← AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708) · 8.3 Labour market forces and government intervention
Mini-Lesson

Labour market forces and government intervention

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Nobody buys workers for their own sake, so what decides how many a business wants to hire?
  2. Mission 2What makes people willing to do a job, and why isn't the pay the whole story?
  3. Mission 3Why do some of the most useful jobs pay less than jobs that seem far less useful?
  4. Mission 4Why would a firm refuse to hire a worker who would add more to its sales than they are paid?
  5. Mission 5Can a group of workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?
  6. Mission 6If a law lifts the lowest pay, do some workers lose their jobs?
  7. Mission 7If a star would happily play for far less, why are they paid so much?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Nobody buys workers for their own sake, so what decides how many a business wants to hire?

Make a guess: Nobody buys workers for their own sake, so what decides how many a business wants to hire?

Mission 1

Derived demand

Derived demanddemand fordeliveries ↑firms producemoredemand fordrivers ↑
  • Firms do not want workers for their own sake. They want the goods and services workers produce.
  • So the demand for labour is a derived demand: derived from the demand for the product.
  • More people order home deliveries → firms want more delivery drivers.
Mission 1

Why labour demand slopes down

Labour demand curveWage rate (W)0W2W1L2L1Quantity of labour (L)D(L)contraction
  • A higher wage → firms want fewer workers: a movement along the demand curve.
  • Call it a contraction in the demand for labour.
  • Substitution effect: labour is now dearer relative to machines, so firms switch to capital where they can.
  • Output (scale) effect: higher costs → higher prices → fewer products sold → fewer workers needed.
  • And diminishing returns: each extra worker adds less output, so is worth hiring only at a lower wage.
  • Axes: "Wage rate (W)" and "Quantity of labour (L)".
Mission 1

Worked example: marginal revenue product

MRP curve and hiringWage, MRP0605040302010123456hire 4 workersNumber of workers (L)MRPMRP = D(L)W = 30Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data. A bakery sells loaves in a competitive market at 5 each.
  • Marginal product (MP): the extra output from one more worker.
  • Marginal revenue product (MRP): the extra revenue from one more worker. MRP = MP × MR.
  • Here P = MR = 5, so MRP = MP × 5.
WorkersTotal outputMPMRP
1121260
2221050
330840
436630
540420
642210
  • Say: "MRP = MP × MR" — not: "MRP = MP × wage".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A juice bar sells juice in a competitive market at 2.50 a cup. With 2 workers it makes 36 cups an hour; with 3 workers it makes 48 cups an hour. What is the marginal revenue product of the 3rd worker per hour?
Mission 1

How many to hire: MRP = wage

MRP curve and hiringWage, MRP0605040302010123456hire 4 workersNumber of workers (L)MRPMRP = D(L)W = 30Illustrative data
  • In a competitive labour market, the firm is a wage taker: each extra worker costs the market wage.
  • Rule: hire while MRP ≥ W; stop where MRP = W.
  • Bakery at W = 30: workers 1–4 have MRP of 60, 50, 40, 30. The 5th adds only 20. Hire 4.
  • So the firm's MRP curve is its demand curve for labour: at each wage, it shows how many workers it hires.
  • Label: "MRP = D(L)". This is marginal productivity theory.
Mission 1

Shifts and movements

Shift of labour demandA shift of the curveWage rate (W)0L1L2Quantity of labour (L)D1(L)D2(L)WA change in the wage: a movement along D1Wage rate (W)0W2W1L2L1Quantity of labour (L)D1(L)
  • A change in the wage → movement along the curve.
  • A wage fall gives an extension; a wage rise gives a contraction.
  • These shift labour demand (D1 → D2):
    • Demand for the product, and so its price (derived demand).
    • Productivity of workers: training, better equipment, better management.
    • Price of capital: cheaper machines that replace workers shift demand left; machines that workers use can shift it right.
    • Non-wage costs of employing workers, e.g. employer payroll taxes.
    • The number of firms hiring this kind of labour.
  • In MRP terms: a higher output price or higher MP shifts the MRP curve right.
  • Say: "a rise in the wage causes a contraction in the demand for labour" — not: "the demand for labour falls".
Mission 1Graph lab

When the price of bread rises

Same bakery. The wage stays at 30. The price of a loaf rises from 5 to 8.

When the price of bread risesMRP of each workerWorkers1234560306090wage = 30
  • Takeaway: a higher output price shifts MRP right; at the same wage, the firm hires 5. Labour demand is derived demand.
Quick check
?Which change would shift the demand curve for bricklayers to the right?
Mission 1Evaluate

How useful is the theory?

  • It depends on elasticity: a wage rise costs few jobs where labour demand is inelastic, many where it is elastic.
  • It depends on productivity: pay can rise without job losses if output per worker rises too.
  • Limits of marginal productivity theory:
    • The MP of one worker is hard to measure in teams and in services (a nurse, a teacher).
    • Wages are often set by bargaining, monopsony or law, not by MRP alone.
    • Firms may not aim only to maximise profit.
  • But it predicts the direction of change well: higher product prices or productivity → more hiring.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: cheaper imports cut the price that farmers get for strawberries. The wage that farms must pay strawberry pickers does not change. What happens to the number of pickers that farms want to employ?
Mission 2

Mission 2: What makes people willing to do a job, and why isn't the pay the whole story?

Make a guess: What makes people willing to do a job, and why isn't the pay the whole story?

Mission 2

Who supplies labour, and why it slopes up

Labour supply curveWage rate (W)0W2W1L1L2Quantity of labour (L)S(L)extension
  • Households supply labour; firms demand it.
  • Each hour of work is an hour less of leisure. The wage is the reward for giving it up.
  • Supply to one occupation slopes up: a higher wage draws workers in from other jobs, and from outside the labour force.
  • A change in the wage → movement along the supply curve.
  • Call it an extension (wage up) or contraction (wage down) of supply.
  • Three levels: an individual's hours; supply to an occupation or industry; supply to the whole economy.
  • Axes: "Wage rate (W)" and "Quantity of labour (L)"; curve "S(L)".
Mission 2

Monetary and non-monetary factors

  • Monetary (wage) factors: basic pay, overtime, bonuses, commission, pensions, perks.
  • Non-monetary (non-wage) factors:
    • working conditions: safety, hours, stress, flexibility, holidays;
    • job security and promotion and training chances;
    • status, satisfaction, location, commuting time.
  • Workers weigh the net advantages of a job: pay plus everything else.
  • Say: "an improvement in working conditions shifts labour supply to the right" — not: "it causes an extension of supply".
  • Only the wage moves along the curve.
Mission 2

What shifts the supply of labour

Shift of labour supplyWage rate (W)0WL3L1L2Quantity of labour (L)S1(L)S2(L)S3(L)Right (S1 to S2): education, immigration, betterconditionsLeft (S1 to S3): higher pay elsewhere
  • These shift supply to an occupation (S1 → S2):
    • Wages in other jobs (alternatives): higher pay elsewhere → supply here shifts left.
    • Working conditions and other non-wage factors.
    • Qualifications and training needed, and licensing rules.
    • Education: more people with the right skills → shifts right.
    • Immigration: more workers arriving → shifts right.
    • Demographics: the size and age of the population.
    • Leisure preferences and culture, e.g. attitudes to working parents.
    • Taxes and benefits: affect the reward from working compared with not working.
Quick check
?Which change would shift the supply curve of delivery drivers to the right?
Mission 2

Income and substitution effects

Backward-bending individual labour supplyWage rate (W)0251510303436Hours workedSsubstitutioneffectdominatesincomeeffectdominatesIllustrative data: 10 pay, 30 hours; 15 pay, 36hours; 25 pay, 34 hours
  • A wage rise has two effects on an individual's hours:
    • Substitution effect: each hour of leisure now costs more lost pay → work more.
    • Income effect: you can reach the same income in fewer hours → buy more leisure, work less (leisure is a normal good).
  • Worked example (illustrative data):
Wage per hourHours chosenWeekly pay
1030300
1536540
2534850
  • 10 → 15: substitution effect stronger: hours rise.
  • 15 → 25: income effect stronger: hours fall, though pay still rises.
  • So an individual's supply curve can bend backwards at high wages.
  • Supply to an occupation still usually slopes up: higher pay attracts new workers.
Quick check
?A freelance designer's hourly rate doubles. She decides to work fewer hours each week, though her weekly earnings still rise. What best explains her choice?
Mission 2

The whole economy: population, migration, participation

  • Labour supply to the whole economy depends on:
    • population size and age structure: more people of working age → more labour;
    • net migration: workers moving in or out;
    • participation: the share of working-age people in the labour force (working or looking for work).
  • Participation rate = labour force ÷ working-age population × 100.
  • Participation depends on childcare, retirement age, health, education (students), and culture.
  • Example: in many high-income countries, far more women joined the labour force from the 1970s onward.
Quick check
?In a country, a large generation of workers reaches retirement age and leaves the labour force. Few young people are entering work, and wages have not changed. What happens to the economy's labour supply?
Mission 2Evaluate

Will higher pay bring more workers?

  • It depends on non-monetary factors: poor conditions can outweigh a pay rise (e.g. jobs with long hours or high stress).
  • It depends on time: jobs with long training respond slowly; supply is more elastic in the long run.
  • It depends on mobility: workers may lack the skills, or live too far away.
  • It depends on income vs substitution effects: existing workers may choose fewer hours.
  • It depends on taxes and benefits: what workers keep, compared with not working.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: in past years, a hospital found that each pay rise attracted more nurses. This year it raises nurses' pay by 10%, and at the same time brings in longer, less flexible shifts. The number of nurses willing to work there barely changes. What is the best explanation?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why do some of the most useful jobs pay less than jobs that seem far less useful?

Make a guess: What mostly decides how much a job pays?

Mission 3

Wages are a price

Labour market equilibriumWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)D = MRPS (labour)Above We wages are bid down; below We theyare bid up.
  • The wage rate is the price of labour.
  • Demand for labour comes from firms. It is a derived demand: firms want workers for the goods and services they make (see Mission 1).
  • Supply of labour comes from workers. More people offer to work in a job at a higher wage (see Mission 2).
  • In a competitive labour market (many firms, many workers, none able to set the wage), the wage settles where demand meets supply: We, Le.
  • Above We: more workers want the job than firms want to hire, so wages are bid down. Below We: firms cannot fill jobs, so wages are bid up.
  • The demand curve for labour is the MRP curve: D = MRP.
Mission 3

What shifts the curves

Shifts of demand and supply of labourDemand for labour rises (shifts right)Wage rate (W)0W2W1L1L2Quantity of labour (L)D1(L)S(L)D2(L)Supply of labour rises (shifts right)Wage rate (W)0W1W2L1L2Quantity of labour (L)D(L)S1(L)S2(L)
  • Demand for labour shifts right when: demand for the product rises · its price rises · workers become more productive (training, better machines) · machines that replace workers become dearer.
  • Supply of labour shifts right when: more people have the skills or qualifications · the job becomes more attractive (safer, flexible hours, status) · the working population grows (including migration) · wages in other jobs fall.
  • A change in the wage itself moves along the curves; it does not shift them.
  • Wage elasticity of labour demand or supply = % change in quantity of labour ÷ % change in the wage.
  • Say: "an extension of the supply of labour" for a move along S — not: "supply of labour increases".
Quick check
?A new rule means it takes two more years to qualify as an electrician. Other things equal, what happens in the market for electricians?
Mission 3

One firm: hire until MRP equals the wage

Firm as a wage takerThe market sets the wageWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)D = MRPS (labour)One firm takes that wageWage rate (W)0WeLfQuantity of labour (L)S = ACL = MCLMRP
  • A firm in a competitive labour market is a wage taker: it can hire as many workers as it wants at the market wage.
  • So the supply of labour to the firm is horizontal at We. Each extra worker adds exactly We to costs.
  • Label it S = ACL = MCL (average and marginal cost of labour).
  • MRP (marginal revenue product): the extra revenue from one more worker. MRP = MP × MR.
  • Rule: hire while MRP > wage; stop where MRP = wage.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm sells its product for 3 in a perfectly competitive market and pays the market wage of 15 per day. The table shows the marginal product of each extra worker. How many workers should it hire to maximise profit?
Workers123456
Marginal product (units per day)1098642
Mission 3Graph lab

When demand for labour rises

When demand for labour risesWageQuantity of labour0300900051015202552012DS
  • Takeaway: when supply of labour is inelastic, a rise in demand mostly raises the wage; when it is elastic, it mostly raises employment.
Mission 3

Worked example: demand for labour rises

  • Illustrative data. Labour demand: Ld = 1000 − 40W. Labour supply: Ls = 60W − 200. (W = wage per hour, L = workers.)
  • Equilibrium: 1000 − 40W = 60W − 200 → 100W = 1200 → W = 12, L = 520.
  • Demand for the product rises: Ld = 1200 − 40W.
  • New equilibrium: 1200 − 40W = 60W − 200 → W = 14, L = 640.
  • Wage: +2 ÷ 12 = +16.7%. Employment: +120 ÷ 520 = +23.1%.
  • Wage elasticity of supply of labour along S ≈ 23.1 ÷ 16.7 ≈ 1.38: elastic, so employment rises by a larger % than the wage.
  • Say: "demand for labour increased, causing an extension of supply" — not: "supply increased".
Mission 3

Why wages differ

Two labour marketsMarket A (e.g. surgeons)Wage rate (W)0WALAQuantity of labour (L)DSMarket B (e.g. shelf-stackers)Wage rate (W)0WAWBLBQuantity of labour (L)DSwage differential
  • Wage differentials: gaps in pay between jobs, people, regions or sectors.
  • Demand side: high productivity or a valuable product means high demand for the worker.
  • Supply side: long training, rare skills or talent keep supply small and inelastic.
  • Compensating differentials: dangerous, dirty or night-shift jobs must pay more to attract workers.
  • Non-money rewards: jobs people love (a sense of vocation, status, long holidays) attract more workers, so supply is larger and pay lower.
  • Immobility: workers who cannot move or retrain let gaps last.
  • Market power and discrimination also matter.
  • Like water and diamonds: water is vital but cheap; a diamond is not vital but costs far more.
  • How useful a thing is does not set its price. Scarcity relative to demand does.
Mission 3

Real data: a pay ladder

  • US, May 2024, mean annual wage (BLS):
  • All occupations: $67,920.
  • Registered nurses: $98,430.
  • Fast food and counter workers: $31,350.
  • UK, April 2025 (ONS): median full-time weekly pay £766.60.
  • A full-time adult on the National Living Wage (£12.21 an hour in 2025) working 37.5 hours earned £457.88 a week.
  • Both kinds of work are useful. Nurses need years of training (small supply) and are in high demand. Fast food jobs need little training, so many people can do them (large supply).
Quick check
?Use the US data in the previous screen. By about what percentage was the mean wage of registered nurses above that of fast food and counter workers in May 2024?
Mission 3

What differentials do

  • Signals: high pay tells workers where to train and move. Over time supply shifts right and the gap can narrow.
  • Skill shortages: if training takes years, a gap can last and posts stay unfilled.
  • Inequality: wider differentials mean a more unequal spread of income.
  • Technology: machines that replace routine tasks cut demand for some workers and raise it for workers whose skills work with the machines.
Mission 3

Evaluate: will the gap last?

It depends on…

  • Time to train: supply of surgeons responds over years; supply of shelf-stackers in weeks.
  • Mobility and information: workers must know about better-paid jobs and be able to move to them.
  • Market power: a single big employer or a strong union can hold the wage away from We.
  • Discrimination: groups paid less for the same productivity.
  • Is the demand change lasting? A short boom may end before new workers qualify.
Mission check

?Care workers are widely seen as vital, yet in many countries they earn less than many office workers. Other things equal, which change would most likely raise care workers' wage?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why would a firm refuse to hire a worker who would add more to its sales than they are paid?

Make a guess: A firm is the only big employer in town. One more worker would add more to its sales than the wage it pays. Why might it still not hire them?

Mission 4

One buyer

  • Monopsony: a market with a single buyer (or one dominant buyer).
  • In a labour market: one employer hires most of the workers with a particular skill or in a particular place.
  • Examples: a mine or factory in a remote town · a state health service that employs most of a country's nurses.
  • In a product market: a few large retailers buying from many small farmers.
  • A monopsonist is a wage setter, not a wage taker.
  • Say: "monopsony" (one buyer) — not: "monopoly" (one seller).
Mission 4

Why one more worker costs more than the wage

Supply and marginal cost of labourWage rate (W)0LQuantity of labour (L)ACL = SMCLGap: extra pay for workers already hired
  • A monopsonist faces the whole upward-sloping supply curve of labour.
  • To attract one more worker it must raise the wage.
  • It must pay that higher wage to all its workers, not just the new one.
  • So the marginal cost of labour is above the wage.
  • Labels: ACL = S (average cost of labour = the wage) and MCL (marginal cost of labour), drawn above ACL.
Mission 4

Worked example: the cost of one more worker

  • Illustrative data. A firm is the only employer in its town. Wage needed to attract L workers: W = 4 + 2L (per hour).
  • Total cost of labour = L × W. Marginal cost = change in total cost when one more worker is hired.
Workers (L)Wage neededTotal wage billMarginal cost of labourMRP
166631
28161027
310301423
412481819
514702215
616962611
  • 5th worker: the wage rises from 12 to 14 for all 5 workers. Wage bill: 48 → 70. Marginal cost = 22, not 14.
Quick check
?Use the table in the previous screen. The firm employs 3 workers at a wage of 10 an hour. What is the marginal cost of hiring a 4th worker?
Mission 4

The monopsony diagram

MonopsonyWage rate (W)0WcWmLmLcQuantity of labour (L)MRP = DACL = SMCLA wage taker would hire Lc at WcHire where MRP = MCL: employment LmWm is read from the supply curve: Wm < Wc, Lm< Lc
  • Step 1: the supply of labour and the MRP curve. If the employer acted as a wage taker, it would hire where they cross: Wc, Lc.
  • Step 2: draw MCL above ACL = S. Profit is greatest where MRP = MCL: employment Lm.
  • Step 3: the firm pays the lowest wage that attracts Lm workers. Read down to the supply curve: wage Wm.
  • Result: Wm < Wc and Lm < Lc. Fewer workers, lower pay.
  • The last worker hired at Lm adds more revenue (MRP) than they are paid (Wm).
  • Say: "read the wage from the supply curve" — not: from the MRP or the marginal cost curve.
Mission 4Graph lab

How many workers?

How many workers?Wage, MRP, costWorkers23456010203016ACL = SMCLMRP = D25Profit from labour
  • Takeaway: the monopsonist stops where MRP = marginal cost of labour, even though the next worker's MRP is above their wage. In the table from an earlier screen it hires 4 workers at a wage of 12. A wage taker facing the same curves would hire 5 at about 14, so the firm turns down a 5th worker who would add 15 to its sales and be paid 14.
Quick check
?On a monopsony diagram, the firm employs Lm. What does the vertical distance between the MRP curve and the supply curve at Lm show?
Mission 4

Monopsony without one employer

  • Firms can set wages even when there are several employers, if workers cannot easily switch.
  • Imperfect information: workers do not know what other firms pay or which jobs are open.
  • Immobility and switching costs: long commutes, housing costs, family ties, firm-specific skills.
  • Each firm then faces an upward-sloping supply of labour, so it has some monopsony power.
  • Employers acting together can do the same. Real case: in 2015 a US court approved a $415 million settlement of a lawsuit claiming that Apple, Google, Intel and Adobe agreed not to recruit each other's staff, holding pay down.
  • Union power can offset monopsony power (a later screen, Mission 5).
Mission 4

Limiting monopsony power

  • Trade unions: bargain as one seller of labour.
  • Minimum wages: can raise both pay and employment in a monopsony (see Mission 6).
  • Regulation and competition policy: codes of practice, fines, bans on no-poaching deals.
  • Better information and mobility: job adverts with pay ranges, help with moving.
Mission 4

Bilateral monopoly

Bilateral monopolyWage rate (W)0WmLmQuantity of labour (L)MRP = DACL = SMCLRange of possible wages: bargainingUnion: pushes the wage upEmployer: pushes the wage down
  • Bilateral monopoly: a monopsony buyer faces a monopoly seller. In labour: one employer and one trade union.
  • The employer wants Wm at Lm.
  • At Lm, each worker's MRP is above Wm, so the union can press for more. The most the firm would pay to keep Lm workers is the MRP at Lm.
  • The wage settles somewhere between Wm and MRP at Lm. Where exactly is indeterminate: it depends on bargaining power.
  • Union power: share of workers in the union, strike threat, the firm's profits, the law, public support.
  • A union wage between Wm and Wc can raise both pay and employment (see Mission 5).
Quick check
?Illustrative data: rows from the monopsony worked example (W = 4 + 2L).
Workers (L)Wage neededMarginal cost of labourMRP
3101423
4121819
5142215

A union now represents all the firm's workers, and the firm still employs at least 4 workers. Within what range of hourly wages would we expect the agreed wage to fall?

Mission 4

Evaluate: is monopsony always harmful?

It depends on…

  • Elasticity of labour supply to the firm: the more easily workers can leave, the less the firm can cut pay.
  • Whether savings reach consumers: in a competitive retail market, lower costs can mean lower prices.
  • Countervailing power: a big buyer facing a big seller may bring the price closer to the competitive level.
  • The long run: low pay and low supplier prices can reduce training, investment and supply.
  • Who is protected: unions, minimum wages and regulators can limit the power.
Mission check

?A region has many apple farmers but only one buyer, a juice company. To buy more apples it must offer a higher price, and it pays that price on all the apples it buys. Compared with a market where many buyers compete (same supply, same value of apples to buyers), what would we expect?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Can a group of workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?

Make a guess: Can a union win higher pay without costing any jobs?

Mission 5

What a trade union does

  • A trade union: an organisation of workers that acts for its members.
  • Collective bargaining: the union negotiates pay and conditions for all its members at once, instead of each worker alone.
  • Aims: higher pay · better conditions and safety · job security · training · a voice in how work changes.
  • Tools: negotiation; if talks fail, industrial action (strikes, overtime bans, working to rule).
  • A union acts as a single seller of labour: some of the market power of a monopoly.
Mission 5

Real data: unions in the UK

  • UK, 2025 (Department for Business and Trade):
  • 6.6 million employees were union members.
  • Union density (members as % of employees): 22.4%, down from 32.4% in 1995.
  • Public sector 48.5%; private sector 12.1%.
  • Union membership peaked at 13.2 million in 1979 (unions listed in Great Britain).
  • Union wage premium: members' average hourly pay was 5.3% above non-members' in 2025 (before allowing for other differences between the two groups).
Quick check
?In 2025, 6.6 million UK employees were union members and union density was 22.4%. About how many employees were there in total?
Mission 5

A union in a competitive labour market

Union in a competitive labour marketWage rate (W)0WuWeLuLeLsexcess supply of labour (unemployment)Quantity of labour (L)supplywith unionD = MRPSIllustrative data: We = £12, Le = 520; Wu = £14,Lu = 440, Ls = 640
  • Without a union: wage We, employment Le.
  • The union negotiates Wu above We. Firms will not pay less, so the supply of labour to firms is horizontal at Wu, then follows S.
  • At Wu firms move up their demand curve: employment falls to Lu.
  • At Wu more people want these jobs (Ls). The gap Ls − Lu is excess supply of labour.
  • Illustrative data: Ld = 1000 − 40W, Ls = 60W − 200. We = £12, Le = 520.
  • Union wage £14: Ld = 1000 − 560 = 440; Ls = 840 − 200 = 640.
  • Employment falls by 80; excess supply 200.
  • Wage +16.7%, employment −15.4%: the wage elasticity of demand for labour is about −0.92.
Mission 5

Raising pay without losing jobs (competitive market)

  • Inelastic demand for labour: if firms cannot easily cut jobs, a higher wage costs few jobs.
  • Productivity deals: the union agrees new working methods or training. Higher productivity shifts demand for labour right.
  • Shifting demand in other ways: campaigns for the industry's product, health and safety that cuts sick days.
  • High profits: a firm earning supernormal profit can pay more without closing.
  • Otherwise, in a competitive market, a wage above We means fewer jobs: union members gain, but others (outsiders) lose.
  • Say: "a contraction of demand for labour" — not: "demand for labour falls" (the curve has not moved).
Mission 5

A union facing a monopsony

Union facing a monopsonyWage rate (W)0WcWuWmLmLuLcQuantity of labour (L)MRP = DACL = SMCLMCL = ACL = Wu, then MCLDashed: MCL before the unionThe union wage Wu lies between Wm and Wc:employment rises from Lm to Lu
  • Recall (see Mission 4): a monopsonist hires where MRP = MCL and pays the low wage Wm on the supply curve.
  • The union sets a wage Wu between Wm and Wc. Now the firm can hire up to the supply curve at Wu, with no need to raise anyone's pay.
  • So the MCL becomes horizontal at Wu (MCL = ACL = Wu) up to the supply curve.
  • The firm hires more workers, because each extra worker now costs only Wu.
  • Illustrative data: ACL = S: W = 5 + 0.5L; MCL = 5 + L; MRP = 20 − 0.5L (L = workers).
  • Monopsony: 5 + L = 20 − 0.5L → L = 10, W = £10.
Mission 5Graph lab

Set the union wage

Set the union wageWageQuantity of labour0203002010£10ACL = SMCLMRP = D
  • Takeaway: between the monopsony wage and the MRP at the monopsony level of employment, a union wage can raise employment; push higher and jobs fall. At a union wage of £12: workers willing = (12 − 5) ÷ 0.5 = 14; the firm wants (20 − 12) ÷ 0.5 = 16. Employment = 14, so pay and employment rise: £10 → £12, 10 → 14 workers.
Quick check
?Use the model in an earlier screen. The union sets the wage at £14 instead. How many workers does the firm employ?
Mission 5

What gives a union power?

  • Membership: a high share of the workforce in the union, so a strike stops production.
  • Inelastic demand for labour, which is more likely when:
  • wages are a small share of total costs · workers are hard to replace with machines or other workers · demand for the product is price inelastic.
  • The firm's profits: profitable firms can afford to pay more.
  • The state of the economy: low unemployment makes strikers harder to replace.
  • The law: rules on ballots, strikes and picketing.
  • Information: unions can tell members what similar workers earn, which reduces employers' power from imperfect information.
Mission 5

Unions and labour market flexibility

  • Labour market flexibility: how quickly wages, hours and jobs adjust to changes in demand.
  • Unions may reduce flexibility:
  • Wage rigidity: wages slow to fall when demand falls, so more jobs are lost.
  • Resisting job cuts, new methods or changes to hours.
  • Unions may also help:
  • Voice: workers raise problems instead of quitting, cutting staff turnover and training costs.
  • Agreeing change: productivity deals can be easier with one negotiating partner.
  • Countering monopsony power.
Quick check
?Unions in four industries each win a 10% pay rise. Other things equal, in which industry are job losses likely to be smallest?
Mission 5

Evaluate: do unions help or harm?

It depends on…

  • Market structure: in a monopsony, unions can raise pay and jobs; in a competitive market, higher pay usually costs some jobs.
  • Elasticity of demand for labour: the more inelastic, the smaller the job loss.
  • Productivity: deals that raise output per worker can pay for higher wages.
  • Who is counted: insiders (members in work) may gain while outsiders lose jobs or chances.
  • Scale and timing: strikes cost output; wage rises above productivity growth across the economy can push up costs and prices.
Mission check

?On a remote island, one fish-processing plant employs almost all workers and pays the monopsony wage. A new union agrees a wage above the current wage but below the wage a competitive market would set. The plant can hire anyone willing to work at that wage. What happens to employment at the plant?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If a law lifts the lowest pay, do some workers lose their jobs?

Make a guess: A government raises the minimum wage. What happens to the number of jobs?

Mission 6

A legal wage floor

  • A minimum wage: the lowest hourly wage an employer may legally pay.
  • It is a price floor in the labour market. It only has an effect if set above the equilibrium wage.
  • Aims: raise low pay · reduce in-work poverty and inequality · make work pay more than benefits.
  • UK example: a National Minimum Wage since 1999. The rate for workers aged 21 and over is called the National Living Wage.
  • From 1 April 2026: £12.71 an hour for 21 and over (it was £12.21 in 2025); £10.85 for ages 18–20; £8.00 for ages 16–17 and apprentices.
  • Rates are set by the government on the advice of the Low Pay Commission.
Mission 6

The diagram: a competitive labour market

Minimum wage in a competitive labour marketWage rate (W)0WminWeLdLeLsexcess supply of labour (unemployment)Quantity of labour (L)D = MRPS (labour)
  • Step 1: labour market clears at We, Le.
  • Step 2: a minimum wage Wmin above We.
  • At Wmin, firms move up their demand curve: employment contracts to Ld.
  • More people want to work at Wmin: supply of labour extends to Ls.
  • Step 3: Ls − Ld is excess supply of labour: unemployment caused by the minimum wage.
  • Workers who keep their jobs earn more; those who lose jobs or cannot find one lose.
  • Say: "a contraction of demand for labour" — not: "demand for labour falls" (the curve has not moved).
Mission 6

Worked example

Minimum wage in a competitive labour marketWage rate (W)098450600excess supply of labour (unemployment)Quantity of labour (L)D = MRPS (labour)WminIllustrative data: We = £8, Le = 500; Wmin = £9,Ld = 450, Ls = 600
  • Illustrative data. Ld = 900 − 50W; Ls = 100W − 300 (W in £ per hour, L = workers).
  • Equilibrium: 900 − 50W = 100W − 300 → We = £8, Le = 500.
  • Minimum wage £9: Ld = 900 − 450 = 450; Ls = 900 − 300 = 600.
  • Employment falls by 50. Unemployment (excess supply) = 600 − 450 = 150.
  • Wage +12.5%; employment −10%.
  • Wage elasticity of demand for labour ≈ −10 ÷ 12.5 = −0.8 (inelastic): the wage bill rises from £4000 to £4050 an hour.
Quick check
Minimum wage in a competitive labour marketWage rate (W)098450600excess supply of labour (unemployment)Quantity of labour (L)D = MRPS (labour)WminIllustrative data: We = £8, Le = 500; Wmin = £9,Ld = 450, Ls = 600
?Use the market in the previous screen. The minimum wage is set at £10 instead. How much unemployment does it create?
Mission 6

How big is the effect?

  • The bite: the minimum wage as a % of the median wage. A higher bite affects more jobs.
  • UK bite: 45.6% in 1999, 52.5% in 2015; the government then set a target of two-thirds of median hourly pay, to be reached in 2024.
  • Elasticity of demand for labour: job losses are bigger where machines or other workers can replace low-paid staff, wages are a big share of costs, or customers can switch.
  • Elasticity of supply of labour: the more new job-seekers a higher wage draws in, the bigger the excess supply.
  • Firms can also respond in other ways: cut hours, training or perks · raise prices · accept lower profit · reorganise to raise productivity.
Mission 6Graph lab

Set the minimum wage

Set the minimum wageWageQuantity of labourDSminimum wage
  • Takeaway: a floor below We does nothing; above We, the job loss grows with the bite and with the elasticity of demand for labour.
Mission 6

A minimum wage facing a monopsony

Minimum wage and a monopsonyWage rate (W)0WcWminWmLmL1LcQuantity of labour (L)MRP = DACL = SMCLMCL = ACL = Wmin, then MCLDashed: MCL before the minimum wageWmin lies between Wm and Wc: employmentrises from Lm to L1
  • Recall (see Mission 4): a monopsony employer hires Lm at wage Wm, below the competitive Wc, Lc.
  • A minimum wage between Wm and Wc makes the MCL horizontal at Wmin: an extra worker no longer raises everyone's pay.
  • The firm hires more, up to the supply curve: wages and employment both rise.
  • Set above the MRP at Lm, it would cut employment below Lm.
  • The same logic as a union wage (see Mission 5).
Mission 6

Evidence: what happened?

  • New Jersey, 1992: the state minimum wage rose from $4.25 to $5.05 an hour. Neighbouring Pennsylvania's did not change.
  • Card and Krueger (1994) surveyed fast-food restaurants in both states. They found no fall in New Jersey's fast-food employment relative to Pennsylvania's.
  • Critics (Neumark and Wascher, 2000), using payroll records, found a small fall. The debate on methods continues.
  • UK: the Low Pay Commission (2024) said it had "not found strong evidence" that the National Living Wage reduced employment or hours.
  • Effects depend on the bite: evidence from moderate rises may not apply to much larger ones.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Country X has a minimum wage of 6 dollars an hour and a median wage of 10 dollars. Country Y has a minimum wage of 9 dollars and a median wage of 18 dollars. Other things equal, which minimum wage is more likely to reduce employment?
Mission 6

Evaluate: does a minimum wage help?

It depends on…

  • The bite: moderate floors show small job effects; very high ones risk more.
  • Elasticity of demand for labour: easy substitution by machines means larger losses.
  • Market structure: with monopsony power, a floor can raise jobs and pay.
  • The economy: in a recession, firms are less able to absorb higher costs.
  • Who gains: many minimum-wage earners are not in the poorest households; benefits and taxes may target poverty better.
  • Other effects: higher productivity and lower staff turnover can offset the cost; fewer hours or perks can offset the gain.
Mission check

?A minimum wage is raised by the same amount above the market wage in two industries. In industry A, firms can easily replace staff with self-service machines. In industry B, there is no practical substitute for the workers, and wages are a small share of costs. Other things equal, where is the fall in employment likely to be larger?
Mission 7

Mission 7: If a star would happily play for far less, why are they paid so much?

Make a guess: If a star would happily play for far less, why are they paid so much?

Mission 7

Two parts of every wage

One wage, two parts50,000 per weekeconomic rent48,000transfer earnings 2,000coachingIllustrative data
  • Transfer earnings: the minimum payment needed to keep a factor of production in its current use.
    • Usually what it could earn in its next best alternative use.
  • Economic rent: any payment to a factor above its transfer earnings.
  • Illustrative data. A professional footballer is paid 50,000 per week. His best other job, coaching, would pay 2,000 per week.
    • Transfer earnings: 2,000. Economic rent: 50,000 − 2,000 = 48,000.
  • Lose the economic rent and he still plays. Pay him less than his transfer earnings and he switches to coaching.
  • Say: "economic rent" — not: the rent a tenant pays for a flat. Economic rent is a surplus over the minimum needed.
Quick check
?A graphic designer earns 900 per week. Her best alternative job, in advertising, would pay 600 per week. (Illustrative data.) Which is correct?
Mission 7

On the diagram

Economic rent and transfer earningsWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)SD(L)transfer earnings: area under Seconomic rent: above S, below We
  • The labour supply curve shows, for each worker, the wage needed to attract them into this job.
  • The first workers would work here for little; later workers need more to tempt them from other jobs.
  • The market wage W is set by demand and supply. Every worker gets W, not their own minimum.
  • At wage We and employment Le:
    • Transfer earnings = the area under the supply curve, from 0 to Le.
    • Economic rent = the area above the supply curve and below the wage line.
  • Total earnings = We × Le = transfer earnings + economic rent.
  • The same idea applies to every factor: land, labour, capital and enterprise.
Mission 7

Worked example: measuring the areas

Economic rent and transfer earningsWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)SD(L)transfer earnings: area under Seconomic rent: above S, below We
  • Illustrative data. Wage 12 per hour; 80 thousand workers employed.
  • The supply curve starts at a wage of 4 and rises in a straight line to 12 at 80 thousand.
  • Total earnings: 12 × 80 = 960 thousand per hour.
  • Economic rent (triangle above S): ½ × 80 × (12 − 4) = 320 thousand.
  • Transfer earnings (the rest): 960 − 320 = 640 thousand.
    • Check: rectangle 4 × 80 = 320, plus triangle ½ × 80 × 8 = 320, gives 640.
  • One-third of these workers' earnings is economic rent.
Quick check
?A labour supply curve is a straight line starting at a wage of 6. The market wage is 20, and 50 thousand workers are employed. (Illustrative data.) What is economic rent, in thousands per hour?
Mission 7

Elasticity decides the split

Elasticity extremesPerfectly inelasticWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)D(L)SPerfectly elasticWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)D(L)SUpward slopingWage rate (W)0WeLeQuantity of labour (L)D(L)Seconomic renttransfer earnings
  • Perfectly inelastic supply (vertical): the workers would work here at any wage. All earnings are economic rent.
  • Perfectly elastic supply (horizontal): any cut in the wage and every worker leaves. All earnings are transfer earnings.
  • In between: the less elastic the supply, the larger the share of economic rent.
  • Inelastic supply comes from rare skills, long training and few alternative jobs.
  • So a large share of economic rent is a sign that the factor has few good alternative uses.
Mission 7Graph lab

Who is earning a surplus?

Illustrative data. The wage stays at 12 and employment at 80 thousand; total earnings 960 thousand.

Who is earning a surplus?WageWorkers (thousands)04012004816208012transfer earningsDS
  • Takeaway: the same pay can be mostly surplus or mostly the cost of keeping workers; elasticity of supply decides.
Mission 7

Applying it to factor markets

  • Land: the total supply of land is fixed. David Ricardo (1817) argued that rent on land is a surplus: the land is there whatever it is paid.
  • Top performers: a rare talent has inelastic supply, and many employers want it. High demand bids the wage up, far above what the star would accept. Most of a star's pay is economic rent.
  • Jobs with many alternatives (e.g. shop work): workers can easily switch, so most of the pay is transfer earnings.
  • Time: in the short run, few people have the skills for a booming job, so supply is inelastic and economic rent is high. In the long run others train, supply becomes more elastic, and the rent shrinks.
  • A short-run rent that disappears as new supply arrives is called quasi-rent.
  • Tax: a tax that takes only economic rent leaves the supply of the factor unchanged. A tax that cuts into transfer earnings drives the factor elsewhere.
Quick check
?Which person's earnings are most likely to be mostly economic rent?
Mission 7Evaluate

Can high pay be taxed without losing the worker?

It depends on:

  • How much is rent. A tax on economic rent leaves the worker in the job; a tax that cuts below transfer earnings does not.
  • Measurement. Transfer earnings are hard to observe: no one knows a worker's minimum.
  • Mobility. A footballer who could play abroad has a high next best alternative, so his transfer earnings, for one country, are high.
  • Time. Rent in a booming job attracts new entrants and shrinks; taxing it may slow that.
  • Fairness. Whether large economic rents are fair is a value judgement, separate from the efficiency question.
Mission check

?In a city's business district, the amount of land is fixed. More firms want offices there, and the annual payment to landowners per square metre doubles. The land has no other use that would pay more. (Illustrative data.) How much of the increase in payments to landowners is economic rent?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Labour demand is derived demand: it depends on demand for the product.
  • MRP = MP × MR; a firm hires until MRP = wage, so the MRP curve is its labour demand curve.
  • A wage change moves along the curve; product price, productivity, capital prices and non-wage costs shift it.

Mission 2

  • Labour supply to a job slopes up: a higher wage draws workers from other jobs and from outside the labour force.
  • The wage moves along the curve; non-wage factors, alternatives, education, migration and demographics shift it.
  • For an individual, a strong income effect can mean fewer hours at a higher wage.

Mission 3

  • In a competitive labour market the wage is set where demand for labour meets supply of labour.
  • Wage differentials come from differences in demand (productivity) and supply (skills, training, how pleasant the job is).
  • A wage-taking firm hires until MRP = wage.

Mission 4

  • A monopsonist must raise the wage for all workers to hire one more, so the marginal cost of labour is above the wage.
  • It hires where MRP = MCL and pays the wage on the supply (ACL) curve: lower wage, lower employment than a competitive market.
  • In bilateral monopoly the wage is indeterminate between Wm and the MRP at Lm.

Mission 5

  • A union bargains collectively and acts as a single seller of labour.
  • In a competitive labour market, a wage above equilibrium usually cuts employment unless demand for labour is inelastic or shifts right.
  • Facing a monopsony, a union wage between Wm and Wc can raise both pay and employment.

Mission 6

  • A minimum wage above equilibrium creates excess supply of labour in a competitive market.
  • How many jobs it costs depends on the bite and on the elasticity of demand for labour.
  • In a monopsony, a minimum wage between Wm and Wc can raise both pay and employment.

Mission 7

  • Transfer earnings: the minimum to keep a factor in its current use. Economic rent: everything above that.
  • On a supply diagram, transfer earnings lie under the supply curve and economic rent above it, up to the wage.
  • The less elastic the supply, the larger the share of economic rent.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Labour market forces and intervention for Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Nobody buys workers for their own sake, so what decides how many a business wants to hire?
  2. Mission 2What makes people willing to do a job, and why isn't the pay the whole story?
  3. Mission 3Why do some of the most useful jobs pay less than jobs that seem far less useful?
  4. Mission 4Why would a firm refuse to hire a worker who would add more to its sales than they are paid?
  5. Mission 5Can a group of workers win higher pay without anyone losing their job?
  6. Mission 6If a law lifts the lowest pay, do some workers lose their jobs?
  7. Mission 7If a star would happily play for far less, why are they paid so much?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge