← A-Level Biology · Eduqas · A-Level Biology revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Biology (A400QS) · Appendices A and C: working scientifically and mathematical skills
Mini-Lesson

Working scientifically and maths skills

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Plants given a new fertiliser grew taller, but they also sat nearest the window. Can you trust the result?
  2. Mission 2Two sets of results share the same average but look nothing alike. What number captures the difference?
  3. Mission 3Two bars on a graph have different heights. When does that difference actually mean something?
  4. Mission 4Five readings agree perfectly. How can every one of them still be wrong?
  5. Mission 5Why are almost all cells too small to see, even inside the largest animals?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Plants given a new fertiliser grew taller, but they also sat nearest the window. Can you trust the result?

Make a guess: Plants given a new fertiliser grew taller, but they also sat nearest the window. Can you trust the result?

Mission 1

Three kinds of variable

Variablesdependent: bubbles per minuteindependent: lamp distance / cmcontrolled:temperature 25 °Csame pondweedsame solution: sodium hydrogencarbonatefertilisedunfertilisedfertiliserlighttwo variableschanged
  • Independent variable: the one you change on purpose.
  • Dependent variable: the one you measure. It may depend on the independent variable.
  • Controlled variables: everything else that could affect the result. Keep them constant.
  • Example: lamp distance (independent) → bubbles of gas per minute from pondweed (dependent). Temperature, CO2 supply and the piece of pondweed stay the same.
  • Change one variable at a time. If two change together, you cannot tell which caused the effect.
  • The hook: fertiliser and light changed together. The result is confounded.
Quick check
?A student places a lamp at different distances from a beaker of pondweed in sodium hydrogencarbonate solution kept at 25 °C, and counts the bubbles of gas released per minute at each distance. Which correctly identifies the variables?
Mission 1

Controls

  • A control is a set-up identical to the others except that the factor being tested is absent (or at a standard level).
  • It shows what happens without the factor, so any difference can be put down to that factor.
  • Negative control: no effect expected (e.g. boiled enzyme, or water in place of an extract).
  • Positive control: an effect is known to occur. It shows the method can detect one.
  • A control need not show "nothing". It gives the baseline for comparison.
  • Say: "temperature was a controlled variable" — not: "temperature was the control".
Quick check
?A student tests the claim that an extract from a hypothetical plant contains an enzyme that speeds up the breakdown of compound P. When P breaks down, the solution turns yellow. Tube 1 contains P, buffer and the extract. Tube 2 contains P and buffer, with water in place of the extract. Both tubes are kept at 25 °C, and the time each takes to turn yellow is recorded. Which statement best justifies including tube 2?
Mission 1

Questions and hypotheses

  • A testable question names what you will change and what you will measure: "Does light intensity affect the rate of photosynthesis in pondweed?"
  • A hypothesis is a provisional explanation that can be tested: "Rate rises with light intensity, because light drives the light-dependent reactions."
  • A prediction says what you expect to measure if the hypothesis is right.
  • The null hypothesis says the independent variable has no effect (or there is no difference). Statistical tests check whether the data let you reject it.
  • Data can support a hypothesis. They never prove it.
Quick check
?A student plans to test whether the number of double bonds in a fatty acid affects its melting point, using fatty acids with 0, 1, 2 and 3 double bonds that all have the same chain length. Which statement is an appropriate null hypothesis for this investigation?
Mission 1

Measuring the dependent variable

Two ways to measure rateproduct formed over timeO2gassyringe0102030051015Volume / cm³Time / srate = 15 ÷ 30= 0.50 cm3 s−1time for a fixed changeH2O2startrises25 srate ∝ 1/t = 1/25 = 0.040 s−1
  • Biologists often measure a rate: change ÷ time.
  • Product formed over time: change in amount ÷ time taken.
  • e.g. 15 cm³ of oxygen in 30 s → 15 ÷ 30 = 0.50 cm³ s⁻¹.
  • Time for a fixed change (a disc rises, a colour appears): rate ∝ 1 ÷ time. A disc that rises in 25 s → 1 ÷ 25 = 0.040 s⁻¹.
  • A shorter time means a faster rate.
  • Measure the initial rate where you can: the reaction slows as substrate is used up.
  • Choose apparatus that suits the size of the change: a gas syringe or a colorimeter beats judging by eye.
Quick check
?A filter-paper disc soaked in catalase solution sinks in hydrogen peroxide and rises when enough oxygen has formed on it. In 1% hydrogen peroxide the disc took 50 s to rise; in 2% it took 20 s. Which statement about the reaction rate is correct?
Mission 1

Experiment, observation or model?

  • Experiment: you manipulate the independent variable and control the rest. Best evidence for cause and effect.
  • Observation (survey, field sampling): you record what is already there. Shows patterns and correlations, not cause.
  • Example: barnacle A grows only where barnacle B is absent (observation). Scrape B off marked plots and A moves in (field experiment).
  • Even a good experiment only indicates a cause; other differences may remain.
Quick check
?Ecologists want to test the hypothesis that two limpet species compete for algae on a shore. Which approach tests the hypothesis by experiment rather than by observation?
Mission 1

Repeats, samples and validity

  • Living things vary. One measurement may be unusual, so repeat and use the mean.
  • Repeats also expose anomalies: results far from the others.
  • Sample size: more individuals make the mean more likely to be near the true population mean.
  • Sample selection: choose at random, so the sample represents the population and no one picks "good" specimens.
  • Valid: the method answers the question asked. It needs controlled variables and a suitable dependent variable.
  • Results that come out the same when repeated are repeatable; when someone else repeats them with other equipment, reproducible.
  • Repeats cannot rescue an invalid design: the hook's plants could be measured 100 times and still be confounded.
Mission 1

Tables and graphs

Table and graph rulesLight intensity/ arbitrary unitsBubbles per minute123meanRate / cm3 s−1DV → y0102030405000.10.20.30.4Illustrative sketch, not real dataTemperature / °CIV → xbar chartcategoriesscatter graphcorrelation
  • Table: independent variable in the first column; repeats, then mean. Units in the headings, never in the cells. Same number of decimal places down each column.
  • Graph: independent variable on the x-axis, dependent on the y-axis.
  • Label each axis with the quantity and its unit.
  • e.g. "Rate / cm³ s⁻¹".
  • Choose a scale that uses over half the grid, in even steps.
  • Line graph: continuous independent variable. Bar chart: categories.
  • Scatter graph: looking for a correlation between two measured variables.
  • Do not extend a line beyond your data.
Mission check

?A student investigates the effect of pH on the rate of a catalase reaction. She runs all the pH 4 and pH 5 tubes in the morning, when the lab is at 16 °C, and the pH 8 and pH 9 tubes in the afternoon, when it is at 24 °C. Which single change best removes the main flaw in her design?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Two sets of results share the same average but look nothing alike. What number captures the difference?

Make a guess: Two sets of results share the same average but look nothing alike. What number captures the difference?

Mission 2

Three averages and a range

  • Mean = sum of values ÷ number of values.
  • Median = the middle value when the values are in order (for an even number, halfway between the middle two).
  • Mode = the most frequent value.
  • Range = largest − smallest.
  • One extreme value pulls the mean towards it. The median hardly moves.
Quick check
?The heights in centimetres of nine students are: 150, 152, 152, 155, 158, 160, 163, 170 and 175. What is the median height?
Mission 2

Standard deviation: the typical spread

Same mean, different SDShore ASD 1.2Shore BSD 6.5mean = 8mean ± 1 SD ≈ 68%± 2 SD ≈ 95%05101520Limpets per quadrat
  • Standard deviation (SD): how far values typically lie from the mean.
  • Small SD: values cluster tightly. Large SD: values are widely spread.
  • Two samples can share a mean and differ hugely in SD: the hook.
  • For data with a normal (bell-shaped) distribution, about 68% of values lie within ±1 SD of the mean, and about 95% within ±2 SD.
  • SD has the same unit as the data.
  • A large SD is not a "mistake". In biology it often reflects real variation between individuals.
Mission 2

Worked example: calculating SD

Stomata counted in five fields of view on one leaf: 22, 26, 19, 27, 21.

Count, xx − x̄(x − x̄)²
22−11
2639
19−416
27416
21−24
  • Mean, x̄ = 115 ÷ 5 = 23.
  • Σ(x − x̄)² = 46.
  • SD, s = √[Σ(x − x̄)² ÷ (n − 1)] = √(46 ÷ 4) = √11.5 = 3.4.
  • Divide by n − 1 (here 4), not n: this estimates the SD of the whole population from a sample.
Quick check
?Limpets were counted in twenty random quadrats on each of two shores. On both shores the mean was 8 limpets per quadrat. The standard deviation was 1.2 on shore A and 6.5 on shore B. What can be concluded?
Mission 2

SD or range?

  • The range uses only two values: the largest and the smallest.
  • One outlying result sets the range on its own.
  • The SD uses every value, so it describes the spread of the whole data set.
  • So SD is usually the more useful measure of dispersion, especially where there is an outlying result.
  • Still check an outlier: is it an anomaly (a mistake) or real variation?
  • Say: "SD shows the spread of the data about the mean" — not: "SD shows how many errors were made".
Quick check
?Two samples of seven leaf lengths, in mm:
Both have a mean of 20 mm and a range of 20 mm. The standard deviation of P is 5.8 mm and of Q is 10.0 mm. Which statement is correct?
  • P: 10, 20, 20, 20, 20, 20, 30
  • Q: 10, 10, 10, 20, 30, 30, 30
Mission check

?The lengths of five seedling roots, in mm, are 14, 16, 15, 18 and 17. Which gives the mean and standard deviation correctly?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Two bars on a graph have different heights. When does that difference actually mean something?

Make a guess: Two bars on a graph have different heights. When does that difference actually mean something?

Mission 3

What an error bar can show

Two kinds of barMeasurementmean±1 SDrangemaxminSame data, different bars:read the legend
  • A bar or point shows a mean. The error bar shows uncertainty or spread.
  • Error bars can show different things. Read the legend first.
  • ±1 SD: the spread of the individual values.
  • Bars from the range (min to max) are sometimes drawn too. They depend on only two values.
Mission 3

Reading SD bars

  • Compare two means, each with ±1 SD bars.
  • Bars overlap widely: many individuals in the two groups are alike. The difference in means may well be due to chance.
  • Bars do not overlap: the difference may be real.
  • SD bars ignore sample size, so they cannot settle it. A statistical test (e.g. a t-test) decides.
  • A small SD means repeats agree closely: a more precise, more repeatable measurement.
Quick check
?Five potato cylinders were bathed in 0.4 mol dm⁻³ sucrose for 24 hours. The mean percentage change in mass was −3.0% with a standard deviation of 1.0%; the mean percentage change in length was −2.0% with a standard deviation of 2.5%. What do these data indicate?
Mission check

?A student grew bean seedlings with fertiliser X or fertiliser Y, 10 plants each. Mean root length ± 1 standard deviation: X, 42 mm (bar from 33 to 51 mm); Y, 47 mm (bar from 39 to 55 mm). Which conclusion is best supported?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Five readings agree perfectly. How can every one of them still be wrong?

Make a guess: Five readings agree perfectly. How can every one of them still be wrong?

Mission 4

Accurate or precise?

Targetscentre = true valueaccurate and preciseprecise, not accurate:systematic errorrepeats don’t fix this:calibrateaccurate on average,not precise:random errorneither
  • Accurate: close to the true value.
  • Precise: repeats agree closely, with little spread about the mean.
  • Random error: unpredictable scatter (judging an end point, natural variation). It lowers precision. Repeats and a mean reduce its effect.
  • Systematic error: shifts every reading the same way (a balance not zeroed, a thermometer reading 2 °C high). It lowers accuracy. Repeats do not remove it; calibrating does.
  • Resolution: the smallest change an instrument can show.
  • Say: "precise but not accurate" — not: "precise, so accurate".
Quick check
?Two students each measured the angle of curvature of the same seedling shoot five times with a protractor. Student A recorded 28°, 29°, 28°, 29°, 28°. Student B recorded 22°, 35°, 30°, 26°, 37°. A later check showed that the true angle was 35° and that Student A had aligned the protractor with the edge of the pot instead of the vertical part of the stem. Which conclusion is justified?
Mission 4

Uncertainty and percentage error

  • Every reading has an uncertainty. On a scale: ± half the smallest division (thermometer marked every 1 °C: ±0.5 °C). Use the value in the question if one is given.
  • Percentage error = uncertainty ÷ measured value × 100.
  • Combined data: a change or difference needs two readings. Add their uncertainties.
  • Worked example: water warms from 20.0 °C to 35.0 °C; each reading ±0.5 °C.
  • Change = 15.0 °C, uncertainty = 0.5 + 0.5 = ±1.0 °C.
  • Percentage error = 1.0 ÷ 15.0 × 100 = 6.7%.
  • A larger measured quantity gives a smaller percentage error: measure bigger changes, or over longer times.
Quick check
?A potato cylinder's mass falls from 3.62 g to 3.40 g in a sucrose solution. The balance reads to ±0.01 g. What is the percentage error in the change in mass?
Mission 4

Anomalies, limitations, improvements

  • Anomaly: a result that does not fit the pattern. Look for a cause; repeat it; leave it out of the mean only with a stated reason.
  • Limitation: a feature of the method that reduces validity, accuracy or precision.
  • Match the improvement to the problem:
    • random scatter → more repeats, then a mean;
    • systematic error → zero or calibrate the instrument;
    • low resolution → an instrument with finer divisions;
    • an uncontrolled variable → control it (water bath, buffer).
Mission 4

Apparatus and units

QuantityTypical apparatusUnit
Massbalanceg
Timestopwatch or data loggers
Volumepipette, burette, syringe, measuring cylindercm³
Temperaturethermometer or temperature probe°C
Lengthruler; eyepiece graticule for cellsmm; µm
pHpH meter or indicatorno unit
  • Pick the apparatus whose resolution suits the size of the change: a pipette for 1.0 cm³, not a 100 cm³ measuring cylinder.
Mission 4

Safety, records and sources

  • Hazard: something that could cause harm (e.g. hydrogen peroxide is an irritant).
  • Risk: how likely harm is, and how bad. A risk assessment lists hazard → risk → control measure (goggles, low concentration).
  • Research from reliable sources: peer-reviewed papers, textbooks, official data.
  • Cite each source: author(s), year, title, where published (journal, publisher or web address and date accessed).
Mission check

?A student uses a water bath to keep enzyme tubes at 30 °C. Her thermometer gives readings that agree closely: 30.0, 30.0, 30.5, 30.0 °C. A calibrated electronic probe in the same water bath reads 28.0 °C. Which improvement would make her temperature measurements more accurate?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why are almost all cells too small to see, even inside the largest animals?

Make a guess: Why are almost all cells too small to see, even inside the largest animals?

Mission 5

Supply and demand

Supply and demanddemand:volumesupply:surface area
  • Materials enter and leave across the surface. Supply depends on surface area.
  • Every part of the cytoplasm uses materials. Demand depends on volume.
  • The surface area to volume ratio (SA:V) compares the two.
  • High SA:V: plenty of surface for each unit of volume.
  • Say: "SA:V is surface area ÷ volume" — not: "volume ÷ surface area".
Mission 5

Worked example: growing cubes

Cubes grow1 µmSA 6 µm2V 1 µm3SA:V 6.02 µmSA 24 µm2V 8 µm3SA:V 3.03 µmSA 54 µm2V 27 µm3SA:V 2.04 µmSA 96 µm2V 64 µm3SA:V 1.512340246SA:V / µm−1side / µm

Model cells as cubes of side s. Surface area = 6s². Volume = s³.

Side / µm1234
Surface area / µm²6245496
Volume / µm³182764
SA:V / µm⁻¹6.03.02.01.5
  • Side × 2: area × 4, volume × 8. SA:V halves.
  • Volume grows faster than surface. Big cells run short of surface.
  • So cells stay small, and large organisms are made of many small cells.
Quick check
?A cube of side 1 mm has a surface area of 6 mm², a volume of 1 mm³ and a surface area-to-volume ratio of 6. The side length is increased to 4 mm. What is the new surface area-to-volume ratio?
Mission 5

Worked example: other shapes

Shapes and formulaersphereSA = 4πr2V = (4/3)πr3rhcylinderSA = 2πrh + 2πr2V = πr2hlwhcuboidSA = 2lh + 2lw + 2whV = lwhdashed: hidden facessphere, r = 5 µmSA = 4π × 52 = 314 µm2V = (4/3) × π × 53 = 524 µm3SA:V = 314 ÷ 524 = 0.60 µm−1
  • Sphere: SA = 4πr²; V = (4/3)πr³.
  • Cylinder: SA = 2πrh + 2πr²; V = πr²h.
  • Cuboid (rectangular solid): SA = 2lh + 2lw + 2wh; V = lwh.
  • Prisms: SA = sum of the areas of all faces; V = cross-section area × length.
  • Sphere, r = 5 µm:
  • SA = 4 × π × 5² = 314 µm².
  • V = (4/3) × π × 5³ = 524 µm³.
  • SA:V = 314 ÷ 524 = 0.60 µm⁻¹.
  • Count every face: hidden faces too.
Quick check
?A hypothetical single-celled organism has the shape of a rectangular solid, 20 μm long, 10 μm high and 10 μm wide. What is the cell's surface area-to-volume ratio?
Mission check

?A spherical single-celled organism grows from a radius of 10 µm to a radius of 30 µm, keeping its shape. Which prediction is best supported?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Change one variable, measure one, keep the rest constant; a control gives the baseline for comparison.
  • A null hypothesis says "no effect"; data can support a hypothesis but never prove it.
  • Experiments manipulate a variable; observations record patterns. Random, repeated samples make a mean trustworthy.

Mission 2

  • Mean, median and mode describe the centre; SD describes the typical spread about the mean, using every value.
  • SD is usually more useful than the range, which depends only on the two extreme values.

Mission 3

  • Read the legend: SD bars show the spread of individuals; SE and confidence bars show how precisely each mean is known.
  • Overlapping SD bars: the difference may be due to chance; a statistical test decides.

Mission 4

  • Precise = repeats agree; accurate = close to the true value. Repeats reduce random error; calibration removes systematic error.
  • Percentage error = uncertainty ÷ measured value × 100; add uncertainties when a value comes from two readings.

Mission 5

  • Supply depends on surface area, demand on volume; as size increases, volume grows faster, so SA:V falls and limits cell size.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Working scientifically and maths skills for Eduqas A-level Biology. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Plants given a new fertiliser grew taller, but they also sat nearest the window. Can you trust the result?
  2. Mission 2Two sets of results share the same average but look nothing alike. What number captures the difference?
  3. Mission 3Two bars on a graph have different heights. When does that difference actually mean something?
  4. Mission 4Five readings agree perfectly. How can every one of them still be wrong?
  5. Mission 5Why are almost all cells too small to see, even inside the largest animals?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Biology · Eduqas