← A-Level Biology Β· OCR Β· A-Level Biology revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Biology A (H420) Β· 4.2.2 Classification and evolution (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Classification and evolution (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Cuttings from one plant share every gene. So why don't they all grow to the same height?
  2. Mission 2If no animal can change its own genes, how can a whole population change over time?
  3. Mission 3A desert fox has enormous ears and almost never drinks. How did it end up so well suited to the desert?
  4. Mission 4Nobody designs a drug-resistant germ, so how do whole populations of them appear so quickly?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Cuttings from one plant share every gene. So why don't they all grow to the same height?

Make a guess: Cuttings from one plant share every gene. So why don't they all grow to the same height?

Mission 1

Genes plus surroundings

Genotype and environmentparentshadesundry soilsame genotype, different phenotypes
  • Genotype: the alleles an organism has.
  • Phenotype: its observable traits.
  • Phenotype = genotype interacting with the environment.
  • Same genotype, different surroundings β†’ different phenotypes. That's the cuttings.
Quick check
?Identical twins have the same genotype. Two identical twins were raised apart, one in a sunny country on a good diet and the other in a cloudy country on a poor diet. Which of these traits are expected to be the same in both twins as adults: ABO blood group, adult height and skin colour?
Mission 1

Where variation comes from

Sources of variationvariationgeneticenvironmentalmutationnew allelesmeiosisnew combinationsrandom fertilisationnew combinationsdietanimalslightplantsmineralsplantsetiolationnormalchlorosis
  • Genetic sources: mutation (the primary source of new alleles), then meiosis and random fertilisation (new combinations).
  • Environmental sources: in animals, diet; in plants, light and minerals.
  • Etiolation: grown in the dark, a plant has long, thin, pale stems and small yellow leaves.
  • Chlorosis: yellow leaves from too little chlorophyll (e.g. low light, or a lack of magnesium or iron).
  • So a population varies widely: many allele combinations Γ— many environments.
  • Variation within a species is intraspecific; between species, interspecific.
Quick check
?Seeds of one genetically uniform variety of bean were sown in two trays. Tray X was kept in darkness; tray Y in light. After two weeks, the seedlings in X had long, thin, pale stems and small yellow leaves. The seedlings in Y were short and green. Which statement is correct?
Mission 1

Two kinds of variation

Two graphsdiscontinuousbar chartcontinuoushistogramnumber of peopleABABOABO blood groupnumber of peopleheight / cm
DiscontinuousContinuous
ValuesSeparate categories, no intermediatesAny value in a range
GenesOne or a fewMany (polygenes)
EnvironmentLittle or no effectLarge effect
ExampleABO blood groupHeight, mass, skin colour
GraphBar chartHistogram: often a normal distribution
  • Exam point: discontinuous = one or few genes; continuous = many genes plus environment.
Mission 1

Many genes, one smooth curve

Polygenesproportion of offspringnumber of contributing alleles102112one gene: 1 : 2 : 11041624314two genes: 1 : 4 : 6 : 4 : 10123456three genes: 1 : 6 : 15 : 20 : 15 : 6 : 11615201561+ environment
  • Polygenic inheritance: many genes, at different loci, affect one trait.
  • Worked example: three genes (A/a, B/b, C/c). Each capital allele adds one unit of height.
  • Cross AaBbCc Γ— AaBbCc. Offspring carry 0–6 capital alleles.
  • Step 1: one gene alone β†’ 3 classes, 1 : 2 : 1.
  • Step 2: two genes β†’ 5 classes, 1 : 4 : 6 : 4 : 1.
  • Step 3: three genes β†’ 7 classes, 1 : 6 : 15 : 20 : 15 : 6 : 1 (out of 64).
  • Step 4: add the environment. Each class spreads out; the gaps fill in β†’ a smooth bell curve.
  • More genes β†’ more classes β†’ closer to continuous.
Quick check
?Human skin colour varies continuously across a population, whereas ABO blood group falls into four separate classes. Which explanation of this difference is correct?
Mission check

?Two true-breeding varieties of a crop plant differ in seed mass. Crossing them gives F1 plants with seeds of intermediate mass, all very similar. The F1 are interbred. Grown in the same field as the F1, the F2 show a wide, bell-shaped spread of seed mass, with very few at either parental extreme. Which explanation fits best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If no animal can change its own genes, how can a whole population change over time?

Make a guess: If no animal can change its own genes, how can a whole population change over time?

Mission 2

Where variation comes from

Sources of variationvariationinphenotypemutation→ new allelesmeiosiscrossing over,independent assortment→ new combinationsrandom fertilisation→ new combinationsenvironment
  • Individuals in a population differ in phenotype.
  • Causes: genes, environment, and both together.
  • Mutation is the original source of all new alleles. It is random: it does not happen because an allele is needed.
  • Meiosis and random fertilisation make new combinations of existing alleles. They make no new alleles.
  • Say: "a mutation arose by chance" β€” not: "the organism mutated to survive".
Quick check
?A population of a plant species has two alleles of a flower-colour gene. A third allele, never seen before, appears in one seedling. Which process could have produced it?
Mission 2

More young than the habitat can support

  • Populations overproduce: far more offspring than can survive.
  • Resources are limited: food, water, nest sites, territory, light.
  • So members of the same species compete (intraspecific competition).
  • Selection pressures decide who survives and breeds:
    • biotic: predation, disease, competition;
    • abiotic: e.g. extreme cold, drought.
Mission 2

Natural selection, step by step

Selection in a beetle populationvariationselection pressure: predationmore offspring from dark beetlesinheritancedark allele frequency risesgeneration 1generation 2
  • (1) Variation: individuals differ in a heritable trait.
  • (2) Selection pressure: e.g. a predator that finds pale beetles more easily on dark bark.
  • (3) Differential survival and reproduction: individuals with the advantageous phenotype are more likely to survive and leave more offspring.
  • (4) Inheritance: they pass on the advantageous allele. Over many generations its frequency rises.
  • No individual changed. The proportions in the population changed.
  • Result: an increased proportion of the population with the advantageous characteristic.
Mission 2

Fitness

  • Fitness is about reproductive success: surviving offspring that go on to breed.
  • Not size, strength or speed. Those count only if they lead to more offspring.
  • A phenotype that raises fitness in one environment may lower it in another.
  • Say: "leaves more surviving offspring" β€” not: "is the fittest because strongest".
Quick check
?In a population of red deer, stag X is the largest and strongest male but leaves two offspring that survive to breed. Stag Y is smaller and weaker but leaves six offspring that survive to breed. Which stag has the higher fitness, and why?
Mission 2

Only heritable traits evolve

  • Selection changes a population only if the trait is heritable: coded in the base sequence of DNA and passed on in gametes.
  • Acquired characteristics are not inherited: trained muscles, an injury, a learned skill.
Quick check
?A woman develops large, strong arm muscles through years of rowing training. Will her children inherit larger arm muscles as a result of her training?
Mission 2

Evolution: a change in allele frequency

Gene pool as beadsgeneration 1200 alleleslater generation200 allelesgenerationsDdallele frequency of D0.20 β†’ 0.40
  • Evolution = a change in the allele frequencies of a population over time.
  • Over long periods, adaptation and selection (with isolation) produce new species and the diversity of life.
Mission 2

Worked example: allele frequency

Illustrative data: a gene with alleles D and d, 100 individuals (200 alleles).

GenotypeDDDddd
Generation 143264
Generation 10164836
  • Count alleles, not individuals. Each DD has two D; each Dd has one.
  • Generation 1: D = 2 Γ— 4 + 32 = 40 of 200. Frequency of D = 0.20.
  • Generation 10: D = 2 Γ— 16 + 48 = 80 of 200. Frequency of D = 0.40.
  • The allele frequency changed: the population evolved.
  • Trap: 36% of generation 1 carry D, but D's frequency is 0.20.
Quick check
?A population of 50 plants contains 8 RR, 24 Rr and 18 rr. What is the frequency of allele R?
Mission check

?A student builds a flowchart model of how natural selection increased the mean beak depth of a population of a hypothetical seed-eating bird species over several generations of drought. Which flowchart best represents this process?
Mission 3

Mission 3: A desert fox has enormous ears and almost never drinks. How did it end up so well suited to the desert?

Make a guess: A desert fox has enormous ears and almost never drinks. How did it end up so well suited to the desert?

Mission 3

What is an adaptation?

  • An adaptation is an inherited feature that increases an organism's chance of surviving and reproducing in its environment.
  • It arises by natural selection: random variation exists; individuals with a useful allele survive and breed more; the allele becomes more common over generations.
  • Individuals do not adapt in their lifetime. Populations change over generations.
  • An adaptation helps in one environment; the same trait may be useless or harmful in another.
  • Say: "individuals with the allele survived and bred more" β€” not: "the fox adapted because it needed to".
Mission 3

Three kinds of adaptation

Fennec fox, three waysanatomicalblood vessels near thesurface radiate heatphysiologicalkidneys conserve waterbehaviouralactive at night,shelters in a burrow by day
  • Anatomical: body structure. Fennec fox: huge ears with blood vessels near the surface radiate heat.
  • Physiological: body processes. Fennec fox: kidneys conserve water; it gets most of its water from food.
  • Behavioural: what it does. Fennec fox: active at night; shelters in a burrow by day.
  • Most organisms show all three, each meeting the same challenge.
Quick check
?Which adaptation is classified correctly?
Quick check
?A hypothetical grass species grows both on soil contaminated with zinc around an old mine and in nearby uncontaminated fields. When grown on zinc soil, plants from the mine site survive, but plants from the fields die. When grown on normal soil, plants from the mine site grow more slowly than plants from the fields. Which reasoning best explains why zinc tolerance is common at the mine site but rare in the fields?
Mission 3

Same problem, same solution

Two molesmarsupial moleAustralia123placental moleEurope1231 tube-shaped body2 tiny or no eyes, no external ears3 spade-like forelimbs, large clawsclosest relativesother marsupialsother placentals
  • Convergent evolution: unrelated groups evolve similar features because they face similar selection pressures.
  • The features are analogous: same function, different evolutionary origin.
  • Marsupial mole (Australia) and placental mole (Europe): both burrow; both have a tube-shaped body, tiny or no eyes, no external ears and spade-like forelimbs with large claws. Their closest relatives are other marsupials and other placental mammals.
  • Say: "similar because of similar selection" β€” not: "similar because closely related".
Quick check
?Cacti of the deserts of the Americas and euphorbias of the deserts of southern Africa both have swollen, water-storing stems and spines, yet they belong to different plant families. Which explanation is correct?
Mission check

?Arctic foxes have much smaller ears than fennec foxes. Which statement best explains how small ears became typical of Arctic foxes?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Nobody designs a drug-resistant germ, so how do whole populations of them appear so quickly?

Make a guess: Nobody designs a drug-resistant germ, so how do whole populations of them appear so quickly?

Mission 4

How a resistant population arises

Resistance risesbefore antibioticantibiotic addedsurvivors dividefrequency of resistance allele risesresistant (mutation)susceptible
  • (1) A random mutation gives a few bacteria an allele for resistance, before any antibiotic is used. Bacteria can also gain resistance genes on plasmids from other bacteria.
  • (2) The antibiotic kills susceptible bacteria. Resistant ones survive.
  • (3) Survivors reproduce fast (binary fission) and pass on the resistance allele.
  • (4) Over generations the frequency of the allele rises: the population is now mostly resistant.
  • Nobody chose which bacteria bred, so this is natural selection, not artificial selection.
  • Say: "the antibiotic selected resistant bacteria" β€” not: "the bacteria became resistant".
Mission 4

Read the data: was resistance there first?

Replica plating123456789101112master plateno antibioticvelvet padantibiotic plateantibiotic plate411411grows inantibioticβ–² = orientation mark

Lederberg and Lederberg (1952): replica plating with the bacterium E. coli.

  • (1) Bacteria spread on a master plate with no antibiotic. Each cell grows into a colony.
  • (2) A sterile velvet pad picks up cells from every colony and presses them onto plates with the antibiotic, keeping their positions.
  • (3) A few colonies grew on the antibiotic plates, at the same positions on every replica.
  • Cells taken from those positions on the master plate, never exposed to the drug, already included resistant cells.
  • So resistance arose before exposure. The drug selected it; it did not cause it.
Quick check
?In a replica-plating test, colonies grow on the antibiotic plate only at the positions of colonies 4 and 11 on the master plate, which has no antibiotic. Cells are then taken from colony 4 on the master plate and placed in a broth containing the antibiotic. What result is expected, and why?
Mission 4

Many drugs, many pests

  • Resistance to a drug usually depends on a specific gene or mutation. Strains can accumulate several: multiresistant bacteria, e.g. MRSA.
  • Every use of an antibiotic is a selection pressure. More use, more selection.
  • Same process in insects: repeated spraying selected pesticide-resistant insects, e.g. DDT-resistant mosquitoes.
Quick check
?A hospital ward uses one particular antibiotic heavily. Over several years, an increasing proportion of the bacteria isolated from patients on the ward are found to be resistant to it. Which statement correctly explains this change?
Mission 4

Read the data: owls and snow

Owls and snowgrey owlbrown owlsurvival in snowy winters:grey higher1981 β†’ 2008schematicsnowy wintersproportion ofbrown owlsKarell et al. (2011) Nature Communications

Tawny owls (Strix aluco) in Finland, studied 1981–2008 (Karell and colleagues, 2011).

  • Two colour forms: grey and brown. Colour is strongly inherited (about 80% heritable).
  • In winters with deep snow, brown owls survived less well than grey owls.
  • Over the study, snowy winters became less common as the climate warmed.
  • The proportion of brown owls rose.
  • Reading: less snow β†’ brown owls' fitness rose β†’ alleles for brown plumage rose in frequency. Evolution driven by climate change.
Quick check
?In Finland, tawny owls (Strix aluco) occur as a grey morph and a brown morph, and the colour is inherited. Brown owls survived snowy winters less well than grey owls. Between 1981 and 2008 winters became milder with less snow, and the proportion of brown owls rose markedly. What best explains the change?
Mission check

?A patient is given an antibiotic. Within a few days, the bacteria in the patient's infection change from almost all susceptible to almost all resistant. Which statement best explains how this happened so quickly?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Phenotype = genotype interacting with the environment; genetically identical organisms still differ.
  • Continuous variation comes from many genes with additive effects plus the environment; discontinuous variation from one or a few genes.

Mission 2

  • Random mutation supplies new alleles; selection pressures make individuals with advantageous heritable phenotypes leave more offspring, so those alleles rise in frequency.
  • Evolution is a change in allele frequencies; fitness is reproductive success.

Mission 3

  • An adaptation is an inherited feature, favoured by natural selection, that improves survival and reproduction in a particular environment.
  • Adaptations are anatomical (or morphological), physiological or behavioural.
  • Convergent evolution: similar selection pressures give similar (analogous) features in unrelated groups.

Mission 4

  • Resistance alleles arise by random mutation (or gene transfer) before exposure; the drug or pesticide kills susceptible individuals, so resistant ones reproduce and the allele's frequency rises.
πŸ†

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Classification and evolution (part 2) for OCR A-level Biology. πŸŽ‰

  1. Mission 1Cuttings from one plant share every gene. So why don't they all grow to the same height?
  2. Mission 2If no animal can change its own genes, how can a whole population change over time?
  3. Mission 3A desert fox has enormous ears and almost never drinks. How did it end up so well suited to the desert?
  4. Mission 4Nobody designs a drug-resistant germ, so how do whole populations of them appear so quickly?

Your stars: 0 / 0

πŸ“£ Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

β†’ Back to A-Level Biology Β· OCR