← AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708) · 7.1 Utility; 7.2 Indifference curves and budget lines; 7.3 Efficiency and market failure; 7.4 Private costs and benefits, externalities and social costs and benefits
Mini-Lesson

The price system and the microeconomy (7.1–7.4)

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?
  2. Mission 2Why do people pay for a gym every month and then hardly ever go?
  3. Mission 3When rice got cheaper, why did some very poor families buy less of it?
  4. Mission 4If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?
  5. Mission 5Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?
  6. Mission 6Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  7. Mission 7How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Also part of this unit: 3 missions in Classification of goods and services; 1 mission in Demand and supply curves; Price, income and cross elasticity of demand; Price elasticity of supply.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?

Make a guess: Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?

Mission 1

What "rational" means

  • Economics models choices as rational: agents weigh benefits against costs and pick the option that best meets their objective.
  • Consumers aim to maximise utility (satisfaction).
  • Firms aim to maximise profit (total revenue − total cost).
Mission 1

Total and marginal utility

Total and marginal utilityTotal utility (utils)0123456Quantity (slices)203444505250TU peakTUIllustrative data: slices of pizza at one mealMarginal utility (utils)20141062−2MU = 0MU falls with each slice and crosses zerobetween slices 5 and 6, where TU peaks.
  • Total utility (TU): the whole satisfaction from all units consumed.
  • Marginal utility (MU): the change in TU from one more unit. MU = ΔTU ÷ ΔQ.
  • Slices of pizza at one meal (illustrative data, in "utils"):
SlicesTUMU
12020
23414
34410
4506
5522
650−2
  • Law of diminishing marginal utility: as more units are consumed, each extra unit adds less utility.
  • TU still rises while MU is positive. TU is at its maximum where MU = 0.
  • Say: "marginal utility falls" — not: "total utility falls" (TU rises until MU turns negative).
Quick check
?Glasses of juice drunk on a hot afternoon give these total utilities (illustrative data): 1 glass 12 utils, 2 glasses 22, 3 glasses 29, 4 glasses 33, 5 glasses 34. What is the marginal utility of the 4th glass?
Mission 1

From diminishing MU to the demand curve

From diminishing marginal utility to a demand curveEach extra unit adds less utilityMarginal utility12345Unit consumedso buyers will buy more only at a lower pricePrice0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDExtension of demand: a movement along D
  • A consumer buys one more unit only if its extra satisfaction is worth at least the price.
  • MU falls with each unit, so the most the consumer will pay for each extra unit falls too.
  • To persuade them to buy more, the price must be lower.
  • So quantity demanded rises as price falls: the demand curve slopes downward.
  • Say: "a fall in price causes an extension of demand" (a movement along D) — not: "demand increases".
Quick check
?Which statement best explains, using utility, why a demand curve usually slopes downward?
Mission 1

Worked example: equal MU per unit of money

Equi-marginal principle and demand for XUnitMUof XMU/Pof XMUof YMU/Pof Y1361215152279121231869949366MU/P of Xat £21813.594.5Buy the highest MU/P each time: Y1, X1, Y2, thenX2 and Y3. Spends all £9: 2 X and 3 Y.Price of X falls £3 → £2: now 3 X and 3 Y (MU/P= 9 for both).Demand for XPrice of X0£3£223Quantity of XDLower price, larger quantity demanded.Illustrative data.
  • Equi-marginal principle: with a limited income, utility is maximised when MU/P is equal for every good and all income is spent.
  • Good X costs £3, good Y costs £1. Income is £9.
  • Illustrative data:
UnitMU of XMU/P of XMU of YMU/P of Y
136121515
22791212
318699
49366
  • Step 1: buy the unit with the highest MU/P each time: Y1 (15), X1 (12), Y2 (12), then X2 and Y3 (9 each).
  • Step 2: spending = 2 × 3 + 3 × 1 = 9. All income spent.
  • Step 3: MU/P of X = 9 = MU/P of Y. 2 X and 3 Y, TU = 63 + 36 = 99, the most this income can buy.
Mission 1

Deriving demand from MU/P

Equi-marginal principle and demand for XUnitMUof XMU/Pof XMUof YMU/Pof Y1361215152279121231869949366MU/P of Xat £21813.594.5Buy the highest MU/P each time: Y1, X1, Y2, thenX2 and Y3. Spends all £9: 2 X and 3 Y.Price of X falls £3 → £2: now 3 X and 3 Y (MU/P= 9 for both).Demand for XPrice of X0£3£223Quantity of XDLower price, larger quantity demanded.Illustrative data.
  • Now the price of X falls from 3 to 2. MU/P of X rises: 18, 13.5, 9, 4.5.
  • MUx/Px > MUy/Py, so switching spending towards X raises total utility.
  • New optimum: 3 X and 3 Y (3 × 2 + 3 × 1 = 9; MU/P = 9 for both; TU = 117).
  • Two points on the demand curve for X: price 3 → 2 units; price 2 → 3 units.
  • Lower price, larger quantity demanded: a downward-sloping demand curve.
Mission 1

Decide at the margin: MB = MC

Marginal benefit and marginal cost of extra hoursMB, MC (money value)060402012345Extra hoursMBMCMB above MC: net benefit (hours 1 to 3)MB below MC (hours 4 and 5)Best choice: 3 hours. MB ≥ MC for the last unit.Illustrative data
  • Marginal benefit (MB): extra benefit from one more unit of an activity. Marginal cost (MC): extra cost of that unit.
  • Rule: do one more unit while MB ≥ MC. Stop where MB = MC.
  • A café decides how many extra hours to open (illustrative data, money values):
Extra hourMBMCMB − MC
1602040
2452520
335305
42530−5
51530−15
  • Best choice: 3 hours. Net benefit = 40 + 20 + 5 = 65. A 4th hour would cut it to 60.
  • Not where total benefit is biggest (5 hours), and not where MB − MC is biggest (hour 1).
Mission 1Graph lab

When the cost of each unit rises

Graph (illustrative data): MB falls from 60; MC rises from 15. They cross at quantity 3.

When the cost of each unit risesBenefit and costQuantity02468020406080330MBMC
  • Takeaway: anything that changes MB or MC moves the best choice; at the optimum, MB = MC.
Quick check
?A farmer can hire extra pickers by the day (illustrative data). The table gives each extra picker's marginal benefit and marginal cost. How many pickers should the farmer hire?
PickerMBMC
19040
27040
35040
43040
51040
Mission 1

Water and diamonds

The paradox of valueWater: plentiful, so the last litre adds littleMarginal utilitylowlargeQuantityMUDiamonds: scarce, so the last one adds a lotMarginal utilityhighsmallQuantityMU
  • The paradox of value: water is vital, diamonds are not, yet diamonds cost far more.
  • Water: plentiful. People already use a lot, so the MU of one more litre is tiny.
  • Diamonds: scarce. Few are owned, so the MU of one more diamond is high.
  • Price reflects marginal utility (what the next unit is worth), not total utility.
  • TU from water is enormous. MU of the last litre is small.
Mission 1Evaluate

How useful is the rational model?

  • Utility cannot be measured directly. "Utils" are a teaching device; economists infer preferences from choices.
  • It depends on information: real consumers rarely know every option and price.
  • It depends on effort and stakes: people use habits and shortcuts for small, frequent buys.
  • The model still predicts the direction of many responses well, e.g. buying less when price rises.
  • More on the limits: Mission 2.
Mission check

?A hiker has had no water all day on a hot trail and would pay a large amount for one bottle. At home, after drinking plenty, she would not pay even a small amount for one more bottle. Which explanation is best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do people pay for a gym every month and then hardly ever go?

Make a guess: Why do people pay for a gym every month and then hardly ever go?

Mission 2

The rational benchmark

  • Standard theory assumes consumers:
    • are rational: they weigh costs and benefits consistently;
    • maximise utility;
    • have perfect information;
    • are self-interested.
  • Behavioural economics uses psychology to test these assumptions against how people really choose.
  • Where people depart from the benchmark in predictable ways, economists call it a bias.
Mission 2

Bounded rationality

  • Bounded rationality: people try to choose well, but are limited by the information they have, the time they have and the brainpower they can spare.
  • So they often satisfice: choose an option that is "good enough" rather than the best.
  • Say: "bounded rationality" (limited ability to optimise) — not: "irrational" (no reasoning at all).
Mission 2

Rules of thumb and habit

  • A rule of thumb (heuristic): a mental shortcut that saves time.
    • "Buy the brand I bought last time."
    • "Pick the second-cheapest item on the menu."
  • Shortcuts are often sensible, but they can lead to choices a fully informed optimiser would not make.
  • Habits: repeated choices made with little thought, e.g. the same coffee every morning. A price rise may barely change behaviour in the short run.
Mission 2

Anchoring

Anchoring: the median estimate follows the anchorMedian estimate (%)0255025%Anchor 101045%Anchor 6565Estimates of the share of African countries inthe United NationsSource: Tversky and Kahneman (1974)
  • Anchoring: judgements are pulled towards an initial number (the anchor), even an irrelevant one.
  • Classic experiment (Tversky and Kahneman, 1974): people saw a "random" number, then estimated the percentage of African countries in the United Nations.
    • Group shown 10: median estimate 25%.
    • Group shown 65: median estimate 45%.
  • In shops: "Was 200, now 120" makes 120 look cheap.
Mission 2

Availability

  • Availability bias: people judge how likely an event is by how easily examples come to mind.
  • Vivid, recent or heavily reported events seem more likely than they are.
  • Example: after a widely reported plane crash, some travellers switch to driving, which is riskier per kilometre travelled.
  • Insurance demand often rises just after a disaster nearby, then fades.
Quick check
?A sofa shop displays a "Was 1,500" label above each sofa, crossed out, with the sale price of 900 underneath. Shoppers rate 900 as a bargain, even though similar sofas elsewhere cost 850. Which bias is the shop using?
Mission 2

Bounded self-control

Gym: plan versus realityOne month on a monthly contractover $70a monthon average 4.3 visits a monthover $17per visitmonthly contract$10per visit10-visit passSource: DellaVigna and Malmendier (2006), USgyms
  • Bounded self-control: people make plans for their future selves, then fail to stick to them.
  • Present benefits and costs loom larger than future ones (present bias).
  • Evidence (DellaVigna and Malmendier, 2006, US gyms):
    • Members on monthly contracts paid over $70 a month.
    • They went on average 4.3 times a month.
    • Cost per visit: more than $17, though a 10-visit pass cost $10 per visit.
  • When signing up, people overestimate how often their future self will go.
  • Other examples: saving too little for retirement; snacking against a diet plan.
Mission 2

Others' behaviour and social norms

  • Social norms: unwritten rules about what people around us do and approve of.
  • People copy others (herd behaviour): a long queue outside a restaurant signals "it must be good".
  • Fashion, smartphone choices and saving behaviour are all shaped by peers.
  • Demand then depends on what others buy, not only on price, income and own tastes.
Mission 2

Bounded selfishness: altruism and fairness

The ultimatum gamePlayer 1Player 2proposes a splitPot of moneyPlayer 1 keepsPlayer 2 getsslider: Player 1 chooses the splitPlayer 2 decidesAcceptboth get paidRejectboth get nothing
  • Bounded selfishness: people care about others, not only themselves.
  • Altruism: giving to charity, donating blood, tipping in a café you will never revisit.
  • Fairness: the ultimatum game.
    • Player 1 splits a sum of money; Player 2 accepts (both get paid) or rejects (both get nothing).
    • A purely self-interested Player 2 accepts any amount above zero.
    • In experiments, offers are typically 40–50% of the sum, and offers under 20% are often rejected.
  • Rejecting money to punish unfairness is not self-interested in the narrow sense.
Quick check
?In an ultimatum game, Player 1 splits 100 and offers Player 2 just 5. Player 2 rejects, so both get nothing. What does the standard rational, self-interested model predict, and what does the rejection suggest?
Mission 2Evaluate

Should economists drop rationality?

  • It depends on stakes and repetition: with large stakes, practice and feedback, people learn and biases shrink.
  • It depends on market forces: firms that misprice lose to rivals, so some biases are offset at market level. Others are exploited (e.g. gym contracts).
  • It depends on predictability: biases that are systematic (anchoring, present bias) can be built into models and policy.
  • Policy uses of these biases: a later lesson.
  • Some behavioural results have been hard to replicate; others, such as anchoring and present bias, are well established.
  • The rational model remains a useful benchmark: it shows what to compare real behaviour against.
Quick check
?A supermarket offers "3 for the price of 2" on cereal boxes that cost 3 each. What percentage discount does a shopper who buys 3 boxes get on the usual price?
Mission check

?Many workers say they should save more for retirement but do not start. In one scheme, workers sign up now to put part of each future pay rise into their pension; nothing leaves today's pay. Many more workers saved more under the scheme. Which bias does the design best get round?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When rice got cheaper, why did some very poor families buy less of it?

Make a guess: When rice got cheaper, why did some very poor families buy less of it?

Mission 3

The budget line

The budget lineQuantity of good Y0106615Quantity of good Xaffordableunaffordableslope −2/3BL1Illustrative data: income 60, Px = 4, Py = 6
  • Two goods, X and Y. A fixed money income, fixed prices.
  • Budget line: all combinations of X and Y the consumer can just afford, spending all income.
  • Illustrative data: income 60; price of X = 4; price of Y = 6.
  • All on X: 60 ÷ 4 = 15 units. All on Y: 60 ÷ 6 = 10 units.
  • Join the two intercepts: a straight line. Check (6, 6): 6 × 4 + 6 × 6 = 60. ✓
  • Slope = −(price of X ÷ price of Y) = −4/6 = −2/3: to get one more X, give up 2/3 of a unit of Y.
  • Inside the line: affordable, income left over. Outside: unaffordable.
Mission 3

Shifting the budget line

Shifts and pivots of the budget lineQuantity of good Y01210121518Quantity of good XBL1BL2BL3BL4income risesprice of X risesprice of X fallsIllustrative data
  • (1) Income rises 60 → 72: both intercepts rise (X 18, Y 12). Parallel shift outwards; slope unchanged.
  • (2) Price of X rises 4 → 5: X intercept falls to 12; Y intercept stays 10. The line pivots inwards on the Y axis.
  • (3) Price of X falls: the line pivots outwards on the Y axis.
  • Income falls → parallel shift inwards. Both prices change by the same % → parallel shift (like an income change).
  • Income and both prices change by the same % → no change in the budget line.
  • Say: "a price change pivots the budget line" — not: "it shifts it parallel".
Quick check
?Income is 60, the price of X is 4 and the price of Y is 6. The price of X falls to 3. What are the new intercepts of the budget line?
Mission 3

Indifference curves

An indifference mapQuantity of good Y0Quantity of good Xhigher satisfactionIC1IC2IC3Red arrows: Y given up for each extra X getssmaller (diminishing MRS).
  • Indifference curve (IC): all combinations of two goods that give the consumer the same satisfaction.
  • The consumer is indifferent between any two points on one curve.
  • Assumptions: more is preferred to less; preferences are consistent (rational); goods are divisible.
  • Slopes down: to keep satisfaction the same, more X must mean less Y.
  • Convex to the origin: the more X you already have, the less Y you will give up for one more X. This is a diminishing marginal rate of substitution (MRS).
  • Higher IC = more satisfaction. A set of ICs is an indifference map.
  • ICs never cross: one point would then give two different levels of satisfaction.
  • Only the ranking matters (ordinal). No need to measure utility in units, unlike marginal utility theory (see Mission 1).
Mission 3

The best affordable choice

The best affordable choiceQuantity of good Y0Quantity of good XZZWat W: MRS = Px/PyBLIC1IC2IC3
  • The consumer wants the highest IC they can reach on their budget line.
  • That is where the budget line is a tangent to an IC: point W.
  • At W: slope of IC = slope of budget line, so MRS = price of X ÷ price of Y.
  • Points where the budget line cuts a lower IC: a higher IC is still reachable by moving along the line.
  • Higher ICs beyond the line: preferred, but unaffordable.
Quick check
?A consumer is at point Z, where her budget line cuts IC1. A higher curve, IC2, just touches the same budget line at another point, W. Which statement is correct?
Mission 3

Splitting the price effect

Splitting the price effect (substitution and income effects)Quantity of good Y0ABCQuantity of good XIC1BL1IC2BL2compensated budget linesubstitution effectincome effectprice effect
  • Price effect: the total change in quantity when a price changes. It has two parts.
  • Substitution effect: X is now relatively cheaper, so the consumer swaps Y for X, holding satisfaction constant.
  • Income effect: the price fall raises real income, so the consumer can reach a higher IC.
  • Price of X falls.
  • (1) Start at A: BL1 tangent to IC1.
  • (2) BL2 pivots outwards; new choice C on higher IC2.
  • (3) Draw an imaginary budget line parallel to BL2 but tangent to the old IC1, at B. It removes the gain in real income.
  • (4) A → B = substitution effect (always more X when X gets cheaper). B → C = income effect.
  • Price effect = substitution effect + income effect.
Mission 3Graph lab

Where does C land?

Where does C land?Good YGood X05101520020406080BL1IC1A
  • Takeaway: the substitution effect always points the same way; the income effect decides the good type.
Mission 3

Normal, inferior and Giffen goods

Normal, inferior and Giffen goodsNormalABCInferiorACBGiffenCABA → B: substitution effectB → C: income effectA → C: price effectQuantity of good X
  • Price of X falls:
GoodSubstitution effectIncome effectPrice effect (overall)
Normalmore Xmore Xmore X
Inferiormore Xless X, but smallermore X
Giffenmore Xless X, and largerless X
  • A Giffen good is an inferior good with an income effect so strong that it outweighs the substitution effect. Its demand curve slopes upwards.
  • Likely when the good is a staple that takes a large share of a poor household's budget, with few substitutes.
  • Real case: in 2006, a study gave poor households in Hunan, China, vouchers that cut the price of rice for five months. Many bought less rice: cheaper rice freed income for meat, a dearer food they preferred.
  • The very poorest, who relied on rice for almost all their calories, did not: like normal buyers, they bought more when it was cheaper.
  • The researchers called this the first real-world evidence of upward-sloping demand. Evidence for wheat in Gansu was weaker.
  • Say: "a Giffen good is a strongly inferior necessity" — not: "a luxury people buy more of because it is expensive" (that is a Veblen or status good, a different idea).
Quick check
?Which statement about a Giffen good is correct?
Mission 3Evaluate

Limits of indifference curves

  • Preferences are not observable. No one can draw a real person's IC map; the curves are assumed, not measured.
  • Only two goods. Real choices involve thousands. (Fix: let Y stand for "all other goods".)
  • Rational, consistent, fixed tastes are assumed. Habit, impulse, framing and advertising break these (see Mission 2).
  • Divisible goods and perfect information are assumed; many choices are lumpy (a car, a holiday) and uncertain.
  • Giffen goods are rare and hard to show with real data.
  • But: the model needs only a ranking, not measured utility, and it separates income and substitution effects clearly.
  • It depends on: how stable tastes are, how many goods matter, and how well informed the consumer is.
Mission check

?The price of good X rises. On an indifference map: the original choice A is at 10 units of X. The point B, where a line parallel to the new budget line is tangent to the original IC, is at 7 units. The new choice C is at 8 units. What kind of good is X?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?

Make a guess: If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?

Mission 4

What a free market gets right

Surplus at equilibriumPrice0PeQeQuantityD = MBS = MCconsumer surplusproducer surplusconsumer surplus + producer surplus =community surplus
  • Each point on the demand curve shows the marginal benefit (MB) of one more unit to buyers.
  • Each point on the supply curve shows the marginal cost (MC) of one more unit to sellers.
  • At competitive equilibrium, P = MB = MC.
  • Consumer surplus: what buyers would pay minus what they do pay.
  • Producer surplus: what sellers receive minus the least they would accept.
  • Consumer + producer surplus = community surplus.
  • If there is no market failure, equilibrium makes this total as large as possible: allocative efficiency.
Mission 4

Market equilibrium vs the social optimum

Equilibrium versus social optimumNo outside effectsCosts and benefits0Qm = Q*QuantityMPB = MSBMPC = MSCmarket equilibrium = social optimumWith an external costCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSBMPCMSCwelfare lossQm: MPB = MPC. Q*: MSB = MSC.
  • Buyers and sellers weigh only their private benefits and costs: market equilibrium is where MPB = MPC.
  • Society counts all benefits and costs: the social optimum is where MSB = MSC.
  • Allocative efficiency: resources make the goods society values most; the value of the last unit equals its full cost, MSB = MSC (for a single firm: P = MC).
  • No outside effects: MPB = MSB and MPC = MSC, so the market reaches the social optimum.
  • Outside effects: the market equilibrium and the social optimum are at different quantities.
  • Say: "the market equilibrium is not the socially optimum position" — not: "the market is not in equilibrium". A market can be in equilibrium and still be inefficient.
Mission 4

Other kinds of efficiency

  • Productive efficiency: output made at the lowest possible average cost (the bottom of the AC curve); no resources wasted.
  • Allocative efficiency: P = MC; society gets the mix of goods it values most.
  • Dynamic efficiency: efficiency over time, from investment and innovation that cut costs or create better products.
  • Pareto optimality: no one can be made better off without making someone else worse off.
  • A Pareto optimal economy is allocatively and productively efficient. Market failure means it is not Pareto optimal: some change could help one person and harm no one.
Quick check
?Which condition shows that a market produces the allocatively efficient quantity?
Mission 4Graph lab

Too much, too little

Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q and MSC = 20 + Q. The social optimum is Q = 50.

Too much, too littlePrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*MSBMSCoutput 50
  • Takeaway: any quantity other than MSB = MSC creates a welfare loss, whether output is too high or too low.
Mission 4

Worked example: measuring the welfare loss

  • Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q; MSC = 20 + Q (price in $, quantity in units per week).
  • Optimum: 120 − Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 50, value 70.
  • Output is 65 instead. At Q = 65: MSC = 20 + 65 = 85; MSB = 120 − 65 = 55.
  • Each extra unit from 50 to 65 costs society more than it is worth.
  • Welfare loss = triangle between MSC and MSB, from Q = 50 to 65.
  • Area = ½ × base × height = ½ × (65 − 50) × (85 − 55) = ½ × 15 × 30 = 225.
  • Total surplus at the optimum = ½ × 50 × (120 − 20) = 2,500. At 65 it falls to 2,500 − 225 = 2,275.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: MSB = 120 − Q and MSC = 20 + Q. A single seller restricts output to Q = 40. What is the welfare loss?
Mission 4

What market failure means

  • Market failure: the price mechanism fails to allocate resources efficiently, so the market outcome is not the social optimum.
  • The result is too much or too little of a good, and a welfare loss.
  • Complete market failure: no market exists at all: a missing market (e.g. street lighting).
  • Partial market failure: a market exists, but at the wrong price or quantity (e.g. too much tobacco, too little vaccination).
Mission 4

Sources of market failure

SourceWhat goes wrongMission
Negative externalitiesCost to third parties: overproduction
Positive externalitiesBenefit to third parties: underproduction
Public goodsFree riders: often no market at all
  • Information gaps (asymmetric information): buyers or sellers misjudge value.
  • Market power (monopoly): output restricted, price above MC.
Mission 4

Private, external, social

Negative and positive externalitiesNegative externality: Qm > Q*Costs and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMECwelfare lossPositive externality: Qm < Q*Costs and benefits0QmQ*QuantityMPB = DMSBMPC = MSC = SMEBwelfare loss
  • Externality: a cost or benefit to a third party, not paid for or received through the market.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost. At the margin: MSC = MPC + MEC.
  • Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit. At the margin: MSB = MPB + MEB.
  • External cost from production (e.g. pollution): MSC above MPC, so the market overproduces.
  • External benefit from consumption (e.g. vaccination): MSB above MPB, so the market underproduces.
  • Either way: a welfare (deadweight) loss triangle that points to the social optimum.
Quick check
?In a region, a factory's smoke harms nearby farms' crops, and there is no way to charge the factory for this. Which statement is correct?
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a competitive market for bread has no externalities and settles at 1,000 loaves a day. The government pays bakers to raise output to 1,200 loaves a day. What happens to total surplus from bread?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Make a guess: Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Mission 5

Two questions about waste

  • Efficiency: getting the most out of scarce resources.
  • Ask two separate questions:
    • How is it made? At the lowest possible cost per unit? → productive efficiency
    • What is made, and how much? The goods society values most? → allocative efficiency
  • One can hold without the other.
  • Both are static efficiency: efficiency at a point in time, with today's technology.
  • Dynamic efficiency asks a third question: are costs and products improving over time?
Mission 5

Productive efficiency

Minimum average costCosts (£)0OutputACMCminimum ACLeft of the minimum: MC < AC, so AC falls.Right of it: MC > AC, so AC rises.Productive efficiency: the output at minimum AC.
  • Productive efficiency: output where average cost (AC) is at its minimum.
  • At that output, MC = AC: the MC curve cuts the AC curve at its lowest point.
  • Why? If the next unit costs less than the average (MC < AC), it pulls AC down. If it costs more (MC > AC), it pushes AC up.
  • Say: "productively efficient at minimum AC" — not: "at the lowest total cost" (that is zero output).
Mission 5

Worked example: finding minimum AC

  • Illustrative data. Fixed cost = 60.
OutputTotal costAC = TC ÷ QMC of that unit
110010040
21306530
31505020
41684218
52004032
62464146
  • AC is lowest, 40, at 5 units: the productively efficient output.
  • 5th unit: MC 32 < AC 42 before it → AC falls.
  • 6th unit: MC 46 > AC 40 before it → AC rises.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm's total costs are: 10 units, 300; 20 units, 440; 30 units, 570; 40 units, 720; 50 units, 950. At which output is the firm productively efficient?
Mission 5

Allocative efficiency

Allocative efficiencyPrice (£)0PeQ1QeQ2QuantityP > MCDS = MCP < MCP = MCQ1: P > MC, too little is made.Q2: P < MC, too much is made.
  • Allocative efficiency: resources make the goods and services society values most, in the right amounts.
  • Condition: P = MC.
    • Price shows what buyers will pay for the last unit: its marginal benefit (MB) to them.
    • MC shows the cost of the resources used for it: the value of what else they could have made.
  • P > MC: buyers value one more unit above its cost → too little is made.
  • P < MC: the last unit costs more than it is worth to buyers → too much is made.
  • Say: "allocatively efficient where P = MC" — not: "where P = AC" (that is normal profit).
Mission 5Graph lab

Can both happen at once?

A price-taking firm always produces where P = MC. You set the market price.

Can both happen at once?Price and costOutput01020305002060q = 4043MCACP = MR
  • Takeaway: P = MC holds at every price; minimum AC only when the price equals minimum AC (here 26).
Quick check
?A firm sells its product for 30. At its current output, the marginal cost of the last unit is 18. What does this show?
Mission 5

Pareto efficiency

  • Pareto efficiency (Pareto optimality): no one can be made better off without making someone else worse off.
  • It needs both: productive efficiency (no waste in how goods are made) and allocative efficiency (the right goods are made).
  • A Pareto improvement: someone gains and no one loses.
  • Pareto efficiency says nothing about fairness: a very unequal outcome can still be Pareto efficient.
Mission 5

Dynamic efficiency

Dynamic efficiency: process innovationCosts (£)0OutputAC1AC1AC2Process innovation: lower cost at every output
  • Dynamic efficiency: efficiency over time, through innovation.
    • Process innovation: new methods lower costs → the whole AC curve shifts down.
    • Product innovation: new and better products.
  • It needs investment, R&D and new technology.
  • Funding: retained supernormal profit is a major source.
  • Incentive: firms innovate to win or protect profit.
Mission 5

X-inefficiency

X-inefficiencyCosts (£)0Q1Outputwasted costACX-inefficient
  • X-inefficiency: a firm produces at a cost above the lowest possible cost for its output.
  • On the diagram: a point above the AC curve, not on it.
  • Causes: organisational slack, overstaffing, overpaying suppliers, managers not pushed to cut costs.
  • Most likely where competition is weak, e.g. a protected monopoly.
  • Competition (or the threat of entry) removes it: high-cost firms lose sales.
  • Say: "X-inefficient" only for costs above the AC curve — not: for every firm away from minimum AC. A point on the curve, away from its minimum, is productively inefficient but not X-inefficient.
Quick check
Points on and above an AC curveCosts (£)0OutputACWXYZ
?A diagram shows a firm's AC curve and four points.
PointPosition
WOn the AC curve, at its minimum
XOn the AC curve, at a smaller output than W
YDirectly above W, well above the AC curve
ZOn the AC curve, at a larger output than W

Which point shows X-inefficiency?

Mission 5

Comparing market structures

Structures comparedPerfect competition (long run)Costs, revenue0OutputACMCP = AR = MR = DFirm with market powerCosts, revenue0P1Q1OutputP > MCACAR = DMRMC
  • Long-run outcomes, as usually taught:
ProductiveAllocativeDynamic
Perfect competitionYes (min AC)Yes (P = MC)Limited: only normal profit; no secrets to protect
Monopolistic competitionNo (excess capacity)No (P > MC)Some: product variety
OligopolyUnlikelyNo (P > MC)Possible: profits and rivalry fund R&D
MonopolyUnlikely; may be X-inefficientNo (P > MC)Possible: profits fund R&D; or none, with no rivals
  • Firms with market power face a downward-sloping demand curve, so they can set P above MC.
Mission 5

Case: patents

  • A patent gives an inventor the sole right to sell an invention for a set time.
  • WTO members must offer patent protection for at least 20 years from the filing date.
  • Static cost: a monopoly → P > MC → allocatively inefficient.
  • Dynamic gain: the expected profit pays for costly R&D (e.g. new medicines).
  • A deliberate trade: less static efficiency now for more dynamic efficiency later.
Mission 5Evaluate

Static or dynamic: which matters more?

  • It depends on whether profit is reinvested: supernormal profit may fund R&D, or be paid out to owners.
  • It depends on competitive pressure: a protected monopoly may stop innovating and let costs drift up.
  • It depends on economies of scale: one large firm's minimum AC may be far below that of many small firms.
  • It depends on time: static losses happen now; dynamic gains, if any, come later and are uncertain.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A firm produces exactly at the lowest point of its AC curve. Its price is 12. At this output, its marginal cost is 7. Which statement is correct?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Make a guess: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Mission 6

The cost nobody pays for

  • A firm pays for labour, materials, energy: its private costs.
  • Its production may also harm third parties, who are outside the trade: polluted air and rivers, noise, carbon emissions.
  • That harm is an external cost. Nobody pays the firm's victims through the market.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost.
  • At the margin: MSC = MPC + MEC (marginal external cost).
  • A negative production externality = an external cost created by producing a good.
  • Examples: a chemical plant's waste in a river harms fishing downstream; an airport's noise lowers the value of nearby homes; a coal power station's emissions harm health.
Mission 6

Worked example: adding up social cost

  • Illustrative data: a paper mill dumps waste in a river. Per tonne of paper:
  • Marginal private cost (wood, labour, energy) = 300.
  • Marginal external cost (lost fishing, water cleaning downstream) = 80.
  • MSC = MPC + MEC = 300 + 80 = 380.
  • Buyers value the last tonne at 360 (MPB). No external benefit, so MSB = 360.
  • The mill makes the tonne: to it, 360 > 300. To society: 360 − 380 = −20. Society loses 20 on that tonne.
  • If all 1,000 tonnes cost the same: private cost 300,000; external cost 80,000; social cost 380,000.
  • The same rule for benefits: social benefit = private benefit + external benefit. Here external benefit = 0.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a cement works has a marginal private cost of 45 per tonne. Its dust causes a marginal external cost of 15 per tonne to nearby residents. What is the marginal social cost of a tonne of cement?
Mission 6

The diagram

Negative production externalityCosts and benefits0P*PmQ*QmQuantityoverproductionMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMEC
  • Step 1: the market. Supply = MPC; demand = MPB = MSB (no external benefit). Market equilibrium at Qm, Pm.
  • Step 2: add the external cost. MSC lies above MPC; the vertical gap = MEC.
  • Step 3: the social optimum is where MSB = MSC: Q* (less), P* (higher).
  • Firms respond to private costs only, so the market produces Qm > Q*: overproduction.
  • The price Pm is too low: it does not include the external cost.
  • Say: "the market overproduces compared with the social optimum" — not: "the market is in disequilibrium".
Mission 6

The welfare loss

Welfare lossCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYwelfare loss (W, X, Y)external cost (not all a welfare loss)W = social optimum
  • For each unit from Q* to Qm: MSC > MSB. It costs society more than it is worth.
  • Adding up these losses gives a triangle:
  • corners: the social optimum (MSB = MSC); MSC at Qm; MSB at Qm.
  • The triangle points towards the social optimum.
  • Called the welfare loss.
  • Say: "welfare loss = the triangle between MSC and MSB, from Q* to Qm" — not: "the whole area between MSC and MPC". That bigger area is the external cost of all output, most of which is still worth bearing.
Mission 6Graph lab

Turn up the pollution

Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q. The marginal external cost (MEC) is the same for every unit.

Turn up the pollutionPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: a bigger MEC does not change what the market produces; it lowers the social optimum and widens the welfare loss.
Mission 6

Worked example: calculating the welfare loss

  • Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q; MEC = 20 per unit, so MSC = 40 + Q.
  • Market: 100 − Q = 20 + Q, so Qm = 40, Pm = 60.
  • Social optimum: 100 − Q = 40 + Q, so Q* = 30, P* = 70.
  • At Qm = 40: MSC = 80; MSB = 60. Height = 80 − 60 = 20 (= MEC).
  • Base = Qm − Q* = 40 − 30 = 10.
  • Welfare loss = ½ × 10 × 20 = 100.
  • Compare: total external cost at Qm = 20 × 40 = 800. The welfare loss is only 100: most of the external cost (20 × 30 = 600) falls on units that are still worth producing.
Quick check
Points on the externality diagramCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYZ
?A negative production externality diagram has MPB = MSB, MPC and MSC. The points are:
PointWhere it is
Wwhere MSC meets MSB (above Q*)
Xon MSC directly above Qm
Ywhere MPC meets MPB (at Qm)
Zon MPC directly below W (at Q*)

Which area shows the welfare loss?

Quick check
?Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 90 − Q; MPC = 10 + Q; MEC = 16 per unit at every output. What is the welfare loss at the market equilibrium?
Mission 6

Putting a number on the external cost

  • Carbon dioxide is a global external cost: emissions anywhere add to climate damage everywhere.
  • The social cost of carbon estimates the damage from one more tonne of CO₂, in today's money.
  • Two US government estimates for emissions in 2020: $51 per tonne (2021) and $190 per tonne (2023).
  • The gap comes mostly from assumptions, above all how much weight to give damage to people in the future.
  • So the MEC used for policy depends on value judgements, not only on science.
Mission 6Evaluate

How big is the problem?

  • It depends on measuring MEC. Health, nature and future harm have no market price, so estimates vary widely.
  • It depends on elasticity. For a given MEC, the more price elastic demand and supply are, the bigger the overproduction (Qm − Q*) and the welfare loss.
  • It depends on who and where. Many small polluters, or harm across borders, make the external cost hard to trace and charge.
  • It depends on time. Some damage builds up over years (carbon, soil), so today's MEC may understate the harm.
  • Ways to correct it (taxes, regulation, permits, property rights) are in an earlier lesson.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a fertiliser plant's runoff harms a lake. The table shows marginal values at each output (thousand tonnes).
OutputMPB = MSBMPCMEC
10903010
20804015
30705020
40606025
50507030

What is the socially optimal output?

Mission 7

Mission 7: How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Make a guess: How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Mission 7

Private and social costs and benefits

Private and social costs and benefitsThe firm's scale: privatecost against private benefitSociety's scale: adds the effectson third partiesPCprivate costPBprivate benefitECexternal costEBexternal benefitSC = PC + ECSB = PB + EB
  • A firm counts its private costs and benefits: what it pays and what it earns.
  • Society also counts external costs and benefits: effects on third parties.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost (SC = PC + EC).
  • Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit (SB = PB + EB).
  • A new road: building costs (private); noise for nearby homes (external cost); faster journeys and fewer crashes (benefits).
  • A project can lose money for its builder yet still be worth it to society, or the other way round.
Mission 7

The method of cost-benefit analysis

The steps of cost-benefit analysis1Identifyevery cost and benefit2Valueeach one in money3Comparesocial benefits − social costs4Decidego ahead if benefits exceed costs5Testwhat if an estimate is wrong?
  • Cost-benefit analysis (CBA): comparing all the social costs and social benefits of a project or policy, valued in money, to decide whether to go ahead.
  • Steps:
    • Identify every cost and benefit: private and external, now and in future.
    • Value each in money. Where there is no market price, estimate one (a shadow price).
    • Compare: net social benefit = social benefits − social costs.
    • Decide: go ahead if social benefits exceed social costs. Between options, pick the highest net social benefit.
    • Test the result: does the decision change if an estimate is wrong?
  • Benefits arriving years from now count for less than benefits today. You will not be asked to calculate this.
  • Say: "net social benefit" — not: "profit". A CBA can approve a project that makes a loss.
Mission 7

Worked example: a town bypass

  • Illustrative data, in millions, all years added together.
ItemTypeValue
Building and maintenancePrivate cost120
Noise for homes near the new roadExternal cost20
Lost woodland habitatExternal cost15
Time saved by travellersBenefit110
Fewer accidentsBenefit40
Lower fuel and vehicle costsBenefit20
  • Social costs = 120 + 20 + 15 = 155.
  • Social benefits = 110 + 40 + 20 = 170.
  • Net social benefit = 170 − 155 = +15, so on these figures the bypass goes ahead.
  • Nobody pays to use the road, so its builder earns nothing: a firm would never build it.
  • But 15 is small next to the estimates. If time saved were valued 20 lower, net social benefit would be −5 and the answer would flip.
Quick check
?A city appraises a new tram line (illustrative data, in millions). Building and running it costs 300. Passengers will pay 180 in fares. Cleaner air and less traffic for other road users are valued at 160. Disruption during building is valued at 20. What is the net social benefit, and the decision?
Mission 7

Valuing things that have no price

Valuing things that have no priceMarketpricesRevealedpreferenceStatedpreferenceRevealed preference: similar houses sell for lessunder a flight path. Stated preference: a surveyasks willingness to pay.Value of a statistical lifeone dot = 1,000 people100,000 people × 100 each= 10 millionIllustrative data
  • Clean air, quiet and travel time are not sold in shops. Economists estimate their value in money:
  • Market prices: use a related price, e.g. the cost of cleaning up a river, or of treating an illness.
  • Revealed preference: watch what people actually pay.
    • Similar houses sell for less under a flight path: the gap values the noise.
    • Workers in riskier jobs are paid more: the extra pay values the risk.
  • Stated preference: ask people in a survey what they would be willing to pay.
  • Value of a statistical life (illustrative data): 100,000 people each pay 100 to cut their risk of dying this year by 1 in 100,000.
    • Expected deaths fall by 1.
    • Total paid = 100,000 × 100 = 10 million: the value of one statistical life.
  • It is not the value of any one named person's life.
Quick check
?To value the loss of quiet near a new airport runway, researchers compare the prices of similar houses inside and outside the flight path. Which method are they using?
Mission 7

Why externalities are hard to measure

  • Who is affected? Harm can spread far, across borders and to future generations.
  • How much harm? Scientists may not know the effect of a pollutant for years.
  • What money value? Different methods give different numbers for the same harm.
  • Survey problems: people may overstate what they would pay, or refuse to put a price on nature.
  • So a tax or subsidy set equal to the "external cost" rests on an estimate.
Mission 7Graph lab

Getting the tax wrong

Illustrative data: the true external cost is 20 per unit. The government sets a tax per unit equal to its estimate.

Getting the tax wrongPrice / costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: the tax corrects the market only if it matches the true external cost, so measurement matters.
Mission 7

How much clean-up is efficient?

How much clean-up is efficient?Benefit and cost per unit0Q*Quantity of clean-upnet socialbenefitMSBMSCnet social benefit: MSB > MSCMSC > MSB
  • Policymakers rarely choose "all or nothing". They choose how much.
  • For each extra unit of clean-up compare:
    • marginal social benefit (MSB): the extra harm avoided
    • marginal social cost (MSC): the extra cost of cleaning up
  • Keep going while MSB ≥ MSC. Stop when the next unit costs more than it is worth.
  • At MSB = MSC, net social benefit is as large as it can be: there is no deadweight loss.
  • Zero pollution is usually not efficient: the last units are very costly to remove.
  • Say: "choose the quantity where MSB = MSC" — not: "where total benefit is largest".
Quick check
?A council can clean up a polluted lake in stages. Illustrative data:
Unit of clean-up1st2nd3rd4th5th6th
Marginal social benefit60453530158
Marginal social cost101520253240

How many units maximise net social benefit?

Mission 7

CBA in use

  • Transport: governments value time saved, accidents avoided, noise and emissions before building roads and railways.
  • Health: some health services compare a treatment's cost with the quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) it adds.
  • Flood defence: a 1936 US law allowed federal flood projects if benefits "to whomsoever they may accrue" exceed the estimated costs.
  • Regulation: the US Environmental Protection Agency recommends a value of a statistical life of US$7.4 million (in 2006 dollars), updated to the year of each analysis, when it weighs rules that cut deaths from pollution.
Mission 7Evaluate

How far can we trust a CBA?

It depends on:

  • The estimates: the money values put on life, time and nature can differ widely. Small changes can flip the decision.
  • Who wins and who loses: CBA adds up gains and losses. A project can pass while one group (e.g. nearby residents) loses heavily and is not compensated.
  • Time and uncertainty: long-lived projects and climate harms reach far into the future, and forecasts can be optimistic.
  • Who does the analysis: interest groups and politicians may push for favourable numbers.
  • Still, a CBA makes assumptions visible, so they can be challenged.
Mission check

?A firm proposes a waste incinerator (illustrative data, in millions). It expects revenue of 50 and costs of 40. Air pollution would impose an external cost of 15 on local residents. Less landfill would give an external benefit of 3. Using cost-benefit analysis, what should the government decide?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Marginal utility falls as consumption rises; this explains a downward-sloping demand curve.
  • Rational choice: keep going while MB ≥ MC; the best choice is where MB = MC.
  • Utility is maximised when MU/P is equal across goods and all income is spent.

Mission 2

  • Bounded rationality, bounded self-control and bounded selfishness are the three main limits to the rational model.
  • Biases such as rules of thumb, anchoring and availability are predictable departures from rational choice.

Mission 3

  • The budget line shows what is affordable (income shifts it parallel, a price change pivots it); ICs show preferences; the best choice is at the tangency.
  • Price effect = substitution effect (always towards the cheaper good) + income effect (normal: same way; inferior: opposite; Giffen: opposite and larger).
  • The model is clear but assumes observable, rational, stable preferences over two goods.

Mission 4

  • At the social optimum MSB = MSC and total surplus is as large as possible: allocative efficiency.
  • Market failure (for example externalities and public goods) leaves output above or below that point, causing a welfare loss.

Mission 5

  • Productive efficiency: minimum AC (MC = AC).
  • Allocative efficiency: P = MC.
  • Dynamic efficiency: costs and products improve over time through R&D and investment.
  • X-inefficiency: costs above the AC curve, often where competition is weak.

Mission 6

  • A negative production externality makes MSC = MPC + MEC lie above MPC.
  • The market produces where MPB = MPC: more than the social optimum where MSB = MSC.
  • The welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MSB from Q* to Qm, pointing to the social optimum.

Mission 7

  • Social cost = private cost + external cost; social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
  • CBA: identify, value, compare, decide. Go ahead if social benefits exceed social costs; choose the quantity where MSB = MSC.
  • Values for things with no price come from related markets, revealed preference and surveys, so they are estimates.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Price system and the microeconomy for Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Water keeps us alive and diamonds do not, so why do diamonds cost so much more?
  2. Mission 2Why do people pay for a gym every month and then hardly ever go?
  3. Mission 3When rice got cheaper, why did some very poor families buy less of it?
  4. Mission 4If buyers and sellers both gain from a trade, how can a free market still produce the wrong amount?
  5. Mission 5Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?
  6. Mission 6Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  7. Mission 7How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge