← AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708) · 9.4 Money and banking (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Money and banking (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?
  2. Mission 2If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?
  3. Mission 3If money has a price, what makes that price go up or down?
  4. Mission 4Where does the money businesses borrow come from, and what decides its price?
Mission 1

Mission 1: When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?

Make a guess: When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?

Mission 1

When the usual tool runs out

Policy rate at the floorPolicy interest rate (%)02007200820092010floorSchematic, not exact data
  • The usual tool: cut the policy interest rate to make borrowing cheaper.
  • Many central banks cut their policy rates close to zero after the 2008 financial crisis.
  • Rates cannot go far below zero: people could hold cash at 0% instead. This floor is the zero (or effective) lower bound.
  • With the economy still weak, central banks turned to unconventional tools.
  • Main one: quantitative easing (QE).
Mission 1

What QE is

QE flowsCentral bankPension fundBankgiltnewreservesdeposit +
  • QE: the central bank creates new central bank reserves (electronic money) and uses them to buy assets, mainly government bonds.
  • UK government bonds are called gilts.
  • It buys from investors such as pension funds and insurers, not straight from the government.
  • The seller's bank account is credited: broad money (bank deposits) rises; banks' reserves rise.
  • So QE increases the money supply while the policy rate is stuck near zero.
  • Say: "the central bank creates reserves to buy bonds" — not: "prints banknotes and gives them away".
Quick check
?Which statement best describes quantitative easing?
Mission 1

How QE reaches spending

QE transmissionCentral bank buys bondsPrice of bonds0P2P1Q1Q2Quantity of bondsyield ↓SD1D2Yields ↓Loan rates ↓Asset prices ↑Wealth ↑Currency ↓Exports ↑Price level0P2P1Y1Y2YfeReal national output (Y)SRASLRASAD1AD2
  • 1. Bond prices up, yields down. Big purchases raise bond prices. A bond's yield (its return) moves the opposite way to its price.
  • 2. Lower long-term interest rates. Government bond yields are a benchmark, so mortgage and business loan rates tend to fall.
  • 3. Portfolio rebalancing. Sellers use their new money to buy other assets (shares, company bonds): their prices rise, firms can borrow more cheaply.
  • 4. Wealth effect. Higher asset prices make owners feel richer: more consumption.
  • 5. Exchange rate. Lower yields can make the currency less attractive: it tends to fall, exports become cheaper.
  • 6. Confidence. It signals the central bank will act.
  • Result: AD shifts right, raising real output and the price level towards the inflation target.
Mission 1

Worked example: price up, yield down

  • Illustrative data. A bond pays a fixed 3 a year, for ever.
  • Yield = annual payment ÷ price × 100.
  • Price 100: 3 ÷ 100 × 100 = 3%.
  • QE buying pushes the price to 120: 3 ÷ 120 × 100 = 2.5%.
  • Price 150: 3 ÷ 150 × 100 = 2%.
  • The payment is fixed, so paying more for it means a lower return.
  • Say: "higher bond prices mean lower yields" — not: "bond prices and interest rates rise together".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A bond pays a fixed 4 a year, for ever. After central bank purchases, its price rises from 100 to 125. What is its yield now?
Mission 1Graph lab

Can QE close the gap?

Illustrative data. Real output 950; full-employment output 1000; policy rate already near zero. A negative output gap of 50.

Can QE close the gap?Price levelReal national output (Y)950105YfeSRASAD
  • Takeaway: with low confidence, 200 of QE lifts output only to about 963; with high confidence, 200 closes the gap, and 400 overshoots to 1050, with the price level up to 115.
Mission 1

Reversing QE

Quantitative tighteningCentral bank sells bondsPrice of bonds0P1P2Q1Q2Quantity of bondsyield ↑DS1S2Price level0P2P1Y1Y2YfeReal national output (Y)SRASLRASAD2AD1
  • Quantitative tightening (QT): the central bank shrinks its bond holdings.
  • Two ways: stop reinvesting as bonds mature, or sell bonds back to investors.
  • Reserves and deposits shrink: the money supply contracts.
  • The chain runs in reverse: bond prices fall, yields rise, borrowing costs rise: AD tends to shift left.
  • UK: the MPC decided to begin reducing its stock of bonds in February 2022.
  • Central banks try to reverse QE gradually and predictably, so markets are not shocked.
Mission 1

Other ways the money supply changes

  • Open market operations (OMO): the central bank buys short-term government securities to add reserves (expand), or sells them to drain reserves (contract).
  • Minimum reserve requirements: a higher required share of deposits held as reserves cuts banks' lending (contract); a lower one lets them lend more (expand).
  • Policy rate (base or discount rate): a higher rate makes borrowing costlier, so less new lending and slower money growth.
  • QE is OMO on a huge scale, in long-term bonds, when the policy rate is at the floor.
  • Deficit financing: if a budget deficit is financed by borrowing from the central bank or banks, new deposits are created: the money supply rises. Borrowing from the public mostly does not.
  • Balance of payments: a net inflow of foreign currency, exchanged for domestic currency, raises the domestic money supply; a net outflow reduces it.
Mission 1

Real world: QE in practice

  • The Bank of England began QE in March 2009, with Bank Rate at 0.5%.
  • In total it bought £895 billion of bonds: £875 billion of gilts and £20 billion of company bonds.
  • The last increase was announced in November 2020, in the pandemic.
  • The Bank of Japan first used QE in March 2001.
  • The US Federal Reserve's assets reached about 4.5 trillion dollars by the time it stopped buying in October 2014.
  • The European Central Bank began large-scale bond buying in 2015: 60 billion euros a month.
  • Question to weigh: why did central banks buy on this scale, and what happens when they stop?
Mission 1Evaluate

Does QE work?

It depends on:

  • Confidence. If households and firms want to save and banks will not lend, new reserves sit idle: "pushing on a string".
  • Who gains. Higher bond, share and house prices help people who own them, which may widen wealth inequality. Supporters reply that QE protected jobs and incomes.
  • Timing and exit. Too much for too long risks inflation; unwinding risks bond-market disruption and losses for the central bank.
  • In the UK, those losses are covered by HM Treasury, so they fall on taxpayers.
  • Evidence. Most studies find early QE lowered long-term yields. How much it raised output and inflation is still debated.
Mission check

?A central bank bought large amounts of government bonds during a slump. Years later, with inflation above target, it starts selling some of the bonds back to investors. Other things equal, what is the most likely effect?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?

Make a guess: If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?

Mission 2

Nominal and real

Nominal and real interest rateSavings1,0001,050Nominal rate 5%Price of a basket1,0001,030Inflation 3%Baskets you can afford11.019Real rate ≈ 2% · about 2% moreIllustrative data
  • You save 1,000 for one year at an interest rate of 5% (illustrative data).
  • After a year you have 1,050. That 5% is the nominal interest rate: the rate in money terms, not adjusted for inflation.
  • Over the same year, inflation is 3%. A basket that cost 1,000 now costs 1,030.
  • 1,050 ÷ 1,030 = 1.019. You can buy only about 2% more than a year ago.
  • That 2% is the real interest rate: the rise in what your savings can buy.
  • Say: "the real interest rate fell" — not: "interest rates fell", when the nominal rate stayed the same and only inflation rose.
Mission 2

The Fisher relation

  • Real interest rate ≈ nominal interest rate − inflation rate.
  • Named after the economist Irving Fisher.
  • Example: nominal 5%, inflation 3% → real ≈ 5 − 3 = 2%.
  • If inflation is higher than the nominal rate, the real rate is negative: savings buy less each year.
  • The exact answer here is 1.94%, not 2%. The subtraction is close when rates are low, and it is the form you use in calculations.
  • Say: "real interest rate = nominal rate minus inflation" — not: "nominal rate minus the interest".
Quick check
?A bank pays a nominal interest rate of 6% on savings. Inflation over the year is 8%. What is the real interest rate?
Mission 2

When real rates go negative

A negative real interest rateEuro area, October 2022Deposit rate0.75%Inflation10.6%Real rate≈ −9.85%Source: ECB deposit facility rate; Eurostat HICPinflation, October 2022
  • Real-world data, euro area, October 2022:
  • The European Central Bank's deposit rate was 0.75%. Euro area inflation was 10.6%.
  • Real rate on that deposit ≈ 0.75 − 10.6 = −9.85%.
  • Nominal rates had started to rise, but real rates were still deeply negative.
  • Borrowers care about the real rate too: a negative real rate means a debt shrinks in real terms.
  • So a rise in the nominal rate is not always "tighter" money: it depends on what happens to inflation.
Mission 2

Expected and actual inflation

Expected and actual inflationLoan agreedExpected inflation 2%Nominal rate 5%planned real rate 3%one year latergain to borrowerLoan repaidActual inflation 6%Nominal rate 5%real rate −1%Illustrative data
  • Lenders set the nominal rate before they know the inflation rate.
  • A lender wants a real return of 3% and expects inflation of 2%. It charges 3 + 2 = 5% nominal (illustrative data).
  • Inflation turns out to be 6%.
  • Real rate actually earned = 5 − 6 = −1%, not the 3% planned.
  • Unexpected inflation helps borrowers and hurts lenders: the money repaid buys less than both expected.
  • Unexpectedly low inflation does the reverse.
Quick check
?A firm borrows at a fixed nominal rate of 7% for one year. When the loan is agreed, both sides expect inflation of 3%. Actual inflation turns out to be 1%. Which statement is correct?
Mission 2

Theory 1: loanable funds

Loanable funds marketReal interest rate (%)0r*r2Q*Q2Quantity of loanable fundsS (saving)S1D (investment)S2
  • Classical economists: the interest rate is the price of borrowing saved funds.
  • Supply of loanable funds: saving by households, firms and government. A higher real rate rewards saving, so supply slopes up.
  • Demand for loanable funds: borrowing for investment (and by government and consumers). A lower real rate makes more projects worthwhile, so demand slopes down.
  • The real interest rate settles where saving = borrowing.
  • More saving (supply shifts right) → the real rate falls.
  • More borrowing (demand shifts right) → the real rate rises.
  • Mainly a long-run theory of the real rate.
Mission 2

Theory 2: Keynes's liquidity preference

Liquidity preferenceNominal interest rate (%)0i*Quantity of moneytransactions andprecautionaryspeculativeliquidity trapLP (demand for money)MS
  • Keynes (1936): the interest rate is the price of giving up liquidity (holding money instead of bonds).
  • People demand money for three motives:
  • Transactions motive: to pay for everyday spending. Rises with income.
  • Precautionary motive: for emergencies. Rises with income and uncertainty.
  • Speculative motive: to hold money instead of bonds when bond prices are expected to fall. Higher when interest rates are low.
  • So the demand for money (liquidity preference, LP) slopes down against the interest rate: holding money costs the interest you give up.
  • The money supply is set by the central bank: a vertical line.
  • The nominal interest rate settles where money demand = money supply.
  • At very low rates, everyone expects rates to rise and bond prices to fall. LP becomes flat: a liquidity trap. Extra money does not lower the rate.
Mission 2Graph lab

Uncertainty and the rate

Money supply is fixed at 400 (billion) and the nominal rate is 4% (illustrative data).

Uncertainty and the rateNominal interest rate (%)Quantity of money (billion)02684004%MSLP
  • Takeaway: with a fixed money supply, a rise in the demand for money raises the nominal interest rate.
Quick check
?In Keynes's liquidity preference theory, investors come to expect interest rates to rise soon. The money supply does not change. What happens?
Mission 2

Why there is not one interest rate

  • Different loans carry different rates. Illustrative data, one year:
BorrowerRate
Central bank policy rate4%
Government (10-year bond)4.5%
Large firm6%
Small firm9%
Credit card20%
  • Risk premium: lenders charge more where default is more likely.
  • Time: longer loans usually pay more (more can go wrong; money is tied up).
  • Security: a loan backed by a house (collateral) is cheaper than an unsecured one.
  • All rates tend to move with the policy rate set by the central bank.
Mission 2Evaluate

Which theory explains interest rates?

It depends on:

  • Time period: loanable funds fits the long-run real rate; liquidity preference fits short-run nominal rates.
  • The central bank: in practice, most central banks set a short-term policy rate and supply whatever money is demanded at it. Market forces then matter more for long-term rates.
  • Banks: banks create deposits when they lend, so lending is not limited to past saving (Bank of England, 2014).
  • Expectations: both theories depend on expected inflation and expected future rates, which can change quickly.
Mission check

?A central bank raises its nominal policy rate from 3% to 5%. Over the same period, inflation rises from 2% to 7%. What happened to the real policy rate?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If money has a price, what makes that price go up or down?

Make a guess: If money has a price, what makes that price go up or down?

Mission 3

Holding money has a cost

  • You can keep your wealth as money (cash, current accounts) or as interest-bearing assets such as bonds.
  • Money is the most liquid asset: you can spend it at once.
  • But money pays little or no interest.
  • So the opportunity cost of holding money is the interest you give up.
  • The higher the nominal interest rate, the more it costs to hold money.
Mission 3

The demand for money

The money marketNominal interest rate (%)04%600Quantity of moneyMD (LP)MSIllustrative data.
  • At a high nominal interest rate, people hold less money and more bonds.
  • At a low rate, holding money costs little, so they hold more.
  • So money demand (MD) slopes down against the nominal interest rate.
  • A change in the interest rate → a movement along MD.
  • MD shifts right when people need more money for spending: a higher price level or higher real output (more transactions).
  • This is Keynes's liquidity preference curve (see Mission 2): transactions, precautionary and speculative motives.
Mission 3

Money supply and equilibrium

The money marketNominal interest rate (%)04%600Quantity of moneyMD (LP)MSIllustrative data.
  • The money supply (MS) is set by the central bank. It does not depend on the interest rate.
  • So MS is a vertical line.
  • Equilibrium: the nominal interest rate where the quantity of money demanded = the money supply.
  • Illustrative data: MS = 600 (billion); MD gives an equilibrium rate of 4%.
  • Say: "money demand shifted right" — not: "money supply increased", when people simply want to hold more money.
Mission 3

Getting back to equilibrium

Getting back to equilibriumNominal interest rate (%)05%4%500600surplus of moneyshortage of moneyQuantity of moneyMD (LP)MSbuy bondsbond pricesriseinterest ratefallssell bondsbond pricesfallinterest raterisesIllustrative data.
  • Bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions.
  • Step 1: rate 5%, above equilibrium. People want to hold only 500 of the 600: a surplus of money of 100.
  • They use spare money to buy bonds → bond prices rise → interest rates fall back to 4%.
  • Step 2: rate below equilibrium → a shortage of money.
  • People sell bonds to get money → bond prices fall → interest rates rise.
  • The nominal rate adjusts; the money supply stays where the central bank put it.
Quick check
?In the money market, the nominal interest rate is below its equilibrium level. What happens next?
Mission 3Graph lab

Prices up, rate?

Prices up, rate?Nominal interest rate (%)Quantity of money (billion)02686004%MSMD
  • Takeaway: a higher price level raises money demand, so with a fixed money supply the nominal rate rises.
Mission 3

The central bank moves the money supply

The central bank raises the money supplyNominal interest rate (%)04%3%600700Quantity of moneyMD (LP)MS1MS2central bankbuys bondsIllustrative data.
  • To raise the money supply, the central bank buys government bonds (open market operations or quantitative easing). It pays with new money.
  • MS shifts right: MS1 → MS2. The nominal rate falls (illustrative data: 600 → 700, rate 4% → 3%).
  • To reduce the money supply, it sells bonds: MS shifts left, the rate rises.
  • Say: "an increase in the money supply lowers the nominal interest rate" — not: "lower interest rates increase the money supply" (wrong direction of cause).
Quick check
?Real output grows strongly, so people make more transactions. The central bank leaves the money supply unchanged. What happens in the money market?
Mission 3Evaluate

How useful is this model?

It depends on:

  • What the central bank targets: most central banks set a policy interest rate and supply whatever money is demanded at it. Then the money supply is not fixed.
  • Stable money demand: if money demand shifts a lot (new payment methods, panics), a fixed money supply gives an unstable rate.
  • Very low rates: near zero, extra money may not cut rates further. Real-world data: the European Central Bank's deposit rate was at or below 0% from July 2012 to September 2022.
  • The link to spending: a lower rate only raises AD if firms and households want to borrow.
Mission check

?After a wave of online payment fraud, people decide to hold more cash. Money demand rises by 50 billion at every interest rate. The central bank wants to keep the nominal interest rate unchanged. What should it do?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Where does the money businesses borrow come from, and what decides its price?

Make a guess: Where does the money businesses borrow come from, and what decides its price?

Mission 4

A market for saving and borrowing

Loanable funds marketReal interest rate (r)0r1Q1Quantity of loanable fundsD (investment)S (saving)surplusshortage
  • Savers lend their unspent income (through banks and bond markets). Borrowers use it, mostly for investment in new capital.
  • The market for loanable funds brings them together.
  • Its price is the real interest rate: what lenders earn and borrowers pay in purchasing power (see Mission 2).
  • Supply slopes up: a higher real rate rewards saving.
  • Demand slopes down: at a lower real rate, more investment projects are worth borrowing for.
  • Equilibrium: real interest rate r1, quantity of loanable funds Q1.
  • If the rate is above r1, there is a surplus of funds: lenders compete and the rate falls. Below r1, a shortage pushes it up.
Mission 4

National saving

  • The supply of loanable funds comes from national saving.
  • National saving = private saving + public saving.
  • Public saving = tax revenue − government spending. A budget deficit is negative public saving.
  • Illustrative data (billion): private saving 900, taxes 600, government spending 700.
  • Public saving = 600 − 700 = −100.
  • National saving = 900 + (−100) = 800.
  • Say: "a budget deficit reduces public saving" — not: "a deficit is the same as the national debt".
Quick check
?Private saving is 500 billion. The government collects 300 billion in taxes and spends 350 billion. What is national saving?
Mission 4

What shifts the curves

What shifts loanable fundsHouseholds save more: S shifts rightReal interest rate (r)0r1r2Q1Q2Quantity of loanable fundsDS1S2Business optimism or an investment tax credit:D shifts rightReal interest rate (r)0r2r1Q1Q2Quantity of loanable fundsD1SD2Bigger budget deficit: D shifts rightReal interest rate (r)0r2r1Q1Q2Quantity of loanable fundsD1SD2
ChangeCurveReal interest rateQuantity
Households save more of their incomeSupply → rightFallsRises
Business optimism; tax credit for investmentDemand → rightRisesRises
Bigger budget deficitSee belowRises—
  • A bigger budget deficit means the government must borrow more.
  • Show it as demand for loanable funds shifting right.
  • Say: "the real interest rate rises" — loanable funds always uses the real rate, not the nominal rate.
Mission 4Graph lab

The government borrows more

Start: real interest rate 6%, loanable funds 500 (billion), all borrowed for private investment (illustrative data).

The government borrows moreReal interest rate (%)Quantity of loanable funds (billion)048105006%SD
  • Takeaway: government borrowing raises the real rate, and some private investment is priced out.
Mission 4

Crowding out

Crowding outReal interest rate (r)07%6%450500550Quantity of loanable fundsD1D1SD2+100 deficitprivate investment 450government 100crowded out 50Illustrative data
  • In the lab, a deficit of 100 raises the real rate from 6% to 7%.
  • Total borrowing rises to 550, but the government takes 100 of it.
  • Private investment falls from 500 to 450: it is crowded out.
  • Less private investment today → a smaller capital stock → slower long-run growth.
  • How much crowding out? It depends on how far the rate rises, and how sensitive investment is to it.
Quick check
?The government gives firms a tax credit for each new machine they buy (an investment tax credit). Other things equal, what happens in the loanable funds market?
Mission 4Evaluate

How well does loanable funds explain interest rates?

It depends on:

  • Interest sensitivity: if saving barely responds to the real rate, the supply curve is steep.
  • Bank lending: banks create deposits when they lend, so new lending is not limited to past saving (Bank of England, 2014).
  • Spare capacity: in a deep recession, firms may want to invest little, so government borrowing may crowd out little.
  • Open economies: capital inflows can stop the real rate rising much.
  • Central banks: they set short-term rates directly; the model fits long-term real rates better.
Mission check

?Worried about their jobs, households decide to save a larger share of their income. Other things equal, what happens in the loanable funds market?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • At the zero lower bound, QE creates reserves to buy bonds: bond prices rise, yields fall, borrowing gets cheaper, AD shifts right.
  • Reversing QE (QT) contracts the money supply and pushes yields up.

Mission 2

  • Real interest rate ≈ nominal interest rate − inflation; it can be negative.
  • Unexpected inflation helps borrowers and hurts lenders.
  • Loanable funds explains the real rate by saving and borrowing; liquidity preference explains the nominal rate by money demand and money supply.

Mission 3

  • The opportunity cost of holding money is the interest given up, so money demand slopes down.
  • Money supply is vertical, set by the central bank; the nominal interest rate is where they meet.
  • MD shifts with the price level and real output; MS shifts with central bank action.

Mission 4

  • Loanable funds: supply = national saving (private + public), demand = borrowing for investment; price = real interest rate.
  • A budget deficit raises the real rate and can crowd out private investment.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Money and banking (part 2) for Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1When interest rates can go no lower, how can a central bank still get people spending?
  2. Mission 2If your savings grow every year, how can you still end up able to buy less?
  3. Mission 3If money has a price, what makes that price go up or down?
  4. Mission 4Where does the money businesses borrow come from, and what decides its price?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge