← AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708) · 9.4 Money and banking (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Money and banking (part 1)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why will a shop swap a meal for a printed slip of paper but not for a bag of apples?
  2. Mission 2If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?
  3. Mission 3When a bank lends you money, whose money are you actually borrowing?
  4. Mission 4Why can't you open an account at a central bank, and what does it do instead?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Government macroeconomic intervention (5.1–5.4).

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why will a shop swap a meal for a printed slip of paper but not for a bag of apples?

Make a guess: Why is a printed slip of paper accepted as payment?

Mission 1

Life without money: barter

  • Barter: swapping goods and services directly. Apples for bread, a haircut for a meal.
  • Problem 1: the double coincidence of wants. You need someone who has what you want and wants what you have.
  • Problem 2: no common measure. How many apples is a haircut worth? Every pair of goods needs its own price.
  • Problem 3: hard to save. Apples rot.
  • Problem 4: hard to split. Half a cow is not much use.
  • Money solves all four. It makes specialisation and trade far easier.
Mission 1

The functions of money

  • Money: anything generally accepted as a means of payment.
  • Its functions:
    • Medium of exchange: accepted in payment for goods and services.
    • Unit of account (or measure of value): prices and incomes are stated in it, so values can be compared.
    • Store of value: holds purchasing power over time.
    • Standard of deferred payment: debts and future payments are stated in it.
  • Say: "money is a medium of exchange" — not: "money is something you buy things with because it is valuable".
Mission 1

When money stops working: Zimbabwe

  • 2007–2008: prices in Zimbabwe rose faster and faster: hyperinflation.
  • Official annual inflation reached 231 million per cent (July 2008).
  • In early 2009 the central bank issued a 100 trillion Zimbabwe dollar note.
  • What failed first: the store of value. Money lost value in days, so people spent it at once.
  • Then the unit of account: shops priced goods in US dollars or changed prices several times a day.
  • Then the medium of exchange: sellers refused Zimbabwe dollars.
  • In 2009 Zimbabwe allowed the US dollar and other currencies to be used instead.
Quick check
?In a country with very high inflation, a family is paid in the local currency. They change their wages into a foreign currency on payday and keep their savings in it. Which function of the local currency has broken down most clearly?
Mission 1

What makes good money?

  • Acceptable: people trust that others will take it.
  • Scarce / limited in supply: if anyone can make more, it loses value.
  • Durable: does not rot or wear out quickly.
  • Portable: easy to carry.
  • Divisible: can be split into small amounts.
  • Uniform: every unit is the same.
  • Hard to forge.
  • Gold scores well on most. Apples score badly on durability and uniformity.
Mission 1

Forms of money

  • Commodity money: has value itself. Gold, silver, salt.
  • Representative money: paper that could be swapped for gold (a gold standard).
  • Fiat money: notes and coins with little value as objects. Accepted because the law makes them legal tender and people trust they will be accepted.
  • Bank deposits: numbers in accounts, spent by card, transfer or cheque.
    • In the UK, bank deposits are about 97% of broad money; notes and coins only about 3% (Bank of England, 2014).
  • Cryptocurrencies (e.g. Bitcoin): a debated case.
    • Their prices swing a lot. Few shops price goods in them.
    • Most central banks say they are not money in the full sense.
Quick check
?A café accepts payment in a cryptocurrency. Its price in US dollars often moves by 10% or more in a week, so the café must rewrite its menu prices in the cryptocurrency every day. Which function of money is failing most directly here?
Mission 1

Liquidity

Liquidity ladderMore liquidLess liquidNotes and coinsCurrent accountdepositsSavings depositsFixed-term depositsBonds and sharesHousesnarrowmoneybroad money(M4)Narrow money also counts banks' reservebalances at the central bank.
  • Liquidity: how quickly and cheaply an asset can be turned into spending power without losing value.
  • Most liquid to least: notes and coins → current account deposits → savings deposits → fixed-term deposits → bonds and shares → houses.
  • Money is the most liquid asset. Narrow and broad measures of money are drawn along this ladder.
Mission 1

Narrow money and broad money

  • Narrow money: money that can be spent at once.
    • Notes and coins, plus banks' reserve balances at the central bank.
    • Some measures of narrow money also count current account deposits.
  • Broad money: narrow money plus deposits held in banks and building societies, including savings deposits.
    • UK measure: M4.
  • Most broad money is created by commercial banks when they lend (see Mission 3).
  • The money supply is the total stock of money in an economy. It can be measured narrowly or broadly.
  • Say: "broad money includes bank deposits" — not: "money means notes and coins".
Quick check
?Which of these is counted in broad money (M4) but not in narrow money?
Mission 1

The money supply and MV = PT

  • The quantity theory of money: MV = PT.
    • M: money supply. V: velocity (how often each unit is spent in a year).
    • P: average price level. T: number of transactions.
  • If V and T are stable, a rise in M leads to a rise in P.
  • You will test this theory in a later mission (see Mission 2).
Mission check

?In a prisoner-of-war camp in the Second World War, cigarettes became money. Prisoners who did not smoke still accepted cigarettes in payment for food and clothes. What best explains why?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?

Make a guess: If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?

Mission 2

The equation of exchange

The equation of exchangeMVPT××=total spendingnominal GDPM money supply · V velocity of circulation · Pprice level · T transactions (often real output)V and output assumed stableM up, so P up by the same %
  • MV = PT (the Fisher equation of exchange)
  • M = the money supply.
  • V = the velocity of circulation: how many times, on average, each unit of money is spent in a year.
  • P = the average price level.
  • T = the volume of transactions (in practice, often measured by real output).
  • Left side: money × times spent = total spending. Right side: prices × output = nominal GDP.
  • The two sides are equal by definition: an identity, not yet a theory.
Mission 2Worked example

Finding velocity

Illustrative data:

  • Money supply M = 500 billion. Nominal GDP = 2,000 billion.
  • V = nominal GDP ÷ M = 2,000 ÷ 500 = 4. Each unit of money is spent 4 times a year.
  • Real output (at base-year prices) = 1,600 billion.
  • P = nominal GDP ÷ real output = 2,000 ÷ 1,600 = 1.25 (prices are 25% above the base year).
  • Check: M × V = 500 × 4 = 2,000 = P × output = 1.25 × 1,600. ✔
  • Any one of the four can be found from the other three: M = P × output ÷ V = 1.25 × 1,600 ÷ 4 = 500; output = M × V ÷ P = 500 × 4 ÷ 1.25 = 1,600.
Mission 2

From identity to theory

The equation of exchangeMVPT××=total spendingnominal GDPM money supply · V velocity of circulation · Pprice level · T transactions (often real output)V and output assumed stableM up, so P up by the same %
  • The quantity theory of money adds three assumptions:
  • (1) V is stable: it depends on slow-changing habits and payment technology.
  • (2) Real output is set by real factors (labour, capital, technology), not by money, at least in the long run.
  • (3) Causation runs from M to P: money changes first.
  • So if M rises and V and output are fixed, P must rise in proportion.
  • Double M → double P.
  • Say: "the quantity theory says money growth causes inflation" — not: "MV = PQ proves it". The equation is always true; the theory is the assumptions.
Mission 2Worked example

In growth rates

  • In growth rates: % change in M + % change in V ≈ % change in P + % change in real output.
  • Illustrative data: money grows 10%, V is constant, real output grows 3%.
  • Inflation ≈ 10 + 0 − 3 = 7%.
  • (Exact: 1.10 ÷ 1.03 − 1 = 6.8%; the approximation is close for small changes.)
  • Rule of thumb: lasting inflation ≈ money growth − output growth, if V is stable.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: M = 800 billion, V = 5, real output = 2,000 billion. Using the quantity equation, what is the price level P?
Mission 2Graph lab

More money, same output

More money, same outputPrice levelReal national output (Y)00.51.522.5Yf1LRASAD
  • Takeaway: with output fixed at full capacity and V stable, more money means a proportionately higher price level.
Mission 2

Money neutrality and monetarism

  • Money neutrality: in the long run, money changes nominal variables (prices, wages) but not real ones (output, jobs).
  • Milton Friedman: "Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon."
  • Monetarists: to control inflation, control the growth of the money supply; keep it close to the growth of real output.
Mission 2

Real case: Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe: money, output and pricesIllustrative shapes, no valuesMoney supplyReal outputPrice levelJuly 2008: 231 million %Time100 trillionZimbabwe dollar note, January 2009
  • 2000s: Zimbabwe's output fell sharply, while its central bank created money to pay for government spending.
  • M soared while real output shrank, so P rose explosively.
  • Official annual inflation reached 231 million per cent in July 2008.
  • In January 2009 a 100 trillion Zimbabwe dollar note was issued.
  • People spent money as fast as they could before it lost value: V rose too, pushing prices up even faster.
  • In 2009 the Zimbabwe dollar was abandoned; people used US dollars and other currencies.
Quick check
?In the long run, the quantity theory predicts that a one-off 20% rise in the money supply, with V and real output fixed, will:
Mission 2Evaluate

Does more money always mean inflation?

  • V is not stable: US M2 velocity fell from about 2.2 in 1997 to about 1.1 in 2020.
  • Many central banks created large amounts of money through QE after 2008, yet inflation stayed low for years.
  • Spare capacity (Keynesian view): below full employment, more spending can raise output, not just prices.
  • Causation can run the other way: banks create money when people want to borrow and spend (see Mission 3), so rising P and output can drive M.
  • But: in 2021–22, after rapid money growth and an energy price shock, UK CPI inflation reached 11.1% (October 2022). How much was due to money is still debated.
  • It depends on: whether V is stable, how much spare capacity there is, the time period, and whether new money is spent.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: over five years, an economy's money supply rises by 50%. Real output rises by 5% and the price level hardly changes. According to the quantity equation, what must have happened to V?
Mission check

?A country's central bank doubles the money supply. In the same period, people start holding on to money twice as long before spending it, so V halves. Real output does not change. What happens to the price level?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When a bank lends you money, whose money are you actually borrowing?

Make a guess: When a bank lends someone 10,000, where does that money come from?

Mission 3

What banks do

  • Commercial (retail) banks:
    • Accept deposits and keep them safe.
    • Make loans to households and firms.
    • Run payments: cards, transfers.
  • They channel savings into investment: firms borrow to build and expand.
  • Borrowers pay interest: the price of credit. Banks charge more for riskier loans.
  • Collateral: an asset the bank can take if a loan is not repaid (e.g. a house for a mortgage).
Mission 3

A bank's balance sheet

A bank's balance sheetAssetsLiabilities and capitalReservescash, central bankLiquid assetse.g. billsInvestmentse.g. bondsLoansto customersDepositsowed to customersBorrowingfrom other banksCapitalassets − liabilitiestop: more liquidbottom: more profitable
  • Liabilities: what the bank owes.
    • Customers' deposits (the bank owes them on demand or at a set date).
    • Borrowing from other banks.
  • Assets: what the bank owns or is owed.
    • Reserves: cash and deposits at the central bank. Most liquid, earn least.
    • Liquid assets: e.g. short-term government bills.
    • Loans to customers. Least liquid, earn most.
    • Investments such as bonds.
  • Capital (equity) = assets − liabilities. It absorbs losses.
Mission 3

Liquidity, profitability and security

A bank's balance sheetAssetsLiabilities and capitalReservescash, central bankLiquid assetse.g. billsInvestmentse.g. bondsLoansto customersDepositsowed to customersBorrowingfrom other banksCapitalassets − liabilitiestop: more liquidbottom: more profitable
  • Banks want three things that pull against each other:
    • Profitability: lend long-term at high interest.
    • Liquidity: enough cash and liquid assets to pay depositors who withdraw.
    • Security: avoid losses that would wipe out capital.
  • More lending → more profit, but less liquid and more risk.
  • Rules limit the risk:
    • Reserve ratio (liquidity ratio) = liquid assets ÷ deposits.
    • Capital ratio = capital ÷ risk-weighted assets.
  • Real world: international (Basel III) rules require capital of at least 8% of risk-weighted assets, plus extra buffers.
Quick check
?A bank sells some of its short-term government bills and uses the money to make more 25-year mortgages. What is the most likely effect?
Mission 3

Loans create deposits

A loan creates a depositAssetsLiabilities and capitalReservesLoansDepositsCapitalBefore the loanLoans +10,000Deposits +10,000Borrower's accountbalance +10,000new moneyIllustrative data
  • When a bank makes a loan, it credits the borrower's account with a new deposit.
  • That deposit is new money: no one else's balance went down.
  • Example (illustrative): a bank lends 10,000 to a café owner.
    • Assets: loans +10,000.
    • Liabilities: deposits +10,000.
    • Broad money rises by 10,000 at once.
  • When loans are repaid, deposits fall: money is destroyed.
  • What limits lending? Demand for loans, the risk of non-payment, the interest rate set by the central bank, and capital and liquidity rules.
  • Say: "banks create deposits when they lend" — not: "banks just lend out savers' money".
Mission 3

The money multiplier model

  • A textbook model of how deposits spread through the banking system.
  • Fractional reserve banking: banks keep only a fraction of deposits as reserves and lend the rest.
  • Worked example (illustrative): reserve ratio 10%; a new cash deposit of 1,000.
    • Round 1: keep 100; lend 900. The 900 is spent and deposited in another bank.
    • Round 2: keep 90; lend 810.
    • Round 3: keep 81; lend 729 … and so on.
  • Maximum total deposits = 1,000 × (1 ÷ 0.10) = 10,000.
  • Bank credit multiplier = 1 ÷ reserve ratio = 10.
Mission 3Graph lab

Rounds of lending

Illustrative data. A new deposit of 1,000 enters the banking system.

Rounds of lendingNew deposits, round by roundNew depositRound1510152005001,0001,000Total depositsso far
  • Takeaway: a lower reserve ratio means more of each deposit is lent on, so deposits grow further.
Mission 3

Why the multiplier overstates

  • The simple multiplier assumes banks lend every penny of excess reserves and every loan comes back as a deposit.
  • In reality:
    • Banks may keep excess reserves, e.g. when they fear losses.
    • People and firms hold some cash instead of deposits.
    • Lending depends on demand for loans and on capital rules.
  • Real world:
    • The Fed's required reserve ratio has been 0% since March 2020.
    • Central banks today mostly set interest rates and supply the reserves banks need.
  • So the multiplier is a maximum, not a forecast.
  • Link to prices (quantity theory): if money grows faster than real output, inflation may follow.
Quick check
?Two economies both have a reserve ratio of 10%. In each, the central bank buys government bonds from banks, adding 1,000 to the banks' reserves. In Economy A, banks lend all their excess reserves, and every loan comes back as a deposit. In Economy B, banks keep some extra reserves, and people keep part of their loans as cash. Using the multiplier model, which is correct?
Mission check

?A bank holds 1,000,000 of its customers' savings deposits. It then agrees a new loan of 50,000 to a firm and credits the firm's account. What happens at once to the savers' balances and to the money supply?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why can't you open an account at a central bank, and what does it do instead?

Make a guess: Why can't you open an account at a central bank, and what does it do instead?

Mission 4

The bank behind the banks

The bank behind the banksHouseholdsand firmsCommercial banksBank XBank YCentral bankBank XreservesBank Yreservesmoves
  • A central bank is the bank at the centre of a country's money system. Examples:
  • Bank of England (founded 1694); US Federal Reserve (1913); European Central Bank (1998), for the countries that use the euro.
  • Its customers are the government and commercial banks, not households or firms.
  • Commercial banks hold accounts there called reserves.
  • When customers of one bank pay customers of another, the two banks settle by moving reserves between their accounts at the central bank.
  • It is usually not run for profit: its aim is a stable economy.
Mission 4

What a central bank does

What a central bank doesCentral bankMonetary policysets the policy interest rateIssues banknotesBanker to the governmentBanker to the banksholds their reservesLender of last resortlends to banks short of cashFinancial stabilitywatches risks to the whole system
  • Monetary policy: sets the policy interest rate to keep inflation low and stable.
  • Issues banknotes.
  • Banker to the government: holds its main account and helps manage its borrowing.
  • Banker to the banks: holds their reserves and runs the system they use to pay each other.
  • Lender of last resort: lends to banks that run short of cash.
  • Financial stability: watches for risks to the whole system and, in many countries, supervises banks.
Mission 4

The goal: stable prices

  • Most central banks aim for low, stable inflation, often a numerical target.
  • Many central banks have a target of about 2%, set by the government or by the central bank itself.
  • The ECB aims for 2% inflation over the medium term, also symmetric.
  • Stable prices help firms and households plan, borrow and invest.
Mission 4

The tools

Central bank toolsPolicy rateoften called the bank rate or baserateOpen market operationsbuying or selling government bondsQuantitative easing (QE)buying bonds on a large scale withnew money
  • Policy interest rate: the rate at which the central bank lends to, or pays on reserves of, commercial banks. Other rates tend to follow.
  • Cambridge: the central bank's policy rate (often called the bank rate or base rate); changes feed through to other rates.
  • Open market operations: buying or selling government bonds to change bank reserves and the money supply.
  • Quantitative easing (QE): buying bonds on a large scale with newly created money, to push down long-term rates.
Quick check
?Which of these is a job of a central bank, and not of a commercial bank?
Mission 4

Lender of last resort

Solvent but illiquid: the lender of last resortAssetsLiabilitiesLong-termloansDepositsCapitalassets > liabilities: solventCash boxdepositors withdraw cashCentral bankloan againstcollateralSolvent but illiquid
  • A bank can be solvent (assets worth more than it owes) but illiquid: it cannot turn its loans into cash fast enough.
  • If depositors panic and withdraw at once (a bank run), even a sound bank can fail.
  • The central bank can lend it cash against good collateral: it is the lender of last resort.
  • Classic rule (Walter Bagehot, 1873): lend freely, against good collateral, at a high rate.
  • Real-world: on 14 September 2007 the Bank of England gave emergency support to Northern Rock. Queues of savers still formed outside its branches.
  • Risk: moral hazard. If banks expect rescue, they may take bigger risks.
Quick check
?A bank's loans are worth more than it owes, but depositors suddenly withdraw more cash than it holds. What can the central bank do as lender of last resort?
Mission 4

Central banks, banks and the money supply

  • Most money is bank deposits, created when commercial banks lend (see Mission 3).
  • The central bank shapes that lending:
  • Policy rate: a higher rate makes loans dearer, so banks lend less and deposits grow more slowly.
  • QE: buying bonds creates reserves for banks and deposits for the sellers, so broad money rises directly.
  • Regulation: rules on capital and liquidity limit how far banks can expand lending.
  • So the central bank influences the money supply and the banking sector, but does not fix the quantity of money directly.
Mission 4

Keeping the system safe

  • Banks fail in ways that can spread to the whole economy. Central banks often help regulate them.
  • Some central banks supervise banks themselves; in other countries a separate regulator does it.
  • More on regulation and crises in another lesson.
Mission 4Evaluate

Should central banks be independent?

  • UK: the Bank of England has set interest rates independently since 1997. The ECB's independence is written into EU treaties.
  • For: rate-setters cannot be pushed to cut rates before an election, so promises of low inflation are more credible. Inflation expectations may stay anchored.
  • Against: unelected officials make decisions that affect jobs, house prices and savers; accountability is weaker.
  • Against: monetary and fiscal policy may pull in opposite directions without coordination.
  • It depends on: how the target is set and reviewed, how open the central bank is, and how far it strays into areas such as QE that change who gains and loses.
Quick check
?Why might giving a central bank operational independence help to keep inflation expectations low?
Mission check

?On a busy shopping day, customers of Bank X pay by card at retailers that bank with Bank Y. At the end of the day, Bank X owes Bank Y 2 billion. How is this usually settled?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Money is anything generally accepted as payment. It removes the double coincidence of wants.
  • Functions: medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value.
  • A fourth: standard of deferred payment.
  • Narrow money is notes, coins and reserves; broad money adds bank deposits.

Mission 2

  • The equation of exchange is an identity: money × velocity = price level × real output.
  • The quantity theory assumes stable V and fixed real output, so money growth causes proportional inflation; money is neutral in the long run.
  • Evidence is mixed: V can change a lot, and spare capacity and the direction of causation matter.

Mission 3

  • Banks create money when they lend: a loan creates a matching deposit.
  • Banks balance profitability against liquidity and security; reserve and capital ratios limit risk.
  • The multiplier model: maximum deposits = new reserves × 1 ÷ reserve ratio. It overstates because of idle reserves and cash leakages.

Mission 4

  • A central bank is banker to the government and to the banks; it issues notes and runs monetary policy.
  • Its main goal is low, stable inflation; its tools include the policy rate, open market operations and QE.
  • It is lender of last resort, helps keep the financial system safe, and is often independent of government.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Money and banking (part 1) for Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why will a shop swap a meal for a printed slip of paper but not for a bag of apples?
  2. Mission 2If a country printed twice as much money, would everything really cost twice as much?
  3. Mission 3When a bank lends you money, whose money are you actually borrowing?
  4. Mission 4Why can't you open an account at a central bank, and what does it do instead?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge