← A-Level Economics · OCR A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Economics (H460) · 3 Implementing policy: fiscal, monetary and supply-side (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Implementing policy: fiscal, monetary and supply-side (part 2)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?
  2. Mission 2If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?
  3. Mission 3When a country's money loses value abroad, who wins and who loses at home?
  4. Mission 4How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  5. Mission 5Why can the right cure for one slump be the wrong cure for the next?
Mission 1

Mission 1: When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?

Make a guess: When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?

Mission 1

When the usual tool runs out

Policy rate at the floorBank Rate (%)02007200820092010floor5.75 (July 2007)0.5(March 2009)Schematic: steps between the two labelledvalues are not exact data
  • The usual tool: cut the policy interest rate to make borrowing cheaper.
  • In the UK: the MPC cut Bank Rate from 5.75% (2007) to 0.5% (March 2009).
  • Rates cannot go far below zero: people could hold cash at 0% instead. This floor is the zero (or effective) lower bound.
  • With the economy still weak, central banks turned to unconventional tools.
  • Main one: quantitative easing (QE).
Mission 1

What QE is

QE flowsCentral bankPension fundBankgiltnewreservesdeposit +
  • QE: the central bank creates new central bank reserves (electronic money) and uses them to buy assets, mainly government bonds.
  • UK government bonds are called gilts.
  • It buys from investors such as pension funds and insurers, not straight from the government.
  • The seller's bank account is credited: broad money (bank deposits) rises; banks' reserves rise.
  • So QE increases the money supply while the policy rate is stuck near zero.
  • Say: "the central bank creates reserves to buy bonds" — not: "prints banknotes and gives them away".
Quick check
?Which statement best describes quantitative easing?
Mission 1

How QE reaches spending

QE transmissionCentral bank buys bondsPrice of bonds0P2P1Q1Q2Quantity of bondsyield ↓SD1D2Yields ↓Loan rates ↓Asset prices ↑Wealth ↑Currency ↓Exports ↑Price level0P2P1Y1Y2YfeReal national output (Y)SRASLRASAD1AD2
  • 1. Bond prices up, yields down. Big purchases raise bond prices. A bond's yield (its return) moves the opposite way to its price.
  • 2. Lower long-term interest rates. Government bond yields are a benchmark, so mortgage and business loan rates tend to fall.
  • 3. Portfolio rebalancing. Sellers use their new money to buy other assets (shares, company bonds): their prices rise, firms can borrow more cheaply.
  • 4. Wealth effect. Higher asset prices make owners feel richer: more consumption.
  • 5. Exchange rate. Lower yields can make the currency less attractive: it tends to fall, exports become cheaper.
  • 6. Confidence. It signals the central bank will act.
  • Result: AD shifts right, raising real output and the price level towards the inflation target.
Mission 1

Worked example: price up, yield down

  • Illustrative data. A bond pays a fixed 3 a year, for ever.
  • Yield = annual payment ÷ price × 100.
  • Price 100: 3 ÷ 100 × 100 = 3%.
  • QE buying pushes the price to 120: 3 ÷ 120 × 100 = 2.5%.
  • Price 150: 3 ÷ 150 × 100 = 2%.
  • The payment is fixed, so paying more for it means a lower return.
  • Say: "higher bond prices mean lower yields" — not: "bond prices and interest rates rise together".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A bond pays a fixed 4 a year, for ever. After central bank purchases, its price rises from 100 to 125. What is its yield now?
Mission 1Graph lab

Can QE close the gap?

Illustrative data. Real output 950; full-employment output 1000; policy rate already near zero. A negative output gap of 50.

Can QE close the gap?Price levelReal national output (Y)950105YfeSRASAD
  • Takeaway: with low confidence, 200 of QE lifts output only to about 963; with high confidence, 200 closes the gap, and 400 overshoots to 1050, with the price level up to 115.
Mission 1

Reversing QE

Quantitative tighteningCentral bank sells bondsPrice of bonds0P1P2Q1Q2Quantity of bondsyield ↑DS1S2Price level0P2P1Y1Y2YfeReal national output (Y)SRASLRASAD2AD1
  • Quantitative tightening (QT): the central bank shrinks its bond holdings.
  • Two ways: stop reinvesting as bonds mature, or sell bonds back to investors.
  • Reserves and deposits shrink: the money supply contracts.
  • The chain runs in reverse: bond prices fall, yields rise, borrowing costs rise: AD tends to shift left.
  • UK: the MPC decided to begin reducing its stock of bonds in February 2022.
  • Central banks try to reverse QE gradually and predictably, so markets are not shocked.
Mission 1

Real world: QE in practice

  • The Bank of England began QE in March 2009, with Bank Rate at 0.5%.
  • In total it bought £895 billion of bonds: £875 billion of gilts and £20 billion of company bonds.
  • The last increase was announced in November 2020, in the pandemic.
  • Question to weigh: why did central banks buy on this scale, and what happens when they stop?
Mission 1Evaluate

Does QE work?

It depends on:

  • Confidence. If households and firms want to save and banks will not lend, new reserves sit idle: "pushing on a string".
  • Who gains. Higher bond, share and house prices help people who own them, which may widen wealth inequality. Supporters reply that QE protected jobs and incomes.
  • Timing and exit. Too much for too long risks inflation; unwinding risks bond-market disruption and losses for the central bank.
  • In the UK, those losses are covered by HM Treasury, so they fall on taxpayers.
  • Evidence. Most studies find early QE lowered long-term yields. How much it raised output and inflation is still debated.
Mission check

?A central bank bought large amounts of government bonds during a slump. Years later, with inflation above target, it starts selling some of the bonds back to investors. Other things equal, what is the most likely effect?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?

Make a guess: If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?

Mission 2

The equation of exchange

The equation of exchangeMVPT××=total spendingnominal GDPM money supply · V velocity of circulation · Pprice level · T transactions (often real output)V and output assumed stableM up, so P up by the same %
  • MV = PT (the Fisher equation of exchange)
  • M = the money supply.
  • V = the velocity of circulation: how many times, on average, each unit of money is spent in a year.
  • P = the average price level.
  • T = the volume of transactions (in practice, often measured by real output).
  • Left side: money × times spent = total spending. Right side: prices × output = nominal GDP.
  • The two sides are equal by definition: an identity, not yet a theory.
Mission 2Worked example

Finding velocity

Illustrative data:

  • Money supply M = 500 billion. Nominal GDP = 2,000 billion.
  • V = nominal GDP ÷ M = 2,000 ÷ 500 = 4. Each unit of money is spent 4 times a year.
  • Real output (at base-year prices) = 1,600 billion.
  • P = nominal GDP ÷ real output = 2,000 ÷ 1,600 = 1.25 (prices are 25% above the base year).
  • Check: M × V = 500 × 4 = 2,000 = P × output = 1.25 × 1,600. ✔
  • Any one of the four can be found from the other three: M = P × output ÷ V = 1.25 × 1,600 ÷ 4 = 500; output = M × V ÷ P = 500 × 4 ÷ 1.25 = 1,600.
Mission 2

From identity to theory

The equation of exchangeMVPT××=total spendingnominal GDPM money supply · V velocity of circulation · Pprice level · T transactions (often real output)V and output assumed stableM up, so P up by the same %
  • The quantity theory of money adds three assumptions:
  • (1) V is stable: it depends on slow-changing habits and payment technology.
  • (2) Real output is set by real factors (labour, capital, technology), not by money, at least in the long run.
  • (3) Causation runs from M to P: money changes first.
  • So if M rises and V and output are fixed, P must rise in proportion.
  • Double M → double P.
  • Say: "the quantity theory says money growth causes inflation" — not: "MV = PQ proves it". The equation is always true; the theory is the assumptions.
Mission 2Worked example

In growth rates

  • In growth rates: % change in M + % change in V ≈ % change in P + % change in real output.
  • Illustrative data: money grows 10%, V is constant, real output grows 3%.
  • Inflation ≈ 10 + 0 − 3 = 7%.
  • (Exact: 1.10 ÷ 1.03 − 1 = 6.8%; the approximation is close for small changes.)
  • Rule of thumb: lasting inflation ≈ money growth − output growth, if V is stable.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: M = 800 billion, V = 5, real output = 2,000 billion. Using the quantity equation, what is the price level P?
Mission 2Graph lab

More money, same output

More money, same outputPrice levelReal national output (Y)00.51.522.5Yf1LRASAD
  • Takeaway: with output fixed at full capacity and V stable, more money means a proportionately higher price level.
Mission 2

Money neutrality and monetarism

  • Money neutrality: in the long run, money changes nominal variables (prices, wages) but not real ones (output, jobs).
  • Milton Friedman: "Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon."
  • Monetarists: to control inflation, control the growth of the money supply; keep it close to the growth of real output.
  • UK: from 1980 the government set targets for money supply growth (the Medium Term Financial Strategy). The targets were often missed and were dropped in the mid-1980s.
Mission 2

Real case: Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe: money, output and pricesIllustrative shapes, no valuesMoney supplyReal outputPrice levelJuly 2008: 231 million %Time100 trillionZimbabwe dollar note, January 2009
  • 2000s: Zimbabwe's output fell sharply, while its central bank created money to pay for government spending.
  • M soared while real output shrank, so P rose explosively.
  • Official annual inflation reached 231 million per cent in July 2008.
  • In January 2009 a 100 trillion Zimbabwe dollar note was issued.
  • People spent money as fast as they could before it lost value: V rose too, pushing prices up even faster.
  • In 2009 the Zimbabwe dollar was abandoned; people used US dollars and other currencies.
Quick check
?In the long run, the quantity theory predicts that a one-off 20% rise in the money supply, with V and real output fixed, will:
Mission 2Evaluate

Does more money always mean inflation?

  • V is not stable: US M2 velocity fell from about 2.2 in 1997 to about 1.1 in 2020.
  • UK quantitative easing: the Bank of England bought 895 billion pounds of assets (2009–2021). CPI inflation averaged a little over 2% a year in the 2010s: much of the new money was held, not spent.
  • Spare capacity (Keynesian view): below full employment, more spending can raise output, not just prices.
  • Causation can run the other way: banks create money when people want to borrow and spend, so rising P and output can drive M.
  • But: in 2021–22, after rapid money growth and an energy price shock, UK CPI inflation reached 11.1% (October 2022). How much was due to money is still debated.
  • It depends on: whether V is stable, how much spare capacity there is, the time period, and whether new money is spent.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: over five years, an economy's money supply rises by 50%. Real output rises by 5% and the price level hardly changes. According to the quantity equation, what must have happened to V?
Mission check

?A country's central bank doubles the money supply. In the same period, people start holding on to money twice as long before spending it, so V halves. Real output does not change. What happens to the price level?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When a country's money loses value abroad, who wins and who loses at home?

Make a guess: When a country's money loses value abroad, who wins and who loses at home?

Mission 3

Prices across the border

  • A firm sets its price in its own currency. The exchange rate decides what that price is abroad.
  • Illustrative data: the pound falls from 1.50 to 1.20 dollars: a 20% depreciation.
  • UK export priced £10: in the US, it was 10 × 1.50 = $15; now 10 × 1.20 = $12. Cheaper abroad.
  • US import priced $30: in the UK, it was 30 ÷ 1.50 = £20; now 30 ÷ 1.20 = £25. Dearer at home.
  • Memory aid: SPICED — Strong Pound, Imports Cheap, Exports Dear. A weak pound does the reverse.
Quick check
?A country's currency depreciates from 2.00 to 1.50 units of foreign currency. A firm keeps the price of its export at 50 in its own currency. What does a foreign buyer now pay?
Mission 3

Net exports and AD

A depreciation on AD/ASPrice level0P3P2P1Y1Y3Y2YfeReal national output (Y)AD1SRAS1LRASAD2SRAS2
  • Depreciation: exports cheaper abroad → export volumes rise. Imports cost more at home → import volumes fall.
  • So net exports (X − M) tend to rise, and AD shifts right (AD1 → AD2).
  • Step 1: AD1 meets SRAS below full capacity.
  • Step 2: AD1 → AD2: real GDP rises, the price level rises, unemployment tends to fall.
  • Step 3: imported raw materials and parts cost more, so SRAS shifts left (SRAS1 → SRAS2): more inflation, less of the output gain.
  • An appreciation does the reverse: net exports fall, AD shifts left.
  • A central bank interest rate cut tends to weaken the currency: a second channel from monetary policy to AD.
  • Say: "a depreciation shifts AD to the right" — not: "a movement along AD".
Mission 3Graph lab

A weaker currency on AD/AS

Illustrative data: the economy starts below full employment.

A weaker currency on AD/ASPrice levelReal national output (Y)Y1P1LRASADSRAS
  • Takeaway: a depreciation raises net exports and AD; the price level rises.
Quick check
?A country's currency appreciates against those of all its trading partners. Other things equal, what happens to its net exports and aggregate demand?
Mission 3

Wider effects of a depreciation

EffectLikely directionWhy
Growth and jobsUpNet exports and AD rise
InflationUpDearer imports (cost-push) and higher AD
Current accountMay improve, after a lagOnly if export and import volumes respond enough to the new prices
FDIMixedHome assets cheaper for foreign buyers; but a falling currency adds risk
Living standardsDown for importers of essentialsImported goods cost more, so real incomes fall
  • Terms of trade worsen: import prices rise in home currency; export prices don't.
  • Winners: exporters, firms competing with imports, the tourism industry.
  • Losers: firms buying imported inputs, consumers, people travelling abroad, borrowers with debts in foreign currency.
  • Real example: the pound fell sharply after the UK's EU referendum in June 2016. UK CPI inflation rose to 3.1% by November 2017, above the 2% target; the Bank of England put most of the overshoot down to the weaker pound raising import prices.
  • Say: "the current account may improve" — not: "a depreciation always cures a deficit".
Quick check
?A furniture maker buys most of its wood from Europe, priced in euros, and sells almost all its furniture at home. Its home currency depreciates against the euro. What is the most likely short-run effect on the firm?
Mission 3

The Marshall-Lerner condition

  • A depreciation makes each import dearer. Whether spending on imports falls depends on how much the import volume falls.
  • Marshall-Lerner condition: starting from balanced trade, a depreciation improves the trade balance if PEDx + PEDm > 1 (absolute values: the price elasticities of demand for exports and for imports).
  • Illustrative data: exports = imports = 100 (home currency). The currency depreciates by 10%.
  • Short run: PEDx = 0.3, PEDm = 0.4. Sum = 0.7 < 1.
    • Exports: 100 × (1 + 0.1 × 0.3) = 103.
    • Imports: 100 × 1.1 × (1 − 0.1 × 0.4) = 105.6.
    • Trade balance: 103 − 105.6 = −2.6. It worsens.
  • Long run: PEDx = 0.8, PEDm = 0.7. Sum = 1.5 > 1.
    • Exports 108, imports 110 × 0.93 = 102.3, balance +5.7. It improves.
  • Say: "the sum of the elasticities must exceed 1" — not: "each elasticity must exceed 1".
Mission 3

The J-curve

The J-curveCurrent account balance+0−t0TimeDepreciationElasticities lowMarshall-Lernercondition met+ surplus, − deficit
  • Right after a depreciation, demand is inelastic: contracts are fixed, buyers take time to switch suppliers, and exporters need time to expand.
  • So the current account worsens first: the same imports cost more.
  • Over time, elasticities rise. Once the Marshall-Lerner condition holds, the balance improves.
  • Plotted against time, the path looks like a J.
  • Real example: in November 1967 the UK devalued the pound from 2.80 to 2.40 dollars (a 14.3% cut). The current account stayed in deficit in 1968 and moved into surplus in 1969.
Mission 3Graph lab

Trace the J-curve

Illustrative data: the currency depreciates by 10% in quarter 0. Elasticities rise from a sum of 0.7 to 1.5 over two years.

Trace the J-curveTrade balanceQuarter02468−4048balance = 0trade balance
  • Takeaway: the balance worsens while elasticities are low, and improves only once their sum passes 1.
Quick check
?A country starts with balanced trade. The price elasticity of demand for its exports is −0.6 and for its imports −0.3. Its currency depreciates. Other things equal, what happens to its trade balance?
Mission 3Evaluate

Does a weaker currency help?

It depends on:

  • Elasticities and time: buyers are slow to switch, so volumes change little at first; the gain may take years.
  • This is the J-curve.
  • Spare capacity: with output below its full employment level, more AD raises output and jobs; near full capacity, mostly inflation.
  • Import content of exports: in global supply chains, dearer imported parts eat into the price advantage.
  • Non-price competitiveness: quality, design and reliability may matter more than price.
  • Why the currency fell, and others' response: a fall caused by lost confidence may also deter investment; rivals may devalue too (competitive devaluation).
Mission check

?Investors abroad move funds into a country, and its currency appreciates sharply. Other things equal, which effect of the appreciation is most likely in the short run?
Mission 4

Mission 4: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Make a guess: How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?

Mission 4

What supply-side policies aim to do

  • Supply-side policies: government policies that aim to raise the economy's productive capacity.
  • They work on the quantity and quality of factors of production and on how efficiently markets work.
  • Goals:
    • long-term growth: LRAS shifts right
    • a lower natural rate of unemployment
    • growth with less inflationary pressure
    • better international competitiveness
Mission 4

On the AD/AS diagram

Supply-side policy shifts LRAS rightPrice level0P1P2Yfe1Yfe2Real national output (Y)ADSRAS1LRAS1LRAS2SRAS2Capacity rises: real output up, price level down.
  • Capacity rises: LRAS shifts right.
  • Productive capacity rises from Yfe1 to Yfe2.
  • With AD unchanged: real output rises, the price level falls.
  • Lower costs per unit often shift SRAS right too.
  • On the Keynesian AS, the vertical section shifts right.
  • Employment can rise at a lower natural rate of unemployment.
Quick check
?Which policy is most clearly aimed at the supply side of the economy?
Mission 4

Worked example: per person, what can policy change?

  • Illustrative data. Real GDP per person = output per hour × hours per worker × workers ÷ population.
  • Population 10 million; workers 5 million; 1,600 hours each a year; output per hour 50.
  • Real GDP = 50 × 1,600 × 5 million = 400 billion. Per person: 40,000.
  • Policy 1: childcare and job support bring 0.5 million more people into work. Real GDP = 440 billion; per person 44,000 (+10%).
  • Policy 2: training and better equipment raise output per hour to 55. Per person also 44,000 (+10%).
  • Both together: 48,400 per person: +21%, not +20%, because the effects multiply.
  • Labour productivity (output per worker or per hour) depends on capital per worker, skills, health, technology and management.
Mission 4

Two approaches

Two approaches to supply-side policyMarket-basedInterventionistCut income and profittaxes (incentives)Education and trainingReform benefitsHealth careReduce trade unionpower; flexible labourmarketsR&D subsidies andgrantsDeregulationInfrastructure(transport, broadband,energy)PrivatisationIndustrial policy:support for chosenindustriesCompetition(anti-monopoly) policy;trade liberalisationSubsidies to firms orregions
Market-basedInterventionist
Cut income and profit taxes (incentives)Education and training
Reform benefitsHealth care
Reduce trade union power; flexible labour marketsR&D subsidies and grants
DeregulationInfrastructure (transport, broadband, energy)
PrivatisationIndustrial policy: support for chosen industries
Competition (anti-monopoly) policy; trade liberalisationSubsidies to firms or regions
  • Market-based: free markets and incentives work better with fewer barriers.
  • Interventionist: markets under-provide some things (positive externalities, public goods), so the government steps in.
  • Immigration control is a labour supply policy: it changes the number and skills of workers.
Mission 4

Market-based policies: how they work

  • Lower income tax raises the reward for work: some work more hours or join the labour force.
  • Lower profit tax raises the return on investment: more capital, more productivity.
  • Benefit reform: a bigger gap between income in and out of work makes taking a job more attractive. Voluntary unemployment falls: a lower natural rate.
  • Deregulation and privatisation: fewer rules and a profit motive push firms to cut costs and innovate.
  • Competition policy and trade liberalisation: rivals force firms to be efficient.
  • Labour market reform: weaker union power and more flexible contracts let wages and jobs adjust faster.
  • But: some of these may widen inequality or weaken job security.
Mission 4

Labour market diagrams

Labour market diagramsMinimum wage above the equilibrium wageWage rate (W)0WminWeLdLeLsunemploymentQuantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)Labour supply shifts rightWage rate (W)0W1W2L1L2Quantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)1S(L)2Benefit reform, flexibility, immigration: morepeople seek work at each wage.Immigration control: labour supply shifts leftWage rate (W)0Quantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)1S(L)0
  • Minimum wage: set above the equilibrium wage, labour supplied exceeds labour demanded: unemployment (Ls − Ld).
  • Removing or lowering it: employment moves towards Le. Evidence on how many jobs this adds is mixed.
  • Benefit reform and flexibility: more people seek work at each wage, so labour supply shifts right: employment rises.
  • Immigration: labour supply shifts right; employment rises; LRAS shifts right. Wage effects are debated: migrants also spend, raising labour demand.
  • Immigration control works the other way: labour supply shifts left; skill shortages may rise in some sectors.
Mission 4

Interventionist policies: how they work

  • Education and training raise human capital: more output per worker. Fewer skill gaps: lower structural unemployment.
  • Health care: fewer days lost to illness; longer working lives.
  • R&D: new ideas spill over to other firms (a positive externality), so markets under-invest. Subsidies or tax credits raise R&D.
  • Infrastructure: roads, rail and broadband cut firms' costs and link workers to jobs.
  • Industrial policy: support for strategic industries.
  • But: costly, slow, and the government may "pick losers" (government failure).
Quick check
?A government sells its state-owned rail company to private investors and lets rival firms bid to run routes. How is this policy meant to raise LRAS?
Mission 4

Two effects at different speeds

Two effects at different speedsPrice level0Yfe1Yfe2Real national output (Y)AD1LRAS1AD2LRAS2spending nowyears later
  • Many supply-side policies also change spending:
    • building roads or schools is government spending: AD shifts right at once
    • a tax cut raises disposable income: AD shifts right
  • The supply-side effect comes later, once the road is built or the trained workers arrive: LRAS shifts right.
  • So fiscal policy can have supply-side effects (e.g. tax incentives), and supply-side policies can have demand-side effects.
Mission 4Graph lab

Build now, grow later

Illustrative data. Start: real output 1000 at full employment; price level 100.

Build now, grow laterPrice levelReal national output (Y)1,000100LRASADSRAS
  • Takeaway: short run (demand effect) output 1050, price level 105; long run, once capacity grows, output 1100 and the price level back to 100.
Quick check
?A government cuts the top rate of income tax. Which effect is a supply-side effect?
Mission 4

Real world: cutting taxes on company profits

  • The US cut its main federal corporate tax rate from 35% to 21% from 2018.
  • Aim: more investment in capital, so higher productivity and pay.
  • One 2024 study estimated investment rose by about 11% at firms given the average tax cut, compared with firms given none, but wages and growth rose by less than supporters had claimed.
  • The UK cut its main corporation tax rate from 28% (2010) to 19% (2017), then raised it to 25% in 2023 for profits over £250,000.
  • Question to weigh: how would you judge whether a tax cut on profits raised capacity, and over how many years?
Mission 4Evaluate

How well do supply-side policies work?

It depends on:

  • Time lags. Education, health and infrastructure take years, even decades, to raise capacity.
  • Response to incentives. Tax cuts may change effort or investment only a little; profits may go to shareholders instead.
  • Cost and trade-offs. Interventionist policies need spending (opportunity cost); market-based ones may widen inequality.
  • The output gap. With weak AD, extra capacity sits unused; Keynesians would boost demand first.
  • Government failure. Poor information can lead to wasted subsidies or badly designed rules.
  • Strength: if they work, growth with lower inflation and a lower natural rate of unemployment.
Mission check

?A government expands free childcare and job training, paid for by cutting other spending, so AD does not change. Over several years, more parents take jobs and workers become more skilled. According to the AD/AS model, what happens in the long run?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why can the right cure for one slump be the wrong cure for the next?

Make a guess: When an economy slumps, what should a government do first?

Mission 5

The toolkit and the policy mix

  • Three sets of tools:
    • Fiscal policy: government spending and taxes.
    • Monetary policy: interest rates, the money supply, QE.
    • Supply-side policies: raise productive capacity (education, incentives, competition).
  • Policy mix: how these are combined at one time.
  • Fiscal and monetary policy can push the same way (both expansionary) or opposite ways (one expansionary, one contractionary).
  • Policies that shift AD are demand-side; policies that shift LRAS are supply-side.
Mission 5

Combining fiscal and monetary policy

Combining fiscal and monetary policyPrice level0P2P1P1Y1Y1Y2Yfenegative output gapReal national output (Y)AD1SRASLRASAD2AD3fiscalmonetaryMoney marketNominal interest rate0i1Quantity of moneyMD1MS1MD2MS2i2 = ?fiscalmonetaryThe new interest rate depends on the sizes of thetwo shifts.
  • Step 1: start with real output below full employment.
  • This is a negative output gap.
  • Step 2: both expansionary: AD shifts right for two reasons. Real output and the price level both rise.
  • Step 3: the interest rate:
    • Fiscal expansion raises incomes and spending, so demand for money rises: rates are pushed up.
    • Monetary expansion raises the money supply: rates are pushed down.
    • Overall change: indeterminate. It depends on which effect is bigger.
  • Opposite directions flip this: the interest-rate change is certain, the AD change is not.
    • Expansionary fiscal + contractionary monetary: interest rate up; AD uncertain.
    • Contractionary fiscal + expansionary monetary: interest rate down; AD uncertain.
  • Say: "the change in the interest rate is indeterminate" — not: "it stays the same".
Mission 5Graph lab

Mix the policies

Illustrative data. Start: real output 960, full employment at 1,000, interest rate 5%.

Mix the policiesPrice levelReal national output (Y)960100LRASSRASADstart 5%5%Interest rate
  • Takeaway: two pushes the same way make the AD change certain; two pushes in opposite ways make the interest-rate change certain.
Quick check
?A government cuts its spending to reduce a budget deficit. At the same time, the central bank buys government bonds to increase the money supply. Which outcome is certain?
Mission 5

Demand shocks and supply shocks

Demand shock and supply shockDemand shock: AD shifts leftPrice level0P1P2Y2Y1Real national output (Y)AD1SRASLRASAD2Supply shock: SRAS shifts leftPrice level0P2P1Y2Y1Real national output (Y)ADSRAS1LRASSRAS2Output falls, price level rises: stagflation
  • An external shock starts outside the economy and outside the government's control.
  • Demand shock: e.g. a world recession cuts demand for exports.
    • AD shifts left. Real output and the price level fall.
    • Expansionary policy can push both back up: no conflict.
  • Supply shock: e.g. world energy prices jump.
    • SRAS shifts left. Real output falls and the price level rises: stagflation.
    • Raising AD helps jobs but adds to inflation. Cutting AD slows inflation but deepens the slump: a policy dilemma.
  • First step in any crisis: diagnose the shock.
  • Say: "a cost-push supply shock" — not: "inflation caused by too much spending".
Mission 5

Conflicts and trade-offs

  • Hitting one objective can make another harder:
    • Inflation vs unemployment: in the short run, along the SRPC, lower inflation may mean higher unemployment.
    • Growth vs the current account: faster growth raises imports.
    • Growth vs the environment: more output can mean more pollution and resource use.
    • Growth vs equality: gains may go mostly to some groups.
  • Unintended consequences: e.g. very low interest rates for years can push up house and share prices.
  • Macroeconomic perspectives differ:
    • Keynesian: markets can stay in a slump for a long time; demand-side policy helps.
    • Classical / monetarist: markets self-correct; policy should keep inflation low and boost supply.
  • Say: "a trade-off" when one objective is given up for another — not: "the policy failed".
Quick check
?A country that imports most of its energy is hit by a sharp rise in world energy prices. Unemployment and inflation both rise. Which statement is most accurate?
Mission 5

The Great Depression

  • USA, 1929–33: real GDP fell by about a quarter; unemployment reached about 25% in 1933.
  • Thousands of banks failed. The money supply fell by about a third.
    • The Federal Reserve did little to stop it.
    • The Smoot–Hawley tariffs (1930) raised taxes on imports; other countries hit back.
  • Recovery began after 1933: the US left the gold standard; the New Deal brought public works and bank reform.
  • UK: governments aimed to balance the budget and cut spending in 1931.
    • The UK left the gold standard in 1931. Bank Rate was cut to 2% in 1932: "cheap money".
  • Keynes's General Theory (1936) argued that governments should raise spending in a slump.
  • Two readings, both still argued:
    • Keynesian: a collapse in spending that budget-balancing made worse.
    • Monetarist: a collapse in money that the central bank allowed.
Mission 5

The 1970s: when the old cure stopped working

  • After 1945, full employment was the top priority. Governments managed AD to keep unemployment low.
  • 1973–74: oil prices roughly quadrupled. A supply shock.
  • Result: stagflation. UK inflation (RPI) peaked at about 27% in 1975.
  • Raising AD to cut unemployment now pushed inflation even higher.
  • Direct controls on inflation were tried:
    • Incomes policies: legal or agreed limits on pay rises (UK, 1970s).
    • Price controls: the US froze wages and prices for 90 days in 1971.
  • Problems with direct controls:
    • They treat symptoms, not causes.
    • Shortages and black markets where prices are held below equilibrium.
    • Hard to enforce; pent-up pay and price rises when they end.
Mission 5

Monetarism and new priorities

  • Late 1970s: inflation became the top priority.
  • USA: from 1979, the Fed (chair Paul Volcker) cut money growth. The federal funds rate reached nearly 20% in 1980–81.
    • Inflation fell from 13.5% (1980) to 3.2% (1983).
    • The cost: a deep recession; unemployment hit 10.8% in 1982.
  • UK: from 1980, the government set targets for money supply growth (monetarism).
    • Inflation fell, but unemployment rose above 3 million in the 1980s.
    • Money targets proved hard to hit and were dropped.
  • 1992: the UK set an inflation target. 1997: the Bank of England was given control of interest rates.
  • Since 2008, financial stability has moved up the list.
Mission 5

2008: the response

  • The global financial crisis began in the banks: lending froze, AD collapsed.
  • UK:
    • Bank Rate cut from 5% (2008) to 0.5% (March 2009).
    • Quantitative easing: the Bank of England bought £200bn of assets, mainly government bonds, by early 2010.
    • VAT cut from 17.5% to 15% for 13 months.
    • Government stakes in failing banks (RBS, Lloyds).
  • USA:
    • Federal funds rate cut to 0–0.25% (December 2008); large-scale asset purchases (QE).
    • $700bn fund to rescue banks (TARP, 2008).
    • $787bn stimulus package (2009).
  • Lessons drawn from the 1930s: stop the money supply and banks collapsing; support AD.
Mission 5

After 2008: the austerity debate

  • From 2010, the UK and many other countries cut deficits: fiscal consolidation ("austerity").
  • Arguments for:
    • High debt can raise borrowing costs. In 2010, Greece's borrowing costs soared.
    • A credible plan may boost confidence and keep interest rates low.
    • Smaller deficits leave room to respond to the next shock.
  • Arguments against:
    • Cutting spending in a weak economy reduces AD and growth.
    • A study by IMF economists (2013) found the multiplier in the crisis was larger than forecasters assumed, so cuts hit output harder.
    • With interest rates near zero, monetary policy could not offset the cuts.
  • Your judgement depends on: the size of the multiplier, the level of debt, and market confidence.
Quick check
?In the USA from 1929 to 1933, the money supply fell by about a third as thousands of banks failed. Which response in 2008 most clearly reflects that lesson?
Mission 5

Problems and constraints for policymakers

  • Time lags: spotting a problem, acting and the effect can take 18 months or more.
  • Poor data and forecasts: GDP figures are revised; the size of the output gap is uncertain.
  • The zero lower bound: rates near 0% leave little room to cut.
  • High public debt limits fiscal room.
  • A global economy:
    • External shocks (energy prices, world recessions, pandemics) are outside any one government's control.
    • Capital flows and exchange rates can undo interest-rate changes.
    • Low-income countries face extra limits: poverty, weak tax bases, costly borrowing.
    • Competitiveness depends on supply-side factors that change slowly.
  • Expectations and politics: short-termism before elections; rising inflation expectations.
  • Result: government failure in macro policy is possible: a policy that arrives late or is the wrong size can destabilise the economy.
Mission 5Evaluate

Which policy works best?

  • Criteria for success: are the targets met (e.g. 2% inflation)? At what cost? How fast? With what side-effects? Who gains and who loses?
  • Relative effectiveness:
    • Monetary: quick to change, but weak near 0% rates and slow to work (about 18–24 months).
    • Fiscal: strong in a deep slump, but slow to agree and limited by debt.
    • Supply-side: lasting gains in capacity, but they take years.
  • It depends on:
    • The cause of the problem: demand shock or supply shock?
    • Spare capacity: a big gap favours stimulus; little spare capacity means inflation.
    • The state of public finances and how open the economy is.
Mission check

?Two economies both face rising unemployment. In Economy X, demand for its exports has collapsed and inflation is falling below target. In Economy Y, the price of imported food and fuel has doubled and inflation is rising above target. Which judgement is best?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • At the zero lower bound, QE creates reserves to buy bonds: bond prices rise, yields fall, borrowing gets cheaper, AD shifts right.
  • Reversing QE (QT) contracts the money supply and pushes yields up.

Mission 2

  • The equation of exchange is an identity: money × velocity = price level × real output.
  • The quantity theory assumes stable V and fixed real output, so money growth causes proportional inflation; money is neutral in the long run.
  • Evidence is mixed: V can change a lot, and spare capacity and the direction of causation matter.

Mission 3

  • Depreciation: exports cheaper abroad, imports more expensive at home, net exports and AD rise. Appreciation: the reverse.
  • The price level rises (AD and dearer inputs); importers, consumers and travellers lose, exporters gain.
  • Marshall-Lerner: a depreciation improves the trade balance only if PEDx + PEDm > 1.
  • J-curve: worse first, better later.

Mission 4

  • Supply-side policies aim to raise capacity: LRAS shifts right, raising real output without adding to inflation.
  • Market-based policies use incentives and competition; interventionist policies fix under-provision of skills, health, R&D and infrastructure.
  • Effects take years and are uncertain in size.

Mission 5

  • The policy mix combines fiscal, monetary and supply-side tools. When two policies push the same way, the AD change is certain and the interest-rate change is not, and the reverse.
  • Diagnose the shock first: demand shocks allow stimulus without conflict; supply shocks force a trade-off.
  • Priorities shifted: full employment after 1945, inflation from the late 1970s, financial stability after 2008. Each crisis was fought with lessons from the last.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Fiscal, monetary and supply-side policy (part 2) for OCR A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?
  2. Mission 2If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?
  3. Mission 3When a country's money loses value abroad, who wins and who loses at home?
  4. Mission 4How can a government raise the most its economy can produce, and why does it take so long?
  5. Mission 5Why can the right cure for one slump be the wrong cure for the next?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · OCR