← A-Level Economics · AQA A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Economics (7136) · 4.2.2 How the macroeconomy works: the circular flow of income, AD/AS analysis and related concepts (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

How the macroeconomy works: the circular flow of income, AD/AS analysis and related concepts (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why does business spending on new machines and buildings swing so much more than household spending?
  2. Mission 2If a government spends 1 billion, why can the country's income end up growing by much more?
  3. Mission 3Why can a jump in oil prices make a whole economy produce less and charge more at once?
  4. Mission 4If a slump ends by itself, why do some economists say we should not wait?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why does business spending on new machines and buildings swing so much more than household spending?

Make a guess: Why does business spending on new machines and buildings swing so much more than household spending?

Mission 1

What counts as investment

  • Investment (I): spending by firms on capital goods used to produce future output.
  • Examples: factories, offices, machines, vehicles, computers, software.
  • Fixed capital: long-lasting assets such as buildings and machinery. In national accounts: gross fixed capital formation.
  • Inventories (stocks) of raw materials and unsold goods: also counted in investment.
  • Buying shares or second-hand assets is not investment: no new capital is made.
  • I is an injection into the circular flow and a component of AD.
Mission 1

Gross and net investment

Gross and net investmentstart 1,000Gross investment 150Depreciation100Capital stock: 1,000 → 1,050Net investment +50Gross investment 80Depreciation100Capital stock: 1,000 → 980Net investment −20Net investment = gross investment −depreciation. Illustrative data.
  • Depreciation (capital consumption): capital worn out or out of date in a year.
  • Gross investment: all spending on new capital goods, including replacements.
  • Net investment = gross investment − depreciation. The change in the capital stock.
  • Illustrative data: capital stock 1,000 at the start of the year.
  • Gross investment 150, depreciation 100 → net investment +50. Capital stock ends at 1,050.
  • Gross investment 80, depreciation 100 → net investment −20. Capital stock shrinks to 980.
  • Say: "net investment is negative" when replacement falls short — not: "firms bought no capital".
Quick check
?In a year, an economy's gross investment is 120 billion and depreciation is 135 billion (illustrative data). Which statement is correct?
Mission 1

What drives investment

Firms invest when the expected return beats the cost.

  • Interest rates: the cost of borrowing, or the return given up on retained profits. Higher rates → less I.
  • Expectations and business confidence: expected future sales and profits.
  • Growth of demand: firms need more capacity when sales rise.
  • Technology: new machines can cut costs or make new products.
  • Business taxes: profit taxes and tax allowances on investment change the return.
  • Credit availability: firms need banks willing to lend.
Mission 1

Worked example: is the project worth it?

Illustrative data. A firm can buy a machine for 1,000,000. It expects a return of 6% a year (60,000).

  • Borrow at 4%: interest cost 40,000 a year < 60,000 return. Worth it.
  • Borrow at 7%: interest cost 70,000 a year > 60,000 return. Not worth it.
  • Using its own savings? It still gives up 4% or 7% it could earn elsewhere: the opportunity cost.
  • If expected sales fall, the expected return falls too, at any interest rate.
Mission 1Graph lab

Rates, confidence and AD

Rates, confidence and ADPrice levelReal national output (Y)SRASAD
  • Takeaway: a change in I, for any reason, shifts AD.
Mission 1

Animal spirits

  • The return on a factory comes over 10, 20 or 30 years. Nobody knows that future well.
  • Keynes (1936) called the urge to invest anyway "animal spirits": "a spontaneous urge to action rather than inaction".
  • Moods spread: optimism → many firms invest; pessimism → many wait.
  • Investment can be postponed: an old machine can run another year. Bread and rent cannot wait.
  • So investment rises and falls far more than consumption over the cycle.
Mission 1

The accelerator

The acceleratorDemand (units)1,0001,1001,3001,4001,400Net investment (machines)01210Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 4: growth slows → I falls1 machine per 100 units of demand. Illustrativedata.
  • Accelerator: net investment depends on the change in output (demand), not its level.
  • Net investment = capital–output ratio × change in output.
  • Illustrative data: 1 machine per 100 units of output. No machines wear out.
YearDemandMachines neededNet investment (machines)
11,000100
21,100111
31,300132
41,400141
51,400140
  • Year 3 → 4: demand still rises, but more slowly, so investment halves.
  • Year 5: demand steady → net investment zero.
  • Small changes in the growth of demand cause big swings in investment.
Quick check
?A firm needs 1 machine for every 50 units of output. Machines do not wear out. Demand over four years is 500, 600, 700 and 750 units (illustrative data). What happens to net investment between year 3 and year 4?
Mission 1Evaluate

Will cheaper borrowing raise investment?

It depends on:

  • Expectations: in a slump, low rates may not outweigh gloomy sales forecasts.
  • Credit: after a financial crisis, banks may refuse to lend at any rate.
  • Spare capacity: firms with idle machines need no new ones.
  • Time lags: projects take months or years to plan.
  • Accelerator limits: firms may not expect a rise in demand to last; the capital–output ratio is not fixed; idle capacity breaks the link.
Mission check

?After a financial crisis, the central bank cuts interest rates to a record low. Business confidence collapses, and banks sharply cut lending to firms. What is most likely to happen to investment?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a government spends 1 billion, why can the country's income end up growing by much more?

Make a guess: If a government spends 1 billion, why can the country's income end up growing by much more?

Mission 2

One injection, many rounds

One injection, many rounds of spendingpassed on: becomes the next round'sincomewithdrawals (saving, tax, imports)Round 1: 10020Round 2: 8016Round 3: 6412.8Round 4: 51.2Rounds added up…total approaches 500Illustrative data: 80% of each extra unit of
  • The government spends 100 (million) on a new bridge. An injection.
  • Builders earn 100. They spend some of it and withdraw the rest (saving, tax, imports).
  • Illustrative data: 80% of each extra unit of income is spent on domestic output.
  • Round 1: 100 → round 2: 80 → round 3: 64 → round 4: 51.2 → …
  • Each person's spending is someone else's income.
  • The rounds add up to 500: national income rises by 5 times the injection.
  • Multiplier effect: a change in an injection causes a larger final change in national income.
  • It works in reverse too: a cut in an injection reduces income by more than the cut.
Mission 2Graph lab

Re-spend more

Re-spend moreRounds of spending100R150R225R313R46R53R6200Total risein income
  • Takeaway: the more of each round is re-spent, the bigger the multiplier.
Mission 2

The multiplier formula

  • Marginal propensity to consume (MPC): the share of each extra unit of income that is spent. MPC = ΔC ÷ ΔY. On the first screen of this mission it was 0.8.
  • Marginal propensity to save (MPS): the share of extra income saved.
  • Multiplier (k) = 1 ÷ (1 − MPC).
  • Closed economy, no government: 1 − MPC = MPS, so k = 1 ÷ MPS.
  • Final change in national income = k × change in injection.
  • Example: MPC = 0.8. k = 1 ÷ 0.2 = 5. A rise of 100 in investment → national income rises by 500.
  • Say: "real national income rises by k times the injection" — not: "the injection is multiplied at once". It takes many rounds.
Quick check
?In a closed economy with no government, the MPC is 0.75. Investment rises by 40 billion. If there is spare capacity, by how much does national income finally rise?
Mission 2

The multiplier on the AD/AS diagram

The multiplier on the AD/AS diagramPrice level0P3P1Y1Y3Real national output (Y)full shift of ADAD1AD2AD3SRASinjectionmultiplierAn injection shifts AD right by the first round ofspending.Each round adds more: the multiplier shifts ADfurther.With upward-sloping SRAS, output rises by lessthan the shift, and the price level rises.
  • Step 1: an injection rises (say G). AD shifts right by the first-round amount: AD1 → AD2.
  • Step 2: the multiplier adds further rounds: AD2 → AD3.
  • Step 3: with upward-sloping AS, part of the extra demand raises the price level. Real output rises by less than the full shift.
  • Near full capacity, most of the effect is on prices, not real output.
Mission 2

How big in reality?

  • Real-world multipliers are estimated, not observed. Estimates vary widely.
  • IMF (2012): forecasts for 2010–11 had assumed fiscal multipliers of about 0.5. Its own estimate for the years after the 2008 crisis was higher: about 0.9 to 1.7.
  • Multipliers tend to be larger in deep recessions with spare capacity.
  • They tend to be smaller near full capacity, in very open economies, or if interest rates rise in response.
  • Economists still disagree on the size: it matters for debates on stimulus and austerity.
Mission 2Evaluate

How strong is the multiplier?

It depends on:

  • Spare capacity: near full capacity, extra demand mostly raises prices.
  • Withdrawals: the more of each round that is saved, taxed or spent on imports, the smaller the multiplier.
  • Confidence: worried households may save extra income.
  • Time lags: the rounds take months to work through.
  • Size: a small injection in a large economy barely shows.
Quick check
?A large car factory closes, and investment in the region falls sharply. What happens to national income, other things equal?
Mission check

?Two economies get the same rise in government spending. In Economy X, households spend much of any extra income on imports. In Economy Y, they buy mostly home-produced goods. Saving and tax rates are the same. Which statement is correct?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why can a jump in oil prices make a whole economy produce less and charge more at once?

Make a guess: Why can a jump in oil prices make a whole economy produce less and charge more at once?

Mission 3

Aggregate supply in the short run

The SRAS curvePrice level0Real national output (Y)SRAS
  • Aggregate supply (AS): the total real output that all firms in an economy plan to produce at each price level, in a given period.
  • Axes: Price level (vertical), Real national output (Y) (horizontal).
  • Short run: some costs, especially money wages (wages in cash terms, also called nominal wages), are fixed. Firms cannot change every cost straight away.
  • The SRAS curve slopes upwards: a higher price level goes with more real output.
  • Long run: all costs can adjust, so the long-run curve (LRAS) is drawn differently.
Mission 3

Why SRAS slopes upwards

Why SRAS slopes upwardsPrice on each unit: 20 → 22Illustrative dataWage per unit: still 12fixed by contractProfit per unit before4Profit per unit after5.6Price level0PL2PL1Y1Y2Real national output (Y)SRAS
  • Sticky wages: money wages are set in contracts and pay deals, often for a year. They do not rise straight away when prices rise.
  • So when the price level rises:
    • firms get more for each unit they sell
    • many costs per unit stay the same
    • profit per unit rises, so firms supply more
  • Rising costs near capacity: to produce more, firms pay overtime and use older, less efficient machines. Extra output costs more, so it needs a higher price level.
  • The reverse holds too: a lower price level squeezes profit per unit, so firms cut output.
  • Say: "a higher price level", "real output" — not: "a higher price", "quantity". This is the whole economy, not one market.
Mission 3

Worked example: a firm with a fixed wage

  • Illustrative data. A firm sells each unit for 20.
  • Costs per unit: wages 12 (fixed by contract for a year), materials 4.
  • Profit per unit: 20 − 12 − 4 = 4.
  • The price level rises by 10%. The firm's price and its materials both rise by 10%:
    • price: 20 × 1.1 = 22
    • materials: 4 × 1.1 = 4.4
    • wages: still 12
  • New profit per unit: 22 − 12 − 4.4 = 5.6, up 40%.
  • Producing more now pays, so output rises: a movement up along SRAS.
  • When wages are renegotiated up 10% (to 13.2), profit per unit is 22 − 13.2 − 4.4 = 4.4: the same as 4 once prices are 10% higher. The extra reason to produce disappears in the long run.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm sells its product for 50. Per unit, it pays 30 in wages, fixed by contract for the year, and 10 for materials. The price level then rises by 10%, and the firm's price and materials cost rise by 10% too. What is the firm's new profit per unit?
Mission 3

Movement along SRAS or shift?

Movement along SRAS versus shift of SRASPrice level0PL2PL1Y1Y2Real national output (Y)ABSRASSRAS1SRAS2extensioncosts rise
  • A change in the price level → a movement along SRAS.
    • Price level rises → output rises: an extension of SRAS.
    • Price level falls → output falls: a contraction of SRAS.
  • A change in firms' costs (anything other than the price level) → a shift of SRAS.
    • Costs rise → SRAS shifts left (up): less output at each price level.
    • Costs fall → SRAS shifts right (down).
  • Say: "SRAS shifts left" — not: "SRAS falls" or "SRAS moves up".
Mission 3

What shifts SRAS

What shifts SRASMoney wages risecosts up: SRAS shifts leftRaw material or energy pricesrisecosts up: SRAS shifts leftCurrency falls in valuecosts up: SRAS shifts leftIndirect or business tax risescosts up: SRAS shifts leftSubsidy to producerscosts down: SRAS shifts rightProductivity risescosts down: SRAS shifts right
ChangeEffect on firms' costs per unitSRAS
Money wages rise (no rise in productivity)UpLeft
Raw material or energy prices riseUpLeft
Currency falls in value (imported inputs cost more)UpLeft
Indirect tax or business tax risesUpLeft
Subsidy to producersDownRight
Productivity rises (more output per worker hour)DownRight
  • Say: "the cost of imported raw materials rises" — not just "the exchange rate changes". Name the direction and the cost it affects.
Mission 3Graph lab

Push firms' costs up

Illustrative data. AD is fixed. Start: price level 100, real output 1000.

Push firms' costs upPrice levelReal national output (Y)6008001,200801201401,000100ADSRAS
  • Takeaway: higher costs shift SRAS left; with AD unchanged the price level rises and real output falls (100 → 110; 1000 → 900).
Quick check
?A country's firms import much of their energy and many components. Its currency falls sharply in value. Looking only at the effect on firms' costs, what happens to SRAS?
Mission 3

Real world: the 1973–74 oil shock

The 1973-74 oil shockPrice of oil: 2.90 → 11.65dollars a barrel, before the embargo toJanuary 1974Source: Federal Reserve HistoryPrice level0PL2PL1Y2Y1Real national output (Y)ADSRAS1SRAS2stagflation
  • In October 1973, Arab oil producers began an embargo on oil exports to the United States and other countries.
  • The price of oil rose from 2.90 dollars a barrel before the embargo to 11.65 dollars a barrel in January 1974: about four times as much.
  • Oil is an input to transport, power, plastics and fertiliser, so costs rose across the economy: SRAS shifted left.
  • The US was in recession from November 1973 to March 1975, while prices rose fast.
  • Rising prices and falling output together: stagflation.
  • Caution: US inflation was already rising before the embargo. The oil shock added to it; it was not the only cause.
Mission 3Evaluate

How much damage does a cost shock do?

It depends on:

  • Size and duration. A brief price spike may barely move SRAS; a lasting rise shifts it for years.
  • How much firms use the input. Energy-heavy industries (steel, chemicals, transport) are hit far harder than services.
  • Second-round effects. If workers win higher money wages to keep up with prices, SRAS shifts left again.
  • Firms' margins. Firms with high profits may absorb some of the cost rather than raise prices.
  • Policy. Subsidies or tax cuts can offset some of the rise in costs, at a cost to public finances.
Mission check

?New software lets workers in most firms produce 10% more each hour. Money wages and AD do not change. What is the most likely short-run effect?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If a slump ends by itself, why do some economists say we should not wait?

Make a guess: If a slump ends by itself, why do some economists say we should not wait?

Mission 4

Two views of aggregate supply

Two views of aggregate supplyClassical LRASPrice level0YfeReal national output (Y)LRASKeynesian ASPrice level0YfeReal national output (Y)spare capacitybottlenecksfull capacity
  • Classical view: LRAS is vertical at full-employment output, Yfe.
  • Keynesian view: AS is reverse-L shaped.
    • flat with large spare capacity, rising as bottlenecks appear, vertical only at full capacity
  • The two views agree at full capacity: more AD there only raises prices.
  • They disagree about below full capacity: does the economy get back to full-employment output on its own, and how fast?
Mission 4

A recessionary gap closes itself (in theory)

A recessionary gap closesPrice level0P1P2P3Y2Yfenegative output gapReal national output (Y)AD1SRAS1LRASAD2SRAS2Nominal wages fall, so SRAS shifts right.Back on LRAS at Yfe, at a lower price level P3.
  • Start: AD has fallen. Output is below full employment; unemployment is above its natural rate.
  • With many people looking for work, nominal wages fall (and other input prices fall).
  • Lower costs → SRAS shifts right.
  • The price level falls, so more real output is bought (a movement down along AD).
  • This continues until SRAS meets AD on LRAS.
  • Long run: output back at full employment, unemployment back at its natural rate, price level lower.
  • Adjustment can be slow. Until it happens, output is lost and unemployment stays high, so governments and central banks may act instead.
Mission 4

An inflationary gap closes itself

An inflationary gap closesPrice level0P3P2P1YfeY2positive output gapReal national output (Y)AD1SRAS1LRASAD2SRAS2Nominal wages rise, so SRAS shifts left.Back on LRAS at Yfe, at a higher price level P3.
  • Start: AD has risen. Output is above full employment; unemployment is below its natural rate.
  • Labour is scarce, and workers expect prices to keep rising: they win higher nominal wages.
  • Higher costs → SRAS shifts left.
  • The price level rises again; real output falls back.
  • Long run: output back at full employment, unemployment at its natural rate, price level higher than before the boom.
  • So a lasting rise in AD has no lasting effect on real output: only the price level is higher.
  • Say: "SRAS shifts", not "LRAS shifts": capacity has not changed.
Quick check
?An economy has an inflationary (positive output) gap. There is no change in policy, and wages and prices are flexible. Which describes how the economy returns to full employment?
Mission 4Graph lab

Wait and watch

Illustrative data. AD has just fallen: the economy is in a recessionary gap, with output 4% below potential.

Wait and watchPrice levelReal national output (Y)1,8002,200901001101201,920104.7LRASAD1AD2SRAS1
  • Takeaway: self-adjustment works through wages and SRAS; output returns to potential at a lower price level.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. An economy is in long-run equilibrium: price level 110, real output 2,000 (billions). A jump in oil prices shifts SRAS left, and the short-run equilibrium becomes price level 115, output 1,950. Oil stays expensive, LRAS does not change, AD does not change, and there is no policy response. Wages and prices are fully flexible. Where does the economy end up in the long run?
Mission 4

The assumptions behind each view

Vertical-LRAS viewKeynesian
Wages and pricesFlexible, down as well as upSticky, especially downwards
MarketsClear: labour supply = labour demandMay not clear for long periods
ExpectationsAdjust: wages soon track pricesSlow to adjust; confidence can stay low
Unemployment in the long runNatural rateCan stay above it (demand-deficient)
Long runArrives fairly quicklyCan take years
Aggregate supplyVertical LRAS at full-employment outputReverse-L; vertical only at full capacity
  • Implication: in the vertical-LRAS view, AD affects only the price level in the long run. In the Keynesian view, AD can change real output and jobs for years.
Mission 4

Why a slump can last

A recessionary gap that persistsPrice level0P1Y1Yfenegative output gapReal national output (Y)AD1AD2AS (Keynesian)Incomes fall, so AD may shift left again(dashed).
  • Why nominal wages may not fall:
    • wage contracts last a year or more
    • trade unions resist pay cuts
    • minimum wage laws set a floor
    • firms prefer to lay off some workers than cut everyone's pay and damage morale
  • Prices can be slow to fall too: changing them has costs.
  • Keynes's second point: even if wages fall, workers' incomes fall. Spending falls, so AD may shift left again.
  • Falling prices raise the real burden of debts: households and firms may cut spending further.
  • Result: the economy can sit on the flat part of Keynesian AS, below full-employment output, for years.
  • A negative output gap with spare capacity that persists.
  • Keynes (1923): "In the long run we are all dead."
Quick check
?In the Keynesian view, why might a negative (recessionary) output gap last for years without government action?
Mission 4

Real world: the Great Depression

  • US, 1929–33: real GDP fell by about a quarter; consumer prices fell by about a quarter.
  • Unemployment reached about 25% in 1933.
  • Wages and prices did fall, but output stayed far below capacity for years.
  • Keynes (The General Theory, 1936): an economy can be stuck with too little demand; government spending can lift it.
  • Friedman and Schwartz (1963): the US money supply fell by about a third from 1929 to 1933. The central bank let it happen: a policy mistake, not proof that markets cannot adjust.
  • Both views agree the slump was deep and long. They disagree on why, and so on the cure.
Mission 4

What each view implies for policy

Fiscal policy in two modelsKeynesian: deep slumpPrice level0P1Y1Y2YfeReal national output (Y)AD1AD2Government spending rises: output up, pricelevel about the same.Classical: full employmentPrice level0P3P2P1YfeY2Real national output (Y)AD1SRAS1LRASAD2SRAS2Government spending rises: output rises for awhile; wages rise, SRAS shifts left, outputreturns to Yfe at a higher price level.
  • Keynesian: in a deep slump, use expansionary fiscal policy (more government spending, lower taxes).
    • AD shifts right on the flat part of AS: real output and jobs rise, with little rise in the price level.
  • Classical: expansionary policy at full employment raises output only for a while.
  • Contractionary fiscal policy (less spending, higher taxes) closes an inflationary gap in both models: AD shifts left.
  • Today most economists accept parts of both. The real argument: how slowly does the economy adjust, and how well can policy be timed?
Mission 4Graph lab

Same push, two models

Illustrative data. Government spending rises: AD shifts right by the same amount in two economies. Economy K: deep recession, on the flat part of Keynesian AS. Economy C: already at full employment, in the vertical-LRAS model.

Same push, two modelsPrice levelReal national output (Y)2,0002,2001101201301,700100Keynesian ASAD
  • Takeaway: where the economy starts, and how flexible wages are, decide whether more AD buys output or only higher prices.
Mission 4Evaluate

How long is the long run?

It depends on:

  • Wage and price flexibility. Contracts, unions, minimum wages and labour-market rules decide how fast SRAS shifts back towards LRAS.
  • Expectations. If people expect low, stable inflation, wages may adjust faster; if confidence collapses, spending may keep falling.
  • Size of the gap. A small gap may close in a few quarters; a deep slump with falling prices and heavy debts can take years.
  • Policy timing. Policy acts with lags; badly timed stimulus can add to inflation once recovery has begun.
Mission check

?An economy is in a recessionary gap after a fall in AD. Wages and prices are flexible, but take three years to adjust fully. Path 1: no policy. Path 2: an expansionary policy shifts AD back to the right straight away. How do the two paths compare?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Net investment = gross investment − depreciation.
  • I depends on interest rates, expectations, demand growth, technology, taxes and credit.
  • Accelerator: net investment depends on the change in output.

Mission 2

  • An injection raises national income by more than itself, through rounds of spending.
  • k = 1 ÷ (1 − MPC).

Mission 3

  • SRAS slopes upwards because money wages and some other costs are sticky in the short run.
  • A change in the price level → a movement along SRAS. A change in costs (wages, raw materials, energy, exchange rate, taxes, subsidies, productivity) → a shift.

Mission 4

  • Without policy, flexible wages shift SRAS until the economy is back on LRAS: output at full employment, unemployment at its natural rate.
  • Keynesians argue wages are sticky downwards and falling incomes cut spending, so a negative gap can persist; the vertical-LRAS view expects fairly quick self-correction.
  • Policy follows: Keynesians favour fiscal stimulus in a slump; the vertical-LRAS view favours supply-side policy and stable inflation.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through How the macroeconomy works: AD/AS (part 2) for AQA A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why does business spending on new machines and buildings swing so much more than household spending?
  2. Mission 2If a government spends 1 billion, why can the country's income end up growing by much more?
  3. Mission 3Why can a jump in oil prices make a whole economy produce less and charge more at once?
  4. Mission 4If a slump ends by itself, why do some economists say we should not wait?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · AQA