← A-Level Economics · Eduqas A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
WJEC Eduqas A-level Economics (A520) · Demand and supply in product markets (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Demand and supply in product markets (part 1)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?
  2. Mission 2Why do economists insist that a price cut does not increase demand?
  3. Mission 3Why do farmers grow more when prices rise, and what makes them grow less at every price?
  4. Mission 4When a price is too high or too low, what pulls it back to where buyers and sellers agree?
  5. Mission 5When a harvest fails or buyers rush in, which way do prices move, and how far?
  6. Mission 6When you would gladly pay more than the price, where does that extra value go?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?

Make a guess: Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?

Mission 1

What "rational" means

  • Economics models choices as rational: agents weigh benefits against costs and pick the option that best meets their objective.
  • Consumers aim to maximise utility (satisfaction).
  • Firms aim to maximise profit (total revenue − total cost).
Mission 1

Total and marginal utility

Total and marginal utilityTotal utility (utils)0123456Quantity (slices)203444505250TU peakTUIllustrative data: slices of pizza at one mealMarginal utility (utils)20141062−2MU = 0MU falls with each slice and crosses zerobetween slices 5 and 6, where TU peaks.
  • Total utility (TU): the whole satisfaction from all units consumed.
  • Marginal utility (MU): the change in TU from one more unit. MU = ΔTU ÷ ΔQ.
  • Slices of pizza at one meal (illustrative data, in "utils"):
SlicesTUMU
12020
23414
34410
4506
5522
650−2
  • Law of diminishing marginal utility: as more units are consumed, each extra unit adds less utility.
  • TU still rises while MU is positive. TU is at its maximum where MU = 0.
  • Say: "marginal utility falls" — not: "total utility falls" (TU rises until MU turns negative).
Quick check
?Glasses of juice drunk on a hot afternoon give these total utilities (illustrative data): 1 glass 12 utils, 2 glasses 22, 3 glasses 29, 4 glasses 33, 5 glasses 34. What is the marginal utility of the 4th glass?
Mission 1

From diminishing MU to the demand curve

From diminishing marginal utility to a demand curveEach extra unit adds less utilityMarginal utility12345Unit consumedso buyers will buy more only at a lower pricePrice0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDExtension of demand: a movement along D
  • A consumer buys one more unit only if its extra satisfaction is worth at least the price.
  • MU falls with each unit, so the most the consumer will pay for each extra unit falls too.
  • To persuade them to buy more, the price must be lower.
  • So quantity demanded rises as price falls: the demand curve slopes downward.
  • Say: "a fall in price causes an extension of demand" (a movement along D) — not: "demand increases".
Quick check
?Which statement best explains, using utility, why a demand curve usually slopes downward?
Mission 1

Worked example: equal MU per unit of money

Equi-marginal principle and demand for XUnitMUof XMU/Pof XMUof YMU/Pof Y1361215152279121231869949366MU/P of Xat £21813.594.5Buy the highest MU/P each time: Y1, X1, Y2, thenX2 and Y3. Spends all £9: 2 X and 3 Y.Price of X falls £3 → £2: now 3 X and 3 Y (MU/P= 9 for both).Demand for XPrice of X0£3£223Quantity of XDLower price, larger quantity demanded.Illustrative data.
  • Equi-marginal principle: with a limited income, utility is maximised when MU/P is equal for every good and all income is spent.
  • Good X costs £3, good Y costs £1. Income is £9.
  • Illustrative data:
UnitMU of XMU/P of XMU of YMU/P of Y
136121515
22791212
318699
49366
  • Step 1: buy the unit with the highest MU/P each time: Y1 (15), X1 (12), Y2 (12), then X2 and Y3 (9 each).
  • Step 2: spending = 2 × 3 + 3 × 1 = 9. All income spent.
  • Step 3: MU/P of X = 9 = MU/P of Y. 2 X and 3 Y, TU = 63 + 36 = 99, the most this income can buy.
Mission 1

Deriving demand from MU/P

Equi-marginal principle and demand for XUnitMUof XMU/Pof XMUof YMU/Pof Y1361215152279121231869949366MU/P of Xat £21813.594.5Buy the highest MU/P each time: Y1, X1, Y2, thenX2 and Y3. Spends all £9: 2 X and 3 Y.Price of X falls £3 → £2: now 3 X and 3 Y (MU/P= 9 for both).Demand for XPrice of X0£3£223Quantity of XDLower price, larger quantity demanded.Illustrative data.
  • Now the price of X falls from 3 to 2. MU/P of X rises: 18, 13.5, 9, 4.5.
  • MUx/Px > MUy/Py, so switching spending towards X raises total utility.
  • New optimum: 3 X and 3 Y (3 × 2 + 3 × 1 = 9; MU/P = 9 for both; TU = 117).
  • Two points on the demand curve for X: price 3 → 2 units; price 2 → 3 units.
  • Lower price, larger quantity demanded: a downward-sloping demand curve.
Mission 1

Decide at the margin: MB = MC

Marginal benefit and marginal cost of extra hoursMB, MC (money value)060402012345Extra hoursMBMCMB above MC: net benefit (hours 1 to 3)MB below MC (hours 4 and 5)Best choice: 3 hours. MB ≥ MC for the last unit.Illustrative data
  • Marginal benefit (MB): extra benefit from one more unit of an activity. Marginal cost (MC): extra cost of that unit.
  • Rule: do one more unit while MB ≥ MC. Stop where MB = MC.
  • A café decides how many extra hours to open (illustrative data, money values):
Extra hourMBMCMB − MC
1602040
2452520
335305
42530−5
51530−15
  • Best choice: 3 hours. Net benefit = 40 + 20 + 5 = 65. A 4th hour would cut it to 60.
  • Not where total benefit is biggest (5 hours), and not where MB − MC is biggest (hour 1).
Mission 1Graph lab

When the cost of each unit rises

Graph (illustrative data): MB falls from 60; MC rises from 15. They cross at quantity 3.

When the cost of each unit risesBenefit and costQuantity02468020406080330MBMC
  • Takeaway: anything that changes MB or MC moves the best choice; at the optimum, MB = MC.
Quick check
?A farmer can hire extra pickers by the day (illustrative data). The table gives each extra picker's marginal benefit and marginal cost. How many pickers should the farmer hire?
PickerMBMC
19040
27040
35040
43040
51040
Mission 1

Water and diamonds

The paradox of valueWater: plentiful, so the last litre adds littleMarginal utilitylowlargeQuantityMUDiamonds: scarce, so the last one adds a lotMarginal utilityhighsmallQuantityMU
  • The paradox of value: water is vital, diamonds are not, yet diamonds cost far more.
  • Water: plentiful. People already use a lot, so the MU of one more litre is tiny.
  • Diamonds: scarce. Few are owned, so the MU of one more diamond is high.
  • Price reflects marginal utility (what the next unit is worth), not total utility.
  • TU from water is enormous. MU of the last litre is small.
Mission 1Evaluate

How useful is the rational model?

  • Utility cannot be measured directly. "Utils" are a teaching device; economists infer preferences from choices.
  • It depends on information: real consumers rarely know every option and price.
  • It depends on effort and stakes: people use habits and shortcuts for small, frequent buys.
  • The model still predicts the direction of many responses well, e.g. buying less when price rises.
  • More on the limits: a later lesson.
Mission check

?A hiker has had no water all day on a hot trail and would pay a large amount for one bottle. At home, after drinking plenty, she would not pay even a small amount for one more bottle. Which explanation is best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do economists insist that a price cut does not increase demand?

Make a guess: Why do economists insist that a price cut does not increase demand?

Mission 2

What demand means

A demand curve from a schedulePrice065432100200300400500Quantity (cups per week)DIllustrative data
  • Demand: the quantity of a good that buyers are willing and able to buy at each price, over a given time period.
  • Law of demand: as price rises, quantity demanded falls, ceteris paribus (other things equal).
  • A demand schedule lists the quantity demanded at each price. Illustrative data:
Price per cupQuantity demanded (cups per week)
6100
5200
4300
3400
2500
  • Plot it: the demand curve (D) slopes downwards.
  • Demand is the whole curve, not one point on it.
Mission 2

Why the curve slopes down

  • Diminishing marginal utility: each extra unit consumed adds less satisfaction than the one before.
  • So a buyer is willing to pay less for the 4th cup than for the 1st. To sell more, the price must fall.
  • When the price of a good falls, two effects raise quantity demanded:
  • Substitution effect: the good is now cheaper relative to other goods, so buyers switch towards it.
  • Income effect: the same money income now buys more, so real income (purchasing power) rises and buyers can afford more.
  • Say: "the price fall raises real income" — not: "the price fall raises people's income".
Quick check
?The price of bus tickets falls while the price of train tickets is unchanged. Which describes the substitution effect for a commuter?
Mission 2

Movement or shift?

A movement along demand and a shift of demandPrice0P1P2Q1Q2Q2QuantityabDD1D2Extension of demand: a movement along DIncrease in demand: D shifts right
  • A change in the good's own price → a movement along D.
  • A change in anything else that affects buyers → a shift of the whole curve.
  • Step 1: price falls from P1 to P2 → slide along D from point a to point b.
  • Step 2: D1 → D2 to the right: more is demanded at every price.
  • Say: "a fall in price causes an extension of demand (a rise in quantity demanded)" — not: "demand increases".
  • A price rise → contraction of demand. A shift right → increase in demand; shift left → decrease.
Mission 2

What shifts demand

What shifts demandIncome rises(normal good)D1D2Price of a substituterisesD1D2Price of acomplement fallsD1D2More fashionable orpopularD1D2Buyers expect theprice to rise soonD1D2More buyers in themarketD1D2
Shift factorIncrease (D shifts right) when…
Incomeincome rises (normal good); income falls (inferior good)
Price of a substitutethe substitute's price rises
Price of a complementthe complement's price falls
Tastes and preferencesthe good becomes more fashionable or popular
Future price expectationsbuyers expect the price to rise soon
Number of consumersmore buyers enter the market
  • The opposite change shifts D left.
Mission 2

Worked example: a shift in numbers

A shift in numbersPrice0543200300400500Quantity (cups per week)shiftmovementD1D2Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data: a new study praises the drink, so 100 more cups are demanded each week at every price.
Price per cupOld quantity (D1)New quantity (D2)
5200300
4300400
3400500
  • Price stays at 4: quantity demanded rises from 300 to 400. Same price, more bought → shift.
  • Compare: price falls from 4 to 3 on D1: 300 → 400. Same rise in quantity, but caused by price → movement.
  • The cause, not the size of the change, decides which it is.
Mission 2Graph lab

Shift or slide?

Shift or slide?PriceQuantity604D
  • Takeaway: only the good's own price moves you along D; every other factor moves D itself.
Quick check
?The price of a sandwich falls from 4.00 to 3.50, and the café sells more sandwiches. Nothing else changes. How should an economist describe this?
Quick check
?Buyers learn that the price of a games console will rise next month. What happens to demand for the console this month?
Mission check

?Coffee machines need pods. The price of pods falls sharply, while the price of coffee machines does not change. What happens in the market for coffee machines?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why do farmers grow more when prices rise, and what makes them grow less at every price?

Make a guess: Why do farmers grow more when prices rise, and what makes them grow less at every price?

Mission 3

What supply means

Supply curvePrice05432100200300400Quantity (kg per week)SIllustrative data: a strawberry farm
  • Supply: the quantity that producers are willing and able to sell at each price, over a given time period.
  • Law of supply: as price rises, quantity supplied rises, ceteris paribus.
  • Why? The profit incentive: a higher price makes extra output more profitable, so firms produce more.
  • Illustrative data: a strawberry farm.
Price per kgQuantity supplied (kg per week)
2100
3200
4300
5400
  • Plot it: the supply curve (S) slopes upwards.
Mission 3

Why supply slopes up: rising marginal cost

MC staircaseCost / Price0P = 8P = 6123456Quantity (units)MC = supplyMC of each unit (bar height)price 6: produce units 1 to 4price 8: unit 5 is now worth producingIllustrative data
  • Marginal cost (MC): the extra cost of producing one more unit.
  • In the short run some inputs are fixed (land, machines). Add more workers and each adds less extra output: diminishing marginal returns.
  • So each extra unit costs more to make: MC rises.
  • A firm that is a price taker sells every unit at the market price. It produces each unit whose MC is no higher than the price.
  • Illustrative data:
Unit1st2nd3rd4th5th6th
MC2346811
  • Price 6 → produce 4 units (the 5th would cost 8). Price 8 → produce 5.
  • A higher price makes higher-cost units worth producing. So the supply curve traces the MC curve.
  • Under perfect competition, the firm's supply curve is its MC curve (above average variable cost: see a later lesson).
Quick check
?A price-taking firm faces the marginal costs in the table on the previous screen (2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 11 for units 1 to 6). The market price is 7. How many units should it supply?
Mission 3

Movement or shift?

Movement along or shift of supplyPrice (£)0P2P1Q1Q2QuantitySS1S2Price rises: extension of supplyRight: increase in supplyPrice (£)0QuantityS1S3Left: decrease in supply
  • A change in the good's own price → a movement along S.
  • A change in anything else that affects producers → a shift of the whole curve.
  • Step 1: price rises P1 → P2 → slide up along S.
  • Step 2: S1 → S2 to the right = increase in supply: more offered at every price.
  • A shift left = decrease in supply.
  • Say: "an increase in supply shifts the curve right" — not: "the supply curve shifts up". A rightward shift looks lower on the graph.
  • Say: "a rise in price causes an extension of supply" — not: "supply increases".
Mission 3

What shifts supply

What shifts supplyS1S2Costs of productionwages or materialsfallS1S2Technologybetter methodsS1S2Indirect taxS2 = S1 + tax; gap =tax per unitS1S2Number of firmsmore firms enterS1S2Expectationslower prices expectedlaterS1S2Shocksgood weather, nodisease
Shift factorSupply increases (S shifts right) when…
Costs of productionwages, raw material or energy prices fall
Technologybetter methods raise output from the same inputs
Indirect taxes and subsidiesa tax is cut or a subsidy is given
Number of firmsmore firms enter the market
Expectationsproducers expect lower prices later, so they sell more now
Shocksgood weather, no disease, no supply disruption
  • An indirect tax per unit shifts S left (vertically up by the tax). A subsidy shifts S right (detail in a later lesson).
Mission 3Graph lab

Which way does S move?

Which way does S move?PriceQuantity803S
  • Takeaway: anything that raises cost per unit shifts S left; anything that lowers it shifts S right.
Mission 3

Worked example: a cost shock in numbers

A cost shock in numbersPrice054200300Quantity (kg per week)S1S2At price 4: 300 → 200 kg, a shift leftTo supply 300 kg: price 4 → 5Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data: fertiliser prices rise, so the farm supplies 100 kg less at every price.
Price per kgOld (S1)New (S2)
3200100
4300200
5400300
  • At a price of 4: 300 → 200 kg. Same price, less offered → decrease in supply (shift left).
  • To supply 300 kg now, the farm needs a price of 5, not 4. The curve sits higher but has moved left.
Mission 3

Real case: frost hits coffee

  • July 2021: frosts hit coffee-growing areas of Brazil, the world's largest coffee producer.
  • Damaged trees mean less coffee for sale at every price in later harvests.
  • That is a shock to supply: S shifts left, not a movement along it.
  • The price rise that followed is the result of the shift (see Mission 5); it does not cause the shift.
Quick check
?The price of oranges rises and orange growers sell more oranges. Nothing else changes. How should an economist describe this?
Mission check

?Which change causes a decrease in the supply of electric scooters?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When a price is too high or too low, what pulls it back to where buyers and sellers agree?

Make a guess: When a price is too high or too low, what pulls it back to where buyers and sellers agree?

Mission 4

Equilibrium: where the curves cross

Market equilibriumPrice (£)0PeQeQuantityDSE
  • Equilibrium: the price at which quantity demanded = quantity supplied.
  • At that price the market clears: every unit offered is bought, every buyer willing to pay it gets one.
  • No pressure for the price to change, unless something else changes.
  • Label it Pe (equilibrium price) and Qe (equilibrium quantity).
  • In this model: many buyers and many sellers, none big enough to set the price alone (a competitive market).
Mission 4

Price too high: excess supply

Surplus and shortagePrice (£)0PeQdQsQsQdQuantityP above PeP below PeDSexcess supplyexcessdemandExcess supply (surplus) = Qs − QdExcess demand (shortage) = Qd − Qs
  • At a price above Pe, quantity supplied > quantity demanded.
  • This is excess supply, or a surplus.
  • Size of the surplus = Qs − Qd at that price.
  • Signs: unsold stock piling up, discounts, "clearance" sales.
  • Only Qd is actually sold: firms cannot sell more than buyers want.
  • Market forces: sellers cut the price to shift their stock.
Mission 4

Price too low: excess demand

Surplus and shortagePrice (£)0PeQdQsQsQdQuantityP above PeP below PeDSexcess supplyexcessdemandExcess supply (surplus) = Qs − QdExcess demand (shortage) = Qd − Qs
  • At a price below Pe, quantity demanded > quantity supplied.
  • This is excess demand, or a shortage.
  • Size of the shortage = Qd − Qs at that price.
  • Signs: queues, waiting lists, "sold out", resale above the original price.
  • Only Qs is actually bought: buyers cannot buy what is not supplied.
  • Market forces: buyers compete, so the price is bid up.
  • A shortage is not the same as scarcity. Scarcity is always present; a shortage exists only when the price is below equilibrium.
Quick check
?A market diagram shows demand curve D and supply curve S crossing at price Pe and quantity Q2. On the horizontal axis, Q1 < Q2 < Q3. At price P1, which is below Pe:
CurveQuantity at P1
SQ1
DQ3

Which distance on the quantity axis shows the excess demand at P1?

Mission 4

Worked example: finding equilibrium and the gap

  • Market for reusable water bottles, thousands per week (illustrative data).
PriceQdQs
69030
88050
107070
126090
  • Step 1: find the row where Qd = Qs: price 10, quantity 70 thousand. That is equilibrium.
  • Step 2: at a price of 12, Qs − Qd = 90 − 60 = 30: a surplus of 30 thousand. Only 60 thousand are sold.
  • Step 3: at a price of 6, Qd − Qs = 90 − 30 = 60: a shortage of 60 thousand. Only 30 thousand are bought.
  • Always compare Qd and Qs at the same price, never with Qe.
Mission 4Graph lab

Set the price, see the gap

Same market as the previous screen. This time the price is stuck at 8.

Set the price, see the gapPriceQuantity (thousands)0481216DSprice 8
  • Takeaway: the shortage shrinks to zero at the equilibrium price, then a gap reopens on the other side as a surplus.
Mission 4

Market forces: movements, not shifts

Market forces move the market along the curvesPrice (£)0PeQeQuantityP above PeP below PeDSexcess supplyexcessdemandprice fallscontraction of supplyextension of demandprice risesextension of supplycontraction of demand
  • Surplus → price falls → quantity demanded rises and quantity supplied falls → until Qd = Qs.
  • Shortage → price rises → quantity demanded falls and quantity supplied rises → until Qd = Qs.
  • These are movements along the curves. Neither curve shifts: the price is on the axis, so it cannot shift its own curve.
  • Say: "the price falls, causing an extension of demand and a contraction of supply" — not: "demand rises and supply falls".
Quick check
?Market for strawberries, thousand kg per day (illustrative data):
PriceQdQs
35025
44040
53055

The price is 5. Which describes the market?

Quick check
?A popular toy has a shortage at its current price, and the seller is free to change the price. A student writes: "The shortage makes the demand curve shift left and the supply curve shift right until they meet." What is the best correction?
Mission 4Evaluate

Does a market always clear?

  • The model predicts the price moves to Pe. How fast, and whether it gets there, depends on:
  • Price flexibility: some prices are sticky. Firms with printed price lists, long contracts, or worries about customer goodwill (e.g. concert and sports tickets) may leave a shortage.
  • Information: buyers and sellers must notice the surplus or shortage before they react.
  • Time lags: farmers cannot grow more until the next harvest, so a shortage can last a season.
  • Intervention: a legal maximum or minimum price stops the market clearing.
  • And the target moves: if a curve shifts, the market chases a new equilibrium (see Mission 5).
Mission check

?A new games console launches at a price of 300, below its equilibrium price of 400 (illustrative data). At 300, quantity demanded is 9 million and quantity supplied is 5 million. At 400, both are 7 million. The firm is free to raise the price. As the price rises from 300 to 400, what happens to the quantity actually bought and sold?
Mission 5

Mission 5: When a harvest fails or buyers rush in, which way do prices move, and how far?

Make a guess: When a harvest fails or buyers rush in, which way do prices move, and how far?

Mission 5

A shift starts a chain

A demand shift starts a chainPrice (£)0P2P1Q1Q2QuantityshortageD1SD2At P1: excess demand (shortage)price bid upmovement along S
  • Something other than the good's own price changes. One curve shifts.
  • Example: incomes rise and the good is normal. Demand shifts right, D1 → D2.
  • At the old price P1 there is now excess demand (a shortage).
  • The price is bid up. Suppliers respond by moving along S.
  • New equilibrium: higher price P2, higher quantity Q2.
  • Say: "a rise in demand causes an extension of supply" — not: "supply increases".
Mission 5

The four single shifts

The four single shiftsDemand increasesPrice (£)0P2P1Q1Q2QuantityD1SD2Demand decreasesPrice (£)0P1P2Q2Q1QuantityD1SD2Supply increasesPrice (£)0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDS1S2Supply decreasesPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityDS1S2
ShiftPriceQuantity
Demand right (increase)risesrises
Demand left (decrease)fallsfalls
Supply right (increase)fallsrises
Supply left (decrease)risesfalls
  • Demand shifts: price and quantity move the same way.
  • Supply shifts: price and quantity move opposite ways.
  • Always ask first: which curve does the event shift? Usually only one.
  • A supply shift right means more is offered at every price, not a move "down" the graph.
Mission 5Graph lab

Shift a curve, predict the result

Illustrative market: bottles, thousands per week. Equilibrium at price 10, quantity 70. Event: a cheaper material cuts producers' costs.

Shift a curve, predict the resultPriceQuantity (thousands)7010DS
  • Takeaway: S shifts right; at the old price there is a surplus, the price falls, and buyers move along D to a higher quantity. New equilibrium: price 8, quantity 80.
Quick check
?Wages rise for drivers employed by food-delivery firms, and nothing else changes. What happens in the market for food delivery?
Mission 5

Two shifts at once

Double shiftsPrice (£)0P2P1P2Q1Q2Q2QuantityD1S1D2S2D2S2Bigger demand shift: price upBigger supply shift: price downQuantity rises both times; price: indeterminate
  • When both curves shift, one of price or quantity is certain; the other depends on which shift is larger.
ShiftsPriceQuantity
D right, S right?rises
D left, S left?falls
D right, S leftrises?
D left, S rightfalls?
  • Method: do each shift alone, then combine. Where they agree, the answer is certain. Where they disagree, it is indeterminate.
  • Draw the bigger shift bigger, and say which you assumed.
Quick check
?In the same year, incomes rise (the good is normal) and a new, more efficient factory opens. What can we be sure of?
Mission 5

How far? It depends on elasticity

Elasticity and the size of the effectPrice inelastic demand: steep DPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityDS1S2Large price rise, small fall in quantityPrice elastic demand: flat DPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityDS1S2Small price rise, large fall in quantity
  • Same leftward shift of supply, two demand curves:
  • Price inelastic demand (drawn steeper through the starting point): large price rise, small fall in quantity.
  • Price elastic demand (drawn flatter through the same point): small price rise, large fall in quantity.
  • Slope is only a drawing guide here: elasticity is about percentage changes.
  • The same logic applies to supply: inelastic supply turns a demand shift mainly into a price change.
  • So markets with inelastic demand and supply have volatile prices. Example: farm commodities, where a harvest cannot be changed until next season.
  • Elasticity in full: (demand) (supply).
Mission 5Case

Cocoa, 2024

Supply shock casePrice (US$ per tonne)011,4416,896Q2Q1QuantityDS1S2London cocoa futures: P1 US$6,896 (1 Oct 2024)to P2 US$11,441 (31 Dec 2024)Source: ICCO, Cocoa Market Report, Dec 2024.Stylised: quantities not to scale.
  • Most of the world's cocoa is grown in West Africa.
  • Late 2024: hot weather with less rain threatened crops in Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana. Another global supply deficit was expected.
  • Supply shifted left. Chocolate makers have few substitutes for cocoa beans.
  • Result: cocoa futures in London rose 66% in three months: from US$6,896 per tonne (1 Oct 2024) to US$11,441 (31 Dec 2024).
  • On the diagram: S1 → S2, price P1 → P2 up sharply, quantity Q1 → Q2 down.
Mission 5

Real markets: housing and energy

HousingPrice of housing0P2P1Q1Q2Quantity of housingD1SD2
  • Housing: demand rises with population, incomes and cheaper or easier mortgages.
  • Supply is price inelastic: land, planning rules and years of building. So rising demand mostly raises prices, not the number of homes.
  • Energy: in 2022, Russia cut pipeline gas deliveries to Europe. Supply shifted left.
  • Demand for gas is inelastic in the short run (heating, power stations), so European wholesale gas prices hit record highs.
  • Over time, higher prices brought more liquefied gas by ship (extension of supply) and lower use (contraction of demand).
  • Commodities: The earlier screens.
Quick check
?The same leftward shift of supply hits two markets. In market X, demand is highly price inelastic. In market Y, demand is highly price elastic. Which is correct?
Mission 5Evaluate

How far can we trust the model?

  • The model predicts the direction of change well. How useful it is depends on:
  • Ceteris paribus: real markets face many changes at once, so outcomes are often double shifts with uncertain results.
  • Competition: it assumes many buyers and sellers who take the price. Firms with market power set prices.
  • Information and rationality: it assumes buyers and sellers know prices and respond to them. Habits and limited information slow responses.
  • Speed of adjustment: prices can be sticky, or overshoot, so markets can spend time out of equilibrium.
  • We never see the curves: data show only prices and quantities traded, so we must work out which curve shifted from other evidence.
Mission check

?Over one year, the price of a good rose sharply, but the quantity bought and sold stayed the same. The demand curve slopes down and the supply curve slopes up. Which change could explain this?
Mission 6

Mission 6: When you would gladly pay more than the price, where does that extra value go?

Make a guess: When you would gladly pay more than the price, where does that extra value go?

Mission 6

Consumer surplus

Consumer and producer surplusPrice0PeQeQuantityDSconsumer surplusDark slice: one buyer would pay 15, pays 10,and gains 5.producer surplus
  • Willingness to pay: the most a buyer would pay for a unit.
  • You would pay 15 for a concert ticket. It costs 10. You gain 5 that you never pay.
  • Consumer surplus = what buyers are willing to pay − what they actually pay.
  • The demand curve shows willingness to pay for each unit.
  • On a graph: the area below the demand curve and above the price, up to the quantity bought.
Mission 6

Producer surplus

Consumer and producer surplusPrice0PeQeQuantityDSconsumer surplusDark slice: one buyer would pay 15, pays 10,and gains 5.producer surplus
  • Each seller has a minimum price they would accept for a unit: its extra cost.
  • The supply curve shows that minimum price for each unit.
  • Producer surplus = price received − minimum price the seller would accept.
  • On a graph: the area above the supply curve and below the price, up to the quantity sold.
  • Say: "producer surplus" — not: "profit". It ignores fixed costs.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: four buyers would each pay at most 12, 10, 8 and 6 for one unit of a good. The market price is 8. What is the total consumer surplus in this market?
Mission 6

Worked example: measuring the areas

Worked surplus areasPrice01612440Quantity (per week)DSCS = ½ × 40 × (16 − 12) = 80PS = ½ × 40 × (12 − 4) = 160Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data. Demand meets the price axis at 16. Supply meets it at 4.
  • Equilibrium: price 12, quantity 40 units a week.
  • Both areas are triangles: ½ × base × height.
  • Consumer surplus = ½ × 40 × (16 − 12) = 80.
  • Producer surplus = ½ × 40 × (12 − 4) = 160.
  • Total (community) surplus = 80 + 160 = 240.
  • Height is always measured from the price line.
Mission 6

Total surplus is largest at equilibrium

Total surplus and deadweight lossPrice0PeQ1QeQuantityDSconsumer surplusproducer surplusCommunity surplus = consumer + producersurplus: the whole triangleconsumer surplusproducer surplusdeadweight (welfare) loss: units from Q1 toQe are not traded
  • Community surplus = consumer surplus + producer surplus.
  • Up to Qe, each unit is worth more to buyers than it costs to make: trading it adds surplus.
  • Beyond Qe, a unit costs more to make than buyers value it: trading it would reduce surplus.
  • So, with no market failure, a competitive market maximises total surplus at equilibrium.
  • This is allocative efficiency.
  • Lost total surplus from producing the wrong quantity is a deadweight loss.
Mission 6

Worked example: deadweight loss

Deadweight loss in numbersPrice013103040Quantity (per week)DSCS = 80PS = 160Total surplus = 240At Q = 30: demand price 13, supply price 10.deadweight loss = ½ × 10 × 3 = 15Total surplus falls from 240 to 225
  • Same market (illustrative data). Output is held at 30, not 40.
  • At Q = 30, buyers value the 30th unit at 13 (demand); it costs 10 (supply).
  • The units from 30 to 40 are not traded. The lost triangle is the deadweight loss.
  • Deadweight loss = ½ × (40 − 30) × (13 − 10) = 15.
  • Total surplus falls from 240 to 225.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. On a diagram, demand meets the price axis at 60 and supply meets it at 15. The market clears at a price of 30 and a quantity of 150. What is total surplus at equilibrium?
Mission 6

When demand or supply shifts

Surplus when supply or demand risesSupply rises (S1 to S2)Price0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDS1S2gain in consumer surplusDemand rises (D1 to D2)Price0P2P1Q1Q2QuantityD1SD2new consumer surplusnew producer surplus
  • Build the new equilibrium first, then redraw the areas.
  • Supply rises (costs fall): price falls, quantity rises.
    • Consumer surplus rises: existing buyers pay less, and new buyers join.
    • Producer surplus: the price is lower, but costs are lower and more units sell. With a parallel shift it rises too.
  • Demand rises: price and quantity rise.
    • Producer surplus rises: a higher price on more units.
    • Consumer surplus is measured under the new demand curve. With a parallel shift it rises too, even though price rose.
  • Demand or supply falls: the reverse.
  • Say: "an increase in supply" (a shift) — not: "an extension of supply" (a movement along the curve).
Mission 6Graph lab

Demand rises

Demand for the good rises (a parallel shift right). Supply does not change.

Demand risesPriceQuantityQePeCSPSDS
  • Takeaway: a parallel rise in demand raises both surpluses; the higher price is more than offset by more units and a higher demand curve.
Quick check
?A fall in costs shifts supply right. Price falls from P1 to P2 and quantity rises from Q1 to Q2. Which areas show the increase in consumer surplus?
AreaWhere it is
aTriangle below demand and above P1, from 0 to Q1
bRectangle between P1 and P2, from 0 to Q1
cTriangle below demand, between P1 and P2, from Q1 to Q2
Mission 6Evaluate

Is the biggest total surplus always best?

  • It depends on third parties: the areas count only buyers and sellers. External costs and benefits are left out.
  • It depends on who gains: a gain of 1 to a rich person counts the same as 1 to a poor person. Equity is a separate question.
  • It depends on ability to pay: willingness to pay reflects income as well as need.
  • It depends on measurement: real demand and supply curves are estimated, not observed.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: a city caps the number of taxi licences. Fewer rides take place than at the free-market equilibrium, and fares rise. Compared with the free-market equilibrium, what happens to total surplus (consumer plus producer surplus)?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Marginal utility falls as consumption rises; this explains a downward-sloping demand curve.
  • Rational choice: keep going while MB ≥ MC; the best choice is where MB = MC.
  • Utility is maximised when MU/P is equal across goods and all income is spent.

Mission 2

  • Demand is the whole schedule or curve; its own price moves you along it, every other factor shifts it.
  • Price fall: extension of demand; non-price change: increase or decrease in demand.
  • The curve slopes down because of diminishing marginal utility.
  • A price fall also works through the substitution effect and the income effect.

Mission 3

  • Supply slopes up because a higher price makes extra output profitable; own price moves you along S, every other factor shifts it.
  • Rising marginal cost is why: a price taker supplies each unit whose MC is no higher than the price.
  • Increase in supply = shift right (it looks lower), decrease = shift left.

Mission 4

  • Equilibrium: the price where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied, so the market clears.
  • Above it: surplus (Qs − Qd), the price falls. Below it: shortage (Qd − Qs), the price rises. Both adjust by movements along the curves.

Mission 5

  • A shift creates excess demand or supply at the old price; the price then changes and the market moves along the other curve to a new equilibrium.
  • Demand shifts move price and quantity the same way; supply shifts move them opposite ways. Two shifts at once leave one result uncertain.
  • The less elastic the curves, the more the price moves.

Mission 6

  • Consumer surplus: below demand, above price. Producer surplus: above supply, below price.
  • Community surplus is maximised at competitive equilibrium (MB = MC): allocative efficiency.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Demand and supply in product markets (part 1) for Eduqas A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?
  2. Mission 2Why do economists insist that a price cut does not increase demand?
  3. Mission 3Why do farmers grow more when prices rise, and what makes them grow less at every price?
  4. Mission 4When a price is too high or too low, what pulls it back to where buyers and sellers agree?
  5. Mission 5When a harvest fails or buyers rush in, which way do prices move, and how far?
  6. Mission 6When you would gladly pay more than the price, where does that extra value go?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · Eduqas