OCR GCSE (9–1) Economics (J205) · 3.8 Limitations of markets
Mini-Lesson
Limitations of markets
3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Why might a busy factory make more than is best for the people who live around it?
Mission 2Can a tax on sugary drinks make people healthier, or does it just raise money?
Mission 3If everyone gains from a lighthouse, why might no one choose to pay for it?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Why might a busy factory make more than is best for the people who live around it?
Make a guess: Why might a busy factory make more than is best for the people who live around it?
Mission 1
When markets get it wrong
Markets use prices to decide what gets made and how much.
Usually this works: if people want more of something, its price rises and firms make more.
Market failure: the market does not allocate resources efficiently.
This is a misallocation of resources: too much of some things is made, too little of others.
The main cause in this mission: externalities. Public goods are in Mission 3.
Mission 1
Private, external, social
Private cost: paid by the person or firm making the decision. A factory pays for fuel, wages and machines.
External cost: falls on a third party, someone outside the deal, who is not paid for it. Smoke harms the health of people nearby.
Social cost = private cost + external cost. The full cost to society.
Private benefit: gained by the buyer. You gain from your own education.
External benefit: gained by a third party. Your employer and the wider economy gain from your skills.
Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
An externality is the gap between the social and the private cost or benefit.
Say: "an external cost falls on a third party" — not: "an external cost is a cost to the firm".
Mission 1
Worked example: adding up the costs
Illustrative data.
A factory makes a batch of paint. It pays 30 for materials, energy and wages.
Fumes from the batch cause breathing problems nearby, costing 12 in health care and lost work.
Private cost = 30. External cost = 12.
Social cost = 30 + 12 = 42.
The factory decides using 30. Society bears 42.
Benefits work the same way. A vaccination gives the person a private benefit of 20 (they don't get ill).
It also gives others an external benefit of 15 (fewer people catch the disease from them).
Social benefit = 20 + 15 = 35.
Quick check
?A farm uses a chemical spray that drains into a river and harms fishing downstream. For each tonne of crops, the farm pays 200 in costs, and the damage to fishing is 50. (Illustrative data.) What is the social cost of each tonne?
Mission 1
Four kinds of externality
Externalities come from making things (production) and from using them (consumption).
Negative (external cost)
Positive (external benefit)
Production
Factory smoke; noise from a building site
A firm trains workers, who later take their skills to other firms
Consumption
Driving at rush hour adds to congestion; smoking near others
Vaccination protects others too; education raises skills across the economy
Ask two questions: Who makes the decision? Who else is affected, and are they harmed or helped?
Quick check
?A student plays loud music in their flat late at night. The neighbours cannot sleep. What kind of externality is this?
Mission 1Graph lab
The smoky factory
Illustrative data. A factory sells each batch of paint for 20: this is what buyers think a batch is worth. Each extra batch costs the factory more to make: 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 21, 23. Each batch also causes an external cost: smoke damage to people nearby. The factory makes a batch if 20 covers its own cost. Society is better off with a batch only if 20 covers the social cost.
Takeaway: the factory ignores the external cost, so it makes more than is best for society. The bigger the external cost, the bigger the gap.
Mission 1
Too much and too little
Negative externality: the decision-maker ignores the external cost. The price is too low for the full cost to society.
Result: overproduction or overconsumption. Too many resources go into making it.
Positive externality: the decision-maker ignores the external benefit.
Result: underproduction or underconsumption. Too few resources go into it.
The amount that is best for society is called the social optimum.
Either way, resources are misallocated: society would be better off with a different mix of goods.
The costs of misallocation: damage to health and the environment, wasted resources, and benefits that society misses out on (e.g. a less skilled workforce).
Say: "overconsumption of the good compared with the social optimum" — not: "people buy too much because it is cheap".
Quick check
?A flu vaccination costs 40. It gives the person a private benefit worth 30 and other people an external benefit worth 20. (Illustrative data.) Each person decides for themselves. What is the most likely result?
Mission 1
Why governments step in
Market failure gives a reason for government intervention: to move output closer to what is best for society.
Make the decision-maker face the external cost or benefit:
tax goods with external costs; subsidise goods with external benefits
regulation and fines: limits on pollution, penalties for breaking them
information: health campaigns and labels
How each tool works, with diagrams where your course needs them.
Mission check
?Flights from an airport cause noise for people who live nearby. Each extra flight costs the airline 50 thousand to run and causes noise damage worth 20 thousand to residents. (Illustrative data.) Which statement is correct?
When a cost lands on a third party, the decision-maker doesn't count it, so the market makes too much.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Can a tax on sugary drinks make people healthier, or does it just raise money?
Make a guess: Can a tax on sugary drinks make people healthier, or does it just raise money?
Mission 2
Why governments step in
Market failure: too much of some goods (external costs), too little of others (external benefits).
The government's toolkit:
taxes and subsidies: change the price
rules: regulation, legislation, fines
state provision and information
Mission 2
An indirect tax
Step 1 of 3
Indirect tax: a tax on spending, paid to the government by the seller. Example: a tax per can of sugary drink.
The tax adds to firms' costs, so supply shifts left: S1 → S2.
The vertical gap between S1 and S2 is the tax per unit.
Price rises: P1 → P2. Quantity falls: Q1 → Q2.
The tax makes the price closer to the full cost to society: the polluter pays.
Pros: less of the harmful good; tax revenue for the government.
Cons: the external cost is hard to measure, so the tax may be too high or too low; it takes a bigger share of poorer people's income; a very high tax can lead to smuggling.
Say: "the supply curve shifts left (decrease in supply)" — not: "demand falls because of the tax".
Mission 2
Real world: the UK sugar tax
The UK Soft Drinks Industry Levy started on 6 April 2018.
It is paid by the makers of soft drinks with added sugar, per litre:
5 g to under 8 g of sugar per 100 ml: 18p per litre
8 g or more per 100 ml: 24p per litre
under 5 g: no levy
Many makers cut the sugar in their drinks to pay less or no levy. When the levy began, the UK government said over half of makers had already done so.
So a tax can work in two ways: a higher price for buyers, and a reason for firms to change the product.
Other countries tax sugary drinks too, e.g. Mexico (from 2014).
Mission 2Graph lab
Tax and elasticity
Illustrative data. A sugary drink sells at 1.50 a can; 200 thousand cans a week. The government adds a tax of 0.30 a can. Two markets: in one, demand is price inelastic (few substitutes); in the other, demand is price elastic (many substitutes).
Takeaway: inelastic demand: sales fall a little, the price rises more, and the tax raises more money. Elastic demand: sales fall a lot.
Quick check
?A government raises the tax on cigarettes, but the number of cigarettes smoked hardly falls. What is the most likely reason?
Mission 2
A subsidy
Step 1 of 2
Subsidy: a payment from the government to producers, to lower their costs.
Used for goods with external benefits: public transport, vaccinations, solar panels.
Firms' costs fall, so supply shifts right: S1 → S2.
Price falls: P1 → P2. Quantity rises: Q1 → Q2.
Pros: more of a good that benefits society; cheaper for consumers.
Cons: opportunity cost: the money could be spent on hospitals or schools, or taxes could be lower. Firms may come to rely on it. The right size is hard to judge.
Quick check
?The government gives bus companies a subsidy for each journey they run. On a demand and supply diagram for bus journeys, what happens?
Mission 2
Rules, fines, permits and provision
Regulation and legislation: laws that limit harm, e.g. limits on factory emissions, bans on dangerous chemicals, safety standards.
Pro: clear and fast. Con: costly to enforce; a limit gives no reason to cut pollution below it.
State (direct) provision: the government supplies the good, e.g. vaccinations, schools. Con: opportunity cost.
Information provision: campaigns and labels, e.g. calorie labels on menus.
Quick check
?A government pays a subsidy to firms that make solar panels. Which of these is an opportunity cost of the policy?
Mission 2Evaluate
Does intervention work?
It depends on:
Information: can the government measure the external cost or benefit? Guess wrong, and the tax or subsidy is the wrong size.
Elasticity: with inelastic demand, a tax raises money but changes behaviour little.
Enforcement: rules and fines only work if they are checked; that costs money.
Unintended effects: illegal markets, smuggling, firms moving abroad, shortages under a maximum price.
Opportunity cost: every subsidy or state service uses money that could go elsewhere.
If intervention makes things worse, that is government failure.
Mission check
?Two cities of similar size each put the same charge on driving into the city centre, to cut traffic. City X has fast, cheap buses and trains to the centre. City Y has almost none. What is most likely?
Whether a tax changes behaviour or mainly raises money depends on how easily buyers can switch.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If everyone gains from a lighthouse, why might no one choose to pay for it?
Make a guess: If everyone gains from a lighthouse, why might no one choose to pay for it?
Mission 3
Two tests for any good
Rival: one person's use leaves less for others. A sandwich you eat cannot be eaten by me.
Excludable: the seller can stop people who have not paid from using it.
Most goods pass both tests: a sandwich, a bus seat, a phone. These are private goods.
Some goods fail both tests: national defence, a flood barrier, street lighting. These are public goods.
Excludable
Non-excludable
Rival
Private good: a sandwich, a bus seat
(other goods)
Non-rival
(other goods)
Public good: national defence, a flood barrier, street lighting
Ask the two questions separately.
Mission 3
Public goods: the lighthouse
A public good is non-rival and non-excludable.
Think of a lighthouse beam:
non-rival: one more ship sees the beam at no extra cost, and the light is no dimmer for the others
non-excludable: at sea, a ship that has not paid cannot be stopped from seeing it
Every ship gains. But a lighthouse is not free to society: it uses resources (land, workers, energy) and must be paid for somehow.
Say: "non-excludable: people who don't pay cannot be stopped from benefiting" — not: "it is free".
Quick check
?Which of these is a public good?
Mission 3
The free rider problem
Step 1 of 3
Free rider: someone who benefits from a good without paying for it.
Non-excludable → a firm cannot make people pay, because they benefit anyway.
Each person thinks: "If others pay, I benefit for free. If they don't, my money alone won't be enough."
So too few people pay. A firm cannot cover its costs, so it does not supply the good.
Result: the good is under-provided, or not provided at all: a missing market.
This is a market failure: a good that would make people better off is not made.
Mission 3Graph lab
Will anyone pay for the flood barrier?
Two neighbours, Ana and Ben, live by a river. A barrier would protect both houses: neither can be left out. Illustrative data. Each values the protection at 100. The barrier costs 150. Together they value it at 200, more than it costs. If both pay, they split the cost (75 each). If one pays, that person pays all 150.
Takeaway: below a cost of 100, one neighbour may pay alone; between 100 and 200, a barrier worth building is not built.
Mission 3
So who pays?
Usually the government provides public goods and pays for them through taxes.
Taxes must be paid by law, so nobody can free ride.
Examples: national defence, flood defences, street lighting, lighthouses.
This is state provision. The government may employ the workers itself, or pay a private firm to do the work.
Real world: UK lighthouses are paid for by light dues, a charge on commercial ships when they arrive at a port.
A ship can't be stopped from seeing the light, but it can be stopped from using the port. The dues are set by government, so they work much like a tax.
The hard part: with no market price, how does the government know how much people value the good?
Quick check
?A town has 2,000 households. Each values new street lights at 30. The lights cost 40,000 to install. (Illustrative data.) Which statement is correct?
Mission 3
Provide, regulate, inform
Three ways a government can change how much of a good is used:
State provision: the government supplies the good, free or cheap, paid for by taxes.
e.g. state schools, vaccinations, national defence.
Pro: everyone can get it. Con: it has an opportunity cost: the tax money could be spent on something else.
Legislation and regulation: laws and rules on what can be made, sold or used.
e.g. a minimum school-leaving age; age limits on buying alcohol; bans on smoking in enclosed public places.
Pro: quick and clear. Con: rules must be enforced, which costs money, and bans can create illegal markets.
Information provision: telling people about the benefits or harms.
e.g. health warnings on cigarette packs; campaigns to promote vaccination.
Pro: cheap; people still choose. Con: people may ignore it.
These policies tackle positive externalities (more education, more vaccination) and negative ones (less smoking). Taxes and subsidies.
Quick check
?A government wants fewer people to smoke. Which policy is an example of information provision?
Mission check
?A town plans a fireworks display, fired high above a hill, that can be seen from anywhere in town. It costs 30,000. The 10,000 residents value it at 10 each. (Illustrative data.) A firm offers to put on the display if enough residents buy tickets. Why is the market likely to under-provide it?
When people who don't pay can't be kept out, payment collapses, even for a good worth more than it costs.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Market failure: the market misallocates resources, making too much of some things and too little of others.
Social cost = private cost + external cost; social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
Negative externalities lead to overproduction or overconsumption; positive externalities to underproduction or underconsumption.
Mission 2
Taxes shift supply left (price up, quantity down); subsidies shift supply right (price down, quantity up).
With inelastic demand, a tax raises revenue but cuts the quantity only a little.
Every policy has costs: information, enforcement, unintended effects and opportunity cost.
Mission 3
Public goods are non-rival and non-excludable; private goods are rival and excludable.
Non-excludability creates free riders, so the market under-provides or fails to provide: a missing market. Governments usually provide public goods through taxes.
Governments can provide, regulate or inform.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Limitations of markets for OCR GCSE Economics. 🎉
Mission 1Why might a busy factory make more than is best for the people who live around it?
Mission 2Can a tax on sugary drinks make people healthier, or does it just raise money?
Mission 3If everyone gains from a lighthouse, why might no one choose to pay for it?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.