← A-Level Economics · Edexcel B A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Pearson Edexcel A-level Economics B (9EB0) · 2.5 The economic cycle (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

The economic cycle (part 2)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1What makes prices across a whole economy keep going up?
  2. Mission 2If all pay rose as fast as prices, would inflation still hurt anyone?
  3. Mission 3Who counts as unemployed, and who slips through the count?
  4. Mission 4Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?
  5. Mission 5Why can jobs sit empty in one place while people elsewhere cannot find work?
Mission 1

Mission 1: What makes prices across a whole economy keep going up?

Make a guess: What makes prices across a whole economy keep going up?

Mission 1

Two routes to inflation

Two routes to inflationDemand-pull: AD shifts rightPrice level0P2P1Real national output (Y)AD1SRASAD2pullCost-push: SRAS shifts leftPrice level0P2P1Real national output (Y)ADSRAS1SRAS2push
  • Inflation: a sustained rise in the general price level.
  • In the AD/AS model, the price level rises in two ways:
    • AD shifts right: spending pulls prices up → demand-pull inflation
    • SRAS shifts left: costs push prices up → cost-push inflation
  • One shift gives a one-off rise in the price level. Ongoing inflation needs the shift to keep happening.
  • Say: "inflation is a rising price level" — not: "inflation means prices are high".
Mission 1

Demand-pull inflation

Demand-pull inflationPrice level0P3P2P1Y1Y2Y3YfeReal national output (Y)ASAD1AD2AD3
  • Demand-pull: AD grows faster than the economy's capacity to produce.
  • "Too much money chasing too few goods."
  • What can push AD right: lower interest rates, easy credit, rising house prices (wealth), high confidence, an export boom, more government spending, tax cuts.
  • With spare capacity, extra AD mostly raises real output.
  • Near full capacity, firms cannot expand much, so extra AD mostly raises the price level.
  • On a Keynesian AS curve: the steeper the section AD moves along, the more of the rise is in prices.
Quick check
?Interest rates are cut and house prices climb, so households borrow and spend more. The economy is already close to full capacity. Which best describes what happens in the short run?
Mission 1

Cost-push inflation

Cost-push inflationPrice level0P2P1Y2Y1 = YfeReal national output (Y)ADSRAS1LRASSRAS2stagflationHigher costs shift SRAS left:wagesenergy,rawmaterialsimportedinputsindirecttaxes
  • Cost-push: firms' costs rise, so they supply less at each price level. SRAS shifts left.
  • Sources of higher costs:
    • wages rising faster than productivity
    • energy and raw materials (commodity prices)
    • imported inputs (a weaker currency or dearer world prices)
    • indirect taxes on inputs or goods
  • Result: the price level rises and real output falls. Unemployment rises: stagflation.
  • Real world: wholesale energy prices jumped in 2021–22. UK CPI inflation reached 11.1% in October 2022; energy and food were the largest contributors.
  • Say: "costs shift SRAS left" — not: "costs shift AD".
Mission 1Graph lab

Pull or push?

Illustrative data. The economy starts in long-run equilibrium: price level 110, real output 2,000 (potential). Two sliders: AD shift and SRAS shift.

Pull or push?Price levelReal national output (Y)1,8002,0002,200100110120LRASADSRAS
  • Takeaway: both raise the price level by about 4.5%. Demand-pull comes with more output; cost-push with less.
Quick check
?Illustrative data for one country over a year.
Year 1Year 2
Price level (index)100104
Real GDP (billions)500490
Unemployment rate5%6%

What is the most likely cause of the inflation?

Mission 1

Imported inflation and commodity prices

Cost-push inflationPrice level0P2P1Y2Y1 = YfeReal national output (Y)ADSRAS1LRASSRAS2stagflationHigher costs shift SRAS left:wagesenergy,rawmaterialsimportedinputsindirecttaxes
  • Imported inflation: higher prices of imports feed through to home prices.
  • Two triggers:
    • world prices rise (oil, gas, metals, food: commodity prices)
    • the home currency depreciates, so each import costs more in home currency
  • Imported inputs raise firms' costs: a cost-push shift of SRAS. Imported consumer goods raise the CPI directly.
  • Real world: sterling fell sharply after the UK's EU referendum in June 2016. UK CPI inflation rose from 0.5% (June 2016) to 3.1% (November 2017).
  • Say: "a depreciation makes imports dearer" — not: "a weaker currency makes imports cheaper".
Quick check
?Country X's currency is the crown. A firm there imports a part priced at 50 euros. The exchange rate falls from 1 crown = 1.25 euros to 1 crown = 1.00 euro. By how much does the part's price in crowns change?
Mission 1

Expectations and the wage-price spiral

The wage-price spiralWage-price spiralprices riseworkers expectmore inflationhigher wageclaimsfirms' costs riseand round again
  • Inflation expectations: what workers and firms think inflation will be.
  • If workers expect prices to rise 5%, they bargain for pay rises of at least 5% to protect real wages.
  • Firms expecting higher costs raise prices in advance.
  • Wage-price spiral: higher prices → higher wage claims → higher costs → higher prices → …
  • Expectations can make inflation self-fulfilling and slow to fall.
  • That is why central banks try to keep expectations anchored to their inflation target.
  • Real world: in the UK in the 1970s, oil price rises fed into large wage claims. UK RPI inflation peaked at about 27% in August 1975.
Mission 1Evaluate

Which cause, and does it matter?

It depends on:

  • Spare capacity. The closer to full capacity, the more a rise in AD shows up as inflation.
  • One-off or ongoing. A single jump in oil prices raises the price level once. It becomes lasting inflation only if wages, expectations or money growth follow.
  • The policy response. Higher interest rates curb demand-pull well. Against cost-push, they cut inflation only by deepening the fall in output.
  • Mixed causes. Real episodes often combine both. 2021–22 saw energy shocks and strong post-pandemic demand.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. Over a year, an economy's price level rises 6% and real output grows 4%, taking it above its potential level. Unemployment falls to a record low. Firms report full order books and staff shortages. World energy and raw material prices are unchanged. What is the most likely main cause of the inflation?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If all pay rose as fast as prices, would inflation still hurt anyone?

Make a guess: If all pay rose as fast as prices, would inflation still hurt anyone?

Mission 2

Four words for changing prices

Four words for changing pricesInflation rate (%)-20246inflationdisinflationdeflationhyperinflation123456789YearPrice level (index)100120123456789Yearstill risingfallingIllustrative data.
  • Inflation: a sustained rise in the general price level.
  • Deflation: a sustained fall in the price level. The inflation rate is negative.
  • Disinflation: the inflation rate falls but stays positive. Prices still rise, more slowly.
  • Hyperinflation: extremely rapid inflation (a common benchmark: over 50% a month). Money loses its value fast.
  • Say: "inflation fell from 4% to 2%: disinflation" — not: "prices fell".
Mission 2

Worked example: reading the inflation rate

  • Illustrative data. Consumer price index (CPI) at the end of each year:
Year1234
CPI250260265.2262.5
  • Inflation rate = (new CPI − old CPI) ÷ old CPI × 100.
  • Year 2: (260 − 250) ÷ 250 × 100 = 4.0%. Inflation.
  • Year 3: (265.2 − 260) ÷ 260 × 100 = 2.0%. The rate fell but prices still rose: disinflation.
  • Year 4: (262.5 − 265.2) ÷ 265.2 × 100 = −1.0%. Prices fell: deflation.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A country's annual inflation rate was 3% in 2020, 5% in 2021, 2% in 2022 and −1% in 2023. In which year did the country have disinflation?
Mission 2

Expected or unexpected?

  • Nominal: measured in money. Real: adjusted for inflation (what the money buys).
  • Real interest rate ≈ nominal interest rate − inflation rate.
  • If inflation is fully expected, people build it in:
    • wages, pensions and benefits rise with prices
    • lenders set interest rates high enough to cover it
  • Then real incomes and real debts stay about the same.
  • If inflation is unexpected, contracts fixed in money terms no longer match prices. Real values change: wealth is redistributed.
  • Even fully expected inflation still has some costs.
  • Say: "a fall in real income" — not: "income fell" when money income rose more slowly than prices.
Mission 2

Worked example: who wins from a surprise?

  • Illustrative data. A bank lends 10,000 for one year at a fixed 5%. Repayment: 10,500.
  • Both sides expect 2% inflation. Expected real interest rate ≈ 5 − 2 = 3%.
  • Inflation turns out to be 7%.
  • Real interest rate ≈ 5 − 7 = −2%.
  • In start-of-year prices, 10,500 ÷ 1.07 = 9,813. The bank gets back less buying power than it lent.
  • Lender loses; borrower gains.
  • Also losing: savers on fixed rates, workers on fixed money wages, people on fixed money pensions.
  • Unexpected deflation works the other way: lenders gain, borrowers lose.
Quick check
?Inflation turns out much higher than anyone expected when contracts were signed. Who gains?
Mission 2

The costs of inflation

  • Menu costs: time and money spent changing prices (price lists, labels, websites).
  • Shoe-leather costs: time and effort spent holding less cash and moving money around to protect its value.
  • Uncertainty: high, variable inflation makes future costs and revenue hard to predict, so firms invest less. Growth can suffer.
  • Savings discouraged: if interest rates lag behind inflation, saving loses real value.
  • International competitiveness: if inflation is higher than in trading partners, exports get dearer and imports relatively cheaper (unless the exchange rate falls to offset it). The current account can worsen.
  • Inefficient resource allocation: when all prices rise fast, changes in relative prices are hard to spot, so price signals work less well.
  • Fiscal drag: if tax thresholds stay fixed while pay rises with prices, more income is taxed at higher rates.
  • Most costs grow with the rate of inflation and with how unpredictable it is.
Mission 2

Hyperinflation: when money stops working

  • At very high inflation, money fails at its jobs:
    • store of value: savings in cash are wiped out
    • medium of exchange: sellers refuse it and people turn to barter or foreign currency
    • unit of account: prices change too fast to compare
  • Real world: Zimbabwe's official annual inflation reached 231 million per cent in July 2008.
  • In 2009 Zimbabwe allowed foreign currencies such as the US dollar and the South African rand, and people stopped using its own currency.
  • Hyperinflations usually end only with a new currency or a new monetary regime (money growth).
Mission 2

Deflation: good news or bad?

Benign and malign deflationBenign deflation: SRAS shifts rightPrice level0P1P2Y1Y2Real national output (Y)ADSRAS1SRAS2Malign deflation: AD shifts leftPrice level0P1P2Y2Y1 = Yfenegative output gapReal national output (Y)AD1SRASLRASAD2
  • Benign ("good") deflation: SRAS shifts right (higher productivity, cheaper commodities, new technology).
    • Price level falls, real output rises, unemployment falls.
  • Malign ("bad") deflation: AD shifts left (weak confidence, a credit crunch, a world recession).
    • Price level falls, real output falls, unemployment rises.
  • Most worries about deflation are about the malign kind.
Mission 2Graph lab

Two kinds of falling prices

Illustrative data. The economy starts in long-run equilibrium: price level 110, real output 2,000 (potential).

Two kinds of falling pricesPrice levelReal national output (Y)1,8002,0002,200100110120LRASADSRAS
  • Takeaway: the same fall in prices can come with a slump (AD) or a boom (SRAS). The cause decides the cost.
Mission 2

The costs of deflation

The deflationary spiralprices fallspending delayedAD fallsoutput and jobs fallprices fall furtherreal debtrises
  • Deferred consumption: if prices are expected to fall, households wait to buy. AD falls further.
  • Real value of debt rises: debts are fixed in money, but prices and incomes fall. Borrowers cut spending; some go bankrupt.
  • Unemployment: firms' revenue falls, but money wages are sticky downwards, so real wages rise and firms cut jobs (cyclical unemployment).
  • Policy ineffectiveness: interest rates cannot go far below zero, so real interest rates (≈ nominal − inflation) stay high when prices fall.
  • Deflationary spiral: falling prices → spending delayed → AD falls → output and jobs fall → prices fall further → …
  • Real world: US consumer prices fell by about a quarter from 1929 to 1933.
  • Real world: Japan's consumer prices fell in most years from 1999 to 2012, with interest rates close to zero.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm owes 100,000 on a loan with no interest. Over a year, the price level falls by 10%, and so do the prices the firm charges. What happens to the real burden of the debt?
Mission 2Evaluate

How much does inflation hurt?

It depends on:

  • The rate and its stability. Low, steady inflation costs little; high, volatile inflation costs a lot.
  • Whether it is expected. Expected inflation is built into wages and interest rates; surprises redistribute.
  • Indexation. Pensions, benefits and tax thresholds linked to prices protect people on fixed incomes.
  • Inflation abroad. What matters for competitiveness is inflation relative to trading partners, and the exchange rate.
  • Low inflation is not zero inflation. Many central banks target about 2%: a small positive rate lets real wages adjust without money pay cuts and leaves room above zero for interest rates.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A family takes a one-year loan from a bank at a fixed 4% interest rate. Both sides expect 3% inflation. Instead, prices fall by 1% over the year. Who gains from the surprise?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Who counts as unemployed, and who slips through the count?

Make a guess: Who counts as unemployed, and who slips through the count?

Mission 3

Three groups, not two

Who is in the labour forceLabour force (economically active): 30 mWorking-age population (16+): 50 mEmployed: 28.5 mUnemployed (ILO): 1.5 mEconomically inactive: 20 mUnemployment rate = 1.5 ÷ 30 = 5%Illustrative data.
  • Start with the working-age population.
  • UK: everyone aged 16 and over.
  • Split it three ways:
    • Employed: did any paid work in the survey week (even 1 hour), or has a job but is temporarily away.
    • Unemployed: no job, available to start, and actively looking for work.
    • Economically inactive: everyone else.
  • ILO definition of unemployed: without a job, looked for work in the last 4 weeks, can start in the next 2 weeks (or has found a job and is waiting to start it).
  • Labour force = employed + unemployed.
  • The labour force is also called the economically active population.
Mission 3

Worked example: the unemployment rate

  • Illustrative data. Working-age population 50 m: employed 28.5 m, unemployed 1.5 m, inactive 20 m.
  • Labour force = 28.5 + 1.5 = 30 m.
  • Unemployment rate = unemployed ÷ labour force × 100.
  • = 1.5 ÷ 30 × 100 = 5%.
  • Not 1.5 ÷ 50 (= 3%): the inactive are not in the labour force.
  • Economic inactivity rate = inactive ÷ working-age population × 100 = 20 ÷ 50 × 100 = 40%.
  • UK practice: ONS quotes employment and inactivity rates for ages 16–64; the unemployment rate uses everyone 16 and over.
  • Say: "5% of the labour force" — not: "5% of the population".
Mission 3

Inactive is not unemployed

  • Economically inactive: not working and not both looking and available.
  • Who? Full-time students, retired people, people looking after family, the long-term sick or disabled.
  • And discouraged workers: they want a job but have stopped looking, because they think none is available.
  • Discouraged workers are not counted as unemployed. Joblessness is understated.
  • Say: "economically inactive" — not: "unemployed", for someone who is not looking for work.
Quick check
?Illustrative data for a country: working-age population 8.0 m, employed 4.6 m, unemployed 0.4 m, inactive 3.0 m. What is the unemployment rate?
Mission 3

Two ways to count

Two ways to count unemploymentLabour Force Survey (ONS)no job?looked in last 4 weeks?can start in 2 weeks?Unemployed (ILO)Claimant Countclaims for unemploymentbenefitClaimantsUnemployed (ILO)Claimant countSurveyonlyClaimantsonlyBoth
  • Labour force survey (ask people):
    • interviewers question a large sample of households about the week before
    • anyone who meets the ILO definition is counted as unemployed
    • UK: the Labour Force Survey (LFS), run by the ONS, gives the ILO unemployment figure
  • Claimant count (count benefit claims):
    • counts people claiming benefits because they are unemployed
    • comes straight from benefit records, so no survey is needed
    • UK: people claiming Jobseeker's Allowance, plus Universal Credit claimants who are required to look for work
Mission 3

Which count is better?

Labour force survey (ILO)Claimant count
Who is countedEveryone meeting the ILO definitionOnly people claiming the benefits
MissesSampling error; people may answer wronglyJobless people not eligible or not claiming (e.g. partner earns, savings, aged under 18)
Changes in the rulesSame definition over time and across countriesBenefit rules change, so the count changes even if joblessness does not
Speed and costSlower and costlyQuick, cheap, available for small local areas
  • So the two figures usually differ, and can move apart.
  • Before Universal Credit, the UK claimant count was usually well below ILO unemployment.
Quick check
?Which person would be counted as unemployed in a labour force survey using the ILO definition, but not in the claimant count?
Mission 3

The UK's two measures in practice

  • ONS publishes both every month.
  • Universal Credit (introduced from 2013) changed who must look for work to keep receiving benefit.
    • Some people in low-paid work must now look for more work and are included in the claimant count.
    • From spring 2020 until mid-2025 the claimant count was higher than LFS unemployment (ONS). Before 2020 it was lower.
  • The LFS has its own problem: fewer households answer.
    • Response fell sharply by 2023. ONS paused its usual LFS estimates in October 2023 and published adjusted figures instead.
    • Reweighted LFS estimates returned in February 2024, labelled "official statistics in development".
  • Lesson: every measure depends on its method. Check how the data were collected before comparing years.
Mission 3

What the rate misses

Hidden in the numbersLabour force 30 mBeforeLabour force 29.5 mAfter0.5 m stop looking(hidden unemployment)underemployment: part-time, wantfull-time (counted as employed)Unemployment rate: 5% → 3.4%, but no onefound a job.Illustrative data: 0.5 m stop looking.
  • Hidden unemployment: discouraged workers count as inactive, not unemployed.
  • Underemployment:
    • part-time workers who want full-time work count as employed
    • people in jobs well below their skills count as employed too
  • Real case: in 2013 Spain's unemployment rate for under-25s was above 50% (Eurostat: 55.5%). Many under-25s are full-time students, so the youth labour force is small: this is a share of the young people in the labour force, not of all young people.
  • So the unemployment rate understates how many people want work, or more work.
Mission 3Evaluate

How well does the unemployment rate measure joblessness?

It depends on:

  • Hidden unemployment: in a long slump, more people give up looking. The rate can fall with no new jobs.
  • Underemployment: when firms cut hours instead of jobs, the rate rises less than lost work.
  • The method: survey response, benefit rules and the size of the informal economy all change what is counted.
  • So use it alongside other data: the employment rate, inactivity, hours worked and vacancies.
Mission check

?Illustrative data for a country (millions of people):
EmployedUnemployedInactive
Year 19.00.605.40
Year 29.00.455.55

Which statement is correct?

Mission 4

Mission 4: Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?

Make a guess: Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?

Mission 4

Between jobs

  • Frictional unemployment: people between jobs, searching for a suitable one.
  • Examples: a school leaver's first search, someone who quit to find better work, a worker who moved town.
  • Cause: imperfect information. Matching workers to vacancies takes time.
  • Usually short-term. Some is unavoidable, even useful: a good match raises productivity.
  • Seasonal unemployment: jobs that disappear at certain times of year (farm harvests, beach resorts, ski resorts, winter construction).
  • Seasonal unemployment is predictable and recurs every year.
Mission 4

The wrong skills, the wrong place

  • Structural unemployment: a mismatch between the skills or locations of the jobless and the jobs on offer.
  • Cause: the pattern of demand and production changes: industries decline, new ones grow.
  • Occupational immobility: workers lack the skills for new jobs (a laid-off steelworker cannot become a nurse overnight).
  • Geographical immobility: jobs are elsewhere, but moving is costly (house prices, family ties).
  • Technological unemployment: machines or software replace a skill, a type of structural unemployment.
  • Often long-term, and concentrated in particular regions.
  • Employment patterns: as economies develop, jobs shift from farming to industry to services. Agriculture's share of world employment fell from over 40% in 1991 to under 30% by 2019 (ILO estimates, World Bank).
  • The global labour force grew as China and India joined world trade. Some manufacturing jobs moved to lower-cost countries: structural unemployment where those jobs were lost.
Mission 4

Not enough demand

Cyclical unemploymentPrice level0P1P2Y1Yfenegative output gapReal national output (Y)AD1AD1SRASLRASAD2Fewer workers are neededGrey: out of work (cyclical unemployment)
  • Cyclical unemployment: caused by too little aggregate demand, in a downturn or recession.
  • Also called demand-deficient unemployment.
  • AD falls → firms sell less → they need fewer workers (labour is a derived demand).
  • Real national output falls below full-employment output: a negative output gap.
  • It affects many industries and regions at once.
  • Real case: UK unemployment rose from about 5% in early 2008 to 8.4% in late 2011 (ONS, Labour Force Survey).
Quick check
?A car factory installs robots to do its welding. The welders it lays off have no skills that other employers in the area want. Which type of unemployment is this?
Mission 4

Wages stuck above equilibrium

Wages above equilibriumReal wage rate (W/P)0WminWeL1LeL2unemployment (excess supply of labour)Quantity of labour (L)D(L)S(L)Wmin
  • If wages are held above the market-clearing level, more people want to work than firms want to hire.
  • The excess supply of labour is unemployment.
  • This is real-wage unemployment (also called classical unemployment).
  • Causes: a minimum wage set above equilibrium; trade union bargaining; wages that do not fall when demand for labour falls.
  • Debate: whether minimum wages cost jobs in practice depends on the level set and the market. Studies disagree; the evidence is in a later lesson.
  • Say: "an excess supply of labour at the minimum wage" — not: "a shortage of workers".
Mission 4Graph lab

When wages cannot fall

Illustrative data.

When wages cannot fallReal wage rate (W/P)Quantity of labour (L)02507501,00005152060010DSminimum wage (not binding)
  • Takeaway: when wages cannot fall, a fall in labour demand shows up as unemployment, not as lower pay.
A fall in demand for labour with a wage that does not fallReal wage rate (W/P)0W1L2L1unemploymentQuantity of labour (L)D(L)1S(L)D(L)2The wage stays at W1
Mission 4

The natural rate

The natural rate of unemploymentUnemployment rate (illustrative data)natural ratefrictionalstructuralseasonalcyclical
  • Even at full-employment output, some people are unemployed. Full employment does not mean zero unemployment.
  • Natural rate of unemployment: the unemployment rate when output is at its full-employment level.
  • It is the unemployment that remains when the labour market is in equilibrium: frictional, structural and seasonal.
  • So: cyclical unemployment = actual rate − natural rate.
  • The natural rate changes slowly: with skills, mobility, benefit rules, demographics and technology.
Mission 4

Worked example: splitting the rate

  • Illustrative data. Actual unemployment rate 7%. Frictional 1.5%, structural 3.5%.
  • Seasonal 0.5%.
  • Natural rate = 1.5 + 3.5 + 0.5 = 5.5%.
  • Cyclical = 7 − 5.5 = 1.5 percentage points.
  • Cyclical unemployment above zero means output is below full employment.
  • Say: "1.5 percentage points above the natural rate" — not: "1.5% above".
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a country's unemployment rate is 6.5%. Its natural rate is estimated at 4.5%. Which statement is correct?
Mission 4

The costs of unemployment

  • Personal: lost income; skills fade; stress and worse mental and physical health.
  • Social: links with crime and family strain; whole communities decline when a big employer closes; inequality rises.
  • Economic:
    • lost output that can never be recovered: the economy is inside its PPC
    • lower tax revenue and higher benefit spending, so a larger budget deficit
    • long spells reduce skills, so potential output may fall too
  • For firms: lower sales, but easier recruiting and less pressure on wages.
  • Say: "benefits are a transfer" — not: "benefits are lost output". The lost output is what the unemployed could have produced.
Quick check
?A deep recession keeps unemployment high for three years. Which effect could reduce the economy's potential output, not just its actual output?
Mission 4Evaluate

How serious is a rise in unemployment?

It depends on:

  • The type and length: short frictional spells can improve job matches; long spells cut skills and can raise the natural rate.
  • Who and where: losses concentrated in one region or group cause deeper social costs than the same rise spread thinly.
  • Support and policy response: benefits, retraining and quick action on demand reduce the lasting damage.
  • What else is happening: rising unemployment with falling inflation leaves room for demand-side policy; with high inflation, the choice is harder.
Mission check

?Four people are unemployed in the same country. Aggregate demand then rises, and output returns to its full-employment level. Whose unemployment is most likely to end because of the rise in demand?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why can jobs sit empty in one place while people elsewhere cannot find work?

Make a guess: Why can jobs sit empty in one place while people elsewhere cannot find work?

Mission 5

Two kinds of immobility

Two barriersOccupational immobilityqualificationskills and trainingGeographical immobilityno jobs herejobs herelow priceshigh prices
  • Labour mobility: how easily workers can move between jobs and places.
  • Occupational immobility: barriers to changing job or occupation.
    • lack of skills or qualifications for the new job
    • time and cost of training; licences (nursing, electricians)
    • age, confidence, discrimination
  • Geographical immobility: barriers to changing location.
    • big gaps in house prices and rents between regions
    • family ties, children's schooling
    • cost of moving; poor information about jobs elsewhere
  • Say: "immobility of labour causes structural unemployment" — not: "immobility is unemployment". Immobility is a cause; unemployment can be its effect.
Quick check
?A steelworker loses her job when the plant closes. There are vacancies for software testers in the same town, but she has none of the skills they ask for. Which barrier is she facing?
Mission 5

Why immobility is a market failure

  • Demand for labour keeps changing: some industries shrink, others grow.
  • Mobile workers move to the growing jobs, and wage differences signal where to go.
  • Immobile workers cannot respond to those signals.
  • Result: surpluses of labour in some markets, shortages in others, at the same time.
  • Labour is misallocated, so output is below what the economy could produce.
  • It is a market failure in society: unemployed workers in one place, unfilled vacancies in another.
  • It causes structural unemployment: industries decline (e.g. coal, steel), or technological change replaces jobs, and workers cannot move into the new ones.
  • Not the same as cyclical unemployment, caused by a fall in aggregate demand across the economy.
  • Impacts: lost output and income, skills decay the longer people are out of work, and higher benefit spending with lower tax revenue.
Mission 5

Policies to improve mobility

  • Occupational mobility:
    • education, training and apprenticeships; retraining grants for adults
    • recognising qualifications from other regions and countries
    • better careers information
  • Geographical mobility:
    • more housing where the jobs are (planning reform, house building)
    • relocation grants; better transport links
    • online job information across regions
  • Move jobs to people: regional policy, e.g. grants or tax breaks for firms that invest in high-unemployment areas.
Mission 5

Migration and the labour market

Migration and the labour marketWage rate (W)0W1W2L1L2Quantity of labour (L)S1D1S2Supply shifts right: the wage falls
  • Immigration adds workers: the supply of labour shifts right (S1 → S2).
  • On its own: the wage falls and employment rises in that market.
  • But migrants also spend their wages. Labour is a derived demand, so the demand for labour shifts right too (D1 → D2).
  • Migrants may complement local workers (different skills), raising local workers' productivity, not competing with them.
  • They can fill skill shortages, e.g. in health and social care.
  • Most migrants are of working age, so they can add more in taxes than they use in services; the size of this effect depends on their jobs and pay.
  • Emigration has its own effects on the country people leave:
    • brain drain: it loses skilled workers it paid to train
    • but it gains money sent home by emigrants (remittances), and unemployment can fall
Mission 5Graph lab

Do new workers push wages down?

Illustrative data. One local labour market: wage 14 per hour, 100 thousand workers.

Do new workers push wages down?Wage per hourWorkers (thousands)0501502000102010014DS
  • Takeaway: if demand for labour rises as much as supply, the wage need not fall; who gains and who loses depends on the size of each shift.
Migration and the labour marketWage rate (W)0W1W1 = W3W2L1L2L3Quantity of labour (L)S1D1S2D2Supply shifts right: the wage fallsMigrants spend: demand shifts right too
Mission 5

Real world: what the evidence says

  • UK free movement for EU citizens ended on 31 December 2020. From 1 January 2021, a points-based immigration system applied to EU and non-EU workers alike.
  • A UK government advisory body (the Migration Advisory Committee, 2018) found migrants had "no or little impact" on the overall employment and unemployment of UK-born workers.
  • It added that effects may be more negative for lower-skilled and more positive for higher-skilled UK-born workers.
  • Geographical immobility: in England in 2023, a typical home cost 8.3 times the annual earnings of a full-time employee working in the same area. In 82% of London local authorities the ratio was above 12 (ONS).
  • So high-wage areas with high housing costs can find it hard to attract workers from cheaper regions.
Mission 5Evaluate

Will the policy work?

It depends on:

  • Substitutes or complements. Migrants with the same skills as local workers compete for jobs; those with different skills can raise local workers' pay.
  • Time. In the short run supply shifts first; over time demand rises as migrants spend and firms invest.
  • The cause of the problem. Retraining fixes occupational immobility but not a housing shortage; relocation grants fail if there are no affordable homes.
  • Government failure. Training schemes may teach skills employers do not want; policies are costly and take years.
Mission check

?A car factory closes. Hundreds of former car workers in the town are unemployed, while the town's hospital cannot fill vacancies for health care assistants. Which policy targets the main cause best?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Demand-pull: AD shifts right faster than capacity; prices and real output rise together.
  • Cost-push: higher costs shift SRAS left; prices rise while output falls.
  • Expectations, wage claims and import prices can keep inflation going.

Mission 2

  • Inflation is a rising price level; disinflation is a falling positive rate; deflation is a falling price level.
  • Unexpected inflation moves wealth from lenders, savers and people on fixed incomes to borrowers; unexpected deflation does the reverse.
  • Inflation also brings menu and shoe-leather costs, uncertainty and weaker competitiveness; malign deflation can spiral into falling output and jobs.

Mission 3

  • Working-age population = employed + unemployed + inactive. Labour force = employed + unemployed.
  • Unemployment rate = unemployed ÷ labour force × 100.
  • Survey (ILO) and claimant count measure different things and often differ.
  • Discouraged and underemployed workers are not counted as unemployed, so the rate understates joblessness.

Mission 4

  • Frictional: between jobs. Structural: skills or location mismatch. Cyclical: too little aggregate demand.
  • Seasonal: jobs that vanish at certain times of year.
  • Real-wage: wages held above equilibrium.
  • Costs are personal, social and economic; lost output is never recovered.

Mission 5

  • Occupational immobility (skills) and geographical immobility (place) leave surpluses and shortages side by side: a market failure and a cause of structural unemployment.
  • Immigration shifts labour supply right, and demand right as migrants spend: the wage effect depends on both shifts.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Economic cycle (part 2) for Edexcel A-level Economics B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1What makes prices across a whole economy keep going up?
  2. Mission 2If all pay rose as fast as prices, would inflation still hurt anyone?
  3. Mission 3Who counts as unemployed, and who slips through the count?
  4. Mission 4Why are some people out of work even when the economy is booming?
  5. Mission 5Why can jobs sit empty in one place while people elsewhere cannot find work?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · Edexcel B