← A-Level Economics · Eduqas A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
WJEC Eduqas A-level Economics (A520) · Market failure (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Market failure (part 2)

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?
  2. Mission 2Why can a huge harvest leave farmers with less money than a small one?
  3. Mission 3What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?
  4. Mission 4Why would a government ever make something cost more?
  5. Mission 5Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?
  6. Mission 6Can a tax take more money from richer people and still hit poorer people harder?
  7. Mission 7When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?
Mission 1

Mission 1: How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?

Make a guess: How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?

Mission 1

Income is a flow, wealth is a stock

Flow and stockincome(per year)wealth(at a point in time)interest,rent,dividends
  • Income: a flow of money over a period, e.g. per year.
    • wages, rent, interest, dividends, profit, government benefits
  • Wealth: a stock of assets owned at a point in time, minus debts.
    • property, savings, shares, pension funds
  • They feed each other: wealth earns income (rent, interest, dividends); saved income builds wealth.
  • So inequality in wealth tends to create inequality in income, and the reverse.
  • Say: "wealth is a stock; income is a flow" — not: "wealthy" means "high income". A retired homeowner can be wealthy on a low income.
Quick check
?Which of these is a change in a household's wealth rather than its income?
Mission 1

Equality or equity?

  • Equality: everyone has the same: equal incomes, wealth or opportunities.
  • Equity: fairness. What is fair is a value judgement: a normative question.
  • Equality of outcome: the same result for all. Equality of opportunity: the same chances, results may differ.
  • Horizontal equity: people in the same position are treated the same.
  • Vertical equity: people in different positions are treated differently, e.g. higher incomes pay a higher share in tax.
  • Say: "equity means fairness" — not: "equity means equality". An equitable distribution need not be equal.
Mission 1

The Lorenz curve

Lorenz curve and GiniCumulative % of income01001540100Cumulative % of populationABLine of equalityLorenz curveGini = A ÷ (A + B)
  • Line up everyone from poorest to richest.
  • Horizontal axis: cumulative % of population. Vertical axis: cumulative % of income (or wealth).
  • Line of equality: the 45° line. The bottom 20% get 20%, the bottom 40% get 40%, and so on.
  • The Lorenz curve shows the actual shares. It sags below the line of equality.
  • Read it: a point at (40, 15) means the poorest 40% receive 15% of income.
  • The further the curve from the line of equality, the more unequal the distribution.
Mission 1

The Gini coefficient

Lorenz curve and GiniCumulative % of income01001540100Cumulative % of populationABLine of equalityLorenz curveGini = A ÷ (A + B)
  • Gini coefficient = A ÷ (A + B).
    • A: area between the line of equality and the Lorenz curve.
    • B: area under the Lorenz curve.
  • 0 = perfect equality. 1 = perfect inequality (one person has everything). Often shown as 0–100.
  • UK disposable household income: Gini 32.9 on the 0–100 scale (financial year ending 2024, ONS).
  • Great Britain household wealth: Gini about 0.6, or 60 on the 0–100 scale (2018–2020, ONS). The richest 10% of households held 43% of all wealth; the poorest half held 9%.
  • World Bank Gini estimates (0–100 scale): South Africa 63.0 (2014); Brazil 48.9 (2020); Slovak Republic 23.2 (2019).
  • Countries survey in different years, so compare with care.
  • Limits: two different Lorenz curves can give the same Gini; a Gini does not show where the inequality lies, or how rich the country is.
Mission 1Graph lab

Moving the curve

Illustrative data. Quintile shares: 5%, 10%, 15%, 25%, 45%. Gini 0.38.

Moving the curveCumulative % of incomeCumulative % of population020406080100020406080100line of equalityLorenz curve
  • Takeaway: shifting income from richer to poorer groups pulls the Lorenz curve towards the line of equality; here the Gini falls from 0.38 to 0.30.
Quick check
?Two countries' Lorenz curves for income are drawn on one diagram. Country X's curve lies further from the line of equality than country Y's at every point. What can you conclude?
Mission 1

Why is income unequal?

  • Human capital: education and skills raise productivity and pay.
  • Ownership of wealth: land, property and shares earn rent, interest and dividends; inheritance passes them on.
  • Inequality of opportunity: family background affects schooling, contacts and health.
  • Discrimination by gender, ethnicity and others.
  • Power: bargaining power of unions, employers with monopsony power, top executives.
  • Tax and benefit policy: progressive taxes and benefits narrow gaps; regressive taxes widen them.
  • Globalisation and technological change: raise the pay of scarce skills; some routine jobs move abroad or are automated.
Mission 1

Inequality as a market failure, and its effects

  • Markets allocate goods to those willing and able to pay. A market can be efficient and still leave some with very little.
  • So an unequal distribution can be seen as a market failure: the market fails to produce an equitable outcome. Whether it does is a value judgement.
  • Effects:
    • individuals: worse health, education and housing for those on low incomes
    • growth: big rewards can create incentives to work and invest; but very unequal societies may waste talent, and an OECD study (2014) found rising inequality lowered growth in OECD countries
    • living standards and social stability: high inequality is linked to lower trust and more political tension
  • The evidence on growth points both ways, so economists disagree on how much inequality harms it.
Mission 1Evaluate

How much inequality is a problem?

It depends on:

  • Values. Fairness is a normative judgement; people disagree on how equal outcomes should be.
  • Causes. Inequality from effort and skill is viewed differently from inequality from inheritance, luck or discrimination.
  • Mobility. Wide gaps matter more if children of poor families stay poor.
  • Living standards of the poorest. Rising inequality with rising absolute incomes differs from falling incomes at the bottom.
  • Measurement. Income or wealth? Before or after taxes and benefits? Wealth is distributed far more unequally than income.
Mission check

?In country P, the Gini coefficient for household income is 0.30 and for household wealth is 0.65. (Illustrative data.) What can you conclude?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why can a huge harvest leave farmers with less money than a small one?

Make a guess: Why can a huge harvest leave farmers with less money than a small one?

Mission 2

Why crop prices jump

Volatile commodity pricePrimary commodity: steep DPrice0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDS1S2Big price fall, small rise in quantityManufactured product: flatter DPrice0QuantityDS1S2Same supply shift: small price fall
  • Primary commodities: raw materials and crops, e.g. cocoa, coffee, wheat, copper, oil.
  • Their supply shifts often and without warning: weather, pests, disease, strikes at mines.
  • Once a crop is harvested, supply is almost fixed for the season: a near-vertical short-run supply curve.
  • Demand is price inelastic: buyers cut back little when price rises, so the demand curve is drawn steep.
  • Inelastic demand + supply shifts = large price swings for small changes in quantity.
  • Say: "a bumper harvest shifts supply to the right; price falls and there is an extension of demand" — not: "demand increases".
Mission 2

Why both curves are so steep

Primary commoditiesManufactured products
PEDLow: necessities (food, fuel, materials) with few substitutesHigher: many close substitutes (brands, models)
PESLow: crops take months or years to grow; new mines take years to open; land and machinery are hard to switch to other uses; perishable crops cannot be stored for longHigher: factories add shifts, use spare capacity and hold stocks of finished goods
  • Example: a new cocoa tree takes several years to bear its first pods, so a high cocoa price cannot quickly raise output.
  • Both PED and PES are usually less than 1 in the short run (ignoring the minus sign for PED).
  • In the long run both become more elastic: farmers replant, buyers find substitutes.
Mission 2

Worked example: a bigger harvest, less money

Harvest and revenueIllustrative dataPoor harvest: 80 × $6080$4,800Normal harvest: 90 × $4090$3,600Bumper harvest: 100 × $20100$2,000Quantity (thousand tonnes)Revenue ($ thousand) = price × quantity
  • Illustrative data: a world market for a crop. Quantity in thousand tonnes; price in $ per tonne.
  • Normal harvest: 90 sold at $40. Revenue = 40 × 90 = $3,600 thousand.
  • Bumper harvest: 100. Buyers take the extra only if the price falls to $20.
  • Revenue = 20 × 100 = $2,000 thousand.
  • %ΔQ = (100 − 90) ÷ 90 × 100 = +11.1%. %ΔP = (20 − 40) ÷ 40 × 100 = −50%.
  • PED = 11.1 ÷ −50 = −0.22: price inelastic.
  • Poor harvest: 80, price rises to $60. Revenue = 60 × 80 = $4,800 thousand.
  • Inelastic demand: price changes by a bigger percentage than quantity, so revenue moves the same way as price and the opposite way to the harvest. A bigger crop earns less; a smaller crop earns more.
  • Shortcut: %ΔP ≈ %ΔQ ÷ PED. With PED −0.22, an 11% rise in quantity needs about a 50% price fall.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a frost cuts the world coffee harvest by 5%. Short-run PED for coffee is −0.25. Roughly how does the world price of coffee change, so that buyers' quantity demanded falls by 5%?
Mission 2

Why volatile prices matter

  • Producers: farm incomes rise and crash from year to year; planning and borrowing become risky, so investment falls.
  • Signals: planting decisions are made on last year's price, so a high price can lead to over-planting and a later crash.
  • So volatile prices are a market failure: price signals give a poor guide to future scarcity, and resources are misallocated.
  • Countries: many low-income countries earn most export revenue from one or two commodities: primary product dependency.
  • UNCTAD calls a country commodity-dependent when commodities make up more than 60% of its merchandise exports.
  • Export earnings, tax revenue and the exchange rate all swing with the commodity price.
  • Case: in 2024 cocoa futures passed $10,000 per tonne for the first time, after poor harvests in West Africa. Many cocoa farmers in Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire sell at prices set in advance by their governments, so they gained much less than the world price rise.
Quick check
?A world price rise for copper ore and a world price rise for smartphones are each the same percentage. Which best explains why the quantity of copper ore supplied rises much less in the next 6 months?
Mission 2

The buffer stock scheme

Buffer stock schemePrice ($ per tonne)PmaxPePminQuantity (thousand tonnes)free pricefree priceDS1S2S3Normal harvest: price inside the band;the agency does nothingBumper harvest: free price below Pmin.Excess supply: agency buys; stockgrowsPoor harvest: free price above Pmax.Excess demand: agency sells; stockshrinksIllustrative data. Quantity axis does not start atzero.
  • Buffer stock scheme: an agency holds a stock of a storable commodity and buys or sells it to keep the price inside a band.
  • Floor: the minimum price. Ceiling: the maximum price.
  • Step 1: normal harvest. Price is inside the band. The agency does nothing.
  • Step 2: bumper harvest. The free-market price would fall below the floor. The agency buys the excess supply at the floor price and adds it to the stock.
  • Step 3: poor harvest. The free-market price would rise above the ceiling. The agency sells from its stock at the ceiling price.
  • Needs: a commodity that can be stored, money to buy in good years, and a stock to sell in bad years.
Mission 2Graph lab

Hold the band

Illustrative data: the crop from an earlier screen. Floor $30, ceiling $50. Normal harvest 90, price $40.

Hold the bandPrice ($)Quantity (thousand tonnes)7080100110020406090DS (harvest 90)floor $30ceiling $50
  • Takeaway: the agency buys or sells only the gap between harvest and quantity demanded at the floor or ceiling price.
Mission 2

Worked example: three harvests

  • Illustrative data: demand from an earlier screen; band $30–$50.
  • Normal (90): free price $40, inside the band. No action.
  • Bumper (100): free price $20. At the floor of $30, buyers take 95. Agency buys 100 − 95 = 5, costing 5 × 30 = $150 thousand.
  • Poor (80): free price $60. At the ceiling of $50, buyers want 85. Agency sells 85 − 80 = 5, earning 5 × 50 = $250 thousand.
  • Farm revenue without the scheme: $2,000–$4,800 thousand.
  • With the scheme: bumper 30 × 100 = $3,000 thousand; poor 50 × 80 = $4,000 thousand.
  • Incomes are more stable. Here the stock is back where it started, because good and bad years balanced out.
Quick check
?A buffer stock diagram shows a downward-sloping demand curve D and a band between a floor price Pmin and a ceiling price Pmax.
PointMeaning
Q1quantity of a normal harvest
Q2quantity demanded at Pmin
Q3quantity of this year's bumper harvest (vertical supply S2)

To hold the price at Pmin, what quantity must the agency buy?

Mission 2

Guaranteed minimum prices for farmers

  • Price stabilisation: reducing swings in price and farm income, e.g. by a buffer stock.
  • Guaranteed minimum price: the government promises to buy a crop at a set price, so the market price cannot fall below it.
  • It works like a buffer stock floor, but with no ceiling and often no plan to sell the stock again.
  • If the guaranteed price is above equilibrium, the state buys a surplus every year and must store, sell abroad or destroy it.
  • Case: India sets minimum support prices for crops such as wheat and rice; a state agency, the Food Corporation of India, buys at these prices and has held large grain stocks.
  • Case: the European Community's price support in the 1970s–80s built up large stores of butter and other farm products.
  • For: secure farm incomes; stable food supply. Against: cost to taxpayers, storage and waste, and incentives to overproduce.
Mission 2Evaluate

Why many schemes collapsed

  • It depends on where the band is set. Nobody knows the long-run equilibrium price. A band set too high means the agency buys year after year: the stock and the bill keep growing.
  • It depends on whether a change is temporary or permanent. A scheme can smooth good and bad years, but not a lasting fall in demand or rise in supply.
  • It depends on storage. Coffee and metals store; fresh fruit does not. Storage costs money every year.
  • It depends on funding. The agency must have money to buy in a run of bumper years.
  • Case: the International Tin Council ran out of funds defending the tin price in October 1985; tin trading on the London Metal Exchange was suspended and the price collapsed.
  • Case: Australia's wool reserve price scheme was suspended in February 1991 with a stockpile of 4.7 million bales, which took until 2001 to sell.
  • Supporters reply: with a band near the long-run average and enough funds, a scheme can reduce income swings for poor producers.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a coffee buffer stock agency sets a band of $3.00–$3.60 per kg. Over five years the free-market price would have been $2.70, $2.80, $3.20, $2.60 and $2.90. What is the most likely outcome if the band is kept unchanged?
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a drought cuts a tea-exporting country's harvest by 10%. Harvests fall by a similar amount across the region, and the world price of tea rises by 40%. What happens to the country's tea export revenue, and why?
Mission 3

Mission 3: What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?

Make a guess: A law holds the price of bread below the market price. What is most likely?

Mission 3

A legal top price

Ceiling above and below equilibriumCeiling above Pe: not bindingPrice0PmaxPeQeQuantityDSCeiling below Pe: bindingPrice0PePmaxQeQuantityDSPmax: maximum price (price ceiling)
  • A maximum price (price ceiling): the highest price that can legally be charged.
  • To have any effect it must be set below the equilibrium price. Then it is binding.
  • Set above equilibrium, it changes nothing: the market price is already lower.
  • Why do governments use them? To make essentials affordable (rents, basic food, fuel) and to protect consumers from sharp price rises.
Mission 3

Why a shortage appears

Shortage under a ceilingPrice0PePmaxQsQeQdshortage (excess demand)QuantityDSPmax: maximum price (price ceiling)
  • Step 1: market clears at Pe, Qe.
  • Step 2: a ceiling is drawn below Pe.
  • At the lower price, quantity demanded extends to Qd.
  • Quantity supplied contracts to Qs.
  • Step 3: the gap Qd − Qs is excess demand: a shortage.
  • Only Qs is bought and sold. Trade falls from Qe to Qs.
  • Say: "an extension of demand and a contraction of supply" — not: "demand rises and supply falls" (neither curve shifts).
Quick check
?In a market, the equilibrium price is $20. The government sets a maximum price of $25. What happens?
Mission 3

Worked example: how big is the shortage?

  • Illustrative data. Demand: Qd = 100 − 2P. Supply: Qs = 4P − 20 (P in $, Q in thousands).
  • Equilibrium: 100 − 2P = 4P − 20, so 6P = 120, Pe = $20, Qe = 60.
  • Ceiling at $15:
  • Qd = 100 − 2 × 15 = 70.
  • Qs = 4 × 15 − 20 = 40.
  • Shortage = 70 − 40 = 30 thousand.
  • Quantity traded falls from 60 to 40.
Mission 3Graph lab

Lower the ceiling

Lower the ceilingPrice ($)Quantity6020DSprice ceilingshortage 30
  • Takeaway: the lower the ceiling, and the more elastic demand and supply are, the bigger the shortage.
Quick check
?Use the illustrative market in an earlier screen (Qd = 100 − 2P, Qs = 4P − 20). The ceiling is set at $18. What is the shortage?
Mission 3

Who gets the goods?

  • Price no longer rations, so something else does:
  • Queues (first come, first served), waiting lists, ballots.
  • Ration coupons from the government.
  • Sellers' preference: friends, regular customers, or discrimination.
  • Black (shadow) markets: illegal resale above the ceiling.
  • In an earlier screen, only 40 thousand units are supplied. Buyers would pay up to $30 for the 40-thousandth unit (100 − 2P = 40 gives P = 30), so black-market prices can rise above the old equilibrium of $20.
  • Berlin froze most rents at 2019 levels in 2020. Reports followed of landlords demanding large payments for furniture as a condition of renting. Germany's Constitutional Court struck the law down in 2021.
Mission 3

Winners and losers

Welfare under a ceilingPrice0PePmaxQsQeQuantityBCEdemand priceDSB: moves from producers to consumersdeadweight (welfare) loss = C + E
  • Assume the scarce goods go to the buyers who value them most.
  • Area B (between Pe and the ceiling, up to Qs): moves from producers to consumers who still buy.
  • Areas C + E (between Qs and Qe): trades that no longer happen. This is the deadweight (welfare) loss.
  • Consumers: gain B, lose C. Those who buy gain; those shut out lose.
  • Producers: lose B and E. Always worse off.
  • If goods go to the wrong buyers (waiting in line, luck), consumers gain less, and the time spent waiting is a further loss.
  • Say: "welfare loss" or "deadweight loss" — not: "the shortage is the loss" (the shortage is a quantity, the loss is an area).
Quick check
Welfare under a ceilingPrice0PePmaxQsQeQuantityBCEDS
?The diagram shows a ceiling below Pe. Area B is the rectangle between Pe and the ceiling, from 0 to Qs. C is the triangle between Qs and Qe, below demand and above Pe. E is the triangle between Qs and Qe, above supply and below Pe. Which area is the deadweight loss?
Mission 3

Case: rent control

  • In 1994, San Francisco extended rent control to small, older rental buildings.
  • Covered tenants became nearly 20% more likely to stay at their address.
  • But landlords of covered buildings cut their supply of rental housing by 15% (selling to owner-occupiers, converting to condominiums).
  • Rents across the city rose by an estimated 5.1%: new renters paid more.
  • Over time supply becomes more elastic, so the shortage grows.
  • Landlords may cut maintenance, so quality falls.
  • Tenants stay in homes that no longer suit them: housing is misallocated and workers move less.
  • Supporters point to security: tenants avoid sudden rent rises and can stay in their communities.
Mission 3

Evaluate: does a maximum price help?

It depends on…

  • Elasticity and time: inelastic demand and supply keep the shortage small in the short run. Supply becomes more elastic over the years, so the shortage grows.
  • How far below equilibrium: a small gap may protect buyers at little cost. A large gap creates queues and black markets.
  • Enforcement and rationing: who actually gets the goods, and at what price?
  • Alternatives: subsidies, income support or building more homes raise supply instead of cutting it.
Mission check

?A city caps rents below the equilibrium rent. Demand for rental homes does not change over the next ten years, yet the shortage of rental homes gets bigger. Which best explains this?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why would a government ever make something cost more?

Make a guess: A law sets the lowest price for milk above the market price. What happens to the amount of milk people buy?

Mission 4

A legal bottom price

Price floor below and above equilibriumFloor below Pe: not bindingPrice0PeQeQuantityDSPminFloor above Pe: bindingPrice0PeQeQuantityDSPmin
  • A minimum price (price floor): the lowest price that can legally be charged.
  • To have an effect it must be set above the equilibrium price (binding).
  • Why do governments use them?
  • Raise producers' incomes, especially farmers, whose prices swing with the weather.
  • Cut consumption of harmful (demerit) goods, such as cheap strong alcohol.
  • A guaranteed minimum price for farm goods: the state promises to buy any output not sold at that price.
  • The minimum wage is a floor in the labour market.
Mission 4

Why a surplus appears

Why a surplus appearsPrice0PeQdQeQssurplus (excess supply)QuantityDSPmin
  • Step 1: market clears at Pe, Qe.
  • Step 2: a floor is drawn above Pe.
  • At the higher price, quantity demanded contracts to Qd.
  • Quantity supplied extends to Qs.
  • Step 3: the gap Qs − Qd is excess supply: a surplus.
  • Without other action, only Qd is sold. Trade falls from Qe to Qd.
  • Say: "a contraction of demand" — not: "demand falls" (the demand curve has not moved).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Demand: Qd = 100 − 2P. Supply: Qs = 4P − 20 (P in $, Q in thousands). Equilibrium is $20 and 60 thousand. A minimum price of $25 is set. What is the surplus?
Mission 4

What happens to the surplus?

Government buys the surplusPrice0PeQdQeQsQuantityDSPmingovernment spending = Pmin × (Qs − Qd)
  • Left unsold: producers carry the cost of goods they cannot sell. Some sell illegally below the floor.
  • Bought by the government (a guaranteed price): taxpayers pay. The stock must be stored, destroyed, given away or sold abroad cheaply.
  • Production limits: output is capped so less surplus is made.
  • Real case: the US dairy price support programme bought dairy products that did not sell. By December 1981, more than 560 million pounds of cheese were in government warehouses. The President ordered 30 million pounds given free to people in need.
  • Pounds here are a weight (lb): 560 million lb is about 254,000 tonnes.
  • Say: "excess supply" or "surplus" — not: "oversupply means supply has shifted".
Mission 4

Worked example: a guaranteed price

  • Illustrative data: same market as an earlier screen. Floor $25, and the government buys the surplus.
  • Qd = 50, Qs = 80, surplus = 30 thousand.
  • Government spending = $25 × 30 = $750 thousand.
  • Consumers' spending: 20 × 60 = $1200 → 25 × 50 = $1250 thousand (they pay more for less).
  • Producers' revenue: $1200 → 25 × 80 = $2000 thousand.
  • Of that $2000, consumers pay 1250 and taxpayers 750.
Mission 4Graph lab

Raise the floor

Raise the floorPrice ($)Quantity (thousands)6020government buysDSprice floor
  • Takeaway: a higher floor and more elastic demand and supply mean a bigger surplus and a bigger bill.
Quick check
?Use the market in an earlier screen. The government guarantees a minimum price of $22 and buys any surplus. How much does it spend?
Mission 4

Case: minimum unit pricing for alcohol

  • Scotland set a minimum price per unit of alcohol: 50p from 2018, raised to 65p on 30 September 2024.
  • A unit is 10 ml of pure alcohol. Units = volume (litres) × % alcohol.
  • 70 cl bottle of 40% spirit: 0.7 × 40 = 28 units. Minimum price = 28 × 65p = £18.20 (it was £14.00 at 50p).
  • It mainly raises the price of cheap, strong drinks.
  • Estimates for the first years (Public Health Scotland, 2023), compared with no policy: alcohol sales down about 3%, deaths wholly caused by alcohol down 13.4%, hospital admissions down 4.1%.
  • Unlike a tax, the extra money goes to retailers and producers, not the government.
  • Debate: supporters say it targets harmful drinking; critics say it hits low-income drinkers hardest and rewards retailers.
Quick check
?Under a 65p minimum unit price, what is the lowest legal price for a 75 cl bottle of wine that is 13% alcohol?
Mission 4

Winners and losers

Welfare under a price floorPrice0PeQdQeQuantityDSPmintransfer from consumers to producersdeadweight lossFirms produce Qd.
  • Consumers lose: they pay more and buy less.
  • Producers who sell gain: the higher price on Qd (a transfer from consumers).
  • If the state buys the surplus: producers gain much more, taxpayers pay, and resources are used to make goods nobody buys at that price. Large deadweight loss.
  • If nobody buys it: producers lose on the unsold output, and a deadweight loss appears between Qd and Qe.
  • Allocative inefficiency: at Qs, the cost of the last unit is above what buyers value it at.
  • But for a demerit good with external costs, the market quantity may be too high. A floor that cuts consumption towards the social optimum can raise welfare.
Quick check
?A minimum price is set above Pe. The government does not buy any surplus, and firms produce only what they can sell (Qd). On the minimum-price diagram on the previous screen, which area moves from consumers to producers?
Mission 4

Production quotas and stabilisation

  • A production quota limits how much each producer may make. Supply cannot go past the quota, so price stays higher without a stockpile.
  • Example: the EU capped milk output with quotas from 1984 until 2015, after years of dairy surpluses.
  • Drawbacks: quotas must be shared out and policed; efficient farms cannot grow; output may still be too high or too low.
  • Price stabilisation: buying in good harvests and selling in bad ones keeps prices in a band (buffer stocks, Mission 2).
Mission 4

Evaluate: does a minimum price help?

It depends on…

  • Elasticity: inelastic demand means a small surplus and higher spending by consumers. Elastic demand and supply mean a big surplus.
  • What happens to the surplus: storage and dumping abroad cost money and can hurt farmers in other countries.
  • The aim: to support farm incomes, or cut harmful consumption? A tax raises the price too, and the money goes to the government.
  • Time: guaranteed prices encourage more output each year, so surpluses can grow.
  • Who gains: large producers sell most, so they gain most.
Mission check

?To cut smoking, a government wants to raise the retail price of cigarettes by the same amount using either a new tax per pack or a minimum price per pack. Assume both give the same retail price. What is the main difference between them?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?

Make a guess: Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?

Mission 5

Equity is not equality

Equal vs equitableequality: same shareequity: fair shareshare givenwhat the person needs
  • Equality: everyone gets the same (income, wealth or opportunity).
  • Equity: a fair distribution. What is fair is a value judgement (normative).
  • Horizontal equity: people in the same position are treated the same (same income → same tax).
  • Vertical equity: people in different positions are treated differently (higher income → pay more).
  • Say: "an equitable distribution" (fair) — not: "an equal distribution", unless you mean identical shares.
Mission 5

Why redistribute?

  • In a free market, income depends on the factors you own and what they earn: wages, rent, interest, profit.
  • Some own little: low skills, no property, unable to work. Their market income may be very low.
  • Many economists call a very unequal outcome a market failure: markets can be efficient yet produce an inequitable result.
  • Redistribution: government moves income or wealth from richer to poorer households, using:
    • taxes, transfers and benefits, state-provided services, and laws on pay.
Mission 5

Progressive, proportional, regressive

Tax ratesAverage tax rate (%)024.5%12%30,00080,000IncomeprogressiveproportionalregressiveIllustrative tax bands (marginal rates)0%20%40%30,000average 12%80,000average 24.5%Bands: 0% to 12,000; 20% to 50,000; 40%above. Illustrative data.
  • Compare the average tax rate (tax ÷ income) at different incomes:
    • Progressive: average rate rises as income rises.
    • Proportional: average rate stays the same.
    • Regressive: average rate falls as income rises.
  • Marginal tax rate: the rate on the next unit of income.
  • Illustrative data. Tax bands: 0% on the first 12,000; 20% from 12,000 to 50,000; 40% above 50,000.
    • Income 30,000: tax = 20% × 18,000 = 3,600. Average rate = 3,600 ÷ 30,000 = 12%. Marginal rate 20%.
    • Income 80,000: tax = 20% × 38,000 + 40% × 30,000 = 7,600 + 12,000 = 19,600. Average rate = 24.5%. Marginal rate 40%.
  • Average rate rises with income: progressive.
  • Taxes on spending (e.g. VAT) are usually regressive relative to income: poorer households spend a bigger share of income.
Quick check
?Using the bands in the previous screen (0% on the first 12,000; 20% from 12,000 to 50,000; 40% above 50,000), what is the average tax rate on an income of 60,000?
Mission 5

Transfers: universal or means-tested?

Universal vs means-testedBenefit received0Incomeuniversalmeans-tested
  • Transfer payments: money paid by government with nothing produced in return: pensions, unemployment and disability benefits, child benefit.
  • Universal benefit: paid to everyone in a group, whatever their income (e.g. a state pension for all over an age).
  • Means-tested benefit: paid only to those with low income or wealth (e.g. the UK's Universal Credit).
UniversalMeans-tested
CostHigh: goes to rich and poorLower: targeted at the poor
Take-upHigh: no test, no stigmaLower: complex, some feel stigma
Work incentiveNot withdrawn as earnings riseWithdrawn as earnings rise: poverty trap
Mission 5

The poverty trap

The poverty trapNet income (£)0Gross earnings (£)taper 55%EMTR 67.6%keep everythingbenefitused upOf £100 extra earnings:£28 income tax and NI£39.60 benefit withdrawn£32.40 kept
  • Poverty trap: as a low earner earns more, benefits are withdrawn and taxes start, so they keep little of the rise.
  • Effective marginal tax rate (EMTR): share of an extra unit of earnings lost to tax and benefit withdrawal.
  • Case: UK, Universal Credit. For each extra £1 of net earnings, benefit falls by 55p (the taper rate, cut from 63% in November 2021).
  • Worked example: a basic-rate taxpayer on Universal Credit earns £100 more.
    • Income tax 20% + National Insurance 8% = £28. Net earnings rise by £72.
    • Benefit withdrawn: 55% × £72 = £39.60.
    • Kept: £72 − £39.60 = £32.40.
    • EMTR = 1 − 0.72 × 0.45 = 67.6%.
  • Say: combine the rates by multiplying what is kept (0.72 × 0.45) — not: by adding them (28% + 55% = 83%), since the taper applies to net earnings.
Mission 5Graph lab

Change the taper

The poverty trapNet income (£)0Gross earnings (£)taper 55%EMTR 67.6%keep everythingbenefitused upOf £100 extra earnings:£28 income tax and NI£39.60 benefit withdrawn£32.40 kept

Line: net income (after tax and benefits) against gross earnings. Flat line = nothing kept; 45° line = everything kept.

Change the taperNet income (£)Extra gross earnings a month (£)01,0002,0003,00006001,2001,8002,400flat: nothing kept45°: everything keptnet incomebenefit runs out
  • Takeaway: a higher taper flattens the line (stronger trap) but ends benefit sooner (cheaper). A lower taper helps work incentives but stretches benefit to higher earners.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A worker pays income tax at 20% on extra earnings. A means-tested benefit is withdrawn at 60% of each extra unit of net (after-tax) earnings. What is the worker's effective marginal tax rate?
Mission check

?A government wants to weaken the poverty trap for low-income working families on a means-tested benefit. Which change would do this most directly?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Can a tax take more money from richer people and still hit poorer people harder?

Make a guess: Can a tax take more money from richer people and still hit poorer people harder?

Mission 6

Direct and indirect taxes

Types of taxTaxesDirect (income,wealth)Indirect (spending)incomeprofitswealthgoodsfueltariff
  • Direct tax: a tax on income or wealth, paid straight to the government by the person or firm it is levied on.
    • Income tax, corporation tax (on company profits), taxes on wealth.
  • UK direct taxes also include National Insurance contributions, capital gains tax and inheritance tax.
  • Indirect tax: a tax on spending on goods and services. The seller pays it to the government, but can pass some or all of it on to buyers in higher prices.
    • VAT (a sales tax), excise duties on fuel, alcohol and tobacco, tariffs on imports.
  • How much of an indirect tax buyers bear depends on elasticity.
  • Say: "VAT is an indirect tax" — not: "VAT is a direct tax because shoppers pay it directly at the till".
Mission 6

Why tax, and what makes a good tax

  • Reasons to tax:
    • raise revenue for public spending
    • redistribute income and wealth
    • correct market failure (taxes on pollution, tobacco)
    • manage aggregate demand (fiscal policy)
  • Adam Smith's canons of a good tax (1776):
    • equity: in line with ability to pay
    • certainty: clear what, when and how much
    • convenience: easy to pay
    • economy: cheap to collect
  • Modern additions: efficiency (few distortions to choices) and flexibility (easy to change).
Quick check
?Which of these is an indirect tax?
Mission 6

Progressive, proportional, regressive

Three kinds of taxAverage tax rate (%)0IncomeProgressiveProportionalRegressiveIllustrative
  • Judge a tax by the share of income it takes, not the amount.
  • Progressive: the share of income paid in tax rises as income rises.
  • Proportional: the share stays the same at every income.
  • Regressive: the share falls as income rises.
  • A regressive tax can still take more money from richer people.
  • Progressive taxes plus benefits for low-income households narrow the gap in incomes (redistribution).
  • Say: "a regressive tax takes a larger proportion of a low income" — not: "poor people pay more money".
Mission 6

Average and marginal tax rates

  • Average tax rate (ART) = total tax ÷ total income × 100.
  • Marginal tax rate (MRT) = change in tax ÷ change in income × 100: the tax on the next unit of income.
  • Progressive: MRT > ART, so ART rises with income.
  • Proportional: MRT = ART.
  • Regressive: ART falls as income rises.
  • Moving into a higher band raises the rate only on income inside that band.
Mission 6

Worked example: income tax bands

Income bandsIllustrative data: income of 60,0000–10,000: 0%tax 010,000–40,000: 20%tax 6,00040,000–60,000: 40%tax 8,000010,00040,00060,000next 1,000: tax 400Total tax 14,000. ART 23.3%. MRT 40%.
  • Illustrative data.
Income bandTax rate
0 – 10,0000% (allowance)
10,001 – 40,00020%
Above 40,00040%
  • Income 60,000:
    • first 10,000: 0
    • next 30,000 × 20% = 6,000
    • last 20,000 × 40% = 8,000
    • total tax = 14,000
  • ART = 14,000 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 23.3%.
  • Earn 1,000 more: tax rises by 400. MRT = 400 ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 40%.
  • Income 30,000: tax 4,000, ART 13.3%, MRT 20%.
  • ART rises from 13.3% to 23.3% as income rises: progressive.
Quick check
?Use the tax bands from the worked example (illustrative data). A worker earns 50,000. What are their average and marginal tax rates?
Mission 6

Are taxes on spending regressive?

  • Illustrative data. Prices include a 20% sales tax (VAT), so tax = spending × 20 ÷ 120.
HouseholdIncomeSpendingTax paidTax as % of income
A20,00018,0003,00015.0%
B100,00050,0008,3338.3%
  • B pays more money in tax.
  • A pays a larger share of income: lower-income households spend a bigger fraction of their income.
  • Relative to income, the tax is regressive.
  • Real UK data show the same pattern: in the financial year ending 2022, indirect taxes took 28.1% of the disposable income of the poorest fifth of people and 9.8% for the richest fifth (ONS).
  • Zero rates on most food and children's clothes in UK VAT reduce, but do not remove, the effect.
Mission 6

Flat taxes

  • A flat tax: one rate on all income above a tax-free allowance.
  • Illustrative data: 20% on income above 12,000.
IncomeTaxART
15,0006004.0%
30,0003,60012.0%
100,00017,60017.6%
  • MRT is 20% for everyone above the allowance, yet ART rises with income.
  • With an allowance, a flat tax is mildly progressive. With no allowance, it is proportional.
  • Real case: Estonia introduced a flat income tax in 1994; several central and eastern European countries followed.
  • Supporters: simple, cheap to collect, keeps the reward for earning more. Critics: less redistribution than several rising bands.
Mission 6

The Laffer curve

Laffer curveTax revenue0t*100Tax rate (%)ABIllustrativeIllustrative. t* = revenue-maximising rate.Illustrative. From B, a rate cut raises revenue.
  • Tax revenue = tax rate × tax base (the income or spending being taxed).
  • At a 0% rate, revenue is zero. At 100%, there is little point earning declared income, so revenue is close to zero.
  • In between, revenue reaches a maximum at some rate, t*.
  • Below t*: a higher rate raises revenue.
  • Above t*: the tax base shrinks so much that a higher rate lowers revenue. A cut could raise revenue.
  • The base shrinks through less work and investment, more avoidance and evasion, and people or firms moving abroad.
  • Nobody knows exactly where t* is. Estimates differ, and most economists think most tax rates are below it.
  • Real case: in 2012 HMRC estimated that cutting the UK top income tax rate from 50% to 45% would cost only about £100 million a year, because high earners respond strongly to the top rate. HMRC stressed the estimate was very uncertain.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a tax rate is currently 70%, and the revenue-maximising rate is 55%. The government cuts the rate to 60%. According to the Laffer curve, what happens to tax revenue?
Mission 6Evaluate

Should a country make its taxes more progressive?

It depends on:

  • How people respond: if high earners cut work, move or avoid tax, revenue may rise less than planned.
  • Value judgements about equity: how much inequality is acceptable is a normative question.
  • Which taxes change: raising income tax rates at the top differs from cutting regressive taxes on spending.
  • Administration: complex systems cost more to run and leave more room for avoidance.
Mission check

?A local council charges every adult the same fixed amount each year, whatever their income. How is this tax best described?
Mission 7

Mission 7: When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?

Make a guess: Why might a policy meant to fix a market leave it worse off?

Mission 7

When the cure is worse

  • Markets can fail (earlier missions). Governments step in with taxes, subsidies, rules and provision.
  • But intervention can also go wrong.
  • Government failure: intervention that causes a net welfare loss compared with leaving the market alone. Resources end up misallocated.
  • A policy that has costs, or does not fix the problem fully, is not automatically a failure.
  • The test: is society better or worse off overall than with no intervention?
  • Say: "government failure = intervention leads to a net welfare loss" — not: "any policy that costs money".
Mission 7

Inadequate information

Tax set too highCosts and benefits0Q taxQ*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMPC + taxtaxwelfare loss (overproduction)new welfare loss (underproduction)old welfare loss
  • To set a Pigouvian tax, the government needs the MEC. It rarely knows it.
  • Also called information gaps.
  • Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; true MEC = 20.
  • No tax: Qm = 40; welfare loss = 100.
  • The government overestimates the harm and sets a tax of 50.
  • New supply: 70 + Q. 100 − Q = 70 + Q, so Q = 15. Q* is 30.
  • Now underproduction. At Q = 15: MSB = 85, MSC = 55, a gap of 30.
  • New welfare loss = ½ × (30 − 15) × 30 = 225.
  • 225 > 100: society is worse off than with no tax. Government failure.
Mission 7Graph lab

How wrong can the tax be?

Illustrative data: as the previous screen. MEC = 20; the market alone gives a welfare loss of 100.

How wrong can the tax be?Price, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSCno-tax loss 100100Welfare losswith this tax
  • Takeaway: a tax a little wrong still helps. A tax far too high can do more harm than the externality.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 60 − Q; MPC = Q. The MEC is 10 at every output, so the market output is 30, the social optimum is 25 and the welfare loss with no tax is 25. The government sets a tax of 30 per unit. What is the new welfare loss, and is this government failure?
Mission 7

Distortions of price signals

Guaranteed price creates a surplusPrice0PminPeQdQeQssurplus: bought into storeQuantityDScost to taxpayers = Pmin × (Qs − Qd)
  • Prices tell producers what to make and consumers what to buy.
  • Taxes, subsidies and price controls change prices. Set badly, they send the wrong signals.
  • Also called price distortion or market distortion.
  • Real world: the European Community's farm policy (CAP) guaranteed farmers high prices and bought up what did not sell.
    • Farmers produced more than consumers wanted.
    • Surpluses filled stores: "butter mountains" and "wine lakes", paid for by taxpayers.
    • From 1984, milk quotas were brought in to limit dairy output.
  • One intervention led to another to fix its side-effects.
Mission 7

Unintended consequences

  • People and firms respond to a policy, sometimes in ways nobody planned.
  • Real world: Mexico City, 1989, "Hoy No Circula" (No Driving Today).
    • Most cars banned from driving one weekday a week, by the last digit of the number plate.
    • Aim: cleaner air.
    • A 2008 study found no evidence that air quality improved.
    • Many households bought an extra car, often an older, more polluting one, to drive on their banned day.
  • Other examples: high taxes on cigarettes can encourage smuggling; rent controls can shrink the supply of rented homes.
Mission 7

Administrative costs

  • Every policy must be designed, run, monitored and enforced.
  • These administrative costs use scarce resources: staff, inspections, IT, legal cases.
  • Firms bear compliance costs too: paperwork, reporting, meeting standards.
  • Illustrative data: a tax on a pollutant removes a welfare loss of 100 a year.
    • Collecting the tax and checking emissions costs 120 a year.
    • Net effect: 100 − 120 = −20. Society is worse off: government failure.
  • Costs can exceed gains when the externality is small, or polluters are many and small.
Mission 7

Conflicting objectives

  • Governments pursue many goals at once: cleaner air, low prices, jobs, tax revenue, re-election.
  • A policy that serves one goal can harm another, so it may be set at the wrong level, or dropped.
  • Real world: the UK planned yearly inflation-linked rises in fuel duty. They were cancelled every year from 2011 to 2025, and duty was cut by 5p a litre in 2022, after fuel prices jumped.
  • Tobacco taxes aim to cut smoking, yet they also raise revenue that depends on people still smoking.
  • Say: "conflicting objectives" — not: "the government did not care". Both goals may be valid.
Mission 7

Capture and political incentives

  • Regulatory capture: a regulator comes to serve the industry it regulates, not the public.
    • Close contacts; staff moving between regulator and industry; lobbying.
  • Asymmetric information in regulation: the firm knows its true costs and harm; the regulator does not. Firms can overstate the cost of meeting rules.
  • Political incentives: politicians face elections. They may favour quick, visible gains over long-term benefits (short-termism), or respond to strong lobby groups.
  • These are why some economists argue that intervention should be limited to clear, large market failures; others argue for better-designed institutions instead.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a city charges households for rubbish by weight. Households respond as planned and throw away less, a gain to society worth 2 million a year. Weighing every bin, sending bills and chasing unpaid ones costs 3 million a year. Which cause of government failure does this show?
Mission 7Evaluate

Market failure or government failure?

It depends on:

  • The size of the market failure. A large externality can justify intervention even if the policy is imperfect.
  • Information. Where the MEC can be measured, policy can be set closer to the optimum.
  • Flexibility. A tax can be adjusted as evidence comes in; a large project or a ban is harder to undo.
  • Effectiveness. Does the policy change behaviour? Inelastic demand can make a tax raise revenue but cut little harm.
  • Consequences for stakeholders. Who gains and who loses: consumers, producers, workers, taxpayers, the government, third parties.
  • Government failure is a reason to design policy carefully, not proof that intervention never works.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a market for private bus services gives too few journeys. The welfare loss is 300 a year. The government brings in a subsidy. Afterwards, the welfare loss is 80 a year and the subsidy scheme costs 150 a year to run. Has government failure occurred?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Income is a flow; wealth is a stock. Wealth is usually distributed more unequally than income.
  • The Lorenz curve shows cumulative shares; the further it sags from the line of equality, the higher the Gini coefficient (0 = perfect equality, 1 = perfect inequality).
  • Causes include human capital, wealth ownership, discrimination, power, tax and benefits, and technology.

Mission 2

  • Primary commodity prices are volatile: supply shifts often, and both PED and PES are low.
  • With inelastic demand, a bigger harvest can mean lower revenue.
  • A buffer stock buys at the floor in good years and sells at the ceiling in bad years; it fails if the band is set above the long-run price or funds run out.

Mission 3

  • A binding maximum price sits below equilibrium. Quantity demanded extends, quantity supplied contracts: a shortage.
  • Non-price rationing and black markets follow. Producers lose, some consumers gain, and a deadweight loss appears.

Mission 4

  • A binding minimum price sits above equilibrium. Quantity demanded contracts, quantity supplied extends: a surplus.
  • Someone pays for the surplus: producers (unsold goods) or taxpayers (guaranteed prices).
  • Consumers pay more; sellers keep the higher price.

Mission 5

  • Equity is fairness, a value judgement; equality means identical shares.
  • Progressive taxes: the average tax rate rises with income.
  • Means-tested benefits target the poor but create a poverty trap: a high effective marginal tax rate.

Mission 6

  • Direct taxes fall on income and wealth. Indirect taxes fall on spending.
  • Progressive, proportional or regressive: judged by the share of income paid (ART), not the amount.
  • ART = total tax ÷ income. MRT = tax on the next unit of income.
  • Laffer curve: above the revenue-maximising rate, a lower rate can raise revenue.

Mission 7

  • Government failure: intervention that causes a net welfare loss compared with the market outcome.
  • Causes: inadequate information, price distortion, unintended consequences, administrative costs, conflicting objectives, regulatory capture and political incentives.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Market failure (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?
  2. Mission 2Why can a huge harvest leave farmers with less money than a small one?
  3. Mission 3What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?
  4. Mission 4Why would a government ever make something cost more?
  5. Mission 5Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?
  6. Mission 6Can a tax take more money from richer people and still hit poorer people harder?
  7. Mission 7When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · Eduqas