← IB Economics · SL IB Economics revision
⭐ 0
IB Diploma Economics SL · 3.5 Demand management: monetary policy; 3.6 Demand management: fiscal policy; 3.7 Supply-side policies
Mini-Lesson

Demand management: monetary policy; Demand management: fiscal policy; Supply-side policies

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?
  2. Mission 2If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?
  3. Mission 3When a slump hits, can a government spend its way out of it?
  4. Mission 4If a country's yearly deficit keeps shrinking, how can its debt still be growing?
  5. Mission 5How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  6. Mission 6Should a country's trains, water pipes and power lines be run by the state or by private companies?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Aggregate demand and supply; 1 mission in Macroeconomic objectives.

Mission 1

Mission 1: How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?

Make a guess: How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?

Mission 1

What monetary policy is

  • Monetary policy: the central bank's use of interest rates and the money supply to influence demand and inflation.
  • A central bank (such as the European Central Bank or the Reserve Bank of India) sets a policy interest rate (base rate).
  • Expansionary policy: lower rates, more money. Contractionary: higher rates, less money.
Mission 1

Goals: an inflation target

  • Main goal: price stability, which means low and stable inflation.
  • Many central banks target about 2% inflation (e.g. the euro area and the US). Other goals: low unemployment, a smaller business cycle, long-term growth, external balance.
  • Why a target: it anchors expectations. If people expect 2%, wages and prices are set to match.
Mission 1

The transmission mechanism

Transmission mechanismMarket rates ↑Asset prices ↓Confidence andexpectationsExchange rate ↑Policyinterest rate↑Spending: C, I, netexports ↓AD ↓Inflation ↓
  • How a rise in the policy rate reaches inflation:
    • Market rates rise: mortgages, loans, savings. Borrowing costs more; saving pays more. Consumption (C) and investment (I) fall.
    • Asset prices fall (houses, shares, bonds). Households feel less wealthy and spend less.
    • Confidence and expectations: a signal that the central bank is serious about inflation.
    • Exchange rate rises: exports more expensive abroad, imports cheaper. Net exports fall; import prices fall.
  • Result: AD grows more slowly. Less pressure on firms' capacity, wages and prices. Inflation slows.
  • A cut works the other way.
Mission 1

Monetary policy on AD/AS

Monetary policy on AD/ASContractionary: rate riseAverage price level0P1P2Y2 = YpY1inflationary gapReal output (real GDP)SRASLRASAD1AD2Expansionary: rate cutAverage price level0P2P1Y1Y2 = Ypdeflationary/recessionary gapReal output (real GDP)SRASLRASAD1AD2
  • Contractionary (rate rise): AD shifts left, AD1 → AD2.
    • Real output falls. The price level is lower than it would have been.
    • Closes an inflationary (positive) gap.
  • Expansionary (rate cut): AD shifts right.
    • Real output and the price level rise. Unemployment falls.
    • Closes a deflationary or recessionary (negative) gap.
  • IB names: deflationary (recessionary) gap and inflationary gap.
  • Say: "inflation slows" (disinflation) — not: "prices fall", unless the price level actually falls (deflation).
Mission 1Graph lab

Closing an inflationary gap

Illustrative data.

Closing an inflationary gapAverage price levelReal output520110LRASSRASAD
  • Takeaway: a rate rise shifts AD left. Too small leaves a gap; too large pushes output below full employment.
Quick check
?A central bank raises its policy interest rate. Which chain of effects is most likely?
Mission 1

Real case: the rate rises after the pandemic

  • Euro area: the European Central Bank raised its deposit rate from −0.5% (2022) to 4.0% (September 2023). Inflation had peaked at 10.6% (October 2022).
  • Inflation then fell, but economists debate how much was due to higher rates and how much to falling energy prices.
Mission 1

Strengths and limits

  • Strengths:
    • Flexible: rates can change in small steps, several times a year.
    • Reversible, and quick to decide: no new law needed.
    • An independent central bank is credible: a promise to hit the target shapes expectations.
  • Limits:
    • Time lags: up to about two years for the full effect on inflation (Bank of England).
    • Supply shocks: rate rises can lower inflation, but at the cost of lower output and jobs.
    • Low confidence: firms and households may not borrow, however cheap credit is.
    • One rate for everyone: regions, and borrowers and savers, are hit differently.
Mission 1

The zero lower bound

  • Rates cannot be cut far below zero: people could hold cash instead.
  • Zero lower bound: once rates are near zero, conventional policy has little room left.
  • Real cases: Bank Rate 0.1% (March 2020). The European Central Bank's deposit rate reached −0.5% (2019); the Bank of Japan's short-term rate was −0.1% from 2016 to March 2024.
  • Liquidity trap (Keynes): rates are so low that more money does not raise spending; people just hold it.
  • Central banks then turn to QE and forward guidance.
Quick check
?A recession has cut confidence. The central bank's policy rate is already 0.25%, and banks are unwilling to lend. Why might a further rate cut do little to raise AD?
Mission 1Evaluate

How well can interest rates steer the economy?

It depends on:

  • The cause of inflation: demand-pull responds well; a supply shock forces a choice between inflation and output.
  • Time lags: a rate change made now acts on demand up to two years later, when conditions may have changed.
  • Confidence and debt: with many variable-rate borrowers, rates bite fast; when confidence is low, cuts may not work.
  • How low rates already are: near the zero lower bound, other tools are needed.
Mission check

?A sharp rise in world oil prices pushes a country's inflation well above target, while real output falls. The central bank raises its policy rate. What is the most likely result in the short run?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?

Make a guess: If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?

Mission 2

Nominal and real

Nominal and real interest rateSavings1,0001,050Nominal rate 5%Price of a basket1,0001,030Inflation 3%Baskets you can afford11.019Real rate ≈ 2% · about 2% moreIllustrative data
  • You save 1,000 for one year at an interest rate of 5% (illustrative data).
  • After a year you have 1,050. That 5% is the nominal interest rate: the rate in money terms, not adjusted for inflation.
  • Over the same year, inflation is 3%. A basket that cost 1,000 now costs 1,030.
  • 1,050 ÷ 1,030 = 1.019. You can buy only about 2% more than a year ago.
  • That 2% is the real interest rate: the rise in what your savings can buy.
  • Say: "the real interest rate fell" — not: "interest rates fell", when the nominal rate stayed the same and only inflation rose.
Mission 2

The Fisher relation

  • Real interest rate ≈ nominal interest rate − inflation rate.
  • Named after the economist Irving Fisher.
  • Example: nominal 5%, inflation 3% → real ≈ 5 − 3 = 2%.
  • If inflation is higher than the nominal rate, the real rate is negative: savings buy less each year.
  • The exact answer here is 1.94%, not 2%. The subtraction is close when rates are low, and it is the form you use in calculations.
  • Say: "real interest rate = nominal rate minus inflation" — not: "nominal rate minus the interest".
Quick check
?A bank pays a nominal interest rate of 6% on savings. Inflation over the year is 8%. What is the real interest rate?
Mission 2

When real rates go negative

A negative real interest rateEuro area, October 2022Deposit rate0.75%Inflation10.6%Real rate≈ −9.85%Source: ECB deposit facility rate; Eurostat HICPinflation, October 2022
  • Real-world data, euro area, October 2022:
  • The European Central Bank's deposit rate was 0.75%. Euro area inflation was 10.6%.
  • Real rate on that deposit ≈ 0.75 − 10.6 = −9.85%.
  • Nominal rates had started to rise, but real rates were still deeply negative.
  • Borrowers care about the real rate too: a negative real rate means a debt shrinks in real terms.
  • So a rise in the nominal rate is not always "tighter" money: it depends on what happens to inflation.
Mission 2

Expected and actual inflation

Expected and actual inflationLoan agreedExpected inflation 2%Nominal rate 5%planned real rate 3%one year latergain to borrowerLoan repaidActual inflation 6%Nominal rate 5%real rate −1%Illustrative data
  • Lenders set the nominal rate before they know the inflation rate.
  • A lender wants a real return of 3% and expects inflation of 2%. It charges 3 + 2 = 5% nominal (illustrative data).
  • Inflation turns out to be 6%.
  • Real rate actually earned = 5 − 6 = −1%, not the 3% planned.
  • Unexpected inflation helps borrowers and hurts lenders: the money repaid buys less than both expected.
  • Unexpectedly low inflation does the reverse.
Quick check
?A firm borrows at a fixed nominal rate of 7% for one year. When the loan is agreed, both sides expect inflation of 3%. Actual inflation turns out to be 1%. Which statement is correct?
Mission check

?A central bank raises its nominal policy rate from 3% to 5%. Over the same period, inflation rises from 2% to 7%. What happened to the real policy rate?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When a slump hits, can a government spend its way out of it?

Make a guess: When a slump hits, can a government spend its way out of it?

Mission 3

What fiscal policy is

  • Fiscal policy: the use of government spending and taxation to influence the economy.
  • Main aim: steady AD, so output stays close to potential: growth, jobs, low inflation.
  • Budget deficit: spending > tax revenue in a year. Budget surplus: tax revenue > spending.
  • National debt: the total stock of past borrowing still owed.
  • Illustrative data: debt 1,000 bn; deficit of 50 bn this year → debt 1,050 bn. A surplus of 10 bn next year → debt 1,040 bn.
  • Say: "the deficit is a yearly flow; the debt is the stock" — not: "deficit and debt mean the same".
Mission 3

Where the money goes and where it comes from

  • Current spending: day-to-day items: public-sector wages, medicines, school supplies.
  • Capital spending: investment that lasts: roads, hospitals, broadband.
  • Transfer payments: pensions and benefits; nothing is produced in return, so they are not part of G in GDP.
  • Revenue: taxes (on income, profits, spending), plus charges for state-provided goods and services and sales of state assets.
Mission 3

Types of tax

  • Direct tax: on income or wealth, paid straight to the government (income tax, corporation tax).
  • Indirect tax: on spending, collected by sellers (VAT, excise duties).
  • Illustrative data, two people earning 20,000 and 80,000 a year:
TypeLower earner paysHigher earner paysShare of income
Progressive2,00020,00010% → 25%: rises with income
Proportional2,0008,00010% for both
Regressive3,0006,00015% → 7.5%: falls with income
  • Indirect taxes are often regressive: lower earners spend a larger share of income.
  • Say: "a regressive tax takes a smaller share of a higher income" — not: "the rich pay less tax".
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a worker earning 30,000 a year pays 3,000 in tax. A manager earning 60,000 a year pays 6,000. What kind of tax is this?
Mission 3

Expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy

Expansionary and contractionary fiscal policyAverage price level0PL1PL2PL2PL1Y1YpY1deflationary (recessionary) gapinflationary gapReal GDPSRASLRASAD1AD2AD1AD2Expansionary: AD shifts right to close thedeflationary (recessionary) gapContractionary: AD shifts left to close theinflationary gap
  • Expansionary: raise G and/or cut taxes → AD shifts right.
  • Used to close a deflationary (recessionary) gap: real output and employment rise; the price level rises a little.
  • Contractionary: cut G and/or raise taxes → AD shifts left.
  • Used to close an inflationary gap: inflationary pressure eases.
Mission 3Graph lab

Close the gap

Illustrative data. Real output is 460; full-employment output is 500: a deflationary (recessionary) gap of 40.

Close the gapAverage price levelReal GDP460100LRAS (Yp)SRASAD
  • Takeaway: expansionary fiscal policy shifts AD right: real output and jobs rise, and so does the price level.
Quick check
?An economy has output above full capacity and inflation well above target. Which policy is contractionary fiscal policy?
Mission 3

Two views: Keynesian vs monetarist and new classical

Two views of fiscal policyKeynesian viewAverage price level0YpReal GDPKeynesian ASAD1AD2AD3AD4Flat section: output rises, the price level stays.Vertical section: the price level rises.Monetarist / new classical viewAverage price level0PL3PL2PL1YpY2Real GDPSRAS1LRASAD1AD2SRAS2AD rises: output goes above Yp. Then SRASshifts left: output returns to Yp at a higher pricelevel.
  • Keynesian view: AS is flat when there is lots of spare capacity.
    • In a deep recession, expansionary fiscal policy raises real output and jobs with little inflation.
    • Near full capacity, it mainly raises the price level.
  • Monetarist / new classical view: LRAS is vertical at potential output.
    • In the short run, more G raises output and the price level.
    • In the long run, wages and costs adjust: SRAS shifts left. Output returns to potential, at a higher price level.
  • So the two views disagree on how far fiscal policy can raise output for long.
Mission 3

Fiscal policy on the supply side

Fiscal policy on the supply sideAverage price level0Real GDPSRASLRAS1AD1AD2LRAS2short run: AD shifts right (spending now)long run: LRAS shifts right (more capacity, yearslater)
  • Some fiscal measures also shift LRAS right:
    • capital spending on infrastructure, broadband, transport
    • spending on education, training and health
    • tax incentives for investment or research
  • These raise productive capacity: more output with less pressure on prices.
  • But they take years, and the first effect is on AD (spending now).
  • The same works the other way: supply-side policies that involve spending also raise AD in the short run.
Mission 3

Time lags and other limits

  • Fiscal policy needs a decision: the government chooses to change spending or tax rates.
  • Time lags: spotting the problem, deciding, passing it into law, then waiting for it to work.
  • A stimulus that arrives late may push up demand when recovery has already begun.
  • Political pressure: tax cuts and spending rises are popular; tax rises and spending cuts are not.
  • Sustainable debt: high debt raises interest costs and may limit room for future stimulus.
Mission 3

Strengths and a real case

  • Strengths: fiscal policy can target sectors or regions (e.g. house building, low-income households).
  • It can work when interest rates are already near zero and monetary policy has little room left: a deep recession.
  • UK 2008–09: VAT was cut from 17.5% to 15% from December 2008 to December 2009, to support spending during the recession. Its effect is debated: some spending was brought forward rather than added.
  • Economists disagree on how much such measures added to output.
Quick check
?A government's budget deficit falls from 50 billion last year to 30 billion this year. What happened to the national debt this year, other things equal?
Mission 3Evaluate

How effective is fiscal policy?

It depends on:

  • Spare capacity: in a deep recession, extra demand raises output; near capacity it mostly raises prices.
  • Time lags: stimulus can arrive too late.
  • Confidence and debt: if people expect future tax rises to repay debt, they may save more. If markets doubt debt is sustainable, interest rates may rise.
Mission check

?A government spots a recession and plans a large spending programme. It takes 18 months to pass and start, and by then the economy is already recovering strongly. What is the main risk?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If a country's yearly deficit keeps shrinking, how can its debt still be growing?

Make a guess: If a country's yearly deficit keeps shrinking, how can its debt still be growing?

Mission 4

Three kinds of spending

Three kinds of government spendingCurrent spendingsalaries, medicinesCapital spendingrail line, hospitalTransfer paymentspensions, benefitsGADnot in G
  • Current spending: day-to-day running costs that are used up within the year. Salaries of teachers and nurses, medicines, office supplies.
  • Capital spending: investment in assets that last for years. New roads, rail lines, hospitals, school buildings.
  • Transfer payments: money paid to people with no good or service in return. Pensions, unemployment benefits, child benefit.
  • Transfers move income from taxpayers to recipients. They are not part of government spending (G) in AD, because no output is bought.
  • G is a component of AD. Capital spending can also raise LRAS over time (better infrastructure, more productive workers).
Mission 4

Where the money comes from, and what for

  • Direct taxes: on income and wealth, paid straight to the government. Income tax, corporation tax.
  • Indirect taxes: on spending, collected by sellers. VAT (sales tax), excise duties on fuel, alcohol and tobacco.
  • Also: sales of goods and services by state-owned enterprises (e.g. public transport fares), and sales of government assets (privatisation).
  • Goals of fiscal policy: low and stable inflation · low unemployment · a stable environment for long-term growth · smaller business cycle swings · a fairer income distribution · external balance.
Quick check
?Which of these is an example of government capital expenditure?
Mission 4

The budget balance

The budget balance900Current 650Capital 100Transfers 2501,000Tax revenueSpendingDeficit = 100Illustrative data, billion.
  • Budget balance = tax revenue − government spending (incl. transfers), over one year.
  • Deficit: spending > revenue. Surplus: revenue > spending. Balanced budget: equal.
  • Illustrative data (billion): tax revenue 900 · current spending 650 · capital spending 100 · transfers 250.
  • Spending = 650 + 100 + 250 = 1,000.
  • Budget balance = 900 − 1,000 = −100: a deficit of 100.
  • A deficit means the government injects more into the economy than it takes out in tax: other things equal, it adds to AD.
Mission 4

Deficit vs debt

The national debt as a bathtubNational debtstockadded this yearDeficit(this year)flowSurplusDebt is a stock: the total owed.Each year's deficit is a flow added to the debt.A surplus drains the tub: the debt is paid down.
  • Deficit is a flow: how much more the government spends than it raises in one year.
  • National debt is a stock: the total owed, built up from all past borrowing.
  • Each year's deficit is borrowed, so it is added to the debt. A surplus can be used to pay debt down.
  • Picture a bath: the deficit is the water flowing in this year; the debt is the water in the tub.
  • So a smaller deficit still adds to the debt, just more slowly. Paying the debt down needs a surplus.
  • Say: "the deficit fell, so the debt grew more slowly" — not: "the deficit fell, so the debt fell".
Quick check
?A government's deficit falls from 80 billion last year to 50 billion this year. Nothing else changes. What happens to the national debt this year?
Mission 4

Why high debt can limit a government

Costs of a high debt:

  • Debt interest: money spent on interest cannot be spent on schools or health, or returned in lower taxes.
  • Credit ratings: agencies grade the risk that a government will not repay. A downgrade can raise the interest rate it must pay.
  • Future taxes and spending: higher taxes or spending cuts may be needed later.
  • Less room to borrow in the next recession.
  • A sustainable debt is one the government can keep servicing (paying the interest and repaying loans as they fall due) without needing ever more borrowing. These costs are why debt is a constraint on fiscal policy.

Possible benefits of a deficit:

  • It supports AD and jobs in a recession.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a government's national debt is 300 billion at the start of Year 1. Its budget balances are: Year 1, surplus of 20 billion · Year 2, surplus of 5 billion · Year 3, deficit of 15 billion. What is the national debt at the end of Year 3?
Mission 5

Mission 5: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Make a guess: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Mission 5

What supply-side policies aim to do

  • Supply-side policies: government policies that aim to raise the economy's productive capacity.
  • They work on the quantity and quality of factors of production and on how efficiently markets work.
  • Goals:
    • long-term growth: LRAS shifts right
    • a lower natural rate of unemployment
    • growth with less inflationary pressure
    • better international competitiveness
Mission 5

On the AD/AS diagram

Supply-side policy shifts LRAS rightAverage price level0P1P2Yfe1Yfe2Real output (real GDP)ADSRAS1LRAS1LRAS2SRAS2Capacity rises: real output up, price level down.
  • Capacity rises: LRAS shifts right.
  • Productive capacity rises from Yfe1 to Yfe2.
  • With AD unchanged: real output rises, the price level falls.
  • Lower costs per unit often shift SRAS right too.
  • On the Keynesian AS, the vertical section shifts right.
  • Employment can rise at a lower natural rate of unemployment.
Quick check
?Which policy is most clearly aimed at the supply side of the economy?
Mission 5

Worked example: per person, what can policy change?

  • Illustrative data. Real GDP per person = output per hour × hours per worker × workers ÷ population.
  • Population 10 million; workers 5 million; 1,600 hours each a year; output per hour 50.
  • Real GDP = 50 × 1,600 × 5 million = 400 billion. Per person: 40,000.
  • Policy 1: childcare and job support bring 0.5 million more people into work. Real GDP = 440 billion; per person 44,000 (+10%).
  • Policy 2: training and better equipment raise output per hour to 55. Per person also 44,000 (+10%).
  • Both together: 48,400 per person: +21%, not +20%, because the effects multiply.
  • Labour productivity (output per worker or per hour) depends on capital per worker, skills, health, technology and management.
Mission 5

Two approaches

Two approaches to supply-side policyMarket-basedInterventionistCut income and profittaxes (incentives)Education and trainingReform benefitsHealth careReduce trade unionpower; flexible labourmarketsR&D subsidies andgrantsDeregulationInfrastructure(transport, broadband,energy)PrivatisationIndustrial policy:support for chosenindustriesCompetition(anti-monopoly) policy;trade liberalisationSubsidies to firms orregions
Market-basedInterventionist
Cut income and profit taxes (incentives)Education and training
Reform benefitsHealth care
Reduce trade union power; flexible labour marketsR&D subsidies and grants
DeregulationInfrastructure (transport, broadband, energy)
PrivatisationIndustrial policy: support for chosen industries
Competition (anti-monopoly) policy; trade liberalisationSubsidies to firms or regions
  • Market-based: free markets and incentives work better with fewer barriers.
  • Interventionist: markets under-provide some things (positive externalities, public goods), so the government steps in.
Mission 5

Market-based policies: how they work

  • Lower income tax raises the reward for work: some work more hours or join the labour force.
  • Lower profit tax raises the return on investment: more capital, more productivity.
  • Benefit reform: a bigger gap between income in and out of work makes taking a job more attractive. Voluntary unemployment falls: a lower natural rate.
  • Deregulation and privatisation: fewer rules and a profit motive push firms to cut costs and innovate.
  • Competition policy and trade liberalisation: rivals force firms to be efficient.
  • Labour market reform: weaker union power and more flexible contracts let wages and jobs adjust faster.
  • But: some of these may widen inequality or weaken job security.
Mission 5

Labour market diagrams

Labour market diagramsMinimum wage above the equilibrium wageWage rate (W)0WminWeLdLeLsunemploymentQuantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)Labour supply shifts rightWage rate (W)0W1W2L1L2Quantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)1S(L)2Benefit reform, flexibility: more people seek workat each wage.
  • Minimum wage: set above the equilibrium wage, labour supplied exceeds labour demanded: unemployment (Ls − Ld).
  • Removing or lowering it: employment moves towards Le. Evidence on how many jobs this adds is mixed.
  • Benefit reform and flexibility: more people seek work at each wage, so labour supply shifts right: employment rises.
Mission 5

Interventionist policies: how they work

  • Education and training raise human capital: more output per worker. Fewer skill gaps: lower structural unemployment.
  • Health care: fewer days lost to illness; longer working lives.
  • R&D: new ideas spill over to other firms (a positive externality), so markets under-invest. Subsidies or tax credits raise R&D.
  • Infrastructure: roads, rail and broadband cut firms' costs and link workers to jobs.
  • Industrial policy: support for strategic industries.
  • But: costly, slow, and the government may "pick losers" (government failure).
Quick check
?A government sells its state-owned rail company to private investors and lets rival firms bid to run routes. How is this policy meant to raise LRAS?
Mission 5

Two effects at different speeds

Two effects at different speedsAverage price level0Yfe1Yfe2Real output (real GDP)AD1LRAS1AD2LRAS2spending nowyears later
  • Many supply-side policies also change spending:
    • building roads or schools is government spending: AD shifts right at once
    • a tax cut raises disposable income: AD shifts right
  • The supply-side effect comes later, once the road is built or the trained workers arrive: LRAS shifts right.
  • So fiscal policy can have supply-side effects (e.g. tax incentives), and supply-side policies can have demand-side effects.
Mission 5Graph lab

Build now, grow later

Illustrative data. Start: real output 1000 at full employment; price level 100.

Build now, grow laterAverage price levelReal GDP1,000100LRASADSRAS
  • Takeaway: short run (demand effect) output 1050, price level 105; long run, once capacity grows, output 1100 and the price level back to 100.
Quick check
?A government cuts the top rate of income tax. Which effect is a supply-side effect?
Mission 5

Real world: cutting taxes on company profits

  • The US cut its main federal corporate tax rate from 35% to 21% from 2018.
  • Aim: more investment in capital, so higher productivity and pay.
  • One 2024 study estimated investment rose by about 11% at firms given the average tax cut, compared with firms given none, but wages and growth rose by less than supporters had claimed.
  • The UK cut its main corporation tax rate from 28% (2010) to 19% (2017), then raised it to 25% in 2023 for profits over £250,000.
  • Question to weigh: how would you judge whether a tax cut on profits raised capacity, and over how many years?
Mission 5Evaluate

How well do supply-side policies work?

It depends on:

  • Time lags. Education, health and infrastructure take years, even decades, to raise capacity.
  • Response to incentives. Tax cuts may change effort or investment only a little; profits may go to shareholders instead.
  • Cost and trade-offs. Interventionist policies need spending (opportunity cost); market-based ones may widen inequality.
  • The output gap. With weak AD, extra capacity sits unused; Keynesians would boost demand first.
  • Government failure. Poor information can lead to wasted subsidies or badly designed rules.
  • Strength: if they work, growth with lower inflation and a lower natural rate of unemployment.
  • Budget, equity, environment. Tax cuts and spending both strain the government budget; looser rules may weaken worker or environmental protection.
Mission check

?A government expands free childcare and job training, paid for by cutting other spending, so AD does not change. Over several years, more parents take jobs and workers become more skilled. According to the AD/AS model, what happens in the long run?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Should a country's trains, water pipes and power lines be run by the state or by private companies?

Make a guess: Should a country's trains, water pipes and power lines be run by the state or by private companies?

Mission 6

Four tools, four meanings

  • Nationalisation: the state takes a firm or industry into public ownership.
  • Privatisation: transfer of a firm or activity from the public sector to the private sector.
  • Regulation: rules set by government or an appointed regulator, e.g. on prices, quality, safety or entry.
  • Deregulation: removing rules that restrict entry, prices or how firms operate.
  • Ownership (who owns it) and market structure (how many rivals) are separate questions.
  • Say: "privatisation changes the owner" — not: "privatisation creates competition".
Mission 6

Forms of privatisation

Ownership and control mapWho owns?publicsectorprivatesectorprivatisationnationalisationWho provides?state staffprivatecontractorcontractingoutstate still paysWho may enter?private rivallicence gatestatemonopolyderegulation / liberalisation
  • Sale of a state-owned firm: shares sold to the public or a buyer (denationalisation). E.g. British Telecom (1984).
  • Contracting out (competitive tendering): the state still pays for a service but invites private firms to bid to provide it, e.g. bin collection.
  • Liberalisation: opening a state monopoly to private rivals (a form of deregulation).
  • Privatisation and deregulation are market-based supply-side policies: they aim to raise competition and efficiency.
Mission 6

The case for privatisation

  • Profit motive: private owners gain from cutting costs, so less X-inefficiency (waste when a firm faces little pressure to keep costs down).
  • Shareholder pressure: a poorly run firm's share price falls, and it risks a takeover.
  • Competition, where the industry allows rivals: lower prices, more choice.
  • Access to private capital for investment, without adding to government borrowing.
  • One-off revenue for the government from the sale.
  • Less political interference in pricing and investment decisions.
  • Example: the UK sold telecoms (1984), gas (1986), water in England and Wales (1989), electricity (1990–91) and rail (1994–97).
Mission 6

The case against, and renationalisation

  • A natural monopoly (one network serves the whole market most cheaply, e.g. a power grid) sold whole stays a monopoly: a private monopoly still needs regulation.
  • Short-termism: dividends may come before long-term investment.
  • Social objectives may be dropped, e.g. loss-making rural routes.
  • Sale price: if shares are sold too cheaply, taxpayers lose; the one-off revenue replaces a flow of future profits.
  • Fragmentation: splitting a network among many firms can raise coordination costs.
  • Renationalisation arguments: run for the public interest, cheaper public borrowing, no dividends to pay out, one integrated network.
  • Example: Railtrack (privatised rail infrastructure) was replaced in 2002 by Network Rail, now a public body. A 2024 law lets passenger train services in Great Britain return to public ownership as contracts end.
Quick check
?A city council stops using its own staff to clean public parks. It invites private firms to bid, and pays the winning firm to do the work for five years. The parks stay free to use. Which policy is this?
Mission 6

Deregulation, licences and prohibitions

Licence capFare (Price)0PeQeRides per day (Quantity)DS = MCFree market: D meets S = MC at Pe, Qe.
  • A licence limits who may operate (e.g. taxis, mobile spectrum). A prohibition bans an activity outright.
  • Deregulation removes barriers, so new firms can enter: supply rises, prices fall, choice widens.
  • Example: the US Airline Deregulation Act (1978) ended government control of fares and routes.
  • Example: UK local buses outside London were deregulated in 1986: any licensed operator could run a route.
  • Risks: firms "cherry-pick" profitable routes; safety and quality may suffer; financial deregulation can raise risk-taking.
  • Say: "deregulation lowers barriers to entry" — not: "deregulation means no rules at all".
Mission 6Graph lab

Lift the licence cap

Illustrative data. A city caps taxi licences, limiting rides to 5,000 a day. Fare: 20. Cost of the last ride (MC): 11.

Lift the licence capFare, costRides per day5,0002011DS = MClicence capgap 9
  • Takeaway: removing an entry limit shifts the market to where price = MC. The gap was a reward for holding a licence.
Licence capFare (Price)020PePe = 14115,000QeQe = 8,000Rides per day (Quantity)DS = MCLicence capcap removedlicence reward: the gap between fare andcostFree market: D meets S = MC at Pe, Qe.Entry allowed: rides rise and the fare falls to thecost of the last ride.
Mission 6

Supply side: shifting LRAS

LRAS shiftAverage price level0P1P2Y1Y2Real GDPADLRAS1LRAS2Privatisation and deregulation, if they work:LRAS shifts right, real GDP rises and the pricelevel falls.
  • Privatisation and deregulation aim to raise efficiency, competition and incentives to innovate.
  • If they work, the economy's productive capacity rises: LRAS shifts right (LRAS1 → LRAS2).
  • With AD unchanged: real GDP rises and the price level falls.
  • Limits: effects take time; a private monopoly may not become more efficient; gains may be small for the whole economy.
Mission 6Evaluate

Does it work?

  • It depends on competition: privatising a firm that faces rivals differs from selling a natural monopoly.
  • It depends on regulation: information, capture and the regulator's powers.
  • It depends on time: cost savings may come fast; under-investment may show only years later.
  • It depends on objectives: efficiency and low prices, or universal service and equity?
  • Evidence on ownership is mixed: many studies find that competition and regulation matter at least as much as who owns the firm.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: a government sells its state-owned national electricity grid as a single company. There is still only one grid, and the government sets up no regulator. What is the most likely result for the price of using the grid?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • The central bank changes the policy rate to steer AD and keep inflation near its target.
  • Higher rates: borrowing costs more, asset prices lower, currency stronger. AD shifts left; inflation slows.
  • Lags, supply shocks and low confidence limit what interest rates can do.
  • Near the zero lower bound, rate cuts lose their power.

Mission 2

  • Real interest rate ≈ nominal interest rate − inflation; it can be negative.
  • Unexpected inflation helps borrowers and hurts lenders.

Mission 3

  • Fiscal policy uses government spending and taxes (and transfers) to influence AD, and some measures also raise AS.
  • Expansionary policy shifts AD right to close a negative (recessionary) gap; contractionary policy shifts AD left to close a positive (inflationary) gap.
  • Deficit = yearly flow; debt = stock. Lags, debt and spare capacity limit effectiveness.

Mission 4

  • Current, capital and transfer spending. Transfers are not part of G.
  • Deficit = flow (one year); debt = stock (all past borrowing). A smaller deficit still adds to the debt.

Mission 5

  • Supply-side policies aim to raise capacity: LRAS shifts right, raising real output without adding to inflation.
  • Market-based policies use incentives and competition; interventionist policies fix under-provision of skills, health, R&D and infrastructure.
  • Effects take years and are uncertain in size.

Mission 6

  • Nationalisation, privatisation, regulation and deregulation answer two different questions: who owns the firm, and what rules it faces.
  • Privatisation and deregulation can cut costs and prices where rivals can enter; natural monopolies still need regulation.
  • As supply-side policies, they aim to shift LRAS to the right.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Macroeconomics for IB Economics SL. 🎉

  1. Mission 1How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?
  2. Mission 2If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?
  3. Mission 3When a slump hits, can a government spend its way out of it?
  4. Mission 4If a country's yearly deficit keeps shrinking, how can its debt still be growing?
  5. Mission 5How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  6. Mission 6Should a country's trains, water pipes and power lines be run by the state or by private companies?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to IB Economics · SL