← A-Level Economics · Edexcel B A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Pearson Edexcel A-level Economics B (9EB0) · 1.5 Market failure and government intervention
Mini-Lesson

Market failure and government intervention

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?
  2. Mission 2Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  3. Mission 3If a vaccine also protects the people around you, why might too few people get one?
  4. Mission 4Who decides what gets made: prices, planners or a mix of the two?
  5. Mission 5Should a government tax pollution, ban it, or let firms buy and sell the right to pollute?
  6. Mission 6When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Introducing the market (part 1).

Mission 1

Mission 1: If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?

Make a guess: If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?

Mission 1

What a free market gets right

Surplus at equilibriumPrice0PeQeQuantityD = MBS = MCconsumer surplusproducer surplusconsumer surplus + producer surplus =community surplus
  • Each point on the demand curve shows the marginal benefit (MB) of one more unit to buyers.
  • Each point on the supply curve shows the marginal cost (MC) of one more unit to sellers.
  • At competitive equilibrium, P = MB = MC.
  • Consumer surplus: what buyers would pay minus what they do pay.
  • Producer surplus: what sellers receive minus the least they would accept.
  • Consumer + producer surplus = community surplus.
  • If there is no market failure, equilibrium makes this total as large as possible: allocative efficiency.
Mission 1

Market equilibrium vs the social optimum

Equilibrium versus social optimumNo outside effectsCosts and benefits0Qm = Q*QuantityMPB = MSBMPC = MSCmarket equilibrium = social optimumWith an external costCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSBMPCMSCwelfare lossQm: MPB = MPC. Q*: MSB = MSC.
  • Buyers and sellers weigh only their private benefits and costs: market equilibrium is where MPB = MPC.
  • Society counts all benefits and costs: the social optimum is where MSB = MSC.
  • Allocative efficiency: resources make the goods society values most; the value of the last unit equals its full cost, MSB = MSC (for a single firm: P = MC).
  • No outside effects: MPB = MSB and MPC = MSC, so the market reaches the social optimum.
  • Outside effects: the market equilibrium and the social optimum are at different quantities.
  • Say: "the market equilibrium is not the socially optimum position" — not: "the market is not in equilibrium". A market can be in equilibrium and still be inefficient.
Mission 1

Other kinds of efficiency

  • Productive efficiency: output made at the lowest possible average cost (the bottom of the AC curve); no resources wasted.
  • Allocative efficiency: P = MC; society gets the mix of goods it values most.
  • Productivity: output per unit of input (e.g. per worker per hour). Higher productivity lowers average cost.
  • At the margin: an extra unit is worth making if its marginal benefit is at least its marginal cost.
Quick check
?Which condition shows that a market produces the allocatively efficient quantity?
Mission 1Graph lab

Too much, too little

Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q and MSC = 20 + Q. The social optimum is Q = 50.

Too much, too littlePrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*MSBMSCoutput 50
  • Takeaway: any quantity other than MSB = MSC creates a welfare loss, whether output is too high or too low.
Mission 1

Worked example: measuring the welfare loss

  • Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q; MSC = 20 + Q (price in $, quantity in units per week).
  • Optimum: 120 − Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 50, value 70.
  • Output is 65 instead. At Q = 65: MSC = 20 + 65 = 85; MSB = 120 − 65 = 55.
  • Each extra unit from 50 to 65 costs society more than it is worth.
  • Welfare loss = triangle between MSC and MSB, from Q = 50 to 65.
  • Area = ½ × base × height = ½ × (65 − 50) × (85 − 55) = ½ × 15 × 30 = 225.
  • Total surplus at the optimum = ½ × 50 × (120 − 20) = 2,500. At 65 it falls to 2,500 − 225 = 2,275.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q and MSC = 20 + Q. A single seller restricts output to Q = 40. What is the welfare loss?
Mission 1

What market failure means

  • Market failure: the price mechanism fails to allocate resources efficiently, so the market outcome is not the social optimum.
  • The result is too much or too little of a good, and a welfare loss.
  • Complete market failure: no market exists at all: a missing market (e.g. street lighting).
  • Partial market failure: a market exists, but at the wrong price or quantity (e.g. too much tobacco, too little vaccination).
Mission 1

Sources of market failure

SourceWhat goes wrongMission
Negative externalitiesCost to third parties: overproduction
Positive externalitiesBenefit to third parties: underproduction
Public goodsFree riders: often no market at all
  • Information gaps (asymmetric information): buyers or sellers misjudge value.
  • Market power (monopoly): output restricted, price above MC.
Mission 1

Private, external, social

Negative and positive externalitiesNegative externality: Qm > Q*Costs and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMECwelfare lossPositive externality: Qm < Q*Costs and benefits0QmQ*QuantityMPB = DMSBMPC = MSC = SMEBwelfare loss
  • Externality: a cost or benefit to a third party, not paid for or received through the market.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost. At the margin: MSC = MPC + MEC.
  • Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit. At the margin: MSB = MPB + MEB.
  • External cost from production (e.g. pollution): MSC above MPC, so the market overproduces.
  • External benefit from consumption (e.g. vaccination): MSB above MPB, so the market underproduces.
  • Either way: a welfare (deadweight) loss triangle that points to the social optimum.
Quick check
?In a region, a factory's smoke harms nearby farms' crops, and there is no way to charge the factory for this. Which statement is correct?
Mission 1Evaluate

Are markets good at allocating resources?

  • Strengths: prices signal scarcity, give incentives, and ration goods with no central planner; competition pushes costs down and rewards innovation.
  • Weaknesses: externalities, public goods, information gaps, market power, unequal incomes.
  • It depends on: how big the failure is, whether better information or property rights could fix it, and whether intervention would do better.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a competitive market for bread has no externalities and settles at 1,000 loaves a day. The government pays bakers to raise output to 1,200 loaves a day. What happens to total surplus from bread?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Make a guess: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Mission 2

The cost nobody pays for

  • A firm pays for labour, materials, energy: its private costs.
  • Its production may also harm third parties, who are outside the trade: polluted air and rivers, noise, carbon emissions.
  • That harm is an external cost. Nobody pays the firm's victims through the market.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost.
  • At the margin: MSC = MPC + MEC (marginal external cost).
  • A negative production externality = an external cost created by producing a good.
  • Examples: a chemical plant's waste in a river harms fishing downstream; an airport's noise lowers the value of nearby homes; a coal power station's emissions harm health.
Mission 2

Worked example: adding up social cost

  • Illustrative data: a paper mill dumps waste in a river. Per tonne of paper:
  • Marginal private cost (wood, labour, energy) = 300.
  • Marginal external cost (lost fishing, water cleaning downstream) = 80.
  • MSC = MPC + MEC = 300 + 80 = 380.
  • Buyers value the last tonne at 360 (MPB). No external benefit, so MSB = 360.
  • The mill makes the tonne: to it, 360 > 300. To society: 360 − 380 = −20. Society loses 20 on that tonne.
  • If all 1,000 tonnes cost the same: private cost 300,000; external cost 80,000; social cost 380,000.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a cement works has a marginal private cost of 45 per tonne. Its dust causes a marginal external cost of 15 per tonne to nearby residents. What is the marginal social cost of a tonne of cement?
Mission 2

The diagram

Negative production externalityCosts and benefits0P*PmQ*QmQuantityoverproductionMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMEC
  • Step 1: the market. Supply = MPC; demand = MPB = MSB (no external benefit). Market equilibrium at Qm, Pm.
  • Step 2: add the external cost. MSC lies above MPC; the vertical gap = MEC.
  • Step 3: the social optimum is where MSB = MSC: Q* (less), P* (higher).
  • Firms respond to private costs only, so the market produces Qm > Q*: overproduction.
  • The price Pm is too low: it does not include the external cost.
  • Say: "the market overproduces compared with the social optimum" — not: "the market is in disequilibrium".
Mission 2

The welfare loss

Welfare lossCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYwelfare loss (W, X, Y)external cost (not all a welfare loss)W = social optimum
  • For each unit from Q* to Qm: MSC > MSB. It costs society more than it is worth.
  • Adding up these losses gives a triangle:
  • corners: the social optimum (MSB = MSC); MSC at Qm; MSB at Qm.
  • The triangle points towards the social optimum.
  • Called the welfare loss.
  • Say: "welfare loss = the triangle between MSC and MSB, from Q* to Qm" — not: "the whole area between MSC and MPC". That bigger area is the external cost of all output, most of which is still worth bearing.
Mission 2Graph lab

Turn up the pollution

Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q. The marginal external cost (MEC) is the same for every unit.

Turn up the pollutionPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: a bigger MEC does not change what the market produces; it lowers the social optimum and widens the welfare loss.
Mission 2

Worked example: calculating the welfare loss

  • Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; MEC = 20 per unit, so MSC = 40 + Q.
  • Market: 100 − Q = 20 + Q, so Qm = 40, Pm = 60.
  • Social optimum: 100 − Q = 40 + Q, so Q* = 30, P* = 70.
  • At Qm = 40: MSC = 80; MSB = 60. Height = 80 − 60 = 20 (= MEC).
  • Base = Qm − Q* = 40 − 30 = 10.
  • Welfare loss = ½ × 10 × 20 = 100.
  • Compare: total external cost at Qm = 20 × 40 = 800. The welfare loss is only 100: most of the external cost (20 × 30 = 600) falls on units that are still worth producing.
Quick check
Points on the externality diagramCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYZ
?A negative production externality diagram has MPB = MSB, MPC and MSC. The points are:
PointWhere it is
Wwhere MSC meets MSB (above Q*)
Xon MSC directly above Qm
Ywhere MPC meets MPB (at Qm)
Zon MPC directly below W (at Q*)

Which area shows the welfare loss?

Quick check
?Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 90 − Q; MPC = 10 + Q; MEC = 16 per unit at every output. What is the welfare loss at the market equilibrium?
Mission 2

Putting a number on the external cost

  • Carbon dioxide is a global external cost: emissions anywhere add to climate damage everywhere.
  • The social cost of carbon estimates the damage from one more tonne of CO₂, in today's money.
  • Two US government estimates for emissions in 2020: $51 per tonne (2021) and $190 per tonne (2023).
  • The gap comes mostly from assumptions, above all how much weight to give damage to people in the future.
  • So the MEC used for policy depends on value judgements, not only on science.
  • Other environmental externalities: water pollution, loss of habitats, noise, waste.
Mission 2Evaluate

How big is the problem?

  • It depends on measuring MEC. Health, nature and future harm have no market price, so estimates vary widely.
  • It depends on elasticity. For a given MEC, the more price elastic demand and supply are, the bigger the overproduction (Qm − Q*) and the welfare loss.
  • It depends on who and where. Many small polluters, or harm across borders, make the external cost hard to trace and charge.
  • It depends on time. Some damage builds up over years (carbon, soil), so today's MEC may understate the harm.
  • Ways to correct it (taxes, regulation, permits, property rights) are in Mission 5.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a fertiliser plant's runoff harms a lake. The table shows marginal values at each output (thousand tonnes).
OutputMPB = MSBMPCMEC
10903010
20804015
30705020
40606025
50507030

What is the socially optimal output?

Mission 3

Mission 3: If a vaccine also protects the people around you, why might too few people get one?

Make a guess: If a vaccine also protects the people around you, why might too few people get one?

Mission 3

Benefits that spill over

Spillover benefitMPBexternalbenefitexternalbenefitvaccinatedpersonother peopleother peopleMPBMEBMSB = MPB + MEBNot to scale
  • Marginal private benefit (MPB): the benefit to the buyer of one more unit. It is the demand curve.
  • Marginal external benefit (MEB): the benefit to third parties of one more unit.
  • Marginal social benefit (MSB) = MPB + MEB.
  • In totals: social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
  • Buyers respond to private benefits only. The external benefit is ignored.
  • Example: vaccination. Each vaccinated person also lowers the chance that others catch the disease.
  • Measles vaccination averted an estimated 60 million deaths worldwide in 2000–2023.
  • Goal: 95% coverage with 2 doses. Actual global coverage in 2023: 83% for dose 1, 74% for dose 2.
  • Many things cause that shortfall, such as access, cost and conflict. The spillover is one reason why free choice alone may not close it.
  • Other cases: education, training, restoring old buildings.
Mission 3

Underconsumption on the diagram

Externality in consumptionPrice, costs and benefits0P1Q1Q*underconsumptionQuantityMPBMPC = MSCMSBwelfare loss
  • Step 1: MPC = MSC (no production externality). The market settles where MPB = MPC: Q1, P1.
  • Step 2: MSB lies above MPB by the external benefit. Social optimum Q* where MSB = MSC.
  • Q1 < Q*: the market underconsumes.
  • Step 3: units from Q1 to Q* have MSB above MSC, but are not consumed. The lost surplus is the welfare loss triangle, pointing to the social optimum.
  • Say: "underconsumption" or "underprovision" — not: "demand is too low", which makes it sound like a demand shift.
Mission 3Graph lab

Turn up the spillover

Turn up the spilloverPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ1MPBMPC = MSC
  • Takeaway: the market ignores external benefits, so the bigger they are, the further Q1 falls short of Q*.
Quick check
?A diagram shows a positive consumption externality with MPC = MSC.
PointWhere it is
XMPB meets MPC = MSC, at Q1
YMSB meets MPC = MSC, at Q*
ZOn MSB, directly above X at Q1

Which area shows the welfare loss?

Mission 3

Positive production externalities

Positive production externalityPrice, costs and benefits0P1Q1Q*QuantityMPB = MSBMPCMSCMEBwelfare loss
  • Some production benefits third parties. That lowers society's cost.
  • MSC = MPC − MEB. MSC lies below MPC.
  • Example: a firm trains workers who later move to other firms, which gain skills they did not pay for.
  • Example: research that other firms copy and build on.
  • Firms produce where MPC = MPB (Q1). Social optimum where MSC = MSB (Q*).
  • Q1 < Q*: underproduction. Welfare loss triangle between Q1 and Q*.
Quick check
?A firm trains apprentices at its own expense. Many later join rival firms, which gain skilled workers without paying for the training. With no government action, what happens?
Mission 3

Merit goods

  • A merit good is more beneficial to the consumer than they realise.
  • It is underconsumed if left to the market.
  • Examples often given: education, healthcare, vaccination, pensions.
  • Why underconsumed:
  • Imperfect information: people underestimate the long-run benefit to themselves.
  • Short-termism: the cost is now, the benefit years later.
  • External benefits: most merit goods also benefit others.
  • Calling a good "merit" is a value judgement.
  • Merit goods are not public goods: they are rival and excludable.
Mission 3

The merit-good diagram

Demerit or merit goodPrice, costs and benefits0Q1Q2Q*QuantityMPB(perceived)MPB (fullinformation)MSBMPC = MSCinformation failureexternal benefitwelfare loss
  • Step 1: buyers act on MPB (perceived). Market at Q1, where it meets MPC = MSC.
  • Step 2: with full information, they would value it more: MPB (full information) lies higher. Quantity Q2.
  • Step 3: adding the external benefit gives MSB, higher still. Social optimum Q* where MSB = MSC.
  • Underconsumption: Q1 < Q2 < Q*. Welfare loss: the triangle between Q1 and Q*.
  • Say: "underconsumed because of imperfect information" — not: "underconsumed because it is too expensive".
Quick check
?Many countries provide school education free of charge. Why do economists usually class education as a merit good rather than a public good?
Mission 3

How governments respond

Responses: subsidy and free provisionA subsidyPrice, costs and benefits0Q1Q*QuantityMPBMSBMPC = MSCMPC − subsidysubsidyFree provisionPrice, costs and benefits0Q*Q at P = 0QuantityMPBMSBMPC = MSCFree provision may overshoot or fall short of Q*.
  • Subsidy per unit equal to the MEB at Q*: MPC shifts down to MPC − subsidy. Quantity rises to Q*.
  • Direct provision, free at the point of use: state schools, public health services.
  • At a price of zero, people consume where MPB meets the quantity axis. That may be above or below Q*.
  • Regulation: compulsory schooling to a set age; vaccination requirements in some countries.
  • Information: campaigns that raise perceived MPB.
  • Strengths and limits of each.
Mission 3Evaluate

Should the government step in?

  • It depends on measuring the MEB: hard to value, so the right subsidy is uncertain.
  • It depends on information: if perceived MPB is the problem, information may be cheaper than a subsidy.
  • It depends on opportunity cost: money spent here cannot be spent elsewhere; risk of government failure (see Mission 6).
  • It depends on the value judgement: some argue people should be free to choose; others that the state should ensure access.
Mission check

?A beekeeper sells honey. Her bees also pollinate the fruit trees in neighbouring orchards, raising the orchards' fruit output. The orchard owners pay her nothing. Compared with the social optimum, how much honey does the market produce?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Who decides what gets made: prices, planners or a mix of the two?

Make a guess: In a country of millions, who decides how many loaves of bread are baked tomorrow?

Mission 4

Three questions every economy must answer

Three questions every economy answersScarce resourcesWhat?which goods,how muchHow?whichmethodsFor whom?who gets theoutputEconomic systemownership + coordinating mechanism
  • Resources are scarce, so every society must decide:
  • What to produce (and how much)?
  • How to produce it (which resources, which methods)?
  • For whom to produce it (who gets the output)?
  • An economic system is the way a society answers these questions.
  • It has two parts: who owns the resources, and the coordinating mechanism that links millions of decisions.
Mission 4

Free market economy

Price signals move resourcesConsumers wantmore of a goodrationingPrice risesthe signalincentiveProfit risesFirms moveresources inConsumers want lessof a goodPrice fallsthe signalincentiveProfit fallsFirms moveresources out
  • Resources are privately owned.
  • The price mechanism coordinates: prices rise where goods are wanted and scarce, fall where they are not.
  • Firms seek profit; consumers choose what to buy. Spending acts like votes (consumer sovereignty).
  • The state's role is small: protect property rights, enforce contracts, keep law and order.
  • Strengths: incentives to work, invest and innovate; prices carry information quickly; wide choice.
  • Weaknesses: some goods under-provided (e.g. street lighting); pollution ignored; large inequality of income and wealth; booms and slumps.
Mission 4

Planned (command) economy

  • Most resources are owned by the state.
  • A central planning agency answers what, how and for whom: it sets output targets and fixes prices.
  • Strengths: resources can be directed to national priorities (e.g. heavy industry, defence, health); income can be kept more equal; full employment can be a target.
  • Weaknesses: planners lack the information to plan millions of goods; fixed prices bring shortages and queues or surpluses; weak incentives to cut costs or innovate; little consumer choice.
Quick check
?In a planned economy, a central agency sets each factory's output and fixes all prices. A shortage of winter coats appears. What is most likely to happen next under this system?
Mission 4

Mixed economy

The spectrum of economic systemsEconomies can move either wayMixedFree marketPlanned
  • Both the market (private sector) and the state (public sector) allocate resources.
  • Most goods are bought and sold in markets.
  • The state provides some goods (e.g. defence, roads, often schools and healthcare), taxes, regulates and redistributes income.
  • Every real economy is mixed. They differ in how much the state does.
  • Think of a spectrum: free market at one end, planned at the other. Countries sit in between, and move along it over time.
Mission 4

Real case: planning and reform

  • The Soviet Union ran its economy through central plans, with five-year plans from 1928 until the state broke up in 1991.
  • Planning built heavy industry fast, but consumer goods were often short and queues were common.
  • China began market reforms in 1978. Over the next few years farm households were allowed to keep or sell output above their state quota; private firms were later allowed.
  • The state still owns many large firms in China, alongside a large private sector: a mixed economy.
  • Both show economies moving along the spectrum, not fixed in one box.
Mission 4

The role of the state

  • Even market supporters give the state a role. Common roles:
  • Legal framework: property rights, contracts, competition law.
  • Public goods and services the market under-provides (e.g. defence, street lighting).
  • Correcting market failure: pollution, information gaps, monopoly.
  • Redistribution: taxes and benefits to reduce inequality.
  • Stabilising the economy in booms and slumps.
  • But governments can fail too: poor information, slow decisions, unintended effects (government failure).
Mission 4Evaluate

Which system allocates resources best?

  • It depends on information: prices pass on dispersed knowledge well; planners struggle with millions of goods.
  • It depends on goals: markets tend to score well on efficiency and choice; equality and national priorities may need the state.
  • It depends on market failures: where externalities or public goods matter, markets alone under- or over-provide.
  • It depends on the state's capacity: good intervention needs good information, honest institutions and incentives.
  • Economists disagree about where on the spectrum an economy should sit. Much of that is a value judgement.
Quick check
?In Country Y, most firms are privately owned and most prices are set in markets. The state funds schools and hospitals from taxes and sets a minimum wage. How is Country Y's economy best described?
Mission check

?A sudden frost destroys half of a country's coffee harvest. How would the response most likely differ between a free market economy and a planned economy with fixed prices?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Should a government tax pollution, ban it, or let firms buy and sell the right to pollute?

Make a guess: A factory's smoke harms people nearby. What should a government aim for?

Mission 5

The aim: make the polluter face the full cost

  • Governments intervene to correct market failure, and also to raise revenue, redistribute income and protect consumers.
  • A negative externality: the market produces Qm, more than the social optimum Q* (see Mission 2).
  • The fix: make decision-makers face the external cost. This is internalising the externality.
  • The target is Q*, not zero. Some pollution is worth its cost.
  • Two families of tools:
    • market-based: taxes, subsidies, tradable permits, property rights. They change prices or incentives.
    • command and control: regulation, bans, limits. They set rules.
  • Others: information, government provision, agreements between countries.
Mission 5

A tax on each unit

Pigouvian taxCosts and benefits0P*PmP* − taxQ*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMPC + tax = MSCtaxwelfare loss (overproduction)tax revenue = tax × Q*
  • A Pigouvian tax: a tax per unit equal to the MEC at the social optimum.
  • Firms now pay MPC + tax. Supply shifts up, from MPC to MPC + tax.
  • If MEC is the same for every unit, MPC + tax = MSC.
  • Quantity falls from Qm to Q*. Price rises from Pm to P*.
  • Consumers and producers share the tax; the government gains tax revenue.
  • The welfare loss triangle disappears.
  • Say: "the tax internalises the external cost" — not: "the tax ends the pollution".
Mission 5

Worked example: setting the tax

  • Illustrative data (from Mission 2): MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; MEC = 20 per unit.
  • No tax: 100 − Q = 20 + Q, so Qm = 40, Pm = 60. Welfare loss = 100.
  • Tax = MEC = 20. New supply: 40 + Q.
  • 100 − Q = 40 + Q, so Q = 30 = Q*.
  • Buyers pay 70 (up 10). Firms keep 70 − 20 = 50 (down 10).
  • Here the burden splits 10: 10, because the curves have equal slopes.
  • Tax revenue = 20 × 30 = 600.
  • Welfare loss = 0: the market now reaches the social optimum.
Mission 5Graph lab

Set the tax

Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; MEC = 20, so MSC = 40 + Q.

Set the taxPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmP*MPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: the tax must match the MEC. Too low leaves overproduction; too high causes underproduction.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 120 − Q; MPC = 30 + Q. The MEC is 30 at every output. The government sets a per-unit tax equal to the MEC. How much tax revenue does it raise?
Mission 5

Carbon taxes

Carbon tax on a polluting industryCoal-fired electricityPrice of electricity0P2P1Q2Q1Quantity of electricityDS1S2 = S1 + carbon taxtaxLow-carbon supplierPrice of electricity0Quantity of electricityS (low-carbon)costs unchanged, so relatively cheaper than coal
  • A carbon tax: a tax per tonne of CO₂ emitted, charged on fuels by their carbon content.
  • On a polluting industry, e.g. coal-fired electricity: S1 → S2 (S + tax). Price rises, quantity falls.
  • Low-carbon producers become relatively cheaper. Firms and households switch.
  • Real world: British Columbia, Canada.
    • 2008: tax of C$10 per tonne CO₂e, with the revenue meant to be returned through other tax cuts.
    • 2024: C$80 per tonne.
    • A 2015 review of studies put emissions 5–15% lower than without the tax.
    • 1 April 2025: the tax on consumers was ended, as Canada dropped its national requirement for one.
  • Lesson: a carbon tax can cut emissions, but it lasts only while it keeps political support.
Mission 5

Subsidies for positive externalities

SubsidyCosts and benefits0QmQ*QuantityMPB = DMSBMPC = SMPC − subsidysubsidycost of subsidy = subsidy × Q*
  • Some goods give external benefits (see Mission 3): MSB > MPB, so the market underproduces.
  • A subsidy per unit equal to the MEB at Q*: supply shifts down to MPC − subsidy.
  • Output rises to Q*; price to buyers falls.
  • Cost to the government = subsidy × Q*.
  • Examples: vaccinations, public transport fares, home insulation.
  • Subsidising a clean substitute (e.g. electric buses) also cuts demand for the polluting good.
Mission 5

Rules: regulation and legislation

Regulation(a) A limit on output at Q*Costs and benefits0limit = Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSC(b) A banCosts and benefits0QuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWhere is Q*?
  • Command and control: the law sets limits, enforced by inspection and fines.
    • emissions standards; limits on output or a cap at Q*
    • bans where the harm is severe: leaded petrol, CFCs
  • Real world: leaded petrol, still sold in 117 countries in 2002, was used for the last time in 2021 (UNEP).
  • Strengths: simple, certain, quick; best when the harm is dangerous at any level.
  • Limits: the same rule for every firm ignores their different costs of cutting; no reward for cutting more than the rule asks; inspection is costly.
  • Voluntary agreements: an industry agrees to cut harm without a law. Cheap, but there are no penalties if firms fall short.
Quick check
?A pesticide sold to farmers is found to poison rivers and wildlife even in very small amounts. What is the strongest economic case for banning it rather than taxing it?
Mission 5

Tradable permits

Permit marketPrice of a permit0P2P1Q2Q1Quantity of permits (tonnes)D for permitsS (cap)S1S2Illustrative onlytighter cap: supply shifts left, permit price rises
  • The government sets a cap: the total pollution allowed. It issues that many permits (1 permit = 1 tonne).
  • Permits are given out or auctioned. Firms may buy and sell them.
  • Firms that can cut cheaply cut more and sell spare permits. Firms that find cutting costly buy.
  • Illustrative data: firms A and B each emit 100 t. Cap = 150 permits, 75 each.
    • Cost of cutting 1 t: A 20, B 60.
    • No trade: each cuts 25 t. Cost = 25 × 20 + 25 × 60 = 2,000.
    • Trade at 40 a permit: A cuts 50 t (cost 1,000) and sells 25 permits to B (+1,000). B cuts nothing and pays 1,000.
    • Same total emissions (150 t). Total cost of cutting falls to 1,000.
  • The permit price rises as the cap tightens: a price on pollution, set by the market.
Mission 5

Real world: the EU Emissions Trading System

  • Started 2005: power stations and heavy industry in the EU.
  • The cap falls every year.
  • After the 2008 crisis, demand for permits fell. By 2013 there was a surplus of about 2 billion permits, and prices stayed low for years.
  • Fix: a Market Stability Reserve (from 2019) takes surplus permits off the market.
  • In February 2023 the price reached about €100 per tonne.
  • Lesson: permits fix the quantity; the price depends on how tight the cap is.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: firms X and Y each emit 60 t. Each is given 40 permits, so together they must cut 40 t. Cutting 1 t costs X 15 and Y 45. By how much does permit trading lower the total cost of cutting 40 t?
Mission 5

Information, provision and agreements

EducationCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB1MSBMSB = MPB2MPC = MSC = Seducationwelfare loss (overconsumption)
  • Information and education: campaigns, labels, warnings.
    • For a demerit good, people overvalue it. Education lowers MPB towards MSB.
  • Government provision: the state supplies a good with external benefits (vaccinations, public transport), to reach Q*.
Mission 5Evaluate

Which tool works best?

It depends on:

  • Measuring the externality. A tax needs the MEC; a cap needs the right total. Both are hard to value (see Mission 2).
  • Elasticity of demand. If demand is price inelastic, a tax cuts output little but raises much revenue.
  • Enforcement and admin costs. Monitoring emissions, collecting taxes and policing bans all cost money.
  • Consequences for stakeholders. Carbon taxes take a bigger share of poorer households' income; returning the revenue can offset this. Firms may move production abroad.
  • Certainty. A permit cap fixes the quantity, not the price; a tax fixes the price, not the quantity.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a city airport's night flights cause noise. Values per flight:
Flights per nightMPB = MSBMPCMEC
1080205
20703010
30604020
40505030
50406040

The government will charge a fixed tax per flight. Which tax brings the number of flights to the social optimum?

Mission 6

Mission 6: When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?

Make a guess: Why might a policy meant to fix a market leave it worse off?

Mission 6

When the cure is worse

  • Markets can fail (earlier missions). Governments step in with taxes, subsidies, rules and provision (see Mission 5).
  • But intervention can also go wrong.
  • Government failure: intervention that causes a net welfare loss compared with leaving the market alone. Resources end up misallocated.
  • A policy that has costs, or does not fix the problem fully, is not automatically a failure.
  • The test: is society better or worse off overall than with no intervention?
  • Say: "government failure = intervention leads to a net welfare loss" — not: "any policy that costs money".
Mission 6

Inadequate information

Tax set too highCosts and benefits0Q taxQ*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMPC + taxtaxwelfare loss (overproduction)new welfare loss (underproduction)old welfare loss
  • To set a Pigouvian tax, the government needs the MEC. It rarely knows it (see Mission 2).
  • Also called information gaps.
  • Illustrative data (from Mission 5): MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; true MEC = 20.
  • No tax: Qm = 40; welfare loss = 100.
  • The government overestimates the harm and sets a tax of 50.
  • New supply: 70 + Q. 100 − Q = 70 + Q, so Q = 15. Q* is 30.
  • Now underproduction. At Q = 15: MSB = 85, MSC = 55, a gap of 30.
  • New welfare loss = ½ × (30 − 15) × 30 = 225.
  • 225 > 100: society is worse off than with no tax. Government failure.
Mission 6Graph lab

How wrong can the tax be?

Illustrative data: as the previous screen. MEC = 20; the market alone gives a welfare loss of 100.

How wrong can the tax be?Price, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSCno-tax loss 100100Welfare losswith this tax
  • Takeaway: a tax a little wrong still helps. A tax far too high can do more harm than the externality.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 60 − Q; MPC = Q. The MEC is 10 at every output, so the market output is 30, the social optimum is 25 and the welfare loss with no tax is 25. The government sets a tax of 30 per unit. What is the new welfare loss, and is this government failure?
Mission 6

Distortions of price signals

Guaranteed price creates a surplusPrice0PminPeQdQeQssurplus: bought into storeQuantityDScost to taxpayers = Pmin × (Qs − Qd)
  • Prices tell producers what to make and consumers what to buy.
  • Taxes, subsidies and price controls change prices. Set badly, they send the wrong signals.
  • Also called price distortion or market distortion.
  • Real world: the European Community's farm policy (CAP) guaranteed farmers high prices and bought up what did not sell.
    • Farmers produced more than consumers wanted.
    • Surpluses filled stores: "butter mountains" and "wine lakes", paid for by taxpayers.
    • From 1984, milk quotas were brought in to limit dairy output.
  • One intervention led to another to fix its side-effects.
Mission 6

Unintended consequences

  • People and firms respond to a policy, sometimes in ways nobody planned.
  • Real world: Mexico City, 1989, "Hoy No Circula" (No Driving Today).
    • Most cars banned from driving one weekday a week, by the last digit of the number plate.
    • Aim: cleaner air.
    • A 2008 study found no evidence that air quality improved.
    • Many households bought an extra car, often an older, more polluting one, to drive on their banned day.
  • Other examples: high taxes on cigarettes can encourage smuggling; rent controls can shrink the supply of rented homes.
Mission 6

Administrative costs

  • Every policy must be designed, run, monitored and enforced.
  • These administrative costs use scarce resources: staff, inspections, IT, legal cases.
  • Firms bear compliance costs too: paperwork, reporting, meeting standards.
  • Illustrative data: a tax on a pollutant removes a welfare loss of 100 a year.
    • Collecting the tax and checking emissions costs 120 a year.
    • Net effect: 100 − 120 = −20. Society is worse off: government failure.
  • Costs can exceed gains when the externality is small, or polluters are many and small.
Mission 6

Conflicting objectives

  • Governments pursue many goals at once: cleaner air, low prices, jobs, tax revenue, re-election.
  • A policy that serves one goal can harm another, so it may be set at the wrong level, or dropped.
  • Real world: the UK planned yearly inflation-linked rises in fuel duty. They were cancelled every year from 2011 to 2025, and duty was cut by 5p a litre in 2022, after fuel prices jumped.
  • Tobacco taxes aim to cut smoking, yet they also raise revenue that depends on people still smoking.
  • Say: "conflicting objectives" — not: "the government did not care". Both goals may be valid.
Mission 6

Capture and political incentives

  • Regulatory capture: a regulator comes to serve the industry it regulates, not the public.
    • Close contacts; staff moving between regulator and industry; lobbying.
  • Asymmetric information in regulation: the firm knows its true costs and harm; the regulator does not. Firms can overstate the cost of meeting rules.
  • Political incentives: politicians face elections. They may favour quick, visible gains over long-term benefits (short-termism), or respond to strong lobby groups.
  • These are why some economists argue that intervention should be limited to clear, large market failures; others argue for better-designed institutions instead.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a city charges households for rubbish by weight. Households respond as planned and throw away less, a gain to society worth 2 million a year. Weighing every bin, sending bills and chasing unpaid ones costs 3 million a year. Which cause of government failure does this show?
Mission 6Evaluate

Market failure or government failure?

It depends on:

  • The size of the market failure. A large externality can justify intervention even if the policy is imperfect.
  • Information. Where the MEC can be measured, policy can be set closer to the optimum.
  • Flexibility. A tax can be adjusted as evidence comes in; a large project or a ban is harder to undo.
  • Effectiveness. Does the policy change behaviour? Inelastic demand can make a tax raise revenue but cut little harm.
  • Consequences for stakeholders. Who gains and who loses: consumers, producers, workers, taxpayers, the government, third parties.
  • Government failure is a reason to design policy carefully, not proof that intervention never works.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a market for private bus services gives too few journeys. The welfare loss is 300 a year. The government brings in a subsidy. Afterwards, the welfare loss is 80 a year and the subsidy scheme costs 150 a year to run. Has government failure occurred?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • At the social optimum MSB = MSC and total surplus is as large as possible: allocative efficiency.
  • Market failure (for example externalities and public goods) leaves output above or below that point, causing a welfare loss.

Mission 2

  • A negative production externality makes MSC = MPC + MEC lie above MPC.
  • The market produces where MPB = MPC: more than the social optimum where MSB = MSC.
  • The welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MSB from Q* to Qm, pointing to the social optimum.

Mission 3

  • A positive consumption externality puts MSB above MPB, so the market stops at Q1 < Q*, with a welfare loss.
  • A positive production externality puts MSC below MPC, with the same result: Q1 < Q*.
  • Merit goods are underconsumed because of imperfect information and external benefits; calling a good "merit" is a value judgement.
  • Governments may subsidise or provide such goods, often free at the point of use.

Mission 4

  • Every economy must answer what, how and for whom; systems differ in ownership and in their coordinating mechanism.
  • Free market: prices and private ownership. Planned: the state owns and plans. Mixed: both; every real economy is mixed.

Mission 5

  • Correcting an externality means making decision-makers face the external cost or benefit, to reach Q*, not zero.
  • Taxes and subsidies change the price; regulation and bans set rules.
  • Permits cap the total and let trading find the cheapest cuts.

Mission 6

  • Government failure: intervention that causes a net welfare loss compared with the market outcome.
  • Causes: inadequate information, price distortion, unintended consequences, administrative costs, conflicting objectives, regulatory capture and political incentives.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Market failure and intervention for Edexcel A-level Economics B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?
  2. Mission 2Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  3. Mission 3If a vaccine also protects the people around you, why might too few people get one?
  4. Mission 4Who decides what gets made: prices, planners or a mix of the two?
  5. Mission 5Should a government tax pollution, ban it, or let firms buy and sell the right to pollute?
  6. Mission 6When a government steps in to fix a market, how can it end up making things worse?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · Edexcel B