← IB Biology Β· HL Β· IB Biology revision
⭐ 0
IB Diploma Biology HL Β· C1 Interaction and interdependence: molecules (part 3)
Mini-Lesson

C1 Interaction and interdependence: molecules (part 3)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1One spot of a mixture goes in; a ladder of spots comes out. How do you work out what each spot is?
  2. Mission 2The carbon atoms in your body were once in the air. How do they keep being recycled?
  3. Mission 3Every year the air's carbon dioxide rises and falls, yet it keeps on climbing. What drives both patterns?
  4. Mission 4Why can a warming of just a degree or two force species to move, or vanish from a place?
  5. Mission 5Switch off the light and a leaf stops making sugar within seconds, yet that stage needs no light. Why?
  6. Mission 6Brighter lamps stop making a greenhouse crop grow any faster. What should the grower change instead?
Mission 1

Mission 1: One spot of a mixture goes in; a ladder of spots comes out. How do you work out what each spot is?

Make a guess: One spot of a mixture goes in; a ladder of spots comes out. How do you work out what each spot is?

Mission 1

How chromatography separates

Separation by chromatographysolventfrontsolventfrontpenciloriginstationaryphase(paper)mobilephase(solvent)lid on
  • (1) Stationary phase: the paper, or a thin layer of silica gel on a plate (TLC). It stays put.
  • (2) Mobile phase: the solvent. It creeps up the stationary phase by capillary action, carrying the mixture.
  • (3) Each molecule spends time dissolved in the solvent and time attached to the stationary phase.
  • More soluble in the solvent, less attracted to the stationary phase: it travels further.
  • So molecules in a mixture separate into spots.
  • TLC runs faster and gives sharper spots than paper.
  • Say: "distance depends on solubility and attraction" β€” not: "on how much of it there is".
Mission 1

Running a chromatogram

Running a chromatogram1.5 cmsolventfrontpencilorigin,small spotsolvent below originlid oncolourlessspotslocatingagent
  • Draw an origin line in pencil (ink would itself separate), about 1.5 cm from the bottom.
  • Put a small, concentrated spot of the sample on the origin. Dry it; add more; dry again.
  • Stand the paper in solvent with the origin above the solvent level, so the sample does not wash off into it.
  • Cover the container, so the air inside stays saturated with solvent vapour.
  • Take it out before the solvent reaches the top. Mark the solvent front in pencil at once.
  • Coloured spots show themselves. Colourless ones need a locating agent.
Mission 1

Worked example: Rf values

Rf measurement0102030405060708090mmoriginspot centresolvent front36 mm60 mmRf = 36 Γ· 60 = 0.60Illustrative data
  • Rf = distance moved by the solute Γ· distance moved by the solvent front.
  • Measure both from the origin; measure to the centre of the spot.
  • Illustrative data: origin 20 mm from the paper's bottom edge; spot centre 56 mm; solvent front 80 mm.
  • Solute: 56 βˆ’ 20 = 36 mm. Solvent: 80 βˆ’ 20 = 60 mm.
  • Rf = 36 Γ· 60 = 0.60. Always between 0 and 1; no units.
  • Same solute, solvent and stationary phase: same Rf. Compare with reference values, or run standards beside the sample.
Quick check
?On a paper chromatogram of leaf pigments, the origin line was 20 mm from the bottom edge of the paper, the centre of the carotene spot was 65 mm from the bottom edge and the solvent front was 70 mm from the bottom edge. What is the Rf value of carotene?
Mission 1

Leaf pigments

Leaf pigmentsRfcarotene0.95xanthophyll0.71chlorophyll a0.65chlorophyll b0.45originsolvent frontRf values: illustrativevalues for one solventthey change with the solvent
  • Grind a leaf with a little sand and propanone to extract its pigments. Spot on the origin.
  • A green leaf gives several spots, not one. Typical order, top to bottom:
  • carotene (orange) Β· xanthophyll (yellow) Β· chlorophyll a (blue-green) Β· chlorophyll b (yellow-green).
  • Each pigment absorbs different wavelengths of light.
  • Identify each by colour and Rf, against reference values for the same solvent.
Quick checkRead the data
?(Illustrative data.) In the solvent used, reference Rf values for leaf pigments are: carotene 0.95 (orange), xanthophyll 0.71 (yellow), chlorophyll a 0.65 (blue-green) and chlorophyll b 0.45 (yellow-green). A student's chromatogram shows three spots: orange at Rf 0.94, blue-green at Rf 0.66 and yellow-green at Rf 0.44. Which conclusion is best supported?
Mission check

?Sugars in a fruit juice are separated by thin-layer chromatography, with glucose, fructose and sucrose standards run on the same plate. The juice gives two spots, level with the glucose and fructose standards; nothing is level with sucrose. On a second plate, with a different solvent, every spot (juice and standards) has a different Rf from the first plate. Which conclusion is correct?
Mission 2

Mission 2: The carbon atoms in your body were once in the air. How do they keep being recycled?

Make a guess: The carbon atoms in your body were once in the air. How do they keep being recycled?

Mission 2

Where carbon is stored

Carbon cycleatmosphere (CO2)oceansproducersconsumersdead organicmatterdecomposerslimestonefossil fuelsand peatphotosynthesisrespirationfeedingdeath and faecesdecompositiondissolvingshells β†’ limestoneincomplete decaycombustion
  • Carbon sits in stores (reservoirs):
  • the atmosphere, as CO2;
  • the oceans, as dissolved CO2 and hydrogencarbonate ions;
  • living organisms, as carbon compounds;
  • dead organic matter and soil;
  • fossil fuels, peat and rocks such as limestone.
  • Carbon atoms move between stores. None is made or destroyed.
Mission 2

The processes that move it

Carbon cycleatmosphere (CO2)oceansproducersconsumersdead organicmatterdecomposerslimestonefossil fuelsand peatphotosynthesisrespirationfeedingdeath and faecesdecompositiondissolvingshells β†’ limestoneincomplete decaycombustion
  • Photosynthesis removes CO2 from air or water and fixes it in producers.
  • Feeding passes carbon compounds along food chains.
  • Respiration in every organism, producers included, returns CO2.
  • Decomposition: decomposers respire the carbon in dead matter and faeces, returning CO2.
  • Combustion of fuels and biomass releases CO2.
  • Photosynthesis supplies the O2 for aerobic respiration; respiration supplies the CO2 for photosynthesis. These yearly fluxes are huge.
  • Say: "plants respire all the time" β€” not: "plants photosynthesise instead of respiring".
Quick check
?A student draws a carbon cycle diagram for a pond. Which set of labelled arrows is correct?
Mission 2

Decomposers unlock the dead

  • Dead organisms and faeces lock carbon and other elements inside large organic molecules.
  • Decomposers (saprotrophic fungi and bacteria) secrete enzymes, digest the matter outside their cells, absorb the products and respire them: CO2 is released.
  • They also release mineral ions, such as ammonium and phosphate, that plants can absorb.
  • So all the elements living things need are recycled, not just carbon.
  • No decomposers, no recycling: carbon builds up in dead matter.
  • Example: waterlogged soil lacks O2, so decay is very slow and peat forms.
  • Say: "decomposers return carbon to the air as CO2" β€” not: "decomposition puts the carbon into the soil".
Quick check
?In an experiment, all the decomposers in a woodland soil are killed, but the trees keep growing for a while. Which change would follow over the next few years?
Mission 2

Sink or source?

  • Compare carbon taken in by photosynthesis with carbon released by all respiration (and fire).
  • Photosynthesis > respiration: net uptake. The ecosystem is a carbon sink.
  • Respiration > photosynthesis: net release. It is a carbon source.
  • Example (illustrative): a grassland fixes 900 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹. Plants respire 450; animals, fungi and bacteria respire 380.
  • Net = 900 βˆ’ (450 + 380) = +70 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹: a sink.
  • Lots of plants does not guarantee a sink: count all respiration.
Quick check
?Suppose measurements in a forest over one year give: carbon fixed by photosynthesis 1200 g m⁻²; carbon released by plant respiration 600 g m⁻²; carbon released by the respiration of animals, fungi and bacteria 650 g m⁻². Is the forest a carbon sink or a carbon source in that year?
Mission 2

Slow stores: oceans, rocks and fuels

Slow stores timelineyearsthousandsof yearsmillionsof yearsage of the carbon store (log scale)biomasspeatcoal, oil,and gascombustion: back to the air very quickly
  • CO2 dissolves in the oceans. Marine organisms build calcium carbonate shells; their remains form limestone.
  • Where decomposition was incomplete (waterlogged, little O2), plant remains became peat and, over millions of years, coal.
  • Oil and natural gas formed from marine plankton buried in sediments with little O2.
  • Combustion returns that stored carbon to the air as CO2 very quickly.
  • Fuels differ in age: biomass (years), peat (thousands of years), coal, oil and gas (millions of years). All their carbon was once fixed by photosynthesis.
  • Fires after lightning are natural, but human activity has greatly increased combustion.
  • Say: "fossil-fuel carbon was fixed by photosynthesis" β€” not: "fossil fuels are just minerals".
Quick check
?Which statement about the combustion of biomass, peat, coal, oil and natural gas is correct?
Mission check

?A peat bog has stored carbon for thousands of years in waterlogged soil. It is drained for farmland, and the peat dries out. What happens to much of the carbon in the peat?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Every year the air's carbon dioxide rises and falls, yet it keeps on climbing. What drives both patterns?

Make a guess: Every year the air's carbon dioxide rises and falls, yet it keeps on climbing. What drives both patterns?

Mission 3Read the data

The Keeling curve

Keeling curve3103303503703904104301960198020002020COβ‚‚ / ppmYear (annual means)316.9338.8369.7414.22019, month by month404406408410412414416JFMAMJJASONDMay 414.9Oct 408.7COβ‚‚ / ppmMonth, 2019

Carbon dioxide in the air at Mauna Loa Observatory, Hawaii (annual means, NOAA):

Year1960198020002020
CO2 / ppm316.9338.8369.7414.2
  • Every year it peaks in May and is lowest in September–October. In 2019: 414.9 ppm in May, 408.7 ppm in October. A swing of about 6 ppm.
  • 1960 to 2020: up 97 ppm, about 1.6 ppm per year on average.
  • The rise is speeding up: about 1.1 ppm per year in 1960–1980; about 2.2 ppm per year in 2000–2020.
Mission 3

Two patterns, two causes

  • The yearly swing: most land, and most plants, are in the Northern Hemisphere.
  • Northern summer: photosynthesis > respiration, so CO2 falls.
  • Northern autumn and winter: respiration and decomposition > photosynthesis, so CO2 rises.
  • The long-term rise: combustion of fossil fuels, and burning and clearing of forests, add CO2 faster than photosynthesis and the oceans remove it.
  • Carbon locked away for millions of years is returned to the air in decades.
  • Say: "the rise comes from combustion" β€” not: "from more people breathing out".
Quick check
?At Mauna Loa, atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration rises to a peak each May and falls to a minimum each September or October, a swing of several parts per million. What causes this annual fluctuation?
Mission 3

The greenhouse effect

Greenhouse effectatmosphereCO2, methaneEarth's surfacesunlightinfraredre-emittedback downmore gas → more infrared retained→ warmer surface
  • Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the Earth's surface.
  • The warm surface gives off infrared radiation.
  • Greenhouse gases absorb infrared and re-emit it, partly back towards the surface. This keeps Earth warm enough for life.
  • More greenhouse gas β†’ more infrared retained β†’ the enhanced greenhouse effect β†’ global warming.
  • CO2 rises from combustion of fossil fuels and from deforestation.
  • Methane rises from ruminant livestock, rice paddies, landfill and leaks from gas and coal extraction.
  • Say: "greenhouse gases absorb infrared" β€” not: "the ozone hole lets in more heat".
Mission 3

Reading past climates

Past-climate evidenceCOβ‚‚ / ppmTemp. anomaly / Β°C8006004002000Years before presentpositive correlationschematic
  • Ice cores: bubbles of air trapped in Antarctic ice record past CO2; the ice itself records past temperature.
  • Over 800 000 years, high CO2 goes with high temperature: a positive correlation.
  • Positive: both rise and fall together. Negative: one rises as the other falls.
  • Correlation alone does not prove cause. Other evidence, such as CO2 absorbing infrared in the lab, supplies the causal link.
Quick check
?Antarctic ice cores show that, over the last 800 000 years, periods of high global temperature coincided with high atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations and periods of low temperature with low concentrations. Which statement about this evidence is correct?
Mission 3

Feedbacks and tipping points

Feedback loopspositive feedback loopswarmingless iceand snowmore solar radiationabsorbed+warmingpermafrost thaws,peat driesCO2 and methanereleased+warmingwarmer oceans holdless CO2more CO2in the air+boreal forest (taiga)sinksourcedroughtbrowningfireswarmer, less snow β†’ drought β†’less production, more fires
  • Positive feedback: warming causes changes that cause more warming.
  • Warmer oceans hold less dissolved CO2; changes in circulation can also release CO2 stored in deep water.
  • Melting snow and ice expose darker sea and land, which absorb more solar radiation.
  • Thawing permafrost and drying peat: old organic matter decomposes, releasing CO2, and methane from waterlogged ground.
  • More droughts and forest fires release more CO2.
  • Tipping point, e.g. the boreal forest (taiga): warmer temperatures and less winter snow β†’ drought β†’ lower primary production, browning, more and fiercer fires that burn legacy carbon in the soil. The forest flips from carbon sink to source.
  • Say: "positive feedback amplifies a change" β€” not: "it restores the original state".
Quick check
?Which sequence of events explains how boreal forests in a warming climate change from net carbon accumulation to net carbon loss?
Mission 3

Will plants absorb the extra CO2?

  • Where CO2 limits photosynthesis, more CO2 could mean more growth.
  • Test predictions with CO2 enrichment experiments.
  • Enclosed greenhouses: CO2 raised; temperature, light and water held constant. Easy to control, but unlike the field.
  • FACE (free-air CO2 enrichment): pipes release CO2 over plots of open field or forest; control plots at today's CO2. Realistic, harder to control.
  • In the field the gain is usually smaller: water and nutrients also limit growth.
  • Lab or field? A trade-off between control of variables and realism.
Mission 3

Drawing carbon back down

  • Use the carbon cycle: increase photosynthesis, slow decomposition, cut combustion.
  • Reforestation and afforestation: growing trees fix CO2 and store it in wood and soil.
  • Forest regeneration: let native forest regrow on its own.
  • Restore peat-forming wetlands: re-wetting cuts O2, slows decomposers, and peat builds up again.
  • Scientists actively debate whether fast-growing non-native plantations or native woodland store more carbon in the long term.
Quick check
?A team wants to predict how a forest will grow at the carbon dioxide concentration expected in 2070. Which plan gives the more realistic prediction, and what does it give up?
Mission check

?At a monitoring station in Tasmania, in the Southern Hemisphere, carbon dioxide shows a much smaller yearly swing than at Mauna Loa, but a similar long-term rise. Which explanation fits both observations?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why can a warming of just a degree or two force species to move, or vanish from a place?

Make a guess: Why can a warming of just a degree or two force species to move, or vanish from a place?

Mission 4

Species on the move

Range shiftsaltitudemountainΓ—local extinctionpoleequatorshifts upslopeshifts poleward
  • Each species survives only within a band of conditions: temperature, rainfall, season length.
  • As the climate warms, that band shifts towards the poles and up mountains.
  • New populations establish at the cool edge; old ones die out at the warm edge. The range shifts.
  • This happens over generations, through dispersal and the survival of young, not by individuals migrating.
  • No cooler place to go (mountain tops, poles), or barriers in the way? Local extinction, or extinction of the species.
  • Evidence: montane birds in New Guinea moved upslope; North American trees spread north while their southern edges contract.
  • Say: "the range shifts" β€” not: "the range grows" or "the animals move house".
Quick check
?The bird species of a mountain in New Guinea were surveyed in 1965 and again in 2012. For most species both the upper and the lower limits of the altitudinal range had moved upslope, by about 100 m on average, over a period in which the region warmed. What is the best interpretation?
Mission 4

Polar ice habitats

Polar habitatsAntarctica: emperor penguinslandfast iceice breaks up earlyArctic: walrusesice over shallow shelfice over deep water
  • Sea ice floats on the ocean. Landfast ice is sea ice attached to the coast.
  • Emperor penguins (Antarctic) breed on landfast ice through the winter. If it breaks up early, before chicks grow waterproof feathers, chicks drown or die of cold.
  • Walruses (Arctic) rest on sea ice between dives for molluscs on the shallow seabed. Summer ice now retreats over deep water: they crowd onto beaches and swim much further to feed.
  • The threat is loss of habitat, not the heat itself.
  • Emperor penguins live only in the Antarctic; walruses only in the Arctic.
Mission 4

Warmer seas: upwelling fails

UpwellingNormallightcold,nutrient-richWarm surface layerlightwarm, less densecold,nutrient-rich
  • Phytoplankton need mineral nutrients that rise (upwell) from cold, deep water.
  • Warm surface water is less dense: it forms a stable layer that blocks upwelling.
  • Less phytoplankton β†’ less energy for zooplankton, fish and seabirds.
  • Off Peru, years with unusually warm surface water bring anchovy catches crashing down.
  • Shifts in ocean currents change both the timing and the extent of upwelling.
Quick check
?Off the coast of Peru, cold nutrient-rich water normally rises to the surface. In some years the surface water is unusually warm, and the catch of anchovies falls sharply. Which explanation is correct?
Mission 4

Coral reefs at risk

Coral threatscoral polypzooxanthellaeheatmore CO2algaeexpelledfewercarbonate ionsbleachinglesscalcificationpale, still alivethinner skeletonpH about 8.1 (still alkaline)
  • Reef-building corals hold mutualistic algae (zooxanthellae) that photosynthesise and feed them.
  • Higher water temperature β†’ corals expel their algae β†’ bleaching. Prolonged heat β†’ corals die.
  • More dissolved CO2 β†’ lower pH and fewer carbonate ions (ocean acidification) β†’ slower building of calcium carbonate skeletons (calcification suppressed).
  • Seawater stays alkaline, about pH 8.1; it is less alkaline, not acidic.
  • Corals are the reef's framework: lose them and the whole reef ecosystem can collapse.
  • Say: "heat causes bleaching; CO2 suppresses calcification" β€” not: "acid bleaches corals".
Quick check
?During a marine heatwave, the corals on a reef turned white. When the water cooled four weeks later, most of the corals regained their colour. Which explanation is correct?
Mission 4

Phenology: falling out of step

Mismatchgreat tit and caterpillarscaterpillar peakchicks hatchbefore warmingMarchJuneafter warmingMarchJunereindeer and chickweedchickweed growth peakreindeer calvebefore warmingMarchJuneafter warmingMarchJunegap: the peak is missed
  • Phenology: research into the timing of biological events: budburst, flowering, bud set, migration, nesting.
  • Two common cues: photoperiod (day length: the same on a given date every year) and temperature (varies from year to year).
  • Warming brings temperature-cued events earlier; photoperiod-cued events stay put.
  • Arctic: mouse-ear chickweed grows when it warms; reindeer migrate to calve by day length. Earlier springs: calves miss the peak of nutritious growth.
  • North European forests: the caterpillar peak has moved earlier; great tit laying has not. Chicks hatch after the food peak.
  • Lost synchrony lowers survival and breeding success.
Quick check
?In a north European oak forest, the date of peak caterpillar biomass advanced by about nine days over 23 years as springs warmed. Over the same period the mean date on which great tits (Parus major) laid their eggs did not change significantly. Which conclusion is supported?
Illustrative data.
Mission 4

More generations, and evolution

  • Insects are ectotherms: warmth speeds their development.
  • Spruce bark beetle: one generation a year in cool summers; two or three in warm ones. Numbers build up fast, and large areas of spruce die.
  • Climate change also changes selection pressures.
  • Tawny owls in Finland come in grey and brown forms; colour is inherited. Brown owls survive snowy winters less well.
  • As winters became milder with less snow, selection against brown weakened, and the brown form became much more common.
  • A change in allele frequency in a population: evolution, seen within decades.
  • Say: "selection changed allele frequencies" β€” not: "the owls changed colour to fit in".
Mission check

?A hypothetical small mammal lives only in cool meadows near the top of an isolated mountain. Over 40 years the region warms by 1.5 Β°C. Which outcome is most likely?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Switch off the light and a leaf stops making sugar within seconds, yet that stage needs no light. Why?

Make a guess: Switch off the light and a leaf stops making sugar within seconds, yet that stage needs no light. Why?

Mission 5

The light-independent stage

Two stageslight-dependentstagelightCalvincycleATPreduced NADPADP + Pα΅’NADPCO2 insugar
  • Happens in the stroma.
  • Uses ATP and reduced NADP from the light-dependent stage.
  • Builds CO2 into sugar in a cycle: the Calvin cycle.
  • Three steps: fixation, reduction, regeneration.
  • It needs no light directly, but stops soon after the light does.
  • Say: "light-independent reactions" β€” not: "dark reactions that happen at night".
Quick check
?A student is drawing a model of how the two stages of photosynthesis in a chloroplast are connected. Which set of arrows between the light-dependent stage and the Calvin cycle should the model show?
Mission 5

Fixation: rubisco captures CO2

Calvin cycle3 RuBP5C each15 C3 Γ— 6Cunstable18 C6 GP3C each18 Crubisco3 CO26 TP3C each18 C6 ATP6 reduced NADP1 TP out (3 C)5 TP (15 C)3 ATP
  • CO2 combines with ribulose bisphosphate (RuBP, 5C).
  • Enzyme: rubisco.
  • The 6C product is unstable: it splits at once into two glycerate 3-phosphate (GP, 3C).
  • No ATP is used in this step.
  • Rubisco is the most abundant enzyme on Earth. It works slowly and poorly at low CO2, so the stroma needs a lot of it.
Mission 5

Reduction: GP to triose phosphate

Calvin cycle3 RuBP5C each15 C3 Γ— 6Cunstable18 C6 GP3C each18 Crubisco3 CO26 TP3C each18 C6 ATP6 reduced NADP1 TP out (3 C)5 TP (15 C)3 ATP
  • Each GP is converted to triose phosphate (TP, 3C).
  • ATP supplies energy (and phosphate).
  • Reduced NADP supplies hydrogen: it reduces GP.
  • ADP, Pα΅’ and NADP go back to the thylakoids.
  • Say: "reduced NADP reduces GP" β€” not: "rubisco reduces CO2".
Quick check
?What is required to convert glycerate 3-phosphate into triose phosphate in the Calvin cycle?
Mission 5

Regeneration: keeping the cycle turning

Calvin cycle3 RuBP5C each15 C3 Γ— 6Cunstable18 C6 GP3C each18 Crubisco3 CO26 TP3C each18 C6 ATP6 reduced NADP1 TP out (3 C)5 TP (15 C)3 ATP
  • Most TP is used to regenerate RuBP, using ATP (no reduced NADP).
  • 5 TP (15 C) β†’ 3 RuBP (15 C).
  • Worked count for one glucose (6 C):

1. Fix 6 CO2 β†’ 12 GP β†’ 12 TP (36 C).

2. 10 TP (30 C) β†’ 6 RuBP (30 C): the cycle is ready again.

3. 2 TP (6 C) leave β†’ one glucose.

  • So five-sixths of TP is recycled; one-sixth is the product.
  • Cost per glucose: 18 ATP (12 for reduction, 6 for regeneration) and 12 reduced NADP.
Quick check
?In a Calvin cycle that produces one molecule of glucose, how many molecules of triose phosphate are made in total, and how many of them are used to regenerate RuBP?
Mission 5

What TP becomes

What TP becomeslight-dependentstagelightCalvincycleATPreduced NADPADP + Pα΅’NADPCO2 intriose phosphate (TP)carbohydratesglucosesucrosestarchcelluloselipidsglycerol + fatty acidsamino acids+ nitrate
  • Carbohydrates: glucose β†’ sucrose (transport), starch (store), cellulose (cell walls).
  • Lipids: glycerol and fatty acids.
  • Amino acids: carbon skeletons from the cycle, plus nitrogen from nitrate or ammonium ions taken up by roots.
  • Every carbon atom in the plant was fixed in the Calvin cycle.
Mission 5

Read the data: lights off

Lights-off graphconcentration / relative unitslightdark05101520-300306090120time after light off / sGPRuBPCO2 lowered at time 0timeRuBP risesGP fallsIllustrative data; pattern first reportedby Calvin's group.

Illustrative data: algae in steady light; light switched off at time 0.

Time after light off / s03060120
GP (relative units)10161920
RuBP (relative units)10421
  • Dark: no ATP or reduced NADP. GP cannot be reduced: GP rises.
  • Rubisco still fixes CO2 until RuBP runs out. No TP, so RuBP is not regenerated: RuBP falls.
  • TP also falls: none is being made.
  • Lower CO2 instead (light on): RuBP is not used, so RuBP rises; little GP is made, so GP falls.
  • Lack of CO2 also stops the light-dependent stage: NADP is not regenerated, electrons back up, and PSII stops.
Quick check
?Algae photosynthesising steadily in light with a plentiful supply of carbon dioxide are suddenly placed in darkness. Within a minute the concentration of glycerate 3-phosphate in the cells rises sharply. Which explanation is correct?
Mission check

?Algae are photosynthesising steadily in bright light. The carbon dioxide supply is suddenly cut to a very low level; the light stays on. What happens to RuBP and GP in the next minute?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Brighter lamps stop making a greenhouse crop grow any faster. What should the grower change instead?

Make a guess: Brighter lamps stop making a greenhouse crop grow any faster. What should the grower change instead?

Mission 6

The limiting factor

Limiting-factor curvesrate of photosynthesis / arbitrary unitslight intensity / arbitrary unitslow CO2, 15 Β°Canother factor limitinglight limitinghigh CO2, 15 Β°Chigh CO2, 25 Β°C
  • Rate of photosynthesis depends on several factors at once: light intensity, CO2 concentration, temperature.
  • The one in shortest supply sets the rate: the limiting factor.
  • Raise the limiting factor β†’ rate rises.
  • Raise any other factor β†’ no change.
  • Light: powers the light-dependent stage. CO2: substrate for rubisco. Temperature: speed of enzyme-catalysed steps.
Mission 6

Reading the curves

Limiting-factor curvesrate of photosynthesis / arbitrary unitslight intensity / arbitrary unitslow CO2, 15 Β°Canother factor limitinglight limitinghigh CO2, 15 Β°Chigh CO2, 25 Β°C

1. Rate rises as light rises: light is limiting.

2. The curve flattens: light is no longer limiting. Another factor is.

3. A curve at higher CO2 reaches a higher plateau: CO2 was limiting the first plateau.

  • On the rising part, curves at different CO2 overlap: there, only light matters.
  • Say: "the plateau shows another factor is limiting" β€” not: "the plant has reached its maximum rate".
Quick check
?Pondweed submerged in water at 25 Β°C with the carbon dioxide concentration of ordinary air was exposed to increasing light intensity. The rate of photosynthesis rose at first and then levelled off, staying constant however much the light intensity was increased. Which change is most likely to raise the rate at this plateau?
Mission 6

Temperature and water

Limiting-factor curvesrate of photosynthesis / arbitrary unitslight intensity / arbitrary unitslow CO2, 15 Β°Canother factor limitinglight limitinghigh CO2, 15 Β°Chigh CO2, 25 Β°Ctemperature and ratetemperatureoptimumenzymes denature,rate falls steeply
  • Light-independent reactions are enzyme-catalysed: warmer β†’ faster, up to an optimum.
  • Above the optimum: enzymes such as rubisco denature; rate falls.
  • Low temperature can limit the rate even in bright light and high CO2.
  • Say: "water stress limits photosynthesis by closing stomata" β€” not: "water is short as a reactant".
Mission 6

Practical: measuring the rate

Rate apparatusLED lampcapillary tube and scalesyringegas collectsinvertedfunnelpondweed,cut end uphydrogencarbonatesolutionthermometerwater bathdistance dmetre rulealgal beads inhydrogencarbonateindicator
  • Skill: vary CO2, light intensity or temperature; suggest and test a hypothesis.
  • Pondweed (e.g. Elodea or Cabomba) in sodium hydrogencarbonate solution (CO2 source).
  • Measure O2: volume collected in a photosynthometer capillary per minute (better than counting bubbles).
  • Vary light: lamp distance; intensity falls about as 1 Γ· dΒ². Use an LED or a water heat shield.
  • Vary CO2: hydrogencarbonate concentration. Vary temperature: water bath.
  • Let the plant acclimatise at each setting; repeat; keep other factors constant.
  • Alternatives: algal beads in hydrogencarbonate indicator; floating leaf discs.
Quick check
?A student places a lamp at different distances from a beaker of pondweed in sodium hydrogencarbonate solution kept at 25 Β°C, and counts the bubbles of gas released per minute at each distance. Which correctly identifies the variables?
Mission 6

Read the data: extra CO2, greenhouse vs field

FACE vs chamberchamberCO2CO2FACE(open field)(enclosed)increase in yield / %0510152025303531%chamber373 β†’ 565ppm14%FACE367 β†’ 583ppmPooled C3 crop data,Ainsworth et al. (2008)
  • Enclosed experiments: greenhouses and chambers.
  • FACE (free-air CO2 enrichment): pipes release CO2 over open-field plots; control plots stay at ambient CO2.
Pooled C3 crop studiesAmbient CO2 / ppmRaised CO2 / ppmYield increase
Chambers (enclosed)37356531%
FACE (open field)36758314%
  • Similar CO2 rise; field gain only about half the chamber gain.
  • In fields, other factors (water, nitrogen, temperature, pests) also limit growth.
  • Controls are harder in the field, but FACE gives the more realistic prediction.
Quick check
?In enclosed chamber trials, C3 crops grown at about 565 ppm carbon dioxide gave on average 31% more yield than crops at about 373 ppm. In FACE experiments in open fields, crops at about 583 ppm gave 14% more yield than crops at about 367 ppm. Which is the best explanation of the difference?
Mission check

?Illustrative data: rate of CO2 uptake by tomato leaves in bright light (arbitrary units). Brighter lamps no longer raise the rate.
CO2 / ppm15 Β°C25 Β°C
4001011
10001321

Which is the grower's best plan?

Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Molecules separate by how they share time between the solvent and the stationary phase.
  • Rf = distance moved by the solute Γ· distance moved by the solvent front, both from the origin; compare with standards or reference values for the same solvent.
  • Leaf extracts give carotene, xanthophyll, chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b.

Mission 2

  • Carbon moves between stores by photosynthesis (removes CO2), feeding, and respiration, decomposition and combustion (all add CO2).
  • Decomposers recycle carbon and every other element; without them, carbon piles up in dead matter such as peat.

Mission 3

  • The yearly swing in CO2 is photosynthesis against respiration in the northern growing season; the long-term rise is combustion of fossil fuels and forests.
  • CO2 and methane absorb infrared; more of them enhances the greenhouse effect.
  • Past climate evidence shows correlation; the causal link comes from other evidence.
  • Positive feedbacks and tipping points can amplify warming; enrichment experiments and sequestration show how ecosystems may respond.

Mission 4

  • Warming shifts the conditions species need poleward and upslope; ranges follow over generations, and species with nowhere to go face local extinction.
  • Warmer surface water blocks nutrient upwelling, cutting primary production in the oceans.
  • Warming can break the synchrony of temperature-cued and photoperiod-cued events, add insect generations and drive evolution.

Mission 5

  • Rubisco fixes CO2 with RuBP β†’ 2 GP; ATP and reduced NADP reduce GP β†’ TP; five-sixths of TP regenerates RuBP (using ATP); one-sixth makes sugars, lipids and amino acids.
  • Light off: GP rises, RuBP falls. CO2 down: RuBP rises, GP falls.

Mission 6

  • The rate is set by the factor in shortest supply (light, CO2 or temperature). A plateau means another factor now limits.
  • Extra CO2 raises yields less in open fields (FACE) than in enclosures, because other factors also limit growth.
πŸ†

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through C1 Interaction and interdependence: molecules (part 3) for IB Biology HL. πŸŽ‰

  1. Mission 1One spot of a mixture goes in; a ladder of spots comes out. How do you work out what each spot is?
  2. Mission 2The carbon atoms in your body were once in the air. How do they keep being recycled?
  3. Mission 3Every year the air's carbon dioxide rises and falls, yet it keeps on climbing. What drives both patterns?
  4. Mission 4Why can a warming of just a degree or two force species to move, or vanish from a place?
  5. Mission 5Switch off the light and a leaf stops making sugar within seconds, yet that stage needs no light. Why?
  6. Mission 6Brighter lamps stop making a greenhouse crop grow any faster. What should the grower change instead?

Your stars: 0 / 0

πŸ“£ Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

β†’ Back to IB Biology Β· HL