← A-Level Economics · Eduqas A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
WJEC Eduqas A-level Economics (A520) · Demand and supply in product markets (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Demand and supply in product markets (part 2)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why do some buyers barely react when a price jumps, while others switch away at once?
  2. Mission 2When a seller charges more, why does the money coming in sometimes go up and sometimes go down?
  3. Mission 3When people get richer, why do they buy less of some things?
  4. Mission 4When prices jump, why can some producers flood the market while others cannot grow more for years?
  5. Mission 5When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?
  6. Mission 6When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why do some buyers barely react when a price jumps, while others switch away at once?

Make a guess: Why do some buyers barely react when a price jumps, while others switch away at once?

Mission 1

Measuring how strongly buyers react

  • A price rises 10%. Do buyers cut back by 1%? Or by 30%?
  • Price elasticity of demand (PED) measures how responsive quantity demanded is to a change in the good's own price.
  • PED = %ΔQd ÷ %ΔP
  • Percentages, not units, so we can compare goods measured in litres, tickets or tonnes.
  • Price and quantity demanded move in opposite directions, so PED is negative.
  • Your course quotes PED with its minus sign (e.g. −0.4). Judge "elastic" or "inelastic" by its size, ignoring the sign.
Mission 1

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. A café raises the price of a coffee from £2.50 to £3.00. Sales fall from 400 to 340 cups a day.
  • %ΔP = (3.00 − 2.50) ÷ 2.50 × 100 = +20%
  • %ΔQd = (340 − 400) ÷ 400 × 100 = −15%
  • PED = −15 ÷ 20 = −0.75. Size below 1: demand is price inelastic.
  • Use PED to predict: a further 8% rise → %ΔQd = −0.75 × 8 = −6%.
  • Or work back: to cut sales by 9%, %ΔP = −9 ÷ −0.75 = +12%.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A shop cuts the price of a phone case from £8 to £6. Weekly sales rise from 200 to 300. What is the PED, and what does it show?
Mission 1

Five values of PED

Five PED curvesperfectly inelasticPED = 0PriceQuantityDrelatively inelasticsize of PED below 1PricePeQeQuantityDunitaryPED = −1PriceQuantityDtwo equal P × Q areasrelatively elasticsize of PED above 1PricePeQeQuantityDperfectly elasticPED = ∞PriceQuantityD
NamePED (size, ignoring sign)MeaningDemand curve
Perfectly inelastic0Quantity does not change at allVertical
Relatively inelasticbetween 0 and 1%ΔQd smaller than %ΔPSteeper, through a given point
Unitary (unit) elastic1%ΔQd equal to %ΔPRectangular hyperbola (a curve)
Relatively elasticbetween 1 and infinity%ΔQd bigger than %ΔPFlatter, through a given point
Perfectly elasticinfinityAny price rise loses all buyersHorizontal
  • Two demand curves through the same point: the flatter one is more elastic at that point.
  • A unitary elastic curve is not a straight line: PED is 1 all along it.
  • Say: "demand is relatively inelastic" — not: "demand doesn't change when price changes" (that is only perfectly inelastic).
Mission 1Graph lab

Shape the demand curve

Illustrative data. PED is −0.5 along the whole curve. Price rises by 10%.

Shape the demand curvePriceQuantity10010D
  • Takeaway: PED tells you the % change in quantity for each 1% change in price.
Mission 1

Slope is not elasticity

Linear demand, changing PEDPrice0elasticinelasticQuantityΔP = 1ΔQ = 1ΔP = 1ΔQ = 1DPED = −4PED = −1PED = −0.25Illustrative data: P = 10 − Q
  • Illustrative data. Straight-line demand: P = 10 − Q. Every 1 off the price adds 1 to quantity. The slope never changes.
  • Price 8 → 7 (−12.5%): Q 2 → 3 (+50%). PED = −4. Elastic.
  • Price 3 → 2 (−33.3%): Q 7 → 8 (+14.3%). PED = −0.43. Inelastic.
  • Same 1-unit changes, very different percentages.
  • Point PED = (ΔQ ÷ ΔP) × (P ÷ Q). At P = 5, Q = 5: PED = −1 × 5 ÷ 5 = −1.
  • Upper half: elastic. Midpoint: unitary. Lower half: inelastic.
  • Say: "demand is relatively inelastic over this price range" — not: "the curve is steep, so demand is inelastic".
Mission 1Graph lab

Slide down the line

Illustrative data: P = 10 − Q, as on the previous screen.

Slide down the linePriceQuantity0510051028D: P = 10 − Q
  • Takeaway: on a straight-line demand curve PED falls in size as price falls: elastic, then unitary at the midpoint, then inelastic.
Quick check
Straight-line demand with points X and YPrice0201552.57.510QuantityXYDIllustrative data
?Illustrative data. A straight-line demand curve meets the price axis at 20 and the quantity axis at 10. Point X is at a price of 15 (quantity 2.5). Point Y is at a price of 5 (quantity 7.5). What is the PED at each point?
Mission 1

What makes demand elastic or inelastic?

  • Substitutes: more and closer substitutes → more elastic. Buyers can switch.
  • Necessity or luxury: necessities and habit-forming goods → less elastic.
  • Share of income: a small share of the budget (salt, matches) → less elastic.
  • Time: buyers find substitutes over time, so demand is more elastic in the long run.
  • How widely the market is defined: one brand of bread has many substitutes; "food" has none. Narrow → more elastic.
  • Say: "demand for petrol is price inelastic" — not: "petrol is inelastic".
Mission 1

Real evidence: US gasoline

  • Real data (Hughes, Knittel and Sperling, 2008). Short-run PED for gasoline (petrol) in the US:
  • 1975–1980: −0.21 to −0.34
  • 2001–2006: −0.034 to −0.077
  • In 2001–2006, a 10% price rise cut gasoline use by less than 1% in the short run.
  • Both periods: inelastic. But demand became less elastic.
  • Think: which determinants on the previous screen might explain it? (How easy is it to switch away from driving? How big a share of income is fuel?)
  • Long run: buyers can change cars, homes and jobs, so demand is more elastic than in the short run.
Quick check
?Which of these is likely to have the most price elastic demand?
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A city raises the price of tap water from 2.00 to 2.20 per cubic metre. Average household use falls from 150 to 147 litres a day. Which statement is correct?
Mission 2

Mission 2: When a seller charges more, why does the money coming in sometimes go up and sometimes go down?

Make a guess: When a seller charges more, why does the money coming in sometimes go up and sometimes go down?

Mission 2

Revenue is the buyers' spending

Total revenue is a rectanglePrice (£)041,000Quantity (tickets per day)TRDTR = total expenditure = P × Q= £4 × 1,000 = £4,000Illustrative data
  • Total revenue (TR) = price × quantity sold.
  • What sellers receive, buyers spend: TR = total expenditure.
  • On a demand curve, TR is the rectangle under the chosen point: height P, width Q.
  • Example (illustrative data): 1,000 tickets at £4 → TR = £4,000.
Mission 2

Two effects pull in opposite directions

  • Raise the price and two things happen:
  • Price effect: each unit still sold earns more → TR up.
  • Quantity effect: fewer units are sold → TR down.
  • Which effect is bigger? Compare the percentage changes.
  • That comparison is exactly what PED measures.
Mission 2

The revenue rule

The revenue rulePriceTRResultDemandElasticoppositedirectionsUnitaryTRunchangedInelasticsamedirectionA price rise is shown. If price falls, both arrowsreverse (TR unchanged stays unchanged).
DemandPED (absolute value)Price risesPrice falls
Price elasticgreater than 1TR fallsTR rises
Unitary (unit) elasticequal to 1TR unchangedTR unchanged
Price inelasticless than 1TR risesTR falls
  • Inelastic: price and TR move the same way.
  • Elastic: price and TR move opposite ways.
  • PED is negative (e.g. −0.4). Judge elastic or inelastic by its size, ignoring the sign.
  • Say: "demand is price inelastic, so a price rise increases total revenue" — not: "a price rise always increases revenue".
Mission 2

Worked example: from PED to revenue

  • Illustrative data. A bus company sells 1,000 tickets a day at £4. PED = −0.4.
  • It raises the fare to £5.
  • %ΔP = (5 − 4) ÷ 4 × 100 = +25%.
  • %ΔQd = PED × %ΔP = −0.4 × 25 = −10% → 1,000 → 900 tickets.
  • TR before: £4 × 1,000 = £4,000. TR after: £5 × 900 = £4,500.
  • TR rises by £500 (+12.5%). Demand is inelastic, so price and TR move the same way.
  • Check: if PED were −2, Qd would fall 50% to 500, and TR would fall to £2,500.
Quick check
?A firm sells 2,000 units a week at £10. Its PED is −1.5. It raises the price to £11. What happens to its total revenue?
Mission 2

Revenue diagrams: gain and loss areas

Gain and loss areas after a price riseRelatively inelastic demandPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityTRDgain £900 > loss £400: TR upRelatively elastic demandPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityTRDloss > gain: TR downTR = P1 × Q1old TR = P1 × Q1gain = (P2 − P1) × Q2loss = P1 × (Q1 − Q2)Illustrative data
  • Price rises from P1 to P2. Compare two rectangles:
  • Gain: (P2 − P1) × Q2, the extra paid on units still sold.
  • Loss: P1 × (Q1 − Q2), revenue on the units no longer sold.
  • Inelastic demand (steep over this range): small fall in Q → gain > loss → TR rises.
  • Elastic demand (flat over this range): big fall in Q → loss > gain → TR falls.
  • From an earlier screen (illustrative data): gain £1 × 900 = £900; loss £4 × 100 = £400; TR up £500.
  • Say: "demand is relatively inelastic over this price range" — steepness alone is not elasticity.
Mission 2Graph lab

Find the tipping point

Find the tipping pointPriceQuantity1,0004D4,000TR before
  • Takeaway: TR rises with price while |PED| < 1, stays the same at 1, and falls once |PED| > 1.
Mission 2

Along a straight-line demand curve

Elasticity and total revenue along a straight-line demand curvePrice0852258QuantityinelasticDelasticunit elasticPED = −1Total revenue02516258QuantityTRmaximumIllustrative data: P = 10 − Q
  • On a straight-line demand curve, PED changes along the line (from Mission 1).
  • Top half: elastic. Cutting price raises TR.
  • Bottom half: inelastic. Cutting price lowers TR.
  • Midpoint: unit elastic. TR is at its maximum.
  • Illustrative data, P = 10 − Q: TR = 16 at P = 8, 25 at P = 5, 16 at P = 2.
Quick check
A straight-line demand curve with intercepts of 12Price0128412QuantityDIllustrative data
?A straight-line demand curve meets the price axis at 12 and the quantity axis at 12 (illustrative data). The firm charges a price of 8 and sells 4 units. It is thinking of cutting the price to 6. Which statement is correct?
Mission 2

Why firms care

  • Inelastic demand (few close substitutes, a necessity, brand loyalty): a price rise raises TR.
  • Elastic demand (many substitutes): price cuts and discounts can raise TR.
  • Firms try to make demand less elastic: branding, advertising, loyalty schemes.
  • Firms with several groups of buyers charge more where demand is inelastic (e.g. peak travel) and less where it is elastic (e.g. student tickets).
  • Revenue is not profit. Selling fewer units also cuts total costs, so with inelastic demand a price rise usually raises profit too.
  • Say: "total revenue" — not: "profit", when you apply the revenue rule.
Mission 2

Why governments care

  • Indirect taxes raise most revenue on goods with inelastic demand: the quantity bought falls little, so the tax base stays large.
  • Examples: tobacco, alcohol, fuel.
  • Real data: the average PED for tobacco products in high-income countries is about −0.4 (IARC, 2011). So a 10% price rise cuts consumption by about 4%.
  • So a tax on an inelastic good raises revenue but cuts consumption only a little.
  • For a given supply curve, the more inelastic demand is, the larger the share of the tax consumers bear.
  • Subsidies raise consumption most where demand is elastic (e.g. cheaper public transport fares win more passengers).
Quick check
?A government wants a new indirect tax on a product to do two things: raise a large amount of tax revenue and cut consumption sharply. Demand for the product has a PED of −0.3. What should its advisers conclude?
Mission 2Evaluate

How useful is PED for decisions?

It depends on …

  • Accuracy of the estimate: PED comes from past data, assuming other things stay the same. Incomes, tastes and rivals' prices change.
  • Time: demand is usually more elastic in the long run, as buyers find substitutes. A tax that raises revenue now may raise less later.
  • Size of the change and where on the curve: PED differs along a demand curve. A small-change estimate may not hold for a big price rise.
  • Firm vs market: one firm's demand is more price elastic than the whole market's if rivals do not follow its price rise.
  • Unintended consequences: high taxes on inelastic goods can encourage smuggling and illegal markets.
  • Judge: PED is a useful guide to the direction of the revenue change. Firms and governments should treat its exact size with caution.
Mission check

?A city bus company cuts all its fares by 20%. The number of journeys taken each week rises by 10%. What happens to fare revenue, and what does this show?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When people get richer, why do they buy less of some things?

Make a guess: When people get richer, why do they buy less of some things?

Mission 3

Elasticity for any cause of demand

  • PED measures how quantity demanded responds to a good's own price.
  • The same idea works for any determinant of demand.
  • Income elasticity of demand (YED) = % change in quantity demanded ÷ % change in income.
  • Cross elasticity of demand (XED) = % change in quantity demanded of good A ÷ % change in the price of good B.
  • A change in a determinant other than the good's own price shifts the demand curve.
Mission 3

Normal and inferior goods

Income shifts demandNormal goodPriceQuantityD1D2Inferior goodPriceQuantityD1D2Income risesIncome rises
  • The sign of YED tells you the type of good.
  • YED > 0: normal good. Income rises → demand rises (shifts right). E.g. clothes, holidays, eating out.
  • YED < 0: inferior good. Income rises → demand falls (shifts left). E.g. supermarket value ranges, instant noodles.
  • Why? With more income, people switch to alternatives they prefer.
  • The same good can be normal for one group and inferior for another.
  • Say: "inferior" means demand falls as income rises — not: poor quality.
Mission 3Graph lab

Income rises

Average incomes rise 10%. Demand for a value-range pasta has a YED of −0.5.

Income risesNormal good: YED +1.2PriceQuantityQePeDSValue-range pasta: YED −0.5PriceQuantityQePeDS
  • Takeaway: a rise in income shifts demand for a normal good right and for an inferior good left.
Mission 3

Necessities and luxuries

  • The size of YED shows how strongly demand responds.
  • 0 < YED < 1: income inelastic. A necessity: demand rises, but by a smaller % than income. E.g. bread, electricity.
  • YED > 1: income elastic. A luxury: demand rises by a bigger % than income. E.g. foreign holidays, restaurant meals.
  • Necessities and luxuries are both normal goods.
  • Say: "income inelastic" — not: "inferior". YED of 0.3 is a normal good.
Mission 3

Worked example: calculating YED

  • Illustrative data: weekly household income rises from 500 to 520.
  • Instant noodles bought each week fall from 20 packs to 18.
  • % change in income = (520 − 500) ÷ 500 × 100 = +4%.
  • % change in quantity demanded = (18 − 20) ÷ 20 × 100 = −10%.
  • YED = −10 ÷ +4 = −2.5.
  • Negative: an inferior good. Strongly responsive (size 2.5).
  • Second good: income +4%, restaurant meals +10%. YED = 10 ÷ 4 = +2.5: a luxury.
  • Always put quantity on top.
Quick check
?Average incomes rise by 5%. Other things equal, quantity demanded of good X rises by 2%. Which is correct?
Mission 3

Cross elasticity: related goods

XED number lineXED < 0complementsXED = 0unrelatedXED > 0substitutes0stronger linkstronger link
  • XED = % change in Qd of good A ÷ % change in price of good B.
  • XED > 0: substitutes. Price of coffee rises → demand for tea rises.
  • XED < 0: complements. Price of games consoles falls → demand for games rises.
  • XED = 0 (or close): unrelated. E.g. pens and bus fares.
  • Size shows how close the link is: +3 means close substitutes; +0.2 means weak substitutes.
  • Say: "a rise in the price of B shifts the demand curve for A" — not: "a movement along A's demand curve".
Mission 3Graph lab

A related good's price changes

The price of games consoles falls by 20%.

A related good's price changesConsole games: XED −1.5PriceQuantityQePeDSRival console B: XED +0.8PriceQuantityQePeDS
  • Takeaway: a change in a related good's price shifts demand. Complements move the opposite way to the price; substitutes move the same way.
Mission 3

Worked example: calculating XED

  • Illustrative data.
  • Price of coffee rises 10%. Quantity of tea demanded rises 5%.
  • XED = +5 ÷ +10 = +0.5. Positive: substitutes (weak ones).
  • Price of consoles falls 20%. Quantity of games demanded rises 30%.
  • XED = +30 ÷ −20 = −1.5. Negative: complements (strong ones).
  • Signs matter: write the % change in price with its sign.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: the price of butter rises from 2.00 to 2.40 a pack. Weekly sales of margarine rise from 50,000 packs to 56,000. What is the cross elasticity of demand for margarine with respect to the price of butter?
Mission 3

What makes the values large or small?

  • YED:
    • Necessity or luxury? Essentials have low YED.
    • Income level: a car may be a luxury in a low-income country and a necessity in a rich one.
    • Better alternatives: if a preferred option exists, the good may be inferior.
  • XED: how close are the goods in use? Close substitutes or tight complements give large values.
  • XED: brand loyalty weakens the link between substitutes.
  • Time: responses grow larger as buyers have longer to adjust their habits.
Mission 3

Why these numbers matter

  • Firms use YED to forecast sales as incomes grow or fall.
    • Luxury sellers expect big swings over the economic cycle; necessity sellers are steadier.
    • In a recession, sales of inferior goods may rise: shops push their value ranges.
    • A mix of high- and low-YED products spreads the risk.
  • Firms use XED to predict the effect of a rival's price cut (substitutes) and to price complements: cheap printer, dear ink.
  • Governments: YED helps forecast tax revenue as incomes grow. XED shows how a tax on one good shifts demand to its substitutes.
Mission 3Evaluate

How far can firms rely on elasticity estimates?

  • It depends on how the estimate was made: values come from past data; tastes and incomes change.
  • It depends on other things being equal: in reality prices, incomes and tastes change together.
  • It depends on the size of the change: values are reliable only for small changes.
  • It depends on who the buyers are: the same good has different YED for poorer and richer households.
  • Time lags: buyers take time to switch, so short-run values understate the long-run effect.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a retailer estimates these YED values. A recession is expected to cut average real incomes. Other things equal, which product's quantity demanded is expected to fall by the largest percentage?
ProductYED
Bread+0.2
Own-brand value range−0.3
Clothing+0.9
Foreign holidays+1.8
Mission check

?Illustrative data: in a recession, average incomes fall by 10%. A discount supermarket estimates the YED for its value range is −0.5. Other things equal, what happens to quantity demanded of the value range?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When prices jump, why can some producers flood the market while others cannot grow more for years?

Make a guess: When prices jump, why can some producers flood the market while others cannot grow more for years?

Mission 4

What PES measures

PES on a supply curvePrice (£)0P2P1Q1Q2QuantitySA price rise: quantity supplied moves along S
  • Price elasticity of supply (PES): how strongly quantity supplied responds to a change in price.
  • PES = %ΔQs ÷ %ΔP
  • Price up → quantity supplied up. So PES is normally positive.
  • A bigger number = a stronger response.
  • Say: "a rise in price causes an extension of supply" — not: "supply increases" (that is a shift).
Mission 4

Reading the number

Constant-PES supply curvesperfectly inelasticPES = 0PriceQuantitySperfectly elasticPES = ∞PriceQuantitySunitaryPES = 1PriceQuantityS
PESNameSupply curve
0Perfectly inelasticVertical
between 0 and 1InelasticQs changes by a smaller % than price
1Unitary (unit) elasticQs changes by the same % as price
greater than 1ElasticQs changes by a bigger % than price
infinitePerfectly elasticHorizontal
  • The dividing line is 1.
Mission 4

Straight-line supply curves

Straight-line supply curves and PESPrice0QuantityS1 (PES > 1)S2 (PES = 1)S3 (PES < 1)
  • A straight supply line through the origin: PES = 1 at every point, whatever its slope.
  • A straight line that starts on the price axis: PES > 1 (elastic) all along it.
  • A straight line that starts on the quantity axis: PES < 1 (inelastic) all along it.
  • So slope alone does not tell you PES. Check where the line meets the axes.
  • Say: "relatively elastic supply" for a line cutting the price axis — not: "elastic because it is flat".
Quick check
Straight-line supply curves and PESPrice0QuantityS1S2S3
?Three straight-line supply curves are drawn on one diagram (illustrative). S1 starts on the price axis above the origin. S2 passes through the origin and is the steepest of the three. S3 starts on the quantity axis to the right of the origin. Which statement is correct?
Mission 4

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. A furniture maker supplies 400 tables a month at a price of £20.
  • The price rises to £25. Quantity supplied rises to 450.
  • %ΔQs = (450 − 400) ÷ 400 × 100 = +12.5%.
  • %ΔP = (25 − 20) ÷ 20 × 100 = +25%.
  • PES = 12.5 ÷ 25 = 0.5 → inelastic.
  • Working backwards (illustrative data): PES = 1.6 and price rises 5% → %ΔQs = 1.6 × 5 = +8%.
Quick check
?A firm supplies 1,200 units a week. The market price rises by 8%, and the firm's PES is 2.5. How many units a week will it now supply?
Mission 4

What makes supply elastic?

  • Time: the longer firms have to respond, the more elastic supply is.
  • Spare capacity: idle machines and staff → output can rise fast.
  • Stocks and storage: goods held in stock, or that can be stored, can be released quickly.
  • Mobility of factors: workers, machines and land that can switch from other uses → more elastic.
Mission 4

Short run vs long run

Short-run and long-run supplyPrice (£)0P1P2PeQeQ1Q2QuantityD1D1S (SR)S (LR)D2
  • Momentary (very short) run: output is fixed. Supply is vertical (PES = 0). E.g. fish already landed today.
  • Short run: firms use spare capacity, overtime and stocks. Supply is inelastic.
  • Long run: firms build capacity, and new firms enter. Supply becomes more elastic.
  • The same rise in demand → in the short run mostly a price rise; in the long run more of a quantity rise.
Mission 4Graph lab

Same demand rise, different supply

Same demand rise, different supplyPriceQuantityQePeD1S0.0%% changein price0.0%% changein quantity
  • Takeaway: the less elastic supply is, the more a rise in demand shows up as a higher price rather than more output.
Quick check
?Demand rises sharply for each of the following. Which producer is likely to have the most price-elastic supply over the next month?
Mission 4

Real world: cocoa, 2024

  • Cocoa beans come mainly from West Africa.
  • Poor West African harvests in the 2023–24 season cut supply.
  • In March 2024, cocoa futures in New York passed $10,000 a metric ton for the first time. Prices had roughly doubled since January.
  • Why could other growers not fill the gap? Newly planted cocoa trees take a few years to bear beans. In the short run, PES is very low.
  • Long-run response: growers elsewhere (e.g. Brazil, Ecuador) are working to expand production.
Mission 4Evaluate

How useful is PES for decisions?

  • Firms: knowing PES shows whether they can profit from a demand surge. Keeping stocks and spare capacity raises PES.
  • Government: the more inelastic supply is, the larger the share of a tax producers bear. A subsidy to raise output works only if supply can respond.
  • Policy example: if housing supply is inelastic, measures that raise demand mostly push up prices. Measures that make supply more elastic (e.g. faster planning) raise quantity.

It depends on …

  • Time horizon: short-run and long-run PES can be very different.
  • Spare capacity in the economy: near full capacity, supply is less elastic than in a recession.
  • Accuracy: PES estimates come from past data. Costs, technology and regulation change.
Mission check

?Demand for electric-bike batteries rises sharply (illustrative data). One month later, the price is 20% higher and quantity supplied is 5% higher than before. Two years later, compared with the original position, the price is 5% higher and quantity supplied is 30% higher. Which statement is correct?
Mission 5

Mission 5: When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?

Make a guess: When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?

Mission 5

A tax on spending

Who hands the tax to the governmentBuyerSellerpays the priceGovernmenttaxBuyers pay the tax onlythrough the price.
  • An indirect tax is a tax on spending on goods and services.
  • The seller hands the tax to the government. Buyers pay it only through the price.
  • Examples: VAT and sales taxes; duties on fuel, alcohol and tobacco.
  • To the seller, the tax is like an extra cost of each unit sold.
Mission 5

Specific or ad valorem?

Specific and ad valorem taxesSpecific tax: a fixed amount per unitPrice (£)0QuantitySS + specific taxttAd valorem tax: a percentage of the pricePrice (£)0QuantitySS + ad valorem taxthe gap widensat higher prices
  • Specific tax: a fixed amount per unit (e.g. per litre of fuel).
    • S shifts up by the same amount at every quantity: parallel.
  • Ad valorem tax: a percentage of the price (e.g. VAT).
    • The tax per unit grows as the price rises: the new curve pivots, diverging from S.
  • Example (illustrative data), a 20% tax on the pre-tax price:
    • pre-tax price £5 → tax £1
    • pre-tax price £10 → tax £2
Quick check
?A government charges a tax of 15% on the pre-tax price of every phone sold. How does it change the supply curve?
Mission 5

The tax diagram

Tax incidencePrice (£)0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityDSS + taxtconsumers' burden: (P1 − Pe) × Q1producers' burden: (Pe − P2) × Q1Tax revenue = both rectangles = t × Q1
  • Build it in steps (a tax of t per unit):
  • 1. Start at equilibrium: Pe, Qe.
  • 2. Supply shifts up by the tax: S → S + tax. Vertical gap = t.
  • 3. New equilibrium: price buyers pay rises to P1; quantity falls to Q1.
  • Sellers keep P1 − t per unit.
  • The price rises by less than the tax (unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic).
  • Say: "supply decreases; there is a contraction of demand" — not: "demand falls".
Mission 5

Who bears the tax?

Tax incidencePrice (£)0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityDSS + taxtconsumers' burden: (P1 − Pe) × Q1producers' burden: (Pe − P2) × Q1Tax revenue = both rectangles = t × Q1
  • The incidence of a tax: how its burden is shared between consumers and producers.
  • Consumers' share per unit = P1 − Pe (the rise in the price they pay).
  • Producers' share per unit = Pe − (P1 − t) (the fall in the price they keep).
  • The two shares add up to the tax, t.
  • Government revenue = t × Q1: the rectangle between P1 and P1 − t, from 0 to Q1.
  • Who hands the money over (the formal incidence or impact) does not decide who bears it.
Quick check
Areas A, B and C after a taxPrice (£)0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityABCDSS + taxtABC
?The diagram shows a market before and after a tax of a fixed amount per unit: D, S and S + tax; equilibrium Pe and Qe before; P1 and Q1 after; and P2 = P1 − tax. Which area shows the burden on producers?
AreaPosition
ARectangle between P1 and Pe, from 0 to Q1
BRectangle between Pe and P2, from 0 to Q1
CTriangle between D and S, from Q1 to Qe
DRectangles A and B together
Mission 5

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. Before the tax: Pe = £6, Qe = 60 units.
  • Specific tax: £1.50 per unit. After the tax: consumers pay £7, Q1 = 50.
  • Producers keep £7 − £1.50 = £5.50.
  • Consumers' burden: (£7 − £6) × 50 = £50.
  • Producers' burden: (£6 − £5.50) × 50 = £25.
  • Government revenue: £1.50 × 50 = £75 (= £50 + £25 ✓).
  • Consumers bear 2/3 of the tax: demand here is less elastic than supply (PED −1, PES 2 at the start).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Before a tax, a good sells at 5.00 per unit and 100 units are traded. After a tax of 2.00 per unit, consumers pay 6.20 and 76 units are traded. What is the total burden of the tax on producers?
Mission 5

Elasticity decides the split

Elasticity and tax incidence(a) Inelastic demand: consumers bear mostPrice (£)0P1PeP2QuantityDSS + tax(b) Elastic demand: producers bear mostPrice (£)0P1PeP2QuantityDSS + taxPerfectly inelasticdemand: consumersbear it allPrice (£)QuantityDSS + taxPerfectly elasticdemand: producersbear it allPrice (£)QuantityDSS + taxconsumers' burdenproducers' burden
  • The side of the market that is less price elastic bears more of the tax.
  • Inelastic demand (e.g. cigarettes, fuel): sellers raise the price and buyers keep buying, so consumers bear most.
  • Elastic demand: buyers switch away, so sellers must absorb the tax: producers bear most.
  • Extreme cases:
    • perfectly inelastic demand: consumers bear it all
    • perfectly elastic demand: producers bear it all
  • Approximate consumers' share = PES ÷ (PES + |PED|).
  • Say: "demand is price inelastic" — not: "demand is low".
Mission 5Graph lab

Shift the burden

Start: a tax of 1.50 per unit; PED −1, PES 2. Consumers bear 2/3 of each unit's tax.

Shift the burdenPrice (£)QuantityQ1QeP1PeP2DSS + tax
  • Takeaway: less elastic demand → consumers bear a bigger share (here 8/9), and Q falls less.
Quick check
?A government wants to raise as much revenue as possible from a tax of the same amount per unit, with the smallest fall in quantity sold. Supply conditions are similar. Which good should it tax?
Mission 5

Stakeholders

  • Consumers: pay a higher price, buy less; consumer surplus falls.
  • Producers: keep less per unit, sell less; producer surplus falls. Revenue falls.
  • Workers: fewer units made can mean fewer jobs in the industry.
  • Government: gains revenue (t × Q1) to spend; can target goods it wants used less.
  • Society:
    • where the good has a negative externality, the tax can move output toward the social optimum
  • Indirect taxes are often regressive: lower-income households spend a larger share of income on them.
Mission 5

Case: the UK sugar levy

  • Soft Drinks Industry Levy, from April 2018, charged on producers and importers. Rates at the start:
    • 18p per litre: drinks with 5 g to 8 g of sugar per 100 ml
    • 24p per litre: 8 g or more
  • (Both rates have risen each year since April 2025.)
  • Below 5 g: no levy. So firms could avoid it by cutting sugar.
  • 2015 to 2018, average sugar in UK soft drinks fell from 4.4 g to 2.9 g per 100 ml.
  • Most of the fall came from reformulation, not from buyers switching.
  • Caution: the study shows a trend; it cannot prove the levy alone caused it.
Mission 5Evaluate

Does the tax work?

  • It depends on PED:
    • inelastic demand → high revenue, small fall in Q
    • elastic demand → bigger cut in consumption, less revenue
    • one tax rarely maximises both
  • It depends on information: to correct an externality, the tax should match the external cost. That is hard to measure.
  • It depends on time and side effects: PED grows in the long run; very high taxes can encourage smuggling and illegal markets.
  • Governments use elasticity estimates to predict both the revenue and the change in behaviour.
Mission check

?A city has a fixed number of parking spaces and no space to add more. The city now charges the owners a fixed tax for each space used per day. Demand for parking is unchanged. Who bears the tax?
Mission 6

Mission 6: When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Make a guess: When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Mission 6

A payment per unit

A payment per unitGovernmentProducersubsidy per unitlower priceBuyer
  • A subsidy is a payment from the government to producers that lowers their costs.
  • A specific subsidy pays a fixed amount per unit.
  • An ad valorem subsidy pays a percentage of the price.
  • Why governments use them:
    • lower prices of goods they want used more, e.g. public transport
    • support producers' incomes, e.g. farmers
    • raise output where there are external benefits
Mission 6

The subsidy diagram

Subsidy incidencePrice (£)0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityDSS − subsidysconsumers' gain: (Pe − P1) × Q1producers' gain: (P2 − Pe) × Q1Dashed box: cost to government = s × Q1
  • Build it in steps (a subsidy of s per unit):
  • 1. Start at equilibrium: Pe, Qe.
  • 2. Supply shifts down by the subsidy: S → S − subsidy. Vertical gap = s.
  • 3. New equilibrium: the price buyers pay falls to P1; quantity rises to Q1.
  • Producers receive P1 + s per unit.
  • The price falls by less than the subsidy (unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic).
  • Say: "supply increases; there is an extension of demand" — not: "demand increases".
Mission 6

Who gains, and what it costs

Subsidy incidencePrice (£)0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityDSS − subsidysconsumers' gain: (Pe − P1) × Q1producers' gain: (P2 − Pe) × Q1Dashed box: cost to government = s × Q1
  • Cost to the government = s × Q1: the rectangle between P1 + s and P1, from 0 to Q1.
  • That rectangle splits in two:
    • consumers' gain per unit = Pe − P1
    • producers' gain per unit = (P1 + s) − Pe
  • The two gains per unit add up to the subsidy, s.
  • This split is the incidence of the subsidy.
Quick check
Market with a subsidy: areas W, X, Y, ZPrice0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityWXYS − subsidyDSZ
?The diagram shows a market before and after a subsidy of a fixed amount per unit: D, S and S − subsidy; equilibrium Pe and Qe before; P1 and Q1 after; and P2 = P1 + subsidy. Which area shows the total cost of the subsidy to the government?
AreaPosition
WRectangle between Pe and P1, from 0 to Q1
XRectangle between P2 and Pe, from 0 to Q1
YTriangle between S and D, from Qe to Q1
ZRectangle between P2 and P1, from 0 to Q1
Mission 6

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. Before: Pe = £8, Qe = 60 units.
  • Specific subsidy: £3 per unit. After: consumers pay £6, Q1 = 70.
  • Producers receive £6 + £3 = £9.
  • Cost to government: £3 × 70 = £210.
  • Consumers' share: (£8 − £6) × 70 = £140.
  • Producers' share: (£9 − £8) × 70 = £70.
  • Consumers get 2/3: here demand is less elastic than supply (PED −0.67, PES 1.33 at the start).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Before a subsidy, a good sells at 10.00 per unit and 200 units are traded. After a subsidy of 4.00 per unit, consumers pay 7.00 and 260 units are traded. What is the total cost of the subsidy to the government?
Mission 6

Elasticity decides the split

Elasticity decides the split(a) Inelastic demand: consumers gain mostPrice (£)0P2PeP1QuantityDSS − subsidy(b) Elastic demand: producers keep mostPrice (£)0P2PeP1QuantityDSS − subsidyPerfectly inelasticdemand: consumersget it allPrice (£)QuantityDSS − sPerfectly elasticdemand: producersget it allPrice (£)QuantityDSS − sconsumers' gainproducers' gain
  • The side of the market that is less price elastic gets more of the subsidy.
  • Inelastic demand: the price falls a lot → consumers gain most.
  • Elastic demand: the price barely falls → producers keep most.
  • Extreme cases:
    • perfectly inelastic demand: consumers get it all; Q does not change
    • perfectly elastic demand: price unchanged; producers get it all
  • More elastic demand and supply → a bigger rise in Q (and a bigger bill).
  • Approximate consumers' share = PES ÷ (PES + |PED|).
Mission 6Graph lab

Who keeps the subsidy?

Start: a subsidy of 2 per unit; PED −0.5, PES 1. Consumers get 2/3 of each unit's subsidy.

Who keeps the subsidy?PriceQuantityQeQ1P2PeP1DSS − subsidy
  • Takeaway: more elastic demand → the price falls less, so producers keep more (consumers' share 1/3) and Q rises more.
Quick check
?A government subsidises a good to cut the price that buyers pay. In which market will buyers get the largest share of each unit's subsidy?
Mission 6

Stakeholders

  • Consumers: pay less, buy more; consumer surplus rises.
  • Producers: receive more per unit, sell more; producer surplus rises.
  • Workers: more output can mean more jobs in the industry.
  • Government: pays s × Q1. Opportunity cost: that money cannot fund schools or hospitals, or must come from taxes or borrowing.
  • Producers may come to depend on the subsidy, with less pressure to cut costs.
Mission 6

Case: paying the buyer instead

  • From 2023 to 30 September 2025, US buyers of qualifying new electric cars could claim a federal tax credit of up to $7,500.
  • This subsidy went to buyers, so it shifted demand up, not supply.
  • The split is the same: it depends on elasticities, not on who receives the payment.
  • If car supply is inelastic, sellers can raise prices and keep much of the credit.
Mission 6Evaluate

Is the subsidy worth it?

  • It depends on elasticities: with elastic demand, the price barely falls and most of the money goes to producers.
  • It depends on information: to correct an external benefit, the subsidy should match its size. That is hard to measure.
  • It depends on the opportunity cost: the same money could fund other spending or lower taxes.
  • It depends on time and side effects: subsidies are hard to remove once firms and voters rely on them; firms may stay inefficient.
Mission check

?A small country's wheat farmers sell all their wheat at the world price, which they are too small to change. The government pays farmers a subsidy for every tonne they grow. Who gains the subsidy?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • PED = %ΔQd ÷ %ΔP: it measures how strongly quantity demanded responds to price. Size above 1: elastic; below 1: inelastic.
  • Substitutes, necessity, share of income, time and market definition decide how elastic demand is.
  • Slope is not elasticity: along a straight-line demand curve PED changes from elastic to inelastic.

Mission 2

  • When demand is price inelastic, price and total revenue move the same way; when it is elastic, they move in opposite ways; at unit elasticity TR is unchanged.
  • PED guides firms' pricing and governments' choice of what to tax, but estimates change over time and along the curve.

Mission 3

  • YED = % change in Qd ÷ % change in income. Positive: normal. Negative: inferior.
  • Size: below 1 is income inelastic (necessity); above 1 is income elastic (luxury).
  • XED = % change in Qd of A ÷ % change in price of B. Positive: substitutes. Negative: complements. Zero: unrelated.

Mission 4

  • PES = %ΔQs ÷ %ΔP: below 1 is inelastic, above 1 is elastic.
  • Supply is more elastic with spare capacity, stocks, mobile factors and, above all, more time.

Mission 5

  • An indirect tax shifts supply up by the tax; the price rises by less than the tax and quantity falls.
  • The burden falls more on whichever side is less price elastic, whoever hands the money over.
  • Specific taxes shift S in parallel; ad valorem taxes pivot it.

Mission 6

  • A subsidy shifts supply down by the subsidy; the price falls by less than the subsidy and quantity rises.
  • The government pays s × Q1; the less elastic side of the market gets more of it.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Demand and supply in product markets (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why do some buyers barely react when a price jumps, while others switch away at once?
  2. Mission 2When a seller charges more, why does the money coming in sometimes go up and sometimes go down?
  3. Mission 3When people get richer, why do they buy less of some things?
  4. Mission 4When prices jump, why can some producers flood the market while others cannot grow more for years?
  5. Mission 5When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?
  6. Mission 6When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · Eduqas