← GCSE Economics · AQA GCSE Economics revision
⭐ 0
AQA GCSE Economics (8136) · 3.2.2 Government objectives; 3.2.3 How the government manages the economy (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Government objectives; How the government manages the economy (part 2)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?
  2. Mission 2How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  3. Mission 3If your pay goes up every year, can you still end up worse off?
  4. Mission 4When a country buys more from the world than it sells, how does it pay the difference?
  5. Mission 5How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?
  6. Mission 6Can workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?

Make a guess: Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?

Mission 1

Who counts as unemployed?

Who is who in the working-age populationWorking-age populationLabour forceEmployedUnemployedEconomically inactiveIllustrative proportions
  • Unemployed (the ILO measure): without a job, have looked for work in the last 4 weeks, and can start within 2 weeks.
  • Employed: did at least one hour of paid work in the week.
  • Labour force (economically active) = employed + unemployed.
  • Economically inactive: not working and not looking, e.g. students, retired people, full-time carers. They are not unemployed.
  • In the UK the survey is the Labour Force Survey (ONS).
Mission 1

Worked example: the unemployment rate

  • Unemployment rate = number unemployed ÷ labour force × 100.
  • Illustrative data. Working-age population 50 m: employed 32.4 m, unemployed 1.6 m, inactive 16 m.
  • Labour force = 32.4 + 1.6 = 34 m.
  • Unemployment rate = 1.6 ÷ 34 × 100 = 4.7%.
  • Divide by the labour force, not the whole population: 1.6 ÷ 50 = 3.2% would be wrong.
Mission 1

The Claimant Count

  • Claimant Count: the number of people claiming benefits because they are unemployed (Jobseeker's Allowance, or Universal Credit while required to look for work).
  • It comes from benefit records, so it is quick and cheap to collect.
  • But it misses jobless people who cannot or do not claim. And under Universal Credit it includes some people in low-paid work.
  • So the two measures can differ a lot (ONS):
    • 2015: Claimant Count 0.80 m; ILO unemployment 1.78 m
    • 2021: Claimant Count 2.28 m; ILO unemployment 1.54 m
  • Say: "the ILO measure counts people looking for work" — not: "it counts people on benefits".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A country has 48 million people of working age. 28.8 million are employed, 1.2 million are unemployed, and the rest are economically inactive. What is the unemployment rate?
Mission 1

Types of unemployment

  • Frictional: people between jobs, searching for the right one. Usually short.
  • Seasonal: jobs that disappear at certain times of year: farm work, beach and ski resorts, building in winter.
  • Structural: a mismatch between people's skills or location and the jobs on offer, because some industries decline while others grow. Often long-lasting and concentrated in particular regions.
    • Technological unemployment, where machines or software replace a skill, is a type of structural unemployment.
  • Cyclical: too little spending in the economy, in a downturn or recession. Firms sell less, so they need fewer workers.
Mission 1

Never zero

Unemployment is never zeroUnemployment rate (%)0FrictionalSeasonalStructuralCyclicalIllustrative proportionsBoom: the rate is never zeroRecession: cyclical unemployment is added ontop
  • Even in a boom, some people are always between jobs (frictional) and some have the wrong skills or live in the wrong place (structural).
  • So full employment does not mean zero unemployment.
  • In a recession, cyclical unemployment is added on top, and the rate rises fast:
    • US unemployment rose from 5.0% in December 2007 to 10.0% in October 2009 (BLS).
    • UK unemployment rose from about 5% in early 2008 to 8.4% in late 2011 (ONS).
  • When spending recovers, cyclical unemployment falls. Frictional and structural unemployment remain.
Quick check
?A car factory installs robots to do its welding. The welders it lays off have no skills that other employers in the area want. Which type of unemployment is this?
Mission 1

The costs of unemployment

Costs of unemploymentFor peoplelost incomeFor communitiesshops closeFor the whole economyidle machineslost outputless taxinmore benefitsout
  • For people (individuals and families): lost income; skills fade the longer they are out of work; stress and worse health.
  • For communities (regions): shops and services close when local incomes fall; young people move away; crime and social problems can rise.
  • For the whole economy:
    • lost output: goods and services that could have been produced are lost for ever; the economy is inside its PPC
    • for the government: less income tax and sales taxes such as VAT, more spent on benefits, so more borrowing
    • for firms: fewer customers, though it is easier to recruit workers
  • Say: "benefits are a transfer" — not: "benefits are lost output". The lost output is what the unemployed could have produced.
Quick check
?Unemployment in a country rises from 4% to 7%. Which is the most likely effect on the government's budget?
Mission 1

Policies to reduce unemployment

Match the policy to the cause:

TypePolicies
CyclicalRaise spending: lower interest rates, more government spending, lower taxes
StructuralTraining and retraining; help to move to where jobs are; attract firms to hard-hit regions
FrictionalBetter information about jobs: job centres and online vacancy sites
SeasonalHard to remove; firms and workers can find other work out of season
  • Spending policies work faster but can push up inflation. Training takes years but tackles the cause of structural unemployment.
Mission 1Evaluate

How serious is a rise in unemployment?

It depends on:

  • The type and length: a short search between jobs does little harm; long spells cut skills and income.
  • Who and where: job losses packed into one town or group hit harder than the same rise spread thinly.
  • The response: benefits, retraining and quick action to raise spending reduce the lasting damage.
Quick check
?Who is counted as unemployed on the ILO measure?
Mission check

?During a boom, a region has thousands of job vacancies for software developers and nurses. Yet 6% of its labour force is unemployed, most of them former factory workers whose factories closed. What kind of unemployment is this mainly, and what would help most?
Mission 2

Mission 2: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Make a guess: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Mission 2

What supply-side policies are

  • Productive capacity: the most an economy can produce when it uses all its resources.
  • Supply-side policies: government policies that aim to raise productive capacity.
  • They work on:
    • the quantity of resources (more workers, more machines)
    • the quality of resources (skills, technology)
    • how efficiently markets and firms use them
  • Compare: fiscal and monetary policy mainly change spending (demand). Supply-side policies change what the economy can produce.
  • Goals: long-term growth, lower unemployment, growth without extra inflation, firms that can compete with the rest of the world.
Mission 2

Capacity on a graph

Capacity grows: PPC1 to PPC2Capital goods0Consumer goodssupply-side policyPPC1PPC2YX: spareresourcesZ
  • A production possibility curve (PPC) shows the most an economy can make of two kinds of goods.
  • Supply-side policies push the PPC outwards: PPC1 → PPC2.
  • The economy can now make more of both goods.
  • Using spare resources moves the economy from a point inside the PPC towards the curve: output rises, but capacity does not.
  • Say: "productive capacity has increased" — not: "the economy is producing more", which could just mean spare resources are now in use.
Mission 2

The toolkit

The supply-side toolkitEducation andtrainingInfrastructureLower income taxLower business(profit) taxLabour marketreformPrivatisationDeregulation
PolicyHow it can raise capacity
Education and trainingBetter skills: each worker produces more
Infrastructure (roads, rail, broadband, energy)Lower costs for firms; workers can reach more jobs
Lower income taxA bigger reward for working: some people work more hours or take a job
Lower business (profit) taxInvestment in new machines pays more
Labour market reform (incl. trade union reform)Wages and jobs adjust faster; easier to hire
PrivatisationSelling state-owned firms: the profit motive pushes them to cut costs
DeregulationFewer rules: lower costs and easier entry for new firms
  • Key list to learn: education and training, lower direct and business taxes, trade union reform, privatisation, deregulation.
Quick check
?Which policy is most clearly a supply-side policy?
Mission 2

Market-based policies: freeing markets

  • Lower taxes on income and profits: a bigger reward for work and investment.
  • Trade union reform and flexible contracts: firms can hire and adjust faster.
  • Privatisation and deregulation: competition and profit push firms to cut costs and innovate.
  • Possible downsides:
    • tax cuts may mostly help higher earners: inequality can widen
    • weaker unions and flexible contracts may mean less job security
    • a privatised firm with no rivals may become a monopoly and raise prices
    • lower taxes mean less revenue for public services
Mission 2

Government-led policies: spending to build capacity

  • Education and training: more skilled workers; fewer job vacancies left unfilled.
  • Infrastructure: faster transport and broadband cut firms' costs and link workers to jobs.
  • Possible downsides:
    • they cost money: higher taxes or borrowing, and an opportunity cost
    • they take years: a new rail line or a better-trained workforce is not built in a month
    • the government may back the wrong projects
Mission 2Graph lab

Build now, grow later

Illustrative data. Start: the economy is producing 1,000 at full capacity; price level 100.

Build now, grow later1,000Output1,000Capacitystart 100100Price level
  • Takeaway: short run (extra spending) output 1,050, price level 105; long run, once capacity grows, output 1,100 and the price level back to 100.
Quick check
?A government cuts the top rate of income tax. Which effect is a supply-side effect?
Mission 2

Real world: taxes on company profits

  • The US cut its main federal corporate tax rate from 35% to 21% from 2018.
  • The UK cut its main corporation tax rate from 28% (2010) to 19% (2017), then raised it to 25% in 2023 for profits over £250,000.
  • Aim of the cuts: more investment in capital, so higher productivity and pay.
  • US evidence: a 2024 review of the research estimated that the cut raised investment by firms by about 11%, but wages and growth rose by less than supporters had claimed.
  • Question to weigh: how would you judge whether a tax cut raised capacity, and over how many years?
Mission 2

Supply-side policies, growth and unemployment

  • Growth comes from more and better resources: investment, technology, a skilled workforce. Supply-side policies target these.
  • Benefits of growth: higher incomes, more jobs, more tax revenue for public services.
  • Costs: pollution, use of scarce resources, and gains that may not reach everyone.
  • Unemployment wastes output, cuts incomes and can harm health. When workers lack the skills firms need (structural unemployment), training and help to move to new jobs are supply-side answers.
Mission 2

Weigh it up: costs and benefits

  • Benefits:
    • growth that lasts, with less inflation than growth driven by spending
    • lower unemployment as skills match jobs
    • firms better able to compete abroad
  • Costs and problems:
    • time lags: years, even decades, for education or infrastructure to pay off
    • opportunity cost: money for training or roads could fund something else
    • uncertain: people and firms may not respond much to tax cuts or incentives
    • some policies may widen inequality or weaken workers' protections
  • It depends on the policy, the country and how long you wait.
Quick check
?A government lowers the tax on company profits to raise investment. Five years later, investment has barely changed. Which explanation is most likely?
Mission check

?An economy is already producing at full capacity. The government wants output to keep rising without faster inflation. Which policy fits best, and how quickly would it work?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If your pay goes up every year, can you still end up worse off?

Make a guess: If your pay goes up every year, can you still end up worse off?

Mission 3

What inflation is

What a rise in prices does to purchasing powera full basketFewer goodsprices riseSame money
  • Inflation: a sustained rise in the general price level: prices on average, not one price.
  • Rate of inflation: the % rise in the general price level over a year.
  • Inflation means each unit of money buys less: its purchasing power falls.
  • Deflation: a sustained fall in the general price level (inflation below 0%).
  • Disinflation: inflation falls, but stays above 0%. Prices still rise, just more slowly.
  • Say: "inflation fell from 6% to 3%, so prices rose more slowly" — not: "prices fell".
Mission 3

Measuring inflation: the CPI

  • CPI (Consumer Prices Index): measures the average change in the prices of a basket of goods and services bought by households.
  • The basket holds hundreds of items: food, clothes, rent, energy, transport, phones, haircuts.
  • Each item is weighted by how much households spend on it. Fuel matters more than matches.
  • Prices are collected every month. The index starts at 100 in a base year.
  • Inflation rate = % change in the CPI over 12 months.
  • The UK government sets the Bank of England a CPI inflation target of 2%.
Mission 3

Worked example: a weighted index

  • Illustrative data. A basket with three groups. Index for each group this year (base year = 100).
GroupWeightPrice index
Food20110
Transport30105
Housing50102
  • Multiply each index by its weight: 20 × 110 = 2,200; 30 × 105 = 3,150; 50 × 102 = 5,100.
  • Add them and divide by the total weight: 10,450 ÷ 100 = 104.5.
  • So prices rose 4.5% since the base year.
  • Food prices rose most (10%), but food has a small weight, so it pulls the average up less.
Mission 3

Worked example: inflation and prices

  • Illustrative data. CPI last year = 120; CPI this year = 126.
  • Inflation rate = (126 − 120) ÷ 120 × 100 = 5%.
  • Effect on a price: a meal costing 40 last year costs about 40 × 1.05 = 42 this year, if its price rose in line with inflation.
  • Say: "the CPI rose by 6 points, which is 5%" — not: "inflation was 6%".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A country's CPI rises from 150 to 156 over a year. What is the rate of inflation?
Mission 3

Real and nominal

  • Nominal value: measured in money, not adjusted for inflation.
  • Real value: adjusted for inflation; what the money can actually buy.
  • Real change ≈ nominal change − inflation.
  • Illustrative data:
    • Pay rises 3%; inflation is 5%. Real pay falls by about 2%: the worker can buy less.
    • Savings of 1,000 earn 2% interest: 1,020 next year. Inflation is 5%, so the 1,020 buys about 3% less than the 1,000 did.
  • Say: "real pay fell" — not: "pay fell", when the money amount rose.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A worker's weekly pay rises from 500 to 520, a rise of 4%. Inflation over the same year is 3%. What has happened to her real pay?
Mission 3

Demand-pull inflation

Demand-pull inflationSpendingPrices pulled upCapacity: full
  • Demand-pull inflation: total spending grows faster than the economy can produce, so prices are pulled up.
  • "Too much money chasing too few goods."
  • Causes:
    • consumers spend more (rising confidence, cheap borrowing, low interest rates)
    • government spends more or cuts taxes
    • foreign buyers want more of our exports
  • Most likely when firms are already near full capacity: they cannot produce much more, so they raise prices.
Mission 3

Cost-push inflation

Cost-push inflationPrices pushed upEnergyWagesImported materialsIndirect taxesCosts rise
  • Cost-push inflation: firms' costs rise, and they push prices up to protect their profits.
  • Causes:
    • dearer raw materials and energy (e.g. world oil and gas prices)
    • higher wages, if they rise faster than productivity
    • dearer imports, e.g. when the exchange rate falls
    • higher indirect taxes, such as VAT
  • Real case: UK CPI inflation reached 11.1% in October 2022, with energy and food prices the biggest contributors (ONS).
Quick check
?Which of these is most likely to cause demand-pull inflation?
Mission 3

Who gains and who loses?

Winners and losers from inflationLoseSavers: interestrate belowinflationLendersPeople on fixedincomesGainBorrowers:interest ratebelow inflation
  • Consumers: if prices rise faster than incomes, they can buy less.
  • People on fixed incomes (e.g. some pensions, benefits that are not raised): lose purchasing power.
  • Savers: lose if the interest rate is below inflation; their savings buy less.
  • Borrowers: gain if the interest rate they pay is below inflation, because the real value of what they owe falls.
  • Lenders: lose for the same reason: they are repaid with money that buys less.
  • Producers: costs rise; if inflation is higher than in other countries, exports become less competitive.
  • Government: tax revenue rises as prices and pay rise, but so does the cost of pensions, benefits and public-sector pay.
Mission 3

Costs for the whole economy

  • Menu costs: firms must keep changing prices: price lists, menus, websites.
  • Shoe-leather costs: people and firms spend time and effort managing money to protect its value (e.g. moving savings around).
  • Uncertainty: when inflation is high or unpredictable, firms are less confident about future costs and prices, so they may invest less.
  • Low and stable inflation (around 2%) is seen as healthy: it is easy to plan around.
Mission 3

Too much, or too little

  • Hyperinflation: extremely high inflation. Zimbabwe's official annual inflation rate reached 231,000,000% in July 2008. In 2009, people stopped using the local currency.
  • Deflation, prices falling, can also be harmful:
    • people delay spending, hoping prices will fall further, so firms sell less and cut jobs
    • the real value of debts rises, so borrowers lose and lenders gain
    • savers gain: their money buys more
  • Example: in Japan, consumer prices fell in 9 of the 14 years from 1999 to 2012.
Mission 3

Controlling inflation

  • Interest rates (monetary policy, set by the central bank):
    • higher rates make borrowing dearer and saving more rewarding
    • so households and firms spend less, and demand-pull inflation falls
    • but spending, output and jobs may fall too
  • Fiscal policy: higher taxes or lower government spending reduce total spending.
  • Supply-side policies: training, competition and new technology raise productivity, which keeps costs down in the long run.
  • Cost-push inflation is harder to control: raising interest rates can cut output without lowering firms' costs.
Quick check
?Inflation turns out much higher than anyone expected. Who is most likely to gain?
Mission check

?Illustrative data. Last year, Amira's pay rose by 4%. Her savings account paid 1% interest. Inflation was 6%. Which statement is correct?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When a country buys more from the world than it sells, how does it pay the difference?

Make a guess: When a country buys more from the world than it sells, how does it pay the difference?

Mission 4

The nation's accounts

The balance of payments accountsBalance of paymentsCurrent accounttrade in goods andservices, incomeFinancial accountassets, lending,reservesCapital account (small)Our countryRest of the worldCredit (+)money inDebit (−)money out
  • The balance of payments records all money flows between a country and the rest of the world over a period (a quarter or a year).
  • Credit (+): money flows in, e.g. a foreign buyer pays for our exports.
  • Debit (−): money flows out, e.g. we pay for imports.
  • Two main parts:
    • current account: trade in goods and services, and income flows
    • financial account: buying and selling assets (firms, shares, bonds), lending and borrowing, and the central bank's reserves of foreign currency.
  • (A small capital account also exists.)
Mission 4

Inside the current account

Parts of the current accountIllustrative data (billions)Goods−40Services+30Balance of trade−10Primary income−15Secondary income−15Current account−40
PartCredit (+) exampleDebit (−) example
Trade in goodsA car sold abroadOil bought from abroad
Trade in servicesA foreign tourist's hotel billInsurance bought from abroad
Primary incomeProfits and interest earned on assets abroadProfits paid to foreign owners of firms here
Secondary incomeMoney sent home by people working abroadForeign aid given
  • Balance of trade = exports − imports of goods and services.
  • Current account balance = balance of trade + primary income + secondary income.
  • Credits > debits: a surplus. Debits > credits: a deficit.
  • Say: "a current account deficit" — not: "the country made a loss".
Quick check
?Which of these is a credit in Kenya's current account?
Mission 4

Worked example: the current account

Parts of the current accountIllustrative data (billions)Goods−40Services+30Balance of trade−10Primary income−15Secondary income−15Current account−40

Illustrative data (billions):

CreditsDebitsBalance
Goods300340−40
Services150120+30
Primary income6075−15
Secondary income1025−15
  • Step 1: each balance = credits − debits.
  • Step 2: balance of trade = −40 + 30 = −10.
  • Step 3: current account = −10 − 15 − 15 = −40: a deficit of 40 billion.
  • A goods deficit does not always mean a current account deficit: services or income can make up for it.
Mission 4

Real data: the UK, end of 2024

ONS, balance of payments, October to December 2024 (excluding precious metals):

PartBalance (£ billion)
Trade in goods−59.5
Trade in services+49.3
Primary income−3.5
Secondary income−5.0
Current account−18.7 (2.6% of GDP)
  • Pattern: a large goods deficit, partly offset by a large services surplus (finance, business services).
  • Balance of trade = −59.5 + 49.3 = −10.2.
Quick check
?Illustrative data (billions): trade in goods −25; trade in services +18; primary income +4; secondary income −7. What is the current account balance?
Mission 4

Paying for a deficit

Every transaction is recorded twiceForeignsellerMachinesCurrent account −10ForeignsellerBank in ourcountryFinancial account +10−10 + 10 = 0Every transaction is recorded twice
  • Every transaction is recorded twice: once as a credit and once as a debit.
  • Example: a firm imports machines worth 10 billion.
    • Current account: import of goods, −10.
    • The foreign seller is paid in our currency and keeps it in our banks or buys our assets: money flowing in on the financial account, +10.
  • So a current account deficit is paid for by money flowing in on the financial account:
    • borrowing from abroad
    • selling assets to foreigners: firms, shares, property, government bonds
  • Overall the balance of payments balances: current + capital + financial account = 0 (apart from errors).
  • Say: "a current account deficit" — not: "a balance of payments deficit".
Mission 4

Why deficits and surpluses happen

Causes of a current account deficit:

  • A boom at home: rising incomes mean more spending on imports.
  • A strong currency: exports dearer abroad, imports cheaper.
  • Low competitiveness: home firms' costs or quality fall behind rivals'.
  • Higher inflation than trading partners: home goods become relatively dearer.
  • A recession abroad: foreign buyers buy fewer of our exports.

Causes of a surplus: the reverse, e.g. a weak currency, strong demand abroad, highly competitive exporters.

Mission 4

Does a deficit matter?

A current account deficit can mean:

  • fewer jobs and less output in industries that compete with imports
  • a growing debt to the rest of the world, with interest and profits paid abroad
  • downward pressure on the exchange rate

But it can be fine when:

  • it is small and short-lived
  • it is paid for by long-term investment (foreign firms building factories) rather than short-term borrowing
  • the imports are machinery that will raise future output.

A surplus brings export jobs and income, but may mean low spending at home, and pushes the currency up.

Quick check
?Country Q's current account deficit widened last year. Which is the most likely cause?
Mission 4

Policies to reduce a deficit

PolicyHow it worksDrawback
Raise interest rates or taxesLess spending at home, so fewer importsSlower growth; more unemployment. Higher interest rates can also push the currency up
Let the currency depreciateExports cheaper, imports dearerHigher import prices: inflation
ProtectionismTariffs and quotas cut importsHigher prices; other countries may retaliate
Supply-side policies (see Mission 2)Better skills, technology and productivity make firms more competitiveSlow: takes years
  • Policies may conflict: cutting the deficit by cutting spending also cuts growth and jobs.
Mission check

?Illustrative data (billions). Country V: trade in goods −35; trade in services +12; primary income −4; secondary income +2. Its central bank's reserves do not change. Which statement is correct?
Mission 5

Mission 5: How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?

Make a guess: How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?

Mission 5

Who sets the rate?

  • Monetary policy: action by the central bank to change interest rates and the money supply, to influence spending and inflation.
  • UK: the Bank of England. Its Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), 9 members, sets Bank Rate.
  • The MPC meets about eight times a year and votes. A handful of people decide one rate for the whole country.
  • Since 1997 the Bank has been independent: the government sets the target, the MPC chooses the rate.
  • Bank Rate feeds through to the rates that banks charge on loans and mortgages and pay on savings.
Mission 5

What it aims for

  • Main aim: price stability: low and stable inflation.
  • UK target: 2% CPI inflation, set by the government.
  • Many central banks aim for about 2%.
  • Other objectives: support growth and jobs, as long as inflation stays near target.
  • The Bank of England also works for financial stability: keeping banks safe, so people can trust their savings and borrow when they need to.
Mission 5

The transmission mechanism

Transmission mechanism of a rise in the interest rateBank RateBorrowing dearerSaving pays moreFirms invest lessExchange rateTotal spending slowsFirms raise prices lessInflation slows
  • How a rise in the interest rate reaches prices:
    • Borrowing costs more: mortgages, loans, credit cards. People and firms borrow less.
    • Saving pays more: people save more and spend less.
    • Households with variable-rate mortgages have less to spend.
    • Firms invest less in new machines and buildings.
    • The exchange rate tends to rise: exports dearer abroad, imports cheaper.
  • Result: total spending grows more slowly. Firms face weaker demand, so they raise prices less: inflation slows.
  • A cut works the other way: more borrowing and spending.
  • Say: "inflation slows" — not: "prices fall". Prices usually still rise, just more slowly.
Mission 5

Worked example: what a rate rise does to a family

  • Illustrative data. The interest rate on loans and savings rises by 3 percentage points.
  • A loan of 10,000:
    • at 2% a year: interest = 10,000 × 0.02 = 200
    • at 5% a year: interest = 10,000 × 0.05 = 500
    • 300 more a year to the lender, so 300 less to spend elsewhere
  • Savings of 5,000:
    • at 1%: interest = 50
    • at 4%: interest = 200
    • saving is more rewarding, so spending now is less attractive
  • Borrowers spend less; savers have a reason to save more. Total spending slows.
Quick check
?A central bank raises its interest rate. Which chain of effects is most likely?
Mission 5Graph lab

Set the rate

Illustrative data. Inflation is 6%; the target is 2%. The interest rate is 1%.

Set the rateinflation target 2%6%Inflation (%)3.0%Outputgrowth (%)4.0%Unemploy-ment (%)
  • Takeaway: a higher rate brings inflation down, but output grows more slowly and unemployment rises. Too high, and output falls.
Mission 5

Effects on growth, jobs and prices

Rate riseRate cut
Spending and borrowingFallRise
SavingMore attractiveLess attractive
Investment by firmsFallsRises
Growth and jobsSlower; unemployment may riseFaster; unemployment may fall
InflationSlowsMay rise
  • So monetary policy can face a conflict: cutting inflation can cost jobs.
Mission 5

Other tools

  • Quantitative easing (QE): the central bank creates new money to buy government bonds, adding money to the economy when interest rates are already very low.
  • The Bank of England bought £895 billion of bonds in this way between 2009 and 2020.
Mission 5

Real case: the rate rises of 2021–23

  • Inflation rose sharply around the world. It peaked in October 2022:
    • UK CPI inflation: 11.1%
    • euro area: 10.6%
  • Central banks raised interest rates again and again.
    • UK: Bank Rate was 0.1% (March 2020). The MPC raised it from December 2021 to 5.25% (August 2023).
    • euro area: the European Central Bank raised its deposit rate from −0.5% (2022) to 4.0% (September 2023).
  • UK inflation was back at 2.0% in May 2024.
  • Economists debate how much of the fall came from higher rates and how much from falling energy prices.
Mission 5

Strengths and limits

  • Strengths:
    • flexible: rates can change in small steps, several times a year
    • quick to decide: no new law needed
    • an independent central bank is trusted to keep inflation low
  • Limits:
    • time lags: up to about two years for the full effect on inflation
    • if inflation comes from rising costs (e.g. oil prices), higher rates cut inflation only by cutting spending, output and jobs
    • when confidence is low, people may not borrow even if rates are low
    • one rate for everyone: borrowers lose, savers gain
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A household has a variable-rate mortgage of 200,000 and savings of 10,000. The interest rate on both rises by 2 percentage points. By how much does its yearly interest position change?
Mission 5

Weigh it up: how well do interest rates work?

It depends on:

  • The cause of inflation: too much spending responds well; a jump in costs forces a choice between inflation and jobs.
  • Time: a change made now works over the next two years, when things may have changed.
  • Debt: if many people have loans at variable rates, a rise bites quickly.
  • Confidence: when people are worried, cheap loans may not get them spending.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. Growth in a country has slowed and unemployment is rising. Inflation is 1.5%, below the 2% target. The central bank cuts its interest rate from 4% to 2%. What is most likely over the next year or two?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Can workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?

Make a guess: A group of workers wins pay above the market wage. What happens to the number of jobs?

Mission 6

What trade unions do

  • A trade union: an organisation of workers that acts for its members.
  • Collective bargaining: the union negotiates with employers for all its members at once, not one by one.
  • Aims:
    • higher pay
    • better working conditions and health and safety
    • shorter hours, more holidays
    • job security and training
    • legal advice and support for members
  • If talks fail, unions may take industrial action: a strike (stop work), work to rule (do only the minimum the contract requires), an overtime ban.
Mission 6

Unions in numbers

  • UK, 2025: 6.6 million employees were union members.
  • Union density (members as a % of employees): 22.4%, about 1 employee in 5.
    • Public sector: 48.5%. Private sector: 12.1%.
  • Membership peaked at 13.2 million in 1979 (a different measure, from union records).
  • Members' average pay was 5.3% higher than non-members', before allowing for other differences (job, skills, sector).
  • Why fewer members? Fewer jobs in mining and factories, more small firms, part-time and self-employed work, and changes to union law.
Mission 6

What makes a union strong?

  • A union has more bargaining power when:
    • most workers in the job are members
    • strikers are hard to replace, by other workers or by machines
    • the work is essential and a strike quickly stops production
    • the employer is profitable and can afford a rise
    • demand for the product is strong, so higher costs can be passed on in prices
    • unemployment is low, so employers struggle to find other workers
    • the law and the public support it
Mission 6

A union and the wage

A union and the wageWage (£ per hour)£14£14£12400500600600excess supply 200Number of workersDD1SUnion wageD2Firms hire 400; 600 want the jobHigher productivity: demand shifts rightIllustrative data
  • Illustrative data. A competitive labour market: We = £12 an hour, Le = 500 workers.
  • Step 2: the union wins a wage of £14, above We.
    • Firms hire fewer: a contraction of demand for labour to 400.
    • More people want the job: 600.
    • Excess supply of 200: some workers are left without these jobs.
    • Members in work are paid more; others lose out.
  • Step 3: instead, the union agrees changes that raise productivity. Each worker is worth more, so demand for labour shifts right.
    • New equilibrium: £14 and 600 workers. Pay and jobs rise.
  • The job loss in step 2 is smaller where demand for labour is inelastic: workers hard to replace, wages a small share of costs.
Quick check
?Use the market in the previous screen (We = £12, Le = 500; firms hire 450 workers at £13, and 550 people want the job). The union wins a wage of £13 instead of £14. How many fewer workers are employed than before?
Mission 6

Union reform: a supply-side policy

  • Supply-side policies aim to raise how much the economy can produce. One of them is union reform: laws that limit union power.
  • From the 1980s, UK laws required secret ballots before strikes and limited picketing. The rules have been changed several times since, in both directions.
  • Arguments for:
    • a more flexible labour market: wages closer to market levels
    • fewer working days lost to strikes
    • lower costs, so firms hire and invest more
  • Arguments against:
    • workers have a weaker voice, so pay and conditions may suffer
    • inequality may rise
    • unions can help raise productivity by improving communication and training
  • Economists disagree on how big each effect is.
Quick check
?A government passes laws that make it harder for unions to call strikes. As a supply-side policy, what is the main aim?
Mission check

?Port workers are paid the market wage. Shipping through the port is growing. The union agrees a deal: workers train to use new cranes that let each of them load far more cargo, and the port raises their pay. How can pay and the number of jobs both rise?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Unemployment rate = unemployed ÷ labour force × 100.
  • Two UK measures: the ILO measure (Labour Force Survey) and the Claimant Count.
  • Frictional: between jobs. Seasonal: time of year. Structural: skills or location mismatch. Cyclical: too little spending.
  • Full employment does not mean zero unemployment.
  • Unemployment costs people, communities and the whole economy.

Mission 2

  • Supply-side policies aim to raise productive capacity: the PPC shifts outwards.
  • Market-based tools: lower taxes, union reform, privatisation, deregulation. Government-led tools: education and training, infrastructure, regional help, incentives.
  • Many also change spending at once; the capacity gain comes later.
  • They take years, cost money, and their effects are uncertain.

Mission 3

  • Inflation: a sustained rise in the general price level, measured by the CPI.
  • Inflation rate = % change in the CPI over a year.
  • Real change ≈ nominal change − inflation.
  • Demand-pull: spending outruns what firms can produce. Cost-push: firms' costs rise.
  • Inflation hurts savers, lenders and people on fixed incomes; it helps borrowers. Deflation does the opposite.
  • Higher interest rates reduce spending and so reduce inflation.

Mission 4

  • The current account records trade in goods and services plus primary and secondary income; balance = credits − debits.
  • Balance of trade is goods and services only; the current account adds income flows.
  • A current account deficit is paid for by money flowing in: borrowing from abroad or selling assets to foreigners.
  • Causes include booms, a strong currency and low competitiveness; policies include higher interest rates, depreciation, protection and supply-side reform.

Mission 5

  • The central bank (UK: the Bank of England's MPC) sets the interest rate to keep inflation near target.
  • Higher rates: borrowing dearer, saving more rewarding, spending slows, inflation slows; output and jobs may suffer.
  • Other tools: money supply, asset purchases (QE), the exchange rate.
  • Rates work with time lags and work less well against rising costs or low confidence.

Mission 6

  • Unions bargain collectively; a wage above equilibrium raises members' pay but can cut jobs.
  • Pay and jobs rise together when the demand for labour shifts right, for example through higher productivity.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Government objectives; How the government manages the economy (part 2) for AQA GCSE Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?
  2. Mission 2How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  3. Mission 3If your pay goes up every year, can you still end up worse off?
  4. Mission 4When a country buys more from the world than it sells, how does it pay the difference?
  5. Mission 5How can one interest rate, set by a handful of people, slow down inflation across a whole country?
  6. Mission 6Can workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Economics · AQA