← A-Level Economics · CCEA A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Economics (AS and A2) · Market failure (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Market failure (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why can a used car that runs perfectly be hard to sell for what it is worth?
  2. Mission 2How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?
  3. Mission 3If almost everyone in a country gets richer, can more people end up counted as poor?
  4. Mission 4Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why can a used car that runs perfectly be hard to sell for what it is worth?

Make a guess: Why can a used car that runs perfectly be hard to sell for what it is worth?

Mission 1

What markets need to know

  • Markets allocate resources well when buyers and sellers know the prices, the quality and the consequences of what they trade.
  • Imperfect information: people lack some of this knowledge, so they make choices they would not make if fully informed.
  • Information failure: missing or uneven information leads to a misallocation of resources: a market failure.
Mission 1

Asymmetric information

Who knows more?The seller knows moreSellerBuyer?used car, repair, financial productThe buyer knows moreSeller?Buyerinsurance customer, borrower
  • Asymmetric information: one party to a deal knows more than the other.
  • The seller knows more:
    • a used car's history
    • whether a repair was needed
    • the risks of a financial product
  • The buyer knows more:
    • an insurance customer knows their own health or driving
    • a borrower knows how likely they are to repay
  • The better-informed side can gain at the other's expense, so the other side trades less, or not at all.
  • Say: "asymmetric information" — not: "imperfect information", when one side knows more than the other.
Quick check
?Which situation is an example of asymmetric information?
Mission 1

Hidden quality: the used-car problem

The used-car market shrinksused-car lotbuyers' offer: averagebuyers' offer: lowerBuyers cannot tell good from poor.Owners of good cars keep them:they are driven off the lot.Only poor cars are left.hidden quality
  • Used cars are either good or poor ("lemons"). The seller knows which. The buyer cannot tell.
  • So buyers will pay only what an average car is worth to them.
  • Owners of good cars get less than their car is worth, so many keep them.
  • Fewer good cars on sale → the average falls → buyers offer even less.
  • The market can shrink until mostly poor cars are traded. Good cars that both sides would gladly trade are not sold.
  • Idea from George Akerlof, "The Market for Lemons" (1970).
Mission 1

Worked example: what will a buyer pay?

  • Illustrative data.
Worth to a buyerLowest price its owner accepts
Good car10,0008,000
Poor car4,0003,000
  • Half the cars are good, half are poor. A buyer cannot tell which is which.
  • Expected value to a buyer = 0.5 × 10,000 + 0.5 × 4,000 = 7,000.
  • So buyers offer at most 7,000.
  • Good-car owners want at least 8,000. 7,000 < 8,000 → they withdraw.
  • Now only poor cars are left, so buyers will pay at most 4,000.
  • Every good car is worth more to a buyer (10,000) than to its owner (8,000), yet none is sold.
Mission 1Graph lab

When do good cars disappear?

Same illustrative cars as the previous screen.

When do good cars disappear?PriceQuantity of used cars04,0008,00012,000good-car owners' minimum 8,000poor-car owners' minimum 3,000D1 (offer 7,000)
  • Takeaway: good cars sell only when at least two-thirds of cars on offer are good; below that, the market shrinks to poor cars.
Mission 1

Moral hazard

Before and after the dealBefore the dealcontract signedAfter the dealmoral hazardmore risk; others bear the cost
  • Moral hazard: after a deal, one party takes more risk because someone else bears the cost, and the other party cannot see it.
  • Examples:
    • an insured driver takes less care with the car
    • a worker on a fixed wage, who cannot be monitored, works less hard
    • a bank takes bigger risks if it expects the government to rescue it ("too big to fail")
  • Financial sector: in 2008, governments in the UK, the US and elsewhere rescued large banks. Rescues protect the economy now but can encourage risky lending later.
  • Responses: insurance excess (the customer pays the first part of any claim); rules on how much capital banks must hold.
Quick check
?A phone insurer offers cover with no excess. Afterwards it finds that customers often take their phones onto building sites without a protective case. Which concept best explains this?
Mission 1

Government responses

Government toolkit for information failureProvide information0–5Hygiene rating: 0 to 5inspected restaurantsNutrition labelon packaged foodLegislation and regulationThe rulebookminimum standards, disclosure
  • Provide information: make it public, free and easy to use.
    • Food hygiene ratings: in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, restaurants are inspected and rated from 0 to 5.
    • Nutrition labels; health campaigns on smoking.
  • Legislation and regulation: minimum standards, compulsory disclosure, consumer rights (e.g. a refund for faulty goods), bans on misleading adverts.
  • Private fixes also exist: warranties, independent inspections, online reviews.
  • Limits: information costs money to collect; people may ignore it; government may not know better than the market (government failure).
Quick check
?In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, food outlets are inspected and given a hygiene rating from 0 to 5. In England, displaying the rating at the door is voluntary. Which is the strongest reason this may not fully close the information gap in England?
Mission 1Evaluate

Should government close information gaps?

It depends on:

  • The cost of information: inspections and labels cost money; is the gain worth it?
  • Whether people use it: information is ignored if it is complex or people are biased (smokers already see warnings).
  • Whether government knows more: regulators may lack information too (government failure).
  • Private fixes: warranties, reviews and inspections may already close much of the gap.
Mission check

?Online, buyers of second-hand laptops cannot check whether a laptop's battery is healthy. Sellers know. Nothing else changes. Which outcome is most likely?
Mission 2

Mission 2: How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?

Make a guess: How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?

Mission 2

Income is a flow, wealth is a stock

Flow and stockincome(per year)wealth(at a point in time)interest,rent,dividends
  • Income: a flow of money over a period, e.g. per year.
    • wages, rent, interest, dividends, profit, government benefits
  • Wealth: a stock of assets owned at a point in time, minus debts.
    • property, savings, shares, pension funds
  • They feed each other: wealth earns income (rent, interest, dividends); saved income builds wealth.
  • So inequality in wealth tends to create inequality in income, and the reverse.
  • Say: "wealth is a stock; income is a flow" — not: "wealthy" means "high income". A retired homeowner can be wealthy on a low income.
Quick check
?Which of these is a change in a household's wealth rather than its income?
Mission 2

Equality or equity?

  • Equality: everyone has the same: equal incomes, wealth or opportunities.
  • Equity: fairness. What is fair is a value judgement: a normative question.
  • Equality of outcome: the same result for all. Equality of opportunity: the same chances, results may differ.
  • Horizontal equity: people in the same position are treated the same.
  • Vertical equity: people in different positions are treated differently, e.g. higher incomes pay a higher share in tax.
  • Say: "equity means fairness" — not: "equity means equality". An equitable distribution need not be equal.
Mission 2

The Lorenz curve

Lorenz curve and GiniCumulative % of income01001540100Cumulative % of populationABLine of equalityLorenz curveGini = A ÷ (A + B)
  • Line up everyone from poorest to richest.
  • Horizontal axis: cumulative % of population. Vertical axis: cumulative % of income (or wealth).
  • Line of equality: the 45° line. The bottom 20% get 20%, the bottom 40% get 40%, and so on.
  • The Lorenz curve shows the actual shares. It sags below the line of equality.
  • Read it: a point at (40, 15) means the poorest 40% receive 15% of income.
  • The further the curve from the line of equality, the more unequal the distribution.
Mission 2

The Gini coefficient

Lorenz curve and GiniCumulative % of income01001540100Cumulative % of populationABLine of equalityLorenz curveGini = A ÷ (A + B)
  • Gini coefficient = A ÷ (A + B).
    • A: area between the line of equality and the Lorenz curve.
    • B: area under the Lorenz curve.
  • 0 = perfect equality. 1 = perfect inequality (one person has everything). Often shown as 0–100.
  • You need to interpret the Gini coefficient, not calculate it.
  • UK disposable household income: Gini 32.9 on the 0–100 scale (financial year ending 2024, ONS).
  • Great Britain household wealth: Gini about 0.6, or 60 on the 0–100 scale (2018–2020, ONS). The richest 10% of households held 43% of all wealth; the poorest half held 9%.
  • World Bank Gini estimates (0–100 scale): South Africa 63.0 (2014); Brazil 48.9 (2020); Slovak Republic 23.2 (2019).
  • Countries survey in different years, so compare with care.
  • Limits: two different Lorenz curves can give the same Gini; a Gini does not show where the inequality lies, or how rich the country is.
Mission 2Graph lab

Moving the curve

Illustrative data. Quintile shares: 5%, 10%, 15%, 25%, 45%. Gini 0.38.

Moving the curveCumulative % of incomeCumulative % of population020406080100020406080100line of equalityLorenz curve
  • Takeaway: shifting income from richer to poorer groups pulls the Lorenz curve towards the line of equality; here the Gini falls from 0.38 to 0.30.
Quick check
?Two countries' Lorenz curves for income are drawn on one diagram. Country X's curve lies further from the line of equality than country Y's at every point. What can you conclude?
Mission 2

Why is income unequal?

  • Human capital: education and skills raise productivity and pay.
  • Ownership of wealth: land, property and shares earn rent, interest and dividends; inheritance passes them on.
  • Inequality of opportunity: family background affects schooling, contacts and health.
  • Discrimination by gender, ethnicity and others.
  • Power: bargaining power of unions, employers with monopsony power, top executives.
  • Tax and benefit policy: progressive taxes and benefits narrow gaps; regressive taxes widen them.
  • Globalisation and technological change: raise the pay of scarce skills; some routine jobs move abroad or are automated.
Mission 2

Inequality as a market failure, and its effects

  • Markets allocate goods to those willing and able to pay. A market can be efficient and still leave some with very little.
  • So an unequal distribution can be seen as a market failure: the market fails to produce an equitable outcome. Whether it does is a value judgement.
  • Effects:
    • individuals: worse health, education and housing for those on low incomes
    • growth: big rewards can create incentives to work and invest; but very unequal societies may waste talent, and an OECD study (2014) found rising inequality lowered growth in OECD countries
    • living standards and social stability: high inequality is linked to lower trust and more political tension
  • The evidence on growth points both ways, so economists disagree on how much inequality harms it.
Mission 2Evaluate

How much inequality is a problem?

It depends on:

  • Values. Fairness is a normative judgement; people disagree on how equal outcomes should be.
  • Causes. Inequality from effort and skill is viewed differently from inequality from inheritance, luck or discrimination.
  • Mobility. Wide gaps matter more if children of poor families stay poor.
  • Living standards of the poorest. Rising inequality with rising absolute incomes differs from falling incomes at the bottom.
  • Measurement. Income or wealth? Before or after taxes and benefits? Wealth is distributed far more unequally than income.
Mission check

?In country P, the Gini coefficient for household income is 0.30 and for household wealth is 0.65. (Illustrative data.) What can you conclude?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If almost everyone in a country gets richer, can more people end up counted as poor?

Make a guess: If almost everyone in a country gets richer, can more people end up counted as poor?

Mission 3

Two meanings of poverty

Two poverty linesWeekly income0500nine households, lowest to highest incomemedianabsolute poverty line (fixed in real terms)relative poverty line (60% of median)Illustrative data
  • Absolute poverty: income too low to pay for basic needs: food, clean water, shelter, clothing.
    • Measured against a line that is fixed in real terms (it rises only with prices).
  • Relative poverty: income far below the typical income of the same society.
    • Measured against a line that moves with the median income, e.g. 60% of median household income.
  • Median: the middle income when all households are lined up from lowest to highest.
  • Absolute poverty asks: can you survive? Relative poverty asks: can you take part in normal life where you live?
  • Say: "relative poverty is low income compared with the median" — not: "a milder form of absolute poverty".
Mission 3

Worked example: the line moves

The poverty line movesWeekly income (illustrative data)05001000nine households, lowest to highest incomemedian 400median 480relative line 240 = 60% of the median 400absolute line 200relative poverty 2/9 = 22%absolute poverty 1/9Bottom three households +2%, everyone else+20%. Dashed outlines: incomes before.relative line 288 = 60% of the new median480absolute line 200 (unchanged)relative poverty 3/9 = 33%absolute poverty 1/9
  • Illustrative data. Nine households, weekly income:
    • 150 · 220 · 280 · 340 · 400 · 460 · 520 · 650 · 900
  • Median = 400. Relative line = 0.6 × 400 = 240.
  • Below 240: two households (150, 220). Relative poverty rate = 2/9 = 22%.
  • Ten years later, in real terms: the bottom three gain 2%; everyone else gains 20%.
    • New median = 400 × 1.2 = 480. New line = 0.6 × 480 = 288.
    • Bottom three now: 153 · 224.4 · 285.6. All below 288.
    • Relative poverty rate = 3/9 = 33%.
  • Absolute line fixed at 200 (real terms): one household below it before (150), one after (153).
  • Everyone got richer. Relative poverty rose; absolute poverty did not.
Quick check
?Over 20 years, the real income of every household in a country doubles, including the median household's. The poverty lines are 60% of the median (relative) and a fixed basket of basic needs (absolute). What happens?
Mission 3

Poverty lines in practice

  • International poverty line (World Bank): $3.00 a day per person, at 2021 prices, adjusted for purchasing power parity (PPP).
    • PPP: adjusts for what money buys in each country, so $3.00 means the same basket everywhere.
    • It is an absolute line. It replaced $2.15 a day (2017 prices) in June 2025.
    • Higher lines for richer countries: $4.20 and $8.30 a day.
  • UK: relative low income = below 60% of median household income, before or after housing costs (BHC/AHC).
  • The UK also uses an "absolute low income" line: 60% of the 2010/11 median, held fixed in real terms.
Mission 3

Case: the numbers

  • World, below the international line:
    • 1990: around 2.3 billion people.
    • 2025: around 831 million: about 1 in 10 people.
  • UK, 2023/24, median income £650 a week (BHC). Line: 0.6 × 650 = £390 a week.
    • Relative low income: 17% of people BHC; 21% AHC.
    • Children: 31% AHC. Pensioners: 16% AHC.
  • These figures are for a couple with no children. So the UK relative line is about £28 a day each (390 ÷ 7 ÷ 2): far above the World Bank's $3.00 a day.
  • One country can cut absolute poverty fast while relative poverty barely moves.
Mission 3

Causes of poverty

Causes of povertyIndividuals and householdsunemploymentlow paylow skillssicknesscaring dutieslarge familiesdiscriminationlittle wealthpovertyEconomy and governmentrecessionrising prices ofessentialschanges to taxes andbenefitsconflict and climateshocks
  • Individuals and households:
    • unemployment, low pay, part-time or insecure work
    • low human capital: few skills or qualifications
    • sickness, disability, caring duties, old age
    • large families or one earner (e.g. lone parents)
    • discrimination (gender, ethnicity, disability) and unequal opportunity
    • owning little wealth or property: no income from rent, interest or profit
  • Economy and government:
    • recession, rising prices of essentials (food, energy, rents)
    • changes to taxes and benefits
    • conflict, weak institutions, climate shocks (low-income countries)
Mission 3

What changes the poverty count?

  • Absolute poverty falls when the real incomes of the poor rise.
  • Relative poverty falls only when the poor's incomes rise faster than the median.
  • So a recession can cut relative poverty: the median falls while benefits and pensions hold steady.
  • And fast growth can raise relative poverty, if gains go mostly to middle and high earners.
  • Say: "relative poverty fell because the median fell" — not: "the poor became better off".
Quick check
?During a recession, median household income falls by 5% in real terms. State pensions are held constant in real terms, and most pensioners' income comes from the state pension. What is most likely to happen to measured relative poverty among pensioners?
Mission check

?Over ten years, the real incomes of the poorest fifth of a country's households rise by 15%. Median real household income rises by 40%. Which outcome is most likely?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?

Make a guess: Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?

Mission 4

Equity is not equality

Equal vs equitableequality: same shareequity: fair shareshare givenwhat the person needs
  • Equality: everyone gets the same (income, wealth or opportunity).
  • Equity: a fair distribution. What is fair is a value judgement (normative).
  • Horizontal equity: people in the same position are treated the same (same income → same tax).
  • Vertical equity: people in different positions are treated differently (higher income → pay more).
  • Say: "an equitable distribution" (fair) — not: "an equal distribution", unless you mean identical shares.
Mission 4

Why redistribute?

  • In a free market, income depends on the factors you own and what they earn: wages, rent, interest, profit.
  • Some own little: low skills, no property, unable to work. Their market income may be very low.
  • Many economists call a very unequal outcome a market failure: markets can be efficient yet produce an inequitable result.
  • So inequality of income and wealth is often listed as a market failure: a failure of equity, not of efficiency.
  • Redistribution: government moves income or wealth from richer to poorer households, using:
    • taxes, transfers and benefits, state-provided services, and laws on pay.
Mission 4

Transfers: universal or means-tested?

Universal vs means-testedBenefit received0Incomeuniversalmeans-tested
  • Transfer payments: money paid by government with nothing produced in return: pensions, unemployment and disability benefits, child benefit.
  • Universal benefit: paid to everyone in a group, whatever their income (e.g. a state pension for all over an age).
  • Means-tested benefit: paid only to those with low income or wealth (e.g. the UK's Universal Credit).
UniversalMeans-tested
CostHigh: goes to rich and poorLower: targeted at the poor
Take-upHigh: no test, no stigmaLower: complex, some feel stigma
Work incentiveNot withdrawn as earnings riseWithdrawn as earnings rise: poverty trap
Mission 4

The poverty trap

The poverty trapNet income (£)0Gross earnings (£)taper 55%EMTR 67.6%keep everythingbenefitused upOf £100 extra earnings:£28 income tax and NI£39.60 benefit withdrawn£32.40 kept
  • Poverty trap: as a low earner earns more, benefits are withdrawn and taxes start, so they keep little of the rise.
  • Effective marginal tax rate (EMTR): share of an extra unit of earnings lost to tax and benefit withdrawal.
  • Case: UK, Universal Credit. For each extra £1 of net earnings, benefit falls by 55p (the taper rate, cut from 63% in November 2021).
  • Worked example: a basic-rate taxpayer on Universal Credit earns £100 more.
    • Income tax 20% + National Insurance 8% = £28. Net earnings rise by £72.
    • Benefit withdrawn: 55% × £72 = £39.60.
    • Kept: £72 − £39.60 = £32.40.
    • EMTR = 1 − 0.72 × 0.45 = 67.6%.
  • Say: combine the rates by multiplying what is kept (0.72 × 0.45) — not: by adding them (28% + 55% = 83%), since the taper applies to net earnings.
Mission 4Graph lab

Change the taper

The poverty trapNet income (£)0Gross earnings (£)taper 55%EMTR 67.6%keep everythingbenefitused upOf £100 extra earnings:£28 income tax and NI£39.60 benefit withdrawn£32.40 kept

Line: net income (after tax and benefits) against gross earnings. Flat line = nothing kept; 45° line = everything kept.

Change the taperNet income (£)Extra gross earnings a month (£)01,0002,0003,00006001,2001,8002,400flat: nothing kept45°: everything keptnet incomebenefit runs out
  • Takeaway: a higher taper flattens the line (stronger trap) but ends benefit sooner (cheaper). A lower taper helps work incentives but stretches benefit to higher earners.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A worker pays income tax at 20% on extra earnings. A means-tested benefit is withdrawn at 60% of each extra unit of net (after-tax) earnings. What is the worker's effective marginal tax rate?
Mission check

?A government wants to weaken the poverty trap for low-income working families on a means-tested benefit. Which change would do this most directly?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Information failure: missing or uneven information leads to a misallocation of resources.
  • Asymmetric information: one side knows more. Hidden quality can drive good products out of a market.
  • Moral hazard: after a deal, people take more risk when others bear the cost.
  • Governments respond with information provision and regulation.

Mission 2

  • Income is a flow; wealth is a stock. Wealth is usually distributed more unequally than income.
  • The Lorenz curve shows cumulative shares; the further it sags from the line of equality, the higher the Gini coefficient (0 = perfect equality, 1 = perfect inequality).
  • Causes include human capital, wealth ownership, discrimination, power, tax and benefits, and technology.

Mission 3

  • Absolute poverty: below a fixed real line for basic needs. Relative poverty: below a share (often 60%) of the median.
  • Growth cuts absolute poverty more reliably than relative poverty; a recession can even cut relative poverty.

Mission 4

  • Equity is fairness, a value judgement; equality means identical shares.
  • Means-tested benefits target the poor but create a poverty trap: a high effective marginal tax rate.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Market failure (part 2) for CCEA A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why can a used car that runs perfectly be hard to sell for what it is worth?
  2. Mission 2How can you sum up who gets what in a whole country with a single number?
  3. Mission 3If almost everyone in a country gets richer, can more people end up counted as poor?
  4. Mission 4Why can a pay rise leave a low-income family barely any better off?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · CCEA