← AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708) · 11.3 Economic development
Mini-Lesson

Economic development

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?
  2. Mission 2Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?
  3. Mission 3As countries grow richer, why do workers move from farms to factories and then to services?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?

Make a guess: Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?

Mission 1

Income per person

Size vs shareLarge total GDPSmaller total GDPmany peoplefew peoplesmaller slicebigger sliceGDP per capita: one person's sliceTotal GDP = the whole pie, the size of theeconomy.
  • Living standards: how well people live.
    • Material: the goods and services they can consume.
    • Non-material: health, education, safety, free time, a clean environment.
  • Total GDP shows the size of an economy, not how well-off its people are.
  • GDP per capita = GDP ÷ population: average output, and income, per person.
  • GNI per capita adds net income from abroad, so it can be a better guide to residents' income.
  • NNI per capita also subtracts depreciation.
  • The World Bank classifies economies as low, lower-middle, upper-middle or high income by GNI per capita in US dollars.
Mission 1

Comparing countries: PPP

One basket, two pricesSame basket50 US dollarsUnited StatesSame basket1,000 zedsCountry ZPPP rate = 1,000 ÷ 50 = 20 zeds per dollarMarket rate50 zeds per dollarPPP rate20 zeds per dollarAt the market rate150,000 ÷ 50 = 3,000 dollarsAt PPP150,000 ÷ 20 = 7,500 international dollarsCountry Z's GDP per capita: 150,000 zeds.Illustrative data.
  • To compare, convert to one currency (usually US dollars).
  • Market exchange rates move with trade and capital flows, and ignore that prices differ between countries.
  • Purchasing power parity (PPP): an exchange rate at which the same basket of goods and services costs the same in both countries.
  • Illustrative data. A basket costs 50 US dollars in the US and 1,000 zeds in Country Z. PPP rate = 20 zeds per dollar. Market rate = 50 zeds per dollar.
  • Z's GDP per capita is 150,000 zeds:
    • at the market rate: 3,000 dollars
    • at PPP: 7,500 international dollars
  • Services such as haircuts and rent are usually cheaper in lower-income countries, so PPP figures raise their incomes.
  • Say: "GDP per capita at PPP" for living standards — not: at market exchange rates.
Quick check
?Country K's GDP per capita is 2,000 US dollars at market exchange rates and 6,000 international dollars at PPP. What best explains the gap?
Mission 1

What GDP misses

The GDP icebergMarket output: counted in GDPNonmarket outputHome cookingChildcareVolunteeringNot captured by GDPHidden economyLeisurePollutionDistribution
  • Nonmarket output: cooking, cleaning, caring for children or relatives, home repairs, volunteering. It is produced but not sold, so it is not in GDP.
  • Hidden economy: work not reported, to avoid tax or rules.
  • Leisure: GDP can be the same whether people work 35 or 50 hours a week.
  • Environment: pollution and lost resources are not subtracted; spending to clean up adds to GDP.
  • Health, education, safety and freedom are not measured directly.
  • Distribution: per capita is an average; it does not show who gets the income.
  • Say: "GDP measures market output" — not: "GDP measures welfare".
Quick check
?A parent leaves a paid job to look after their own child at home. The family stops paying for childcare. Nothing else changes. What happens to measured GDP?
Mission 1

Average or typical? Mean and median

  • GDP per capita is a mean: total ÷ number of people.
  • The median is the middle income when incomes are ranked: the typical person.
  • Illustrative data. Five incomes (thousands): 10, 15, 20, 25, 80.
    • Mean = 30. Median = 20.
  • Next year only the top income rises, to 130.
    • Mean = 40 (up 33%). Median = 20 (unchanged).
  • So GDP per capita can rise while the typical person is no better off.
Mission 1Evaluate

How useful is GDP per capita for comparing living standards?

It depends on:

  • What you compare: between countries, use PPP; over long periods, quality and new products are hard to capture.
  • The nonmarket and hidden economy: larger in some countries, so their output is understated more.
  • Distribution: the same mean can hide very different median incomes.
  • What else differs: working hours, health, environment, freedom.
  • But: GDP data are regular, follow international rules (the UN System of National Accounts), and tend to go with better health and education.
  • So: use GDP per capita alongside other indicators, not alone.
Mission check

?Real GDP per capita in Country P is 20% higher than in Country Q, measured in the same prices. Which finding would most weaken the claim that people in P have a higher material living standard?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?

Make a guess: Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?

Mission 2

Growth is not the same as development

Growth is not the same as developmentEconomic growthreal GDP risesthey can overlapEconomic developmentwell-being risesincomehealtheducationfreedom
  • Economic growth: an increase in real GDP (output) over time.
  • Economic development: an improvement in people's well-being and living standards. It is multidimensional:
    • higher incomes and less poverty
    • better health and longer lives
    • more education and skills
    • more freedom and choice (Amartya Sen: development as expanding what people are able to do and be)
  • Growth can happen without much development: the gains may go to a few, or come with pollution.
  • Development can happen with slow growth: cheap public health and schooling can lengthen and improve lives.
  • Say: "growth is a rise in real output; development is a rise in well-being" — not: "development means growth".
Mission 2

Monetary indicators

The indicator dashboardIncome per person(PPP)HealthEducationInequalitymonetary indicatornon-monetary indicatorsWorld Bank income groups (by GNI per capita)low incomelower-middle incomeupper-middle incomehigh incomeDials show what is measured, not values
  • GDP per capita: output per person. GNI per capita adds net income from abroad.
  • NNI per capita also subtracts depreciation of capital.
  • Compare countries at purchasing power parity (PPP): it corrects for differences in price levels (prices tend to be lower in poorer countries).
  • Classification: developed, developing and emerging economies.
  • The World Bank groups economies as low, lower-middle, upper-middle or high income by GNI per capita.
Mission 2

Non-monetary indicators

The indicator dashboardIncome per person(PPP)HealthEducationInequalitymonetary indicatornon-monetary indicatorsWorld Bank income groups (by GNI per capita)low incomelower-middle incomeupper-middle incomehigh incomeDials show what is measured, not values
  • Health: life expectancy at birth, infant mortality rate, maternal mortality.
  • Education: adult literacy rate, years of schooling.
  • Inequality: Gini coefficient, income share of the richest 10%.
  • One indicator alone gives only part of the picture.
Quick check
?A government wants one indicator to track whether its new clinics are reducing deaths among babies. Which is best?
Mission 2

The Human Development Index (HDI)

HDI: three pillarsHDI: scored from 0 to 1Healthlifeexpectancy atbirthEducationexpectedyears ofschooling;mean years ofschoolingStandard oflivingGNI per capitaat PPPDimension index (0 to 1)10.8000.600Health0.6750.533Education0.6960.696IncomeCountry PCountry QHDI and UNDP groupsQ 0.606P 0.72201low: below 0.550medium: 0.550 to 0.699high: 0.700 to 0.799very high: 0.800 and aboveIllustrative data
  • Published by the UN Development Programme (UNDP) since 1990.
  • Three dimensions, four indicators:
    • a long and healthy life: life expectancy at birth
    • knowledge (education): expected years of schooling for children; mean years of schooling for adults
    • a decent standard of living: GNI per capita at PPP
  • Each dimension is scored from 0 to 1, then combined. The HDI runs from 0 to 1.
  • UNDP groups: very high (0.800 and above), high (0.700–0.799), medium (0.550–0.699), low (below 0.550).
  • Say: "HDI measures health, education and income" — not: "HDI measures income".
Mission 2

Worked example: same income, different HDI

HDI: three pillarsHDI: scored from 0 to 1Healthlifeexpectancy atbirthEducationexpectedyears ofschooling;mean years ofschoolingStandard oflivingGNI per capitaat PPPDimension index (0 to 1)10.8000.600Health0.6750.533Education0.6960.696IncomeCountry PCountry QHDI and UNDP groupsQ 0.606P 0.72201low: below 0.550medium: 0.550 to 0.699high: 0.700 to 0.799very high: 0.800 and aboveIllustrative data
  • Illustrative data. Countries P and Q both have GNI per capita of 10,000 international dollars (PPP).
Life expectancyExpected schoolingMean schooling
P72 years13.5 years9 years
Q59 years12 years6 years
  • Each dimension is scaled between a minimum and a maximum (life expectancy: 20 to 85 years):
    • Health: P (72 − 20) ÷ 65 = 0.800; Q (59 − 20) ÷ 65 = 0.600
    • Education: P 0.675; Q 0.533
    • Income: both 0.696
  • HDI: P = 0.722 (high); Q = 0.606 (medium).
  • Same income, but P's people live longer and learn more.
  • Two design features:
    • Income enters as a logarithm: doubling P's income to 20,000 raises HDI only to 0.756. An extra dollar matters more to the poor.
    • The three scores are combined by a geometric mean, so a very low score in one dimension pulls the HDI down more than a simple average would.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Country S has a GNI per capita at PPP far higher than Country T's, but T has the higher HDI. What best explains this?
Mission 2

Poverty and welfare: MPI and MEW

  • Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI), UNDP and Oxford University, since 2010.
  • Ten indicators in the same three dimensions as HDI:
    • health: nutrition, child mortality
    • education: years of schooling, school attendance
    • living standards: cooking fuel, sanitation, drinking water, electricity, housing, assets
  • A household is multidimensionally poor if it is deprived in at least one third of the weighted indicators.
  • It shows who is poor and in what way, not just average income.
  • Measure of Economic Welfare (MEW), Nordhaus and Tobin (1972): starts from GNP, adds leisure and unpaid work, subtracts pollution, commuting costs and defence spending.
  • MEW is closer to welfare, but its valuations are judgements and it is rarely published.
Quick check
?Which indicator would best show whether poor households in a region now have electricity, clean water and children in school?
Mission 2

Why development is hard to measure

  • Data quality: large informal and subsistence sectors; surveys are costly and infrequent.
  • Averages hide distribution: a rising mean can leave the poor behind.
  • Value judgements: which dimensions count, and how to weight them?
  • Missing dimensions: freedom, security, culture and the environment are hard to put in numbers.
  • PPP estimates depend on price surveys that may be out of date.
Mission 2

How growth and development are linked

How growth and development are linkedGrowth: real GDPrisesHigher incomes andtax revenueMore health andeducationMore productiveworkersexitThe loop breaks if:•gains go to a few•growth comes from exporting a resourcethat employs few people•growth damages health and theenvironment
  • Growth can fund development:
    • higher incomes for families
    • more tax revenue for schools, clinics, water and roads
  • Development can fuel growth: healthier, better-educated workers are more productive.
  • But growth may not bring development if:
    • the gains go to a few (rising inequality)
    • growth comes from exporting a resource that employs few people
    • it damages health and the environment
  • So the link is likely but not automatic: it depends on how the gains are shared and spent.
Mission 2Evaluate

Is HDI a better measure of development than GNI per capita?

It depends on:

  • The purpose: HDI captures health and education; GNI per capita at PPP better shows material living standards.
  • Distribution: both are averages.
  • What is left out: HDI has no measure of inequality, freedom, the environment or happiness.
  • Weights: HDI weights its three dimensions equally. That is a judgement, not a fact.
  • So: use HDI as a better starting point than income alone, alongside other indicators.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. Over 20 years, Country X's GNI per capita at PPP doubled, mainly from oil exports owned by a small group. Life expectancy and years of schooling barely changed. Which conclusion is best supported?
Mission 3

Mission 3: As countries grow richer, why do workers move from farms to factories and then to services?

Make a guess: As countries grow richer, why do workers move from farms to factories and then to services?

Mission 3

What less-developed economies tend to have in common

Country profileA typical less-developed economyLow income per headMany workers in farmingLarge informal sectorYoung population, high birth rateExports: a few primary commoditiesTendencies, not rules
  • Low income per head and a large share of people in poverty.
  • A large share of workers in agriculture, often small-scale and low-productivity.
  • A large informal sector: unregistered, untaxed work.
  • High birth rates and a young population; higher infant mortality.
  • Low savings and investment; weak infrastructure.
  • Exports concentrated in a few primary commodities.
  • These are tendencies, not rules: developing economies differ hugely from each other.
Mission 3

Three sectors

Sector shiftShare of employment (%)0Level of developmentprimarysecondarytertiarySchematic, not dataFarming’s share of the world’s jobs199142.8%202326.6%Source: ILO modelled estimates, World Bank
  • Primary: extracting natural resources: farming, fishing, forestry, mining.
  • Secondary: manufacturing and construction.
  • Tertiary: services: retail, finance, health, education, tourism.
  • As countries develop, the main share of jobs and output moves primary → secondary → tertiary.
  • Real data: farming's share of the world's jobs fell from 42.8% in 1991 to 26.6% in 2023.
  • In high-income economies, most workers are in services. The share of jobs in manufacturing has fallen: deindustrialisation.
Mission 3

Why the structure changes

Why workers moveFarm productivityrisesSpending shifts togoods and servicesWorkers leave farmingHousehold spending, illustrativeLow income60%25%15%High income15%35%50%foodmanufactured goodsservicesIllustrative data
  • Productivity in farming rises: better seeds, fertiliser, machines. Fewer workers produce the food a country needs.
  • Demand shifts: as incomes rise, people spend only a little more on food. Spending on manufactured goods, then services, grows faster.
    • Food has a low income elasticity of demand; many services are income elastic.
  • So workers move to factories and cities, and later into services.
  • In rich economies, manufacturing becomes more capital-intensive, and some moves to lower-cost countries. Its share of jobs falls even if its output rises.
  • Say: "the share of workers in farming falls" — not: "farm output falls".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. In Country H today, 3% of workers are in the primary sector, 20% in the secondary sector and 77% in the tertiary sector. Thirty years ago the secondary share was 35%. Which statement is best supported?
Mission 3

Population: births, deaths and migration

Demographic transitionRate per 1,000 peoplebirth ratedeath ratenaturalincreaseStage 1Stage 2Stage 3Stage 4Total populationTimeSchematic, no country data
  • Birth rate: live births per 1,000 people per year.
  • Death rate: deaths per 1,000 people per year.
  • Infant mortality rate: deaths of babies under one year old per 1,000 live births.
  • Natural increase = birth rate − death rate. Net migration = immigrants − emigrants.
  • Worked example (illustrative data): birth rate 35, death rate 10 per 1,000.
    • Natural increase = 35 − 10 = 25 per 1,000 = 2.5% a year.
    • At 2.5% a year the population doubles in about 70 ÷ 2.5 = 28 years.
  • Demographic transition: death rates fall first (clean water, vaccines, medicine), so population grows fast. Birth rates fall later (lower infant mortality, education of women, urban living, contraception).
  • Migration: emigration can drain skills (brain drain) but brings remittances home.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Country J has a birth rate of 30 per 1,000, a death rate of 8 per 1,000 and net migration of −4 per 1,000 (more people leave than arrive). By what percentage does J's population change in a year?
Mission 3

Optimum population

Optimum populationOutput per head0optimum populationPopulationunder-populationover-populationnew technology
  • Optimum population: the population at which output per head is highest, given a country's land, capital and technology.
  • Under-population: too few workers to make full use of resources; more people would raise output per head.
  • Over-population: diminishing returns to labour on fixed resources; more people lower output per head.
  • The optimum moves: new technology or more capital raises it.
  • It is hard to measure, so it is a guide to thinking, not a target.
Mission 3

Urbanisation

  • Urbanisation: a rising share of people living in towns and cities.
  • Real data: 55% of the world's people lived in urban areas in 2018. In 2018 the UN projected 68% by 2050.
  • Pull factors: jobs in industry and services, higher wages, schools, hospitals.
  • Push factors: low farm incomes, lack of land, drought.
  • Benefits: firms and workers gain from being close together; services are cheaper to provide.
  • Costs: informal settlements (slums), congestion, pollution, pressure on water and housing.
Mission 3

Inequality and development: the Kuznets curve

Kuznets curveInequality (Gini coefficient)0Income per headKuznets hypothesis: a possible pattern, not alaw
  • Simon Kuznets (1955): as income per head rises, inequality first rises, then falls: an inverted U.
  • Axes: income per head (horizontal) vs inequality, e.g. the Gini coefficient (vertical).
  • Why it might rise: workers move from low-income farming to better-paid industry; the gap between the two groups grows.
  • Why it might fall: most workers reach the modern sector; education spreads; governments redistribute.
  • Evidence is mixed:
    • some East Asian economies grew fast with relatively low inequality
    • inequality has risen in many high-income countries since the 1980s
  • So it describes a possible pattern, not a law.
Quick check
?A low-income country begins to industrialise. Workers move from farms to much better-paid factory jobs in the cities. According to the Kuznets hypothesis, what is most likely to happen to its Gini coefficient at first?
Mission 3

Trade patterns at different levels of development

  • Low-income countries: mostly export primary commodities (crops, minerals, oil); import manufactures and fuel.
  • Emerging economies: export more manufactures; China became a major exporter of manufactured goods.
  • High-income countries: trade much in services (finance, education, tourism) and in similar manufactured goods with each other (intra-industry trade).
  • Dependence on a few commodities exposes a country to volatile world prices.
Mission 3Evaluate

Are these characteristics causes or results of low development?

It depends on:

  • Direction of cause: a large farm sector may hold incomes down, but low incomes also keep demand for other goods low.
  • Population: rapid growth strains resources, but a young workforce can be a dividend if there are jobs and schools.
  • Urbanisation: cities raise productivity if housing, water and transport keep up; otherwise slums grow.
  • Policy and institutions: two countries with the same features can develop very differently.
  • So: these features describe where a country is; they do not on their own decide where it goes.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. In Country Z, new seeds and machines double the output of each farm worker. As incomes rise, people spend only a little more on food. What is most likely to happen to the share of Z's workers in farming?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Real GDP per capita is the usual starting point for comparing living standards.
  • Between countries, convert at PPP, not market exchange rates.
  • GDP leaves out nonmarket output.
  • It also misses the hidden economy, leisure, the environment and distribution.

Mission 2

  • Growth is a rise in real output; development is a rise in well-being on many dimensions.
  • HDI combines health, education and income (GNI per capita at PPP) into one index from 0 to 1.
  • The MPI counts households deprived in health, education and living standards.
  • MEW adjusts national income for leisure, unpaid work and harm.
  • No single number captures development: use several indicators.

Mission 3

  • Less-developed economies tend to have more workers in agriculture, younger populations and more informal work.
  • As incomes rise, jobs move from primary to secondary to tertiary sectors.
  • Natural increase = birth rate − death rate; add net migration for total change.
  • Optimum population maximises output per head; the Kuznets curve suggests inequality rises, then falls, with development.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Economic development for Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?
  2. Mission 2Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?
  3. Mission 3As countries grow richer, why do workers move from farms to factories and then to services?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to AS & A Level Economics · Cambridge