had lost a treasure, I knew that night that I had gained one." What does Doyle suggest with this ending?
Mission checkScreen 9

?Why is Watson glad when the treasure box is empty?
Mission 4

Who has the best right to the Agra treasure?

Make a guess: Who has the best right to the Agra treasure?

The Sign of Four · greed and the Agra treasureScreen 1

The treasure's journey

The treasure's journeyAgra fort: Achmet (killed)1857the four (Small, Mahomet Singh, AbdullahKhan, Dost Akbar)Andamans: the secret sold to Sholto andMorstanEngland: Major Sholto (PondicherryLodge)hidden in a sealed garret1882found by Bartholomewtaken by Small and Tongathe Thames
WhenWhat happens to the box
1857A rajah sends his jewels to Agra fort with a servant, Achmet; Small and three others kill Achmet and hide the box (ch 12)
LaterThe four, convicts in the Andaman Islands, sell the secret to Major Sholto and Captain Morstan (ch 12)
ThenSholto takes the treasure to England and breaks the bargain (ch 12)
1878–1882Morstan dies in Sholto's house; Sholto dies with the secret (ch 4)
The novelBartholomew finds it; Small and Tonga take it; it is chased down the Thames (chs 4–10)
Extract The Sign of Four · greed and the Agra treasureScreen 2

A deathbed confession

“‘I have only one thing,’ he said, ‘which weighs upon my mind at this supreme moment. It is my treatment of poor Morstan’s orphan. The cursed greed which has been my besetting sin through life has withheld from her the treasure, half at least of which should have been hers. And yet I have made no use of it myself,—so blind and foolish a thing is avarice. The mere feeling of possession has been so dear to me that I could not bear to share it with another. See that chaplet dipped with pearls beside the quinine-bottle. Even that I could not bear to part with, although I had got it out with the design of sending it to her. You, my sons, will give her a fair share of the Agra treasure. But send her nothing—not even the chaplet—until I am gone. After all, men have been as bad as this and have recovered.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter IV "The Story of the Bald-Headed Man". Thaddeus repeats his dying father's words.
Tap the evidenceScreen 3
?Tap the words where Major Sholto admits that his greed has done him no good. (Use the extract on screen 2.)

Tap a word in the extract.

“‘ ,’ , ‘ . . , . ,— . . . , . , , . — — . , .

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter IV "The Story of the Bald-Headed Man". Thaddeus repeats his dying father's words.
The Sign of Four · greed and the Agra treasureScreen 4

A treasure that curses

  • Small, in chapter 11: the treasure "never brought anything but a curse yet upon the man who owned it".
  • He lists the owners: "To him it brought murder, to Major Sholto it brought fear and guilt, to me it has meant slavery for life."
  • Even Bartholomew is "a little inclined to my father's fault" (ch 4).
  • Small would rather the Thames have it than "kith or kin of Sholto or of Morstan" (ch 12).
Method → effectScreen 5
?Small sums up the treasure's history. (Use screen 4.)
Show screen 4: A treasure that curses
  • Small, in chapter 11: the treasure "never brought anything but a curse yet upon the man who owned it".
  • He lists the owners: "To him it brought murder, to Major Sholto it brought fear and guilt, to me it has meant slavery for life."
  • Even Bartholomew is "a little inclined to my father's fault" (ch 4).
  • Small would rather the Thames have it than "kith or kin of Sholto or of Morstan" (ch 12).
To him it brought murder, to Major Sholto it brought fear and guilt, to me it has meant slavery for life.

Step 1 Which method does Doyle give Small here?

Step 2 What effect does it have?

The Sign of Four · greed and the Agra treasureScreen 6

Every claim is stained

Every claim is stainedTheir claimThe stainThe rajahIt was hisHe hid it to backboth sides in 1857Small and the four“Look how I have earnedit!” (ch 12)They murderedAchmet to get itMajor SholtoHe held itHe broke thebargain and hid abodyMorstan, then MaryHalf of the officers'shareMorstan agreed to“a dirty business”(ch 12)The StateJones: it must go “to theauthorities” (ch 9)It takes no part inthe story
WhoTheir claimThe stain
The rajahIt was hisHe hid it to back both sides in 1857
Small and the four"Look how I have earned it!" (ch 12)They murdered Achmet to get it
Major SholtoHe held itHe broke the bargain and hid a body
Morstan, then MaryHalf of the officers' shareMorstan agreed to "a dirty business" (ch 12)
The StateJones: it must go "to the authorities" (ch 9)It takes no part in the story
Rank themScreen 7
?Rank these answers to: How does Doyle present greed in The Sign of Four? (1 = strongest)

Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.

Mission checkScreen 8

?Who has the best right to the Agra treasure?
Mission 5

Does the danger come from abroad, or from Britain's own men?

Make a guess: Does the danger come from abroad, or from Britain's own men?

The Sign of Four · empire and IndiaScreen 1

Empire comes home

Empire comes homeIndiaLondontiger-skin,hookahthe treasure'siron boxAndamanconvictsettlementThaddeus's roomPondicherry LodgeMajor Sholto,retiredSmall andTonga,escaped
  • In 1890 India was under British Crown rule; before 1858 the East India Company governed British India.
  • Major Sholto and Captain Morstan were officers "of the 34th Bombay Infantry" (ch 2).
  • Sholto came back rich, with "a staff of native servants" (ch 4), to a house called Pondicherry Lodge.
  • Thaddeus's room suggests "Eastern luxury" (ch 4): India as treasure and décor.
  • Watson's own wound is from the Afghan campaign (ch 1).
The Sign of Four · empire and IndiaScreen 2

1857 through Small's eyes

  • The Indian Rebellion began on 10 May 1857 at Meerut, as a mutiny of sepoys, Indian soldiers in the Company's army.
  • Both sides killed civilians; British reprisals were brutal, including against whole villages.
  • Small's account (ch 12) is one-sided: he uses racist, dehumanising names for the rebels.
  • Yet he admits they were "our own picked troops, whom we had taught and trained".
  • After 1857 the British built a convict settlement at Port Blair in the Andaman Islands: where Small, Sholto and Morstan meet.
Extract The Sign of Four · empire and IndiaScreen 3

The offer at the gate

“‘How can I decide?’ said I. ‘You have not told me what you want of me. But I tell you now that if it is anything against the safety of the fort I will have no truck with it, so you can drive home your knife and welcome.’

“‘It is nothing against the fort,’ said he. ‘We only ask you to do that which your countrymen come to this land for. We ask you to be rich. If you will be one of us this night, we will swear to you upon the naked knife, and by the threefold oath which no Sikh was ever known to break, that you shall have your fair share of the loot. A quarter of the treasure shall be yours. We can say no fairer.’

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XII "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small". Small is on guard at Agra fort in 1857; Abdullah Khan holds a knife to him.
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the words where Abdullah Khan suggests why the British came to India. (Use the extract on screen 3.)

Tap a word in the extract.

“‘ ?’ . ‘ . , .’

“‘ ,’ . ‘ . . , , , . . .’

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XII "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small". Small is on guard at Agra fort in 1857; Abdullah Khan holds a knife to him.
The Sign of Four · empire and IndiaScreen 5

How the novel presents Tonga

Who speaks for Tonga?Who speaks for Tonga?The gazetteer (ch VIII)describes the islandersin hostile terms fromcolonial storiesHolmes (ch VIII)trusts it as “the verylatest authority”Watson (ch X)describes Tonga withanimal imagerySmall (ch XII)calls him a “faithfulmate”, yet showed himat fairs for moneyTonga's own words(none: he never speaks)
  • Tonga, from the Andaman Islands, never speaks for himself. Others define him.
  • Holmes trusts a gazetteer, "the very latest authority" (ch 8). Its "cannibal" claims echo colonial shipwreck stories.
  • Watson uses animal imagery (ch 10). Small calls him a "faithful mate", yet exhibited him at fairs, billed as a cannibal, for money (ch 12).
  • He dies unmourned: "that strange visitor to our shores" (ch 10).
  • Arup K. Chatterjee (2020) argues Tonga shows the limits of British imperial anthropology, the "science" that ranked races.
Sort itScreen 6
?Is each piece of context linked to the novel, or bolted on (or wrong)?

Tap a statement, then tap the group it belongs in. Then press Check.

Pick the strongestScreen 7
?Which sentence best discusses how Doyle presents Tonga?
Mission checkScreen 8

?Does the danger come from abroad, or from Britain's own men?
Mission 6

Small calls his crime justice. Does the novel agree?

Make a guess: Small calls his crime justice. Does the novel agree?

The Sign of Four · crime and justiceScreen 1

The official police

Two detectivesTwo detectivesAthelney Jones(Scotland Yard)facts, no theoriesarrests Thaddeusarrests McMurdoarrests Mrs. Bernstonearrests Lal Rao: theone arrest provedright (ch XII)praised in theStandardHolmes (consultingdetective)footprintscreosoteTobythe Irregularsdisguisegives Jones the credit
  • Athelney Jones of Scotland Yard: "Stern facts here,—no room for theories" (ch 6).
  • He arrests Thaddeus, the gatekeeper, the housekeeper and the Indian servant (ch 7). Only Lal Rao, the butler, turns out to be involved (ch 12).
  • The Standard praises his "trained and experienced faculties" (ch 8): Doyle's irony.
  • Holmes lets Jones have "all the official credit" (ch 9).
  • A convention since Poe: the private genius outdoes the official police.
Extract The Sign of Four · crime and justiceScreen 2

Small's idea of justice

“Justice!” snarled the ex-convict. “A pretty justice! Whose loot is this, if it is not ours? Where is the justice that I should give it up to those who have never earned it? Look how I have earned it! Twenty long years in that fever-ridden swamp, all day at work under the mangrove-tree, all night chained up in the filthy convict-huts, bitten by mosquitoes, racked with ague, […]

That was how I earned the Agra treasure; and you talk to me of justice because I cannot bear to feel that I have paid this price only that another may enjoy it! I would rather swing a score of times, or have one of Tonga’s darts in my hide, than live in a convict’s cell and feel that another man is at his ease in a palace with the money that should be mine.”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XII "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small". Jones has told Small that thwarting justice will hurt his chances at trial. […] marks a cut of sixteen words, including a racist phrase not needed here.
Tap the evidenceScreen 3
?Tap the words where Small claims he has paid for the treasure with suffering. (Use the extract on screen 2.)

Tap a word in the extract.

“!” . “ ! , ? ? ! , , , , , […]

; ! , , .”

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter XII "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small". Jones has told Small that thwarting justice will hurt his chances at trial. […] marks a cut of sixteen words, including a racist phrase not needed here.
The Sign of Four · crime and justiceScreen 4

What Small leaves out

  • At Agra he trips the fleeing Achmet: "I cast my firelock between his legs" (ch 12).
  • On the Andamans he kills a guard with his wooden leg.
  • Watson feels "the utmost horror" at the "flippant and careless" way he tells it.
  • Small insists he "never raised hand against Mr. Sholto"; Tonga killed Bartholomew.
  • So Small has been wronged by Sholto, and is also a murderer.
The Sign of Four · crime and justiceScreen 5

Who is punished?

Who is punished?Smallfaces trialLal RaoarrestedTongakilled withouttrialMajor Sholtonever triedpunished by lawnever punished by law
CharacterWrong doneWhat happens
Major SholtoBetrays the four; hides Morstan's bodyNever tried; dies in fear (ch 4)
SmallAchmet's murder; the guardFaces trial; expects Dartmoor (ch 11)
TongaKills BartholomewShot dead in the Thames, without trial (ch 10)
ThaddeusNoneArrested, then cleared by an alibi (ch 9)
JonesArrests the wrong peopleGets the credit (ch 12)
Quick checkScreen 6
?After Small's outburst, Holmes says quietly: "We have not heard your story, and we cannot tell how far justice may originally have been on your side." What does this show most clearly?
Pick the strongestScreen 7
?Which sentence best answers: How does Doyle present justice in the novel?
Mission checkScreen 8

?Small calls his crime justice. Does the novel agree?
Mission 7

Why does Doyle's London keep vanishing into fog?

Make a guess: Why does Doyle's London keep vanishing into fog?

The Sign of Four · London describedScreen 1

The novel's London

The novel's LondonBaker Streetthe Strand and theLyceumacross Vauxhall Bridgeto the Surrey sidenew South LondonstreetsPondicherry Lodge,Upper Norwoodthe ThamesWestminster toPlumstead Marshes(ch X)
PlaceWhat Doyle stresses
Baker StreetOrder, books, "the yellow fog" outside (ch 1)
The Strand and the LyceumCrowds, lamps, fog (ch 3)
New South London suburbsRaw brick terraces, a "third-rate suburban dwelling-house" (ch 3)
Pondicherry Lodge, NorwoodHigh walls topped with broken glass; a garden dug into pits (ch 5)
The ThamesA night chase from the Tower to the marshes (ch 10)
  • Victorian London's fogs were thickened by smoke from coal fires and factories.
Extract The Sign of Four · London describedScreen 2

Into the fog

Into the fog1It was a September evening, and not yet seven2o’clock, but the day had been a dreary one, and3a dense drizzly fog lay low upon the great city.4Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the5muddy streets. Down the Strand the lamps6were but misty splotches of diffused light7which threw a feeble circular glimmer upon the8slimy pavement. The yellow glare from the9shop-windows streamed out into the steamy,10vaporous air, and threw a murky, shifting11radiance across the crowded thoroughfare.12There was, to my mind, something eerie and13ghost-like in the endless procession of faces14which flitted across these narrow bars of15light,—sad faces and glad, haggard and merry.16Like all human kind, they flitted from the17gloom into the light, and so back into the18gloom once more. I am not subject to19impressions, but the dull, heavy evening, with20the strange business upon which we were21engaged, combined to make me nervous and22depressed.11fog, Mud-coloured, muddy, misty, slimy, murky: asemantic field of murkThe Sign of Four, Chapter III

It was a September evening, and not yet seven o’clock, but the day had been a dreary one, and a dense drizzly fog lay low upon the great city. Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the muddy streets. Down the Strand the lamps were but misty splotches of diffused light which threw a feeble circular glimmer upon the slimy pavement. The yellow glare from the shop-windows streamed out into the steamy, vaporous air, and threw a murky, shifting radiance across the crowded thoroughfare. There was, to my mind, something eerie and ghost-like in the endless procession of faces which flitted across these narrow bars of light,—sad faces and glad, haggard and merry. Like all human kind, they flitted from the gloom into the light, and so back into the gloom once more. I am not subject to impressions, but the dull, heavy evening, with the strange business upon which we were engaged, combined to make me nervous and depressed.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter III "In Quest of a Solution". Holmes, Watson and Mary are driving to the Lyceum Theatre to meet an unknown letter-writer.
Method → effectScreen 3
?Watson describes the sky over the Strand. (Use the extract on screen 2.)
Show the extract (screen 2)

It was a September evening, and not yet seven o’clock, but the day had been a dreary one, and a dense drizzly fog lay low upon the great city. Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the muddy streets. Down the Strand the lamps were but misty splotches of diffused light which threw a feeble circular glimmer upon the slimy pavement. The yellow glare from the shop-windows streamed out into the steamy, vaporous air, and threw a murky, shifting radiance across the crowded thoroughfare. There was, to my mind, something eerie and ghost-like in the endless procession of faces which flitted across these narrow bars of light,—sad faces and glad, haggard and merry. Like all human kind, they flitted from the gloom into the light, and so back into the gloom once more. I am not subject to impressions, but the dull, heavy evening, with the strange business upon which we were engaged, combined to make me nervous and depressed.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter III "In Quest of a Solution". Holmes, Watson and Mary are driving to the Lyceum Theatre to meet an unknown letter-writer.
Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the muddy streets.

Step 1 Which method does Doyle use here?

Step 2 What effect does it have?

Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the words that turn the passing crowd into an image of all human life. (Use the extract on screen 2.)

Tap a word in the extract.

, , , . . . , , , . , , ,— , . , , . , , , , .

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter III "In Quest of a Solution". Holmes, Watson and Mary are driving to the Lyceum Theatre to meet an unknown letter-writer.
The Sign of Four · London describedScreen 5

A city that spreads

Monster tentaclesthe monster tentacles which the giantcity was throwing out into the countryThe Sign of Four, Chapter III
  • The new suburbs are "the monster tentacles which the giant city was throwing out into the country" (ch 3): a metaphor of a creature growing.
  • Thaddeus calls his room "An oasis of art in the howling desert of South London" (ch 4).
  • Against this, Mrs. Forrester's house is "a tranquil English home in the midst of the wild, dark business" (ch 7).
  • So safety sits in small, lit, private spaces; danger in the open city.
The Sign of Four · London describedScreen 6

The river and the marshes

  • The chase: the launch's engines "like a great metallic heart" (ch 10).
  • It ends by "the melancholy Plumstead Marshes", with "pools of stagnant water".
  • Tonga's bones lie in "the dark ooze at the bottom of the Thames".
  • The jewels are scattered "over five miles or so" of the river (ch 12).
  • London's river swallows the empire's treasure and the stranger it brought.
Rank themScreen 7
?Rank these answers to: How does Doyle present London in the extract on screen 2? (1 = strongest)
Show the extract (screen 2)

It was a September evening, and not yet seven o’clock, but the day had been a dreary one, and a dense drizzly fog lay low upon the great city. Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the muddy streets. Down the Strand the lamps were but misty splotches of diffused light which threw a feeble circular glimmer upon the slimy pavement. The yellow glare from the shop-windows streamed out into the steamy, vaporous air, and threw a murky, shifting radiance across the crowded thoroughfare. There was, to my mind, something eerie and ghost-like in the endless procession of faces which flitted across these narrow bars of light,—sad faces and glad, haggard and merry. Like all human kind, they flitted from the gloom into the light, and so back into the gloom once more. I am not subject to impressions, but the dull, heavy evening, with the strange business upon which we were engaged, combined to make me nervous and depressed.

Source: The Sign of Four, Chapter III "In Quest of a Solution". Holmes, Watson and Mary are driving to the Lyceum Theatre to meet an unknown letter-writer.

Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.

Mission checkScreen 8

?Why does Doyle's London keep vanishing into fog?
Recap

Big ideas

  • Two stories: the investigation (forward, in London, over a few days) and the crime (back to India in 1857), told last by Small.
  • Doyle follows detective conventions: genius detective, admiring narrator, slow police, locked room, clues, final explanation.
  • Paper 1 Section B starts from an extract and moves out to the whole novel, so know where each chapter sits.
  • Holmes uses cocaine when he has no case; in 1890 it was legal and sold by chemists, but Watson warns of the harm.
  • His method: observation, then deduction; Watson calls him "a calculating-machine".
  • Doyle presents him as brilliant but flawed: moody, vain, cold about women, and not always right.
  • Watson narrates afterwards and adds the "romanticism" Holmes dislikes; the romance plot is his.
  • Mary is presented through Watson's admiring eyes as calm, kind and capable; readers debate how much the novel lets her act.
  • The treasure is a "barrier" (ch 7) and a "golden barrier" (ch 11): when it is lost, love is free to speak.
  • The box travels from a rajah, through a murder at Agra, to the Andamans, to Norwood, to the Thames.
  • Sholto confesses that "cursed greed" was his "besetting sin"; Small says the treasure brought "a curse" on each owner.
  • Every claim is stained: the strongest answers weigh them, not pick a winner without evidence.
  • Context: India under British rule; the 1857 Rebellion; the Andaman convict settlement founded after it.
  • Abdullah Khan's offer, "We ask you to be rich", turns a light on why the British characters are in India.
  • Tonga is presented only through others' words; read that presentation critically, as a product of imperial racial thinking.
  • Official justice is clumsy: Jones arrests the innocent and still gets the credit.
  • Small's "A pretty justice!" speech argues he earned the treasure by suffering; the novel lets him speak.
  • But Small is also a killer, and Watson's horror balances his case: argue both sides with evidence.
  • The fog (ch 1, ch 3) creates mood: pathetic fallacy and personification make the city gloomy and threatening.
  • Doyle's London spreads ("monster tentacles"), while safety is found in small private homes.
  • The Thames chase ends in marshes and "dark ooze", where the treasure and Tonga are lost.

Key quotations to learn

  • "Detection is, or ought to be, an exact science" (Ch I, "The Science of Deduction") Holmes's view of his work, against Watson's romance.
  • "when you have eliminated the impossible whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth" (Ch VI, "Sherlock Holmes Gives a Demonstration") The locked-room method.
  • "You know my methods. Apply them" (Ch VI, "Sherlock Holmes Gives a Demonstration") The reader is invited to try too.
  • "This is all an insoluble mystery to me" (Ch V, "The Tragedy of Pondicherry Lodge") Watson's puzzlement keeps the suspense.
  • "nothing at all new to me in the latter part of your narrative" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Small's story confirms Holmes's deductions.
  • "My mind … rebels at stagnation." (Ch I, "The Science of Deduction") His need for problems.
  • "I cannot live without brain-work." (Ch I, "The Science of Deduction") Explains the cocaine.
  • "I never guess." (Ch I, "The Science of Deduction") Confidence in his method.
  • "You really are an automaton,—a calculating-machine!" (Ch II, "The Statement of the Case") Watson on his coldness.
  • "A client is to me a mere unit,—a factor in a problem." (Ch II, "The Statement of the Case") Reason over feeling.
  • "there still remains the cocaine-bottle" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") The ending circles back.
  • "a firm step and an outward composure" (Ch II, "The Statement of the Case") First impression of Mary.
  • "After the angelic fashion of women" (Ch VII, "The Episode of the Barrel") Watson's Victorian ideal of women.
  • "a mere vulgar fortune-seeker" (Ch VII, "The Episode of the Barrel") The charge Watson fears.
  • "This Agra treasure intervened like an impassable barrier between us." (Ch VII, "The Episode of the Barrel") Money as an obstacle (simile).
  • "the golden barrier was gone from between us" (Ch XI, "The Great Agra Treasure") The same image, now a metaphor.
  • "Whoever had lost a treasure, I knew that night that I had gained one." (Ch XI, "The Great Agra Treasure") Love outweighs riches.
  • "The cursed greed which has been my besetting sin" (Ch IV, "The Story of the Bald-Headed Man") Sholto's confession.
  • "so blind and foolish a thing is avarice" (Ch IV, "The Story of the Bald-Headed Man") Greed brings no pleasure.
  • "never brought anything but a curse yet upon the man who owned it" (Ch XI, "The Great Agra Treasure") The treasure as a curse.
  • "Look how I have earned it!" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Small's claim through suffering.
  • "It’s a dirty business" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Morstan's own judgement of the bargain.
  • "We only ask you to do that which your countrymen come to this land for. We ask you to be rich." (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Empire and greed linked.
  • "I am as ready to be rich as you can be" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Small agrees at once.
  • "our own picked troops, whom we had taught and trained" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") The rebels were the Company's own soldiers.
  • "the suggestion of Eastern luxury" (Ch IV, "The Story of the Bald-Headed Man") India brought home as décor.
  • "that strange visitor to our shores" (Ch X, "The End of the Islander") Tonga dies an outsider, unmourned.
  • "Stern facts here,—no room for theories" (Ch VI, "Sherlock Holmes Gives a Demonstration") Jones's confident blundering.
  • "You are welcome to all the official credit" (Ch IX, "A Break in the Chain") Holmes and the police.
  • "Justice!" snarled the ex-convict. "A pretty justice!" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Small's challenge to the law.
  • "Look how I have earned it!" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Suffering as a claim.
  • "we cannot tell how far justice may originally have been on your side" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Holmes listens before judging.
  • "the utmost horror of the man" (Ch XII, "The Strange Story of Jonathan Small") Watson's judgement balances Small's.
  • "See how the yellow fog swirls down the street" (Ch I, "The Science of Deduction") Holmes's dull, foggy world.
  • "a dense drizzly fog lay low upon the great city" (Ch III, "In Quest of a Solution") The fog sets the mood.
  • "Mud-coloured clouds drooped sadly over the muddy streets." (Ch III, "In Quest of a Solution") Personification, pathetic fallacy.
  • "they flitted from the gloom into the light, and so back into the gloom once more" (Ch III, "In Quest of a Solution") The crowd as human life.
  • "the monster tentacles which the giant city was throwing out into the country" (Ch III, "In Quest of a Solution") The city as a spreading creature.
  • "a tranquil English home in the midst of the wild, dark business" (Ch VII, "The Episode of the Barrel") Safety in the private home.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through The Sign of Four for AQA GCSE English Literature. 🎉

  1. Mission 1The thieves are caught in chapter 10. Why are there two more?
  2. Mission 2Why does Holmes's story open and close with cocaine?
  3. Mission 3Why is Watson glad when the treasure box is empty?
  4. Mission 4Who has the best right to the Agra treasure?
  5. Mission 5Does the danger come from abroad, or from Britain's own men?
  6. Mission 6Small calls his crime justice. Does the novel agree?
  7. Mission 7Why does Doyle's London keep vanishing into fog?

Your stars: 0 / 0

Next: more lessons and games on the GCSE English Literature · AQA page.

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a mate to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE English Literature · AQA

Specification points and sources for this lesson are listed at the bottom of the page.

Sources (18)

The specification points and sources behind this lesson.

  1. 1 AQA GCSE English Literature 8702 spec v1.3, Paper 1, 3.1.2 and 4.2
  2. 2 AQA 8702/1 question paper, June 2023, https://filestore.aqa.org.uk/sample-papers-and-mark-schemes/2023/june/AQA-87021-QP-MQP18A4-JUN23.PDF (as cited for JH1)
  3. 3 AQA GCSE English Literature 8702 spec v1.3, 3.1.2 and 4.2
  4. 4 "The Sign of the Four", Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sign_of_the_Four
  5. 5 Smithsonian Magazine, "Edgar Allan Poe invented the detective story", https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/edgar-allan-poe-invented-detective-story-180962914/
  6. 6 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch I; ch V; ch VI; ch IX; ch XII
  7. 7 "Drug policy of the United Kingdom", Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_the_United_Kingdom
  8. 8 "Sherlock Holmes and the Seven Percent Solution", https://www.jack-the-ripper-tour.com/generalnews/sherlock-holmes-and-the-seven-percent-solution/
  9. 9 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch I; ch II; ch III; ch VII; ch IX; ch XII
  10. 10 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch I; ch II; ch IV; ch V; ch VII; ch IX; ch XI; ch XII
  11. 11 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch IV; ch IX; ch X; ch XI; ch XII
  12. 12 "Indian Rebellion of 1857", Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Rebellion_of_1857
  13. 13 "Andaman Islands", Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andaman_Islands
  14. 14 Arup K. Chatterjee, "The science of the Andamans and the sign of the four: The distorted racial hierarchy of British imperial anthropology", Shima 14(2), 2020, pp. 214–234; abstract at https://pure.jgu.edu.in/id/eprint/174/
  15. 15 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch I; ch II; ch IV; ch VIII; ch X; ch XII
  16. 16 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch IV; ch VI; ch VII; ch VIII; ch IX; ch X; ch XI; ch XII
  17. 17 "What Caused The Fog In London", https://www.jack-the-ripper-tour.com/generalnews/what-caused-the-fog-in-london/
  18. 18 Conan Doyle, The Sign of the Four : ch I; ch III; ch IV; ch V; ch VII; ch X; ch XII